When the Minnesota Department of Human Services (“DHS”) determines there is a credible allegation of fraud under investigation against a Medical Assistance provider, it must temporarily withhold or reduce that provider’s payments without advance notice. DHS need not do so if it finds good cause not to suspend payments under the federal rule, 42 C.F.R. § 455.23(e) or (f). That withhold is temporary, it rests on an allegation rather than a finding, and the provider can answer it. I suggest treating the withhold notice as the most important document in the matter, because it names the statute DHS relies on and sets out the allegations you can answer.
Two layers of law govern a DHS payment withhold based on fraud. A federal Medicaid regulation, 42 C.F.R. § 455.23, requires every state Medicaid agency to suspend payments on a credible allegation of fraud unless the agency has good cause not to. Minnesota carries that rule out in Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, which the Legislature amended in 2026 with new subdivisions on notice, administrative review, 90-day reviews, and forfeiture. A second Minnesota statute, Minn. Stat. § 245.095, lets DHS withhold payments across all of its programs.
This page is for owners of Minnesota businesses enrolled to bill Medical Assistance: home care and personal care agencies, disability and housing services providers, substance use disorder programs, and similar health and human-services businesses. Owners of clinics and practices face the same withhold rules, and the page for medical and dental practice owners covers their other questions. The Minnesota healthcare attorney page covers the wider set of healthcare rules, and the regulatory compliance practice page covers the agency issues a licensed business faces.
How Does a DHS Payment Withhold Work?
A fraud-based DHS payment withhold stops or reduces a provider’s Medical Assistance payments while a fraud investigation is pending, and DHS imposes it before telling the provider. Under Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c, “the commissioner must temporarily withhold or reduce payments to an individual or entity without providing advance notice of the withholding or reduction” when the provider is convicted of a crime involving the conduct the statute describes, or when “the commissioner determines there is a credible allegation of fraud for which an investigation is pending under the program.” A newly enrolled provider can face a different withhold with no fraud allegation: “If the commissioner or the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services designates a provider type as high-risk under section 256B.044, subdivision 1, the commissioner may withhold payment from providers within that category upon initial enrollment for a 90-day period,” and “The withholding for each provider must begin on the date of the first submission of a claim” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.0443). The fraud-based duty has a good-cause exception, described next.
The duty applies “Except when the commissioner finds good cause not to suspend payments under Code of Federal Regulations, title 42, section 455.23(e) or (f)” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c). The federal regulation behind it reads the same way: “The State Medicaid agency must suspend all Medicaid payments to a provider after the agency determines there is a credible allegation of fraud for which an investigation is pending under the Medicaid program against an individual or entity unless the agency has good cause to not suspend payments or to suspend payment only in part” (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(a)). Under 42 C.F.R. § 455.23(e), “A State may find that good cause exists” on listed grounds. One is where “beneficiary access to items or services would be jeopardized by a payment suspension” because “An individual or entity is the sole community physician or the sole source of essential specialized services in a community” or because “The individual or entity serves a large number of beneficiaries within a HRSA-designated medically underserved area” (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(e)(4)). Section 455.23(f)(1) uses the same two access grounds for a partial suspension. Another is written evidence from the provider, discussed below.
A withhold can reach payments that come through a managed care plan. Federal rules require the state’s contract with each plan to include “Provision for the MCO’s, PIHP’s, or PAHP’s suspension of payments to a network provider for which the State determines there is a credible allegation of fraud” under the federal suspension rule (42 C.F.R. § 438.608(a)(8)).
DHS also holds a separate, discretionary withhold power. Under Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 5, “Except as otherwise provided by state or federal law, the commissioner may withhold payments to a provider, vendor, individual, associated individual, or associated entity in any program administered by the commissioner” on grounds that include “a credible allegation of fraud for which an investigation is pending for a program administered by a Minnesota state or federal agency.” The two statutes carry different review routes, so the statute your notice cites decides what you can do next.
What Counts as a Credible Allegation of Fraud?
A credible allegation of fraud is an allegation DHS has verified and judged reliable after a careful, case-by-case review; it is not a finding that fraud happened. The standard appears in Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c: “Allegations are considered credible when the allegations have indicia of reliability and the commissioner has reviewed all allegations, facts, and evidence carefully and acts judiciously on a case-by-case basis.” Under the same subdivision, a credible allegation is “an allegation that has been verified by the state from any source,” and the statute lists sources it includes without limiting itself to them:
- “fraud hotline complaints”
- “claims data mining”
- “patterns identified through provider audits, civil false claims cases, and law enforcement investigations”
- “court filings and other legal documents, including but not limited to police reports, complaints, indictments, informations, affidavits, declarations, and search warrants”
Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 2, uses a similar definition for its own withholds and adds “information from the inspector general appointed under chapter 15E.”
