When someone posts something false about your business, the right response depends on what the post is. A fake review, or one that only gives a bad opinion, calls for a calm public reply and a report to the platform. Legal action fits a post that states a provable false fact, including a competitor’s fake review that disparages your business, and even then a demand letter can come before any lawsuit. In Minnesota, defamation is common law, built by court decisions rather than a statute. Two Minnesota statutes and a federal rule sit on top of it. The 2024 anti-SLAPP statute can make a business that sues pay the reviewer’s attorney fees related to an early motion to dismiss, if the act applies and the reviewer wins that motion. Dropping the suit after the motion is filed does not end that exposure. The Deceptive Trade Practices Act gives a business its own claim against disparagement by false or misleading representation of fact made in the course of business. The FTC’s rule on fake reviews bars businesses from writing them. This page, part of my business torts practice, weighs each option for a Minnesota business owner facing a false post on Google, Yelp, or another review site.
What Should You Do First When a False Review Appears?
I suggest saving proof of the review, checking your own records for the reviewer, and deciding what kind of review it is before anyone at the business replies, because those steps cost nothing. They also keep every later option open.
- Save proof. When someone asked me about a false review, I suggested saving a screenshot of each post right away, showing the date, the web address, and the account name, because posts can be edited or deleted. The posting date also matters for the deadline described later on this page.
- Check your records. A review from someone who says they were a customer, when your business has no record of them, may come from someone angry at the business or from a competitor.
- Sort the review. A review falls into one of three kinds: a fake review by someone who was never a customer; a review by a real customer that states a false fact; or a pure opinion or an honest account of a bad experience. The First Amendment protects pure opinion, a statement that cannot be proven true or false. Google’s policy also allows reviews that describe negative experiences in a respectful manner, so the third kind can stay up.
- Hold the reply. I suggest deciding on your response before anyone posts a reply, because a reply written in anger becomes part of the public record next to the review.
A health care practice has added privacy rules for any reply; the options for that reader are on the pages about fake patient reviews and how to answer a patient review without breaking HIPAA.
How Do Your Options Compare, From a Public Reply to a Lawsuit?
Your options run from a public reply and a report to the platform, through a direct conversation and a request to correct the post, to a demand letter and a lawsuit. For most reviews, I suggest starting with the cheaper options, because, as I told someone asking about false posts, each step can also draw more attention to the posts.
- A public reply. It fits every kind of review. It costs a few minutes. The risk is a reply that argues, reveals private details, or falsely accuses the reviewer.
- More genuine reviews. It fits a business whose rating rests on a handful of reviews. It costs staff attention over time. The risk is breaking a platform rule or the FTC rule on incentives and insider reviews.
- A conversation with the poster. It fits a real customer with a real complaint. It costs time and some pride. The risk is a conversation the poster describes in the next post.
- An owner-to-owner call with a competitor. It fits a fake review you can tie to a competing business. It costs one call. The risk is accusing someone you cannot prove wrote the review.
- A report to the platform. It fits fake reviews, conflicts of interest, harassment, and other policy violations. It costs nothing. The risk is a decision you cannot control.
- A request to correct or remove the post. It fits a false fact in a review by someone you can identify. It costs a short letter or message. The risk is that the request becomes the next post.
- A demand letter. It fits a provable false statement of fact, especially one a request did not fix. It costs a lawyer’s fee for the letter. The risk is the backfire described below.
- A lawsuit. It fits a false statement that causes real, measurable harm. It costs the most of these options in fees and time. The risk is the anti-SLAPP fee-shifting rule and the attention a case draws.
A Short, Factual Public Reply
A calm reply speaks to future customers more than to the reviewer. A good reply thanks the reviewer, states your side in a sentence or two without arguing, and invites the person to contact the business directly. A reply should not accuse the reviewer of lying unless you can prove it. Under the FTC’s rule, it is unlawful to use “a public false accusation in response to a consumer review that is made with the knowledge that the accusation was false or made with reckless disregard as to its truth or falsity” in an attempt to get the review removed (16 C.F.R. § 465.7(a)).
