Minnesota employees owe their employer a duty of loyalty while the employment lasts. The duty bars the employee from soliciting your customers for themselves or otherwise competing with you until the job ends, though the employee may prepare to compete. Once employment ends, the duty no longer restricts the former employee. A nondisclosure or nonsolicitation agreement, trade secret law, and claims for unfair competition or misuse of confidential information can still protect the employer.
The duty comes from Minnesota case law rather than a statute, and statutes govern the pieces around it: trade secrets, noncompetes, unemployment benefits, whistleblower protection, and final pay. This page is for Minnesota business owners and managers who suspect a current employee of working against the company. Officers and directors have separate duties under corporate law, covered in fiduciary duties of officers and directors. This page is part of my trade secret and employee-departure materials.
What Is an Employee’s Duty of Loyalty in Minnesota?
An employee’s duty of loyalty is a duty, which Minnesota case law treats as part of the employment relationship, not to work against the employer while employed: no soliciting its customers for oneself and no competing with it. It applies to rank-and-file employees and managers alike, whether or not they signed anything.
The Minnesota Supreme Court applied the duty to a dairy route driver in Sanitary Farm Dairies, Inc. v. Wolf, 261 Minn. 166, 112 N.W.2d 42 (Minn. 1961). In his last two days on the job, the driver told about half the customers he called on that he would later in the week solicit their business on his own behalf as a distributor of a competitor’s products. The court wrote: “This, in our opinion, constituted a solicitation of business inconsistent with the loyalty which he owed his employer.” It relied on the Restatement of Agency, quoting: “Unless otherwise agreed, an agent is subject to a duty not to compete with the principal concerning the subject matter of his agency.”
The Minnesota Court of Appeals put it plainly in Marn v. Fairview Pharmacy Services LLC, 756 N.W.2d 117 (Minn. Ct. App. 2008): “caselaw has established that employees owe a duty of loyalty to their employers.” In Rehabilitation Specialists, Inc. v. Koering, 404 N.W.2d 301 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), the employee “did not have a written employment contract with RSI, nor had she signed a covenant not to compete,” and the court still sent the loyalty claim to trial.
Is an Employee Held to the “Punctilio of an Honor the Most Sensitive”?
No. That phrase states the strict standard for partners and joint venturers, and a Minnesota employee’s duty is narrower. It comes from Meinhard v. Salmon, 249 N.Y. 458, 164 N.E. 545 (N.Y. 1928), where Chief Judge Cardozo wrote for the New York Court of Appeals: “Joint adventurers, like copartners, owe to one another, while the enterprise continues, the duty of the finest loyalty.” He continued: “A trustee is held to something stricter than the morals of the market place. Not honesty alone, but the punctilio of an honor the most sensitive, is then the standard of behavior.”
Meinhard is New York law, so a Minnesota court may find it persuasive but is not bound by it. The Minnesota employee cases bar soliciting customers and competing while employed, and they still allow an employee to prepare to compete.
What Does the Duty of Loyalty Prohibit While Someone Still Works for You?
While employed, an employee may not solicit your customers for their own benefit or otherwise compete with you. Koering states the rule: “An employee’s duty of loyalty prohibits her from soliciting the employer’s customers for herself, or from otherwise competing with her employer, while she is employed.”
In Koering, the company’s administrator, whose “responsibilities included soliciting business and negotiating contracts for RSI,” told a major customer she was thinking of starting her own business, tentatively secured five contracts from it, and sent it draft contracts before she resigned. The company had no contracts at those five facilities. The court still said “it was Koering’s duty to attempt to secure additional contracts from it for RSI, not for herself.” Quoting a federal appeals decision, the court added that “If prospective customers undertake the opening of negotiations which the employee could not initiate, he must decline to participate in them.” Reversing summary judgment for the employee, the court wrote, “We reverse and remand for trial.” It held only that “a fact issue exists as to whether her conduct crossed the line from preparation to solicitation,” not that a breach occurred.
