You can contest a beneficiary change in Minnesota on several grounds. They include your parent’s lack of mental capacity, another person’s undue influence, and a change signed by an agent who had no authority to make it. A capacity or undue influence claim is decided on evidence of what happened when the form was signed, and in the decisions discussed below the other side included the person named by the change. Other routes include the divorce statute, a will that names the account, and, for life insurance, a letter that clearly shows the insured’s intent where the insured also made affirmative efforts to make the change. For a bank account or a security registered in beneficiary form, Minnesota statutes say what a written notice of the dispute does. Its effect depends on who gives the notice and whether the institution receives it before it pays.
Three bodies of law apply. Minnesota statutes define how these assets pass, limit what an agent under a power of attorney or a conservator may do, and revoke a former spouse’s designation on divorce. The standards for mental capacity and undue influence come from Minnesota Supreme Court decisions, including decisions from 1925 and 1938. A federal statute, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), limits state law for employer plans. This article is written for an adult child or other family member whose parent’s life insurance, retirement account, or payable-on-death designation was changed shortly before death. For how I handle these disputes, see my trust and estate litigation page.
What Is a Beneficiary Designation, and Why Does It Pass Outside the Will?
A beneficiary designation is an instruction in your parent’s contract with an insurer, bank, brokerage, or retirement plan that names who receives the asset at death. It takes effect under that contract and the statutes below, which is why a will dividing the estate equally can leave the insurance or the account with one person. For a payable-on-death account or a security registered in beneficiary form, a will that makes a “specific reference” to the account or security can change the result.
Minnesota has a separate statute for each kind of asset:
- Life insurance. Under Minn. Stat. § 61A.12, subdivision 1, “When any insurance is effected in favor of another, the beneficiary shall be entitled to its proceeds against the creditors and representatives of the person effecting the same.” The same subdivision has a separate rule for premiums paid in fraud of creditors.
- Payable-on-death (P.O.D.) accounts. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.6-204, paragraph (b), “If the account is a P.O.D. account, on the death of the original party or of the survivor of two or more original parties, any sums remaining on deposit belong to the P.O.D. payees if surviving, or to the survivor of them if one or more die before the surviving original party.” Under Minn. Stat. § 524.6-206, these transfers “are not to be considered as subject to probate except as to the transfers expressly changed by will, as provided for by section 524.6-204, clause (d).” Under Minn. Stat. § 524.6-205, “The provisions of section 524.6-204 as to rights of survivorship are determined by the form of the account at the death of a party,” and a written order changing that form “must be signed by a party and received by the financial institution during the party’s lifetime.”
- Transfer-on-death (TOD) securities. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.6-309, subdivision 1, “A transfer on death resulting from a registration in beneficiary form is effective by reason of the contract regarding the registration between the owner and the registering entity and sections 524.6-301 to 524.6-311 and is not testamentary.”
For two of these assets, a will can change the result if it names the asset. Under § 524.6-204, paragraph (d), “A right of survivorship arising from the express terms of the account, or under this section, or under a P.O.D. payee designation, may be changed by specific reference by will, but the terms of such will shall not be binding upon any financial institution unless it has been given a notice in writing of a claim thereunder, in which event the deposit shall remain undisbursed until an order has been made by the probate court adjudicating the decedent’s interest disposable by will.”
Under § 524.6-309, subdivision 2, securities have a similar rule: “A registration in beneficiary form may be canceled by specific reference to the security or the securities account in the will of the sole owner or the last to die of multiple owners, but the terms of the revocation are not binding on the registering entity unless it has received written notice from any claimant to an interest in the security objecting to implementation of a registration in beneficiary form prior to the registering entity reregistering the security.”
I suggest reading your parent’s will for a sentence that names the specific account, because both statutes require a “specific reference” in the will. Written notice has a separate role. Under § 524.6-204, paragraph (d), the will’s terms are not “binding upon any financial institution unless it has been given a notice in writing” of a claim under the will, and § 524.6-309, subdivision 2, sets a parallel written-notice condition for the registering entity. A joint account with a right of survivorship follows its own rules, covered in what happens to a joint bank account after a parent dies.
What Grounds Can Set Aside a Beneficiary Change in Minnesota?
Minnesota decisions and statutes recognize several grounds for setting aside a beneficiary change, including lack of mental capacity, undue influence, and an agent or conservator acting outside the authority the law gives them. Divorce works differently: a statute revokes a former spouse’s designation without a court finding, subject to the statute’s exceptions. ERISA has its own rule for an employer plan it governs: under 29 U.S.C. § 1104, subsection (a)(1)(D), the plan’s fiduciary must act “in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the plan.” A federal appeals court applying Minnesota law has also let a claim of unjust enrichment proceed against a person a retirement plan had paid. Each has its own source:
- Lack of mental capacity. The Minnesota Supreme Court applied the standard for contracts to a life insurance beneficiary change in a 1938 decision.
