Minnesota’s Court of Appeals held the guarantor liable, in whole or in part, in 12 of the 19 decisions in this index on a guaranty of a business, commercial, or investment obligation. Those decisions, filed from January 1, 2016, through November 20, 2026, decided whether, or how much, a guarantor owed, a guarantor’s defense, or a paying guarantor’s rights under the guaranty. In three, the guarantor was a company rather than a person (33 City Center, Gamma, 2700 Hennepin). The court affirmed full liability in 10 and partial liability in 2, held the guarantor not liable in 4, reversed and remanded 1 on the amount owed, and decided 2 on other grounds. My searches found no Minnesota Supreme Court decision on a guarantor’s liability in that window.

The guarantors who won pointed to the documents, a statute, or the creditor’s own conduct. A lease guarantee had expired by its own terms (33 City Center). The company suing could not prove it held the landlord’s rights (Drummer). A later signed sale-of-goods agreement superseded the guarantee, and the supplier’s claims under it were time-barred (Trebelhorn). No signed written promise existed (Hentges). A lender’s statutory violation cut what the guarantors owed (First and Third). A guaranty judgment was not renewed in time (Klingelhutz).

The common defenses failed. Lack of consideration failed where the guaranty was part of the deal or the lender extended a past-due loan (Williams, 11 Water). Lease changes the guaranty allowed did not release the guarantor (Life Fitness), and an eviction settlement limited to possession did not end the guaranty (R&S Crossing). General complaints about the bank’s numbers did not get a guarantor to trial (Lake Region).

Each figure on this page is a count of public decisions, refreshed yearly. The page is part of my Minnesota contract law work for business owners.

What Personal Guarantee Cases Has the Minnesota Court of Appeals Decided Since 2016?

The Minnesota Court of Appeals decided the 19 guaranty appeals below, listed by filing date; each case name links to the court’s opinion. The outcome column states the guarantor’s result on appeal. Most rows involve a lease or a loan, and for a lease guarantor, my page on how a commercial lease guaranty is enforced covers the landlord’s side of that process.

