A contract signed by someone with no authority to sign it can still bind a Minnesota corporation or LLC in several ways. Among them, the company is bound if its own conduct gave the signer apparent authority, or if it later ratifies the contract. The person who signed can also be liable to the other side. Whether the company is bound beyond the signer’s actual authority is mostly agency law that Minnesota courts built. Statutes add routes of their own, including an LLC’s filed statement of authority under chapter 322C and a corporation’s statutory ratification under chapter 302A. Chapter 302A (business corporations) and chapter 322C (LLCs) also set who holds signing authority by default. This page is for owners, officers, and managers of Minnesota corporations and LLCs deciding what to do about a contract someone signed without authority, and it is part of my Minnesota contract materials.
How Does Minnesota Law Decide Whether an Unauthorized Signature Binds the Company?
An unauthorized signature can bind a Minnesota company through several routes. The main ones are that the signer had actual authority after all, the company’s own conduct gave the signer apparent authority, or the company ratified the contract after learning of it. If no route applies, the contract is invalid as against the company, though the signer may still be liable.
I found no Minnesota statute that codifies apparent authority for corporate officers or LLC members; the rule comes from Minnesota Supreme Court and Court of Appeals decisions. The test centers on the other side’s belief and where it came from. In Powell v. MVE Holdings, Inc., 626 N.W.2d 451 (Minn. App. 2001), the Court of Appeals said the company “can be held to O’Halloran’s agreement only if Powell’s belief that O’Halloran had authority to make that agreement is reasonable and traceable to Holdings.” In plain terms, the other company’s belief counts only if it was reasonable and the company itself caused it.
A genuine signature does not settle the question either. A contract needs the mutual assent of both parties, and when the signer could not act for the company, the company’s own contractual intent is missing unless one of these routes supplies it.
What Is a Contract Signatory or Authorized Signatory?
A contract signatory is the person who signs a contract. When the party is a company, the signatory signs on its behalf, and an authorized signatory (in British spelling, an “authorised signatory”) is a signatory with actual authority to bind the company. Signatory authority is that power to bind, so a signature from someone without it does not by itself commit the company.
Actual authority comes in two kinds. In Hockemeyer v. Pooler, 268 Minn. 551, 130 N.W.2d 367 (Minn. 1964), the Minnesota Supreme Court explained: “The agent’s actual authority consists of express and implied authority. Express authority is that authority which the principal directly grants to the agent. Implied authority includes only those powers which are essential to carry out the duties expressly delegated.” For a company, the express grant usually comes from its articles, bylaws, operating agreement, or board, or from the default statutes in the next section. Implied authority is therefore part of actual authority, not a separate route. Apparent authority works differently: it rests on what the company led the other side to believe. In Powell, the Court of Appeals said, “A principal is bound not only by an agent’s actual authority but also by authority that the principal has apparently delegated to the agent.”
Who Has Authority to Sign for a Minnesota Corporation or LLC?
In a Minnesota corporation, the chief executive officer signs the company’s ordinary contracts by default, and the articles, bylaws, or board can change that default. In a Minnesota LLC, being a member does not by itself give anyone authority to sign, and the LLC’s management structure decides who may act.
Corporations. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.201, subd. 1, “The business and affairs of a corporation shall be managed by or under the direction of a board,” subject to the exceptions that subdivision names. The board’s direction leaves room for officers to sign. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.305, subd. 2, the chief executive officer shall “sign and deliver in the name of the corporation any deeds, mortgages, bonds, contracts or other instruments pertaining to the business of the corporation,” except where the authority “is required by law to be exercised by another person or is expressly delegated by the articles or bylaws or by the board to some other officer or agent of the corporation” under clause (d). Subdivision 1 makes those duties a default: they apply “Unless the articles, the bylaws, or a resolution adopted by the board and not inconsistent with the articles or bylaws, provide otherwise.” A corporation whose board never chose officers still has them: under Minn. Stat. § 302A.321, “In the absence of an election or appointment of officers by the board, the person or persons exercising the principal functions of the chief executive officer or the chief financial officer are deemed to have been elected to those offices,” with one exception for locating the principal executive office.
Other officers, such as a chief operating officer or a vice president, have the powers “provided for in the articles or bylaws or determined by the board” under Minn. Stat. § 302A.311. An employee’s signing authority can trace to an officer: under Minn. Stat. § 302A.351, “Unless prohibited by the articles or bylaws or by a resolution approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present, an officer may, without the approval of the board, delegate some or all of the duties and powers of an office to other persons.” A written shareholder control agreement can also move these powers. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.457, subd. 2, an agreement signed by all of the shareholders (and any subscribers for shares) can govern “the management of its business” and “the election of directors or officers,” and it “is binding upon and enforceable against only those persons and other persons having knowledge of the existence of the agreement.” My page on who can legally bind a company covers powers of attorney and other sources of authority.
Directors. A director who holds no office has no signing power of that director’s own under these sections, because the board acts as a body. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.237, subd. 1, “The board shall take action by the affirmative vote of the greater of” a majority of the directors present at a duly held meeting or a majority of a quorum, unless the chapter or the articles require more. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.239, subd. 1, the board can act without a meeting by “written action signed, or consented to by authenticated electronic communication, by all of the directors,” or, where the articles allow it, by fewer directors for an action that does not need shareholder approval. A director who signs a contract alone binds the company only through an officer role, authority the board or an officer delegated, apparent authority, or the company’s ratification.
LLCs. Minn. Stat. § 322C.0301, subd. 1 provides: “A member is not an agent of a limited liability company solely by reason of being a member.” Subdivision 2 keeps other law in play: a person’s status as a member “does not prevent or restrict law other than this chapter from imposing liability on a limited liability company because of the person’s conduct.” Agency law, including apparent authority, is that other law.
