A competitor that buys your brand name as a search-ad keyword has not necessarily infringed your trademark. Federal appeals courts in New York, Denver, and San Francisco have held or affirmed that the keyword purchase alone, with a labeled ad that does not show your name, is not infringement. The Eighth Circuit, which hears appeals from Minnesota’s federal court, has not decided that question. It has held that confusion before a sale may count, though not where the buyers are as sophisticated as careful professional purchasers. In the decided cases, courts weighed the wording and labeling of the ad and what happened after the click, along with numbers showing how few searchers clicked the ad or were confused.
This guide is for the owner of a Minnesota business who searched for the company’s own name and found a competitor’s ad on top. The rules are mostly federal: the Lanham Act’s likelihood-of-confusion standard, applied by the Eighth Circuit in a case that came from Minnesota. Minnesota adds its Deceptive Trade Practices Act and its own trademark registration statute. Google’s trademark complaint process is a platform rule, and it is one tool among several. It is part of my Minnesota trademark practice materials.
When Does a Competitor’s Bid on Your Brand Name Become Trademark Infringement?
A bid on your name becomes infringement when you have a valid, protectable mark and the competitor’s use is likely to confuse customers about who offers the product or service. The confusion test also reaches confusion about whether the competitor is affiliated with, connected to, sponsored by, or approved by you. The purchase of the keyword, by itself, has been held not to meet that test in other circuits. The Eighth Circuit has not ruled on the keyword-only question.
The federal infringement statute, 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1)(a), reaches use of a registered mark “in connection with the sale, offering for sale, distribution, or advertising of any goods or services on or in connection with which such use is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive.” Its companion, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A), covers use that “is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive as to the affiliation, connection, or association of such person with another person, or as to the origin, sponsorship, or approval of his or her goods, services, or commercial activities by another person.” Both turn on confusion, so buying a word is only the start of the question. Confusion is also not the only element. In H&R Block, Inc. v. Block, Inc., 58 F.4th 939 (8th Cir. 2023), the Eighth Circuit wrote that to establish trademark infringement the owner “must show: (1) it has a valid, protectible mark, and (2) there is a likelihood of confusion between its mark and the marks” the other business is using.
The Second Circuit put the keyword-only rule plainly in 1-800 Contacts, Inc. v. JAND, Inc., 119 F.4th 234 (2d Cir. 2024). The court wrote that “the mere act of purchasing a competitor’s trademarks as keywords in the search advertising context does not constitute trademark infringement or unfair competition.” In a footnote, the court also wrote that it was “not holding that a plaintiff can never allege some sort of violation of the Lanham Act where the defendant’s only use of the plaintiff’s mark is in the keyword purchase.” Second Circuit decisions persuade a Minnesota federal court but do not bind it.
The leading Eighth Circuit case did not reach the keyword-only question. In Select Comfort Corp. v. Baxter, 996 F.3d 925 (8th Cir. 2021), the Sleep Number owner sued a rival online mattress seller. Before the appeal, the district court noted that the brand owner “expressly disavowed any theory of trademark infringement that relied exclusively on Defendants’ use of Plaintiffs’ trademarks as paid search terms with search engine providers such as Google.” The brand owner instead relied on the keywords together with the rival’s ad text, web addresses, and call-center conduct. A seller of another company’s products faces different rules, covered on my page about selling another company’s branded products.
How Does the Eighth Circuit Decide Whether a Search Ad Confuses Customers?
The Eighth Circuit weighs a list of nonexclusive factors and asks whether the average buyer is likely to be confused about source or affiliation. It has held that confusion before a sale, called initial-interest confusion, may count. The exception applies where the average buyers are as sophisticated as careful professional purchasers, a finding the court said typically will rest with the jury.
In Select Comfort, the court said the factors it considers come from its 1980 SquirtCo decision and include:
- the strength of the owner’s mark;
- how similar the two marks are;
- how closely the products compete;
- whether the other business intended to pass off its goods as the owner’s;
- incidents of actual confusion; and
- the type of product, its cost, and the conditions of purchase.
