A co-owner of your Minnesota company who started or joined a competing business has created a business partner dispute where timing matters. Customers, employees, and information can move to the new company while you decide what to do. Minnesota law answers the first question by entity type. The LLC and partnership statutes name a duty to refrain from competing with the company. In a member-managed LLC that duty binds each member, and in a general partnership it binds each partner. In a manager-managed LLC it applies “to the manager or managers and not the members”; in a board-managed LLC it applies “to the governors and not the members” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subds. 7 and 8). In a corporation, directors and officers must act in good faith and in the corporation’s best interests. A court deciding whether to order relief under the shareholder-remedies statute must also consider the duty shareholders of a closely held corporation owe one another to act in an honest, fair, and reasonable manner. Your operating agreement or shareholder agreement can change these defaults, so I suggest reading it before you act, because its terms may decide whether the rival business is a breach at all.
What Duty Stops a Co-Owner From Competing With the Company?
In a member-managed Minnesota LLC, each member owes the company a duty “to refrain from competing with the company in the conduct of the company’s activities before the dissolution of the company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 2). A general partner owes the same duty to the partnership. An owner’s dissociation changes this: “A person has the power to dissociate as a member at any time, rightfully or wrongfully, by withdrawing as a member by express will under section 322C.0602, clause (1)” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0601, subd. 1); when that happens, “if the company is member-managed, the person’s fiduciary duties as a member end with regard to matters arising and events occurring after the person’s dissociation” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0603, subd. 1); and upon a partner’s dissociation, “the partner’s duty of loyalty under section 323A.0404(b)(3) terminates” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0603(b)(2)). In a corporation, the statute states the standard for directors and officers in general terms. A separate provision tells a court what to consider about shareholders of a closely held corporation when it decides whether to order relief. Who owes the duty depends on how your company is organized. “Except as provided in section 322C.1101, subdivision 5, with respect to nonprofit limited liability companies, a limited liability company is a member-managed limited liability company unless the operating agreement” expressly provides that the company is or will be “manager-managed” or “board-managed,” “managed by managers” or “managed by a board,” or that management is or will be “vested in managers” or “vested in a board,” or “includes words of similar import” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407, subd. 1). The rules for each form are these:
- Member-managed LLC. A member owes “the fiduciary duties of loyalty and care” to the company and, subject to a limit on members’ direct claims, to the other members (§ 322C.0409, subd. 1). The loyalty duty also requires a member “to account to the company and to hold as trustee for it any property, profit, or benefit derived by the member,” including benefit “from a use by the member of the company’s property” or “from the appropriation of a limited liability company opportunity” (subd. 2).
- Manager-managed or board-managed LLC. The loyalty duties “apply to the manager or managers and not the members” (subd. 7), or to “the governors and not the members” (subd. 8). In these companies, the duty not to compete “continues until winding up is completed,” and “A member does not have any fiduciary duty to the company or to any other member solely by reason of being a member” (subds. 7 and 8). Every member still owes the contractual obligation of good faith and fair dealing, “including acting in a manner, in light of the operating agreement, that is honest, fair, and reasonable” (subd. 4).
- General partnership. A partner’s duty of loyalty includes the duty “to refrain from competing with the partnership in the conduct of the partnership business before the dissolution of the partnership” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0404(b)). The same section also provides: “A partner does not violate a duty or obligation under this chapter or under the partnership agreement merely because the partner’s conduct furthers the partner’s own interest” (§ 323A.0404(e)).
- Corporation. “A director shall discharge the duties of the position of director in good faith, in a manner the director reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 1). Officers are held to the same standard (Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 1). Under the shareholder-remedies statute, “In determining whether to order equitable relief, dissolution, or a buy-out, the court shall take into consideration the duty which all shareholders in a closely held corporation owe one another to act in an honest, fair, and reasonable manner in the operation of the corporation,” along with “the reasonable expectations of all shareholders as they exist at the inception and develop during the course of the shareholders’ relationship with the corporation and with each other” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 3a).
How these duties work in an LLC generally is covered in fiduciary duties in an LLC. When your partner diverted a specific deal rather than opening a rival business, the closer rule is the one on taking a corporate opportunity.
How Can Your Operating Agreement or Shareholder Agreement Change the Rule?
