Commercial general liability insurance policies for businesses are necessary. They protect businesses against covered claims if they are ever sued. There are a number of exclusions in a lot of commercial general liability policies. One of those exclusions is the Knowingly False Publication Exclusion. Coverage is excluded for a “personal and advertising injury” arising out of oral or written publication of material.
When there is a personal and advertising injury there is an exclusion that prevents coverage if the publication at issue was false and the business, or insured, knew that it was false when it was published. The reason that this exclusion exists is because insurance companies want to prevent insureds from shifting liability to an insurance company for any lawsuit that arises out of intentionally publishing false material. An example of the exclusion would read that the coverage is excluded for “personal and advertising injuries arising out of oral or written publication of material, if done by or at the direction of the insured with knowledge of its falsity.” In an unpublished Minnesota decision General Cas. Co. of Ill. v. Four Seasons Greetings, 2004 WL 2987796 (Minn. App. 2004), the Minnesota Court of Appeals held that the advertising exclusion did not apply because the actions of the insured were not false. In that case, Four Seasons Greetings was sued for allegedly infringing the copyright of Taylor Corporation by copying manufacturing, producing, publishing, selling, promoting, and/or advertising greeting cards that were substantially similar to Taylor’s works. When the insurance company denied a defense and coverage, a declaratory action was commenced. Because the insured’s advertising was not knowingly false, the exclusion did not bar coverage.