Who may act for an LLC depends on its structure under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407. An LLC is member-managed “unless the operating agreement” says it is manager-managed or board-managed (subdivision 1). In a member-managed LLC, “The management and conduct of the company are vested in the members,” and “An act outside the ordinary course of the activities of the company may be undertaken only with the consent of all members” (subdivision 2). In a manager-managed LLC, “any matter relating to the activities of the company is decided exclusively by the managers,” except as the chapter otherwise provides (subdivision 3). In a board-managed LLC, “only officers, managers, or other agents designated by the board or through a process approved by the board have the right to act for the limited liability company, and that right extends only to the extent consistent with the terms of the designation” (subdivision 4). A person the board designates as chief executive officer, or by a similar title, shall “sign and deliver in the name of the limited liability company any deeds, mortgages, bonds, contracts, or other instruments pertaining to the business of the limited liability company, except in cases in which the authority to sign and deliver is required by law to be exercised by another person or is expressly delegated by the board of governors to some other officer or agent of the limited liability company” under clause (14) of subdivision 4. These are default rules: under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 2, “To the extent the operating agreement does not otherwise provide for a matter described in subdivision 1, this chapter governs the matter.” I suggest reading the operating agreement first, because it decides which structure applies and can change these rules.
When Does Apparent Authority Bind the Company Anyway?
Apparent authority binds the company when the company’s own conduct led the other side to believe the signer could sign, and the other side knew of that conduct. What the signer said about his or her own authority does not count, because the proof has to come from the company.
The Minnesota Supreme Court set out the elements in Truck Crane Service Co. v. Barr-Nelson, Inc., 329 N.W.2d 824 (Minn. 1983), quoting an earlier decision:
- “The principal must have held the agent out as having authority, or must have knowingly permitted the agent to act on its behalf”
- “the party dealing with the agent must have actual knowledge that the agent was held out by the principal as having such authority or had been permitted by the principal to act on its behalf”
- “the proof of the agent’s apparent authority must be found in the conduct of the principal, not the agent.”
Powell shows the elements working against a company. The CEO agreed to buy back the stock of an executive he was pushing out, without express board approval. Six months earlier, with board approval, the same CEO had signed an agreement buying other shareholders’ stock at the same price. The Court of Appeals affirmed a judgment against the company. It noted that “unless there is contrary evidence, contracts made by a corporation’s president in the ordinary course of business are presumed to be within the president’s authority,” while cautioning that “a job title alone will not conclusively establish apparent authority for a contract.” The court also said that “Whether an agent is clothed with apparent authority is a question of fact,” so these disputes turn on evidence of how the company actually operated.
Inattention can create apparent authority too. In Duluth Herald & News Tribune v. Plymouth Optical Co., 176 N.W.2d 552 (Minn. 1970), the court quoted an earlier decision that the scope of apparent authority “is determined not only by what the principal knows and acquiesces in, but also by what the principal should, in the exercise of ordinary care and prudence, know his agent is doing.” A franchisor that let its franchisee use its name for three years was held liable for advertising contracts the franchisee signed in that name. My page on apparent authority covers the doctrine in more depth.
How Much Must the Other Side Check a Signer’s Authority?
A business dealing with someone who claims to sign for a company is expected to check that person’s authority, and a warning from the company can defeat its later claim. That duty has a practical limit, though: when checking would have turned up nothing, the other side’s reliance can still be reasonable.
The duty comes from West Concord Conservation Club, Inc. v. Chilson, 306 N.W.2d 893 (Minn. 1981), relying on an earlier decision: “Every person who undertakes to deal with an agent is put on inquiry and must discover whether the agent has the authority to complete the proposed act.” In Truck Crane, the company’s president had written to the supplier denying liability, and the court held that the letter “put the plaintiff on inquiry as to the authority of any other Barr-Nelson employee to countermand such a position.”
In Powell, the company argued that the seller was on notice that the CEO lacked authority. The court answered that “even accepting that Powell knew O’Halloran needed board and Investors’ approval to agree to buy the stock, it is unclear what Powell could have done to ascertain whether O’Halloran had the necessary approval.” The CEO and the company’s in-house counsel had both testified that the board “acted informally and secretly, generally preparing board resolutions only when a third party such as the IRS required them.”
A Minnesota LLC can put signing authority on the public record. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0302, subd. 1, “A limited liability company may file with the secretary of state a statement of authority.” A grant of authority in the statement, other than for real estate, “is conclusive in favor of a person that gives value in reliance on the grant,” subject to the exceptions in subdivision 5. A limitation works less strongly: under subdivision 4, it “is not by itself evidence of knowledge or notice of the limitation by any person.” Under subdivision 3, the statement “affects only the power of a person to bind a limited liability company to persons that are not members.” Subdivisions 6, 7, and 8 add rules for real estate, including the effect of a statement of dissolution or termination. My page on the statement of authority explains when filing one helps.
How Can You Verify Signatory Authority Before Signing a Contract?
Before you sign with a company, I suggest asking for documents that come from the company itself, because apparent authority has to rest on the company’s conduct, not on what the signer says. For a large or unusual deal, I suggest asking for:
- A certified board resolution or secretary’s certificate. A corporate secretary or other officer certifies the resolution approving this contract, or the officers’ names and signing limits, and that it remains in effect.
- The relevant part of the bylaws or operating agreement. These show whether the signer’s office carries signing power and whether this kind of deal needs a board, member, or manager vote.