In an LLC, “Except as otherwise provided in subdivisions 2 and 3, the operating agreement governs” the members’ relations with one another and with the company (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 1), and “To the extent the operating agreement does not otherwise provide for a matter described in subdivision 1, this chapter governs the matter” (subd. 2). Subdivision 3 then lists what “An operating agreement may not” do. An operating agreement may narrow or remove the duty not to compete, within limits a court enforces. A partnership agreement and corporate articles have their own limits. Before you accuse your partner of breaching a duty, I suggest reading every governing document for these terms, because one sentence there can decide whether the competing business is a breach at all:
- What an operating agreement may do. “If not manifestly unreasonable, and without limiting the terms that may be included in an operating agreement, the operating agreement may” restrict or eliminate the duty “to refrain from competing with the company in the conduct of the company’s business before the dissolution of the company,” or “identify specific types or categories of activities that do not violate the duty of loyalty” (§ 322C.0110, subd. 4). “The court shall decide any claim under subdivision 4 that a term of an operating agreement is manifestly unreasonable” (subd. 8). The court judges the term as of when it was adopted. It may strike the term only if it is “readily apparent” that its objective is unreasonable or that it is an unreasonable means to that objective (subd. 8).
- What an operating agreement may not do. It may not, “subject to subdivisions 4 to 7, eliminate the duty of loyalty, the duty of care, or any other fiduciary duty” (subd. 3). An agreement that limits money damages for owners cannot reach “breach of the duty of loyalty” (subd. 7).
- Partnership agreements. A partnership agreement may not “eliminate the duty of loyalty under section 323A.0404(b) or 323A.0603(b)(3),” and may not “eliminate the obligation of good faith and fair dealing under section 323A.0404(d)” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0103(b)). It may identify permitted categories of activities in the same words the LLC statute uses, “if not manifestly unreasonable,” and it may let the partners approve a specific act “after full disclosure of all material facts” (§ 323A.0103(b)(3)).
- Corporations. Articles that limit a director’s personal liability cannot do so “for any breach of the director’s duty of loyalty to the corporation or its shareholders” (§ 302A.251, subd. 4). Written shareholder agreements, “including employment agreements and buy-sell agreements,” are “presumed to reflect the parties’ reasonable expectations concerning matters dealt with in the agreements” (§ 302A.751, subd. 3a).
When Does Preparing to Compete Cross the Line?
For an employee, preparing crosses the line when it becomes soliciting the employer’s customers or otherwise competing while still employed. The Minnesota Court of Appeals, citing an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision, stated the rule: “An employee’s duty of loyalty prohibits her from soliciting the employer’s customers for herself, or from otherwise competing with her employer, while she is employed.” The court added: “An employee has the right, therefore, while still employed, to prepare to enter into competition with her employer” (Rehabilitation Specialists, Inc. v. Koering, 404 N.W.2d 301 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987)).
The case involved an administrator who had no written employment contract and had not signed a covenant not to compete. Before leaving, she filed corporate documents for her new business, met with a bank, and applied for insurance. She also told a vice-president of one of the employer’s major customers that “she was thinking about beginning her own business and inquired about possible opportunities for contracting for new business,” and she tentatively secured five contracts from him. The trial court granted her summary judgment, and the Court of Appeals reversed and sent the case to trial, holding: “Whether an employee’s actions constituted a breach of her duty of loyalty is a question of fact to be determined based on all the circumstances of the case.” The court also held that the employer’s lack of existing contracts with those five facilities did not rule out a finding of disloyal competition, because the customer was the employer’s.
For an employee, the line in Koering ran between steps that set up a new business and steps that take business from the employer. The court held: “We believe a fact issue exists as to whether her conduct crossed the line from preparation to solicitation.” It pointed to her dealings with the employer’s customer: what she told him about her plans, the five contracts she tentatively secured, and the draft contracts she sent. Koering was an employee, not an owner; for an LLC member or partner, the statutes quoted in the section on the duty not to compete set the owner’s duty in their own words.
What Can a Noncompete or Nonsolicitation Term Among Owners Still Do?