A Record of Genuine Reviews
A single false review does less harm next to many genuine ones. The platforms set different rules for asking. Google’s content policy allows a business to “Solicit or encourage the posting of content that does represent a genuine experience, without offering incentives to do so or attempting to influence the rating or the contents of the review.” Yelp’s Content Guidelines state: “Businesses should never ask customers to write reviews.” The FTC rule bars any business from offering incentives “conditioned expressly or by implication on, the writing or creation of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, whether positive or negative” (16 C.F.R. § 465.4). The FTC rule also bars an officer or manager from writing a review of the business without “a clear and conspicuous disclosure of the officer’s or manager’s material relationship to the business” (16 C.F.R. § 465.5(a)). An officer or manager who solicits or demands reviews from employees or immediate relatives also violates the rule when a resulting review appears “without a disclosure of the reviewer’s material relationship to the business” (16 C.F.R. § 465.5(c)(1)). That applies if the officer or manager “Encouraged the prospective reviewer not to make such a disclosure,” “Did not instruct that prospective reviewers disclose clearly and conspicuously their relationship to the business,” or “knew or should have known that such a review appeared without such a disclosure and failed to take remedial steps.” Federal law also limits review restrictions in a standard-form contract imposed on an individual customer, a rule covered in contracts that bar customer reviews.
A Conversation With the Poster
A real customer with a real complaint may correct or remove a post once the problem is fixed. A private call or message that offers to make the problem right can do more than any letter. I suggest keeping that conversation about the customer’s experience rather than the review, and never offering money or a discount for removing it, for the reasons in the FAQ below.
A Request to Correct or Remove the Post
When a review states a specific false fact, a short, polite request can ask the poster to correct or remove that statement. The request works best when it names the false sentence, states the true fact in one line, and asks for one specific change. A request that threatens a lawsuit becomes a demand letter, with the risks covered in the demand-letter section below.
What Does Google Remove, and How Does Reporting Work?
Google removes reviews that break its own content policies, such as fake engagement, reviews by people with a conflict of interest, and harassment. Google’s help page states: “You can report any review, but only those that violate Google policies are eligible for removal.” It adds: “Google doesn’t get involved in conflict between businesses and customers.”
Google’s policy for Maps contributions says fake engagement “is not allowed and will be removed.” It bars users from posting content “on a competitor’s place or business to undermine that business’ or product’s reputation.” It treats a conflict of interest as including “current or former employment, a contractual or consultory relationship, or other professional or personal affiliations that demonstrate a conflict of interest (such as industry competitors, familial relationships, etc.).” Its offensive-content rule bars “Unsubstantiated allegations of unethical behavior or criminal wrongdoing,” while the same policy states: “We do allow content that describes negative experiences in a respectful manner.” Yelp’s guidelines tell users not to review “your peers or competitors in your industry.”
On Google, you report a review from your Business Profile or Google’s Reviews Management Tool by choosing the reason it breaks the policy. Google’s help page on reporting reviews says that “Review evaluation typically takes several days” and that you can “submit a one-time appeal” if you disagree with the decision. For one person asking about false posts, I suggested a report that named the specific policy the post broke. The video on this page suggests having a group of people report a review; Google’s help page states, “Do not report a review just because you disagree with it or dislike it.”
The platform decides under its own policy because federal law does not make it answer for the review. Under 47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1), “No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider.”
What Makes a Review Defamatory Under Minnesota Law?
A review is defamatory in Minnesota when it states something false about the business, the statement was communicated to others, it tends to harm the business’s reputation, and readers understand it to refer to the business. Truth defeats the claim, minor inaccuracies do not make a statement false, and pure opinion, which cannot be proven true or false, is protected.