- Undue influence. The Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed a jury verdict setting aside a change for undue influence in a 1925 decision.
- An agent’s or conservator’s lack of authority. Under Minn. Stat. § 523.24, subdivision 6, the insurance power “In a statutory short form power of attorney” lets the agent change an insurance beneficiary, but “the attorney-in-fact cannot be a new beneficiary except” in two cases the statute names. In a 2002 decision discussed below, the Minnesota Court of Appeals noted the clause’s reach: “Moreover, subdivision 6(3) addresses only insurance transactions, not IRAs or checking accounts.” A conservator needs a court’s express authorization.
- Unjust enrichment. In Gelschus v. Hogen, 47 F.4th 679 (8th Cir. 2022), a federal appeals court applying Minnesota law to a dispute over retirement plan benefits quoted an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision. Under that decision, a claim of unjust enrichment may be invoked “in support of claims based upon failure of consideration, fraud, mistake, and in other situations where it would be morally wrong for one party to enrich himself at the expense of another.” Gelschus itself concerned a divorce agreement, and the fraud claim in that case was not appealed.
- Divorce. Minn. Stat. § 524.2-804 revokes a revocable designation to a former spouse, with exceptions.
Subdivision 4 of § 524.2-804 limits automatic revocation: “No change of circumstances other than as described in this section and in section 524.2-803 effects a revocation.” The other section it names is Minn. Stat. § 524.2-803. Under its paragraph (d), “A named beneficiary of a life insurance policy who feloniously and intentionally kills the person upon whose life the policy is issued is not entitled to any benefit under the policy,” and under its paragraph (c), “A named beneficiary of a bond or other contractual arrangement who feloniously and intentionally kills the principal obligee is not entitled to any benefit under the bond or other contractual arrangement and it becomes payable as though the killer had predeceased the decedent.” Outside those two statutes, a late change stays in effect unless a court sets it aside on a ground such as those above. For a payable-on-death account, § 524.6-205, quoted above, adds that a written order changing the form of the account must be signed by a party and “received by the financial institution during the party’s lifetime.” For the pension plans that 29 U.S.C. § 1055 covers, an election to waive either survivor annuity form of benefit “shall not take effect unless” the spouse “consents in writing to such election” and the consent “is witnessed by a plan representative or a notary public,” with the section’s other consent conditions, or a plan representative is satisfied the consent “may not be obtained,” including “because there is no spouse” or “because the spouse cannot be located.” The full rule is quoted under how federal law limits a challenge to an employer plan’s beneficiary form. If your parent’s assets were held in a trust, the route is challenging a trust amendment that cut you out.
What Mental Capacity Does a Parent Need to Change a Beneficiary?
Under the standard the Minnesota Supreme Court applied to a life insurance beneficiary change, a parent has capacity if the parent can understand, to a reasonable extent, the nature and effect of the change. The decision is Timm v. Schneider, 279 N.W. 754 (Minn. 1938). Quoting a Minnesota legal digest, the court stated: “Mere mental weakness does not incapacitate a person from contracting. It is sufficient if he has enough mental capacity to understand, to a reasonable extent, the nature and effect of what he is doing.”
The facts of Timm show how the standard works. A widow had named her brothers and sister as beneficiaries of her policy. She remarried in April 1930 and applied the next month to make her new husband the beneficiary. After she died in 1936, the insurer paid him, and her siblings sued him to recover the proceeds. They claimed that she lacked capacity and that he had unduly influenced her.
The court accepted that she had been ill: “There is no doubt that Mrs. Schneider had sustained a nervous breakdown and was suffering with some delusions.” The jury still found for the husband, and the Supreme Court affirmed, with one justice dissenting on whether the trial had been fair. The court relied on testimony that she kept house and dealt with merchants in the ordinary way. It also relied on a note she wrote in her own hand in the margin of the change form about who would pay her expenses.
For you, the question is what your parent understood when the form was signed. I suggest gathering the medical and care records from the weeks around the change, along with the change form itself. I suggest both because the court in Timm relied on evidence of daily functioning and on what the insured wrote on the form.
How Is Undue Influence Over a Beneficiary Change Proved?
