Under Minnesota law, money a parent gave a child before death affects the other heirs in one of three ways, and the type decides which rule applies. A loan is a debt the estate can collect, including by subtracting it from your sibling’s share of the estate, though under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-903 your sibling keeps “the benefit of any defense” available in a direct lawsuit on the debt. A gift counts against your sibling’s share only if the will, your parent’s contemporaneous writing, or your sibling’s written acknowledgment says it should. A gift with no such writing stays with your sibling and is not counted. When the estate proves the money was handed over and was intended as a loan, the sibling who says it was a gift must prove the gift by clear and convincing evidence. In a suit to recover a parent’s property, proof that it belonged to your parent immediately or shortly before death can also shift that burden to your sibling. A presumption of gift can apply instead when a parent paid the purchase price of property put in a child’s name.

The rules come from several sources. Whether the money was a gift or a loan is decided by Minnesota court decisions. What a gift or a loan does to your sibling’s share is set by the Minnesota probate code, chapter 524. Statutes outside chapter 524 on collecting old debts, and federal and Minnesota tax law, also apply. This article is written for an heir or beneficiary of a Minnesota estate whose sibling received money from a parent before death and who now disputes what that money was. Money in a joint account follows a different statute, explained in a joint bank account after a parent dies. For how I handle these disputes, see my trust and estate litigation page.

How Does Minnesota Decide Whether Money a Parent Gave Was a Gift or a Loan?

Under Minnesota case law, the person claiming a gift must prove it by clear and convincing evidence, subject to a presumption of gift for some purchases a parent pays for. In Oehler v. Falstrom, 142 N.W.2d 581 (Minn. 1966), the Minnesota Supreme Court stated: “The legal elements are (1) delivery, (2) intention to make a gift on the part of the donor, and (3) absolute disposition by him of the thing which he intends to give to another.” It added: “A gift, however, can only be established by clear and convincing evidence.”

Oehler also set the order of proof. A man gave his neighbors $5,500 toward a home down payment and later sued, saying it was a loan. The court stated that “when plaintiff had established by the evidence submitted in his behalf that he had delivered the two checks totaling $5,500 to defendants and that these had been applied in making the downpayment on the home purchased by them, and that such payments were intended to be a loan to them, he had made out a prima facie case of ownership and the burden then rested on defendants to establish a gift.” For you, the same order applies once the estate proves delivery and a loan: your sibling must then prove the gift. The estate does not always have to prove a loan: describing an earlier decision in which “the plaintiff brought an action to recover personal property belonging to the estate of a deceased person,” the court in Oehler stated that “proof that the property belonged to decedent immediately or shortly prior to death made out a prima facie case of ownership and that the burden then rested on the one who asserted a gift of such property to prove such gift.” Quoting an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision, the Court of Appeals in Kiecker v. Estate of Kiecker, 404 N.W.2d 881 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), stated that when property is transferred to one person and “the purchase price is paid by another and the transferee is the wife, child, or other natural object of the bounty of the person paying the purchase price, there is a presumption that the transaction is a gift, unless the person paying the purchase price manifests an intention that the transferee shall not have the beneficial interest in the property,” but it did not apply the presumption because “the record does not establish by clear and convincing evidence that decedent intended to ‘pay the purchase price’ of the farm.”

The burden does not decide every case for the estate. The trial court in Oehler had ruled only that the lender failed to prove a loan, and the Supreme Court sent the case back to decide whether the gift was proved. On that same record, the trial court found a gift, and the Supreme Court affirmed in Oehler v. Falstrom, 160 N.W.2d 403 (Minn. 1968). Relying on an earlier decision, it stated that “intent can be inferred from the circumstances surrounding the gift.”

In re Estate of Lobe, 348 N.W.2d 413 (Minn. Ct. App. 1984), involved a claim against a woman’s estate. The man who had been in a romantic relationship with her said he had loaned her money over five years. Quoting an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision, the court described clear and convincing proof as proof that the facts are “highly probable.” It affirmed the denial of his claim, noting “the lack of any written evidence of debt.” Neither Oehler nor Lobe involved a parent and child, and each turned on its own record.

