A closely held company is ready for a working board of directors when people outside the owner group need a formal say in major decisions. It is also ready when the owners need a decision process they cannot get from running the business day to day. Minnesota law already requires every corporation to have a board, and one director satisfies it. For an owner whose company already has a board, the decision is whether to add outside directors, give an LLC a board of governors, or form an advisory board that holds no vote.
The rules on what a board is and what it changes come from Minnesota’s business corporation act (chapter 302A) and its limited liability company (LLC) act (chapter 322C). No Minnesota statute tells an owner when to add outside directors, so that part of this page is business judgment. For the wider set of rules on who controls a company, see company control and governance.
What Does Minnesota Law Require of a Corporate Board?
Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.201, subd. 1, a Minnesota corporation must be run “by or under the direction of a board,” and that board may be a single director. The articles of incorporation can move board powers to other people, and two other routes let shareholders act in the board’s place. The default, though, is a board. The controlling sentence of § 302A.201, subd. 1, reads: “The business and affairs of a corporation shall be managed by or under the direction of a board, subject to the provisions of subdivision 2 and section 302A.457, and except as may be otherwise provided in the articles.” When the articles hand board powers to other natural persons, those persons take on “all of the duties, liabilities, and responsibilities of directors” for the powers they exercise.
Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.203, “The board shall consist of one or more directors. The number of directors shall be fixed by or in the manner provided in the articles or bylaws.” Minn. Stat. § 302A.205 adds that “Directors shall be natural persons,” so a company or trust cannot hold a seat. The first board “may be named in the articles or elected by the incorporators pursuant to section 302A.171 or by the shareholders” (§ 302A.201, subd. 1).
In practice, this means your corporation probably already has a board: the owners themselves, or one owner alone.
How Can a Minnesota Corporation Operate Without Using Its Board?
Shareholders can bypass the board in two ways: by acting unanimously, or by signing a shareholder control agreement. Either way, the owners who exercise the board’s power also take on a director’s liability for that exercise. For unanimous shareholder action, under § 302A.201, subd. 2, “The holders of the shares entitled to vote for directors of the corporation may, by unanimous affirmative vote, take any action that this chapter requires or permits the board to take.” For that action, “the shareholders collectively and individually have all of the duties, liabilities, and responsibilities of directors under this chapter with respect to and arising from the action.” This route works for two or three owners who agree on everything, and it stops working when one owner says no.
A shareholder control agreement. Minn. Stat. § 302A.457 lets owners write their own management rules in a written agreement. Under subdivision 2, the agreement “is valid and specifically enforceable, if the agreement is signed by all persons who, on the date the agreement first becomes effective, are then the shareholders of the corporation, whether or not the shareholders all have voting shares, and the subscribers for shares, whether or not voting shares, to be issued.” The agreement “is enforceable by the persons who are parties to it and is binding upon and enforceable against only those persons and other persons having knowledge of the existence of the agreement.” “A copy of the agreement shall be filed with the corporation. The existence and location of a copy of the agreement shall be noted conspicuously on the face or back of each certificate for shares issued by the corporation and included in information sent to the holders of uncertificated shares according to section 302A.417, subdivision 7.” Subdivision 3 moves liability with the power: the agreement relieves the directors of, and imposes on the parties, “the liability for acts or omissions imposed by law upon directors to the extent that and so long as the discretion or powers of the directors in the management of the business and affairs of the corporation are exercised by the shareholders under a provision in the agreement.”
A control agreement can fit a small owner group that wants to keep decisions among the owners, and it “may also include as parties persons who are neither shareholders nor subscribers” (subd. 1). A board becomes the better fit once someone outside that agreement needs a vote.
How Does a Minnesota LLC Decide Whether It Has a Board?
A Minnesota LLC has no board unless its operating agreement creates one. The default is member management, where every owner shares in running the company. An operating agreement may instead make the LLC “board-managed,” with a board of governors that works much like a corporate board. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407, subd. 1, “a limited liability company is a member-managed limited liability company unless the operating agreement” expressly provides for manager or board management, or uses words of similar import. In a member-managed LLC, “Each member has equal rights in the management and conduct of the company’s activities” (subd. 2). A manager-managed LLC, the third option, puts decisions in one or more managers instead.
