Defending a derivative lawsuit as a director, officer, or LLC manager in Minnesota turns on several early questions. They include whether the plaintiff can bring the claim at all and whether a committee of independent people will decide it for the company. Another is whether the company must pay your defense costs while the case runs. The claim belongs to the company, so the company’s own rules (its articles, bylaws, or operating agreement) and Minnesota’s corporation and LLC statutes shape the defense. The procedure comes from a court rule, Minn. R. Civ. P. 23.09, which governs “a derivative action brought by one or more shareholders or members to enforce a right of a corporation or of an unincorporated association,” and, for corporations, from Minnesota Supreme Court decisions. For a limited liability company (LLC), the legislature also wrote rules into Minn. Stat. § 322C.0902 and the sections after it.
This page is written for the director or officer of a closely held Minnesota corporation, and for the member, manager, or governor of a Minnesota LLC, who has been named as a defendant. It is part of my material on the shareholder dispute and the other owner conflicts that can put a business at risk.
What Is a Derivative Lawsuit, and How Is It Different From a Direct Claim?
A derivative lawsuit is a claim a shareholder or member brings on the company’s behalf, for a harm done to the company. A direct claim is the owner’s own claim for an injury the owner suffered. The difference decides which procedural rules the plaintiff must meet, and those rules can give a defendant an early defense. For an LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0901, subd. 2, requires a member suing directly to plead and prove an actual or threatened injury that is not solely the result of an injury to the company.
The Minnesota Supreme Court described the test in Wessin v. Archives Corp., 592 N.W.2d 460 (Minn. 1999): courts focus “the inquiry to whether the complained-of injury was an injury to the shareholder directly, or to the corporation.” The Court explained that a derivative action is required because “the funds to be recovered belong not to the shareholders individually, but to the corporation.” In Wessin, minority shareholders of a closely held corporation sued directly, and the Court held that “despite the smaller number of shareholders in a closely held corporation, such shareholders are still subject to the derivative pleading requirements” of the rule, then numbered 23.06. The Court later explained in In re Medtronic, Inc. Shareholder Litigation, 900 N.W.2d 401 (Minn. 2017), a public-company merger case decided on a motion to dismiss, that its earlier cases did not establish “a requirement that a shareholder’s injury must be separate and distinct from any injuries to all other shareholders to bring a direct action.” Its formulation: “when shareholders are injured only indirectly, the action is derivative; when shareholders show an injury that is not shared with the corporation, the action is direct.”
For an LLC, a member suing directly “must plead and prove an actual or threatened injury that is not solely the result of an injury suffered or threatened to be suffered by the limited liability company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0901, subd. 2). The plaintiff’s side of the procedure is covered in how derivative lawsuits work in Minnesota.
How Can a Derivative Lawsuit Be Dismissed Early?
A derivative lawsuit can end early when the plaintiff cannot meet the procedural requirements that come with suing for the company. The grounds include a plaintiff who does not own the right shares or membership interest at the right times, or who cannot fairly represent the other owners. They also include a complaint that does not plead the demand or its futility with particularity, or that pleads a company claim as a personal one.
Minn. R. Civ. P. 23.09 sets these requirements:
- Ownership at the time of the transaction. “[T]he complaint shall allege that the plaintiff was a shareholder or member at the time of the transaction of which the plaintiff complains or that the plaintiff’s share or membership thereafter devolved on the plaintiff by operation of law.”
- Continuing ownership. In Vista Fund v. Garis, 277 N.W.2d 19 (Minn. 1979), the plaintiff had sold its shares and bought some back before suing. Construing the rule’s earlier version, the Minnesota Supreme Court held that “continuous ownership must be required,” agreeing that the plaintiff must be a shareholder “from the time the alleged improper acts occurred, continuously and uninterruptedly, until the time such action is commenced.” It held that “summary judgment was proper dismissing such claims.” The Court did not decide a sale after filing: it noted that “as a general rule the courts have held that where a plaintiff has ceased to be a shareholder after a derivative action has been commenced, the action has been held to abate,” but said “we need not examine the correctness of this rule.”
- The demand, pleaded with particularity. The complaint “shall also allege with particularity the efforts, if any, made by the plaintiff to obtain the desired action from the directors or comparable authority and, if necessary, from the shareholders or members, and the reasons for the plaintiff’s failure to obtain the action or for not making the effort.”