Undue influence is proved with evidence that another person’s pressure overcame your parent’s free choice, so that the change form states that person’s wishes. In Burke v. Bay, 205 N.W. 219 (Minn. 1925), the Minnesota Supreme Court stated the rule for a change of life insurance beneficiary: “in showing undue influence, there must be evidence to satisfy the jury that the free agency of the person signing the instrument was destroyed or interfered with to such an extent that the instrument does not express the wish and intent of the person signing it.”
In Burke, a mother with cancer had named her daughter as sole beneficiary. Her second husband obtained a blank change form and brought it to the home of the nurse who was caring for her. The nurse asked him not to raise the policy with his wife, so he left the form with the nurse. The nurse read the form to the mother and presented it with pen and ink, and the mother signed it five days before she died. The change gave the husband half of the proceeds.
The evidence at trial included these facts:
- The husband had spoken to his wife about the change a number of times, and the nurse said the wife had refused and asked for time to think.
- A physician testified that a patient in her condition is greatly weakened, mentally and physically, in the period before death.
- The husband, who gained from the change, supplied the form, and the nurse presented it for signature.
The jury found for the daughter, and the Supreme Court affirmed. The court did not call the case one-sided: “Under the proofs in the instant case, a verdict either way would seem to be authorized by the evidence.” Timm went the other way on this ground. There, “The question of undue influence was taken away from the jury, and plaintiffs concede that the court was right in so doing.”
I suggest writing down who obtained the form, who presented it for signing, and what your parent said about the change, because the evidence in Burke included those facts. The factors Minnesota courts weigh in a will contest, and the capacity test for a will, are covered in contesting a will for undue influence in Minnesota.
When Can an Agent Under a Power of Attorney Change a Beneficiary?
An agent under a Minnesota statutory short form power of attorney who holds the insurance power may change the beneficiary of the parent’s insurance. Under Minn. Stat. § 523.24, subdivision 6, the agent “cannot be a new beneficiary” except in two cases the statute names. The limit applies to changes the agent makes. It does not restrict a change the parent personally signs.
Subdivision 6 of § 523.24 begins: “In a statutory short form power of attorney, the language conferring general authority with respect to insurance transactions, means that the principal authorizes the attorney-in-fact” to take the listed actions. Clause (3) includes the power “to change the beneficiary of the contract of insurance, provided, however, that the attorney-in-fact cannot be a new beneficiary except, if permitted under subdivision 8, the attorney-in-fact can be the beneficiary of death benefit proceeds under an insurance contract, or, if the attorney-in-fact was named as a beneficiary under the contract which was procured by the principal prior to the granting of the power of attorney, then the attorney-in-fact can continue to be named as the beneficiary under the contract or under any extension or renewal of or substitute for the contract.”
The first exception points to subdivision 8, the gift power. Subdivision 8 allows gifts to the agent only “if authorized by the principal in part Third, to the attorney-in-fact,” and it adds that “no attorney-in-fact nor anyone the attorney-in-fact has a legal obligation to support may be the recipient of any gifts in any one calendar year which, in the aggregate, exceed the federal annual gift tax exclusion amount in the year of the gift.” I suggest reading the power of attorney itself first, because subdivision 6 defines a power granted “In a statutory short form power of attorney,” and the form shows which powers your parent marked.
The Minnesota Court of Appeals read clause (3) in In re Will of Kipke, 645 N.W.2d 727 (Minn. Ct. App. 2002). A grandfather signed a statutory short form naming his grandson as attorney-in-fact. The grandfather then signed forms making the grandson the beneficiary of three annuities, in place of his sons. The sons argued that the statute barred the grandson from taking. The court disagreed: “Therefore, we conclude that the statute does not limit the principal’s ability to control his property, including making beneficiary changes.” It also noted the clause’s reach: “Moreover, subdivision 6(3) addresses only insurance transactions, not IRAs or checking accounts.”
Kipke has limits. The parties agreed the facts were undisputed, and the decision does not address capacity or undue influence. The court read the 2000 statutes, and the words it quoted from clause (3) appear in the current section. The first fact to establish is therefore who signed the change form. If your parent signed it, the grounds include capacity and undue influence. If the agent signed it, the limit in clause (3) applies to an insurance contract, and the standard in Minn. Stat. § 523.21, quoted below, applies to “any power conferred by the power of attorney.”