A Minnesota Supreme Court case on online reviews is McKee v. Laurion, 825 N.W.2d 725 (Minn. 2013), and the doctor who sued lost it. A patient’s son posted an account of a hospital examination of his father by “Dr. McKee, a neurologist,” on “rate-your-doctor” websites, and Dr. McKee sued him, “asserting claims for defamation per se and interference with business.” The Minnesota Supreme Court held that “none of the six statements is actionable either (1) because there is no genuine issue of material fact as to the falsity of the statements or (2) because the statements are not capable of conveying a defamatory meaning that would harm respondent’s reputation and lower him in the estimation of the community.” The court quoted an earlier decision for the rule that “true statements, however disparaging, are not actionable.” It added: “If the statement is true in substance, minor inaccuracies of expression or detail are immaterial.” And it held that calling the doctor “a real tool” was pure opinion, because the term “cannot be reasonably interpreted as stating a fact and it cannot be proven true or false.”
What this means for your business: a review that gets details slightly wrong but captures what happened is not defamatory. A review that invents a fact, such as a sale that never happened, a charge you never made, or a crime no one committed, is the kind that can be. A false review aimed only at the quality of your product or service is different. In Advanced Training Systems, Inc. v. Caswell Equipment Co., 352 N.W.2d 1 (Minn. 1984), the Minnesota Supreme Court held that a product-disparagement claim requires “special damages in the form of pecuniary loss directly attributable to defendant’s false statements,” and it wrote that allegations of shoddy goods “merely disparage the product and do not libel the producer.” For the general rules, see Minnesota defamation law.
What Laws Reach a Fake Review Posted by a Competitor?
Two rules reach a competitor’s fake review. The FTC’s rule makes it unlawful for a business to write a review that materially misrepresents whether the reviewer exists or used or otherwise had experience with the business. Minnesota’s Deceptive Trade Practices Act reaches a person who, in the course of business, disparages another business by false or misleading representation of fact.
The FTC rule, 16 C.F.R. § 465.2(a), states: “It is an unfair or deceptive act or practice and a violation of this part for a business to write, create, or sell a consumer review, consumer testimonial, or celebrity testimonial that materially misrepresents, expressly or by implication” certain facts. Those facts include “That the reviewer or testimonialist exists” and “That the reviewer or testimonialist used or otherwise had experience with the product, service, or business that is the subject of the review or testimonial.” The FTC enforces that rule; for your business, it is a point to raise in a platform report and a demand.
Minnesota gives you a claim of your own. Minn. Stat. § 325D.44, subd. 1 defines deceptive trade practices by a person acting “in the course of business, vocation, or occupation.” One of them is when the person “disparages the goods, services, or business of another by false or misleading representation of fact.” Under § 325D.44, subdivision 2, “a complainant need not prove competition between the parties or actual confusion or misunderstanding.” The remedy is an injunction, and under Minn. Stat. § 325D.45, subd. 1, “Proof of monetary damage, loss of profits, or intent to deceive is not required.” Fees can run either way. Section 325D.45, subdivision 2, lets the court award attorney fees against a party that “has brought an action knowing it to be groundless,” or against one that “has willfully engaged in the trade practice knowing it to be deceptive.” Because the statute’s words reach someone acting in the course of business, it fits a competitor better than a customer writing about a personal experience.
Before any of those steps, an owner-to-owner call can end the problem if you can tie the review to a competing business. The call works best when you describe what you found rather than accuse, and ask for the review to come down. For more on a competitor’s false statements, see false statements by a competitor.
When Does a Demand Letter Work, and When Does It Backfire?
A demand letter works best when the review states a provable false fact, the author is identifiable, and the letter asks for a specific result, such as removing or correcting the false sentence. It backfires when the reviewer posts about the letter, and a letter resting on no real claim can violate the FTC’s rule against groundless legal threats.
The Minnesota Court of Appeals’ decision in J&D Dental v. Hou, 26 N.W.3d 491 (Minn. App. 2025) shows the backfire risk. After the business’s lawyer sent a customer a demand letter about her Google review, she “posted seven additional and substantially similar Google reviews,” each stating that the business had threatened legal action after she shared her experience. One review became eight. I suggest writing any letter expecting that the reviewer may post it.
