Assuming the lease when you buy a Minnesota business means the seller assigns its lease to you and you agree to perform it. Once you hold the lease, you answer to the landlord for breaches of the covenants that run with the leasehold, such as rent, that occur while you hold it. Charges not yet due when you take the lease pass to you with it. The assumption agreement you sign decides what more you take on, such as the seller’s past defaults and liability for the rest of the term.

The rules come mainly from Minnesota Supreme Court and Court of Appeals decisions on lease assignments and lease options, with Minnesota’s statute of frauds setting what must be in a signed writing. This page is for the owner of a Minnesota company buying a business whose location is leased, as part of my work on business acquisitions. The rest of the purchase, from due diligence to closing, is covered in buying a business.

What Does It Mean to Take Over the Lease When You Buy a Business?

Taking over the lease means the seller assigns its leasehold to you, and from then on you answer to the landlord for breaches, while you hold it, of the covenants that run with the leasehold. Minnesota’s statute of frauds covers the assignment of a lease longer than one year. That assignment must be made by act or operation of law, or by a writing signed by the party assigning it or by its agent authorized in writing.

The Minnesota Supreme Court has described the assignee’s position this way: “An assignee, apart from an express agreement to assume and perform or to take subject to the lessee’s covenants, is in privity of estate with the lessor and is liable to him personally for a breach of the lessee’s covenants which are annexed to and run with the leasehold and which are broken while he holds the leasehold estate” (Whitney v. Leighton, 225 Minn. 1, 30 N.W.2d 329 (Minn. 1947)). Privity of estate is the legal tie created by holding the leasehold itself. Covenants that “run with the leasehold,” such as paying rent and taxes, bind whoever holds it.

Under Minn. Stat. § 513.04, no interest in land “other than leases for a term not exceeding one year” may be “assigned” except “by act or operation of law, or by deed or conveyance in writing, subscribed by the parties creating, granting, assigning, surrendering, or declaring the same, or by their lawful agent thereunto authorized by writing.” I suggest having the seller sign a written assignment at closing, because a multi-year lease handed over on a handshake leaves your right to the space open to dispute.

A commercial lease may also require the landlord’s consent to an assignment. Whether and on what standard the landlord may refuse is covered in when a landlord can refuse consent to a business sale. The transfer steps themselves are covered in how a leasehold interest is assigned.

How Does an Assignment and Assumption Agreement Change What You Owe?

An assignment and assumption agreement adds a contract promise to the obligations that come with holding the lease. Minnesota’s limits on an assignee’s liability were stated for an assignee who assumed nothing. Those limits reach breaches only while the assignee holds the lease, and a reassignment that is not fraudulent or merely colorable ends liability for later duties but not for duties that arose before it. Once you sign an assumption, its own words set what you owe the landlord and for how long.

The limits come from cases about a bare assignment. In Cohen v. Todd, 130 Minn. 227, 153 N.W. 531 (Minn. 1915), the court noted that “Neither by the terms of the assignment, nor in any other manner, did defendant assume any contract obligation to pay rent,” and reasoned: “The assignee having assumed no contract obligation cannot be sued on contract.” Whitney, quoted above, states its rule for an assignee acting without an express agreement to assume the lease. It allows such an assignee to reassign “in the absence of fraud against the lessor,” and puts on the landlord the burden to show a reassignment was “fraudulent or merely colorable.” The assignee there still owed taxes that attached before he reassigned, because he “had the power to put an end to his liability for the 1936 taxes by assigning the lease prior to May 1 of that year” and did not.

I suggest reading the assumption agreement for four points before you sign it, because each one sets the size of what you take on:

  1. The obligations assumed. The agreement may cover only obligations arising after closing, or every obligation under the lease, past ones included.
  2. The effective date. A date tied to closing separates the seller’s period from yours.
  3. The seller’s indemnity. The seller can promise to cover anything from its period that the landlord later bills to you.
  4. Who signs. A version signed only by you and the seller differs from one the landlord also signs as part of its consent.

The seller keeps its own exposure, because an assignment does not release the original tenant from future liabilities unless the landlord agrees to a release. That point is covered in the seller’s liability after assigning a lease.

What Happens to the Seller’s Unpaid Rent and Lease Defaults?

