Protecting Your Assets: Understanding Trusts, Fraudulent Transfer Laws, and Beneficial Interest
The fear of being sued and losing valuable assets can be a daunting prospect for many individuals, especially those with substantial wealth or investments. Fortunately, there are legal measures that can be taken to protect assets from potential lawsuits and creditors. One such strategy involves utilizing a revocable trust and understanding the concept of fraudulent transfer laws and the right to step into your shoes for beneficial interest. In this article, we will explore the fundamentals of these tools and how they can provide a level of asset protection for you and your beneficiaries.
The Revocable Trust
A revocable trust, also known as a living trust, is a legal entity created during a person’s lifetime to hold and manage assets. The person who establishes the trust, known as the grantor, transfers ownership of their assets into the trust’s name. As the term “revocable” suggests, the grantor retains the ability to modify or revoke the trust at any time during their lifetime, maintaining control over the assets held within it.
Asset Protection Benefits
One of the significant advantages of a revocable trust is its ability to shield assets from probate. Probate is the legal process through which a court validates a will and distributes assets to beneficiaries after a person’s death. By placing assets in a revocable trust, they pass directly to the trust’s beneficiaries, bypassing the probate process. This ensures a smoother and potentially more private transfer of wealth.
However, it is crucial to understand that while a revocable trust provides probate avoidance, it does not offer substantial protection against lawsuits or creditors during the grantor’s lifetime. Since the grantor maintains control over the trust and its assets, the assets are still considered part of their personal estate, susceptible to potential claims.
Fraudulent Transfer Laws
The concept of asset protection becomes more relevant when considering fraudulent transfer laws. These laws are designed to prevent individuals from deliberately transferring assets to avoid creditors and legal obligations. A transfer can be classified as fraudulent if it is done with the intent to defraud creditors or if it leaves the grantor insolvent or unable to meet existing obligations.
When it comes to revocable trusts, the possibility of invoking fraudulent transfer laws depends on the timing of the trust’s creation and funding. If a trust is established long before any potential legal threat arises, and the funding is not done with fraudulent intent, it may be more challenging for creditors to challenge the trust’s validity.
Right to Step into Your Shoes for Beneficial Interest
In certain cases, courts can order a grantor to access the assets held in a revocable trust for the purpose of satisfying their debts or legal obligations. This concept is known as the “right to step into your shoes for beneficial interest.” Essentially, this means that while the grantor may not directly own the trust assets, they still benefit from them, and, therefore, those assets can be considered as potentially available to creditors.
The extent to which creditors can access trust assets depends on various factors, including state laws, the intent behind the trust’s creation, and the nature of the debt or liability involved. Therefore, it is essential to consult with a knowledgeable attorney when structuring your trust and considering asset protection.
Conclusion
A revocable trust can serve as an effective estate planning tool to avoid probate and provide for a smoother transfer of assets to beneficiaries after the grantor’s death. However, when it comes to protecting assets from potential lawsuits and creditors during the grantor’s lifetime, a revocable trust may offer limited benefits. Understanding the nuances of fraudulent transfer laws and the right to step into your shoes for beneficial interest is essential when considering asset protection strategies.
To ensure that your assets are adequately protected, it is crucial to work closely with a qualified estate planning attorney. They can guide you through the process of establishing a trust that aligns with your specific needs and objectives, while also helping you navigate the complex legal landscape to safeguard your assets effectively. Remember, asset protection is a proactive measure, and planning ahead can provide you and your loved ones with peace of mind for the future.
Video Transcript
Before I Get Sued, Can I Transfer All My Assets to a Trust?
So here is the setup. Imagine you realize there is a good chance you are going to get sued. Let’s assume it is for a specific situation. Do you have the right to transfer all of your assets into a trust at that time? And if you do, will that protect you? And in particular, will it protect the assets that you have transferred into the trust?
So let’s say, for example, you have a cabin, a home, shares in a business that you own and operate, and some expensive vehicles. Can you transfer all of those into a trust so that if you get sued and lose in court, you don’t have any money? Everything is in the trust. And so, you might even be able to file for bankruptcy, and everything is protected in the trust. Will that work? No, it won’t. It won’t work for a variety of reasons. And I will explain what those reasons are.