The agent’s records are the evidence. Under § 523.21, “The attorney-in-fact shall keep complete records of all transactions entered into by the attorney-in-fact on behalf of the principal.” The section also states who may see them: “The persons entitled to examine and copy the records of the attorney-in-fact are the principal, a person designated by the principal in the document creating the power of attorney as the recipient of accountings required by this section, and the guardian or conservator of the estate of the principal while the principal is living and the personal representative of the estate of the principal after the death of the principal.” The section also states the agent’s standard of conduct and liability: “In exercising any power conferred by the power of attorney, the attorney-in-fact shall exercise the power in the same manner as an ordinarily prudent person of discretion and intelligence would exercise in the management of the person’s own affairs and shall have the interests of the principal utmost in mind. The attorney-in-fact is personally liable to any person, including the principal, who is injured by an action taken by the attorney-in-fact in bad faith under the power of attorney or by the attorney-in-fact’s failure to account when the attorney-in-fact has a duty to account under this section.”
A conservator is held to a stricter process. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.5-411, paragraph (a), a conservator may take the listed actions only “After notice to affected persons as provided in this section, and after hearing, and upon express authorization of the court.” Three of the listed actions concern beneficiaries:
- Clause (5): “subject to the terms of the plan document, contract, or agreement, exercise rights to elect options and change beneficiaries under insurance policies and annuities or surrender the policies and annuities for their cash value, and any change pursuant to this clause, shall invalidate the existing elections and beneficiary designations.”
- Clause (7): “subject to the terms of the plan document, contract, or agreement, exercise rights to elect options and change beneficiaries under any qualified or nonqualified retirement plan,” followed by a list of plan types.
- Clause (8): “exercise the power to create, terminate, or alter the beneficial interests and beneficiaries of, a payable on death (POD) account, a transfer on death (TOD) security registration or account, or joint tenancy interests with rights of survivorship.”
The people entitled to notice of that hearing include “the heirs-at-law of the person subject to conservatorship.” If your parent had a conservator, the conservatorship court file should show whether the court authorized the change.
How Does Divorce Affect a Beneficiary Designation in Minnesota?
Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-804, a Minnesota divorce or annulment revokes a revocable beneficiary designation your parent made to the former spouse, except as provided by any of four things. Three are a court order, a retirement plan document, and a contract on dividing the marital property made before or after the marriage or the divorce. The fourth is the express terms of a governing instrument executed before the divorce (other than certain trust instruments). For an employer plan governed by ERISA, 29 U.S.C. § 1104, subsection (a)(1)(D), directs the plan’s fiduciary to act “in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the plan.” In Gelschus, a 401(k) plan paid the former husband named on its form. This matters when the form on file still names a former spouse.
Subdivision 1 of § 524.2-804 opens with its exceptions: “Except as provided by the express terms of a governing instrument, other than a trust instrument under section 501C.1207, executed prior to the dissolution or annulment of an individual’s marriage, a court order, a contract relating to the division of the marital property made between individuals before or after their marriage, dissolution, or annulment, or a plan document governing a qualified or nonqualified retirement plan, the dissolution or annulment of a marriage revokes any revocable” provision in three listed categories. The first category is a “disposition, beneficiary designation, or appointment of property made in a governing instrument by an individual to the individual’s former spouse or any members of the former spouse’s family who are not also members of the individual’s family.”
Where the revocation applies, subdivision 2 states the effect: “Provisions of a governing instrument are given effect as if the former spouse died immediately before the dissolution or annulment.” Subdivision 3 adds a reversal: “Provisions revoked solely by this section are revived by the individual’s remarriage to the former spouse or by a nullification of the dissolution or annulment.”
The company is protected until it receives written notice. Subdivision 5 begins: “A payor or other third party is not liable for having made a payment or transferred an item of property or any other benefit to a beneficiary designated in a governing instrument affected by a dissolution, annulment, or remarriage, or for having taken any other action in good faith reliance on the validity of the governing instrument, before the payor or other third party received written notice of the dissolution, annulment, or remarriage.” It continues: “A payor or other third party is liable for a payment made or other action taken after the payor or other third party received written notice of a claimed forfeiture or revocation under this section.” The notice has a required destination: “Written notice of the dissolution, annulment, or remarriage under paragraph (a) must be delivered to the payor’s or other third party’s main office or home.” I suggest sending the notice to the company’s main office, with a copy of the decree, because a notice sent to a local agent or branch may not meet that requirement. For an employer plan governed by ERISA, the Gelschus court ruled on a 401(k) plan that had paid the former husband: “Neither did Honeywell abuse its discretion by distributing plan benefits to Clifford after learning about the MTA,” the couple’s marital termination agreement.
After notice, the statute lets the company step out of the dispute: “Upon receipt of written notice of the dissolution, annulment, or remarriage, a payor or other third party may pay any amount owed or transfer or deposit any item of property held by it to or with the court having jurisdiction of the probate proceedings relating to the decedent’s estate or, if no proceedings have been commenced, to or with the court having jurisdiction of probate proceedings relating to decedents’ estates located in the county of the decedent’s residence.”