- A power of attorney, when someone signs as an attorney-in-fact rather than as an officer or manager.
- A search of the Minnesota Secretary of State’s records for a Minnesota LLC’s statement of authority, which can give you the conclusive reliance described above.
A contract clause in which the signer states that he or she is authorized puts that promise in writing, but it cannot create authority the company never gave.
What Role Do Witnesses Play When Authority Is Missing?
A witness can prove who signed and when. A witness does not supply authority. The authority question still turns on the company’s grant or its own conduct, because the Truck Crane test quoted above locates the proof of apparent authority in the company’s conduct, not the signer’s.
How Does Signatory Authority Work in International Contracts?
When the other company was formed in another country, or the contract crosses borders, I suggest checking two bodies of law. The first is the law the contract names as its governing law. The second is the company law of the place where the other company was formed, which sets up its officers and governing documents. Minnesota’s own LLC statute is an example of that home-state rule: under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0106, “The law of this state governs: (1) the internal affairs of a limited liability company.” For a foreign company, I suggest asking for a current extract from its home country’s company registry showing its officers or directors. A board resolution or power of attorney for this deal, translated where needed, should come with it. A governing-law clause and a signer’s statement of authority in the contract reduce later disputes over which rules apply.
How Do You Spot a Contract Signed Without Authority?
I suggest comparing the signer and the deal against the company’s own records, because those records define the signer’s actual authority. A contract was likely signed without authority when:
- The signer’s office does not carry signing power under the bylaws, operating agreement, a board resolution, or a filed statement of authority, or the contract exceeds a written dollar limit.
- The deal needed a board, shareholder, member, or manager vote, and no vote appears in the minutes or written consents. The section below on deals that need more than one signer gives examples.
- The signer had left the company or lost the office before signing.
- No one with authority approved the deal, the signature does not match, or the paperwork was rushed around the usual approval steps.
Finding one of these signs does not end the question. The company can still be bound through apparent authority or ratification, so the next step is a deliberate decision, covered in the next two sections.
How Does a Company Ratify a Contract It Never Authorized?
A company ratifies an unauthorized contract by approving it, either expressly or through conduct such as accepting its benefits, with knowledge of the material facts, which can include facts a reasonable inquiry would disclose. Once ratified, the contract binds the company as though the signer had authority from the start, so ratification is a decision to make deliberately.
The Minnesota Supreme Court described ratification in Anderson v. First Nat. Bank of Pine City, 228 N.W.2d 257 (Minn. 1975), relying on earlier decisions: it occurs when one, “having full knowledge of all the material facts, confirms, approves, or” sanctions, “by affirmative act or acquiescence, the originally unauthorized act of another.” In Losinski v. American Dry Cleaning Co., 281 N.W.2d 884 (Minn. 1979), the court applied the rule to corporations, citing a treatise: when an officer enters into a contract “without authorization but which could have been authorized in the first instance by the directors or stockholders, such contract or transaction may become binding on the corporation if ratified expressly or by implication.” The same passage adds that “if the circumstances are such as to put a reasonable person on inquiry the corporation is considered to have knowledge of any facts such inquiry would disclose.” Ratification can happen in several ways, including:
- A written approval, such as a board resolution or a written consent of the LLC’s members or managers, adopted with the material facts in front of the decision makers. It leaves the clearest record.
- Conduct. In Cooney v. Milwaukee Mutual Insurance Co., 397 N.W.2d 352 (Minn. App. 1986), the court said, citing an earlier decision, “A corporation may ratify unauthorized acts of its agent by accepting the benefits of the transaction.” There, an insurer ratified its agent’s acts by accepting at least one premium payment.
When the original approval had to take a set form, ratification must take it too, whichever of these ways is used. In Losinski, the articles required a shareholder vote that never took place, and the court held that “any valid ratification was required to take the same form.” For a land purchase agreement, Gresser v. Hotzler, 604 N.W.2d 379 (Minn. App. 2000) held: “Because the statute of frauds requires written authorization for an agent to enter into a purchase agreement, Gresser cannot claim ratification through conduct or oral statements.”
A Minnesota corporation also has a statutory route, added in 2025. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.166, subd. 1, a “defective corporate act” is “not void or voidable solely as a result of a failure of authorization” if it is ratified under the section or validated by a court. The section reaches an act that would have been “within the corporation’s power under section 302A.101 but is void or voidable due to a failure of authorization,” under Minn. Stat. § 302A.011, subd. 72. A failure of authorization includes the failure “of the board or an officer to authorize or approve an act or transaction taken by or on behalf of the corporation that requires board or officer approval for the act or transaction’s due authorization” under Minn. Stat. § 302A.011, subd. 74.
The board’s resolutions must state, among other things, “the nature of the failure of authorization in respect of each defective corporate act to be ratified” (subdivision 2). Under subdivision 4, the act “must be submitted to shareholders for approval under subdivision 5, unless” one of that subdivision’s exceptions applies. The board’s own vote has a floor: under subdivision 2, paragraph (c), “The quorum and voting requirements that apply to the board’s ratification of any defective corporate act must be the quorum and voting requirements applicable to the type of defective corporate act proposed to be ratified at the time the board adopts the resolutions ratifying the defective corporate act.” With a narrow exception, a larger number of directors required by the articles, bylaws, an agreement, or chapter 302A when the act occurred still applies.
After the board acts, “prompt notice of the ratification must be given to all shareholders of valid shares and putative shares, whether voting or nonvoting” (subdivision 8), unless “notice of the ratification of the defective corporate act is given in accordance with subdivision 5.” Under subdivision 7, once the validation effective time arrives (which can be immediately after the board adopts its resolutions when no shareholder vote is required), the ratified act is “no longer deemed void or voidable as a result of the failure of authorization described in the resolutions adopted under subdivision 2, effective retroactively from the time of the defective corporate act.”