- Adequate representation. “The derivative action may not be maintained if it appears that the plaintiff does not fairly and adequately represent the interest of the shareholders or members similarly situated in enforcing the right of the corporation or association.”
For an LLC, the statute sets the parallel rules. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0903, subd. 1, “Except as otherwise provided in subdivision 2, a derivative action under section 322C.0902 may be maintained only by a person that is a member at the time the action is commenced and remains a member while the action continues.” Subdivision 2 lets the court substitute another member if the sole plaintiff dies. A sale of the plaintiff’s interest does not settle that question alone. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0502, subd. 1, a transfer of a transferable interest “does not by itself cause a member’s dissociation.” Minn. Stat. § 322C.0602 lists the events that do, including expulsion “by the unanimous consent of the other members” if “there has been a transfer of all of the person’s transferable interest in the company,” other than a transfer for security purposes or a charging order that has not been foreclosed. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0904, the complaint must state with particularity “the date and content of the plaintiff’s demand and the response to the demand by the other members, managers, or board of governors” or, “if a demand has not been made, the reasons a demand under section 322C.0902, clause (1), would be futile.” Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0902, clause (1), a member who makes a demand may maintain the action only if “the member, manager, or board does not bring the action within a reasonable time,” unless “a demand under clause (1) would be futile.” What a demand should contain is on the page about the derivative demand letter.
A mislabeled claim is a ground too. In Wessin, the trial court entered judgment on the pleadings because the shareholders had not followed the derivative rule, and the Supreme Court reinstated that order “dismissing the case without prejudice.” Without prejudice means the plaintiff could file again in the proper form.
Timing matters on the defense side. Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 12.01, “Defendant shall serve an answer within 21 days after service of the summons upon that defendant unless the court directs otherwise pursuant to Rule 4.043.” Check the current text of the rule before relying on this period. Rule 12.02 lets a defendant raise “failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted” by motion, and “A motion making any of these defenses shall be made before pleading if a further pleading is permitted.” Under Rule 12.08, “A defense of lack of jurisdiction over the person, insufficiency of process, or insufficiency of service of process is waived (1) if omitted from a motion in the circumstances described in Rule 12.07, or (2) if it is neither made by motion pursuant to this rule nor included in a responsive pleading or an amendment thereof permitted by Rule 15.01 to be made as a matter of course.” I suggest calendaring the answer date the day you are served. I also suggest raising any jurisdiction or service defense in any Rule 12 motion or, without one, in your answer, because Rule 12.08 waives a defense omitted from them.
How Does a Special Litigation Committee Affect the Defendants?
A special litigation committee is a group of independent people the company appoints to decide, in the company’s place, whether the derivative claim against you should go forward. Its decision can end the case, let it continue, or settle it. For a corporation, a court must defer to a committee’s decision to settle “if the proponent of that decision demonstrates” that its members “possessed a disinterested independence” and that its procedures “were adequate, appropriate, and pursued in good faith.” For an LLC, under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0905, subd. 5, the court asks whether the members were “disinterested and independent” and acted “in good faith, independently, and with reasonable care,” with the committee carrying the burden of proof.
For a corporation, Minn. Stat. § 302A.241, subd. 1, provides that “Committees may include a special litigation committee consisting of one or more independent directors or other independent persons to consider legal rights or remedies of the corporation and whether those rights and remedies should be pursued.” Under subdivision 1, “A resolution approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors currently holding office may establish committees having the authority of the board in the management of the business of the corporation only to the extent provided in the resolution,” and under subdivision 2, “Unless the articles or bylaws provide for a different membership or manner of appointment, a committee shall consist of one or more persons, who need not be directors, appointed by affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present.” Under subdivision 7, “Committee members are deemed to be directors for purposes of sections 302A.251, 302A.255, and 302A.521.” In re UnitedHealth Group Inc. Shareholder Derivative Litigation, 754 N.W.2d 544 (Minn. 2008), answered a federal court’s question about a public company’s committee that had decided to settle. The Minnesota Supreme Court held that “a court should defer to an SLC’s decision to settle a shareholder derivative action if (1) the members of the SLC possessed a disinterested independence and (2) the SLC’s investigative procedures and methodologies were adequate, appropriate, and pursued in good faith.” The Court also reaffirmed its statement in Janssen v. Best & Flanagan, 662 N.W.2d 876 (Minn. 2003), that if the initial committee’s investigation and recommendation fail that standard, “the derivative suit proceeds on its merits” with “no opportunity to rectify any deficiencies.” It noted that Janssen had clarified that “a board has one opportunity to properly convene an SLC, which itself has only one opportunity to conduct a proper investigation.”