In a board-managed LLC, subdivision 4 provides that “The activities and affairs of a limited liability company are to be managed by and under the direction of a board of governors, which shall consist of one or more governors as determined by members holding a majority of the voting power of the members.” “A governor must be a natural person. A person need not be a member to be a governor,” so an LLC can seat an outside governor. “A governor may be removed at any time, without cause and without advance notice, by a majority of the voting power of all of the members.” Some decisions stay with the owners: “The consent of all members is required to” sell substantially all of the company’s property outside the ordinary course (with two listed exceptions), approve a merger, conversion, or domestication, and amend the operating agreement.
Three changes follow the switch, each by default:
- The owners must agree to it. In a member-managed LLC, “The operating agreement may be amended only with the consent of all members” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 2), unless your agreement sets another amendment rule. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 2, “To the extent the operating agreement does not otherwise provide for a matter described in subdivision 1, this chapter governs the matter.”
- Fiduciary duties move to the governors. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 8, “Subdivisions 1, 2, 3, and 5 apply to the governors and not the members,” and “A member does not have any fiduciary duty to the company or to any other member solely by reason of being a member.”
- Owners’ information rights narrow. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410, subd. 2, the broad information rights of a member-managed LLC “apply to the managers or governors and not the members.” A member who is not a governor may then obtain full information about the company “as is just and reasonable if” the member meets three conditions. The member must seek the information “for a purpose material to the member’s interest as a member,” make a demand in a record received by the company “describing with reasonable particularity the information sought and the purpose for seeking the information,” and seek information “directly connected to the member’s purpose.”
An owner who will not sit on the board should weigh that third change before agreeing to it.
When Does an Owner-Run Company Need a Working Board?
No statute sets the moment, so the answer is a business judgment: a working board earns its cost when the company needs decisions made by people other than the managers who carry them out. A board is not the only answer. An advisory group gives outside judgment without giving up a vote. A regular owners’ meeting with written agendas can fix a communication problem. Outside general counsel gives an ongoing outside view of legal risk. These are situations where the need for a board can appear:
- An investor wants a seat. An outside investor may ask for a board seat as a condition of investing. Once that seat exists, the board stops being a formality, because the investor’s director votes on what the board decides.
- The founder steps back from daily management. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.305, subd. 2, the chief executive officer has, “Unless the articles, the bylaws, or a resolution adopted by the board and not inconsistent with the articles or bylaws, provide otherwise” (subd. 1), “general active management of the business of the corporation” and must “perform other duties prescribed by the board.” When the CEO is no longer the main owner, a board is how the owners direct and check that person.
- The owners deadlock. Two equal owners who disagree have no one to break the tie. An odd-numbered board with an independent director, or a tie-breaker director called in only for a deadlock, gives the company a way to decide.
- The company outgrows informal decisions. Larger contracts, debt, acquisitions, and a leadership bench can push decisions past what owners can sensibly decide informally.
Before adding a director, I suggest asking which of these needs you actually have, because under Minn. Stat. § 302A.207 a director “holds office for the term for which the director was elected and until a successor is elected and has qualified, or until the earlier death, resignation, removal, or disqualification of the director.”
What Is the Difference Between a Governing Board and an Advisory Board?
A governing board holds the corporation’s decision power, and its members owe director duties. An advisory board gives advice that the governing board is free to take or reject. The difference is authority. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.241, subd. 1, a resolution “approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors currently holding office” may give a committee the board’s authority “only to the extent provided in the resolution.” The committee’s members are then treated as directors for the duty, conflict, and indemnification statutes.
Committee members do not have to be directors: under § 302A.241, unless the articles or bylaws provide otherwise, “a committee shall consist of one or more persons, who need not be directors, appointed by affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present” (subd. 2). And under subdivision 7, “Committee members are deemed to be directors for purposes of sections 302A.251, 302A.255, and 302A.521,” which are the standard of conduct, the conflict-of-interest rule, and the indemnification rule.