The statute also limits challenges. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.167, subd. 5, the limit reaches an action claiming a ratified act is void or voidable “due to a failure of authorization identified in the resolution adopted in accordance with section 302A.166, subdivision 2 or 3.” It also reaches an action asking a court to set conditions on the ratification or declare it ineffective (in the statute’s words, that a ratification “not be effective or be effective only on certain conditions”). Such an action “is prohibited from being brought after the expiration of 120 days from the later of the validation effective time and the time notice, if any, that is required to be given pursuant to section 302A.166, subdivision 8, is given with respect to the ratification.” The limit does not apply “to an action asserting that a ratification was not accomplished in accordance with section 302A.166 or to any person to whom notice of the ratification was required to have been given pursuant to section 302A.166, subdivision 5 or 8, but to whom the notice was not given.” Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.011, subd. 78, the validation effective time is the latest of several events, including shareholder approval or, “if no vote of the shareholders is required to approve the ratification of the defective corporate act, immediately following the time when the board adopts the resolutions required under section 302A.166, subdivision 2 or 3.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. My page on documenting a ratification after the fact covers the resolutions and notices.
Is an Unauthorized Contract Automatically Void or Voidable?
An unauthorized contract is not automatically void. It does not bind the company unless one of the routes on this page applies, but the company keeps the choice to adopt it. Under Losinski, quoted above, a contract that the directors or stockholders could have authorized in the first instance may become binding on the corporation if ratified. For a corporation, section 302A.166 adds a statutory cure. It covers an act within the corporation’s power that “is void or voidable due to a failure of authorization” under Minn. Stat. § 302A.011, subd. 72, and lets the corporation ratify it. Unless the company ratifies the contract, the other side can hold the company to it only through another route, such as apparent authority.
How Can a Company Reject a Contract Signed Without Authority?
A company that does not want the contract should decide after learning the material facts, avoid accepting the contract’s benefits in the meantime, and tell the other side in writing. Rejecting the contract does not end an apparent-authority claim, which turns on the company’s conduct before the deal.
Three Minnesota rules shape that decision:
- Benefits and inquiry can supply knowledge. In Gresser, the Court of Appeals said, citing Anderson and Cooney, that “ratification cannot occur when the principal does not have full knowledge of all material facts, unless constructive knowledge is imputed by the principal’s acceptance of a transaction’s benefits.” The same court held that “The mere delivery of a check as earnest money is insufficient to constitute a benefit.” Under Losinski, a corporation is also considered to know the facts a reasonable inquiry would disclose when the circumstances call for one. Benefits already used before the signature came to light can come out differently. In Anderson, the loan proceeds had gone to pay the Andersons’ debts, and the court addressed the bank’s argument that the husband ratified by keeping the funds only under its estoppel defense. It upheld the ruling of no estoppel because “the harm had been done by the time Mr. Anderson learned that his wife had signed his name to the loan papers. At that point the benefit had already been conferred and the proceeds used.”
- The party raising ratification as a defense must prove it. In Anderson, the bank defending the suit relied on ratification, and the court explained: “As ratification was an affirmative defense, defendant had the burden of proving all material facts necessary to establish it.”
- An earlier written denial can put the other side on inquiry. In Truck Crane, the company’s president wrote to the supplier denying liability before the guarantee was signed. The court held that the letter put the supplier on inquiry about the authority of any other employee to countermand that position.
The company has more than one way to resolve the problem, and the legal steps are only part of it:
- Keep the deal. If the contract is one the company would have approved, a deliberate ratification, perhaps after negotiating changes the company can live with, ends the uncertainty. The risk is that ratification binds the company to the whole contract as signed unless the other side agrees to changes.
- Call the other company’s owner. A direct conversation between owners can unwind the deal or reshape it, particularly where the relationship matters to both. Anything said in that call that sounds like acceptance can later be argued as ratification “by affirmative act or acquiescence,” in the words of Anderson, so I suggest deciding the company’s position before the call.
- Reject it in writing. A resolution or written decision, followed by a letter to the other side, records the company’s position. The other side may still claim apparent authority.
- Defend a lawsuit. If the other side sues, apparent authority is a question of fact, so the outcome depends on evidence of how the company dealt with the signer and the other side.
Once, someone who contacted me about a contract signed for their firm reported that a former member with no signing authority under the operating agreement had signed a vendor contract. That person rejected it and sent the vendor the firm’s operating agreement, and the vendor kept billing. I told that person that a contract signed by someone without proper authority may not be enforceable against the company, and that whether the vendor could rely on apparent authority would be the key question.
Are Verbal Contracts Made Without Authority Enforceable?
An oral agreement made by someone without authority binds the company through the same routes as a signed one: actual authority, apparent authority, or ratification. Powell involved what the court called “the oral agreement between Holdings and Powell,” and the court said, “A signed agreement is not required for formation of a contract.” The CEO’s apparent authority bound the company to it.
A rule requiring a writing changes the result. In Gresser, described in the ratification section above, the statute of frauds required written authorization for an agent’s land purchase agreement, which ruled out ratification through conduct or oral statements. I suggest putting any agreement that matters in writing, signed by someone whose authority you have checked.
What Does an Unauthorized Signing Cost the Business?
Beyond the legal question, an unauthorized signing can leave the company with an obligation it never budgeted for, plus the cost of investigating and disputing it. Disowning a signed deal can also strain the company’s relationships with the other side, its lenders, its investors, and its customers, who may read the dispute as a sign of weak internal controls.