The duty reaches more than taking customers. In Marn, an employee left anonymous messages urging one of his employer’s major customers to reevaluate its contract and suggesting the customer start its own pharmacy. The court held that he “had a duty of loyalty to his employer and he violated that duty when he attempted to interfere with” the employer’s business contract.
Not every complaint about an employee is a loyalty claim. Sanitary Farm Dairies, Koering, and Marn each involved an employee working against the business while still employed: soliciting its customers, competing with it, or interfering with its contract with a customer.
How Far Can an Employee Go in Preparing to Compete?
An employee may take steps to start a competing business before resigning, but may not begin competing or soliciting customers until the job ends. Koering says an employee “has the right, therefore, while still employed, to prepare to enter into competition with her employer,” and that “There is no precise line” between preparation and solicitation.
The preparation in Koering included forming a company, financing, and insurance: “Prior to leaving, Koering filed corporate documents for her new business, met with a bank to obtain financing and applied for business insurance.” The court did not treat those steps as the problem; the customer dealings were. The Restatement comment that Sanitary Farm Dairies quoted draws the same line, saying an agent “may purchase a rival business and upon the termination of the agency immediately compete with his former employer,” but “may not, however, before the termination of his employment, solicit customers for such rival business.”
Sanitary Farm Dairies phrased the limit this way: an employee “cannot feather his own nest at the expense of his employer while he is still on the payroll.” Because the line is drawn case by case, “Whether an employee’s actions constituted a breach of her duty of loyalty is a question of fact to be determined based on all the circumstances of the case.” That is why a loyalty claim can survive summary judgment, as the claim in Koering did. The steps to take when an employee resigns to join or start a competitor are covered in when an employee leaves to compete.
How Does the Duty Apply to Confidential Information and Trade Secrets?
An employee who takes or uses your confidential information can face a claim for breaking a contract or a common-law duty, and a trade secret claim under Minnesota and federal law. Where the claim rests on misappropriating a trade secret, the Minnesota Uniform Trade Secrets Act (MUTSA) replaces conflicting tort and restitution claims, while contract claims survive.
The Minnesota Supreme Court addressed former employees who used confidential information in Cherne Industrial, Inc. v. Grounds & Associates, Inc., 278 N.W.2d 81 (Minn. 1979). It held: “A trial court may issue an injunction against a party who has, in violation of an explicit agreement or a common law duty, wrongfully used confidential information or trade secrets obtained from his employer.” The former employees in that case had signed agreements barring them from using or disclosing confidential information, and the court found they “had both contractual and common law duties not to disclose this information and not to use it to harm plaintiff’s business.” Cherne was decided before Minnesota adopted MUTSA.
Under Minn. Stat. § 325C.01, subd. 5, information is a trade secret only if it “derives independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known to, and not being readily ascertainable by proper means by, other persons who can obtain economic value from its disclosure or use, and” it “is the subject of efforts that are reasonable under the circumstances to maintain its secrecy.” Misappropriation under subdivision 3 includes “acquisition of a trade secret of another by a person who knows or has reason to know that the trade secret was acquired by improper means,” and subdivision 2 defines improper means to include “theft, bribery, misrepresentation, breach or inducement of a breach of a duty to maintain secrecy, or espionage through electronic or other means.” More on what counts as a trade secret is in a separate article.
MUTSA also changes how the claim is pled. Under Minn. Stat. § 325C.07, the act displaces “conflicting tort, restitutionary, and other law of this state providing civil remedies for misappropriation of a trade secret.” It does not affect “contractual remedies, whether or not based upon misappropriation of a trade secret” or “other civil remedies that are not based upon misappropriation of a trade secret.” A loyalty claim built on soliciting customers stands on its own; a loyalty claim that only restates a trade secret taking runs into § 325C.07.
When Does the Duty of Loyalty End?