For an LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0905 writes the process into the statute. Under subdivision 3, in a member-managed LLC the committee may be appointed “by the consent of a majority of the members not named as defendants or plaintiffs in the proceeding,” and “if all members are named as defendants or plaintiffs in the proceeding, by a majority of the members named as defendants.” In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, the same subdivision gives the appointment to a majority of the managers or governors “not named as defendants or plaintiffs in the proceeding,” and, if all of them are named, to a majority of those “named as defendants.” Once a committee is appointed, “on motion by the committee made in the name of the company, except for good cause shown, the court shall stay discovery for the time reasonably necessary to permit the committee to make its investigation” (subd. 1). The committee “may be composed of one or more disinterested and independent individuals, who may be members” (subd. 2). Under subdivision 5, “The court shall determine whether the members of the committee were disinterested and independent and whether the committee conducted its investigation and made its recommendation in good faith, independently, and with reasonable care, with the committee having the burden of proof.” If the committee meets that test, “the court shall enforce the determination of the committee.” Otherwise, the court “shall dissolve the stay of discovery entered under subdivision 1 and allow the action to proceed under the direction of the plaintiff.”
I suggest giving a committee complete and prompt answers, because the court’s review turns on how thorough the investigation was. The limits on the discovery stay and the court’s test are covered on the page about the special litigation committee.
How Does the Business Judgment Rule Protect a Director or Officer?
A Minnesota director or officer who acts in good faith, with a reasonable belief that the action serves the company, and with ordinary care is not liable just for holding the position. Courts also apply a business judgment rule, which the Minnesota Supreme Court has said gives a degree of deference to directors’ decisions. For an LLC, the duty of care in Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 3, is stated “Subject to the business judgment rule.”
For a corporate director, Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 1, provides: “A director shall discharge the duties of the position of director in good faith, in a manner the director reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances. A person who so performs those duties is not liable by reason of being or having been a director of the corporation.” Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 1, sets the same standard for an officer. Under § 302A.251, subd. 2, “A director is entitled to rely on information, opinions, reports, or statements, including financial statements and other financial data,” prepared or presented by officers, employees, outside advisers, or a board committee who meet the subdivision’s conditions. That reliance has a limit: it “does not apply to a director who has knowledge concerning the matter in question that makes the reliance otherwise permitted by paragraph (a) unwarranted.”
In Janssen v. Best & Flanagan, 662 N.W.2d 876 (Minn. 2003), a case about a nonprofit corporation, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that courts established a business judgment rule that “grants a degree of deference to the decisions of corporate directors.” It then quoted a treatise: “The business judgment rule is a presumption protecting conduct by directors that can be attributed to any rational business purpose.” Citing the same treatise, the Court said the rule means that “as long as the disinterested director(s) made an informed business decision, in good faith, without an abuse of discretion, he or she will not be liable for corporate losses resulting from his or her decision.” In UnitedHealth (2008), the Court later said of the quoted presumption sentence that “this statement was based on a treatise, not precedent, and it was not part of our narrow holding that the two elements of the business judgment rule are good faith and independence.”
When the claim concerns a deal between you and the company, a separate section addresses whether the deal itself stands. Minn. Stat. § 302A.255, subd. 1, covers a contract between the corporation and one or more of its directors, or between the corporation and “an organization in or of which one or more of its directors are directors, officers, or legal representatives or have a material financial interest.” Such a contract “is not void or voidable” for that reason if, among other routes the subdivision lists, “The contract or transaction was, and the person asserting the validity of the contract or transaction sustains the burden of establishing that the contract or transaction was, fair and reasonable as to the corporation at the time it was authorized, approved, or ratified,” or the material facts were disclosed to the board and it approved “in good faith by a majority of the directors or committee members currently holding office, but the interested director or directors shall not be counted in determining the presence of a quorum and shall not vote.” On the fairness route, the person asserting the deal’s validity carries the burden of proving it fair.
