Aaron Hall · [email protected]

Minnesota Accountant's Lien: Securing Payment

What Minnesota law says about an accountant holding client records for unpaid fees, including a CPA's duty to furnish records. Aaron Hall, Minneapolis.

Licensed Since 2007 Thousands of Businesses Advised Super Lawyers 2018–2026

When a client refuses to pay for completed accounting work, can the accountant hold the client’s records until the bill is paid? Usually not without risk. Minnesota has a general lien statute, Minn. Stat. section 514.18, but it does not mention accountants, and a licensed CPA has a separate duty under Minn. Stat. section 326A.13 to furnish a client’s records on request. For help with unpaid fees, see my collections page.

What Is an Accountant’s Lien in Minnesota?

People use the phrase accountant’s lien to mean a right to hold a client’s financial records, tax documents, and similar property until the client pays. A lien of that kind would depend on actual possession of the documents, unlike a statutory lien that requires a government filing.

The closest statute is Minn. Stat. section 514.18, which gives a lien to whoever, at the request of the owner or legal possessor of personal property, “shall store or care for or contribute in any of the modes mentioned in section 514.19 to its preservation, care, or to the enhancement of its value,” with “the right to retain possession of the property until such lien is lawfully discharged.” Section 514.19 includes “making, altering or repairing any article, other than livestock, or expending any labor, skill or material on it.” Neither section mentions accountants or client records. The statute that does speak to them is Minn. Stat. section 326A.13: a licensee “shall furnish to a client or former client, upon request and reasonable notice,” a copy of working papers that “would ordinarily constitute part of the client’s records” and are not otherwise available to the client, and “any accounting or other records belonging to, or obtained from or on behalf of, the client” that the licensee removed from the client’s premises or received for the client’s account. That section states no exception for unpaid fees. Other working papers “remain the property of the licensee” absent an express agreement to the contrary, so the licensee keeps them as owner rather than as lienholder.

An accountant who is not a licensee falls outside section 326A.13, but section 514.18 still does not name accountants. For any accountant, a clear engagement letter that describes the work and the payment terms, together with a retainer or payment before deliverables are released, gives more dependable protection than a lien claim over records the client already owns.

How Does an Accountant Protect This Lien if Possession Is Lost?

Where a section 514.18 lien exists, subdivision 2 gives a 60-day window after “the voluntary surrender or other loss of possession”: the lienholder may preserve the lien by filing a verified statement and notice of intention to claim a lien in the appropriate UCC filing office. Subdivision 4 says subdivisions 2 and 3 “shall apply to machinery, implements and tools of all kinds but shall not apply to motor vehicles,” so an accountant should not assume the filing procedure reaches paper records.

Subdivision 3 treats the lien as a security interest under the Uniform Commercial Code, with foreclosure “in the manner prescribed for security interests under article 9.” Client records have little resale value, so that remedy offers an accountant little practical help.

Does an Accountant’s Lien Beat a Bank’s Security Interest?

It can, where a possessory lien exists at all. Minn. Stat. section 336.9-333 provides that “[a] possessory lien on goods has priority over a security interest in the goods unless the lien is created by a statute that expressly provides otherwise.” Its definition is limited to a lien securing “services or materials furnished with respect to goods” by a person in the ordinary course of business, created by statute or rule of law, whose effectiveness depends on possession. Section 514.18, subdivision 3, separately makes its lien valid “against everyone except a purchaser or encumbrancer in good faith without notice and for value whose rights were acquired prior to the filing of the lien statement and who has filed a statement of interest in the appropriate filing office.”

Whether financial records count as goods, and whether preparing them is a service with respect to goods, are threshold questions for an accountant relying on this section. For more on lien priority, see liens.

What Records Can an Accountant Hold Under a Lien?

For a licensed CPA, section 326A.13 draws the main line. Records belonging to or obtained from the client, and working papers that would ordinarily be part of the client’s records and are not otherwise available to the client, must be furnished on request and reasonable notice. Other working papers remain the licensee’s property absent an express agreement to the contrary, and the licensee may keep copies of client documents that form the basis for work done.

Digital records raise the same issue. Best practice is to address the return of records in the engagement agreement before the work begins, including who holds what, in what format it is returned, and when new deliverables are released. For a broader overview of how liens operate in Minnesota, see An Overview of Minnesota Lien Law and How Do I Contest a Lien in Minnesota?.

What Should a Business Owner Do When Facing an Accountant’s Lien?

If your accounting firm is withholding records, I suggest making a written request for them, citing Minn. Stat. section 326A.13 if the firm is a licensed CPA firm. Also confirm the amount owed and review the engagement agreement.

Prompt resolution matters because the stakes compound with time. Tax filing deadlines, regulatory reporting obligations, and audit schedules do not pause because of a fee dispute. Minnesota’s six-year statute of limitations for breach of contract (Minn. Stat. section 541.05) governs the underlying debt, and a protracted standoff benefits neither side. In most cases, a negotiated payment arrangement (partial payment in exchange for immediate release of the records, with the balance on an agreed schedule) resolves the dispute faster and cheaper than litigation. When negotiation fails, garnishment and levy tools available through the courts can enforce a judgment, but those are last resorts. The Minnesota Board of Accountancy may proceed against a person or firm that violates a statute it is empowered to enforce (Minn. Stat. section 326A.08).

For guidance on collecting unpaid professional fees or responding to a lien claim, see Collections or email [email protected].

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Minnesota accountant keep client records until the bill is paid?

A licensed CPA should not assume so. Minn. Stat. section 326A.13 says a licensee shall furnish to a client or former client, upon request and reasonable notice, records belonging to or obtained from the client and copies of working papers that would ordinarily be part of the client’s records, and it states no exception for unpaid fees. Minn. Stat. section 514.18 gives a general lien to one who stores or cares for personal property at the owner’s request, but it does not mention accountants.

What happens if the accountant returns the records before getting paid?

Where a section 514.18 lien exists, subdivision 2 lets the lienholder preserve it after surrendering possession by filing a verified statement and notice of intention to claim a lien in the appropriate UCC filing office within 60 days. Subdivision 4 says those filing provisions apply to machinery, implements and tools of all kinds, so an accountant should not assume they reach paper records.

Does an accountant's lien take priority over a bank's security interest?

It can. Minn. Stat. section 336.9-333 gives a possessory lien on goods priority over a security interest in the goods, unless the lien is created by a statute that expressly provides otherwise. The section reaches only a lien securing services or materials furnished with respect to goods whose effectiveness depends on possession.

What Clients Say

“Aaron may have a higher rate, but with that comes exceptional value. He looks for ways to save you money, delegates work wisely, and always keeps billing fair and transparent.”

— Mark

“If there were 6 stars, I would highlight all 6. Aaron is wonderful to work with. Knowledgeable, insightful, helpful, timely, fair and open.”

— Chris D.

“He helped me negotiate critical legal decisions using expertise, good judgment and thoughtful reflection.”

— Melanie W.

Discuss Your Legal Matter

Every business situation is unique. Attorney Aaron Hall provides experienced legal counsel tailored to your specific goals and circumstances.

↑