A prompt, documented decision limits both kinds of harm. Ratifying a deal the company can live with ends the uncertainty, and a clear written rejection, delivered early, tells the other side where it stands before it relies further on the contract. A short explanation to a key lender or customer, with the corrective steps the company has taken, can keep the relationship intact.
When Does a Deal Need More Than One Signer or a Vote?
Some deals need more than one person’s signature or a vote of the owners, so even an officer or manager with ordinary signing authority cannot complete them alone. The main examples are a sale of substantially all of the company’s assets outside its usual business and an instrument the company’s own rules say needs two signatures.
For a Minnesota corporation, Minn. Stat. § 302A.661, subd. 2 provides that a corporation, by a vote of a majority of the directors present, “may sell, lease, transfer, or otherwise dispose of all or substantially all of its property and assets, including its good will, not in the usual and regular course of its business,” only “when approved at a regular or special meeting of the shareholders by the affirmative vote of the holders of a majority of the voting power of the shares entitled to vote.” The subdivision also requires that “Written notice of the meeting shall be given to all shareholders whether or not they are entitled to vote at the meeting.”
Paragraph (b) has an exception: “Shareholder approval is not required under paragraph (a) if, following the sale, lease, transfer, or other disposition of its property and assets, the corporation retains a significant continuing business activity.” It adds a safe harbor: “If a corporation retains a business activity that represented at least (1) 25 percent of the corporation’s total assets at the end of the most recently completed fiscal year and (2) 25 percent of either income from continuing operations before taxes or revenues from continuing operations for that fiscal year, measured on a consolidated basis with its subsidiaries for each of clauses (1) and (2), then the corporation will conclusively be deemed to have retained a significant continuing business activity.”
Subdivision 1 also lets the board act alone, “without shareholder approval,” to “grant a security interest in all or substantially all of its property and assets whether or not in the usual and regular course of its business” or to “transfer any or all of its property to an organization all the shares or other ownership interests of which are owned directly, or indirectly through wholly owned organizations, by the corporation.” My page on board approval lists other corporate actions that can need a vote.
Chapter 302A also requires a board vote for loans, guarantees, and share issuances. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.501, subd. 1, a corporation “may lend money to, guarantee an obligation of, become a surety for, or otherwise financially assist a person, if the transaction, or a class of transactions to which the transaction belongs, is approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present,” and one of the further conditions that subdivision lists is met. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.401, subd. 1(a), “Subject to any restrictions in the articles, a corporation may issue securities and rights to purchase securities only when authorized by the board.” An officer who guarantees another business’s debt or promises shares without that board action has acted without an approval the statute requires, and whether the company is bound then turns on apparent authority and ratification.
For a Minnesota LLC, the default rules in Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407 depend on the structure. In a member-managed LLC, an act outside the ordinary course “may be undertaken only with the consent of all members” (subdivision 2). In a manager-managed LLC, the consent of all members is required to “undertake any other act outside the ordinary course of the company’s activities” (subdivision 3). In a board-managed LLC, the consent of all members is required to sell substantially all of the company’s property outside the ordinary course (subdivision 4). That rule has a proviso, “provided that member consent is not required for” a security interest in that property or a transfer to a wholly owned organization.
A required vote also controls how the company can later approve the deal. In Losinski, a vice president signed a lease giving her son an option to buy real estate that made up substantially all of the company’s assets. The articles required a shareholder vote for that kind of sale, the shareholders never voted, and the Minnesota Supreme Court reversed a ruling that the company had impliedly ratified the option.
For checks, notes, and other negotiable instruments, Minn. Stat. § 336.3-403 provides: “If the signature of more than one person is required to constitute the authorized signature of an organization, the signature of the organization is unauthorized if one of the required signatures is lacking.”
Why Is Ultra Vires a Different Question From Officer Authority?
Ultra vires asks whether the corporation itself had the power to act, while the rest of this page asks whether a particular person had authority to act for it. A Minnesota business corporation has broad power to contract, and the statute protects even a contract beyond that power except in three kinds of court proceedings.
Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.161, subd. 7, “A corporation may make contracts and incur liabilities, borrow money, issue its securities, and secure any of its obligations by mortgage of or creation of a security interest in all or any of its property, franchises and income.” Subdivision 1 makes those powers “subject to any limitations provided in any other statute of this state or in its articles.”
Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.165, a contract “if otherwise lawful, is not invalid because the corporation was without the power to do, continue, or perform the act, contract, conveyance, or transfer, unless the lack of power is established in a court in this state” in one of three kinds of proceedings:
- A shareholder suit to enjoin the act. If the act is being performed under a contract, the court “may, if just and reasonable in the circumstances, set aside and enjoin the performance of the contract.”
- A suit by or for the corporation, including one brought “through shareholders in a representative or derivative suit, against the incumbent or former officers or directors of the corporation for exceeding or otherwise violating their authority, or against a person having actual knowledge of the lack of power.”
- A proceeding by the attorney general to dissolve the corporation or to stop it from transacting unauthorized business.
An officer’s lack of authority, by contrast, is decided under the agency rules above. My page on the ultra vires doctrine covers the corporate-power question.
How Is the Person Who Signed Without Authority Held Liable?
A person who signs a contract for a company without authority can be liable to the other side for breaching an implied promise that he or she had authority. The signer can also answer to the company under the duties officers, LLC members, and managers owe it.