Case Filed Docket Status What was guaranteed Outcome What decided it
In re Estate of Murray March 7, 2016 A15-1061 Unpublished Bank line of credit for a business venture Other The partner who guaranteed the line of credit paid the bank, and the court enforced his guaranty’s waiver of claims against the borrower arising from the guaranty or his performance of it to defeat his challenge to the borrower’s disclaimer of an inheritance. The court noted that the waiver “applies only to Pint as guarantor” and did not decide whether he could recover as the bank’s assignee.
Williams v. Stussy May 23, 2016 A15-1621 Unpublished $60,000 private loan to a corporation Enforced The loan agreement required a founder’s personal guarantee, so guarantees he signed several months later, before the lender disbursed the money, were deemed contemporaneous in effect and needed no further consideration, and they covered the note’s interest.
Drummer Development, Inc. v. Baxter BBQ, Inc. May 30, 2017 A16-1933 Unpublished Restaurant lease Not enforced The company that sued was not the landlord on the lease and had too little evidence of an assignment, so it lacked standing to collect from the two owners who signed the guaranty.
BPG Grand Oak Building Retail Investors, LLC v. Webster Jacob, LLC June 26, 2017 A16-1955 Unpublished Restaurant lease Enforced The landlord had no duty to disclose highway construction plans that were also available to the public, and the court declined to reach the guarantor’s inadequately briefed argument about the guaranty’s $110,000 limit.
Trebelhorn v. Agrawal November 20, 2017 A17-0584 Precedential Fuel supplier’s credit account for a gas station Not enforced The owner later signed the supply agreement personally and was held “a comaker, not a guarantor,” under it, its merger clause made his earlier personal guarantee unenforceable, and the claims under the supply agreement, a sale of goods, were time-barred.
Morgan-Walg, LLC v. Nicollet Island Development Co. August 6, 2018 A17-1844 Unpublished Promissory notes in a store-development venture Sent back The creditor’s own papers put the unpaid principal at $18,978,500 in one place and $20,717,818 in another, the developers gave dates of specific payments that were not accounted for, and nothing documented the numbers in the creditor’s CFO affidavit, so the court found a factual dispute over the amount owed and reversed and remanded “for proceedings consistent with this opinion”; the duress and unconscionability defenses failed.
33 City Center Holding LLC v. Rosa Mexicano Minneapolis, LLC April 8, 2019 A18-1374 Unpublished Restaurant lease, under a limited 60-month guarantee by the tenant’s parent Not enforced The tenant paid rent through the guarantee term and left nine months after it ended, and its earlier statements about leaving did not let the landlord extend the guarantee.
Gamma Lending Omega, LLC v. Talon First Trust, LLC April 22, 2019 A18-1205 Unpublished Office-building loan Enforced The borrower and its owner, the loan guarantor, were held to a 5% late charge, because it was not an invalid liquidated-damages clause, and to the lender’s attorney fees, because the district court did not abuse its discretion in awarding them.
R&S Crossing, LLC v. AF Enterprises, LLC January 27, 2020 A19-0967 Unpublished 60-month commercial lease Enforced The eviction settlement covered only possession and kept all lease and guaranty claims; the guarantors missed the summary-judgment hearing, and denial of their motion to vacate the judgment was affirmed because they showed no reasonable defense on the merits.
North Mill Equipment Finance, LLC v. Gruz Boga, LLC May 26, 2020 A19-0975 Unpublished Equipment lease of a dump truck Enforced The lease said the truck was leased “as-is,” and the owner who guaranteed it offered no evidence of any promise about the truck’s condition.
Mittelstaedt v. Henney January 4, 2021 A20-0573 Precedential Lease of a repair-shop property Enforced In a footnote, the court rejected the defense that the intended co-guarantor did not sign until after the eviction action began, because the rule he relied on protects the parties to a guaranty “before it becomes effective,” and this lease had taken effect.
Klingelhutz Judgment, LLC v. Klingelhutz March 15, 2021 A19-1894 Nonprecedential Bank loan, with a 2009 judgment on the guaranty Other The bank’s successor sued to renew the 2009 judgment on the guaranty, and the court held the suit time-barred, measuring from the date the judgment was entered rather than the later date it was docketed.
Minnesota Bank & Trust v. 11 Water LLC September 7, 2021 A21-0008 Nonprecedential $5 million hotel-redevelopment loan Enforced The bank’s extension of a past-due loan was consideration for a 50% owner’s later guaranty, and his claim that a bank officer misled him failed because the alleged statements concerned future facts and conflicted with the guaranty’s own terms.
Old Republic Surety Co. v. Weinerman and Associates LLC November 22, 2021 A21-0401 Nonprecedential Surety bond for a collection agency’s license, under an indemnity agreement Enforced Two officers who signed an agreement to reimburse the surety were personally liable, and the surety’s claim did not accrue until it paid bond claims and its request for reimbursement was refused.
S. M. Hentges & Sons, Inc. v. Mark Elliot Homes, LLC January 9, 2023 A22-0736 Nonprecedential A developer’s unpaid contractor invoices, under a claimed guaranty by the developer’s financiers Not enforced The financiers’ letter to the contractor described their own loan and never promised to pay the developer’s debt, so no signed written guaranty existed.
2700 Hennepin LLC v. VPC Minneapolis Uptown Pizza, LLC June 3, 2024 A23-1273 Nonprecedential Pizza restaurant lease, guaranteed by the tenant’s parent Partly enforced With no proven tenant default in the lease’s first 36 months, the guaranty’s cap limited rent to 12 months ($322,314.46), but a separate promise to pay enforcement costs supported $269,321.83 in attorney fees.
First and Third Properties, LLC v. Platinum Six, LLC April 21, 2025 A24-1326 Nonprecedential Residential mortgage loans to a real-estate company Partly enforced The district court found that the lender violated the Minnesota Residential Mortgage Originator and Servicer Licensing Act in making the loans, which breached the implied covenant of good faith in the guaranty, so the two owners owed only the borrower’s reduced debt.
Life Fitness, LLC v. Dahmen August 10, 2026 A25-1986 Nonprecedential Fitness-equipment lease Enforced The guaranty ran to the lessor’s successors and said amendments and extensions would not impair it, so pandemic changes made without him, which raised his exposure about 2%, did not release him.
Lake Region Bank v. Thermo Seal Insulation, LLC October 19, 2026 A26-0365, A26-0497 Nonprecedential; petitions for review pending Two bank loans to an insulation company Enforced The bank produced the notes, guaranties, default notice, and payoff statements, and the owner’s general claims of accounting “irregularities” were not specific, admissible evidence.