For an LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 3, states the duty of care “Subject to the business judgment rule” and provides that a member “may rely in good faith on opinions, reports, statements, or other information provided by another person that the member reasonably believes is a competent and reliable source for the information.” Subdivision 2, clause (2), includes in a member’s duty of loyalty the duty “to refrain from dealing with the company in the conduct or winding up of the company’s activities as or on behalf of a person having an interest adverse to the company,” and subdivision 5 makes it “a defense to a claim under subdivision 2, clause (2), and any comparable claim in equity or at common law that the transaction was fair to the limited liability company.”
Subdivision 6 lets all members of a member-managed or manager-managed LLC “authorize or ratify, after full disclosure of all material facts, a specific act or transaction that otherwise would violate the duty of loyalty.” In a manager-managed LLC, “Subdivisions 1, 2, 3, and 5 apply to the manager or managers and not the members” (subd. 7), and in a board-managed LLC, “Subdivisions 1, 2, 3, and 5 apply to the governors and not the members” (subd. 8); in both, “Subdivision 6 applies only to the members.” Separately, under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 5, the operating agreement “may specify the method by which a specific act or transaction that would otherwise violate the duty of loyalty may be authorized or ratified by one or more disinterested and independent persons after full disclosure of all material facts.” I suggest gathering the board minutes, reports, and advice you relied on, because those records are what show an informed decision. The doctrine is covered in more depth on the page about the Minnesota business judgment rule.
What Can the Articles or Operating Agreement Do to Limit Your Liability?
Under § 302A.251, subd. 4, a corporation’s articles can eliminate or limit a director’s money-damages liability to the company and its shareholders “for breach of fiduciary duty as a director.” An LLC’s operating agreement can do the same for members, managers, and governors. Neither document can reach the listed exceptions, which include a breach of the duty of loyalty, so the clause can reach a claim of carelessness but not those listed claims. An LLC’s operating agreement can also change the duties themselves: under § 322C.0110, subd. 4, “If not manifestly unreasonable,” it may “restrict or eliminate” listed loyalty duties, “identify specific types or categories of activities that do not violate the duty of loyalty,” and “alter the duty of care, except to authorize intentional misconduct or knowing violation of law.”
Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 4, “A director’s personal liability to the corporation or its shareholders for monetary damages for breach of fiduciary duty as a director may be eliminated or limited in the articles.” The articles cannot limit a director’s liability:
- “for any breach of the director’s duty of loyalty to the corporation or its shareholders”
- “for acts or omissions not in good faith or that involve intentional misconduct or a knowing violation of law”
- “under section 302A.559 or 80A.76” (the unlawful-distribution and securities-liability sections)
- “for any transaction from which the director derived an improper personal benefit”
- “for any act or omission occurring prior to the date when the provision in the articles eliminating or limiting liability becomes effective.”
Officers get less. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 2, the articles may limit an officer’s liability “to the shareholders for monetary damages for breach, during the time the corporation is a publicly held corporation, of fiduciary duty as an officer,” and never “in any action by or in the right of the corporation.” A derivative suit is brought “to enforce a right of a corporation” under Rule 23.09.
For an LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 7, lets the operating agreement “eliminate or limit a member’s, manager’s, or governor’s liability to the limited liability company and members for money damages,” except for these claims:
- “breach of the duty of loyalty”
- “a financial benefit received by the member or manager to which the member or manager is not entitled”
- “a breach of a duty under section 322C.0406” (the liability for an improper distribution)
- “intentional infliction of harm on the company or a member”
- “an intentional violation of criminal law”
Subdivision 4 of § 322C.0110 separately lets the operating agreement, “If not manifestly unreasonable,” “restrict or eliminate” the loyalty duties it lists, including the duty to refrain from adverse dealing that § 322C.0409, subd. 2, clause (2), states. Subdivision 3 of § 322C.0110 adds a limit running the other way: the operating agreement may not “unreasonably restrict the right of a member to maintain an action under sections 322C.0901 to 322C.0906.” I suggest reading the articles or operating agreement before you answer, because the clause can narrow the claims that put your own money at risk. For a corporation, I suggest also checking for a shareholder control agreement, because it can shift a director’s liability to its parties. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.457, subd. 3, the effect of an agreement the section authorizes is “to relieve the board and the director or directors in their capacities as directors of, and to impose upon the parties to the agreement, the liability for acts or omissions imposed by law upon directors to the extent that and so long as the discretion or powers of the directors in the management of the business and affairs of the corporation are exercised by the shareholders under a provision in the agreement.” Other sources of personal exposure are covered on the page about when board members can be held personally liable.