The court explained that “no one factor is controlling and different factors will carry more weight in different settings.” My page on trademark infringement claims in Minnesota walks through each factor.
The key holding for search ads is about timing. The court held that a theory of initial-interest confusion “may apply in our circuit,” and that “a plaintiff should not be barred from proving presale, initial-interest confusion” when a jury question exists about how careful the buyers are. On whether buyer sophistication should be measured at the “point of click” or at the final purchase, it added: “we do not believe it is appropriate to cabin the analysis to any one point in time.” The limit is that “the theory of initial-interest confusion cannot apply in our Circuit where the relevant average consumers are sophisticated at the level of the careful professional purchasers who were at issue in Sensient,” an earlier case about industrial food buyers.
How Does the Ad’s Own Text Change the Analysis?
The ad’s wording and labeling carry heavy weight in the keyword-ad cases. An ad that is labeled as an ad and names the competitor has been held unlikely to confuse. Ads that repeated the brand name or a near copy of it were part of the record when the Eighth Circuit reversed a judgment on an infringement claim and remanded it. The Fifth Circuit reversed the dismissal of a complaint alleging keyword use combined with generic, unlabeled ads and misleading call-center practices.
The clearly labeled ad is the bidder’s strongest position. In 1-800 Contacts, Inc. v. Lens.com, Inc., 722 F.3d 1229 (10th Cir. 2013), the Tenth Circuit reasoned that a searcher may assume a result belongs to the business searched for, “But that inference is an unnatural one when the entry is clearly labeled as an advertisement and clearly identifies the source, which has a name quite different from the business being searched for.” In JAND, the Second Circuit relied on the complaint’s own exhibits, which showed “the word ‘Ad’ is displayed directly next to Warby Parker’s domain name at the top of its paid search ad in bold.” It also wrote that “the pleadings failed to plausibly allege that Warby Parker used 1-800’s Marks anywhere during the search advertising process outside of its purchase at the initial, permissible keyword auction.”
The ad text in Select Comfort was different. The rival used the brand owner’s marks “as identical phrases in their own web-based advertising” and in web addresses. The court described ads with phrases like these: “Examples included the use of terms such as ‘Sleep 55% Off Number Beds’ and ‘Comfort Air Beds on Sale’ in online advertisements.” In ruling that the trial errors were not harmless, the Eighth Circuit pointed to “the strength of the Plaintiffs’ evidence on the issue of confusion,” which included call-center transcripts and statements by the rival’s principals.
What happens after the click also counts. In Adler v. McNeil Consultants, 10 F.4th 422 (5th Cir. 2021), the Fifth Circuit reversed a dismissal where the keyword use was “combined with generic, unlabeled advertisements and misleading call-center practices.” That was a ruling at the pleading stage, before any evidence was tested.
What Evidence Shows That a Competitor’s Search Ads Confuse Customers?
The Eighth Circuit treats evidence that real customers were confused as strong proof, and the Ninth Circuit has compared the count of confused customers with how many people saw the ads. Screenshots of the ads, records of misdirected calls and emails, and the competitor’s own statements are the core of the proof.
The Eighth Circuit has said that “[a]ctual confusion in the marketplace is often considered the best evidence of likelihood of confusion,” quoting an earlier decision, in H&R Block, Inc. v. Block, Inc., 58 F.4th 939 (8th Cir. 2023). That case was not about search ads, and the court reversed and vacated a preliminary injunction because “the evidence in the record is inadequate to establish substantial consumer confusion by an appreciable number of ordinary consumers, nor irreparable harm that is concrete and imminent.”
The record in Select Comfort shows what strong evidence looks like. It included survey evidence, call-center transcripts of shoppers who thought they had reached the brand owner, and statements in which the rival’s principals described confusion between the brands as a “good thing.”