The duty of loyalty ends with the employment. After that, a former employee may compete and approach customers, subject to any valid agreement, the rules on trade secrets and confidential information, and the principles of unfair competition. Minnesota’s noncompete ban leaves nondisclosure and nonsolicitation agreements as the main contract tools.
In Sanitary Farm Dairies, the court was “not persuaded that the identity and location of customers, whose patronage has been secured by the joint efforts of an employer and a route employee, constitute either a trade secret, confidential information, or a property right which requires equitable protection.” It held that “In the absence of a restrictive covenant, and subject to the principles of unfair competition,” it was not error to deny the employer’s motion for a temporary injunction “in so far as it sought to enjoin the defendants from doing business with” customers on the routes the driver was servicing when he quit. The court also held that the driver “was obliged to give plaintiff sufficient notice of his intention to quit,” and that lulling the employer into believing he had reconsidered “was unfair competition.” For the customers that conduct affected, the trial court “should have enjoined defendants from soliciting or doing business with such customers until plaintiff had an adequate opportunity to do its own soliciting,” but the restraining order the Supreme Court entered on appeal “has accomplished the same purpose,” so the court affirmed the denial.
A noncompete is no longer available for most new agreements. Under Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 2, “Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable.” The 2023 law that enacted it states: “This section is effective July 1, 2023, and applies to contracts and agreements entered into on or after that date.” The two exceptions are a noncompete “agreed upon during the sale of a business” and one “agreed upon in anticipation of the dissolution of a business.”
Subdivision 1 keeps the other tools: “A covenant not to compete does not include a nondisclosure agreement, or agreement designed to protect trade secrets or confidential information. A covenant not to compete does not include a nonsolicitation agreement, or agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists, or solicit customers of the employer.” I suggest signing those agreements at hiring rather than at departure, because they are the contract protection that remains once the duty of loyalty ends. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1833(b)(3), “An employer shall provide notice of the immunity set forth in this subsection in any contract or agreement with an employee that governs the use of a trade secret or other confidential information,” and an employer that does not “may not be awarded exemplary damages or attorney fees under subparagraph (C) or (D) of section 1836(b)(3) in an action against an employee to whom notice was not provided.” The notice rule “shall apply to contracts and agreements that are entered into or updated after the date of enactment of this subsection,” and an employer “shall be considered to be in compliance with the notice requirement” if it “provides a cross-reference to a policy document provided to the employee that sets forth the employer’s reporting policy for a suspected violation of law.” Drafting points are covered in nondisclosure agreements that hold up.
What Can an Employer Recover When an Employee Breaches the Duty?
The legal consequences of disloyalty for an employee can include a lawsuit, an injunction, forfeited pay, a firing that costs unemployment benefits, and, where the conduct is theft, criminal charges, each covered below. An employer can sue for breach of the duty of loyalty and, on the same facts, for unfair competition, and can ask a court for an injunction against using confidential information. When trade secrets are involved, MUTSA allows an injunction and damages for actual loss and unjust enrichment, and the federal act allows a parallel claim.
Koering held that “An employee’s breach of his duty of loyalty may constitute unfair competition.” Cherne shows the injunction remedy for confidential information. Under the Minnesota Uniform Trade Secrets Act, Minn. Stat. § 325C.02 provides that “Actual or threatened misappropriation may be enjoined,” and Minn. Stat. § 325C.03 provides that “Damages can include both the actual loss caused by misappropriation and the unjust enrichment caused by misappropriation that is not taken into account in computing actual loss.”
Under the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act, 18 U.S.C. § 1836(b)(1) provides that “An owner of a trade secret that is misappropriated may bring a civil action under this subsection if the trade secret is related to a product or service used in, or intended for use in, interstate or foreign commerce.” Under § 1836(b)(3), a court may grant an injunction “to prevent any actual or threatened misappropriation described in paragraph (1) on such terms as the court deems reasonable.” The order may not “prevent a person from entering into an employment relationship, and that conditions placed on such employment shall be based on evidence of threatened misappropriation and not merely on the information the person knows,” and it may not “otherwise conflict with an applicable State law prohibiting restraints on the practice of a lawful profession, trade, or business.” When the federal route fits is covered in federal Defend Trade Secrets Act claim.