When Does a Lifetime Gift Count Against a Sibling’s Share If There Is No Will?

When a parent dies without a will, a lifetime gift reduces a sibling’s inheritance only if your parent’s contemporaneous writing or your sibling’s written acknowledgment says it should count. Minn. Stat. § 524.2-109, paragraph (a), provides that a lifetime gift to someone who is an heir at the parent’s death “is treated as an advancement against the heir’s intestate share only if” one of two writings exists.

The first is when “the decedent declared in a contemporaneous writing or the heir acknowledged in writing that the gift is an advancement.” The second is when “the decedent’s contemporaneous writing or the heir’s written acknowledgment otherwise indicates that the gift is to be taken into account in computing the division and distribution of the decedent’s intestate estate.”

In plain terms, the writing must come from your parent or from your sibling. The statute requires your parent’s writing to be “contemporaneous” with the gift and sets no timing word for your sibling’s written acknowledgment. Family memory of what was said is not a writing. Without one of the two writings, the gift is not treated as an advancement, and your sibling’s share is computed without it.

When a writing exists, paragraph (b) sets the value: “property advanced is valued as of the time the heir came into possession or enjoyment of the property or as of the time of the decedent’s death, whichever first occurs.”

How Does a Will Change the Way a Lifetime Gift Is Counted?

When a parent leaves a will, a lifetime gift reduces what the will gives your sibling only if the will, your parent’s contemporaneous writing, or your sibling’s written acknowledgment says so. Minn. Stat. § 524.2-609, paragraph (a), provides that the gift “is treated as a satisfaction of a devise in whole or in part, only if (i) the will provides for deduction of the gift, (ii) the testator declared in a contemporaneous writing that the gift is in satisfaction of the devise or that its value is to be deducted from the value of the devise, or (iii) the devisee acknowledged in writing that the gift is in satisfaction of the devise or that its value is to be deducted from the value of the devise.”

A “devise” is a gift made by the will, and the “devisee” is the person who receives it. Paragraph (b) values a partial satisfaction “as of the time the devisee came into possession or enjoyment of the property or at the testator’s death, whichever occurs first.”

I suggest reading the whole will, including any clause about loans, advances, or amounts a child owes, because a will can deduct a gift or address a debt directly. In Hurtig v. Gabrielson, 525 N.W.2d 612 (Minn. Ct. App. 1995), the court noted that a father who had signed a $50,000 bank note for his daughter “could also have directed that her debt was to be forgiven if that had been his intent.” If your parent’s estate passes through a trust, I suggest reading the trust’s terms too, because in Hurtig the court relied on them: “The terms of the trust give appellant absolute discretion over distributions to the contingent beneficiaries.”

How Does the Estate Collect a Loan From a Sibling Who Also Inherits?

The estate’s personal representative can collect a loan from a sibling by suing on it, or by subtracting it from the sibling’s share of the estate. Minn. Stat. § 524.3-903 provides: “The amount of a noncontingent indebtedness of a successor to the estate if due, or its present value if not due, shall be offset against the successor’s interest; but the successor has the benefit of any defense which would be available to the successor in a direct proceeding for recovery of the debt.”

A “successor” under Minn. Stat. § 524.1-201, clause (55), includes “those persons, other than creditors, who are entitled to property of a decedent under the decedent’s will, this chapter or chapter 525.” A sibling who inherits under the will or without one fits that definition. A sibling whose share passes through a trust can stand differently. In Hurtig, where the will poured the estate into a trust, the court stated “Respondent is not entitled to property under the decedent’s will: she may receive property if and only if appellant in his discretion as trustee determines that it should be distributed to her,” and it relied on the trust’s terms, quoted above under how a will changes the count. For an estate with no will, Minn. Stat. § 524.2-110 adds: “A debt owed to a decedent is not charged against the intestate share of any individual except the debtor.”

