Nominative Fair Use Overview
“Nominative fair use” is one exception to the general rule that you may not use another’s trademark in commerce. That is, use of another’s trademark is allowed under the nominative fair use doctrine. Nominative fair use, by definition, is not trademark infringement because such use is not likely to confuse consumers. The nominative fair use defense gives protection to those who use another’s trademark for the purpose of identifying the brand without suggesting affiliation or sponsorship with the brand owner. The following test evaluates the likelihood of confusion in nominative use cases. To determine whether nominative fair use applies, courts generally look to three factors:
- whether the product was “readily identifiable” without use of the trademark;
- whether the defendant used more of the trademark than necessary (also known as the minimum necessary test); or
- whether the trademark’s use falsely suggested sponsorship or endorsement by the trademark owner.
A 2010 federal appeals decision provides guidance regarding nominative fair use in the context of domain names and websites. If you want to get a summary of what we learned from this case, see the Nominative Fair Use for Websites & Domain Names heading below. This case, decided on July 8, 2010 in the 9th Circuit, provides some guidance regarding the issue of what constitutes nominative fair use. The decision binds only courts within the 9th Circuit, which does not include Minnesota, so a court elsewhere may treat it as persuasive rather than controlling.
Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc., v. Farzad Tabari
Facts
In this case, Farzad and Lisa Tabari are independent auto brokers who help customers buy Lexus cars from authorized dealers. They offered this service at two domain names, buy-a-lexus.com and buyorleaselexus.com. Toyota brought suit claiming trademark infringement. The District Court analyzed the case under a likelihood of confusion analysis, found in favor of Toyota, and issued an injunction preventing the Tabaris from using those domain names or any other domain name that included the mark. The Tabaris appealed.
9th Circuit’s Analysis
The 9th Circuit, not the District Court, determined that a likelihood of confusion analysis under the Sleekcraft factors was the wrong test. It said that analysis “doesn’t apply where a defendant uses the mark to refer to the trademarked good itself,” and that the nominative fair use test replaces it. The court made these points:
Domain Names
A domain name consisting of only the trademark plus a suffix such as .com will typically suggest sponsorship or endorsement, and so will names like trademark-USA.com or official-trademark-site.com. The court said the Tabaris’ domain names do not fall within that narrow class.
Logo and Disclaimer
By the time of trial, the Tabaris had removed the stylized mark and logo from their website and added a disclaimer stating, “We are not an authorized Lexus dealer or affiliated in any way with Lexus. We are an Independent Auto Broker.” The court said that, “[w]hile not required, such a disclaimer is relevant to the nominative fair use analysis.”
9th Circuit Court of Appeals’ Holding
The Court of Appeals vacated the injunction and remanded the case to the District Court. It instructed the District Court to apply only the nominative fair use test from New Kids on the Block v. News Am. Publ’g, Inc., 971 F.2d 302 (9th Cir. 1992) and not the Sleekcraft factors, and it placed the burden on Toyota to show that the use was not nominative fair use. The court added that, at the very least, the injunction “must be modified to allow some use of the Lexus mark in domain names by the Tabaris.”
For the full case, see Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc., v. Farzad Tabari, No. 07-55344 (9th Circ. July 8, 2010).
Nominative Fair Use for Websites & Domain Names
In short, what we learned from this case is that website owners may use another’s trademark on their website if they meet the requirements of nominative fair use:
- the website owner must use the trademark to describe the genuine trademarked products being sold;
- the website owner is using the trademark no more than necessary; and
- the website owner did not create a likelihood of consumer confusion through the trademark.