An advisory group that only meets, discusses, and recommends leaves every decision with the board. A group that a resolution of a majority of the directors currently holding office gives the board’s authority to approve something is a committee, and its members carry director duties for it. Like board observers and advisors generally, an advisory group holds no formal vote, yet its members see sensitive company information. I suggest a written advisory agreement before the first meeting, covering confidentiality, conflicts, pay, and how the role ends, because that agreement records what each advisor has agreed to.
What Duties Will an Outside Director Owe Your Company?
An outside director of a Minnesota corporation owes the same statutory duties as any other director: good faith, a reasonable belief that the decision serves the corporation, and ordinary prudence. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 1, “A director shall discharge the duties of the position of director in good faith, in a manner the director reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances.”
Outside directors depend on management for information. Under subdivision 2, a director may rely on reports prepared or presented by officers or employees “whom the director reasonably believes to be reliable and competent in the matters presented,” or by “a committee of the board upon which the director does not serve, duly established in accordance with section 302A.241, as to matters within its designated authority, if the director reasonably believes the committee to merit confidence.” A director may also rely on “counsel, public accountants, or other persons as to matters that the director reasonably believes are within the person’s professional or expert competence.” The protection has a limit: “Paragraph (a) does not apply to a director who has knowledge concerning the matter in question that makes the reliance otherwise permitted by paragraph (a) unwarranted.”
Conflicts are handled by Minn. Stat. § 302A.255, subd. 1, which lists ways a deal between the company and a director avoids being void or voidable because of the director’s interest. One route is approval in good faith by a majority of the directors in office after the material facts are fully disclosed, with the interested director neither counted for the quorum nor voting. The statute reaches more than a deal with a director personally. It also covers a deal “between a corporation and an organization in or of which one or more of its directors are directors, officers, or legal representatives or have a material financial interest” (subd. 1). Under subdivision 2, a director has a material financial interest in each organization in which the director or the relatives listed there have a material financial interest. Subdivision 2 also provides that “a contract or other transaction between a corporation and the spouse, parents, children and spouses of children, brothers and sisters, spouses of brothers and sisters, and the brothers and sisters of the spouse of a director, or any combination of them, is considered to be a transaction between the corporation and the director.” The full set of routes, and how a director limits personal exposure, is covered in director fiduciary duties in Minnesota.
In a board-managed LLC, the governors carry the duties of loyalty and care (§ 322C.0409, subd. 8). Under § 322C.0409, subd. 3, the care standard applies “Subject to the business judgment rule.” Under § 322C.0110, subd. 4, the operating agreement may, “If not manifestly unreasonable,” “alter the duty of care, except to authorize intentional misconduct or knowing violation of law.”
What Protection Will an Outside Director Ask For?
A careful outside candidate may ask for three layers of protection before joining: a liability limit in the articles, indemnification from the company, and insurance. Minnesota law permits all three, and each has limits a candidate’s own lawyer may check. For a corporation, the liability limit sits in the articles, any limit on indemnification sits in the articles or bylaws, and the insurance is a policy the corporation buys. An LLC has parallel rules in chapter 322C, set out after the list.
- A liability limit in the articles. Under § 302A.251, subd. 4, “A director’s personal liability to the corporation or its shareholders for monetary damages for breach of fiduciary duty as a director may be eliminated or limited in the articles.” The articles cannot remove liability for a breach of the duty of loyalty, or for acts not in good faith, intentional misconduct, or a knowing violation of law. They also cannot remove liability under two other statutes the subdivision names, for a transaction giving the director an improper personal benefit, or “for any act or omission occurring prior to the date when the provision in the articles eliminating or limiting liability becomes effective.” That last limit is a reason to have the provision in effect before the director’s first vote, and adoption alone does not do that: under Minn. Stat. § 302A.153, “Articles of amendment are effective when filed with the secretary of state or at another time within 30 days after filing if the articles of amendment so provide.”
