If the person who sold you your Minnesota business signed a noncompete at the sale and is now competing for your customers, Minnesota law can let you enforce that promise when its reach is reasonable. The state’s 2023 noncompete ban, Minn. Stat. § 181.988, governs a covenant between an employee and employer entered into on or after July 1, 2023. For a covenant the section reaches, it states that one “agreed upon during the sale of a business” is “valid and enforceable” when it is temporary and geographically restricted, barring a similar business “within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time.” Whether you can stop this seller turns on the covenant’s words, whether its reach is reasonable, and the evidence you can put in sworn form.

One statute frames the question. The reasonableness test, what counts as a breach, and the damages you can recover come from Minnesota Supreme Court decisions, and Minnesota’s civil procedure rules govern a court order to stop the competition. This page is for the buyer after closing. The deal terms that create this protection are part of my business sale and acquisition work, and the steps before closing are in the guide to buying a business.

How Does Minnesota’s Noncompete Ban Treat a Seller’s Covenant?

Minnesota’s noncompete ban excepts a covenant made when a business is sold, so a seller’s promise not to compete can still be enforced. Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 2(a) provides: “Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable.” Paragraph (b) then provides that, “Notwithstanding paragraph (a), a covenant not to compete is valid and enforceable if” one of two conditions is met, and its clause (1) reaches a covenant “agreed upon during the sale of a business.” Its enacting law, Laws 2023, chapter 53, article 6, section 1, states that the section “is effective July 1, 2023, and applies to contracts and agreements entered into on or after that date.”

The same clause says who may agree and what the covenant may do: “The person selling the business and the partners, members, or shareholders, and the buyer of the business may agree on a temporary and geographically restricted covenant not to compete that will prohibit the seller of the business from carrying on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time.” In plain terms, the owners of a selling company (its partners, members, or shareholders) may sign the covenant along with the seller. The section’s ban governs a covenant defined in subd. 1(a) as “an agreement between an employee and employer that restricts the employee, after termination of the employment,” and for a covenant the section reaches, signed on or after July 1, 2023, the sale exception describes the “temporary and geographically restricted” covenant quoted above.

Minnesota courts measured sale covenants by their own standard long before the statute. In Bennett v. Storz Broadcasting Co., 134 N.W.2d 892 (Minn. 1965), an employment case, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that “courts recognize a distinction between restrictive covenants as they relate to the ordinary commercial transaction involving business or property transfers and those which relate to employment contracts entered into by wage earners. A different measure of reasonableness is used.” The rules for employee covenants, and the ban’s reach over them, are on the page about Minnesota noncompete agreements.

What Makes a Seller’s Noncompete Reasonable in Territory, Time, and Scope?

A Minnesota court tests a seller’s covenant on three elements. It asks whether the covenant goes beyond the protection needed for the goodwill you bought, whether it places an undue hardship on the seller, and whether it harms the public. In Bess v. Bothman, 257 N.W.2d 791 (Minn. 1977), a case about the sale of a towing business’s trucks and part of its goodwill, the Minnesota Supreme Court said: “A party may purchase the goodwill of a business and, to protect his investment, require the seller not to compete with the business sold. But such a restraint of trade is valid only if it is reasonable, and a restraint that provides more protection to the purchaser than is necessary to secure the goodwill he purchased is unreasonable and therefore illegal.”

The court named three elements that “gauge the validity of territorial and temporal restrictions in this situation”:

  1. “whether the restriction exceeds the protection necessary to secure the goodwill purchased”;
  2. “whether the restriction places an undue hardship on the covenantor” (the seller who made the promise); and
  3. “whether the restriction has a deleterious effect on the interests of the general public.”

On time, Bess said buyers “are entitled to a restriction of sufficient duration so that defendant’s reentry into the field would not for that reason alone draw customers whose patronage plaintiffs had acquired.” The court upheld a five-year bar limited to the town where the business operated, after the seller essentially conceded that territory was reasonable.

The covenant’s own words set its scope: which activities it bars, where, and for how long. I suggest reading those three terms in your purchase agreement or separate noncompete agreement before you contact the seller, because your first message to the seller should rest on the covenant’s actual words. The covenant can sit beside the representations, warranties, and indemnity terms of an asset purchase agreement, and a remedies or indemnity clause there may add to what you can recover.