The personal representative has other tools too. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-709, the personal representative “may maintain an action to recover possession of property or to determine the title thereto.” Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-715, “Except as restricted or otherwise provided by the will or by an order in a formal proceeding and subject to the priorities stated in section 524.3-902,” a personal representative, “acting reasonably for the benefit of the interested persons,” may under clause (17) “effect a fair and reasonable compromise with any debtor or obligor, or extend, renew or in any manner modify the terms of any obligation owing to the estate.” When the personal representative is the sibling who owes the money, Minn. Stat. § 524.3-713 provides that “any transaction which is affected by a substantial conflict of interest on the part of the personal representative, is voidable by any person interested in the estate except one who has consented after fair disclosure, unless (1) the will or a contract entered into by the decedent expressly authorized the transaction; or (2) the transaction is approved by the court after notice to interested persons.”

Kiecker, cited above, shows the estate winning. An uncle had sold his farm to his nephew on a contract for deed, and his will left the nephew 22% of the estate. The nephew sued for the deed, claiming the rest of the payments had been forgiven. The court held that gift was not proved and affirmed the estate’s judgment for a payment owing. When a sibling files a claim against the estate, the estate’s own counterclaim rule also applies, as explained in counterclaims in Minnesota trust and estate disputes.

What Evidence Shows Whether the Money Was a Gift or a Loan?

I suggest starting with any writing made at the time, because the cases below turn on what the record shows. Examples include a signed promissory note, a written repayment schedule, or a letter from your parent calling the money a gift, a loan, or an advance. Repayment history also helps, because checks and transfers from your sibling back to your parent show how both of them treated the money.

The cases show which facts courts weigh:

  • Silence and conduct. In the 1968 Oehler decision, the court relied on the lender’s conduct: “Briney took no steps to establish that the $5,500 was a loan until at least 6 months after the money had been delivered. During those 6 months he did not set up any schedule of repayment.”
  • Missing paperwork. In Lobe, the absence of “any written evidence of debt” supported the finding of gifts.
  • Writings, clear and unclear. In Kiecker, the uncle had signed a receipt stating that unpaid payments “have been gifted,” which the court described as a receipt “which forgave arrearages.” A check memo reading “Last Payment on Fram [sic]” did not, because “no evidence explains what decedent meant by that memo.”
  • Who controlled the money. In In re Estate of LeBrun, 458 N.W.2d 139 (Minn. Ct. App. 1990), a son said an envelope of cash in his father’s filing cabinet had been a gift to him. The trial court found the father had controlled the cash until his death, and the Court of Appeals affirmed that it belonged to the estate.

Tax filings can also help. Under 26 U.S.C. § 6019, “Any individual who in any calendar year makes any transfer by gift other than” the excluded transfers “shall make a return for such year with respect to the gift tax imposed by subtitle B.” A gift tax return your parent filed reporting the transfer is a record of how your parent described it. Bank statements, your parent’s notes or ledgers, and emails between your parent and your sibling round out the record. A challenge to a gift as the product of pressure or dementia is a separate claim, covered in contesting a will for undue influence.

What Time Limits Apply to Collecting an Old Family Loan?

An old family loan may be too old to collect, and the limit depends on whether the loan is a negotiable note. For a loan without a negotiable note, Minn. Stat. § 541.05, subdivision 1, provides: “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within six years.” Clause (1) of that subdivision lists an action “upon a contract or other obligation, express or implied, as to which no other limitation is expressly prescribed.” Minn. Stat. § 541.01 provides that “Actions can only be commenced within the periods prescribed in this chapter, after the cause of action accrues, except where a different limitation is prescribed by the Uniform Commercial Code or, in special cases, by other statute.” Neither section says when a family loan accrues. In In re Estate of Fauskee, 497 N.W.2d 324 (Minn. Ct. App. 1993), applying the statutes as they read in 1990, a son’s two notes to his mother “provided for payment on demand,” and “no demand was ever made.” The court noted, citing an earlier decision, that a “demand note is considered due immediately,” but it quoted an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court rule: “Where, by the contract of the parties, express or implied, the money or debt which is the subject-matter thereof is payable only upon a demand in fact therefor, the statute of limitations does not begin to run until an actual demand for payment is made. The demand, however, must be made within a reasonable time, which is ordinarily the period of the statute of limitations; but, where the parties contemplated a delay in making the demand to some indefinite time in the future, the statutory period for bringing the action is not controlling as to the question of reasonable time.” The trial court found that “the agreement was that John would repay his mother when he was financially able to do so,” and the Court of Appeals held that “recovery on the notes by Effa Fauskee’s estate was not barred by the statute of limitations.” Check the current text of §§ 541.01 and 541.05 before relying on this period.