- Indemnification. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 2, “Subject to the provisions of subdivision 4, a corporation shall indemnify a person made or threatened to be made a party to a proceeding by reason of the former or present official capacity of the person,” if the person meets the subdivision’s conditions, which include acting in good faith and receiving no improper personal benefit. Subdivision 4 lets the articles or bylaws prohibit or condition indemnification and advances of expenses “if the prohibition or conditions apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class.” It also provides that “A prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances may not apply to or affect the right of a person to indemnification or advances of expenses with respect to any acts or omissions of the person occurring prior to the effective date of a provision in the articles or the date of adoption of a provision in the bylaws establishing the prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances.” A candidate will want to read both documents. The conditions, advances, and who decides eligibility are covered in indemnification of directors and officers.
- Insurance. Under subdivision 7, “A corporation may purchase and maintain insurance on behalf of a person in that person’s official capacity against any liability asserted against and incurred by the person in or arising from that capacity, whether or not the corporation would have been required to indemnify the person against the liability under the provisions of this section.” That last clause lets the corporation buy coverage for a loss the indemnification duty would not reach.
An LLC has parallel rules. Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 2, uses the same “shall indemnify” structure. Subdivision 7 says an LLC “may purchase and maintain insurance on behalf of a member, manager, or governor of the company.” The permission applies even where the operating agreement could not limit the person’s liability for the conduct, and whether or not the LLC would have been required to indemnify the person. Under § 322C.0110, subd. 7, “[t]he operating agreement may alter or eliminate the indemnification for a member, manager, or governor provided by section 322C.0408, subdivision 2, and may eliminate or limit a member’s, manager’s, or governor’s liability to the limited liability company and members for money damages, except for” five listed categories. They are a breach of the duty of loyalty, an improper financial benefit, and a breach of one other duty the subdivision names. The other two are intentional harm to the company or a member and an intentional violation of criminal law. Under § 322C.0408, subd. 4, a separate provision lets the articles of organization or the operating agreement prohibit or condition indemnification and advances of expenses “if the conditions apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class,” and provides that “A prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances may not apply to or affect the right of a person to indemnification or advances of expenses with respect to any acts or omissions of the person occurring before the effective date of a provision in the articles of organization, a member control agreement, or the date of adoption of a provision in the bylaws establishing the prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances.”
How Big Should the First Board Be, and Who Should Sit on It?
I suggest an odd number, such as three or five, for a first board, because an odd-numbered board with every seat filled and every director voting cannot split evenly, and a small board meets easily. I also suggest checking whether your corporation has cumulative voting before you pick a number, because board size decides whether a minority owner can elect a director.
Cumulative voting is on unless your articles turn it off. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.215, subd. 2, “Unless the articles provide that there shall be no cumulative voting, and except as provided in section 302A.223, subdivision 5, each shareholder entitled to vote for directors has the right to cumulate those votes in the election of directors by giving written notice of intent to cumulate those votes to any officer of the corporation before the meeting, or to the presiding officer at the meeting at which the election is to occur at any time before the election of directors at the meeting.” A shareholder who does so may vote “by casting for one candidate the number of votes equal to the number of directors to be elected multiplied by the number of votes represented by the shares,” or may spread those votes among candidates on the same principle. The more seats up for election, the smaller the share a minority owner needs to win one. Turning cumulative voting off later can be blocked: in a corporation that is not publicly held, no such amendment may be adopted “if the votes of a proportion of the voting power sufficient to elect a director at an election of the entire board under cumulative voting are cast against the amendment” (subd. 3).
Removal follows the same math. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.223, subd. 3, “any one or all of the directors may be removed at any time, with or without cause, by the affirmative vote of the holders of a majority of the voting power of all shares entitled to vote at an election of directors,” except that a director elected solely by a class or series of shares can be removed only by a majority of that class or series. With cumulative voting, “unless the entire board is removed simultaneously, a director is not removed from the board if there are cast against removal of the director the votes of a proportion of the voting power sufficient to elect the director at an election of the entire board under cumulative voting” (subd. 4). These removal rules “apply unless modified by the articles, the bylaws, or an agreement described in section 302A.457” (subd. 1).