Self-help with the employee’s pay is limited by statute. Under Minn. Stat. § 181.79, subd. 1, an employer may not deduct a claimed debt from wages “unless the employee, after the loss has occurred or the claimed indebtedness has arisen, voluntarily authorizes the employer in writing to make the deduction or unless the employee is held liable in a court of competent jurisdiction for the loss or indebtedness.” Subdivision 1 also provides that “A deduction may not be in excess of the amount established by law as subject to garnishment or execution on wages.” It adds that “Any authorization for a deduction shall set forth the amount to be deducted from the employee’s wages during each pay period,” and that “Any agreement entered into between an employer and an employee contrary to this section shall be void.” The section does not apply “in cases where a contrary provision in a collective bargaining agreement exists,” where an employee, “prior to making a purchase or loan from the employer, voluntarily authorizes in writing that the cost of the purchase or loan shall be deducted from the employee’s wages,” or to certain discipline rules for commissioned salespeople. Under subdivision 2, an employer that violates the section “shall be liable in a civil action brought by the employee for twice the amount of the deduction or credit taken.” That is the remedy under § 181.79 alone; a deduction from final pay can add the final-pay remedies in the next paragraph.
A separate common-law rule can defeat pay that a seriously disloyal employee claims. In Stiff v. Associated Sewing Supply Co., 436 N.W.2d 777 (Minn. 1989), the Minnesota Supreme Court reinstated a trial court judgment that an employee who had embezzled company funds forfeited the commissions he claimed. It explained that § 181.79 “applies when a disputed deduction is attempted to be offset against an undisputed wage or earnings,” and that in that case “it is the earnings, themselves, which are in dispute.” Stiff applied the 1978 text of § 181.79. Under Marsh v. Minneapolis Herald, Inc., 270 Minn. 443, 134 N.W.2d 18 (Minn. 1965), a forfeiture “may result” where a breach “causes loss to the employer or is willful and fraudulent or corrupt” and “goes to the very root of the subject-matter” of the employment. When pay is weekly, Marsh adds, the misconduct “must be established for each week worked.” In Marsh itself, the court found the evidence of disloyalty insufficient and reversed with directions to enter judgment for the employee.
Final pay follows its own timing rules. Minn. Stat. § 181.13 makes earned and unpaid wages “immediately due and payable upon demand of the employee” after a discharge. The employee’s demand “must be in writing but need not state the precise amount of unpaid wages or commissions” under the same section. If the wages are “not paid within 24 hours after demand, whether the employment was by the day, hour, week, month, or piece or by commissions, the employer is in default” and owes a penalty. Minn. Stat. § 181.14, subd. 1, governs pay after a resignation. It requires payment “not later than the first regularly scheduled payday following the employee’s final day of employment, unless an employee is subject to a collective bargaining agreement with a different provision.” The same subdivision adds: “If the first regularly scheduled payday is less than five calendar days following the employee’s final day of employment, full payment may be delayed until the second regularly scheduled payday but shall not exceed a total of 20 calendar days following the employee’s final day of employment.” For an employee who handled company money or property, subdivision 4 gives the employer “ten calendar days after the termination of the employment to audit and adjust the accounts of the employee before the employee’s wages or commissions shall be paid as provided in this section, and the penalty herein provided shall apply in such case only from the date of demand made after the expiration of the period allowed for payment of the employee’s wages or commissions.” Subdivision 4 also bars a deduction from final pay for losses or claimed debts except as § 181.79 permits. In an employee’s action for a violation of § 181.13 or § 181.14, Minn. Stat. § 181.171, subd. 3, provides that “the court shall order an employer who is found to have committed a violation to pay to the aggrieved party reasonable costs, disbursements, witness fees, and attorney fees.” A dispute over how much pay is owed, as distinct from a deduction for losses, has its own rule in § 181.14, subdivision 3. An employer that “makes a legal tender of the amount which the employer in good faith claims to be due” is not liable “for any sum greater than the amount so tendered and interest thereon at the legal rate,” unless the employee recovers a greater sum in court.