What Happens When a Court Finds the Seller’s Covenant Too Broad?

A Minnesota court can narrow an overbroad sale covenant and enforce the narrowed version. In Bess, the court described the seller’s covenant this way: “the covenant was unbounded by territorial or temporal limitations and, without limitations restricting its prohibition to protection of the goodwill of the towing business sold, the covenant embodies, as the district court found, an illegal restraint of trade.” The Minnesota Supreme Court held “that the district court had authority to modify and enforce the covenant not to compete,” and it affirmed an order limited to general towing in one town for five years. Minnesota calls this equitable modification: the court rewrites the overbroad term to a reasonable scope instead of voiding the whole promise.

Two limits apply. First, modification is the judge’s choice. Bess said enforcement “remains a matter of equitable discretion and should be granted only when neither injury to the public interest nor injustice to the parties will result.” Second, it works only on a covenant the law still allows. The 2023 ban covers a covenant between an employee and employer entered into on or after July 1, 2023, unless one of paragraph (b)’s exceptions applies. One exception is a covenant agreed upon in the sale of a business. A covenant the ban covers is “void and unenforceable” under Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 2(a), so no valid covenant remains for a court to narrow. For a covenant the law still allows, a seller’s argument that it is too broad may shrink the order you get without defeating the claim.

What Counts as Competing or Soliciting Under the Covenant?

Competing is whatever the covenant’s words forbid. A seller who conducted the business in the same area for many years and built a sizable clientele can breach a no-competition promise without asking old customers for their business. In Haynes v. Monson, 224 N.W.2d 482 (Minn. 1974), the sellers of a bookkeeping and tax practice in Austin promised not to carry on that business within 50 miles of Austin for five years. One seller opened an office in Red Wing, about 100 miles away, and kept doing work for 45 to 50 Austin clients, whose papers were mailed to Red Wing or left at his Austin home.

The Minnesota Supreme Court said covenants like this one “should be strictly construed,” and it still affirmed a summary judgment against the sellers, which the lower court granted because there was “no genuine material issue as to whether or not the plaintiff has breached the contract.” The court concluded that “on the basis of the record before us, there existed no genuine issue of material fact.” Its reasoning: “when one has conducted a business in the same area for many years and has built a sizable clientele, active solicitation on his part is unnecessary to compete so as to defeat the covenant. Solicitation by mere reputation and past business practices is more than sufficient.” The court described the purpose of these covenants as “to protect purchasers of a going concern from an infringement upon their investment and the continuation of the business for a profit.”

Conduct a covenant’s words may reach includes:

  • opening or working for a competing business inside the territory;
  • owning or investing in a competitor, if the covenant bars being “interested in” one, as the Haynes covenant did;
  • serving former customers who come to the seller without being asked; and
  • recruiting your employees, if the sale documents bar it.

A promise not to solicit your customers or hire your employees is a separate contract term, read on its own words. Minnesota’s ban does not treat a customer nonsolicitation clause as a noncompete: Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 1(a) states that a covenant not to compete “does not include a nonsolicitation agreement, or agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists, or solicit customers of the employer.” The same paragraph also states: “A covenant not to compete does not include a nondisclosure agreement, or agreement designed to protect trade secrets or confidential information.”

How Do You Document the Seller’s Competition?

A Minnesota court decides a request to stop the seller on sworn evidence, so your proof should be built for an affidavit from the start. Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.02(b) provides: “A temporary injunction may be granted if by affidavit, deposition testimony, or oral testimony in court, it appears that sufficient grounds exist therefor.” The Haynes record shows what that proof can look like: the seller’s own deposition described his work for Austin clients, and in an affidavit, Duane Grafe “indicated that he had telephoned Haynes’ Austin residence, at the suggestion of defendant Gerhard A. Monson, to arrange to have some tax work done.” Monson was one of the buyers.

A general claim of harm is not enough. In Carl Bolander & Sons Co. v. City of Minneapolis, 502 N.W.2d 203 (Minn. 1993), where a recycling company asked to stop a city’s competing facility, the Minnesota Supreme Court said a “mere statement that it is suffering or will suffer irreparable injury, without more, is not enough to support a claim for injunctive relief.”