A divorce court’s order can also limit a later change. In Taylor v. Taylor, 413 N.W.2d 587 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), a 1977 decree required a father to “continue to maintain his life insurance coverage for the benefit of the 2 minor children” until they reached age 25. In 1983 he named his second wife sole beneficiary of the policy, a plan through his employment, and she conceded “that she was aware of the beneficiary restriction in the dissolution decree.” He died when the children were 23 and 24, and they sued her for the proceeds. The Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for the children: “The trial court did not err in holding that appellant could not collaterally attack the provision of the dissolution decree, and concluding that she would be unjustly enriched by the retention of the insurance proceeds.” The opinion does not discuss ERISA.
In American Family Life Insurance Co. v. Noruk, 528 N.W.2d 921 (Minn. Ct. App. 1995), a husband changed his life insurance beneficiary from his wife to his sister. The change violated a temporary order in the couple’s pending divorce, and he died before a final judgment. The court held that “when a life insurance policy’s designated beneficiary is changed in violation of a dissolution court’s temporary order, and the death of one of the parties intercedes before a final judgment is rendered, equitable considerations control in determining the ownership of policy proceeds.” On the trial court’s findings, the Court of Appeals affirmed the award of the proceeds to the sister.
How Does Federal Law Limit a Challenge to an Employer Plan’s Beneficiary Form?
For an employer plan governed by ERISA, federal law limits state rules about whom the plan must pay. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1144, subsection (a), “Except as provided in subsection (b) of this section, the provisions of this subchapter and subchapter III shall supersede any and all State laws insofar as they may now or hereafter relate to any employee benefit plan described in section 1003(a) of this title and not exempt under section 1003(b) of this title.”
ERISA also tells the plan which document to follow. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1104, subsection (a)(1)(D), a plan fiduciary must act “in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the plan insofar as such documents and instruments are consistent with the provisions of this subchapter and subchapter III.”
The United States Supreme Court applied the preemption clause to a state revocation-on-divorce statute in Egelhoff v. Egelhoff, 532 U.S. 141 (2001). The statute was Washington’s, and the assets were an employer life insurance policy and a pension plan governed by ERISA. The Court was asked whether ERISA “preempts that statute to the extent it applies to ERISA plans. We hold that it does.” Egelhoff decided Washington’s statute. Minnesota’s statute, § 524.2-804, lists as one of its exceptions “a plan document governing a qualified or nonqualified retirement plan.” The exception’s words are “retirement plan,” and one of the two plans in Egelhoff was a life insurance policy.
Preemption did not end the dispute in Gelschus, which came from the federal district court in Minnesota. An employee tried to replace her former husband with her siblings as beneficiaries of her 401(k), and the plan rejected the form because the percentages were not whole numbers. After she died, the plan paid the former husband. The court upheld the plan’s decision because “When Sally died, the only valid designation named Clifford as sole beneficiary.”
The estate’s claims against the former husband were a different matter: “Agreeing with this persuasive authority, this court rules that Gelschus’s claims against Clifford are not preempted by ERISA.” Those claims were for breach of contract and unjust enrichment under the couple’s divorce agreement, and the court sent them back to the district court. Gelschus does not address a claim that a plan designation resulted from incapacity or undue influence.
Three practical points follow. First, in Gelschus the plan paid the person named on its own form, and the dispute continued against him. I suggest asking the plan administrator for the plan document and the beneficiary forms on file, because § 1104(a)(1)(D) makes those documents the plan’s instructions. Second, ERISA does not cover every retirement plan. 29 U.S.C. § 1003, subsection (b), excludes a plan when “such plan is a governmental plan (as defined in section 1002(32) of this title)” or when “such plan is a church plan (as defined in section 1002(33) of this title) with respect to which no election has been made under section 410(d) of title 26,” along with three other categories.
Third, a surviving spouse has a separate federal rule in 29 U.S.C. § 1055 for the pension plans that section covers. Under subsection (c)(2), “Each plan shall provide that an election under paragraph (1)(A)(i) shall not take effect unless” one of two things is true. The first has three parts: “the spouse of the participant consents in writing to such election,” the election designates a beneficiary or form of benefits “which may not be changed without spousal consent” (or the spouse’s consent expressly permits later designations), and “the spouse’s consent acknowledges the effect of such election and is witnessed by a plan representative or a notary public.” The second is that a plan representative is satisfied the consent “may not be obtained because there is no spouse, because the spouse cannot be located, or because of such other circumstances as the Secretary of the Treasury may by regulations prescribe.” The election that paragraph names is one “to waive the qualified joint and survivor annuity form of benefit or the qualified preretirement survivor annuity form of benefit (or both)” under the plan.