Each claim carries its own filing deadline, set by statute, and I suggest checking the current text for each claim rather than relying on a general rule. Because breach is a fact question under Koering, I also suggest preserving the emails, texts, and system records that show what the employee did and when, because a court will decide the claim on all the circumstances.
How Does an Employer Investigate a Suspected Breach of Loyalty?
An employer usually detects a loyalty breach through a tip, a lost customer, or irregularities in its records, and confirms it by reviewing those records before confronting the employee. Common warning signs are a customer mentioning that the employee approached them, a key account dropping without explanation, a coworker’s or hotline report, and an audit that turns up irregularities in expense reports, invoices, sales data, or account activity.
I suggest preserving the evidence before anything else: stop any routine deletion of the employee’s email and files, and set aside the company laptop and phone the employee used. The investigation should then review what the company already holds, such as company email, calendars, customer-relationship records, financial records, and system logs showing file downloads, transfers to personal accounts, or access to information outside the job. An employee’s personal accounts and devices raise separate legal questions, so I suggest getting advice before reviewing anything the company does not own.
Interviews should start with the people who know the facts, such as the coworker who raised the concern, a supervisor, or a customer who was contacted, with a written note of what each said and when. The employee under suspicion is usually interviewed last, once the records are in hand. A coworker who reported a suspected violation of law in good faith is protected by Minn. Stat. § 181.932, quoted below, so the investigation should never treat the report itself as a problem. For an employee who handled company money or property, the ten-calendar-day audit period in § 181.14, subdivision 4, quoted above, gives the employer time to check the employee’s accounts before final wages are due.
A written summary of each finding and the evidence behind it should come before any decision on discipline, a demand letter, or a lawsuit. I suggest involving counsel before you confront the employee, so the investigation is shaped around the claims and remedies that may follow.
Can Breach of the Duty of Loyalty Lead to Criminal Charges?
Breach of the duty of loyalty is not itself a crime in Minnesota, but conduct that breaches it, such as stealing company money or a trade secret, can be charged under a criminal statute. The duty comes from case law, and under Minn. Stat. § 609.015, subd. 1, “Common law crimes are abolished and no act or omission is a crime unless made so by this chapter or by other applicable statute.”
Minnesota’s theft statute, Minn. Stat. § 609.52, subd. 2, reaches a person who “intentionally and without claim of right takes, uses, transfers, conceals or retains possession of movable property of another without the other’s consent and with intent to deprive the owner permanently of possession of the property.” That covers an employee who takes or keeps company funds. It also covers trade secrets. A person commits theft who “intentionally and without claim of right converts any article representing a trade secret, knowing it to be such, to the actor’s own use or that of another person.” Under subdivision 3, the sentence depends largely on the value stolen. Theft of “an article representing a trade secret” carries up to “imprisonment for not more than ten years or to payment of a fine of not more than $20,000, or both.” Federal law adds a trade secret crime in 18 U.S.C. § 1832(a) for one who, intending to convert a trade secret “that is related to a product or service used in or intended for use in interstate or foreign commerce, to the economic benefit of anyone other than the owner thereof,” and “intending or knowing that the offense will, injure any owner of that trade secret,” knowingly “steals, or without authorization appropriates, takes, carries away, or conceals” it.
A prosecutor, not the employer, decides whether to charge. A criminal case does not replace the civil claims above; the employer brings those itself.