An assignee who assumed nothing is not liable to the landlord for breaches that happened before it took the lease. In Cohen, citing an earlier decision, the court said such an assignee “is liable only for obligations maturing or breaches occurring while he holds the estate as assignee, and not for those which occurred before he became assignee or after he ceased to be such.” Unpaid rent can still put the lease itself at risk. Under Minn. Stat. § 504B.291, “A landlord may bring an eviction action for nonpayment of rent irrespective of whether the lease contains a right of reentry clause.” Unless the landlord “has also sought to evict the tenant by alleging a material violation of the lease,” the tenant “may, at any time before possession has been delivered, redeem the tenancy and be restored to possession by paying to the landlord or bringing to court the amount of the rent that is in arrears, with interest, costs of the action, and an attorney’s fee not to exceed $5, and by performing any other covenants of the lease.” For a lease “for a term of more than 20 years,” subdivision 2 of that section adds a written notice before the action may begin. Another default left uncured can put the lease at risk when the lease lets the landlord terminate for it.

The Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed the end of a lease over a tenant’s own long-running repair default in 1985 Robert Street Associates v. Menard, Inc., 403 N.W.2d 900 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987). Menard had rented the space since 1974, and the party enforcing the lease had bought the landlord’s interest, not the tenant’s. That lease provided that it “would terminate if the tenant’s default were not cured within thirty days of notice of the default.” The trial court found the premises “were not in good order, condition and repair as required by the 1978 lease.” The appeals court said that “The evidence indicated Menard materially breached the repair covenant over a long period of time,” and reasoned that “The terms of the parties’ lease clearly establish the landlord’s right to terminate the lease upon default on the lease covenants.” It held the award of damages in addition to forfeiture “was not an abuse of discretion.”

Unpaid rent shows in the seller’s books, but a repair, maintenance, or use default may not, so I suggest asking for these before closing:

  • Every default notice the landlord has sent in the last few years, and the seller’s response.
  • An inspection of the space against the lease’s repair and maintenance clauses.
  • The landlord’s written confirmation that no default exists, in the estoppel certificate described below.
  • A purchase-agreement promise by the seller to cure any default before closing, or a price reduction covering the cost of the cure.

How Are CAM Reconciliations and Tax Pass-Throughs Split at Closing?

Charges that are not yet due when you take the lease pass to you with it, and a charge for the seller’s period can be billed after closing. Common area maintenance (“CAM”) charges, taxes, and other pass-throughs may be estimated monthly and reconciled after year-end, so the bill for the seller’s last year may arrive while you hold the lease. The purchase agreement should split those charges, because otherwise a court may presume the price already accounted for them.

The Minnesota Supreme Court addressed this timing in the sale of a business with its lease. In Trask v. Graham, 47 Minn. 571, 50 N.W. 917 (Minn. 1891), one partner sold his interest in a sawmill and its lease to the other. The buyer “was himself liable for the rent for the whole quarter within which he became assignee, the rent not having yet accrued,” and for taxes not yet delinquent, because “the assignee took the leasehold estate cum onere as to them also,” meaning with the burden attached. The court explained: “It must be presumed that the contract was made in contemplation of the legal relations of the parties, and that the consideration was adjusted accordingly.” If the parties wanted the seller to pay, “it should have been so expressed in the contract.”

The lease’s own wording decides when a charge arises. Whitney held an assignee liable for taxes that attached while he held the lease, though they were payable after he gave it up: “The question is when the duty arose, not when it was to be discharged.” In Columbia Associates v. Propper Oil Co., 402 N.W.2d 223 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), a tenant owed its share of taxes levied and utilities used during its last year, billed after it left: “Simply because payment on these charges was deferred does not mean that Propper Oil is discharged from liability.” That court said its result was “reinforced by” an earlier decision, “albeit in slightly different form.” The earlier lease referred to “taxes paid by the lessor,” and the landlord there lost its claim to taxes assessed in the tenancy’s last year but payable the next. I suggest these purchase-agreement terms, because Trask presumes the price already reflects the legal split unless the contract says otherwise:

  1. A proration of rent, CAM, taxes, and insurance as of the closing date.
  2. A seller payment for any reconciliation covering the period before closing, whenever the landlord bills it.
  3. A holdback from the price, or an escrow, sized to the last reconciliation, until the next one is final.
  4. A credit to you for any refund the reconciliation shows for the seller’s period, or an agreement that it goes to the seller.

How to cap CAM in the lease itself is covered in negotiating a Minnesota commercial lease.

What Should the Landlord’s Estoppel Certificate Confirm?

An estoppel certificate is a signed statement from the landlord confirming the lease’s current facts. It is most useful when it confirms every fact you are pricing into the purchase. A buyer uses it to learn, from the one party who would later dispute them, what the lease documents are, what rent is paid, and whether any default exists. You can then compare the landlord’s statements with what the seller told you.