What Did the Guarantors Who Won Have in Common?

Each guarantor who won, in whole or in part, pointed to the guaranty’s terms, a statute, or the creditor’s own conduct. The grounds were an expired guarantee term, a creditor that could not prove it held the rights, and a later agreement with a time bar. Others were no signed writing, a lender’s statutory violation, a late judgment renewal, and a cap on the amount. None won by showing that the business had failed.

  1. The guarantee ended by its own terms (33 City Center). The guarantee covered “the first full 60 months after the rent commencement date,” and the tenant paid through that period. The court held that the landlord’s assignee “failed to allege an unequivocal repudiation of the lease.” It also noted that “even if appellant had alleged an unqualified renunciation of the contract, the doctrine of anticipatory breach would not allow appellant to extend the limited contractual guarantee.”
  2. The company suing could not prove it held the landlord’s rights (Drummer). It offered only an affidavit asserting an assignment of “the rent receivables,” so the court held that it “does not have standing.”
  3. A later signed agreement replaced the guarantee (Trebelhorn). The owner then signed a supply agreement making him personally liable, and its merger clause meant “the Credit Application was no longer individually enforceable against Agrawal.” The court held that “Agrawal is a comaker, not a guarantor, under the Supply Agreement.” The district court had treated that agreement as a sale of goods, and “On appeal, appellant does not challenge the district court’s predominant-purpose determination.” On that basis, the supplier’s claims under the supply agreement were held time-barred under the sale-of-goods statute quoted in point 2 of the section below on what these cases mean.
  4. No signed written promise existed (Hentges). Minn. Stat. § 513.01 bars a suit on “every special promise to answer for the debt, default or doings of another” unless the agreement “or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing, and subscribed by the party charged therewith.” In plain terms, a promise to answer for another’s debt must be in a signed writing that expresses the consideration. Hentges applied the statute to a guaranty “so long as the agreement is collateral to another party’s debt and not an original promise to pay a debt.” The financier’s letter here described its own loan and promised nothing to the contractor. My page on when a personal guarantee on a loan becomes enforceable covers the writing in more depth.
  5. The lender’s own violation reduced the debt (First and Third). The district court found that the lender violated the Minnesota Residential Mortgage Originator and Servicer Licensing Act. That breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in the guaranty, whose waiver of defenses excepted “CLAIMS BASED [UP]ON THE FAILURE OF THE LENDER TO ACT IN A COMMERCIALLY REASONABLE MANNER.” The Court of Appeals affirmed on that unchallenged ground.
  6. A guaranty judgment was not renewed in time (Klingelhutz). The judgment was entered April 15, 2009, and the renewal suit was commenced in May 2019. The court held it time-barred, measuring from the judgment’s entry rather than its later docketing.

2700 Hennepin, the other partly enforced row, also limited what the guarantor owed: the guaranty’s cap held the rent claim to 12 months, though the guarantor still owed the landlord’s attorney fees. In Morgan-Walg, the court found a factual dispute over the amount owed and reversed and remanded “for proceedings consistent with this opinion.”

Which Guarantor Defenses Failed?