For a negotiable promissory note, Minn. Stat. § 336.3-118, paragraph (a), provides: “Except as provided in subsection (e), an action to enforce the obligation of a party to pay a note payable at a definite time must be commenced within six years after the due date or dates stated in the note or, if a due date is accelerated, within six years after the accelerated due date.” Paragraph (b) provides: “Except as provided in subsection (d) or (e), if demand for payment is made to the maker of a note payable on demand, an action to enforce the obligation of a party to pay the note must be commenced within six years after the demand. If no demand for payment is made to the maker, an action to enforce the note is barred if neither principal nor interest on the note has been paid for a continuous period of ten years.” Subsections (d) and (e) cover bank checks and certificates of deposit. Section 336.3-118 reaches only a note under Article 3 of the Uniform Commercial Code, because Minn. Stat. § 336.3-104 provides that “‘Instrument’ means a negotiable instrument,” and a negotiable instrument must, among other requirements, be “payable to bearer or to order at the time it is issued or first comes into possession of a holder.” Check the current text of § 336.3-118 before relying on these periods.

Your parent’s death can extend the count. Minn. Stat. § 541.16 provides: “If the death of a person occurs within the last year of the period of limitation for the commencement of an action, the action may be commenced by the personal representative at any time within one year after such death.” The second sentence of § 541.16 covers claims against a person who has died, not claims the estate holds. Check the current text of § 541.16 before relying on this period.

Under chapter 541, a later promise to pay counts only in writing, though a Minnesota Court of Appeals decision has enforced an oral acknowledgment. Minn. Stat. § 541.17 provides: “No acknowledgment or promise shall be evidence of a new or continuing contract sufficient to take the case out of the operation of this chapter unless the same is contained in some writing signed by the party to be charged thereby; but this section shall not alter the effect of a payment of principal or interest.” For a loan governed by § 541.05, a signed note from your sibling admitting the debt, or a payment, is therefore worth looking for, because § 541.17 reaches “the operation of this chapter.” In Fauskee, the son “orally acknowledged the two debts” at a family meeting after his mother’s death. The court stated that “an oral acknowledgement may estop a debtor from using this defense” and affirmed the finding that his “oral acknowledgment of the notes was enforceable.” That holding was a second ground, because the court had already held that the time limit never began to run.

The offset statute keeps your sibling’s defenses. Section 524.3-903, quoted above under collecting a loan, gives your sibling any defense available in a direct lawsuit on the debt. In In re Trust Created Under Last Will of Cargill, 420 N.W.2d 268 (Minn. Ct. App. 1988), a trust beneficiary’s debt had been discharged in bankruptcy. The court held: “The language of this provision expressly permits respondent to raise the bankruptcy as a defense to the trustee’s claim to future distributions.” Cargill also described an older Minnesota rule that let an estate deduct even a debt too old to sue on. It noted that the statute that codified “the concept of common law offset or right of retainer” was repealed when Minnesota adopted the Uniform Probate Code. Hurtig later distinguished Cargill because Cargill did not involve a discretionary trust. It held that a beneficiary’s bankruptcy discharge did not let her override a trustee’s absolute discretion and compel distributions. Cargill involved a bankruptcy discharge, not a time limit to sue.

What Are the Gift and Estate Tax Consequences of Money Given Before Death?