Can Third Parties Sue for Breach of the Duty of Loyalty?
The employee’s duty of loyalty runs to the employer, so the employer is the party with the claim. Marn describes a duty that “employees owe . . . to their employers,” and Koering frames it as a bar on “soliciting the employer’s customers for herself, or from otherwise competing with her employer.” A customer or other outsider harmed by the same conduct would need a legal claim of its own, separate from the loyalty claim.
Are There Insurance Policies Covering Breaches of the Duty of Loyalty?
Some policies cover part of the loss, and the answer turns on the policy’s own wording. Employee theft of money or property is usually the subject of commercial crime or fidelity coverage, which a standard general liability policy typically does not provide. Directors and officers (D&O) policies respond to certain claims against the company’s leaders, and they commonly exclude deliberate dishonesty. I suggest pulling every policy and reading its insuring agreement, exclusions, and notice requirements as soon as you suspect a loss, because crime policies usually set deadlines for notice and proof of loss.
How Does a Loyalty Breach Affect Unemployment Benefits?
An employee fired for a serious breach of the duty of loyalty can be ineligible for unemployment benefits, because Minnesota disqualifies an applicant discharged for employment misconduct. The decision turns on the statute’s definition of misconduct, not on the employer’s label.
Under Minn. Stat. § 268.095, subd. 4, an applicant discharged by an employer is ineligible if “the applicant was discharged because of employment misconduct as defined in subdivision 6.” Subdivision 6 defines it: “Employment misconduct means any intentional, negligent, or indifferent conduct, on the job or off the job, that is a serious violation of the standards of behavior the employer has the right to reasonably expect of the employee.” The same subdivision excludes “conduct an average reasonable employee would have engaged in under the circumstances” and “good faith errors in judgment if judgment was required.” It also provides: “If the conduct for which the applicant was discharged involved only a single incident, that is an important fact that must be considered in deciding whether the conduct rises to the level of employment misconduct under paragraph (a).”
In Marn, an unemployment-law judge disqualified the employee who urged a major customer to reevaluate its contract, and the Court of Appeals affirmed on review, holding that the breach of the duty of loyalty was disqualifying misconduct. Marn applied an earlier version of the definition, which the legislature has since amended, so the current text quoted above governs a new case.
Why Is Reporting a Legal Violation Not Disloyalty?
An employee who in good faith reports a violation, suspected violation, or planned violation of law to you, to any governmental body, or to a law enforcement official is protected by Minnesota’s whistleblower statute, so the report cannot be treated as disloyalty. The statute does not permit knowingly false or reckless statements, or disclosures that would violate law. The duty of loyalty reaches working against the business, such as steering away its customers.
Under Minn. Stat. § 181.932, subd. 1, “An employer shall not discharge, discipline, penalize, interfere with, threaten, restrain, coerce, or otherwise retaliate or discriminate against an employee regarding the employee’s compensation, terms, conditions, location, or privileges of employment” because the employee “in good faith, reports a violation, suspected violation, or planned violation of any federal or state law or common law or rule adopted pursuant to law to an employer or to any governmental body or law enforcement official.” Subdivision 1 also protects an employee who “in good faith, reports a situation in which the quality of health care services provided by a health care facility, organization, or health care provider violates a standard established by federal or state law or a professionally recognized national clinical or ethical standard and potentially places the public at risk of harm.” The statute does not protect everything labeled a report. Subdivision 3 provides that the section “does not permit an employee to make statements or disclosures knowing that they are false or that they are in reckless disregard of the truth,” and Minn. Stat. § 181.931, subd. 4, defines good faith as “conduct that does not violate section 181.932, subdivision 3.” Subdivision 5 provides that the section “does not permit disclosures that would violate federal or state law or diminish or impair the rights of any person to the continued protection of confidentiality of communications provided by common law.” Under Minn. Stat. § 181.935, an injured employee “may bring a civil action to recover any and all damages recoverable at law, together with costs and disbursements, including reasonable attorney’s fees, and may receive such injunctive and other equitable relief as determined by the court.”