Lack of consideration, a bank officer’s assurances, lease changes the guaranty allowed, an eviction settlement limited to possession, and general complaints about the bank’s numbers all failed in the decisions I found. So did duress, unconscionability, an as-is truck lease, a landlord’s silence about public plans, a co-guarantor’s late signature, and officers’ claim that they were not parties to a bond:

  • Lack of consideration. In Williams, the loan was made on the condition that a founder guarantee it, so “his guarantees are deemed contemporaneous in effect and require no further consideration.” In 11 Water, the bank’s extension of a past-due loan was enough, and “No additional obligation on the part of the bank or benefit to Monson is required to find adequate consideration.”
  • A bank officer’s assurances. In 11 Water, the owner’s fraud defense failed “for two reasons.” First, “Monson’s alleged misrepresentations relate to future–and not present or past–facts,” and the court stated, quoting an earlier decision for its last words: “A misrepresentation about future events does not constitute fraud unless the record shows that ’the promisor had no intention to perform at the time the promise was made.’” Second, his claim conflicted with the guaranty, which stated that it was “a guaranty of payment and performance and not of collection.”
  • Changes to the lease. In Life Fitness, the court quoted a 1974 Minnesota Supreme Court decision: “[A] material alteration in the principal contract, made after execution of the guaranty contract and without consent of the guarantor, discharges the guarantor” if it adversely affects the guarantor’s interests. This guaranty said the owner’s obligations “SHALL NOT BE IMPAIRED IN ANY MANNER WHATSOEVER BY ANY” amendments or extensions, and the court found no adverse effect.
  • An eviction settlement. In R&S Crossing, the parties were “settling only claims regarding the possession of the Leased Premises” and did not waive “any contract claims under the Lease [or] the Lease Guarantees.”
  • General complaints about the bank’s numbers. In Lake Region, the owner’s “allegations were conclusory and nonspecific.”
  • Other defenses. In Morgan-Walg, unconscionability failed where the second forbearance agreement acknowledged that both parties were “sophisticated commercial part[ies] experienced in transactions.” Duress failed because, even assuming a forbearance agreement was signed under duress, “that fact is not material,” since the claims rested on the promissory notes and nothing showed the notes or guaranty were signed under duress. A complaint about a truck leased “as-is” also failed (North Mill), as did a landlord’s silence about public construction plans (BPG Grand Oak). A co-guarantor’s signature given after the eviction action began was no defense once the lease had taken effect (Mittelstaedt). Officers’ claim that they were not parties to a bond they had agreed to indemnify failed too (Old Republic).

What Do These Cases Mean If You Signed a Personal Guarantee?

These cases turned on the guaranty’s words, the creditor’s dates and paperwork, and the evidence the guarantor brought. Five points follow from the rows for anyone who signed a personal guarantee. They cover the whole guaranty, the creditor’s dates and paperwork, specific evidence, a closed business, and a workout’s terms.

  1. The whole guaranty. I suggest reading every term, including any cap, end date, fee clause, and waiver, because each one changed a result here. If the guaranty states no end date, Life Fitness, quoting a 1930 Minnesota Supreme Court decision, stated that a guaranty not limited as to time “must as a matter of construction be limited to a time which is reasonable, taking into consideration not merely the language of the guaranty, but all the circumstances of the case.” The court added that whether that time was reasonable “is a question of law.” It held that enforcing the guaranty for the same length of time as the equipment lease was reasonable, since the guarantor had joined in extending the lease as the lessee’s managing member. In 2700 Hennepin, the cap limited rent to $322,314.46 but not $269,321.83 in fees. In 11 Water, a guaranty “of payment and performance and not of collection” let the bank enforce it without first exhausting its remedies against the borrower or the collateral. My page on a guarantor’s rights when the borrower defaults explains that difference. My page on the risks in a personal guarantee clause covers ways to limit that exposure.