The statute keeps the allegation apart from the question of whether it is true. When an administrative law judge reviews a withhold, the recommendation “must not make findings on the veracity of the underlying allegations of fraud, as the underlying investigation remains ongoing and underlying facts may be litigated in future administrative, civil, or criminal proceedings after the commissioner issues a final decision” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2d).
What Must the Withhold Notice Tell You?
DHS must send written notice no later than five days after the withhold starts, unless a law enforcement agency asks in writing to delay it. The notice must describe the allegations “in a manner reasonably calculated to provide notice” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c), though it need not disclose specific information DHS determines is likely to jeopardize an ongoing investigation. Subdivision 2c of Minn. Stat. § 256B.064 sets the timing: “The commissioner must send notice of the withholding or reduction of payments under paragraph (a) within five days of withholding or reducing payments unless requested in writing by a law enforcement agency to temporarily withhold the notice.” The notice must do five things:
- State that payments are being withheld or reduced under that subdivision.
- “set forth the allegations as to the nature of the withholding or reduction in a manner reasonably calculated to provide notice, which must include but is not limited to date ranges of suspected claims, locations of suspected service delivery, and general nature of individual or entity conduct, but need not disclose specific information that the commissioner determines is likely to jeopardize an ongoing investigation”
- Except after a conviction, state that the withhold is temporary and cite the circumstances that will end it.
- “identify the types of claims to which the withholding or reduction applies”
- “inform the individual or entity of the right to submit written evidence for consideration by the commissioner.”
The notice arrives by mail, and its legal effect runs from the mailing. DHS “must serve the notice required under this section using a signature-verified confirmed delivery method to the address submitted to the department by the individual or entity. Service is complete upon mailing” (subd. 4). I suggest keeping the address on file with DHS current. I also suggest recording each notice’s mailing date, from its postmark or delivery record, because service is complete upon mailing.
How Long Does a Payment Withhold Last?
Minnesota ties a fraud-based withhold’s end to events rather than to a number of days. DHS must immediately stop withholding once it determines the evidence of fraud is insufficient or the legal proceedings over the alleged fraud are completed, whichever comes first. That duty does not apply if DHS has sent notice of intention to impose monetary recovery or sanctions. The release rule is in Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c: “The commissioner must immediately cease to withhold or reduce payments under this subdivision and must release the withheld or reduced payments no later than ten days following the earlier of the commissioner’s determination that there is insufficient evidence of fraud by the individual or entity, or legal proceedings relating to the alleged fraud are completed, unless the commissioner has sent notice of intention to impose monetary recovery or sanctions.” The final clause matters: once DHS sends notice of a proposed recovery or sanction, that ten-day release duty does not apply.
A withhold can also end sooner. The federal good-cause rule that subdivision 2c cites provides that “A State may find that good cause exists not to suspend payments, or not to continue a payment suspension previously imposed” on listed grounds (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(e)). Under 42 C.F.R. § 455.23(d)(4), “If the Medicaid fraud control unit or other law enforcement agency declines to accept the fraud referral for investigation the payment suspension must be discontinued unless the State Medicaid agency has alternative Federal or State authority by which it may impose a suspension or makes a fraud referral to another law enforcement agency.” The federal rule also says suspensions “will be temporary and will not continue after” either “The agency or the prosecuting authorities determine that there is insufficient evidence of fraud by the provider” or “Legal proceedings related to the provider’s alleged fraud are completed” (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(c)).
Each 90 days a withhold stays in place, an administrative law judge checks whether the investigation is still active. “If a payment withhold or reduction under subdivision 2c remains in effect after 90 days, the commissioner must submit evidence to an administrative law judge under seal for the administrative law judge to determine whether the commissioner or a law enforcement agency is actively pursuing an investigation under this section” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2e). The judge reviews that evidence privately, and under subd. 2e “The recommendation of the administrative law judge is advisory and the commissioner’s decision to continue a withholding is final and not subject to appeal or reduction.” DHS must send you notice no later than ten business days after each review, and “The notice must include the administrative law judge’s recommendation.” The subdivision describes DHS submitting evidence and the provider receiving notice; it does not describe a submission by the provider.