Understanding Revocable Trusts and Their Limitations
So first off, the most common type of trust used for estate planning is a revocable trust. That is a trust that you can revoke or change. You can put stuff in and pull it out, etc. That is not going to work because whatever you have a right to in a lawsuit, your creditor would have a right to. So if you have a right to pull stuff out of a trust, the creditor has a right to that. So that is not going to work.
Exploring Irrevocable Trusts for Asset Protection
But what about an irrevocable trust? An irrevocable trust can protect your assets from creditors in certain circumstances. But it is not going to work here. First, what is an irrevocable trust? An irrevocable trust is a trust that you set up, and you cannot change it. You cannot revoke it. You cannot modify it after you have set it up. So sometimes, though, people will name themselves as a trustee, so they get to manage that trust, or they will name themselves as a beneficiary, which means they can benefit from the assets of the trust.
Challenges with Irrevocable Trusts for Asset Protection
So why doesn’t this work? Well, first, if you want to continue to use your business and your home and your vehicles, you are going to need to be a beneficiary because a beneficiary is a person who benefits from those assets if you put them into an irrevocable trust, and if you wanted to make decisions about all this stuff, you are probably going to want to be a trustee. If you are a trustee or a beneficiary, the creditor, if the court grants it, has rights to everything you have. You could benefit from driving the vehicle or selling the vehicle; the creditor would have those rights.
Considerations with Foreign Trusts and Jurisdiction
There is an exception to this, and that is if you use a trust that is in another country that does not honor the orders by United States courts, and you appoint somebody else as the trustee of that trust. But keep in mind, if you are here in the United States and, in that case, the court has jurisdiction over you, the court can tell you what to do, including holding you in contempt of court if a court believes that you have the ability to make payments to a creditor, but you are not doing it.
So it is quite difficult to set up an irrevocable trust that allows you to benefit from some of the assets unless you get sued, in which case some other appointee or trustee appointed by you is handling that and cutting you essentially off from that.
You can do it, but there is a significant expense. You have to find essentially a law firm in another country that will serve as your trustee. But there are a couple of other problems with this. If you set this up at the time that you are aware of a threat and a lawsuit, the court can undo that transaction, essentially disgorging the trust of these assets. If these assets are located in the United States, a court can order the county recorder’s office to change the title of real estate. The court can order the department of motor vehicles to change the title of vehicles. The court can order a bank to transfer money to your creditor. So even though a trust may be outside the jurisdiction of the United States courts, if the assets or the property or you are within the United States, you are susceptible to the jurisdiction and authority of the courts here in the United States. Sure, a trust might make it a little more difficult, but ultimately, a court can grant access to a creditor or ownership to a creditor for your stuff that is within the United States jurisdiction.
Fraudulent Transfer Laws and Bankruptcy Code Implications
Another problem with transferring assets into a trust at the time, you know, of a threat is what is called fraudulent transfer laws. If you transfer anything with the intent of preventing a creditor from getting access to it, so you have a known creditor, a known threat, and you transfer it away, under fraudulent transfer statutes, that transaction can be undone by a court.
Very similarly, the bankruptcy laws, the United States bankruptcy code, allow a trustee to undo transactions for the benefit of creditors. So a trustee can retroactively do this. There are a number of online services that sell these international trusts to protect your assets. There is a lot of hype. There is a lot of fear-mongering that goes along with that. If you are considering doing something like that, I would recommend you work with an attorney licensed in your state who is representing you, not one of these services, to take a look at the circumstances and determine, does it really protect you in the way that you hope?
I am a bit cynical because I see the hype and the fear-mongering from some of these services. And my clients have come to me and said, “Will this protect us? We need to do this right away.” In fact, I have had clients who have already spent the money, and I look at the situation, I go, “It is not going to protect you. We have fraudulent transfer laws. We have a bankruptcy code. The court already has jurisdiction over you and all the assets that you have. These assets are in the United States.” For many, many reasons, you usually cannot transfer assets into a trust and thereby protect them from your creditors. Now, if you do it way in advance, sometimes it can work. It all depends on the circumstances.
Conclusion
If you’d like to be notified of the next YouTube live that we have, or the next live Q&A, you can go visit aaronhall.com/free, enter your email address, and you will get access to exclusive educational videos. You will also receive a notice next time we go live. You can also subscribe on YouTube, and if you follow us on other social media platforms, you will see some of the videos that we put out on those as well. It was great having some time with you today. If you have follow-up questions, feel free to add them to the comment section below or send them by email. We will do our best to answer those in the next live Q&A. Thanks for joining me today.