I suggest asking the landlord to confirm these facts, because each one is a point the seller’s records alone cannot prove:

  • The complete list of lease documents: the lease, every amendment, side letter, and assignment.
  • The monthly base rent, the current CAM and tax estimates, and the date through which rent is paid.
  • The security deposit held, and whether it will be credited to you.
  • That no default by the tenant or the landlord exists, and no notice of default is outstanding.
  • The term’s expiration date and every renewal, extension, expansion, or purchase option still available.
  • Whether the last CAM reconciliation is final, and any amount the landlord claims for it.
  • That the landlord consents to the assignment to you, if consent has not been given separately.

The lease may contain an estoppel clause that requires a party to sign one on request within a set time. I suggest reading that clause early, and making a satisfactory certificate a condition of closing in the purchase agreement, because without one you have only the seller’s word for these facts.

What Personal Guaranty Will the Landlord Ask You to Sign?

A landlord approving an assignment to a new company may ask the company’s owner to sign a personal guaranty of the lease. A guaranty is a promise to pay the company’s lease obligations if the company does not. Under Minnesota’s statute of frauds, the landlord cannot sue on a guaranty unless it, or a note or memorandum of it, expresses the consideration, is in writing, and is signed by you.

Minn. Stat. § 513.01 provides: “No action shall be maintained, in either of the following cases, upon any agreement, unless such agreement, or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing, and subscribed by the party charged therewith.” Clause (2) of that section covers “every special promise to answer for the debt, default or doings of another.” A personal guaranty of your company’s lease is a promise to answer for the company’s debt.

I suggest negotiating the guaranty’s terms before you sign it, because the written guaranty is the promise the landlord can enforce against you personally. The points to settle include whether the guaranty covers the full remaining term or a shorter period, and any dollar cap. They also include whether it ends after a period of on-time payment, and whether it covers the seller’s pre-closing obligations you did not assume. The common limit structures are covered in the commercial lease negotiation page linked above, and the ways a dispute over a guaranty plays out are covered in how Minnesota courts enforce a commercial lease guaranty.

How Do the Remaining Term and Renewal Options Affect Your Purchase?

The remaining term and any option to stay longer decide how long you can operate in the space at a known rent. Minnesota law distinguishes an extension, which continues the existing lease on timely notice or some other condition, from a renewal, which requires a new lease. If any term for the added period must still be negotiated or determined, you need a new lease before you can count on that period. A lease for longer than one year is void unless it, or a note or memorandum of it, states the consideration in a writing signed by the landlord or its agent authorized in writing.

The Minnesota Supreme Court restated the distinction in Med-Care Associates, Inc. v. Noot, 329 N.W.2d 549 (Minn. 1983), citing an 1898 decision: “The legal distinction between an extension and a renewal of a lease is that an extension merely continues the original lease, while a renewal requires a new lease.” It continued: “If any contractual term for the additional period must be negotiated or determined, the statute of frauds requires a new lease, and the new period is a renewal. If the lease is continued by the party holding the option merely on timely notice or on some other condition, no new lease is required, and the option is an extension.” The holding in Med-Care concerned how a Medicaid statute used the word “renewal,” and the court restated the lease-law distinction along the way.

A new lease for longer than one year must meet Minn. Stat. § 513.05: it “shall be void unless the contract, or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing and subscribed by the party by whom the lease or sale is to be made, or by the party’s lawful agent thereunto authorized in writing.” An option that leaves the rent for later agreement therefore gives you less certainty than one that states the rent or a formula.

A landlord can grant a renewal right in the same agreement that lets a buyer assume the lease. In Unity Investors Ltd. Partnership v. Lindberg, 421 N.W.2d 751 (Minn. Ct. App. 1988), the landlord had “permitted appellant to assume the existing 1976 lease” by agreement, and “Appellant was given the right to renew the lease” on terms set by reference to another tenant’s lease. The pharmacy operator gave timely notice, and the court held the lease extended, because “The terms for renewal were definite and certain by reference to the original lease and the modification provided by option (a).” I suggest reading three things in the option clause before you price the business, because each can shorten the time you have:

  1. Whether the option is limited to the original tenant or passes to an assignee.
  2. Whether exercising it requires that no default exists at the time of notice.
  3. The notice date, which falls well before the lease ends and is the date to calendar.

What Are Your Options If the Lease Does Not Fit Your Plans?

When the lease’s term, rent, guaranty demand, or default history does not fit your plans, you have five main options. You can talk with the landlord, sign an amendment or a new lease, or adjust the price and terms with the seller. You can also buy the company instead of its assets, or use a closing condition to walk away.