A conviction changes the result. “Upon conviction of a crime related to the provision, management, or administration of a health service under medical assistance, a payment withheld pursuant to this section by the commissioner or a managed care organization that contracts with the commissioner under section 256B.035 is forfeited to the commissioner or managed care organization, regardless of the amount charged in the criminal complaint or the amount of criminal restitution ordered” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2g).
How Do You Challenge a Payment Withhold?
You can answer a withhold under § 256B.064 in several ways, including by submitting written evidence to DHS and by filing a written request for an administrative review before an administrative law judge. The review asks one narrow question: whether DHS can establish a credible allegation of fraud. Written evidence can also support a request that DHS lift the withhold or narrow it to part of the business. A withhold under § 245.095 follows a different route, described at the end of this section.
Written evidence. The notice must tell you of “the right to submit written evidence for consideration by the commissioner” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c). Under the federal good-cause rules, written evidence can support lifting a withhold or narrowing it. A state may end a suspension when “The State determines, based upon the submission of written evidence by the individual or entity that is the subject of the payment suspension, that the suspension should be removed” (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(e)). It may limit a whole suspension to part on the same kind of written showing. It may also do so where “The credible allegation focuses solely and definitively on only a specific type of claim or arises from only a specific business unit of a provider” and the state documents in writing that a partial suspension would keep potentially fraudulent claims from being paid (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(f)). In one inquiry I answered, a provider had already given the Attorney General’s Office its timesheets, payroll records, care plans, and service agreements, and the owner pointed to proof DHS already held. As I wrote in reply, neither was the written-evidence submission the withhold notice described, and that notice said where to mail it.
Administrative review. Under Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2d, a provider “may request a review under paragraph (c) by filing with the commissioner a written request for an administrative review.” “The review request must specify the reason the payment withholding or reduction decision is in error and clearly request a review,” and DHS then has ten business days to refer it to the Court of Administrative Hearings. Four features shape the review:
- Cost. “The costs for the review under paragraph (c) must be borne equally by both parties.”
- Scope. “The burden of proof upon review of a temporary withhold or reduction is limited to whether the commissioner can establish that there is a credible allegation of fraud as provided in subdivision 2c, paragraph (a), clause (2).”
- Evidence. DHS submits its evidence under seal, you may submit evidence that the withhold is in error, the judge reviews the evidence privately, and “The commissioner must not be subject to discovery by the individual or entity during the proceedings.”
- Effect. The judge’s findings “must not be used or considered for any other purpose, including impeachment, in any civil, criminal, administrative, or contractual proceeding,” and “The administrative law judge’s findings of facts, conclusions of law, and recommendations under subdivisions 2d and 2e are not subject to judicial review” (subd. 2f).
A § 245.095 withhold. If the notice cites Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 5, it must “inform the provider, vendor, individual, associated individual, or associated entity of the right to submit written evidence to contest the withholding action for consideration by the commissioner,” and the provider “has a right to request administrative reconsideration.” “A request for administrative reconsideration must be made in writing, state with specificity the reasons the payment withholding decision is in error, and include documents to support the request.” DHS then has 60 days from receiving the request to decide whether the withhold stays, and “The withholding of payments under this section is a temporary action and is not subject to appeal under section 256.045 or chapter 14.”
How Is a Withhold Different From a Sanction or Overpayment Recovery?
A withhold is temporary and comes before any hearing. For a sanction or a monetary recovery, DHS must give prior notice and an opportunity for a contested case hearing, subject to exceptions the statute states. Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2, says “Except as provided in subdivision 2c, the commissioner must not obtain a monetary recovery or impose a sanction without prior notice and an opportunity for a hearing, according to chapter 14, on the commissioner’s proposed action, provided that the commissioner may suspend or reduce payment to an individual or entity, except a nursing home or convalescent care facility, after notice and prior to the hearing if in the commissioner’s opinion that action is necessary to protect the public welfare and the interests of the program.” Exclusion from Medicare is another exception: “The commissioner must suspend or terminate an individual’s or entity’s participation in the program without providing advance notice and an opportunity for a hearing when the suspension or termination is required because of the individual’s or entity’s exclusion from participation in Medicare” (subd. 2b).