Federal law adds a trade secret immunity. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1833(b)(1), “An individual shall not be held criminally or civilly liable under any Federal or State trade secret law for the disclosure of a trade secret” made “in confidence to a Federal, State, or local government official, either directly or indirectly, or to an attorney” and “solely for the purpose of reporting or investigating a suspected violation of law,” or made in a court filing “if such filing is made under seal.” Subsection (b)(5) adds that, “Except as expressly provided for under this subsection, nothing in this subsection shall be construed to authorize, or limit liability for, an act that is otherwise prohibited by law, such as the unlawful access of material by unauthorized means.”
Marn shows the difference in an unemployment case. The question the court decided was whether the unemployment-law judge erred “in determining that relator was discharged for employment misconduct,” and the opinion does not apply § 181.932. The employee there had patient-safety concerns, and in answering his argument that an average employee would have acted as he did, the court said the case was not a whistleblower situation. It noted that he did not report the alleged wrongdoing to the board of pharmacy or the company’s hotline and instead contacted a major customer. The court wrote: “If relator was concerned about how prescriptions were being filled, an appropriate recourse might have been to contact the board of pharmacy with a specific report. Relator also could have called Fairview’s anonymous hotline to report alleged wrongdoing.” I suggest reading any complaint an employee raises for a possible legal violation before you treat it as disloyalty, because a good-faith report within the statute is protected even when it is unwelcome.
What Does a Company Owe Its Employees in Return?
The employer’s side of the relationship is set mostly by statute. The obligations this page touches are to pay final wages on the schedule in Minn. Stat. §§ 181.13 and 181.14, deduct a claimed loss from wages only as § 181.79 allows, and never retaliate against a good-faith report protected by § 181.932. Each is quoted above, in the sections on what an employer can recover and on reporting a legal violation. An employer that breaks one of them can owe the employee money even while its own loyalty claim against that employee is strong, so I suggest keeping the two separate: pay what is undisputed, and sue for the loss.
How Does the Duty of Loyalty Work for Officers, Directors, and Shareholders?
Officers and directors owe duties of good faith to the corporation under corporate statutes, and a shareholder can enforce those duties for the corporation through a derivative claim. Those duties are covered in more depth in fiduciary duties of officers and directors.
How Do Loyalty Duties Shape Corporate Governance?
For a Minnesota business corporation, Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 1, provides that “A director shall discharge the duties of the position of director in good faith, in a manner the director reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances.” Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 1, applies the same standard to officers. Deals between the corporation and its own directors have a separate procedure in Minn. Stat. § 302A.255, subd. 1, which keeps such a transaction from being “void or voidable” because a director is a party if one of the statute’s conditions is met. In practice, those rules are why boards adopt conflict-of-interest policies, have interested directors disclose their stake, and have disinterested directors or shareholders approve the deal.
How Does Breach of the Duty of Loyalty Affect Shareholder Rights?
A director’s or officer’s disloyalty usually harms the corporation first, so a shareholder’s main tool is a derivative action, a suit brought on the corporation’s behalf. Minn. R. Civ. P. 23.09 describes it as an action “brought by one or more shareholders or members to enforce a right of a corporation,” with “the corporation or association having failed to enforce a right which may properly be asserted by it.” The complaint must “allege with particularity the efforts, if any, made by the plaintiff to obtain the desired action from the directors,” and the case “shall not be dismissed or compromised without the approval of the court.”
How Do Duty of Loyalty Standards Vary Across States and Countries?
The duty of loyalty is state law, so its standards vary from state to state, and other countries have their own rules; this page states Minnesota’s rule. A company with employees in several states or countries should expect that the law where the employee works, or the law an agreement validly chooses, may govern a given dispute. I suggest conflict-of-interest, outside-work, and confidentiality policies written to hold up under the law of each place you employ people, and agreements reviewed under that place’s law before anyone signs.