  2. The creditor’s dates and paperwork. I suggest noting when the debt went unpaid, when any judgment was entered, and whether the company demanding payment is the one named in your guaranty, because Trebelhorn, Klingelhutz, and Drummer turned on those facts. For a judgment, Minn. Stat. § 541.04 provides: “No action shall be maintained upon a judgment or decree of a court of the United States, or of any state or territory thereof, unless begun within ten years after the entry of such judgment.” Minn. Stat. § 548.09, subdivision 1, adds: “The judgment survives, and the lien continues, for ten years after its entry.” For the supply agreement in Trebelhorn, a sale of goods under which the owner was “a comaker, not a guarantor,” the court applied Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725, subsection (1): “An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within four years after the cause of action has accrued. By the original agreement the parties may reduce the period of limitation to not less than one year but may not extend it.” Subsection (2) adds: “A cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the breach.” For other contract claims, Minn. Stat. § 541.05, subdivision 1, provides: “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within six years: (1) upon a contract or other obligation, express or implied, as to which no other limitation is expressly prescribed.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. In Life Fitness, the court called it determinative that Life Fitness “was the original creditor and the creditor asserting rights at summary judgment.” On assignment, it read the master lease, which said “Lessor [Life Fitness] is assigning this Agreement,” together with the guaranty signed the same day, which “shall inure to the benefit of [Life Fitness’s] successors and assigns,” and held that the guaranty survived each assignment.

  3. Specific evidence, and who may appear for the company. I suggest answering any demand or suit with specific, admissible evidence, because general objections did not get a guarantor to trial here. If that evidence is still in the creditor’s hands, 11 Water stated: “A party resisting summary judgment on the ground that it requires additional time to conduct discovery must submit an affidavit.” Quoting an earlier decision, the court added that the affidavit “must be specific about the evidence expected, the source of discovery necessary to obtain the evidence, and the reasons for the failure to complete discovery to date.” It also weighed whether the party had a good-faith belief that material facts would be uncovered and had “been diligent in obtaining or seeking discovery before requesting” further time. It stated that a party’s “failure to submit such an affidavit, by itself, justifies the district court’s decision to rule on the motion without granting relief under rule” 56.04 of the Minnesota Rules of Civil Procedure.

    In R&S Crossing, the guarantors missed the summary-judgment hearing and moved to vacate the judgment under Minn. R. Civ. P. 60.02(a), the rule’s reason for “Mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.” The court stated that a party seeking that relief “must establish all four Finden factors.” They are a reasonable defense on the merits, a reasonable excuse for the failure or neglect, due diligence after notice of the entry of judgment, and no substantial prejudice to the other party. The motion failed because the guarantors “failed to establish the first Finden factor–that they possessed a reasonable defense on the merits,” and the court noted, quoting an earlier decision, that a meritorious claim “must ordinarily be demonstrated by more than conclusory allegations in the moving papers.” Minn. R. Civ. P. 60.02 provides: “The motion shall be made within a reasonable time, and for reasons (a), (b), and (c) not more than one year after the judgment, order, or proceeding was entered or taken.” Minn. R. Civ. P. 60.02 adds: “A Rule 60.02 motion does not affect the finality of a judgment or suspend its operation. This rule does not limit the power of a court to entertain an independent action to relieve a party from a judgment, order, or proceeding, or to grant relief to a defendant not actually personally notified as provided in Rule 4.043, or to set aside a judgment for fraud upon the court.” Check the current text of the rule before relying on this period.

    In Lake Region, the court quoted the Minnesota Supreme Court’s rule that “a corporation must be represented by an attorney in legal proceedings,” adding: “This rule also applies to LLCs like Thermo Seal.” In conciliation court, Minn. Stat. § 491A.02, subdivision 4(a), provides that a corporation or limited liability company “may be represented in conciliation court by an officer, manager, or partner,” and that the subdivision “also applies to appearances in district court by a corporation or limited liability company with five or fewer shareholders or members . . . if the action was removed from conciliation court.” The same subdivision requires that “an authorized power of attorney, corporate authorization resolution, corporate bylaw, or other evidence of authority acceptable to the court must be filed with the claim or presented at the hearing” in the case of an officer, employee, commercial property manager, or agent. My page on a closed Minnesota company that has been sued covers how the company is served and when its answer is due.