Federal law also limits what a letter may say. Under 16 C.F.R. § 465.7(a), it is unlawful “For anyone to use an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a public false accusation in response to a consumer review” in certain attempts. The rule covers an attempt to “Prevent a review or any portion thereof from being written or created” or to “Cause a review or any portion thereof to be removed, whether or not that review or a portion thereof is replaced with other content.” The rule defines the term in 16 C.F.R. § 465.1(p): “An unfounded or groundless legal threat is a legal threat based on claims, defenses, or other legal contentions unwarranted by existing law or based on factual contentions that have no evidentiary support or will likely have no evidentiary support after a reasonable opportunity for further investigation or discovery.” A letter about an opinion review fits that definition far more easily than a letter about a provable false fact.
For one review the business believed was false, though, I recommended a cease-and-desist letter, because the business wanted the review removed and the poster to stop posting. For more on the risks, see how a cease-and-desist letter can backfire, and for the parts of a letter, see what a defamation cease-and-desist letter contains.
How Does Minnesota’s Anti-SLAPP Law Affect a Lawsuit Over a Review?
Minnesota’s anti-SLAPP law, the Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, lets a reviewer who is sued ask the court to dismiss the case early. If the reviewer wins that motion, the court must award the reviewer’s reasonable attorney fees related to it. For an ordinary review, the law applies only if the review is speech on a matter of public concern, which courts decide case by case. Dropping the lawsuit after the reviewer files the motion does not end that exposure.
The act applies to a claim based on a person’s exercise of free speech “on a matter of public concern,” under Minn. Stat. § 554.08(b)(3). It also applies, with no public-concern showing, to a “communication on an issue under consideration or review in a legislative, executive, judicial, administrative, or other governmental proceeding” (Minn. Stat. § 554.08(b)(2)). That can include a review on an issue already under consideration or review in a court case or another governmental proceeding. Paragraph (c) lists causes of action the act does not cover. Paragraph (d) applies the act to a cause of action under paragraph (c), clause (3), (8), or (11), when it is “a legal action against a person related to the communication, gathering, receiving, posting, or processing of consumer opinions or commentary, evaluations of consumer complaints, or reviews or ratings of businesses.” In Paragon Restorations, LLC v. Robinet Productions, LLC, No. A25-0826 (Minn. App. Dec. 29, 2025), discussed below, the Court of Appeals reasoned that “the business-review provision is not an exception to the requirements of Minnesota Statutes section 554.08 (b).”
The steps move quickly. Under Minn. Stat. § 554.09, the reviewer “may file a special motion for expedited relief to dismiss the cause of action.” Under Minn. Stat. § 554.10(a)(1), filing it means “all other proceedings between the moving party and responding party, including discovery and a pending hearing or motion, are stayed,” with limited exceptions. If the act applies, Minn. Stat. § 554.13(a) requires dismissal with prejudice when, among other grounds, the business “fails to establish a prima facie case as to each essential element of the cause of action.” And under Minn. Stat. § 554.16, when the reviewer who filed the motion wins it, “the court shall award court costs, reasonable attorney fees, and reasonable litigation expenses related to the motion” to that reviewer.
Under Minn. Stat. § 554.13(b) and (c), a voluntary dismissal without prejudice “does not affect a moving party’s right to obtain a ruling on the motion and seek costs, attorney fees, and expenses,” and a voluntary dismissal with prejudice “establishes for the purpose of section 554.16 that the moving party prevailed on the motion.”