The Ninth Circuit shows the risk of thin numbers. In Lerner & Rowe PC v. Brown Engstrand & Shely LLC, 119 F.4th 711 (9th Cir. 2024), the firm offered 236 calls from people who mentioned its name. Google data showed the rival’s ad appeared 109,322 times on searches for that name. The court calculated: “Evidence of 236 instances of actual confusion, therefore, constitutes only 0.216% of the total number of users exposed to the challenged advertisements.”
A practical file for a Minnesota business can include:
- Dated screenshots of searches for your name on a phone and a computer, showing the full ad and its label.
- The landing page each ad leads to, saved the same day.
- Calls and messages from people who reached the competitor while looking for you, with what they said.
- Auction data. If you run ads on your own name, Google Ads offers an auction report that “lets you compare your performance with other advertisers who are participating in the same auctions that you are.” Google’s help page says the report shows no data when impression share is less than 10%.
What Are Your Options Short of a Lawsuit?
A business owner has five practical options before a lawsuit: a direct call to the other owner, bidding on their own name, a Google complaint, a demand letter, and a negotiated agreement. Each fits a different situation, and they can be combined.
- Owner-to-owner contact. A call or note from one owner to the other costs nothing and keeps the relationship intact, and the other owner may not know what its advertising agency bought. The risk is tipping off a deliberate bidder before you have saved your evidence, so I suggest taking screenshots first.
- Bidding on your own name. Your own labeled ad gives searchers a direct path to you. This is a marketing cost, and it changes nothing about the competitor’s conduct.
- A Google complaint. It can remove your name from a direct competitor’s ad text, but it does not reach the keyword itself. The next section covers how it works.
- A demand letter. A letter fits when the ad text, landing page, or call handling creates confusion and the direct approach did not work. The section after next covers what it should ask for.
- A negotiated agreement. Two businesses can agree on how each uses the other’s name in ads.
Which option fits depends on whether customers are actually being misdirected. If your evidence shows only a labeled ad that never displays your name, the JAND complaint failed to plausibly allege confusion on that kind of record. For that reason, I suggest giving the business options the most weight.
How Does Google’s Trademark Complaint Process Work?
Google reviews a trademark owner’s complaint about how a mark is used in ad text, and it can restrict that use. It does not restrict the purchase of a trademark as a keyword. Google’s decision is a platform rule, and it does not decide whether the law was broken.
Google’s Trademarks policy lists the uses it will not restrict, starting with “Using trademarks as keywords.” It lists the uses it will restrict, including “Using trademarks in an ad from a direct competitor” and ads that use the mark “in a confusing, deceptive, or misleading way.” The policy also says: “The trademark must be used in the ad, not only on the ad’s landing page.”
The complaint has procedural limits. Google states that it “will only accept complaints against specific advertisers identified on the basis of their URL(s) within the countries and industries in which trademark owners have demonstrated trademark rights.” That means you name each competitor by its web address and show your rights in the mark. When Google restricts a mark, the policy says “the restrictions will generally be applied on an ongoing basis in any ads that use the same second-level domain in their final URL.”
A Google complaint fits one problem well: your name in a rival’s ad text. It does nothing about a labeled ad that never mentions your name, and the remedy the policy describes is that Google “may restrict use of the trademark,” with no money for past diversion.
What Should a Demand Letter About Search Ads Ask For?
A demand letter about search ads should ask for the specific changes the cases treat as confusing. Those are removing your mark and look-alike phrases from ad text and web addresses, naming the competitor in its ads, and answering calls under its own name. A letter that demands only an end to keyword bidding asks for something courts in other circuits have held is not infringement.
I suggest tying each demand to evidence you have, because a letter that overreaches can give the competitor grounds to sue first in a court of its choosing. My page on the cease and desist letter for trademark owners covers that risk, what to attach, and how to set the tone. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1111, a registrant that did not give notice of registration, such as the ® symbol, recovers “no profits and no damages” in an infringement suit unless the competitor “had actual notice of the registration.” If your federal registration has not been displayed with that notice, I suggest naming the registration in the letter for that reason.
