When a Minnesota business purchase falls apart before closing, who keeps the earnest-money deposit depends first on what your signed documents say about it, and then on why the deal failed. A deposit can go back to the buyer who ends the deal under a contingency or termination right the agreement gives. When the buyer backs out without such a right, a seller can keep the deposit as liquidated damages if the agreement made it that and the amount is not a penalty. Otherwise the seller credits it against damages limited to a fair equivalent of its actual damages. A buyer has claims of its own when the seller is the one who will not close.
Minnesota courts decide these disputes under contract law, and the earnest-money decisions this page relies on involve real-estate purchase agreements, so each is described with its facts. When a business broker holds the deposit, Minnesota’s real estate broker chapter limits when the broker may release it. This page is for the buyer or seller after the deal has failed. The deal terms that set up a deposit are part of my business sale and acquisition work, and the steps before signing are in the guide to buying a business.
What Decides Who Keeps the Deposit When a Business Purchase Fails?
The deposit terms in the documents you signed decide first, and the reason the deal failed decides the rest. Three documents can carry those terms: a letter of intent (LOI), the purchase agreement, and a separate escrow agreement with the broker, title company, or attorney who holds the money. I suggest reading each document for four terms, because any one of them can change the answer:
- whether the deposit is refundable;
- the events that let either side end the deal;
- what happens to the deposit after each kind of ending; and
- who may tell the holder to release it.
What happened then fits one of three paths: a party ended the deal under a right the agreement gives, the buyer backed out without one, or the seller would not close.
A label in the agreement does not settle the question by itself. In Frank v. Jansen, 226 N.W.2d 739 (Minn. 1975), a home sale the buyers abandoned, the Minnesota Supreme Court held that “a provision in a contract of this kind calling for a forfeiture of the downpayment upon a breach of the contract will not of itself establish the fact that it is to be considered as liquidated damages.” The court said that whether the parties agreed to liquidated damages “must be gleaned from the contract and all of the facts pointing to the intention of the parties.”
A deposit paid when only an LOI is signed follows the LOI’s own deposit paragraph if that paragraph binds. An LOI can state that most of its terms do not bind, so whether its deposit paragraph binds turns on the LOI’s language. The page on whether a letter of intent binds covers that test, and the page on walking away from a letter of intent covers the exit.
When Does a Failed Contingency Return the Buyer’s Deposit?
A failed contingency returns the deposit when the agreement’s refund terms say it does and the buyer pursued the contingency in good faith. Jones v. Amoco Oil Co., 483 N.W.2d 718 (Minn. Ct. App. 1992) involved the sale of the land under a fire-damaged gas station to the operator who had run it. Its financing clause said that if the buyer could not obtain financing, the contract “shall be null and void and of no further force or effect and all earnest money herein paid shall be returned to Purchaser.” The seller ended the deal and sent the earnest money back. The buyer, who said he was ready to close, lost: the Court of Appeals affirmed a judgment setting aside a $740,000 jury verdict in his favor.
The buyer in Jones relied entirely on a bank loan. Quoting an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision, the court said such a buyer is able to buy “only if he had a definite and binding commitment from such third-party loaner,” and it concluded, “We agree with the trial court that Jones failed to obtain suitable financing.” The court held that the contract “was nullified by its own terms.”
A buyer cannot hold a contingency open to escape the deal. In Hoffman v. Nygaard, 393 N.W.2d 695 (Minn. Ct. App. 1986), a home purchase, the court said the buyers “had an affirmative duty to satisfy the financing contingency in good faith.” It also said, “However, the financing available must comply with the terms of the purchase agreement before the contracting parties can demand performance.” In Plaisted v. Fuhr, 367 N.W.2d 541 (Minn. Ct. App. 1985), another home purchase, the court said, “The buyers cannot have the exclusive right to determine whether financing can be or has been obtained without making illusory the promise to purchase.” Plaisted also limited that duty: the buyers, whose written loan application was still pending, did not have to apply again. The court reversed a judgment of specific performance against them: “The purchase agreement expired by its own terms when the financing deadline of May 1 was not met, without bad faith on the part of the Fuhrs as vendees.”
Diligence, financing, landlord-consent, and license contingencies work as conditions, and the page on conditions precedent explains how Minnesota treats a condition, including waiver and excuse. If your business purchase includes Minnesota real estate, Minnesota’s statutes on ending real-estate purchase agreements may also govern how the agreement ends, and the guide to commercial purchase agreement contingencies covers them. I suggest reading each contingency’s deadline and notice step before the deadline passes, because Jones and Plaisted each applied the agreement’s own words about what happens when financing is not in place by its date.