The board’s control reaches the owner’s own office. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.341, subd. 2, “An officer may be removed at any time, with or without cause, by a resolution approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present,” and “A removal as described in this subdivision is subject to the provisions of a shareholder control agreement and is without prejudice to any contractual rights of the officer.” In a board-managed LLC, a person the board designates as CEO must “serve as an agent of the limited liability company at the will of the board, without prejudice to any rights the person may have under a contract with the limited liability company” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 4).
On who should sit, a first board can combine:
- The owners who run the business, who know it best.
- An investor’s designee, where an investment requires one.
- At least one independent director, someone with no stake and no family tie, whose vote can carry a disputed decision and counts toward approving a conflict transaction under § 302A.255 when the interested director cannot vote.
Two more choices go in the articles or bylaws. The articles of a corporation that is not publicly held “may confer upon one or more directors voting powers greater than or less than those of other directors,” but adding that after the initial articles “requires the approval of all of the shareholders entitled to vote on the amendment” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.237, subd. 2). The second choice is term length. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.207, “Unless fixed terms are provided for in the articles or bylaws, a director serves for an indefinite term that expires at the next regular meeting of the shareholders. A fixed term of a director shall not exceed five years.” Check the current text of § 302A.207 before relying on this limit.
How Do You Set Up a Board Step by Step?
Setting up a working board takes a governing-document change, an election, the protection documents, and a first meeting with minutes. The order matters because a liability limit in the articles cannot reach a director’s acts before it takes effect, so I suggest putting the protection documents in place before the new director’s first vote. For an LLC, the governing-document change is an amendment to the operating agreement rather than to articles or bylaws. For a Minnesota corporation, the steps run in this order:
-
Decide the structure. Choose the number of seats, who fills them, whether any seat belongs to a class of shares, and whether you also want an advisory group.
-
Amend the articles or bylaws. The number of directors is fixed in the articles or bylaws (§ 302A.203). Once shares are issued, an articles amendment such as the liability provision in step 3 goes to the shareholders. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.135, subd. 1, “Except as otherwise set forth in section 302A.133, after the issuance of shares by the corporation, the articles may be amended in the manner set forth in this section.” A board resolution, or a proposal by shareholders holding 3% or more of the voting power, that sets out the amendment “shall be submitted to a vote at the next regular or special meeting of the shareholders of which notice has not yet been given but still can be timely given” (subd. 2). “Written notice of the shareholders’ meeting setting forth the substance of the proposed amendment shall be given to each shareholder entitled to vote in the manner provided in section 302A.435 for the giving of notice of meetings of shareholders” (subd. 3). “The proposed amendment is adopted when approved by the affirmative vote of the shareholders required by section 302A.437, except as provided in paragraphs (b) and (c) and subdivision 5” (subd. 4); paragraphs (b) and (c) can require a larger vote where the articles set a larger proportion for a type of business.
The shareholders may instead act without a meeting. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.441, subd. 1, a shareholder action “may be taken without a meeting by written action signed, or consented to by authenticated electronic communication, by all of the shareholders entitled to vote on that action.” The articles of a corporation that is not publicly held “may provide that any action may be taken by written action signed, or consented to by authenticated electronic communication, by shareholders having voting power equal to the voting power that would be required to take the same action at a meeting of the shareholders at which all shareholders were present, but in no event may written action be taken by holders of less than a majority of the voting power of all shares entitled to vote on that action.” Adding that provision after the initial articles “requires the approval of all of the shareholders entitled to vote on the amendment.” Where the articles allow fewer signers, subdivision 3 adds a notice duty: “When written action is permitted to be taken by less than all shareholders, all shareholders who did not sign or consent to the written action must be notified of its text and effective time no later than five days after the effective time of the action. Failure to provide the notice does not invalidate the written action.” Check the current text of § 302A.441 before relying on this period.