The sanctions include suspending payments, temporarily withholding payments, suspending or “terminating participation in the program,” and fines (subd. 1b). “When imposing sanctions under this section, the commissioner must consider the nature, chronicity, or severity of the conduct and the effect of the conduct on the health and safety of persons served by the individual or entity.” Monetary recovery is broader than fraud: “The commissioner may obtain monetary recovery from an individual or entity that has been improperly paid by the department either as a result of conduct described in subdivision 1a or as a result of an error by the individual or entity submitting the claim or by the department, regardless of whether the error was intentional” (subd. 1c), including by “debiting from future payments any money improperly paid.” Missing paperwork has its own penalty: “The commissioner may order an individual or entity to forfeit a fine for failure to fully document services according to standards in this chapter and Minnesota Rules, chapter 9505” (subd. 2a).
To contest a proposed sanction or recovery, you file a written appeal request. Under subd. 2, the request must list each disputed item with the reason and an estimated dollar amount, the computation you believe is correct, and the statute or rule you rely on. It must also name a contact person and include “other information required by the commissioner.” “A timely appeal stays payment of the fine until the commissioner issues a final order” (subd. 2a). After DHS’s final decision, court review runs by a petition for a writ of certiorari to the Court of Appeals under Minn. Stat. § 14.63.
How Do Enrollment and Licensing Actions Interact With a Withhold?
DHS can act on a provider’s enrollment and on a DHS license separately from a withhold, and each action has its own rules. On enrollment, “If a provider fails to comply with any individual provider requirement or condition of participation, the commissioner may suspend the provider’s ability to bill until the provider comes into compliance” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.0442, subd. 1). DHS may impose that billing suspension immediately when needed to protect public funds or program integrity, and “The commissioner’s decision to suspend a provider’s ability to bill is not subject to an administrative appeal.” Subdivision 3 requires DHS to deny or terminate enrollment on listed grounds. One is when “CMS or the commissioner determines that the provider has falsified any information provided on the application or cannot verify the identity of any provider applicant.” Another is an owner of 5% or more with a program-related conviction in the last ten years, unless DHS documents in writing that termination is not in the program’s best interests. Termination imposed as a sanction under § 256B.064 carries the contested case hearing described above, except a termination required by Medicare exclusion (subd. 2b).
A program that holds a license DHS issued under chapter 245A faces a second track. DHS must suspend the license on a temporary, immediate basis when “the license holder or controlling individual is criminally charged in state or federal court with an offense that involves fraud or theft against a program administered by a state or federal agency” (Minn. Stat. § 245A.07, subd. 2). DHS may impose the same suspension when the license holder or a controlling individual “is the subject of a pending administrative, civil, or criminal investigation or subject to an administrative or civil action related to fraud against a program administered by a state or federal agency.” At the expedited hearing on that second kind of suspension, DHS’s burden “is met only if the commissioner demonstrates by a preponderance of the evidence that the license holder or controlling individual is the subject of a pending administrative, civil, or criminal investigation or is subject to an administrative or civil action related to fraud against a program administered by a state or federal agency” (subd. 2a). A temporary immediate suspension has two effects:
- Funding. “No state funds shall be made available or be expended by any agency or department of state, county, or municipal government for use by a license holder regulated under this chapter while a license issued under this chapter is under immediate suspension.”
- Operation. “A license holder and any controlling individual shall discontinue operation of the program upon receipt of the commissioner’s order to immediately suspend the license.”
The license holder may appeal a temporary immediate suspension and a later suspension or revocation. For an ordinary suspension or revocation, “Except as provided in subdivision 2a, paragraph (c), if a license holder submits a timely appeal of an order suspending or revoking a license, the license holder may continue to operate the program as provided in section 245A.04, subdivision 7, paragraphs (i) and (j), until the commissioner issues a final order on the suspension or revocation” (subd. 3). The exception it names reads: “When the final order under paragraph (b) affirms an immediate suspension, or the license holder does not submit a timely appeal of the immediate suspension, and a final licensing sanction is issued under subdivision 3 and the license holder appeals that sanction, the license holder continues to be prohibited from operation of the program pending a final commissioner’s order under section 245A.08, subdivision 5, regarding the final licensing sanction” (subd. 2a(c)). After an immediate suspension that is affirmed or not timely appealed, if the license holder “remains the subject of a pending administrative, civil, or criminal investigation or subject to an administrative or civil action related to fraud against a program administered by a state or federal agency,” then “the commissioner shall issue a suspension order under subdivision 3, paragraph (a), clause (6)” (subd. 2a(b)), and “The license holder shall continue to be prohibited from operation of the program while a suspension order issued under paragraph (b), clause (2) or (3), remains in effect” (subd. 2a(d)).