Federal gift tax is owed by your parent as the donor, and your sibling can become liable for it if it goes unpaid. Under 26 U.S.C. § 2502, subsection (c), “The tax imposed by section 2501 shall be paid by the donor.” Under 26 U.S.C. § 6324, subsection (b), “If the tax is not paid when due, the donee of any gift shall be personally liable for such tax to the extent of the value of such gift.” Under 26 U.S.C. § 2503, subsection (b), “In the case of gifts (other than gifts of future interests in property) made to any person by the donor during the calendar year, the first $10,000 of such gifts to such person shall not, for purposes of subsection (a), be included in the total amount of gifts made during such year.” The same subsection provides that “the $10,000 amount contained in paragraph (1) shall be increased by an amount equal to” an inflation adjustment, so the current figure is higher.

Minnesota has its own estate tax rule for gifts made shortly before death. Minn. Stat. § 291.016, subdivision 2, clause (3), adds to the Minnesota taxable estate “the aggregate amount of taxable gifts as defined in section 2503 of the Internal Revenue Code, made by the decedent within three years of the date of death.” Check the current text of § 291.016 before relying on this period. Subdivision 3 then subtracts an exclusion amount, which is “$3,000,000 for decedents dying in 2020 and thereafter.” For an estate near that figure, a taxable gift to your sibling made in that period can raise the Minnesota estate tax the estate owes.

A family loan made during life has its own tax and documentation rules, covered in intrafamily loan forgiveness.

What Are Your Options When You and Your Sibling Disagree About the Money?

You have four routes: a direct conversation, a written request to the personal representative, mediation, and a petition in the probate court. Each can be combined with a negotiated settlement at any stage.

  1. Talk with your sibling. I suggest starting by asking for any note, repayment records, or writing about the money, because a single document can settle the question for both of you. This route fits when the facts are unclear to everyone. Its risk is delay while estate assets are distributed.
  2. Ask the personal representative in writing. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-703, paragraph (a), a personal representative “is a fiduciary who shall observe the standards of care in dealing with the estate assets that would be observed by a prudent person dealing with the property of another.” I suggest putting your request to treat the money as a loan in writing, because it records your demand, and one of the fee routes below begins “after demand.”
  3. Mediate. A mediator can help siblings divide an estate around a disputed loan without a court deciding it, as explained in mediating an inheritance dispute.
  4. Petition the court. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-105, “Any interested person in a decedent’s estate may apply to the registrar for determination in the informal proceedings provided in this article, and may petition the court for orders in formal proceedings within the court’s jurisdiction including but not limited to those described in this article.” The court’s jurisdiction extends to “actions to determine title to property alleged to belong to the estate.” Minn. Stat. § 524.1-201, clause (34), defines an interested person to include “heirs, devisees, children, spouses, creditors, beneficiaries and any others having a property right in or claim against the estate of a decedent, ward or protected person which may be affected by the proceeding.”

Legal fees can come from the estate, on both sides. Minn. Stat. § 524.3-720 provides that a personal representative “who defends or prosecutes any proceeding in good faith, whether successful or not,” is entitled to “necessary expenses and disbursements including reasonable attorneys’ fees incurred” from the estate. For an heir, the same section applies “When after demand the personal representative refuses to prosecute or pursue a claim or asset of the estate or a claim is made against the personal representative on behalf of the estate and any interested person shall then by a separate attorney prosecute or pursue and recover such fund or asset for the benefit of the estate, or when, and to the extent that, the services of an attorney for any interested person contribute to the benefit of the estate, as such, as distinguished from the personal benefit of such person.” In those cases, “such attorney shall be paid such compensation from the estate as the court shall deem just and reasonable and commensurate with the benefit to the estate from the recovery so made or from such services.”

When your sibling is the personal representative and refuses to treat the money as a loan, the steps to restrain or remove a personal representative are in executor misconduct in Minnesota. Probate has its own deadlines, including limits on opening an estate and on reopening one after it closes, which are quoted in the deadlines to contest a will or trust in Minnesota.

What if the sibling who got the money died before our parent?