For bylaws, Minn. Stat. § 302A.181, subd. 2, provides: “Unless reserved by the articles to the shareholders, the power to adopt, amend, or repeal the bylaws is vested in the board. The power of the board is subject to the power of the shareholders, exercisable in the manner provided in subdivision 3, to adopt, amend, or repeal bylaws adopted, amended, or repealed by the board.” Where the board holds that power, the same subdivision also says: “After the adoption of the initial bylaws, the board shall not adopt, amend, or repeal a bylaw fixing a quorum for meetings of shareholders, prescribing procedures for removing directors or filling vacancies in the board, or fixing the number of directors or their classifications, qualifications, or terms of office, but may adopt or amend a bylaw to increase the number of directors.” I suggest checking your articles before the board votes to add a seat, because the board’s bylaw power applies only where the articles have not reserved it to the shareholders. Under subdivision 1, “Bylaws may contain any provision relating to the management of the business or the regulation of the affairs of the corporation not inconsistent with section 302A.201 or any other provision of law or the articles.” So I also suggest checking whether your articles fix the number of directors, as § 302A.203 permits, because a bylaw increase may not be inconsistent with the articles. For a family company, see bylaws for a family-owned business.
-
Put protection in place. Have the shareholders approve the articles provision limiting director liability, as step 2 describes. Then I suggest filing it with the secretary of state early enough that it takes effect under § 302A.153 before the new director’s first vote, because the limit cannot reach acts before it takes effect. I also suggest confirming the indemnification terms in the articles and bylaws and binding the insurance before that vote, because a careful candidate may ask for both before joining.
-
Elect the directors. “Unless otherwise provided in the articles, directors are elected by a plurality of the voting power of the shares present and entitled to vote on the election of directors at a meeting at which a quorum is present” (§ 302A.215, subd. 1). If cumulative voting applies, a shareholder who wants to cumulate must first give written notice of intent to cumulate under subdivision 2.
-
Hold the first meeting. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.231, subd. 4, “Unless the articles or bylaws provide for a different time period, a director may call a board meeting by giving at least ten days’ notice or, in the case of organizational meetings pursuant to section 302A.171, subdivision 2, at least three days’ notice, to all directors of the date, time, and place of the meeting.” Check the current text of § 302A.231 before relying on these notice periods. No notice is needed for a meeting whose date, time, and place “have been provided in the articles or bylaws, or announced at a previous meeting of the board” (subd. 5), so adopting a yearly calendar at the first meeting saves later notices. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.235, “A majority, or a larger or smaller proportion or number provided in the articles or bylaws, of the directors currently holding office is a quorum for the transaction of business.” Between meetings, the board may act by written action under Minn. Stat. § 302A.239, subd. 1, signed, or consented to by authenticated electronic communication, by all of the directors. If the articles allow it, the board may instead act by the signatures of the number of directors “that would be required to take the same action at a meeting of the board at which all directors were present,” except for an action requiring shareholder approval. Under subdivision 3, “When written action is permitted to be taken by less than all directors, all directors shall be notified immediately of its text and effective date.”
-
Keep minutes. Minn. Stat. § 302A.461, subd. 2, requires the corporation to keep “records of all proceedings of the board for the last three years.” Check the current text of § 302A.461 before relying on this period. Under subdivision 4, a shareholder of a corporation that is not publicly held “has an absolute right, upon written demand, to examine and copy, in person or by a legal representative, at any reasonable time” those records, so an owner who is not on the board can read what the minutes say. A court may, on the corporation’s application, issue a protective order letting it withhold portions of the board’s records for a limited time “to prevent premature disclosure of confidential information which would be likely to cause competitive injury to the corporation” (subd. 4a). On content, see what board minutes should contain.
For an LLC, step 2 is an amendment to the operating agreement making the company board-managed, which by default needs every member’s consent (§ 322C.0407, subd. 2). After that, § 322C.0407, subd. 4, supplies default rules for electing governors, calling and noticing board meetings, quorum, and written action, to the extent the operating agreement does not provide otherwise (§ 322C.0110, subd. 2).