In Wolfson v. Beris, 295 N.W.2d 562 (Minn. 1980), a part owner of downtown real estate agreed to sell it without power to sell for the other owners. The Minnesota Supreme Court adopted the Restatement rule that a person who purports to contract on behalf of another “who has full capacity but whom he has no power to bind, thereby becomes subject to liability to the other party thereto upon an implied warranty of authority, unless he has manifested that he does not make such warranty or the other party knows that the agent is not so authorized.” The court affirmed the judgment against him, vacated the damages award, and sent the case back for a new damages calculation. My page on personal liability for signing covers the signer’s side in more detail.
The measure of recovery is the lost bargain. The court said the buyer “is entitled to the benefit of the bargain for which he thought he had contracted.” For that real estate sale, it held that “the measure of Wolfson’s damages includes not only the difference between the property’s contract price and its market value on the day of sale, but also any increase in the value of the property up until the time Wolfson learned that Beris lacked authority to contract for its sale.”
Inside a corporation, Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 1 provides that “An officer shall discharge the duties of an office in good faith, in a manner the officer reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances.” An officer who hands signing power to an employee is held to that standard for “the act of delegation” and “the supervision of persons to whom those duties and powers are so delegated” under Minn. Stat. § 302A.351.
In a member-managed LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 3 sets a member’s duty of care, “Subject to the business judgment rule,” as acting “with the care that a person in a like position would reasonably exercise under similar circumstances and in a manner the member reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the company.” In a manager-managed LLC, subdivision 7 provides that those duties “apply to the manager or managers and not the members.” Under subdivision 4, every member also must act “consistently with the contractual obligation of good faith and fair dealing.”
What Happens to Money, Goods, Warranties, and Service Terms Already Exchanged?
If the contract does not bind the company, none of its terms bind the company, warranties and service commitments included. The other side’s claim then runs against the signer under Wolfson, unless the signer disclaimed the warranty or the other side knew the signer lacked authority. The company also cannot count on the other side’s warranties or service promises under a contract it has rejected. Ratification works the other way: it adopts the whole contract as signed, warranties and service terms included.
Money or goods already exchanged need attention right away, because keeping the benefits can ratify the contract under Cooney. If the company is rejecting the contract, I suggest offering to return what it received, or to pay for what it used, in the same letter that states its position.
Can an Unauthorized Signing Affect the Signer’s Personal Credit?
Only a debt the signer personally owes can affect the signer’s personal credit. A contract that binds only the company is the company’s debt. A signer becomes personally responsible through a personal guarantee or a judgment against the signer, such as one on the implied warranty of authority in Wolfson. If that personal debt goes unpaid, it can show up in the signer’s credit and collection records like any other personal debt.
Can Shareholders Undo a CEO’s Unauthorized Contract?
Ordinarily the board, not individual shareholders, decides whether to ratify or reject a CEO’s unauthorized contract, because the corporation’s business is managed “by or under the direction of a board” under § 302A.201, quoted above. Shareholders act through these channels:
- The board. Shareholders elect the directors, and the board decides whether to ratify or reject the contract.
- A unanimous shareholder vote. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.201, subd. 2, “The holders of the shares entitled to vote for directors of the corporation may, by unanimous affirmative vote, take any action that this chapter requires or permits the board to take.” A unanimous vote can therefore ratify or reject the contract in the board’s place, and a shareholder control agreement under § 302A.457 can also move that decision to the shareholders.
- A required vote. Where a deal needs a shareholder vote, such as the asset sale under § 302A.661 described above, the shareholders decide it, and Losinski required any ratification to take that same form.
- A challenge to a statutory ratification, brought within the period § 302A.167 sets, described in the ratification section above.
- A suit under § 302A.165, described in the ultra vires section above, which includes a shareholder suit to enjoin an act beyond the corporation’s power and a derivative suit against officers or directors “for exceeding or otherwise violating their authority.”
An officer who signed without authority also answers to the corporation under the § 302A.361 duty quoted above. For directors, Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 4 lets the articles eliminate or limit “A director’s personal liability to the corporation or its shareholders for monetary damages for breach of fiduciary duty as a director,” but not, among other exceptions, “for any breach of the director’s duty of loyalty” or “for acts or omissions not in good faith or that involve intentional misconduct or a knowing violation of law.” That subdivision addresses directors, not officers.
Is Signing a Contract Without Authority a Crime?
The rules above are civil: they decide who is bound and who pays. Minnesota’s forgery statutes add criminal liability only where their elements are met, and each of the two below requires an intent to defraud.
- Aggravated forgery. Under Minn. Stat. § 609.625, subd. 1, a person who, “with intent to defraud, falsely makes or alters a writing or object” so that it purports to have been made “by authority of one who did not give such authority,” among other forms, commits aggravated forgery when the writing is one of the listed kinds. The list includes “a writing or object whereby, when genuine, legal rights, privileges, or obligations are created, terminated, transferred, or evidenced,” other than a check or financial transaction card.
- Check forgery. Under Minn. Stat. § 609.631, subd. 2, a person who, “with intent to defraud,” falsely makes, alters, or endorses a check in one of the ways that subdivision lists is guilty of check forgery. One listed way is a check altered so that it purports to have been made “by the authority of one who did not give authority.”
Theft by swindle under Minn. Stat. § 609.52, subd. 2 reaches a person who “by swindling, whether by artifice, trick, device, or any other means, obtains property or services from another person,” among other elements of that statute. An officer who signs in good faith, believing he or she has authority, lacks the intent to defraud the forgery statutes require.
How Do Forged and Electronic Signatures Fit These Rules?