How Do Indemnification and Advancement of Defense Costs Work?
A Minnesota corporation or LLC must advance defense costs on written request, when the statute’s conditions are met, to a person sued because of an official capacity. That person includes a corporation’s director or officer and an LLC’s manager, governor, or member of a member-managed company. It must also indemnify that person at the end when the conditions in Minn. Stat. § 302A.521 or Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408 are met. The company’s articles, bylaws, or operating agreement can prohibit or condition both, but a condition must apply “equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class.” A new limit in a corporation’s articles or bylaws “may not apply to or affect” a person’s rights for acts or omissions before it took effect.
Section 302A.521, subd. 1, defines “Proceeding” as “a threatened, pending, or completed civil, criminal, administrative, arbitration, or investigative proceeding, including a proceeding by or in the right of the corporation.” Advances come under subdivision 3. You are “entitled, upon written request to the corporation, to payment or reimbursement by the corporation of reasonable expenses, including attorneys’ fees and disbursements, incurred by the person in advance of the final disposition of the proceeding.” The statute requires three things first: “a written affirmation by the person of a good faith belief that the criteria for indemnification set forth in subdivision 2 have been satisfied,” “a written undertaking by the person to repay all amounts so paid or reimbursed by the corporation, if it is ultimately determined that the criteria for indemnification have not been satisfied,” and “a determination that the facts then known to those making the determination would not preclude indemnification under this section.” The undertaking “is an unlimited general obligation of the person making it, but need not be secured and shall be accepted without reference to financial ability to make the repayment.”
Indemnification at the end covers “judgments, penalties, fines, including, without limitation, excise taxes assessed against the person with respect to an employee benefit plan, settlements, and reasonable expenses” (subd. 2). One of the five conditions in subdivision 2 is that the person “received no improper personal benefit and section 302A.255, if applicable, has been satisfied.” Under subdivision 4, “The articles or bylaws either may prohibit indemnification or advances of expenses otherwise required by this section or may impose conditions on indemnification or advances of expenses in addition to the conditions contained in subdivisions 2 and 3,” if the rule applies equally to everyone or to a class. A new limit “may not apply to or affect the right of a person to indemnification or advances of expenses with respect to any acts or omissions of the person occurring prior to the effective date of a provision in the articles or the date of adoption of a provision in the bylaws establishing the prohibition or limit.”
The decision belongs first to the disinterested directors: subdivision 6 sends it to “the board by a majority of a quorum, if the directors who are at the time parties to the proceeding are not counted for determining either a majority or the presence of a quorum,” then to a committee, special legal counsel, or the shareholders. A court can decide it “if an adverse determination is made under clauses (1) to (4) or under paragraph (b), or if no determination is made under clauses (1) to (4) or under paragraph (b) within 60 days after (i) the later to occur of the termination of a proceeding or a written request for indemnification to the corporation or (ii) a written request for an advance of expenses, as the case may be, by a court in this state, which may be the same court in which the proceeding involving the person’s liability took place, upon application of the person and any notice the court requires.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on this period. On that application, “The person seeking indemnification or payment or reimbursement of expenses pursuant to this clause has the burden of establishing that the person is entitled to indemnification or payment or reimbursement of expenses.”
For an LLC, § 322C.0408 follows the same structure for advances, with a proceeding defined to include one “by or in the right of the limited liability company” (subd. 1) and advances “upon written request to the limited liability company” (subd. 3). One indemnification condition differs: the person must have “received no improper personal benefit and complied with the duties stated in sections 322C.0405 and 322C.0409, if applicable” (subd. 2). The articles of organization or the operating agreement may prohibit or condition indemnification or advances (subd. 4), and the limit on reaching earlier acts reads differently: a prohibition or limit “may not apply to or affect the right of a person to indemnification or advances of expenses with respect to any acts or omissions of the person occurring before the effective date of a provision in the articles of organization, a member control agreement, or the date of adoption of a provision in the bylaws establishing the prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances.” Under § 322C.0110, subd. 7, “The operating agreement may alter or eliminate the indemnification for a member, manager, or governor provided by section 322C.0408, subdivision 2.”