What Happens to the Deposit When the Buyer Backs Out Without a Contract Right?
When a buyer backs out without a contingency or termination right, the seller can keep the whole deposit as liquidated damages if the agreement made it that and the amount is not a penalty. Otherwise the seller credits the deposit against its damages, which are limited to a fair equivalent of its actual damages. In Costello v. Johnson, 121 N.W.2d 70 (Minn. 1963), a house sale, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that in a real-estate sale, “whether or not there is a contractual provision for liquidated damages,” the law’s guiding principle is, quoting Gorco Construction Co. v. Stein, 99 N.W.2d 69 (Minn. 1959), “that the injured party is entitled to receive a fair equivalent for the actual damages necessarily resulting from failure to perform the contract and no more.” Costello also quoted Gorco’s rule for a liquidated-damages provision: “where the actual damages resulting from a breach of the contract cannot be ascertained or measured by the ordinary rules, a provision for liquidated damages not manifestly disproportionate to the actual damages will be sustained.”
Whether the seller keeps or credits the deposit depends on whether the agreement made the deposit liquidated damages, meaning a sum the parties fixed in advance instead of proving the actual loss. In Frank, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that before a court finds liquidated damages, “there must be evidence to support a finding that the parties intended the stipulated amount to be in lieu of compensatory damages.” If the deposit is liquidated damages, it is the seller’s whole recovery: “There cannot be both liquidated damages and compensatory damages.” Frank also quoted a legal encyclopedia, 22 Am. Jur. 2d, Damages, § 235: “If a provision is construed to be one for liquidated damages, the sum stipulated forms, in general, the measure of damages in case of a breach, and the recovery must be for that amount. No larger or smaller sum can be awarded even though the actual loss may be greater or less.”
Without that intent, the deposit is credited against the seller’s proven loss. In Costello, the agreement let the sellers keep the earnest money “as a part of his just compensation for such failure,” and it provided that the seller “may declare this contract terminated and proceed for damages.” Because the buyers had not appealed an award larger than the deposit, the court assumed the clause was not a liquidated-damages agreement. It added: “The contract provision permitting plaintiffs to declare the contract terminated upon defendants’ default and thereafter to proceed for damages also indicates that the parties did not intend to contract with respect to liquidated damages.” The trial court had set the earnest money off against the damages it found, and the Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed.
The seller’s proven loss is measured by what performance would have given the seller. Frank, quoting an 1875 Minnesota decision, stated the common-law rule that a party who “sustains a loss by reason of a breach of contract” is “so far as money can do it, to be placed in the same situation, with respect to damages, as if the contract had been performed.” Frank added that this rule “is modified by” an 1854 English decision “which is still followed in this state,” limiting damages to those that “(1) either arise naturally, that is, in the usual course of things, from the breach itself, or (2) such as may reasonably be supposed to have been contemplated by the parties, when making the contract, as a probable result of breach.” For the home sale in Frank, that meant “the difference between what defendants agreed to pay for the property and the actual market value at the time of defendants’ breach plus such expenses as plaintiffs reasonably incurred in attempting to mitigate their damages less the amount they have already received as a downpayment.” The seller has a duty too: “It is the duty of the seller in a contract of this kind, upon a breach by the buyer, to use reasonable diligence to minimize his damages.”
A buyer who simply changes its mind has no contingency to stand on. In Hoffman, the buyers did not breach by refusing a loan while they waited for a workers’ compensation settlement. Both parties testified that the settlement was one of the financing contingencies, “even though not expressed in the written agreement.” The buyers did breach by refusing to close the sale after receiving the settlement. The court said they “were not free to abandon the purchase agreement because they became dissatisfied with the arrangement they had agreed to in the contract,” and that “Financing was available to them and they were obligated to finalize a loan and purchase Hoffmans’ home when they received the worker’s compensation settlement.”
When Is Keeping the Whole Deposit an Unenforceable Penalty?
A deposit kept as liquidated damages can still be challenged as an unenforceable penalty. In Costello, a dispute over earnest money the sellers kept, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that Gorco “stated the rule which applies to provisions for liquidated damages in this state.” The page on non-refundable deposits explains that penalty test, including the rule for goods in Minnesota’s Uniform Commercial Code at Minn. Stat. § 336.2-718.