Minnesota voids covenants not to compete, with exceptions that matter to owners. The statute provides that a covenant not to compete “means an agreement between an employee and employer that restricts the employee, after termination of the employment, from performing: (1) work for another employer for a specified period of time; (2) work in a specified geographical area; or (3) work for another employer in a capacity that is similar to the employee’s work for the employer that is party to the agreement,” and it provides: “Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable” (Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subds. 1 and 2). Terms that survive include nonsolicitation and nondisclosure agreements, and, on the statute’s conditions, covenants made in a sale or dissolution of a business. Three points matter for co-owners:
- The ban reaches employment relationships. The statute’s definition of employee covers “any individual who performs services for an employer, including independent contractors” (§ 181.988, subd. 1). A co-owner who also works for the company can fall within that definition. The ban reaches agreements made on or after July 1, 2023, because the session law provides, “This section is effective July 1, 2023, and applies to contracts and agreements entered into on or after that date” (2023 Minn. Laws ch. 53, art. 6, sec. 1).
- Other restrictions survive. “A covenant not to compete does not include a nonsolicitation agreement, or agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists, or solicit customers of the employer.” Nor does it include “a nondisclosure agreement, or agreement designed to protect trade secrets or confidential information” (subd. 1).
- Owner exits have their own exceptions. “Notwithstanding paragraph (a), a covenant not to compete is valid and enforceable if” one of two conditions is met (subd. 2(b)). The first: “the covenant not to compete is agreed upon during the sale of a business. The person selling the business and the partners, members, or shareholders, and the buyer of the business may agree on a temporary and geographically restricted covenant not to compete that will prohibit the seller of the business from carrying on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time” (subd. 2(b)(1)). The second: “the covenant not to compete is agreed upon in anticipation of the dissolution of a business. The partners, members, or shareholders, upon or in anticipation of a dissolution of a partnership, limited liability company, or corporation may agree that all or any number of the parties will not carry on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area where the business has been transacted” (subd. 2(b)(2)).
While your partner is still a member, manager, governor, or partner, the fiduciary duties described in the section on the duty not to compete apply to the owners that section names. In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, a member owes no fiduciary duty “solely by reason of being a member” (§ 322C.0409, subds. 7 and 8). A covenant addresses what happens after an owner leaves. Leaving does not erase what happened before: in an LLC, a member’s dissociation “does not of itself discharge the person from any debt, obligation, or other liability to the company or the other members that the person incurred while a member” (§ 322C.0603, subd. 2), and “A person’s ceasing to be a manager does not discharge any debt, obligation, or other liability to the limited liability company or members which the person incurred while a manager” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 3), with the same rule for a governor (subd. 4). More on the statute is in Minnesota noncompete agreements.
How Does Minnesota Protect Customer Lists and Other Trade Secrets?
A customer list, pricing model, or process can be a trade secret under the Minnesota Uniform Trade Secrets Act if it meets two conditions. The information, “including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process,” must derive “independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known to, and not being readily ascertainable by proper means by, other persons who can obtain economic value from its disclosure or use, and” must be “the subject of efforts that are reasonable under the circumstances to maintain its secrecy” (Minn. Stat. § 325C.01, subd. 5). The statute’s remedies run for “misappropriation,” which includes “acquisition of a trade secret of another by a person who knows or has reason to know that the trade secret was acquired by improper means” and “disclosure or use of a trade secret of another without express or implied consent” by a person in one of the circumstances subdivision 3 lists (subd. 3). If your partner’s taking of that information to the new company meets that definition, the statute gives these remedies:
- Injunction. “Actual or threatened misappropriation may be enjoined” (Minn. Stat. § 325C.02).
- Damages. “Damages can include both the actual loss caused by misappropriation and the unjust enrichment caused by misappropriation that is not taken into account in computing actual loss” (Minn. Stat. § 325C.03).
- Attorney fees, both directions. The court may award reasonable attorney’s fees to the prevailing party if “(i) a claim of misappropriation is made in bad faith, (ii) a motion to terminate an injunction is made or resisted in bad faith, or (iii) willful and malicious misappropriation exists” (Minn. Stat. § 325C.04). So when “a claim of misappropriation is made in bad faith,” the owner who brings it can be ordered to pay fees if the other side prevails.
Federal law runs alongside. Under the Defend Trade Secrets Act, “An owner of a trade secret that is misappropriated may bring a civil action under this subsection if the trade secret is related to a product or service used in, or intended for use in, interstate or foreign commerce” (18 U.S.C. § 1836(b)(1)). A federal injunction may not “otherwise conflict with an applicable State law prohibiting restraints on the practice of a lawful profession, trade, or business” (§ 1836(b)(3)). The state statute itself is explained in the Minnesota Uniform Trade Secrets Act guide.