  1. A direct conversation with the landlord. A meeting among you, the seller, and the landlord fits when the problem is information, such as an unclear default history or a guaranty request the landlord may narrow. It costs little. I suggest putting anything agreed into a signed document, because a spoken promise about a multi-year lease is hard to enforce.
  2. An amendment or a new lease. You and the landlord can sign an amendment, or a new lease while the seller’s lease ends by written agreement. A new lease for longer than one year needs the signed writing that § 513.05 requires, quoted above. In West 70th, Inc. v. Koch, 298 Minn. 121, 213 N.W.2d 332 (Minn. 1973), the landlords of a barbershop accepted the buyer’s rent for about 20 months and then threatened eviction. The buyer chose this route, paying more rent and gaining “certain advantages not available under the old lease.”
  3. A price or terms adjustment with the seller. A shorter term, a higher rent ahead, or a default to cure can be reflected in the price, a holdback, or a seller indemnity. Money does not keep you in the space, though, if the landlord later ends the lease.
  4. Buying the company instead of its assets. In a stock or membership-interest purchase, the company stays the tenant. The lease may still contain a change-of-control clause, a subject of the landlord-consent page linked above. The company comes with its liabilities; the tradeoffs are covered in a stock sale vs an asset sale.
  5. A closing condition and walking away. The purchase agreement can make the landlord’s written consent, a satisfactory estoppel certificate, and an acceptable guaranty conditions of closing. The agreement can then let you decline to close if one fails, at the cost of the time and diligence already spent.
Can the landlord collect the seller's past-due rent from me after closing?

Not merely because you now hold the lease. In Cohen v. Todd (Minn. 1915), the Minnesota Supreme Court, citing an earlier decision, said an assignee who assumed no contract obligation “is liable only for obligations maturing or breaches occurring while he holds the estate as assignee, and not for those which occurred before he became assignee or after he ceased to be such.” An assumption agreement or consent that takes on past amounts changes that. Unpaid rent can still cost you the lease: under Minn. Stat. § 504B.291, a landlord may evict for nonpayment “irrespective of whether the lease contains a right of reentry clause.” Unless the landlord also alleges a material lease violation, the tenant may redeem before possession is delivered. To redeem, the tenant pays the arrears with interest, costs, and a fee up to $5 and performs the lease’s other covenants. A lease longer than 20 years adds a notice step.

Do I stay liable on the lease if I later sell the business and assign the lease again?

It depends on what you signed. In Whitney v. Leighton (Minn. 1947), for an assignee holding “apart from an express agreement to assume and perform or to take subject to the lessee’s covenants,” the court, quoting an earlier decision, said an assignee “may, by assigning it, even to a pauper, put an end to his liability in point of time.” A landlord who shows the reassignment was “fraudulent or merely colorable” avoids its effect, and the assignee there still owed taxes that attached before he reassigned. An assumption agreement and a personal guaranty each follow their own words, so I suggest reading both with your eventual exit in mind before you sign.

What if the seller never got the landlord's written consent to the assignment?

You may face an eviction threat even after paying rent for months. In West 70th, Inc. v. Koch (Minn. 1973), landlords who had accepted a barbershop buyer’s rent for about 20 months told him to vacate because the seller never got their written approval. The buyer renegotiated the lease, and the courts allowed him to offset half of the legal expense and rent increase against his note to the seller, because the seller had breached its warranty of title. That seller had “warranted and represented” that it had the right to assign its lease, so I suggest putting the same promise in your purchase agreement. The court restated that a landlord who accepts rent knowing of the assignment waives its objection, yet agreed the buyer “should not be required to risk losing his business in litigation.”

Does a renewal notice sent late lose the option?

It can, so I suggest treating the lease’s notice date as fixed. In Trollen v. City of Wabasha, 287 N.W.2d 645 (Minn. 1979), the court adopted a Connecticut court’s rule. Equity relieves a missed notice that “results from accident, fraud, surprise, or mistake,” but “will never relieve” wilful or gross negligence. Mere neglect “which do not fall within accident or mistake” is relieved only “when the delay has been slight, the loss to the lessor small,” and literal enforcement would be unconscionable. In Capistrant v. Lifetouch National School Studios, Inc., 916 N.W.2d 23 (Minn. 2018), the court said it has “not relied on Trollen outside of the real property context.”

Taking Over the Lease in Your Minnesota Business Purchase

When you buy a Minnesota business in leased space, the lease comes to you with the rent periods and charges not yet due, and the assumption agreement you sign decides what more you take on. Minnesota decisions limit an assignee who assumed nothing to obligations maturing or breaches occurring while it holds the lease. A signed assumption, an estoppel certificate, a negotiated guaranty, and a renewal option with fixed terms are the documents that set your exposure. I suggest settling each before closing, because after closing the landlord and seller have less reason to agree. For the rest of the purchase, see my Minnesota business acquisitions practice.

If you are buying a Minnesota business and want to know what its lease will put on you, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.