The tracks feed each other. Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 5, lets DHS withhold payments when “the provider is operating after a state or federal agency orders the suspension, revocation, or decertification of the provider’s license or certification, or if the provider is subject to a temporary immediate suspension, regardless of whether the action is under appeal.” When a provider is excluded from one DHS program, Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 1, directs DHS to “disenroll, revoke or suspend a license, disqualify, or debar the excluded provider, vendor, or individual in any other program administered by the commissioner.” A license issued by a city or county follows a different process, covered on the page about a city business license suspension or revocation.
What Deadlines Apply After a DHS Notice?
Each appealable DHS action this page covers has its own deadline. Each runs from the event its statute names: the mailing of the notice, the license holder’s receipt of it, or the date DHS issued an order through the provider hub. A billing suspension under Minn. Stat. § 256B.0442, subd. 1, “is not subject to an administrative appeal.” The periods for the actions this page covers, quoted from each statute:
- Withhold review. The provider requests it “by filing with the commissioner a written request for an administrative review,” and “The review request must be received by the commissioner no later than 30 days after the date the notification of the payment withhold or reduction was mailed to the individual or entity” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2d).
- Proposed sanction or monetary recovery. “The appeal request must be received by the commissioner no later than 30 days after the date the notification of monetary recovery or sanction was mailed to the individual or entity” (subd. 2).
- Disenrollment or other action after an exclusion. The provider appeals “by filing with the commissioner a written request of appeal,” and “The commissioner must receive the appeal request no later than 30 days after the date the notice was mailed to the provider, vendor, individual, associated individual, or associated entity” (Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 4).
- Court review after a contested case. “A petition for a writ of certiorari by an aggrieved person for judicial review under sections 14.63 to 14.68 must be filed with the court of appeals and served on all parties to the contested case not more than 30 days after the party receives the final decision and order of the agency” (Minn. Stat. § 14.63).
- Temporary immediate suspension of a DHS license. “The appeal of an order immediately suspending a license must be made in writing by certified mail, personal service, or other means expressly set forth in the commissioner’s order. If mailed, the appeal must be postmarked and sent to the commissioner within five calendar days after the license holder receives notice that the license has been immediately suspended. If a request is made by personal service, it must be received by the commissioner within five calendar days after the license holder received the order” (Minn. Stat. § 245A.07, subd. 2).
- License suspension or revocation. “The appeal of an order suspending or revoking a license must be made in writing by certified mail, by personal service, or through the provider licensing and reporting hub. If mailed, the appeal must be postmarked and sent to the commissioner within ten calendar days after the license holder receives notice that the license has been suspended or revoked. If a request is made by personal service, it must be received by the commissioner within ten calendar days after the license holder received the order. If the order is issued through the provider hub, the appeal must be received by the commissioner within ten calendar days from the date the commissioner issued the order through the hub” (subd. 3).
Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.
What Other Exposure Can Follow a Fraud Withhold?
A withhold that grows out of a DHS fraud investigation comes with a referral to law enforcement. When a state investigation leads to a payment suspension, the federal rule requires a written fraud referral to the Medicaid fraud control unit that must “Be made in writing and provided to the Medicaid fraud control unit not later than the next business day after the suspension is enacted” (42 C.F.R. § 455.23(d)). Minnesota’s statute adds that “When a temporary withholding or reduction of payments under subdivision 2c involves potential criminal conduct, the commissioner must coordinate with appropriate law enforcement authorities, including the Minnesota attorney general’s Medicaid Fraud Control Unit, and may consult with state or federal investigative agencies as necessary” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 7).
Other consequences can follow from the same facts:
- Recovery and sanctions. DHS may seek repayment and impose sanctions up to termination, through the contested case process described above. One sanction is mandatory: “The commissioner must suspend an individual’s or entity’s participation in the program for a minimum of five years if the individual or entity is convicted of a crime, received a stay of adjudication, or entered a court-ordered diversion program for an offense related to a provision of a health service under medical assistance, including a federally approved waiver, or health care fraud” (subd. 1b).