A trade secret claim has a statutory deadline. Under Minnesota law, “An action for misappropriation must be brought within three years after the misappropriation is discovered or by the exercise of reasonable diligence should have been discovered. For the purposes of this section, a continuing misappropriation constitutes a single claim” (Minn. Stat. § 325C.06). Under federal law, “A civil action under subsection (b) may not be commenced later than 3 years after the date on which the misappropriation with respect to which the action would relate is discovered or by the exercise of reasonable diligence should have been discovered. For purposes of this subsection, a continuing misappropriation constitutes a single claim of misappropriation” (18 U.S.C. § 1836(d)). Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.
How Do You Gather Evidence Without Escalating the Dispute?
I suggest starting with the company records you are entitled to as an owner and asking for them in writing, because the records statutes tie several of those rights to notice or a written demand. The LLC rules are in Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410, and the corporate rules are in Minn. Stat. § 302A.461. Each right has conditions, explained in gathering evidence in a co-owner dispute. For a competing business, the useful records can include the customer list and sales history, recent invoices, the company’s email and file-sharing logs, and payments to vendors the new company also uses. In a corporation that is not a publicly held corporation, a shareholder “has a right, upon written demand, to examine and copy, in person or by a legal representative, other corporate records at any reasonable time only if the shareholder, beneficial owner, or holder of a voting trust certificate demonstrates a proper purpose for the examination” (§ 302A.461, subd. 4(b)), and under the statute a proper purpose “is one reasonably related to the person’s interest as a shareholder, beneficial owner, or holder of a voting trust certificate of the corporation” (subd. 4(d)).
I suggest preserving what the company already holds before anyone confronts your partner, because a confrontation can prompt deletions.
For information an LLC furnishes to a member under § 322C.0410, “In addition to any restriction or condition stated in its operating agreement, a limited liability company, as a matter within the ordinary course of its activities, may impose reasonable restrictions and conditions on access to and use of information to be furnished under this section, including designating information confidential and imposing nondisclosure and safeguarding obligations on the recipient,” and “In a dispute concerning the reasonableness of a restriction under this subdivision, the company has the burden of proving reasonableness” (subd. 7). Who decides for the company depends on its management. In a member-managed LLC, “Each member has equal rights in the management and conduct of the company’s activities” and “A difference arising among members as to a matter in the ordinary course of the activities of the company may be decided by a majority of the members” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 2). In a manager-managed LLC, “Except as otherwise expressly provided in this chapter, any matter relating to the activities of the company is decided exclusively by the managers” (subd. 3). In a board-managed LLC, the company’s activities “are to be managed by and under the direction of a board of governors” (subd. 4).
What Remedies Can a Minnesota Court Order?
A court can stop the competition while the case proceeds, “upon the giving of security by the applicant” (Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.03), award money, and in some cases remove the competing owner or order a buyout. Which remedy fits depends on the entity, on who controls it, and on what your partner took. The LLC statute provides for judicial expulsion of a member, court dissolution or a fair-value buyout, and direct or derivative claims. A court may expel a general partner or determine that a partnership must be dissolved. A shareholder may seek equitable relief, dissolution, or a court-ordered sale of shares, and the trade secret statute adds an injunction and damages. The main remedies are these:
-
A temporary injunction. In reviewing a temporary injunction, the Minnesota Supreme Court weighed five considerations. They begin with “The nature and background of the relationship between the parties preexisting the dispute giving rise to the request for relief,” the harm to each side if the order is granted or denied before trial, and “The likelihood that one party or the other will prevail on the merits” (Dahlberg Bros., Inc. v. Ford Motor Co., 137 N.W.2d 314 (Minn. 1965)). The case arose from a carmaker’s termination of a dealer’s franchise, and the court affirmed the injunction. For trade secrets, § 325C.02 adds its own injunction remedy. Two court-rule steps apply. “No temporary injunction shall be granted without notice of motion or an order to show cause to the adverse party” (Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.02). “No temporary restraining order or temporary injunction shall be granted except upon the giving of security by the applicant, in such sum as the court deems proper, for the payment of such costs and damages as may be incurred or suffered by any party who is found to have been wrongfully enjoined or restrained” (Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.03).