A forged signature is an unauthorized signature. On a check or other negotiable instrument, it counts only as the forger’s own signature in favor of a good-faith payer or taker for value. The company can ratify it, and other rules in Articles 3 and 4 of the Uniform Commercial Code can change the result. One of them is the company’s duty to examine its bank statements and report a forged check to its bank promptly. An electronic signature may not be denied legal effect solely because it is electronic, but whether it binds the company still depends on whether the person who used it had authority.
Minnesota’s Uniform Commercial Code defines an unauthorized signature in Minn. Stat. § 336.1-201: the term “means a signature made without actual, implied, or apparent authority. The term includes a forgery.” For negotiable instruments, Minn. Stat. § 336.3-403 provides: “Unless otherwise provided in this article or article 4, an unauthorized signature is ineffective except as the signature of the unauthorized signer in favor of a person who in good faith pays the instrument or takes it for value. An unauthorized signature may be ratified for all purposes of this article.” One of those other rules is Minn. Stat. § 336.3-406: “A person whose failure to exercise ordinary care substantially contributes to an alteration of an instrument or to the making of a forged signature on an instrument is precluded from asserting the alteration or the forgery against a person who, in good faith, pays the instrument or takes it for value or for collection.” For checks drawn on the company’s own account, Minn. Stat. § 336.4-406 adds a reporting duty: the customer “must exercise reasonable promptness in examining the statement or the items,” and “a customer who does not within one year after the statement or items are made available to the customer (subsection (a)) discover and report the customer’s unauthorized signature on or any alteration on the item is precluded from asserting against the bank the unauthorized signature or alteration.” Check the current text of section 336.4-406 before relying on this period. Outside those instruments, a forged signature on an ordinary contract raises the same questions as any other unauthorized signature. The main questions are whether the company’s own conduct gave the signer apparent authority, and whether the company ratified the contract.
Electronic signing changes the form, not the authority question. Under Minn. Stat. § 325L.07, “A record or signature may not be denied legal effect or enforceability solely because it is in electronic form.” That chapter turns on the parties’ agreement, which their conduct can show: under Minn. Stat. § 325L.05, “This chapter applies only to transactions between parties, each of which has agreed to conduct transactions by electronic means. Whether the parties agree to conduct transactions by electronic means is determined from the context and surrounding circumstances, including the parties’ conduct.” Under Minn. Stat. § 325L.09, “An electronic record or electronic signature is attributable to a person if it was the act of the person,” and its effect “is determined from the context and surrounding circumstances at the time of its creation, execution, or adoption, including the parties’ agreement, if any, and as otherwise provided by law.” When an employee clicks to accept a contract in the company’s name, the signature is that employee’s act, and the agency rules above decide whether it binds the company.
E-signature platform controls can prevent some unauthorized signings and help detect others, but they cannot supply authority. A company can set up its account so that only named people can send or sign contracts, and identity checks and audit trails record who signed and when. Section 325L.09 lets that evidence count: the act of the person “may be shown in any manner, including a showing of the efficacy of any security procedure applied to determine the person to which the electronic record or electronic signature was attributable.” That evidence answers who signed. Whether that person could bind the company is still the agency question above. My page on electronic signatures in Minnesota covers the rest of the statute.
How Can a Company Prevent Unauthorized Signatures?
A company can prevent many unauthorized-signature disputes by writing down who may sign what, making that record available to the people it deals with, and telling counterparties when someone’s authority ends. Each step below creates the kind of evidence the Minnesota cases above turned on.
- Put signing authority in writing. I suggest a board resolution or bylaw for a corporation, or an operating-agreement provision for an LLC, naming who may sign which contracts and up to what dollar amount. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.305, subd. 1, the CEO’s default duties apply unless the articles, bylaws, or a board resolution provide otherwise, and the resolution must be “adopted by the board and not inconsistent with the articles or bylaws.” The default signing duty already excludes a signing that is required by law to be made by another person or that the articles, bylaws, or board expressly delegate to another officer or agent.
- Limit delegation where it matters. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.351, a resolution approved by a majority of the directors present can prohibit an officer from delegating duties to other people, which keeps signing power with the officers the board chose.
- Consider a statement of authority for an LLC. Some LLCs regularly need outsiders to rely on a manager’s or officer’s signature. Such an LLC can file one under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0302, subd. 1, because a filed grant gives outsiders who are not members something conclusive to rely on.
- Require two signatures on large instruments. For checks and notes, Minn. Stat. § 336.3-403 treats an organization’s signature as unauthorized when one of the required signatures is missing.
- Notify counterparties when authority changes. When an officer, manager, or employee with signing authority leaves or loses it, I suggest a short letter to key vendors, lenders, and customers. In Truck Crane, the president’s earlier written denial put the supplier on inquiry about any other employee who tried to reverse it. When an LLC’s filed statement of authority grants that person authority, “a grant of authority not pertaining to transfers of real property” stays “conclusive in favor of a person that gives value in reliance on the grant” unless, among other exceptions, “the statement has been canceled or restrictively amended under subdivision 2” of Minn. Stat. § 322C.0302. To amend or cancel the statement, the LLC must “file with the secretary of state an amendment or cancellation.” A grant of authority to transfer real property follows subdivision 6 instead.
- Keep records of board and owner decisions. In Powell, testimony that the board prepared resolutions “only when a third party such as the IRS required them” led the court to say it was unclear “what Powell could have done to ascertain whether O’Halloran had the necessary approval.” Minutes and written consents give the company proof of what it did and did not approve.
How Should a Company Train the People Who Sign?
Written signing limits work only if the people who sign know them. I suggest short, regular training for officers, managers, and any employee who signs or approves contracts, including the COO and other officers whose powers depend on what the board has set. The training should cover three things:
- The written limits. Who may sign which contracts, up to what amount, under the current resolution, bylaws, or operating agreement.