For other individual account plans, whether the section applies turns on three conditions in subsection (b)(1)(C). The first is whether the plan provides that the participant’s benefit “is payable in full, on the death of the participant, to the participant’s surviving spouse (or, if there is no surviving spouse or the surviving spouse consents in the manner required under subsection (c)(2), to a designated beneficiary),” and the other two concern life annuities and transfers from other plans. Under subsection (b), a plan does not fail those requirements “merely because the plan provides that benefits will not be payable to the surviving spouse of the participant unless the participant and such spouse had been married throughout the 1-year period ending on the earlier of the participant’s annuity starting date or the date of the participant’s death.” If you are the surviving spouse, I suggest asking the plan for any spousal consent on file, because subsection (c)(2) requires that consent to be in writing and witnessed.
How Do You Ask the Company to Hold Payment?
You ask in writing, and what the notice does depends on the asset and on who gives it. For securities registered in beneficiary form, Minn. Stat. § 524.6-308 ends the registering entity’s protection after written notice “from any claimant to any interest in the security.” For a bank account, Minn. Stat. § 524.6-211 ends the bank’s protection only after written notice “from any person entitled to request payment,” once the bank “has had a reasonable opportunity to act on it,” and under § 524.6-211 a bank with reason to believe a dispute exists “may refuse, without liability, to make payments.” For life insurance, reported Minnesota cases show insurers placing disputed proceeds with a court, in escrow, or in trust while the claimants litigated.
- Payable-on-death accounts at banks and credit unions. Under § 524.6-211, a bank that pays according to the account terms is discharged, with a limit: “The protection here given does not extend to payments made after a financial institution has received written notice from any person entitled to request payment to the effect that withdrawals in accordance with the terms of the account, including one having an agency designation, should not be permitted, and the financial institution has had a reasonable opportunity to act on it when the payment is made.” That sentence covers notice from a person entitled to request payment, and the section limits it: “No other notice or any other information shown to have been available to a financial institution shall affect its right to the protection provided here.” On who may request payment of a P.O.D. payee’s interest, Minn. Stat. § 524.6-210 provides: “Payment of the interest of a P.O.D. payee may be made, on request, to the P.O.D. payee or to the personal representative or heirs of a deceased P.O.D. payee upon presentation to the financial institution of proof of death showing that the P.O.D. payee survived all persons named as original parties.” Under § 524.6-211, “Unless the notice is withdrawn by the person giving it, the successor of any deceased party and all other parties entitled to payment must concur in any demand for withdrawal if the financial institution is to be protected under this section.” A later sentence of § 524.6-211 is broader: “A financial institution that receives written notice pursuant to this section or that otherwise has reason to believe that a dispute exists as to the rights of the parties may refuse, without liability, to make payments in accordance with the terms of the account.”
- Brokerage accounts registered in beneficiary form. Under § 524.6-308, paragraph (c), a registering entity that transfers the security “in good faith reliance” on the registration is discharged from claims, with a limit: “The protections of sections 524.6-301 to 524.6-311 do not extend to a reregistration or payment made after a registering entity has received written notice from any claimant to any interest in the security objecting to implementation of a registration in beneficiary form.”
- Life insurance and annuities. In Burke, the trial court ordered the insurer to pay the policy amount into court, and the insurer was then discharged. In Lemke v. Schwarz, 286 N.W.2d 693 (Minn. 1979), the daughters hired a lawyer and notified the insurers of their claim, and “Both insurance companies subsequently paid the proceeds of the insurance policies to the plaintiffs’ attorney to be held in trust pending the resolution of this matter.” In Kipke, “Pursuant to stipulation of the parties and order of the court, the insurance companies deposited their respective annuity sums in escrow, and were dismissed from this action.” These are what happened in three cases. They are not a rule that an insurer must hold payment.
- Employer plans. ERISA’s rule that a plan follows its own documents, 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(D), applies.
Payment does not decide who owns the money. The last sentence of § 524.6-211 reads: “The protection here provided shall not affect the rights of parties in disputes between themselves or their successors concerning the beneficial ownership of funds in, or withdrawn from, multiple-party accounts.” Paragraph (d) of § 524.6-308 has a parallel sentence: “The protection provided by sections 524.6-301 to 524.6-311 to the registering entity of a security does not affect the rights of beneficiaries in disputes between themselves and other claimants to ownership of the security transferred or its value or proceeds.”