A competitor may agree to stop bidding on your name as part of resolving the dispute. That term raises antitrust questions, which my page on the trademark settlement agreement addresses, along with the other terms a settlement should cover.
What Can a Court Order Against Infringing Search Ads?
A court can order the competitor to change or stop the confusing ads, and it can award the competitor’s profits, your damages, and costs under federal law. Each remedy has conditions. Minnesota law adds an injunction under its Deceptive Trade Practices Act and, for a mark registered with the state, an injunction, profits, and damages.
Under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a), “A plaintiff seeking any such injunction shall be entitled to a rebuttable presumption of irreparable harm upon a finding of a violation identified in this subsection in the case of a motion for a permanent injunction or upon a finding of likelihood of success on the merits for a violation identified in this subsection in the case of a motion for a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order.” In H&R Block, the Eighth Circuit held the presumption unavailable because the brand owner had not shown a likelihood of confusion.
Money is governed by 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a). Once a violation is established, the plaintiff “shall be entitled, subject to the provisions of sections 1111 and 1114 of this title, and subject to the principles of equity, to recover (1) defendant’s profits, (2) any damages sustained by the plaintiff, and (3) the costs of the action.” Attorney fees are narrower: “The court in exceptional cases may award reasonable attorney fees to the prevailing party.” One condition catches registered owners. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1111, a registrant “failing to give such notice of registration” is limited: “no profits and no damages shall be recovered under the provisions of this chapter unless the defendant had actual notice of the registration.” The ® symbol next to your mark is one form of that notice. Select Comfort also left open how confusion before a sale affects money; the court made “no comment as to how a finding of confusion at times other than the moment of purchase might affect the analysis of remedies and the determination of damages.”
Minnesota’s Deceptive Trade Practices Act covers a business that “causes likelihood of confusion or of misunderstanding as to the source, sponsorship, approval, or certification of goods or services” or “as to affiliation, connection, or association with, or certification by, another” (Minn. Stat. § 325D.44, subd. 1). Its remedy is an injunction, and “Proof of monetary damage, loss of profits, or intent to deceive is not required” (Minn. Stat. § 325D.45, subd. 1). Under subdivision 2, the court may award attorney fees against a business that “has willfully engaged in the trade practice knowing it to be deceptive.” The same subdivision allows fees against an owner who “has brought an action knowing it to be groundless.”
A mark registered with the Minnesota Secretary of State adds a state claim. Minn. Stat. § 333.28 covers use “in connection with rendering of services, selling, offering for sale, or advertising of any goods or services” of a mark so similar to the registered mark “as to be likely to cause confusion or mistake on the part of a purchaser.” Section 333.28 makes the claim subject to Minn. Stat. § 333.30, which preserves rights in a mark “acquired in good faith at any time at common law, except that the rights as against the registrant of the same or confusingly similar mark are limited to the areas of the person’s use established prior to the registration date and areas in which the person’s mark has become known prior to the registration date.” Where the claim under § 333.28 is copying the mark onto labels, signs, or advertisements, the owner recovers profits or damages only if “the acts have been committed with knowledge that such mark is intended to be used to cause confusion or mistake or to deceive.”
Under Minn. Stat. § 333.29, subd. 1, “The court may require the defendants to pay to the owner either or both of the following: (1) all profits derived from the wrongful manufacture, use, display, or sale; or (2) all damages suffered by reason of the wrongful manufacture, use, display, or sale.” The same subdivision adds: “The court, in its discretion, may enter judgment for an amount not to exceed three times the profits and damages and reasonable attorneys’ fees of the prevailing party if the court finds the other party committed the wrongful acts with knowledge or in bad faith or otherwise as according to the circumstances of the case.” My page comparing federal and Minnesota state trademark registration explains when each registration is worth having.
Can Google make a competitor stop bidding on my brand name?