-
Turning over profits. In a member-managed LLC, a member owes a duty to hold as trustee any profit derived “from a use by the member of the company’s property” or from appropriating a company opportunity (§ 322C.0409, subd. 2). In a manager-managed LLC that duty falls on the managers, and in a board-managed LLC on the governors (subds. 7 and 8). A general partner owes a parallel duty “to account to the partnership and hold as trustee for it any property, profit, or benefit derived by the partner in the conduct and winding up of the partnership business or derived from a use by the partner of partnership property, including the appropriation of a partnership opportunity” (§ 323A.0404(b)(1)). If your partner built the new business on company property, the claim can reach that profit.
-
Expelling the competing owner. An LLC member can be expelled under the operating agreement if it provides for expulsion, or, “on application by the company,” by judicial order where the member, among other grounds, “has willfully or persistently committed, or is willfully and persistently committing, a material breach of the operating agreement or the person’s duties or obligations under section 322C.0409” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0602). A judicial expulsion before the company terminates is a wrongful dissociation, and “A person that wrongfully dissociates as a member is liable to the limited liability company and, subject to section 322C.0901, to the other members for damages caused by the dissociation” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0601, subd. 3). On application by the partnership or another partner, a court may expel a partner on the same kind of ground: where “the partner willfully or persistently committed a material breach of the partnership agreement or of a duty owed to the partnership or the other partners under section 323A.0404” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0601(5)). Expulsion is a dissociation (§ 322C.0602, clauses (3) and (5); § 323A.0601(3) and (5)), so the dissociation rules quoted in the section on the duty not to compete apply to it. In a member-managed LLC, the expelled member’s fiduciary duties as a member end for “matters arising and events occurring after the person’s dissociation” (§ 322C.0603, subd. 1), and for an expelled partner, “the partner’s duty of loyalty under section 323A.0404(b)(3) terminates” (§ 323A.0603(b)(2)). The dissociation does not of itself discharge a liability the member incurred while a member (§ 322C.0603, subd. 2), as the noncompete section quotes.
-
Ending a general partnership. A partnership “is dissolved, and its business must be wound up,” on events that include, “in a partnership at will, the partnership’s having notice from a partner, other than a partner who is dissociated under section 323A.0601(2) to (10), of that partner’s express will to withdraw as a partner, or on a later date specified by the partner,” and, “on application by a partner, a judicial determination that,” among its grounds, “another partner has engaged in conduct relating to the partnership business which makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in partnership with that partner” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0801(1), (5)).
-
Court relief and a buyout in a corporation. In a shareholder’s action, “A court may grant any equitable relief it deems just and reasonable in the circumstances or may dissolve a corporation and liquidate its assets and business” on grounds that include conduct by “the directors or those in control” that is “unfairly prejudicial toward one or more shareholders” and a board deadlock the shareholders “are unable to break” (§ 302A.751, subd. 1). Once a ground is established, the court may “order the sale by a plaintiff or a defendant of all shares of the corporation held by the plaintiff or defendant to either the corporation or the moving shareholders” if it finds the order “would be fair and equitable to all parties under all of the circumstances of the case” (subd. 2). If a buy-sell agreement or similar document already sets a price, “the court shall order the sale for the price and on the terms set forth in them, unless the court determines that the price or terms are unreasonable under all the circumstances of the case” (subd. 2). If the parties cannot agree on fair value “within 40 days of entry of the order,” the court determines it (subd. 2). A party who acts “arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith” can be ordered to pay the others’ “reasonable expenses, including attorneys’ fees and disbursements” (subd. 4).
In a case where minority shareholders of a closely held corporation alleged that the majority shareholder misappropriated and wasted corporate assets, the Minnesota Supreme Court, citing an earlier decision, stated: “Where the injury is to the corporation, and only indirectly harms the shareholder, the claim must be pursued as a derivative claim.” It held “that despite the smaller number of shareholders in a closely held corporation, such shareholders are still subject to the derivative pleading requirements,” and that the shareholders’ claims, though pleaded under § 302A.751, “are traditional derivative claims subject to the derivative pleading requirements”; it reinstated the trial court’s dismissal of those claims without prejudice (Wessin v. Archives Corp., 592 N.W.2d 460 (Minn. 1999)).