- The exclusion list. “The commissioner must maintain and publish a list of each excluded individual and entity that was convicted of a crime related to the provision, management, or administration of a medical assistance health service, or suspended or terminated under this section” (subd. 3). “Medical assistance payments cannot be made by an individual or entity for items or services furnished either directly or indirectly by an excluded individual or entity, or at the direction of excluded individuals or entities.”
- Other DHS programs. Exclusion from one program reaches the others under § 245.095, subd. 1.
- Forfeiture. A related conviction forfeits withheld payments under subd. 2g.
Information moves between these tracks. “The commissioner may exchange information, including claims data, with state or federal agencies, professional boards, departments, or programs for the purpose of investigating or prosecuting a criminal, civil, or administrative proceeding related to suspected fraud or exclusion from any program administered by a state or federal agency” (Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 6). The statute’s protection against later use, quoted above, covers the administrative law judge’s findings, conclusions, and recommendation. Statements and records given to DHS can be shared with the agencies investigating the same facts.
How Do You Keep Payroll and Client Services Going During a Withhold?
Payroll obligations continue while DHS’s payments stop. Minn. Stat. § 181.101 says “every employer must pay all wages, including salary, earnings, and gratuities earned by an employee at least once every 31 days” on a regular payday designated in advance, and the section has no exception for a business whose payments are withheld. If staff leave, final pay follows two rules. After a discharge by an employer “employing labor within this state,” “the wages or commissions actually earned and unpaid at the time of the discharge are immediately due and payable upon demand of the employee” (Minn. Stat. § 181.13). After a resignation, “the wages or commissions earned and unpaid at the time the employee quits or resigns shall be paid in full not later than the first regularly scheduled payday following the employee’s final day of employment,” unless a collective bargaining agreement provides otherwise; migrant workers have a separate rule (Minn. Stat. § 181.14, subd. 1). The pages on Minnesota’s final pay rules and layoffs in Minnesota cover the steps if the business has to cut staff.
Clients come next. A disability services provider licensed under chapter 245D may end services on listed grounds, one of which reads “the license holder has not been paid for services, except an interruption to a person’s public benefits that has lasted less than 60 days does not constitute nonpayment” (Minn. Stat. § 245D.10, subd. 3a). The statute does not say directly whether a DHS withhold counts as nonpayment under that clause. “Prior to giving notice of service termination, the license holder must document actions taken to minimize or eliminate the need for termination,” and the written notice goes to the person or the person’s legal representative and the case manager. Those documented actions must include, at a minimum, “consultation with the person’s support team or expanded support team to identify and resolve issues leading to issuance of the termination notice” and “a request to the case manager for intervention services identified in section 245D.03, subdivision 1, paragraph (c), clause (1), or other professional consultation or intervention services to support the person in the program,” though for the case manager request, “This requirement does not apply to notices of service termination issued under paragraph (b), clauses (4) and (7),” and clause (4) is the nonpayment ground quoted above (subd. 3a(c)). “If, based on the best interests of the person, the circumstances at the time of the notice were such that the license holder was unable to take the action specified in clauses (1) and (2), the license holder must document the specific circumstances and the reason for being unable to do so.”
The notice must include “the reason for the action”; except when the program or license holder ceases to operate, “a summary of actions taken to minimize or eliminate the need for service termination or temporary service suspension as required under paragraph (c), and why these measures failed to prevent the termination or suspension”; “the person’s right to appeal the termination of services under section 256.045, subdivision 3, paragraph (a)”; and “the person’s right to seek a temporary order staying the termination of services according to the procedures in section 256.045, subdivision 4a or 6, paragraph (c)” (subd. 3a(d)(2)). “If the service termination is from residential supports and services as defined in section 245D.03, subdivision 1, paragraph (c), clause (3), or from integrated community supports as defined in section 245D.03, subdivision 1, paragraph (c), clause (8), the license holder must also notify the commissioner in writing.”
The notice periods are set in the same subdivision: “Notice of the proposed termination of service, including those situations that began with a temporary service suspension, must be given at least 90 days prior to termination of services under paragraph (b), clause (7), 60 days prior to termination when a license holder is providing intensive supports and services identified in section 245D.03, subdivision 1, paragraph (c), and 30 days prior to termination for all other services licensed under this chapter.”