I suggest that a seller planning to keep a large deposit list the costs and losses the buyer’s default caused, because Costello, quoting Gorco, said that “when the measure of damages resulting from a breach of contract is susceptible of definite measurement, we have uniformly held an amount greatly disproportionate to be a penalty.” A breakup fee in an LOI is a separate payment with its own terms.
What Happens to the Deposit When the Seller Will Not Close?
When the seller will not close without a right to end the deal, the buyer’s claim starts with the agreement’s refund terms. Those terms can return the deposit on a seller default, and they can add or limit other remedies. Beyond the deposit, the common-law damages rule Frank quoted, placing the injured party where performance would have, applies to a buyer as well. The same limit from Frank applies: damages that arise naturally from the breach, or that the parties could reasonably have contemplated when making the contract as a probable result of breach. A seller also cannot rely on a contingency it blocked. In re Hennepin County 1986 Recycling Bond Litigation, 540 N.W.2d 494 (Minn. 1995) was a dispute over bond agreements decided on a motion to dismiss. The Minnesota Supreme Court said that every contract includes an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. That covenant bars one party from acting to “unjustifiably hinder” the other’s performance, words the court quoted from an earlier decision.
The same opinion said that “the party to a contract cannot take advantage of the failure of a condition precedent when the party itself has frustrated performance of that condition.” A seller whose own conduct frustrates a landlord’s consent the deal depends on, for example, can face that argument when it later points to the missing consent. The court also said that “the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing does not extend to actions beyond the scope of the underlying contract,” so the argument rests on what the agreement required. A seller’s conduct between signing and closing can also breach its pre-closing covenants, which that page covers.
How Does a Broker or Escrow Agent Release a Disputed Deposit?
A business broker holding the deposit must return earnest money on a rejected offer to the buyer. Otherwise the broker may release it only on one of four events listed in Minnesota’s broker statute, so neither side can force a release by demand alone. Minn. Stat. § 82.55, subd. 19(d) treats as a broker anyone who, “for another and for commission, fee, or other valuable consideration or with the intention or expectation of receiving the same,” “offers or attempts to negotiate a sale, option, exchange, purchase or rental of any business opportunity or business, or its good will, inventory, or fixtures, or any interest therein.” Subdivision 26 defines “trust funds” as “funds received by a broker, salesperson, or closing agent in a fiduciary capacity as a part of a real estate or business opportunity transaction,” including “earnest money deposits.”
Minn. Stat. § 82.75, subd. 5(d) provides that “Trust funds may only be disbursed upon the occurrence of one of the following”: a closing, “written agreement between the parties,” an affidavit under the residential cancellation statute, or “a court order.” The statute also sets a default time: “Disbursement must be made within ten business days following the consummation or termination of a transaction if the applicable agreements are silent as to the time of disbursement.” Under subdivision 5(b), “Unless otherwise agreed upon in writing by the parties to a transaction, the broker with whom trust funds are to be deposited shall be the listing broker,” and under subdivision 5(c), “If the offer is rejected, the earnest money shall be returned to the potential buyer not later than the next business day after rejection.” Subdivision 1 lets the money “be paid to one of the parties pursuant to express written agreement between the parties to a transaction” instead of deposited in the trust account.
Not every holder is a broker under the chapter. Minn. Stat. § 82.56 provides that “Unless a person is licensed or otherwise required to be licensed under this chapter, the term real estate broker does not include” a list of persons. That list includes “a licensed practicing attorney if the attorney complies in all respects with the trust account provisions of this chapter” and a securities broker-dealer “when participating in a transaction in which all or part of a business opportunity or business, including any interest therein, is conveyed or acquired pursuant to an asset purchase, merger, exchange of securities, or other business combination, if the agent or broker-dealer is licensed pursuant to chapter 80A.” For an attorney, that exclusion depends on following the chapter’s trust account provisions, which include the release rules above. For another escrow agent outside the chapter, the escrow agreement’s release terms are the instructions the parties gave it, so I suggest reading them before you send a demand to the holder.
What Are the Ways to Resolve a Deposit Dispute?
A deposit dispute can end with a revived deal, a negotiated split, a demand, or a court order. The right one depends on how much is at stake and whether the deal is still worth doing. A signed agreement between buyer and seller is one of the four events that let a broker release the deposit under Minn. Stat. § 82.75, subd. 5(d), and a court order is another. Each option below notes when it fits and its risk.
- Revive or restructure the deal. If the deal failed over financing or a diligence finding, an owner-to-owner conversation can produce a written amendment: a later deadline, a lower price, or seller financing for part of the gap. This fits when both sides still want the transaction. The risk is more time and money spent on a deal that may fail again.