Two Court of Appeals decisions held that the act did not apply to a personal-grievance review. In J&D Dental, the court decided public concern “on a case-by-case basis,” weighing the content, form, and context of the speech. The court wrote: “The majority of Hou’s speech recounts an individual grievance about her personal experience at J&D Dental, making this case more like those in which the Supreme Court has determined speech was not on a matter of public concern.” The court added that it expressed “no opinion on the merits” of the business’s defamation claims. It also noted that health care speech held to be of public concern elsewhere “reached matters of broader public import.” In Paragon, the court addressed speech outside a governmental proceeding. It held that the reviewer must show public concern “regardless of whether” the suit relates to reviews or ratings of businesses. The Minnesota Supreme Court is reviewing Paragon and scheduled oral argument for November 5, 2026, so the answer could change. For the statute in more detail, see Minnesota’s anti-SLAPP law.
What Can a Lawsuit Recover, and What Does It Cost?
A business that wins a defamation case recovers damages for harm to its reputation, but presumed damages (damages awarded without proof of actual loss) are limited when the review involves a matter of public concern. Against that recovery sit attorney fees, months of litigation, and the attention a lawsuit draws to the review.
The Minnesota Supreme Court addressed presumed damages in Maethner v. Someplace Safe, Inc., 929 N.W.2d 868 (Minn. 2019). The court held that “a private plaintiff may not recover presumed damages for defamatory statements” when the statements involve “a matter of public concern unless the plaintiff can establish actual malice.” If the statements do not involve a matter of public concern, “presumed damages are available if” the plaintiff can show the statements are “defamatory per se.” The public-concern question therefore bears on both the anti-SLAPP motion and presumed damages.
Winning the anti-SLAPP motion does not win the case. In Paragon, the business defeated the reviewer’s motion, yet, as the Court of Appeals described it, “the district court still dismissed Paragon’s defamation claim, separately determining that Paragon had failed to state a claim upon which relief could be granted and that no fact issue precluded judgment of dismissal as a matter of law.”
The cost that matters may not be money. A legal fight that people expect to bring closure can instead keep the dispute going and leave them frustrated, distracted, stressed, and poorer for the fees. I suggest weighing the review’s real effect on new business against that cost. For how damages are measured, see business defamation claims.
How Do You Identify an Anonymous Poster?
Learning who wrote an anonymous review can require a lawsuit against the author and a subpoena to the platform for the account information.
Because 47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1) bars treating the platform “as the publisher or speaker” of a review someone else wrote, the defamation claim runs against the author. The video on this page suggests naming the review website, such as Google, in the lawsuit along with the poster. Under 47 U.S.C. § 230(e)(3), though, “No cause of action may be brought and no liability may be imposed under any State or local law that is inconsistent with this section,” so a defamation claim over the review runs against its author, not Google. The need for a lawsuit makes unmasking a litigation step, with the anti-SLAPP exposure described above, rather than a separate, cheaper option. For the broader steps, see protecting your reputation against anonymous posters.
What Deadline Applies to a Defamation Claim Over a Review?
Minnesota sets a limitations period for libel and slander claims in Minn. Stat. § 541.07, and a claim not commenced before it runs is barred. Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 3.01, a civil action “is commenced against each defendant” when the summons is served on that defendant, or by one of the other methods the rule lists, not when papers are filed with the court. The statute provides: “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code, this section, section 541.05, 541.073, 541.076, or 604.205 otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within two years” for the actions it lists. Those include actions “for libel, slander, assault, battery, false imprisonment, or other tort resulting in personal injury”. Because of those exceptions, check the current text, and the date the review was posted, before relying on any deadline. The screenshot you saved in the first step keeps a record of when the review appeared.
What Does the Video Say About Fake or Defamatory Reviews?
What Can You Do About a Fake or Defamatory Online Review?
The first thing I recommend that people do is ask a group of people to report the review as fake or defamatory, or otherwise against the terms of service.
For example, if you have a Google Review from somebody who says they were a customer, but you have no record of that person being a customer, it might be somebody who is angry at you. Maybe it is a competitor; maybe it is somebody who has some other issue with you. Sometimes these things just come across randomly, but you can have a group of people who have Google Accounts report that review as a violation of the Google terms of service. And often, with enough of those reports, Google will just remove that. So that is what I recommend as a first step.