If DHS issues a temporary immediate suspension to a residential program, “For suspensions issued to a licensed residential program as defined in section 245A.02, subdivision 14, the effective date of the order may be delayed for up to 30 calendar days to provide for the continuity of care of service recipients” (Minn. Stat. § 245A.07, subd. 2b). The same subdivision imposes a duty: “The license holder must cooperate with the commissioner” so that “service recipients receive continued care during the period of the delay” and “to facilitate the transition of service recipients to new providers.” It also limits the delay: “In these cases, the suspension order takes effect when all service recipients have been transitioned to a new provider or 30 days after the suspension order was issued, whichever comes first.” I suggest planning client transitions early, because people who depend on daily care cannot wait for a review to finish.
A 2026 statute adds duties for providers serving a “recipient” of “community residential services, family residential services, customized living, 24-hour customized living, integrated community supports, residential substance use disorder treatment services, or residential mental health treatment services under medical assistance” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.045, subd. 1): “If a medical assistance service provider determines it is unable to continue to provide services to a recipient due to a serious operational event, the provider must: (1) notify each recipient; each recipient’s responsible party, if applicable; the lead agency; and the commissioner as soon as possible but no later than 30 days before terminating services to each recipient; (2) fully cooperate with the commissioner and lead agency in supporting each recipient in transitioning to another provider of each recipient’s choice; and (3) provide each recipient with a copy of the relevant recipient bill of rights or recipient protections, if applicable, as soon as possible but no later than 30 days before terminating services” (subd. 2).
Two other statutes extend these duties beyond residential services: “Providers of home care services must meet the recipient protection requirements under section 256B.045 when subject to an administrative action or a serious operational event as defined in section 256B.045, subdivision 1” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.0651, subd. 17), and “Agency-providers of CFSS services or FMS providers must meet the recipient protection requirements under section 256B.045” on the same terms (Minn. Stat. § 256B.85, subd. 23a(c)). Under § 256B.045, subd. 1, an “administrative action” includes a decision to “initiate a payment withhold under section 245.095 or 256B.064.” These duties add to the licensing rules: “Nothing in this section absolves a provider of its obligations under chapters 144A, 144G, 245A, 245D, 245G, and 245I with respect to service suspensions, service terminations, contract terminations, and coordinated moves” (§ 256B.045, subd. 2(b)).
What Options Does a Provider Have After a Withhold?
A provider facing a withhold has several paths, and the right mix depends on what the notice alleges, how much revenue it reaches, and whether law enforcement is involved. The statute the notice cites decides which legal routes are open: a § 256B.064 withhold carries administrative review, and a § 245.095 withhold carries administrative reconsideration. These are the main paths, legal and practical:
- Submit written evidence. This fits when the allegation rests on a misunderstanding the records can answer, such as which enrollment or service line the conduct involves. Its risk is that whatever the business submits can reach the agencies investigating, so the submission should be accurate and complete.
- Ask DHS to narrow the withhold. Under 42 C.F.R. § 455.23(f), “A State may find that good cause exists to suspend payments in part” on listed grounds. One applies where the allegation “focuses solely and definitively on only a specific type of claim” or “arises from only a specific business unit of a provider,” and the State “determines and documents in writing” that a partial suspension would keep “potentially fraudulent claims” from “continuing to be paid.” A narrower withhold can keep unaffected service lines paid while the investigation runs.
- File a written request for administrative review. This fits when there is reason to doubt that DHS verified the allegation with the care the statute requires. Its limits are real: the question is narrow, DHS’s evidence is sealed, the cost is shared, and the judge’s findings, conclusions, and recommendations “are not subject to judicial review” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2f).
- Talk with DHS about scope, in writing. A direct exchange with the DHS investigator about which claims, locations, and dates the notice covers can clarify what the business needs to answer. I suggest writing that exchange with the expectation that law enforcement may read it, because DHS must coordinate with law enforcement when a withhold involves potential criminal conduct (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 7).
- Build a cash plan. Payroll, rent, and insurance keep coming. A line of credit, revenue from services outside Medical Assistance, cost reductions, and an honest timeline from the business’s banker and accountant decide how long the business can operate unpaid.
- Preserve the records. Timesheets, visit notes, care plans, service agreements, payroll records, and messages are the evidence for each route above. The page on preserving records during an investigation covers how.
- Plan an orderly wind-down if it comes to that. If the business cannot carry the cost, a planned transition of clients and staff under the notice and final-pay rules above protects the people served and limits new claims against the business. Those notice rules include the licensing-chapter duties that § 256B.045, subd. 2(b), keeps in force.