Can I be the only director of my Minnesota corporation?
Yes. Minnesota Statutes § 302A.203 says the board “shall consist of one or more directors,” so a one-person board is lawful. Under § 302A.205, a director must be a natural person, meaning an individual rather than a company or trust. The articles or bylaws fix the number and may add qualifications. A sole director can still bring in outside judgment through an advisory group without adding a vote.
Will adding outside directors mean I can be outvoted in my own company?
On ordinary board votes, yes. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.237, subd. 1, the board acts by “the greater of (1) a majority of directors present at a duly held meeting at the time the action is taken, or (2) a majority of the minimum proportion or number of directors that would constitute a quorum for the transaction of business at the meeting,” unless the chapter or the articles require more. That includes your job as an officer. The section above on sizing the first board quotes the officer-removal rule and its limits. It also quotes the rules on cumulative voting, director removal, and extra votes for a director, each of which can change an owner’s say on the board.
Do members of an advisory board owe my company fiduciary duties?
Not under Minnesota’s director-duty statute, unless the board makes them a committee. Minn. Stat. § 302A.251 binds directors, and § 302A.241, subd. 7, deems committee members “to be directors for purposes of sections 302A.251, 302A.255, and 302A.521,” even when they are not directors. An advisor outside both roles is not bound by that standard, so I suggest a written advisory agreement covering confidentiality and conflicts, because that document states what the advisor has agreed to.
May the board pay an outside director?
Yes, unless your articles or bylaws limit it. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.211, “Subject to any limitations in the articles or bylaws, the board may fix the compensation of directors.” Under § 302A.255, subd. 2, a resolution fixing a director’s compensation “is not void or voidable or considered to be a contract or other transaction between a corporation and one or more of its directors for purposes of this section,” even though the director being paid is present and voting. I suggest stating the pay in the board resolution, because that resolution is the record of what the board approved.
Must my company buy D&O insurance before an outside director joins?
Not under Minnesota’s corporation and LLC statutes, which make it optional. Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 7, says a corporation “may purchase and maintain insurance” covering a director’s liability in that role, whether or not the corporation would have been required to indemnify the director. Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 7, gives an LLC the same permission for its governors. An outside candidate may make directors and officers (D&O) coverage a condition of joining, so I suggest getting a quote before you make an offer, because the premium affects whether the seat is affordable.
Can the board make decisions without meeting in person?
Yes. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.231, subd. 3, a director may join a board meeting by conference telephone or, if the board authorizes it, other remote means “through which the director, other directors so participating, and all directors physically present at the meeting may participate with each other during the meeting.” Under subd. 2, a meeting may be held “solely by one or more means of remote communication through which all of the directors may participate with each other during the meeting, if the same notice is given of the meeting required by subdivision 4, and if the number of directors participating in the meeting is sufficient to constitute a quorum at a meeting.” The board may also act without meeting by written action under § 302A.239, whose signing and notice rules are quoted in step 5 of the setup steps above.
Choosing the Right Board for Your Company
Your Minnesota corporation already has a board, and your LLC can choose one. The decision in front of you is whether outsiders get a vote. An outside director fits when an investor, a leadership change, or a deadlock needs a decision-maker outside the owner group. An advisory group, a control agreement, or outside counsel fits when outside judgment is the need. Whatever you choose, I suggest having the liability limit, indemnification terms, and insurance in place before the first vote, because the articles limit cannot reach acts before it becomes effective. An articles amendment takes effect no earlier than its filing with the secretary of state (§ 302A.153). I also suggest keeping minutes, which shareholders of a corporation that is not publicly held can examine “upon written demand” and “at any reasonable time” (§ 302A.461, subd. 4). For the rest of the rules on how owners and boards share control, see company governance.
If you are weighing a board, outside directors, or an advisory group for your company, email [email protected] with a short description of the company and what prompted the question. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you share any confidential details.