In Minnesota, you may be able to sue someone who improperly interferes with a likely business relationship.

A helpful summary of “tortious interference with prospective contractual relations” is provided in section 766B of the Restatement (Second) of Torts:

one who intentionally and improperly interferes with another’s prospective contractual relation is subject to liability to the other for the pecuniary harm resulting from loss of the benefits of the relations, whether the interference consists of: a) inducing or otherwise causing a third person not to enter into or continue the prospective relation or b) preventing the other from acquiring or continuing the prospective relation.

This article explains the five elements to prove tortious interference and notes supporting Minnesota cases. Minnesota’s test is narrower than the Restatement’s “improperly” language, because it requires conduct that is independently tortious or unlawful.

Elements to Tortious Interference with Prospective Contractual Relations

The Minnesota Supreme Court calls this claim tortious interference with prospective economic advantage. Under Minnesota law, the elements are,

  1. the existence of a reasonable expectation of economic advantage,
  2. the defendant’s knowledge of that expectation of economic advantage,
  3. that the defendant intentionally interfered with the plaintiff’s reasonable expectation of economic advantage, and the intentional interference is either independently tortious or in violation of a state or federal statute or regulation,
  4. that in the absence of the wrongful act of the defendant, it is reasonably probable that the plaintiff would have realized the economic advantage or benefit, and
  5. that the plaintiff sustained damages.

Gieseke v. IDCA, Inc., 844 N.W.2d 210, 219 (Minn. 2014).

Reasonable Expectation of Economic Advantage or Benefit Belonging to the Plaintiff

A mere loss of unspecified business does not establish the intentional interference with prospective business relations. H. Enters Int’l, Inc. v. Gen. Elec. Capital Corp., 833 F.Supp 1405, 1417 (D. Minn. 1993). A plaintiff must specifically identify a third party with whom the plaintiff had a reasonable probability of a future economic relationship; a projection of future business from unidentified customers, without more, is not enough. Gieseke, 844 N.W.2d at 221.

Defendant’s Knowledge of the Expectation of Economic Advantage

A plaintiff must show that the defendant knew of the plaintiff’s expectation of economic advantage. Because the expectation must involve an identified third party, the evidence should tie the defendant’s knowledge to that specific relationship.

Interference with the Reasonable Expectation of Economic Advantage or Benefit

This element requires evidence that the defendant’s interference was intentional and that it was either independently tortious or a violation of a state or federal statute or regulation. Conduct that is negligent or merely unfair is not enough. The Minnesota Supreme Court set this limit so that businesses may rigorously compete with one another without fear of liability, as long as they do so lawfully.

Reasonable Probability that a Plaintiff Would Realize Economic Advantage But For the Defendant’s Wrongful Act

It is not enough for a plaintiff to show that a defendant interfered. A plaintiff must also provide evidence that there is a reasonable probability that they would have realized economic advantage or benefit in the absence of the defendant’s wrongful act. Pure speculation regarding a plaintiff’s advantage or benefit is not enough to satisfy this element.

Damages

Lastly, a plaintiff must establish that they have been injured or suffered damages because of the interference of the defendant. A way to satisfy this element is for a plaintiff to show that they lost business revenue because of the acts of the defendant.