Directors and officers (D&O) insurance is a separate source of payment. A corporation “may purchase and maintain insurance on behalf of a person in that person’s official capacity against any liability asserted against and incurred by the person in or arising from that capacity, whether or not the corporation would have been required to indemnify the person” (§ 302A.521, subd. 7). Section 322C.0408, subd. 7, lets an LLC buy insurance for a member, manager, or governor, even where the operating agreement could not limit that person’s liability for the conduct. The policy itself sets when and how a claim must be reported and what it covers. I suggest asking the company for a copy of any D&O policy and reading its notice clause the day you are served, because the notice requirement is a contract term separate from the statutes. The rules are covered in depth on the page about indemnification of directors and officers.
Who Represents the Company, and Who Represents You?
The company’s lawyer represents the company. That lawyer may also represent you, but only within the conflict-of-interest rules, and a serious charge of wrongdoing against those in control can create a conflict that decides who represents whom. The lawyer must also tell you whom they represent in one situation: under Rule 1.13(e), the lawyer “shall explain the identity of the client when the lawyer knows or reasonably should know that the organization’s interests are adverse to those of the constituents with whom the lawyer is dealing.”
Under Minn. R. Prof. Conduct 1.13(a), “A lawyer employed or retained by an organization represents the organization acting through its duly authorized constituents.” Under Rule 1.13(f), “A lawyer representing an organization may also represent any of its directors, officers, employees, members, shareholders or other constituents, subject to the provisions of Rule 1.7.”
A comment to the rule, which guides how the rule is read rather than adding to it, addresses derivative suits: “Most derivative actions are a normal incident of an organization’s affairs, to be defended by the organization’s lawyer like any other suit. However, if the claim involves serious charges of wrongdoing by those in control of the organization, a conflict may arise between the lawyer’s duty to the organization and the lawyer’s relationship with the board. In those circumstances, Rule 1.7 governs who should represent the directors and the organization.”
The practical result is that what you tell the company’s lawyer may belong to the company. I suggest asking that lawyer, at the start, whether they represent you as well as the company, because the answer decides whose confidences they keep.
How Does Settlement of a Derivative Lawsuit Work?
A derivative action covered by Rule 23.09 cannot be settled or dismissed by agreement between the plaintiff and the defendants alone: the court must approve it, and the other owners get notice. The rule covers derivative actions brought by “shareholders or members” to enforce a right “of a corporation or of an unincorporated association.” For an LLC, the statute also sends any settlement proceeds to the company and lets a special litigation committee settle on terms it approves, subject to the court’s review.
Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 23.09, “The action shall not be dismissed or compromised without the approval of the court, and notice of the proposed dismissal or compromise shall be given to shareholders or members in such manner as the court directs.” A settlement that a special litigation committee approves is tested under the UnitedHealth standard in the committee section above.
For an LLC, a special litigation committee may determine that the proceeding should “be settled on terms approved by the committee” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0905, subd. 4), and the court enforces that determination only after the subdivision 5 review. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0906, subd. 1, “any proceeds or other benefits of a derivative action under section 322C.0902, whether by judgment, compromise, or settlement, belong to the limited liability company and not to the plaintiff,” and “if the plaintiff receives any proceeds, the plaintiff shall remit them immediately to the company.” Under subdivision 2, “If a derivative action under section 322C.0902 is successful in whole or in part, the court may award the plaintiff reasonable expenses, including reasonable attorney fees and costs, from the recovery of the limited liability company.”
For your own exposure, the indemnification statutes list “settlements” among the amounts a company must indemnify when the conditions are met (§ 302A.521, subd. 2). I suggest working out, before you agree to any number, who pays it: you, the company, or an insurer, because the answer depends on the indemnification conditions, the governing documents, and the policy.
What Are the Options When You Are Named in a Derivative Suit?
A director, officer, or manager named in a derivative suit has more choices than fighting every claim to trial. The options range from a direct conversation with the owner who sued to a motion to dismiss, and each fits different facts. Some of them run through the court. A special litigation committee’s decision faces the court review described above, and Rule 23.09 requires the court’s approval of any dismissal or compromise of the derivative actions it covers.
- Talk owner to owner. A derivative suit in a closely held company can grow out of a falling-out between the owners. A direct conversation, with your lawyer’s input on what to say, can surface what the plaintiff actually wants, such as information, a change in management, or an exit. It fits when the relationship can still work. The risk is a statement that becomes evidence, so I suggest deciding in advance what you will and will not discuss.