Does an employee who signed no agreement still owe a duty of loyalty?
Yes. The duty comes from the employment itself, not from a signed document. In Rehabilitation Specialists, Inc. v. Koering, 404 N.W.2d 301 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), the administrator who left to compete had no written employment contract and had not signed a covenant not to compete, and the Minnesota Court of Appeals still sent the employer’s loyalty claim to trial. A signed agreement adds contract rights, such as a nondisclosure or nonsolicitation term, that can last after the job ends.
Can I withhold a disloyal employee's final paycheck?
Not as an offset. Minn. Stat. § 181.79 bars deducting a claimed debt from wages without a judgment or the employee’s voluntary written authorization given after the debt arose, stating a per-pay-period amount, and caps deductions at the garnishment limit. Exceptions include a contrary union contract and a voluntary written purchase or loan authorization given beforehand. A violation costs twice the deduction, and final-pay penalties and fees can apply under §§ 181.13, 181.14, and 181.171. Under Stiff v. Associated Sewing Supply Co. (Minn. 1989), an embezzling employee forfeited claimed commissions. I suggest paying undisputed wages and suing for the loss.
May my employee accept work a customer offers without being asked?
Probably not while still employed. In Rehabilitation Specialists, Inc. v. Koering, 404 N.W.2d 301 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), the trial court had ruled for the employee because she discussed her plans to leave but did not solicit the employer’s customers. Quoting a federal appeals decision, the Court of Appeals said that if prospective customers open negotiations the employee could not initiate, the employee must decline to participate in them. It found a fact question and reversed summary judgment for the employee. Whether a particular exchange crossed the line is decided on all the circumstances.
Can an employee run a side business while working for me?
It depends on whether the business competes with you. The duty Minnesota courts enforce is a duty not to compete with the employer concerning the subject matter of the job, unless the parties agreed otherwise, as the Minnesota Supreme Court noted in Sanitary Farm Dairies, Inc. v. Wolf (Minn. 1961). A side business serving your customers or selling what you sell is the conduct the cases address. Your written policies on outside work and on company time and information can set further terms.
Is a former employee free to contact my customers?
Generally yes, after the job ends, subject to any valid agreement, trade secret and confidential-information rules, and unfair competition principles. In Sanitary Farm Dairies, Inc. v. Wolf (Minn. 1961), with no restrictive covenant, the Minnesota Supreme Court upheld denying a temporary injunction against a former driver doing business with customers on his routes, but held he competed unfairly by lulling the employer about quitting. Minn. Stat. § 181.988 voids noncompetes entered into on or after July 1, 2023, except one agreed upon during a business sale or in anticipation of dissolution, and excludes nondisclosure, nonsolicitation, and client-list agreements.
Can I fire an employee who reported our company to a state agency?
Not because of a good-faith report. Minn. Stat. § 181.932, subd. 1, bars an employer from discharging, disciplining, or penalizing an employee because the employee in good faith reported a violation, suspected violation, or planned violation of law to the employer or to any governmental body or law enforcement official; the statute does not permit knowingly false or reckless statements or disclosures that would violate law. Under Minn. Stat. § 181.935, the employee can sue for damages, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees, and can receive injunctive relief. A firing for other, documented reasons is a separate question.
Next Steps When You Suspect an Employee Is Disloyal
A Minnesota employee’s duty of loyalty bars soliciting your customers or competing with you while employed, allows preparation to compete, and ends with the employment. What you can do turns on what the employee did and when, whether a trade secret or a signed agreement is involved, and whether any complaint the employee raised was a protected report. When the employee has already left with your information, the steps for a former employee who took your secrets apply.
More on trade secrets and employee departures is on the practice page. If you suspect a current or departing employee of soliciting your customers or competing with you and want to know which claims fit your facts, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.