I suggest sending the notice by a method that proves delivery and keeping a copy, because both statutes turn on whether the institution “has received written notice” before it pays.
What Deadline Applies to Contesting a Beneficiary Change?
No decision discussed in this article decides which limitations period applies to a contest of a beneficiary change. The limitations statute to read first is Minn. Stat. § 541.05, subdivision 1, a general statute for civil actions. It opens with the words “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within six years” and then lists nine kinds of action. Two entries on the list are actions “upon a contract or other obligation, express or implied, as to which no other limitation is expressly prescribed” and actions “for relief on the ground of fraud, in which case the cause of action shall not be deemed to have accrued until the discovery by the aggrieved party of the facts constituting the fraud.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.
I suggest not assuming that the fraud entry’s discovery rule applies to a capacity or undue influence claim. The entry’s words are “for relief on the ground of fraud,” and no decision discussed here applies them to those claims.
Payment is a second reason to act promptly. Under § 524.6-308, a registering entity’s protections “do not extend to a reregistration or payment made after” it has received written notice from a claimant. Under § 524.6-211, a bank’s protection ends only for payments made after written notice “from any person entitled to request payment,” once the bank “has had a reasonable opportunity to act on it when the payment is made.” A will or trust contest runs on its own periods, which are quoted in the deadlines to contest a will or trust in Minnesota.
What Are Your Options When a Beneficiary Was Changed Before Death?
Your options run from gathering records to a lawsuit, and you can pursue more than one. In Burke, Timm, and Kipke, the people who challenged the change were the beneficiaries named before it. In Lemke, the daughters were not the named beneficiaries when their father died. He was “the named insured under the terms of two life insurance policies which listed defendant as the beneficiary.” The court held that “the plaintiffs are entitled to the proceeds” of both policies. It rested that result on the insured’s intent and on a second finding: “In addition, we find that the insured made affirmative efforts to effect this change and under the circumstances substantially complied with the relevant policy provisions.” A personal representative sued in Gelschus. He cited Minn. Stat. § 524.3-709, under which a personal representative “may maintain an action to recover possession of property or to determine the title thereto,” and the court wrote that it “need not address” that argument because he had standing on another basis.
- Find out what was signed and who was named before. Burke, Timm, and Kipke do not address a challenger who was never named on the policy. The daughters in Lemke were not the named beneficiaries when their father died, and they relied on his letter. The opinion does not say whether they had been named earlier. If the earlier form named someone else, setting the change aside may send the money to that person, so I suggest learning the earlier designation before spending money on a challenge. After the death, § 523.21 lets the personal representative examine and copy an attorney-in-fact’s records.
- Send written notice of the dispute. This fits when the money has not been paid. Its effect depends on the kind of asset and, for a bank account, on who gives the notice.
- Talk with the person now named. A direct conversation, alone or with a mediator, fits when the relationship can bear it and the facts are disputed in good faith. In Kipke, the parties stipulated, the insurers deposited the annuity sums in escrow, and the insurers were dismissed while the court decided. The risk is delay, because a conversation with the person named is not a written notice to the institution under § 524.6-211 or § 524.6-308.
- Bring a claim in court. In Gelschus, the court ruled that the personal representative had standing to enforce the divorce agreement as a third-party beneficiary. He had that standing either as personal representative or as the assignee of the siblings’ claims. Against an agent, § 523.21 makes the attorney-in-fact “personally liable to any person, including the principal,” who is injured by an action the agent takes “in bad faith under the power of attorney.” If the personal representative is the person who gained from the change, the remedies against a personal representative are covered in executor misconduct in Minnesota.
- Decide not to pursue it. In Timm, the challengers went through a jury trial and an appeal and lost, and the proceeds in dispute were $719. I suggest weighing the amount at stake against the evidence you can prove with documents and witnesses, because in both Burke and Timm a jury decided the facts.
Can a parent's letter change a life insurance beneficiary?
Under Lemke v. Schwarz (Minn. 1979), a letter can, when it clearly and unambiguously shows the insured’s intent to change the beneficiary and the insured made affirmative efforts to make the change. In Lemke, the insured wrote his daughter a letter the day before he died, and the daughters did “not argue that decedent’s letter to his daughter constituted a valid will.” The court held: “where an insured has clearly and unambiguously demonstrated an intent to change the beneficiary on a life insurance policy, this intent should be given effect unless prejudice to the insurer would result.” It added: “In addition, we find that the insured made affirmative efforts to effect this change and under the circumstances substantially complied with the relevant policy provisions.” Where intent is confused or conflicting, “the named beneficiary should be entitled to the proceeds.” For an employer plan governed by ERISA, the federal appeals court in Gelschus v. Hogen (8th Cir. 2022) upheld a 401(k) plan’s rejection of a defective form. It quoted an earlier decision that the substantial-compliance doctrine, if still available, “would not deprive the administrator of the power to require strict compliance with the terms of the plan.” This article’s statutes on a change by will cover payable-on-death accounts and transfer-on-death securities.