  4. A closed business. A closed business did not end a guaranty in these rows unless the guaranty’s own terms ended it. A guaranty with no stated end date is limited to a reasonable time, as point 1 explains. The 2700 Hennepin tenant closed its restaurant for good in 2020, and its guarantor was still liable up to the cap plus fees. The 33 City Center guarantor owed nothing for later rent only because its guarantee term had already ended. Whether bankruptcy changes the answer depends on who files, as my page on whether bankruptcy discharges a personal guarantee explains.

  5. A negotiated extension or settlement. A workout can buy time or reduce the company’s debt. In 11 Water, the bank’s extension counted as consideration for the guaranty. In the later 2018 and 2019 forbearance agreements, the guarantors reaffirmed their guaranties. One guarantor, Monson, also waived and released “all claims, defenses, and counterclaims” arising from the bank’s acts or omissions on the loan documents or collateral, “other than [the bank’s] willful acts or omissions,” arising on or before the date of the agreements. The court held that his counterclaims that predate the forbearance agreements were waived. In R&S Crossing, the eviction settlement kept the guaranty claims. I suggest reading those terms before signing, because in these rows they preserved the creditor’s claims against the guarantor and, in 11 Water, gave up the guarantor’s own earlier claims against the bank.

How Much Weight Do These Decisions Carry?

Two of the 19 decisions are precedential, and the other 17 carry labels that limit their weight. Trebelhorn and Mittelstaedt are precedential opinions. Trebelhorn’s syllabus concerns the limitation period for an account-stated claim, and Mittelstaedt’s guaranty ruling sits in a footnote of an opinion about the expert-affidavit requirement for claims against an attorney.

Eight rows are nonprecedential opinions. Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 136.01, subd. 1(c), provides: “Nonprecedential opinions and order opinions are not binding authority except as law of the case, res judicata or collateral estoppel, but nonprecedential opinions may be cited as persuasive authority.” In plain terms, those decisions settle the dispute between their own parties, and a lawyer in another case may cite a nonprecedential one as an example of how a panel reasoned. The other nine rows, filed from 2016 through May 2020, carry the caption “unpublished.”

Are Any of These Cases Still Open?

Lake Region (Nos. A26-0365 and A26-0497) is still open. The owner filed a petition for further review in the Minnesota Supreme Court on October 31, 2026, and the company filed one on November 18, 2026. The appellate docket showed both petitions undecided when I checked it for this update, and this page makes no prediction about them. The 2024, 2025, and other 2026 rows show no petition for review on the docket.

How Was This Count Built?

This index lists the decisions I found, and it may not hold every decision. My searches covered Minnesota Court of Appeals and Minnesota Supreme Court opinions filed from January 1, 2016, through November 20, 2026. They used two full-text opinion searches, eight guaranty search terms, and a read of each opinion’s PDF.

  • Sources. The full-text Minnesota opinion collection on HallApproved.com, and the court’s own opinion search on mncourts.gov.
  • Terms. Guaranty, guaranties, guarantor, guarantors, personal guaranty, personal guarantee, personally guaranteed, and guaranty agreement.
  • What counts. A decision counts when the court decided whether, or how much, a guarantor owed, a guarantor’s defense, or a paying guarantor’s rights under the guaranty. Two rows stretch the usual picture: Old Republic involved officers’ indemnity agreement for a surety bond, which the court said they “personally guaranteed,” and Hentges involved a claimed guaranty by a developer’s financiers.
  • What was left out. Excluded were 41 decisions that mention a guaranty only in the background facts and opinions where a search term appeared only in passing. Also excluded were order opinions, consumer co-signer cases, and a 2025 Minnesota Supreme Court decision on a construction surety’s priority against a secured lender.
  • Checks. Each row was read from the court’s PDF, including its caption, date, docket number, status, and disposition. The 2024 through 2026 rows were also checked on the appellate docket for this update.

District court rulings are outside these searches.

Does closing my business end my personal guarantee?