- Ask the company to address the claim. The board of a corporation can appoint a special litigation committee. In an LLC, a majority of the members, managers, or governors not named as defendants or plaintiffs can appoint one, or, if all of them are named, a majority of those named as defendants. It fits when independent people are available and the facts support the decisions you made. The risk is that the committee may decide the claim should go forward, a court enforces its decision if it passes review, and a corporation’s committee that fails review gets no second attempt.
- Move to dismiss. A plaintiff who lacks the required ownership, did not plead the demand or futility with particularity, or pleaded a company claim as a personal one can face an early motion. In an LLC, so can a plaintiff who sued before the people who received the demand had a reasonable time to act. It fits when the defect is clear on the complaint. The risk is cost without finality, because a dismissal without prejudice lets the plaintiff file again.
- Defend on the merits. The standard of conduct, the business judgment rule, and any exculpation clause are defenses to the claim itself. In an LLC, fairness is one too: Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 5, quoted in the business judgment section, makes fairness a defense to a subdivision 2, clause (2), adverse-dealing claim and any comparable claim. In a corporation, fairness is one of the routes under § 302A.255 by which a deal with a director “is not void or voidable.” It fits when the records show an informed, good-faith decision. The risk is the time and cost of discovery and trial.
- Negotiate a resolution. A settlement, or a buyout of the plaintiff’s interest as part of one, can end the dispute. In an LLC, a transfer of the plaintiff’s interest “does not by itself cause a member’s dissociation” under § 322C.0502, subd. 1, and § 322C.0903, subd. 1, lets the suit be maintained only by a person who “remains a member while the action continues.” It fits when the business needs the conflict over. Under Rule 23.09, any dismissal or compromise of a derivative action it covers still needs the court’s approval, with notice “to shareholders or members in such manner as the court directs.”
Derivative claims can arrive alongside direct claims by the same owner, and the page on defending a shareholder oppression claim covers that second track.
Can the company's regular lawyer defend me too?
Sometimes. Under Minn. R. Prof. Conduct 1.13(a), the company’s lawyer “represents the organization acting through its duly authorized constituents,” and under Rule 1.13(f) that lawyer “may also represent any of its directors, officers, employees, members, shareholders or other constituents, subject to the provisions of Rule 1.7.” A comment to the rule explains that when a derivative claim involves “serious charges of wrongdoing by those in control of the organization,” a conflict may arise, and Rule 1.7 then governs who represents the directors and the company. I suggest asking the company’s lawyer directly whom they represent.
Will the company pay my legal fees before the case ends?
It may have to, if you ask in writing and meet the statute’s steps, and unless the governing documents prohibit or condition it. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 3, a corporation must pay reasonable expenses in advance on your written request. The payment follows your written affirmation of a good faith belief that you meet the indemnification criteria, your written undertaking to repay, and a determination that the known facts do not rule out indemnification. Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 3, sets the same steps for an LLC. The limits on what those documents can say about advances differ between the two statutes, and the indemnification section above quotes each one.
What if the owner who sued sells out during the case?
For an LLC, the answer turns on whether the plaintiff stops being a member, because under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0903, subd. 1, a derivative action “may be maintained only by a person that is a member at the time the action is commenced and remains a member while the action continues.” The early-dismissal section above covers when membership ends. For a corporation, in Vista Fund v. Garis (Minn. 1979), the Minnesota Supreme Court noted that courts have generally held such an action abates, but said “we need not examine the correctness of this rule.”
Does it matter that I am an officer and not a director?
Yes, for any clause limiting liability. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 2, the articles may limit an officer’s liability only for breaches during the time the corporation is publicly held. They can never limit it “in any action by or in the right of the corporation,” and a derivative suit is brought to enforce a right of the corporation. If you hold both roles, the director clause in § 302A.251, subd. 4, reaches breach “as a director,” and these limits govern your conduct as an officer. An officer must still meet the same good-faith standard as a director under subdivision 1, and Minn. Stat. § 302A.521 covers officers in their official capacity.
Defending a Derivative Lawsuit
A derivative suit is the company’s claim, so the company’s documents and the corporation or LLC statute decide much of the defense. I suggest working through four points in order, because each can change what the suit costs you. The first is whether the plaintiff can bring the claim, and the second is whether a special litigation committee will decide it. The third is what your standard of conduct and any exculpation clause protect, and the fourth is whether the company must advance your defense costs. Each answer matters, and the disagreement between the owners behind it can be part of a larger business partner dispute.
If you have been named as a defendant in a derivative lawsuit, email [email protected] with a short description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.