-
Dissolution or a buyout in an LLC. The ground below can reach a competing owner who is a manager or governor, or a member in control of the company. A member may ask a court to dissolve the LLC on grounds that include that “the managers, governors, or those members in control of the company” have acted or are acting “in a manner that is oppressive and was, is, or will be directly harmful to the applicant” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0701, subd. 1). The court may instead order “the sale for fair value of all membership interests a member owns in a limited liability company to the limited liability company or one or more of the other members” (subd. 2). That proceeding must be brought in a court in the county where the company’s registered office is located (subd. 3). “Oppressive” is a defined term that looks to conduct by one or more “members in a member-managed limited liability company or who are otherwise in control of any limited liability company,” “managers in a manager-managed limited liability company,” or “governors of a board-managed limited liability company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0102, subd. 18). The conduct must also frustrate a reasonable expectation that, among other conditions, “was material to the applicant’s decision to become a member of the limited liability company or for a substantial time has been material during the member’s continuing membership” (subd. 18). Separately, and with no control requirement, any member may apply for dissolution on the ground that “it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the company’s activities in conformity with the articles of organization and the operating agreement” (§ 322C.0701, subd. 1).
-
A claim for the company or for you. A member suing in the member’s own name “must plead and prove an actual or threatened injury that is not solely the result of an injury suffered or threatened to be suffered by the limited liability company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0901, subd. 2). Otherwise the claim belongs to the company, and a member may bring a derivative lawsuit after a demand if the others do not act “within a reasonable time,” or without one if “a demand under clause (1) would be futile” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0902). Except as subdivision 2 provides when a sole plaintiff dies, “a derivative action under section 322C.0902 may be maintained only by a person that is a member at the time the action is commenced and remains a member while the action continues” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0903, subd. 1), and “the complaint must state with particularity: (1) the date and content of the plaintiff’s demand and the response to the demand by the other members, managers, or board of governors; or (2) if a demand has not been made, the reasons a demand under section 322C.0902, clause (1), would be futile” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0904). Any recovery in a derivative action, by judgment or settlement, will “belong to the limited liability company and not to the plaintiff” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0906, subd. 1). If the action succeeds in whole or in part, the court may award the plaintiff “reasonable expenses, including reasonable attorney fees and costs, from the recovery of the limited liability company” (subd. 2).
The claims resting on the duties in § 322C.0409, § 323A.0404, § 302A.251, and § 302A.361 are claims for breach of fiduciary duty, and that page covers what an owner must prove. If your partner also moved company money into the new business, the added claims are covered in a business partner taking company money.
What Are Your Options Before Anyone Files a Lawsuit?
An agreement can resolve a competing-owner dispute at any stage, and the right first move depends on what you want: your partner out, the competition stopped, or a fair price for your own exit. A lawsuit is one tool among several. An agreed path can include approving the venture on the record, a negotiated buyout, or a mediated settlement, and the owners set the terms of each. These are the realistic options, with when each fits and its risk:
- A direct owner-to-owner conversation. This fits when the relationship still works and the new business may be a misunderstanding about what the owners allowed. The risk is timing: it tells your partner what you know, so I suggest preserving company records first.
- Approving the venture on the record. If the owners can live with the new business, they can approve it with conditions. In an LLC, “All of the members of a member-managed limited liability company or a manager-managed limited liability company may authorize or ratify, after full disclosure of all material facts, a specific act or transaction that otherwise would violate the duty of loyalty” (§ 322C.0409, subd. 6). In a board-managed LLC, subdivision 8 provides that this approval rule “applies only to the members,” so the members give it, not the board. In a partnership, “all of the partners or a number or percentage specified in the partnership agreement may authorize or ratify, after full disclosure of all material facts, a specific act or transaction that otherwise would violate the duty of loyalty” (§ 323A.0103(b)). Approval fits when the businesses can coexist; its risk is that it gives up a claim for what came before.
- A negotiated buyout. One owner buys out the other, with a business appraiser setting a value both sides can test. Where the buyout is a sale of a business, the seller, its owners, and the buyer may agree on “a temporary and geographically restricted covenant not to compete,” on the conditions of § 181.988 quoted in the noncompete section. This fits when the owners no longer want to work together.
- Mediation. A mediator helps the owners negotiate; the deal is only what the owners sign. It fits when both want an end but cannot agree on terms.
- A demand letter. A letter stating the duty, the conduct, and what must stop, with a date, can set the terms of a negotiation. Its risk is that it can harden positions if it promises a lawsuit the owner is not ready to bring.