- Who approves what. Which deals go to the CEO, the board, or the owners before anyone signs, such as the guarantees, share issuances, and asset sales described above.
- What to do when pressed. When a counterparty asks someone to sign outside those limits, the signer should say no, explain that the deal needs approval, and send it to the person who can give it.
Walking through a real example, such as Powell or Truck Crane, shows people how a casual signature can bind the company.
What Role Do Auditors and Employee Reports Play?
An external auditor reviewing the financial statements may test internal controls and contract approvals, and that review can flag a commitment made outside company policy. The audit does not check the authority behind every contract, and it does not substitute for the company’s own approval records or for a counterparty’s own check of authority. An internal review that periodically compares signed contracts with the signing-authority records catches more.
Employees are often the first to see an unauthorized signing. An internal reporting channel, including an anonymous one, lets them raise it early. Minnesota protects some of these reports: under Minn. Stat. § 181.932, subd. 1, an employer “shall not discharge, discipline, penalize, interfere with, threaten, restrain, coerce, or otherwise retaliate or discriminate against an employee” because the employee, “in good faith, reports a violation, suspected violation, or planned violation of any federal or state law or common law or rule adopted pursuant to law to an employer or to any governmental body or law enforcement official.” The protection attaches to a report of a suspected violation of law, such as a forged signature, rather than to every policy complaint. Under subdivision 2, the identity of an employee who makes such a report “to a governmental body or law enforcement official” is private data; an anonymous internal report depends on the channel the company sets up.
Does Your Industry Add Its Own Signing Rules?
The general agency rules on this page apply in every industry, but regulated businesses can face more. A bank, an insurer, a health care provider, or a company contracting with a government agency may be subject to regulator approvals or signing procedures for certain transactions. A contract with a government agency also raises the authority question on the agency’s side, under the rules that govern who may sign for it. I suggest checking your industry’s regulations and any government contract’s signing requirements before relying on the general rules described here.
What Insurance Covers Losses From an Unauthorized Signing?
Insurance can respond, depending on the policy. Crime or fidelity coverage is the usual place to look for losses from employee dishonesty or forgery, and many crime policies cover forged checks. A directors and officers (D&O) policy may cover claims against the company’s directors and officers, but many D&O policies exclude or limit claims for amounts owed under a contract. I suggest reading the policy terms, including the definitions and exclusions, and giving the insurer notice promptly when a loss or claim surfaces, because most policies set notice deadlines.
Is my LLC bound if one member signed a contract without the other members' consent?
Membership alone does not bind it. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0301, subd. 1, a member is not an agent of the LLC solely by reason of being a member. Subdivision 2 lets law other than chapter 322C impose liability on the LLC because of the member’s conduct. In a member-managed LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407, subd. 2 permits an act outside the ordinary course only with the consent of all members. That default applies “To the extent the operating agreement does not otherwise provide” under § 322C.0110, subd. 2. Other routes, including apparent authority and ratification, can still bind it.
Does paying the first invoice mean we accepted the contract?
It can, if the company pays knowing the material facts or in circumstances that would put a reasonable person on inquiry. In Anderson v. First Nat. Bank of Pine City (Minn. 1975), the court tied ratification to full knowledge of all the material facts. In Losinski v. American Dry Cleaning Co. (Minn. 1979), it treated a corporation as knowing what such an inquiry would disclose. In Cooney v. Milwaukee Mutual Insurance Co. (Minn. App. 1986), the court said a corporation may ratify by accepting a transaction’s benefits. I suggest deciding before paying, because payment can be treated as acceptance.
Can a vendor rely on a former employee's signature after the employee left?
A vendor can rely on it only if company conduct, known to the vendor, led it to believe the person could sign. In Truck Crane Service Co. v. Barr-Nelson, Inc. (Minn. 1983), the court held that a still-employed former secretary-treasurer lacked apparent authority as a matter of law. I suggest written notice to vendors when authority ends, because apparent authority rests on company conduct. An LLC whose filed statement of authority grants that person authority not pertaining to transfers of real property ends that grant by filing an amendment or cancellation (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0302, subds. 2 and 5).
Does an internal signing limit protect us if the other company never knew about it?
It limits the signer, but it may not protect the company against an outsider. In Powell v. MVE Holdings, Inc. (Minn. App. 2001), a CEO’s agreement bound the company through apparent authority even though it lacked board approval, because the seller’s belief was reasonable and traceable to the company. For a Minnesota LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0302, subd. 4 provides that a limitation in a filed statement of authority is not by itself evidence of knowledge or notice of the limitation by any person. That rule has exceptions, including recorded real-estate limits.
Can the other company sue the employee who signed instead of our company?
Yes, it can. In Wolfson v. Beris (Minn. 1980), the Minnesota Supreme Court adopted a rule for a person who purports to contract for someone who has full capacity but whom he has no power to bind. That person becomes liable to the other party on an implied warranty of authority. The rule does not apply if the signer made clear he gave no such warranty, or if the other party knew the signer lacked authority. A company that ratifies the contract takes the obligation on itself.
Unauthorized Signatures and Your Company
A signature can bind a Minnesota corporation or LLC in several ways. They include a signer who had authority, company conduct that made the other side reasonably believe the signer had it, and the company’s later ratification. The company controls authority and apparent authority before the contract is signed, and ratification afterward. After finding an unauthorized contract, I suggest a prompt, informed decision to keep it or reject it, recorded in writing, because accepting the contract’s benefits in the meantime can ratify it. My broader material on Minnesota contract law covers formation, enforcement, and disputes.
If your company is facing a contract someone signed without authority, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.