Can I Use a Company Name Already in Use Across State Lines?
Choosing the right name for your brand or company is a crucial step in establishing your identity in the market. However, in a vast and interconnected world, it’s not uncommon to find similar or identical brand names being used by different entities in various states. This raises a significant question for entrepreneurs and business owners: Can I use a brand name or company name if somebody is already using it in another state? This article aims to shed light on this complex issue, exploring legal considerations, potential conflicts, and best practices to safeguard your business interests.
Understanding Trademarks and Uniqueness
Before delving into the matter, it’s essential to understand the concept of trademarks. Trademarks are intellectual property rights that protect brand names, logos, and slogans from being used by others in a way that might cause confusion among consumers. Trademarks help distinguish one company’s products or services from those of others, ensuring that customers can identify and trust the source of a particular offering.
When selecting a brand name, it is crucial to ensure its uniqueness to avoid infringing on existing trademarks. Conducting a comprehensive search before finalizing a name is a prudent step. However, it is possible for two businesses to have the same or similar names as long as they operate in different industries and geographical areas without creating confusion among consumers.
The Importance of Geographical Scope
When dealing with a situation where a brand name is already in use in another state, one crucial factor to consider is the geographical scope of both businesses. Trademark rights are generally limited to specific geographic regions where the mark is actively used and recognized. For example, if a company is operating solely in California and has a registered trademark there, it does not automatically have nationwide rights. This means that another business in a different state may be able to use the same or similar name if it operates outside the original company’s geographic area.
However, if the original business has obtained a federal trademark registration with the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), it would have broader protection, giving it the ability to prevent others from using the same or confusingly similar name across the entire country, regardless of state boundaries.
Potential Conflicts and Legal Issues
Using a brand name that is already in use by another company can lead to legal conflicts, even if you operate in different states. If your business causes confusion among consumers, it may lead to allegations of trademark infringement, dilution, or unfair competition. Such legal battles can be costly and time-consuming, and it is advisable to avoid them whenever possible.
When a Conflict Arises
If you discover that another business is using the same or a similar name in a different state, the best course of action is to seek legal advice from a qualified intellectual property attorney. They can assess the situation and provide guidance on the potential risks and options available to you.
Possible Solutions
- Coexistence Agreement: In some cases, businesses with similar names can enter into a coexistence agreement that outlines the specific geographic areas where each company can operate. This allows both parties to use the name within their designated territories without conflicting with each other.
- Rebranding: If the potential risks and costs of a legal battle seem too high, consider rebranding your business with a unique name that avoids any conflicts. While rebranding can be challenging, it may be a necessary step to protect your long-term interests.
Conclusion
Choosing a brand name is a significant decision, and understanding the legal implications and potential conflicts is crucial for a successful business venture. When faced with the question, “Can I use a brand name or company name if somebody is already using it in another state?” – the answer is not straightforward. It depends on the specific circumstances, including trademark rights, geographical scope, and potential for consumer confusion. To avoid legal disputes and protect your business, conducting thorough research and seeking professional legal advice are essential steps. Remember, a unique and distinguishable brand name is the foundation of your company’s identity and success.
Video Transcript
Can I Use a Brand Name or Company Name if Somebody is Already Using It in Another State?
The answer is yes if you are going to just stay in your state. The answer is no if they have registered that trademark. So, this was a question from Brittany. Basically, she said, “There is a person with pretty much the same name as mine. Does it really matter if it is in a different state? They are from Ohio. I am from Delaware.” This is a question she posted on YouTube.
Understanding the County-by-County Analysis
So let’s play this out. You are a business owner who wants to use a business name, but somebody in another state is using it. Well, first off, as long as nobody in your state has used it, you have every right to do that. In fact, it is a county-by-county analysis. So you are welcome to operate in any county in the United States where somebody else is not already using a confusingly similar name. So that is a name that is either exactly the same or similar enough to be confusing to the general public. So as long as nobody is using a confusingly similar name in your county, you are good to go. You can use that name. This assumes that they have not registered a trademark with the U. S. Patent and Trademark Office. If they have done that, they have nationwide exclusive rights to that name.
But one thing to consider is whether you might want to get a registered trademark in the future. If you do, you might have to carve out an exclusion for whoever that other company is already using a confusingly similar name or the exact same name.
A Case Example with Amazon Bookstore
There was a big case about this with the Amazon bookstore in Minneapolis and the big Amazon.com bookstore. Minneapolis had a little bookstore called Amazon Bookstore for decades. And then Amazon.com came along. Now, who has nationwide rights? Well, Amazon.com applied for a federal trademark. They would have nationwide rights.
But what about this Amazon bookstore operating in Hennepin County, Minnesota? Don’t they have the rights to keep using their name? The general rule is, yeah, they do. But there are some other pieces to this. First, you have to enforce your rights in order to preserve them. If you neglect to enforce your rights, you may lose the right to have exclusive use of that.
Now, ultimately, there was a lawsuit between Amazon.com and the Amazon bookstore in Minneapolis, and they settled. And I believe the settlement was they could continue to operate simultaneously. The Amazon bookstore in Minneapolis would continue to operate just in that geographic area. And Amazon.com could exist everywhere else. But that was a settlement agreement, and parties have a right to settle however they want. If that one had gone to court, it is not really clear how that would have been resolved.
Summary
So if somebody is using your business name in another state, it is not a problem unless you want to get federal trademark registration rights or the other party does, but otherwise, there is no problem with you operating in different states under the exact same business name. I think this has become more of a challenge with the internet these days because if somebody Googles a particular name, Google has to decide which one do I show first. Now, Google generally will take into account where someone is geographically located and show the business with that name in that geographic location. But since the internet, this has become more of a challenge for companies with the exact same name who don’t have federal trademark rights. How do you get federal trademark rights? You just apply for a trademark application with the USPTO, which stands for U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Conclusion
All right. If you find these videos helpful, and you are interested in little short videos, little snippets, or some of the best excerpts from the videos that we have produced, you can find those by searching for Aaron Hall, Attorney, on TikTok, Instagram, and various other social media platforms. So feel free to follow us there, especially if you are interested in that short-form content, which is some of the best little snippets of legal questions presented by business owners.
I am Aaron Hall, an attorney for business owners and entrepreneurs. If you would like to get more videos like this, feel free to follow this channel by subscribing. And I encourage everybody to subscribe at aaronhall.com/free. That is where you can get some exclusive videos, helping business owners avoid common and expensive legal problems and help grow your company so you achieve success in your company and, hopefully, as well in your life. Thanks for joining me here today.