- Removing your partner from management. Where you hold the votes, removal needs no court. In an LLC, “A manager may be removed at any time by the consent of a majority of the members without notice or cause,” and “A governor may be removed at any time, without cause and without advance notice, by a majority of the voting power of all of the members” (§ 322C.0407, subds. 3 and 4). In a corporation, “The provisions of this section apply unless modified by the articles, the bylaws, or an agreement described in section 302A.457,” and, subject to exceptions for directors elected by one class or series of shares and for cumulative voting, “any one or all of the directors may be removed at any time, with or without cause, by the affirmative vote of the holders of a majority of the voting power of all shares entitled to vote at an election of directors” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.223, subds. 1, 3, and 4). “An officer may be removed at any time, with or without cause, by a resolution approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present,” and the removal “is subject to the provisions of a shareholder control agreement and is without prejudice to any contractual rights of the officer” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.341, subd. 2). Removal from management does not end an LLC owner’s membership: “If a person that is both a manager and a member ceases to be a manager, that cessation does not by itself dissociate the person as a member” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 3), and the same holds for a governor (subd. 4).
If the competing owner controls the company or refuses to talk, the court remedies above become the realistic route.
Can my partner compete if our operating agreement says nothing about it?
It depends on how the LLC is managed and on whether your partner is still a member. Where the operating agreement is silent, the statute “governs the matter” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 2). The section of this page on the duty not to compete quotes the statute’s rules (Minn. Stat. §§ 322C.0407, 322C.0409, and 322C.0603). They cover when an LLC counts as member-managed, who owes the duty in each type of LLC, and when a member’s leaving ends it.
Is there a deadline to sue a co-owner who started a competing business?
Yes, and each claim has its own. For a trade secret claim, Minn. Stat. § 325C.06 provides: “An action for misappropriation must be brought within three years after the misappropriation is discovered or by the exercise of reasonable diligence should have been discovered. For the purposes of this section, a continuing misappropriation constitutes a single claim.” Under the federal statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1836(d): “A civil action under subsection (b) may not be commenced later than 3 years after the date on which the misappropriation with respect to which the action would relate is discovered or by the exercise of reasonable diligence should have been discovered. For purposes of this subsection, a continuing misappropriation constitutes a single claim of misappropriation.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.
Can we settle it through mediation instead of court?
Yes. The owners can settle by agreement at any point, with a mediator’s help. A settlement can approve the venture on the record or set the terms of an exit, such as a buyout. What the owners must do to approve the venture differs by entity type (Minn. Stat. §§ 322C.0409 and 323A.0103). A covenant not to compete in a sale of a business must meet the conditions of Minn. Stat. § 181.988. The options section and the noncompete section of this page quote both rules.
Does a minority shareholder who does not work in the business owe this duty?
Yes, in a Minnesota closely held corporation. Minn. Stat. § 302A.751 refers to “the duty which all shareholders in a closely held corporation owe one another to act in an honest, fair, and reasonable manner in the operation of the corporation,” and a court deciding whether to order relief under that section must consider it. Its conduct grounds for relief include that “the directors or those in control of the corporation have acted in a manner unfairly prejudicial toward one or more shareholders.” Whether a rival business breaks the duty turns on the facts and on any written shareholder agreement, which the statute presumes reflects “the parties’ reasonable expectations concerning matters dealt with in the agreements.”
Should I cut off my partner's access to company systems?
It depends on who makes the company’s ordinary-course decisions and on what the access covers. In an LLC, the records statute (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410) and the management statute (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407) govern those points; in a corporation, Minn. Stat. § 302A.461 sets shareholders’ inspection rights. The section of this page on gathering evidence quotes the LLC rules on restricting a member’s access to company information and on who decides for the company.
A Co-Owner Competing With Your Minnesota Company
Your rights turn on your written agreement and on the statute for your entity type, which says what that agreement may and may not change. An LLC member in a member-managed company, an LLC manager or governor, and a general partner owe a stated duty not to compete. For a member of a member-managed LLC and for a general partner, the statutes end that duty for matters after the owner’s dissociation, as the section on that duty quotes. Corporate directors and officers must act in good faith and in the corporation’s best interests. For closely held shareholders, a court deciding on relief considers the duty they owe one another to act in an honest, fair, and reasonable manner. I suggest reading the agreement, preserving the company’s records, and then choosing between an agreed path and a court remedy, because the evidence you hold shapes each option that follows. More on these disputes is on my ownership disputes page.
If a co-owner of your Minnesota company started or joined a competing business, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.