Evidence that can carry an affidavit includes:

  • the purchase agreement, any separate noncompete agreement, and the closing documents showing when the covenant was signed;
  • the names of customers who moved to the seller, and written statements from customers willing to sign one;
  • the seller’s website, advertising, social media, and public business-registration records; and
  • messages from the seller to your customers or staff, and any employee departures that followed.

I suggest saving dated copies of online material now, because websites and posts change.

What Are the Options Before Going to Court?

Before a lawsuit, you can try to stop a competing seller through a direct conversation, a negotiated fix to the covenant, outreach to your own customers, or a demand letter. When those fail, a lawsuit with a motion for a temporary injunction is the fifth option. Each fits a different relationship with the seller and carries its own risk, from customers lost and covenant time used up while you talk to giving the seller time to prepare. The first four keep the dispute out of court, and the fifth begins it.

  1. A direct conversation. This fits when the seller may have misread the covenant or still works with you on a transition or a note. The risk is time: while you talk, customers may move. The covenant’s term also keeps running. In Cherne Industrial, Inc. v. Grounds & Associates, Inc., 278 N.W.2d 81 (Minn. 1979), an employee-covenant case, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that generally, “if the restrictive period of a covenant not to compete has expired, an injunction will not be granted to enforce the covenant,” though “there may be situations where injunctive relief extending beyond the expiration of the period established by the covenant is appropriate.” I suggest confirming what was said in a short written follow-up the same day, because the written version can later serve as evidence.
  2. A negotiated fix. A narrower territory, a payment for release of the remaining term, or an agreed split of certain customers can end the dispute. This fits when the seller’s new work overlaps only part of your market. A signed amendment should say which original terms survive, because that leaves no question later about what still binds the seller.
  3. Customer outreach. Calling your key customers to confirm service and pricing is a business move that protects the goodwill you bought. I suggest keeping what you tell customers about the seller to accurate facts.
  4. A demand letter. A letter that quotes the covenant, describes the conduct, states what must stop, and asks the seller to preserve records puts the claim on paper. The risk is that it gives the seller notice to prepare, though a temporary injunction requires notice anyway. The page on pre-litigation demand letters covers content and timing.
  5. A lawsuit with a motion for a temporary injunction. This fits when customers are leaving now and talk has failed, as the next section explains.

How Does a Temporary Injunction Stop a Competing Seller?

A temporary injunction is a court order that stops the seller’s competition while the lawsuit is pending, and Minnesota’s civil rules set its conditions. Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.02(a), “No temporary injunction shall be granted without notice of motion or an order to show cause to the adverse party.” Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.03(a), “No temporary restraining order or temporary injunction shall be granted except upon the giving of security by the applicant, in such sum as the court deems proper, for the payment of such costs and damages as may be incurred or suffered by any party who is found to have been wrongfully enjoined or restrained.” That security belongs in your budget, because it answers for the seller’s losses if the order proves wrong.

In Dahlberg Bros., Inc. v. Ford Motor Co., 137 N.W.2d 314 (Minn. 1965), the Minnesota Supreme Court reviewed a temporary injunction “in light of five considerations which we consider relevant in deciding whether the determination made by the trial court should be sustained on appeal.” How each one works is covered on the page about temporary injunctions in Minnesota business cases. For a seller’s covenant, I suggest showing harm customer by customer, tied to the goodwill you paid for, because a bare claim of harm failed in Bolander.

A restraining order without notice is available only under the narrower conditions of Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.01, and an order binds the people Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.04 names, including those acting in concert with the seller who receive actual notice of it. A court can also enforce the covenant after trial. In Bess, the Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed a judgment enjoining the seller from conducting a general towing business in Forest Lake for five years.

What Damages Can a Buyer Recover From a Seller Who Competes?

A buyer can recover profits lost because of the seller’s breach, if it proves them with reasonable certainty. In Cardinal Consulting Co. v. Circo Resorts, Inc., 297 N.W.2d 260 (Minn. 1980), the Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed a tour company’s lost-profits verdict against a hotel that broke its contract. Quoting earlier decisions, the court stated that lost profits “may be recovered where they are shown to be the natural and probable consequences of the act or omission complained of and their amount is shown with a reasonable degree of certainty and exactness.” It added: “The controlling principle is that speculative, remote, or conjectural damages are not recoverable.”