Not in the decisions I found, unless the guaranty’s own terms ended it. A guaranty with no stated end date is limited to a reasonable time, judged by its language and all the circumstances (Life Fitness). In 2700 Hennepin, the tenant closed its restaurant in 2020. The guarantor parent company was held liable for the 12 months’ rent its cap allowed, plus the landlord’s attorney fees. In 33 City Center, the guarantee covered only the lease’s first 60 months, and the tenant paid through that period and left nine months later, so the guarantor owed nothing for the later rent.

Can a lender enforce a guarantee I signed after the loan was made?

Yes, if the guaranty had consideration beyond the original debt or was part of the original deal, as in the two decisions I found. In 11 Water, the court stated: “A guaranty to pay a pre-existing debt must be supported by consideration beyond the original obligation.” There, the bank’s extension of a past-due loan was that consideration, and no added benefit to the co-owner was required. In Williams v. Stussy, the loan agreement required a founder’s guarantee; he signed “several months later,” before the money was disbursed, so his guarantees were deemed contemporaneous in effect and needed no further consideration.

Does a change to the lease or loan release me as guarantor?

It can if the change is a material alteration, made without your consent, that adversely affects your interests, but it did not release the guarantor in Life Fitness. Quoting a 1974 Minnesota Supreme Court decision, the court stated that a “material alteration in the principal contract, made after execution of the guaranty contract and without consent of the guarantor, discharges the guarantor” if the alteration adversely affects the guarantor’s interests. There, the guaranty said changes would not impair his obligations, and he had reaffirmed its waivers. The pandemic changes, which raised his exposure about 2%, did not adversely affect his interests.

Is a letter saying a loan will be guaranteed enough to make a guarantee?

It was not enough in Hentges. A financier’s letter said its own development loan would be secured by a mortgage and guarantee, but never promised to pay the developer’s debts to the contractor. Minn. Stat. § 513.01 covers “every special promise to answer for the debt, default or doings of another.” No suit may be maintained on such a promise unless it or a memorandum of it, expressing the consideration, is in writing and signed by the party charged. Hentges applied that rule to a guaranty collateral to another party’s debt, not to an original promise to pay a debt.

Can a creditor sue to renew a guaranty judgment at any time?

No. Minn. Stat. § 541.04 provides: “No action shall be maintained upon a judgment or decree of a court of the United States, or of any state or territory thereof, unless begun within ten years after the entry of such judgment.” In Klingelhutz, a guaranty judgment was entered April 15, 2009, and the suit to renew it, brought “so as to secure a new ten-year limitations period,” was commenced in May 2019, so the court held it time-barred. For collecting, Minn. Stat. § 548.09, subd. 1, provides: “The judgment survives, and the lien continues, for ten years after its entry.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.

Do these decisions bind Minnesota trial courts?

Mostly no. Two of the 19 are precedential, Trebelhorn and Mittelstaedt. Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 136.01, subd. 1(c), provides: “Nonprecedential opinions and order opinions are not binding authority except as law of the case, res judicata or collateral estoppel, but nonprecedential opinions may be cited as persuasive authority.” Eight rows are nonprecedential. Nine older rows carry the caption “unpublished.”

Does this index include every Minnesota guaranty decision?

No. It lists the Minnesota Court of Appeals opinions I found, other than order opinions, filed from January 1, 2016, through November 20, 2026. Each decided whether, or how much, a guarantor owed, a guarantor’s defense, or a paying guarantor’s rights under the guaranty. I searched the full-text opinion collection on HallApproved.com and the court’s own opinion search on mncourts.gov. District court rulings fall outside those searches, and a decision the searches missed would not appear until the yearly update.

Minnesota Personal Guarantee Case Index

In the 19 Minnesota Court of Appeals decisions indexed here, filed from 2016 through November 20, 2026, the guarantor was held liable in whole or in part in 12. The guarantors who won pointed to the guaranty’s own terms, a statute, or the creditor’s conduct. The petitions for review in Lake Region are the open matters to watch. The rest of my contract law practice covers the loans, leases, and supply agreements behind these cases.

If you signed a personal guarantee and have received a demand or a lawsuit, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.