Does a dementia diagnosis make a beneficiary change invalid?
A dementia diagnosis does not by itself make a beneficiary change invalid. In Timm v. Schneider (Minn. 1938), the Minnesota Supreme Court applied the standard for contracts to a life insurance beneficiary change: “Mere mental weakness does not incapacitate a person from contracting. It is sufficient if he has enough mental capacity to understand, to a reasonable extent, the nature and effect of what he is doing.” The insured in Timm had suffered a nervous breakdown and delusions, and the jury still found for the new beneficiary. Evidence of how your parent functioned around the signing bears on that question.
Can my sibling name herself beneficiary using our parent's power of attorney?
Not through the insurance power of a Minnesota statutory short form power of attorney, with two exceptions. Under Minn. Stat. § 523.24, subdivision 6, “the attorney-in-fact cannot be a new beneficiary except, if permitted under subdivision 8, the attorney-in-fact can be the beneficiary of death benefit proceeds under an insurance contract,” or where the parent had named the attorney-in-fact as beneficiary before granting the power. In In re Will of Kipke (Minn. Ct. App. 2002), the court concluded that this limit does not restrict a change the parent personally makes, and that it “addresses only insurance transactions, not IRAs or checking accounts.” For any power, Minn. Stat. § 523.21 requires the attorney-in-fact to “have the interests of the principal utmost in mind.”
Is my parent's former spouse still the beneficiary after a Minnesota divorce?
A Minnesota divorce revokes a revocable beneficiary designation to the former spouse, except as one of four things provides. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-804, subdivision 1, they are the express terms of a governing instrument (other than certain trust instruments) signed before the divorce, a court order, “a contract relating to the division of the marital property” made before or after the marriage or the divorce, and “a plan document governing a qualified or nonqualified retirement plan.” A revoked designation is read “as if the former spouse died immediately before the dissolution or annulment.” Remarriage to the former spouse, or a nullification of the divorce, revives it. An employer plan governed by federal law follows its own plan documents.
Can I still bring a claim after the company has paid the new beneficiary?
Payment did not end the dispute in the decisions that reached the question, for the claims those courts allowed. In Timm v. Schneider (Minn. 1938), the earlier beneficiaries sued the new beneficiary after the insurer paid him, and the case was tried on the insured’s capacity. In Gelschus v. Hogen (8th Cir. 2022), an estate’s contract and unjust enrichment claims under a divorce agreement were sent back to the trial court against the person a 401(k) plan had paid. Its conversion and civil theft claims failed, and the decision does not address incapacity or undue influence. For bank accounts, Minn. Stat. § 524.6-211 provides that the bank’s protection “shall not affect the rights of parties in disputes between themselves or their successors concerning the beneficial ownership of funds in, or withdrawn from, multiple-party accounts.”
Next Steps on a Late Beneficiary Change
A late beneficiary change stands unless a court sets it aside or a statute revokes it. For a payable-on-death account, § 524.6-205 also provides that a written order changing the form of the account must be signed by a party and “received by the financial institution during the party’s lifetime.” Under 29 U.S.C. § 1055, in the pension plans it covers, a participant’s waiver of a survivor annuity “shall not take effect unless,” among other conditions, the spouse “consents in writing to such election” and the consent “is witnessed by a plan representative or a notary public,” or a plan representative is satisfied the consent “may not be obtained,” as where there is no spouse or “the spouse cannot be located.” The grounds in Minnesota include lack of capacity under the standard in Timm, undue influence under the standard in Burke, and an agent’s or conservator’s lack of authority. Section 524.2-804 revokes a former spouse’s designation on divorce, subject to its exceptions, and ERISA makes an employer plan follow its own documents. The first facts to establish are who signed the form, what your parent understood when it was signed, who was named before, and whether the money has been paid. For a bank or brokerage account, §§ 524.6-211 and 524.6-308 give effect to a written notice the institution receives before it pays, on the conditions each section states, including who must give the notice. More on how I handle these cases is on my trust and estate litigation page.
To find out whether a late beneficiary change can be contested, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send confidential documents.