The answer turns on whether your parent left a will. With no will, Minn. Stat. § 524.2-109, paragraph (c), provides that the property “is not taken into account in computing the division and distribution of the decedent’s intestate estate, unless the decedent’s contemporaneous writing provides otherwise.” For a loan, Minn. Stat. § 524.2-110 provides that if the debtor fails to survive the decedent, “the debt is not taken into account in computing the intestate share of the debtor’s descendants.” Under a will, a gift counts only if paragraph (a) of Minn. Stat. § 524.2-609 makes it a satisfaction, and paragraph (c) provides that if the devisee fails to survive, “the gift is treated as a full or partial satisfaction of the devise, as appropriate, in applying sections 524.2-603 and 524.2-604, unless the testator’s contemporaneous writing provides otherwise.”

Did our parent forgive the loan by writing on a check or telling my sibling to forget it?

Not unless your sibling proves it, because forgiving a loan is a gift. In Kiecker v. Estate of Kiecker, 404 N.W.2d 881 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), a nephew claimed his uncle had forgiven the remaining farm payments, and the Court of Appeals stated: “The alleged donee bears the burden of proving the gift by clear and convincing evidence.” The uncle’s check memo did not meet that burden, and the court noted that the uncle “never confirmed the gift orally.” The estate kept its judgment for the payment owing.

Can my sibling, as personal representative, simply declare the money a gift?

No. Minn. Stat. § 524.3-703, paragraph (a), provides that a personal representative “is a fiduciary who shall observe the standards of care . . . that would be observed by a prudent person dealing with the property of another.” Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-105, any interested person may petition the court. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-720, when “a claim is made against the personal representative on behalf of the estate” and you, through a separate attorney, recover the money for the estate, that attorney is paid from the estate as the court finds “just and reasonable and commensurate with the benefit to the estate.”

What happens if the loan was owed to both parents and one parent is still living?

The surviving parent may own the debt, leaving the estate nothing to collect. In In re Estate of LeBrun, 458 N.W.2d 139 (Minn. Ct. App. 1990), a son and his wife signed a promissory note payable to “Peter or Elaine LeBrun,” the father and his second wife. The trial court found the note jointly owned with a right of survivorship, and the Court of Appeals held the evidence sufficient “to uphold the trial court’s finding that the note is the property of Elaine, as the surviving joint tenant.” I suggest reading the note’s payee line first, because it can decide who may collect.

Can I challenge the gift itself if our parent had dementia or was pressured?

Yes, a lifetime gift can be challenged in its own claim, separate from the question whether it was a gift or a loan. A claim that the parent lacked capacity or was under a sibling’s undue influence attacks a gift everyone agrees was made. That claim has its own rules and burden of proof. They are covered in this site’s article on contesting a will for undue influence in Minnesota, in its section on lifetime gifts, deeds, and account changes.

Does the same rule apply to money my sibling took from a joint account with our parent?

Not entirely. Money in a joint bank account is governed by Minnesota’s multiparty accounts statute, which sets its own presumption about who owns the balance at death and its own rules for money withdrawn before the death. That subject is covered in this site’s article on a joint bank account after a parent dies in Minnesota. The rules on this page apply to money your parent handed over or paid directly to your sibling.

Next Steps on Money a Parent Gave Before Death

The first step is to find the writing. A signed note or repayment record supports a loan the estate can collect under § 524.3-903, subject to your sibling’s defenses under that section. Without a will, a writing that meets § 524.2-109, meaning your parent’s contemporaneous writing or your sibling’s written acknowledgment, counts a gift against your sibling’s share. Under a will, a writing that meets § 524.2-609 has the same effect. Without any writing, the question can turn on whether your sibling proves a gift by clear and convincing evidence, or on the presumption of gift for a purchase price a parent paid. I suggest asking the personal representative in writing to take a position on the money before the estate is distributed, because § 524.3-903 takes the offset from your sibling’s interest in the estate. More on how I handle these cases is on my trust and estate litigation page.

To find out whether the estate has a claim to money your parent gave your sibling, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send confidential documents.