Other options, though, include sending a cease and desist letter to the party involved or bringing legal action so a lawsuit, and naming Google as a party or this other individual as a party.
What Are the Three Steps?
I kind of follow those three steps. Step one, have a number of people report the review as against the terms of service. Step two, is a demand letter or a cease and desist letter. You can see more about that in the description below. And third, you can bring a lawsuit, and it is important that you name both the owner of the review website, like Google, for example. And if you know it, the person who posted the review. If you don’t know that person’s name, often, you can get it after starting the lawsuit against the web hosting platform. Then they will share information with you during the course of discovery, and you can learn who that person is, what phone numbers or email addresses they have used, etc.
Conclusion
All right, if you have any constructive feedback, please feel free to provide that. I am somewhat new to this, and I am working to provide value that is relevant to you as business owners and other listeners interested in entrepreneurial and business topics. It is my goal to demystify business law so that people have a practical understanding and are able to run their businesses and avoid legal problems and hopefully experience a better business and a better life.
If you would like to read about me, you can go to aaronhall.com. If you would like the free videos that I send out only exclusively to subscribers, you can get them at aaronhall.com/free. And if you would like more content like this, you are welcome to subscribe to this YouTube channel, and you will be notified next time when we go live, which I expect will be quite soon here. Thanks for joining me today.
Can our customer contract prohibit negative reviews?
Not in a standard-form contract with an individual customer. Under the Consumer Review Fairness Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45b(b)(1), a form-contract provision prohibiting or restricting the customer’s ability to post a review is void from the start, and Section 45b(c) makes offering one unlawful. Section 45b(b)(3) excepts bans on disclosing “trade secrets or commercial or financial information obtained from a person and considered privileged or confidential,” “personnel and medical files and similar information the disclosure of which would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy,” and others. The act excludes employment and independent contractor contracts and preserves defamation claims.
Can we offer a discount to customers who post a review?
Not on Google, and never for a positive review. The FTC rule at 16 C.F.R. § 465.4 bars incentives conditioned on reviews expressing a particular sentiment, positive or negative. Google’s policy bars incentives such as payment, discounts, or free goods for posting any review, though it allows asking for genuine reviews without one; Yelp’s guidelines say businesses should never ask customers for reviews. Elsewhere, the FTC’s Endorsement Guides at 16 C.F.R. § 255.5, administrative interpretations rather than a rule, state that an incentivized review that “fails to clearly and conspicuously disclose the incentives provided to that reviewer is likely deceptive.”
Is Google liable for leaving a false review up?
Generally no. Under 47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1), a website is not treated as the publisher or speaker of information that someone else provided, so a defamation claim over a false review runs against the person who wrote it. Whether Google removes the review depends on whether it breaks Google’s own content policy, which is why a report should name the specific policy the review violates.
What if a former employee wrote the review?
Report it to the platform as a conflict of interest. Google’s content policy lists current or former employment as a conflict of interest, and Yelp’s guidelines tell users not to review their own business or employer. If the review also states a false fact about your business, the defamation rules on this page apply to a former employee like anyone else. Proving who wrote an anonymous review can require a lawsuit and a subpoena to the platform.
Should we pay the reviewer to take the review down?
No. Google’s content policy bars a business from offering incentives such as payment, discounts, or free goods in exchange for the revision or removal of a negative review, and it removes content posted after such an incentive. An offer of money can also become the reviewer’s next post. A request to correct or remove a false statement, made without payment, avoids the platform-policy problem, though the reviewer may still post about it.
Choosing Your Response to a False Review
For most false reviews, the right order is to reply well, report what breaks the platform’s rules, and save a letter or lawsuit for a provable false statement of fact. Sorting each review first avoids the two costliest mistakes: suing over an opinion, and sending a letter that becomes the next review. I handle these disputes as part of my business torts practice. If you want to know whether a specific review supports a letter or a claim, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.