- Agree on a split. A signed release that divides the deposit, with each side giving up its claims to the rest, moves the money without a lawsuit. This fits when each side has a fair argument and the deposit is small next to the cost of fighting. The risk is giving up part of a claim you might have won.
- Send a demand. A demand letter states your position, the agreement terms behind it, and what you ask the other side to sign. This fits when the documents favor you. The risk is that a demand can harden the other side’s position.
- Ask a court to decide. A lawsuit ends with a court order that releases the money. A holder that refuses to choose can petition to place the money in the court’s custody under Minn. R. Civ. P. 67.02 when the money “is claimed adversely by two or more other persons, and the right thereto as between such claimants is in doubt,” setting out the facts and the known claimants; the court accepts custody “If satisfied of the truth of such showing.” Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 22, the holder can also bring its own action making the buyer and seller interplead (litigate their claims against each other) when it “is or may be exposed to multiple liability,” and a holder already sued “may obtain such interpleader by way of cross-claim or counterclaim.” This fits when the deposit is large or the other side will not respond. The risk is cost and time, which can exceed a small deposit.
Can the seller keep my deposit and also sue me for more?
The seller cannot do both if your agreement made the deposit liquidated damages, a sum fixed in advance instead of proven loss. In Frank v. Jansen, 226 N.W.2d 739 (Minn. 1975), a home sale, the Minnesota Supreme Court said, “There cannot be both liquidated damages and compensatory damages.” If the agreement lets the seller keep the deposit as part of its compensation and also sue, the seller can seek proven damages. In Costello v. Johnson, 121 N.W.2d 70 (Minn. 1963) the earnest money was set off against them.
Do I have to apply to a second lender before my financing deadline?
Not while your written application is still pending and the lender has not rejected it, under the rule one Minnesota court applied, unless your agreement requires more. In Plaisted v. Fuhr, 367 N.W.2d 541 (Minn. Ct. App. 1985), a home purchase, the buyers’ written loan application was still pending at the deadline, and “The bank had not at any time rejected the application.” The court said, “We can find no duty either to make multiple applications or to waive a financing deadline imposed for the benefit of both parties.”
Can the broker refuse to return my deposit until the seller signs off?
Yes, if the broker holds it as trust funds under Minnesota’s broker statute and the seller did not reject your offer. Minn. Stat. § 82.75, subd. 5(d) states that trust funds “may only be disbursed upon the occurrence of one of the following”: a closing, “written agreement between the parties,” an affidavit under the residential cancellation statute, or “a court order.” If the offer was rejected, subdivision 5(c) states that “the earnest money shall be returned to the potential buyer not later than the next business day after rejection.”
Can the escrow agent hand the deposit to a court instead of choosing a side?
Yes, under Minn. R. Civ. P. 67.02, when the money “is claimed adversely by two or more other persons, and the right thereto as between such claimants is in doubt.” The holder petitions the court in the money’s county, and once the court accepts custody and notice is given as its order directs, “the petitioner is relieved from further liability on account thereof.” Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 22, the holder can instead sue to make the claimants interplead when it “is or may be exposed to multiple liability,” and a sued holder “may obtain such interpleader by way of cross-claim or counterclaim.”
What if my deposit was paid under a letter of intent?
The letter of intent’s own deposit paragraph governs if that paragraph binds, which depends on the LOI’s language, and the page on whether a letter of intent binds covers that test. If a business broker holds the money, Minn. Stat. § 82.75, subd. 5 still applies. Subdivision 5(c) returns earnest money on a rejected offer to the buyer. Otherwise, subdivision 5(d) limits release to a closing, a written agreement between the parties, an affidavit under the residential cancellation statute, or a court order.
Deposit Disputes After a Failed Business Purchase
The deposit follows the documents first. A buyer who ended the deal under a contingency it pursued in good faith can recover it when the agreement says so. When the buyer simply backed out, a seller can keep the deposit as liquidated damages if the agreement made it that and the amount is not a penalty. That deposit is then the seller’s whole recovery. Without such a clause, the deposit is credited against the seller’s damages, limited to a fair equivalent of its actual loss. Earnest money on a rejected offer goes back to the buyer. On an accepted offer, a business broker holding the money may release it only on a closing, a written agreement between the parties, an affidavit under the residential cancellation statute, or a court order. The deposit terms in a purchase agreement are part of my business sale and acquisition work.
If your business purchase has fallen through and the deposit is in dispute, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.