Not through a trademark complaint about the keyword itself. Google’s Trademarks policy lists “Using trademarks as keywords” among the uses it will not restrict. The same policy does restrict “Using trademarks in an ad from a direct competitor,” so a complaint can reach a competitor’s ad that shows your name in its text. Whether the keyword purchase is infringement is a separate legal question that Google’s policy does not decide.
Can I find out which competitors are bidding on my brand name?
Yes, in two ways. Searching your own name on Google shows which ads appear, and screenshots of those results are your first evidence. If you run ads on your own name, Google Ads offers an auction report that compares your ads with other advertisers in the same auctions. Google’s help page says that report shows no data when impression share is less than 10%, so your own searches remain the most direct check.
Should I bid on my own brand name?
That is a business decision, and no law requires it. An ad of your own on your name gives a searcher a labeled path to you on the same results page. In the 1-800 Contacts case against Warby Parker (JAND, 2d Cir. 2024), the court pointed to a screenshot showing the brand owner’s own paid ad just below the rival’s; that ad “prominently displays 1-800’s Marks twice.”
Do I need a registered trademark to object to a competitor's search ads?
No. The federal statute at 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a) reaches use in commerce of any word, term, name, symbol, or device likely to cause confusion. The Tenth Circuit in Lens.com (2013) wrote that under it the owner of any valid mark, registered or not, may sue. A federal registration adds the infringement claim under 15 U.S.C. § 1114. A registrant who did not display notice of registration, such as the ® symbol, recovers no profits or damages unless the competitor had actual notice of the registration (15 U.S.C. § 1111). Minnesota’s Deceptive Trade Practices Act is Minn. Stat. § 325D.44. It reaches a business that causes likelihood of confusion or of misunderstanding, including as to the source, sponsorship, or approval of goods or services or an affiliation with another.
What if the competitor's ad sends callers to a call center that does not say who it is?
That combination can support a claim. In Adler (5th Cir. 2021), the court reversed the dismissal of a complaint alleging keyword use combined with generic, unlabeled ads and call-center staff who answered without saying who they were. That ruling came at the pleading stage, before any evidence was tested. In Select Comfort (8th Cir. 2021), transcripts of callers who believed they had called the brand owner were part of the confusion evidence. Recordings or notes of those calls can matter as much as the ad itself.
Does it matter that my customers are businesses rather than consumers?
It can. The Eighth Circuit holds that confusion before a sale cannot count where the average buyers are as sophisticated as careful professional purchasers. The question is how carefully your average buyer shops, and consumers are not automatically outside it. In Select Comfort (8th Cir. 2021), the court wrote that “authority is mixed as to whether mattress shoppers and online shoppers should be deemed careful, sophisticated consumers.” It also said a finding of customer sophistication typically will rest with the jury, so evidence about how your buyers actually shop bears on whether they meet that standard.
Will I have to prove the competitor meant to confuse people?
Not to show a likelihood of confusion, but some money remedies turn on what the competitor knew. In the Eighth Circuit, intent is one nonexclusive factor, and no one factor controls. Minn. Stat. § 325D.45 provides that a Deceptive Trade Practices Act injunction requires no proof of monetary damage, loss of profits, or intent to deceive. Minn. Stat. § 325D.44 adds that a complainant need not prove actual confusion. Attorney fees under § 325D.45, and profits or damages on some state-registration claims, require proof of knowledge. The section What Can a Court Order Against Infringing Search Ads? quotes each condition.
Next Steps When a Competitor Bids on Your Name
A competitor’s bid on your name is a business problem first, and it becomes a legal claim when the ads are likely to cause confusion. The Eighth Circuit has held that confusion before a sale may count unless the buyers are as sophisticated as careful professional purchasers. For that reason, the ad text, the landing page, and the call handling matter more than the keyword. I suggest saving dated screenshots and records of misdirected customers before contacting the competitor, because that record shapes each option from a phone call to a lawsuit. My trademark practice page covers the related work.
If a competitor’s search ads are drawing customers who were looking for your business, email [email protected] with a short description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.