I suggest assembling revenue by customer from before and after the seller started competing, because the court will ask how each lost dollar connects to the seller’s conduct.

If your agreement fixes a dollar amount for a breach, a Minnesota court tests that amount before enforcing it. In Gorco Construction Co. v. Stein, 99 N.W.2d 69 (Minn. 1959), the Minnesota Supreme Court said “The controlling factor, rather than intent, is whether the amount agreed upon is reasonable or unreasonable in the light of the contract as a whole, the nature of the damages contemplated” and the surrounding circumstances. The page on liquidated damages versus penalties explains that line.

Some purchase agreements let a buyer reduce later payments to the seller for a breach. Whether you may hold back payments on a seller note turns on the note, the purchase agreement, and whether the seller’s breach is material, covered on the page about a buyer withholding seller-note payments.

Does the noncompete reach the seller's new company or a relative running it?

It depends on whether the seller’s role there is conduct the covenant forbids. The covenant in Haynes v. Monson, 224 N.W.2d 482 (Minn. 1974) barred the sellers, “either solely or jointly, with or as manager or agent of any person or corporation, directly or indirectly,” from being “engaged or interested in the business.” A court order can reach further. Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.04, an injunction binds the parties, “their officers, agents, servants, employees, and attorneys,” and “those persons in active concert or participation with them who receive actual notice of the order by personal service or otherwise.”

Is the seller's noncompete void if it is only in an employment agreement signed after closing?

It can be, if it was signed on or after July 1, 2023, falls within Minnesota’s ban, and was not “agreed upon during the sale of a business” under Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 2(b)(1). Subd. 1(a) defines the banned covenant as “an agreement between an employee and employer that restricts the employee, after termination of the employment,” and subd. 1(c) counts independent contractors as employees. If you sue on a covenant the ban covers, subd. 2(d) lets a court award “an employee who is enforcing rights under this section reasonable attorney fees.”

Can I stop paying the seller note because the seller is competing?

It depends on your note and purchase agreement and, apart from them, on whether the seller’s breach is material. In Bob Acres, LLC v. Schumacher Farms, LLC, 797 N.W.2d 723 (Minn. Ct. App. 2011), the court, quoting a dictionary and a treatise, said a material breach can excuse the harmed party “from further performance” and “goes to the root or essence of the contract.” In Haynes v. Monson, 224 N.W.2d 482 (Minn. 1974), buyers who stopped paying a seller still serving clients in the protected territory won dismissal, on that record, of the sellers’ suit for the balance. I suggest checking your documents for a set-off right before withholding, because a seller can sue on missed payments.

Does a covenant with no end date still bind the seller?

It depends on when it was signed and whether Minn. Stat. § 181.988 reaches it. For one signed on or after July 1, 2023, that the section reaches, subd. 2(b)(1) permits a “temporary and geographically restricted” sale covenant. In a 1977 decision, Bess v. Bothman, 257 N.W.2d 791 (Minn. 1977), a covenant with no territory or time limit was narrowed and enforced, and the court noted earlier cases holding “that a covenant with a proper territorial limitation may be valid even absent an explicit temporal restriction.” The section What Happens When a Court Finds the Seller’s Covenant Too Broad? covers the limits.

Enforcing a Seller’s Noncompete in Minnesota

Section 181.988 reaches a covenant between an employee and employer entered into on or after July 1, 2023. For a covenant it reaches, § 181.988 makes one agreed upon in a Minnesota business sale valid and enforceable if it is temporary and geographically restricted, barring a similar business “within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time.” Under Bess, a court asks whether the covenant exceeds the protection needed for the goodwill you bought, places an undue hardship on the seller, or harms the public, and enforcement remains “a matter of equitable discretion.” Your position rests on the covenant’s exact words, sworn evidence of what the seller is doing, and customer-level proof of what it has cost you. The deal documents that set up this protection are part of my work on buying and selling businesses.

If the seller who sold you your business is competing with you, email [email protected] with a brief description of what the seller is doing. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.