These options can run together: written evidence, a request to narrow the withhold, and a cash plan do not exclude one another.
Can our program keep operating while DHS withholds payments?
It depends on the license action. For a program holding a DHS license under chapter 245A, the answer turns on which order the program has received. Those orders include a temporary immediate suspension, an order suspending or revoking the license, and a later order after an immediate suspension is affirmed or not timely appealed. Minn. Stat. § 245A.07 governs operation after each of these orders, and the section above on enrollment and licensing actions quotes the operating rules from subdivisions 2, 2a, and 3.
Can we appeal if our enrollment shows termination status?
Yes for a Minn. Stat. § 256B.064 sanction or § 245.095, subd. 1, disenrollment, “by filing with the commissioner a written request of appeal” received “no later than 30 days after the date the notification of monetary recovery or sanction was mailed” (§ 256B.064, subd. 2) or “no later than 30 days after the date the notice was mailed” (§ 245.095, subd. 4). Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. A Medicare-exclusion termination has no hearing (§ 256B.064, subd. 2b), and a § 256B.0442 billing suspension “is not subject to an administrative appeal.”
Does a withhold mean DHS has found that we committed fraud?
Not when the withhold rests on “a credible allegation of fraud for which an investigation is pending under the program” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c), which is an allegation rather than a finding. A withhold can also follow a conviction “of a crime involving the conduct described in subdivision 1a.” On review, the administrative law judge’s recommendation “must not make findings on the veracity of the underlying allegations of fraud” (subd. 2d). The judge’s findings also “must not be used or considered for any other purpose, including impeachment, in any civil, criminal, administrative, or contractual proceeding.”
Will DHS tell us who made the allegation?
Not necessarily. Under Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 5, “After an investigation is complete, the reporter’s name must be kept confidential,” and the subject may compel disclosure “only with the consent of the reporter or upon a written finding by a district court that the report was false and there is evidence that the report was made in bad faith.” That subdivision “does not alter disclosure responsibilities or obligations under the Rules of Criminal Procedure,” and when the identity is relevant to a prosecution, “the district court must conduct an in-camera review before determining whether to order disclosure.”
Do payments from our managed care plans stop too?
They can. Federal rules require each state contract with a managed care plan to include “Provision for the MCO’s, PIHP’s, or PAHP’s suspension of payments to a network provider for which the State determines there is a credible allegation of fraud” under the federal suspension rule (42 C.F.R. § 438.608(a)(8)). Minnesota’s forfeiture rule also reaches a payment withheld by “a managed care organization that contracts with the commissioner” if a related conviction follows (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2g).
Can DHS withhold payments for our other programs or a related company?
Yes, within the classes the statute defines. “Except as otherwise provided by state or federal law,” Minn. Stat. § 245.095, subd. 5, lets DHS withhold payments to “a provider, vendor, individual, associated individual, or associated entity in any program administered by the commissioner” on listed grounds, including a credible allegation of fraud under investigation. An “associated entity” is “a provider or vendor owned or controlled by an excluded individual,” and an “associated individual” is one that “would have knowledge of the financial practices of the program in question” (subd. 2). The provider may submit written evidence and request administrative reconsideration.
What happens if the investigation ends?
DHS must immediately stop withholding and release the withheld payments “no later than ten days following the earlier of” its determination that the evidence of fraud is insufficient or the end of the legal proceedings, “unless the commissioner has sent notice of intention to impose monetary recovery or sanctions” (Minn. Stat. § 256B.064, subd. 2c). After a “conviction of a crime related to the provision, management, or administration of a health service under medical assistance,” the withheld payment is forfeited “regardless of the amount charged in the criminal complaint or the amount of criminal restitution ordered” (subd. 2g).
Next Steps After a DHS Payment Withhold
A fraud-based DHS payment withhold is a temporary action resting on an allegation, and the statute the notice cites decides the review route. I suggest identifying which statute the notice cites and recording its mailing date, because service of the notice is complete upon mailing. I also suggest deciding early whether to submit written evidence, ask for a partial withhold, or request review, because payments stay withheld while you decide. Payroll and client care continue while the matter runs. For other agency and licensing issues, the compliance practice page covers the wider set of rules.
If DHS has withheld your payments and you want to know which route fits your notice, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.