In order for a court to have authority over a potential defendant, the court must have personal jurisdiction, also known as in personam jurisdiction. What this means is that the court must be able to exercise its authority over that particular defendant. A state court generally has personal jurisdiction over an individual who lives in the state or is served while physically present there, and over a company that is at home there, with the place of incorporation and principal place of business as the usual examples (Burnham v. Superior Court, 495 U.S. 604 (1990); Daimler AG v. Bauman, 571 U.S. 117 (2014)). Personal jurisdiction becomes complicated when a defendant to a lawsuit resides in a different state but is being sued in a state where the plaintiff resides. The court will only have jurisdiction over the defendant from another state in certain situations.
Analyzing Whether a Minnesota Court has Personal Jurisdiction
There are two main steps to analyzing whether or not a court (forum state) has personal jurisdiction over a defendant.
First, look to the long arm statute of the forum state. Every state has a long arm statute. Some states directly address in these statutes what requirements must be met in order to have personal jurisdiction. Other long arm statutes simply restate that personal jurisdiction is acceptable if such jurisdiction does not violate due process rights under the U.S. Constitution.
Second, these long arm statutes often state the second prong of the personal jurisdiction analysis, that personal jurisdiction cannot violate due process. Minnesota’s long arm statute, Minn. Stat. § 543.19, reaches as far as the Due Process Clause allows, so the remaining analysis is whether exercising jurisdiction over the defendant would violate due process (Rilley v. MoneyMutual, LLC, 884 N.W.2d 321 (Minn. 2016)).
Whether a court having personal jurisdiction violates due process rights under the Constitution is a more complicated question. Due process requires that, for the forum state to have jurisdiction over a defendant, that defendant must have “certain minimum contacts” with the forum state and having jurisdiction cannot violate “traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.” International Shoe Co. v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310 (1945).
These “minimum contacts” with the forum state should be such that the defendant should reasonably anticipate to be brought to court in that state because he purposefully availed himself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum state. World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson, 444 U.S. 286, 297 (1980). The logic follows that if the defendant engaged in significant activities in the forum state, that because his actions are shielded by the benefits and protections of the forum state’s laws, it is not unreasonable for him to submit to the forum state’s jurisdiction. Burger King Corp. v. Rudzewicz, 471 U.S. 462, 476 (1985).
In Minnesota there is a five-factor test to determine whether the defendant had sufficient contacts with the forum state for that state to have jurisdiction over him:
(1) the quantity of contacts with Minnesota,
(2) the nature and quality of the defendant’s contacts with Minnesota,
(3) the connection between the cause of action and the defendant’s contacts,
(4) Minnesota’s interest in providing a forum, and
(5) the convenience of the parties.
Aftanase v. Economy Baler Co., 343 F.2d 187, 197 (8th. Cir. 1965); Dent-Air, Inc. v. Beech Mountain Air Serv., Inc., 332 N.W.2d 904, 907 (Minn. 1983).
The first three factors - quantity of contacts, their nature and quality, and the connection of the cause of action with those contacts - are the primary ones, while the last two, interest of the forum state and convenience, receive lesser mention; the Eighth Circuit weighed all five together in concluding that personal jurisdiction in Minnesota was consistent with fair play and substantial justice. The court will address these factors on a case by case basis to determine if the defendant truly had sufficient minimum contacts with Minnesota.
The defendant entering into a contract with a resident of the forum state can constitute the requisite purposeful availment and minimum contacts; however, a contract between the parties alone does not automatically establish sufficient minimum contacts. Burger King Corp, 471 U.S. at 478-79. Other factors regarding the contract need to be taken into consideration, including negotiations both prior and future, terms of the contract, as well as course of dealing between the parties in order to determine whether the defendant purposefully had minimum contacts with the forum state. Id. at 479. Personal jurisdiction is usually acceptable when a contract has a substantial connection with the forum state. McGee v. Int’l Life Ins. Co., 355 U.S. 220, 223 (1957).
Personal Jurisdiction & Sufficient Minimum Contacts for Internet Websites
Personal jurisdiction has been complicated by the advent of websites and internet businesses. Nowadays companies have websites and therefore have a presence everywhere those websites can be accessed. The main issue that has arisen is whether plaintiffs can sue in their own state when bringing a claim against an internet company, or whether they must bring suit in the state where the defendant resides or has its place of business. The most prevalent test in determining personal jurisdiction over an internet company comes from Zippo Mfg. v. Zippo Dot Com, 952 F.Supp. 1119 (W.D. Pa. 1997). the Zippo-test is:
At one end of the spectrum are situations where a defendant clearly does business over the Internet. If the defendant enters into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet, personal jurisdiction is proper. At the opposite end are situations where a defendant has simply posted information on an Internet Web site which is accessible to users in foreign jurisdictions. A passive Web site that does little more than make information available to those who are interested in it is not grounds for the exercise [of] personal jurisdiction. The middle ground is occupied by interactive Web sites where a user can exchange information with the host computer. In these cases, the exercise of jurisdiction is determined by examining the level of interactivity and commercial nature of the exchange of information that occurs on the Web site.
The Zippo Test
Zippo, 952 F. Supp. at 1124 (citations omitted). The Zippo-test breaks down websites into three categories: interactive websites, passive websites, and websites that are a combination of interactive and passive. An interactive website is typically one where there is a two-way online communication that fosters an ongoing business relationship. This includes websites that allow for business transactions and where information is exchanged with the users for the purposes of soliciting business. A forum state is more likely to have personal jurisdiction over these website operators. A passive website is one in which the site makes information available to interested viewers, but no business is being transacted. In most cases, the operator of a passive website will not fall under the forum state’s exercise of personal jurisdiction. There are several websites, however, that lie somewhere in the middle. For example, some websites provide information but also allow the users to exchange information by providing email addresses, a phone number or other activity that begins an ongoing relationship to maybe solicit business in the future. The Zippo-test provides for these situations by considering how interactive the website actually is and to what extent exchanging such information is of a commercial nature. The higher the commercial nature and the interactivity of the website, the greater the chances that the website operator is purposefully availing itself of the forum state’s jurisdiction.
In Rilley v. MoneyMutual, LLC, 884 N.W.2d 321 (Minn. 2016), the Minnesota Supreme Court considered the contacts with Minnesota of a website that matched loan applicants with payday lenders. The court treated emails like any other contact with the forum, weighed the contacts in the aggregate, and found sufficient minimum contacts based on more than 1,000 emails to known Minnesotans and Google AdWords advertising specific to Minnesota. It also held that “a purely national advertising campaign that does not target Minnesota specifically cannot support a finding of personal jurisdiction,” and overruled Humphrey v. Granite Gate Resorts, Inc., 568 N.W.2d 715 (Minn. Ct. App. 1997), aff’d, 576 N.W.2d 747 (Minn. 1998), to the extent it was inconsistent with that holding. A website alone is not necessarily sufficient to establish minimum contacts.
A court must have personal jurisdiction over a defendant in order to have the authority to enforce a judgment on that defendant. In most states, the court can have personal jurisdiction as long as doing so does not violate due process rights. In order to satisfy due process rights, the defendant must have sufficient minimum contacts with the forum state in order to fall under that state’s authority. When it comes to websites, determining personal jurisdiction is a little more complicated. The analysis looks at how the defendant directed its online activity at the forum state, including how interactive and commercial a website is. In Minnesota, whether personal jurisdiction exists is a question of law, and it turns on the specific contacts the defendant had with the state.