A business insurance coverage review reads each of your company’s policies against what the company actually does and what its contracts promise, so a gap surfaces before renewal instead of after a claim. In Minnesota, courts give clear policy language its plain and ordinary meaning, construe ambiguous language against the insurer, and require the insurer to prove that an exclusion applies. Statutes require an employer liable to pay workers’ compensation to insure it or hold the commissioner’s order permitting self-insurance, though that chapter excludes some owners unless the company elects to cover them. They also require reparation security for a vehicle of a type required to be registered or licensed, or principally garaged, in Minnesota. For commercial liability and property policies from licensed insurers, statutes require notice before the insurer cancels, declines to renew, or renews on worse terms, with exceptions that include excess and surplus lines policies.
This guide is for the owner or chief financial officer (CFO) of an owner-led Minnesota company preparing for its next renewal. It sits within my work on Minnesota business compliance, and it covers what to read, which Minnesota rules decide what the words mean, and how the work divides between your broker and a lawyer.
What Does a Business Insurance Coverage Review Cover?
A business insurance coverage review covers every policy the company holds, compared with every risk the company runs and every insurance promise it has made. The product is a written list of gaps: risks no policy reaches, exclusions that remove coverage the company assumed it had, and contract promises the endorsements do not deliver. Once a gap is on the list, your broker can price the cost of closing it, and the company can decide with that number in hand.
The work runs in five steps:
- Gather the full policies. You need the declarations page, every coverage form, and every endorsement, because a proposal summary or a certificate of insurance may not show the exclusions or conditions.
- List what the company does. The list should name each location, owned and leased property and its current value, vehicles, products and services, and employees and contractors. It should also name the personal data the company holds and the changes planned for the coming year, because each item is a risk some policy has to reach.
- List the insurance promises. Pull the insurance clause from each customer, vendor, lease, and loan agreement.
- Read each policy against both lists. The reading should cover the insuring agreement, the definitions, the exclusions, the conditions (notice, cooperation, and other insurance), and every endorsement, because a defined term can narrow what the insuring agreement appears to give.
- Write down each gap. I suggest asking the broker for the cost and the endorsement or policy that would close each one, because once a gap has a price, the company can decide whether to close it.
How Do Minnesota Courts Read Policy Language and Exclusions?
Minnesota courts read clear policy words by their plain and ordinary meaning, read ambiguous words against the insurer, and make the insurer prove that an exclusion applies. In Travelers Indemnity Co. v. Bloomington Steel & Supply Co., 718 N.W.2d 888 (Minn. 2006), a case about a corporation’s general liability and umbrella policies, the Minnesota Supreme Court stated: “If the language of an insurance contract is unambiguous, it must be given its plain and ordinary meaning.” It added, “But if the language is ambiguous, it will be construed against the insurer, as drafter of the contract.”
The same opinion divides the burden of proof: “While the insured bears the initial burden of demonstrating coverage, the insurer carries the burden of establishing the applicability of exclusions.” In American Family Insurance Co. v. Walser, 628 N.W.2d 605 (Minn. 2001), a homeowner’s policy case, the court wrote, “We also construe exclusions strictly against the insurer.”
These rules shape the review in two ways. Because your company must first show that a loss fits the insuring agreement, the review should start with the insuring agreement and its defined terms. Because clear words are enforced as written, a review should not count on an ambiguity argument to rescue a clear exclusion. My page on the intentional acts exclusion shows how one liability exclusion is read.
Which Coverage Does Minnesota Law Require a Company to Carry?
Minnesota law requires workers’ compensation coverage of an employer liable to pay compensation, though the requirement may leave out some owners. It also requires reparation security for each company vehicle of a type required to be registered or licensed, or principally garaged, in Minnesota. Under Minn. Stat. § 176.181, subd. 2, “Every employer, except the state and its municipal subdivisions, liable under this chapter to pay compensation shall insure payment of compensation with some insurance carrier authorized to insure workers’ compensation liability in this state, or obtain a written order from the commissioner of commerce exempting the employer from insuring liability for compensation and permitting self-insurance of the liability.”
That required policy may not cover the owners themselves. Under Minn. Stat. § 176.041, subd. 1, “This chapter does not apply to any of the following,” and the list includes “a sole proprietor,” a partner engaged in a business, and “an executive officer, as defined in section 176.011, subdivision 11, of a closely held corporation having less than 22,880 hours of payroll in the preceding calendar year, if that executive officer owns at least 25 percent of the stock of the corporation.” Clause (18) adds a manager of “a limited liability company having ten or fewer members and having less than 22,880 hours of payroll in the preceding calendar year, if that manager owns at least a 25 percent membership interest in the limited liability company.” Subdivision 1a lets the business elect coverage for these owners. Notice of the election “shall be provided in writing to the insurer,” “The insurance policy shall be endorsed to indicate the names of those persons for whom coverage has been elected or terminated under this subdivision,” and “An election of coverage under this subdivision shall continue in effect as long as a policy or renewal policy of the same insurer is in effect.” I suggest confirming that the policy is endorsed with the name of each owner the company means to cover. I also suggest making the election again with any new insurer, because the statute ties the election to a policy of the same insurer.
Subdivision 3 of § 176.181 sets the penalty for failing to insure. Section 176.181, subd. 3, lets the commissioner order an employer “to pay a penalty of up to $1,000 per employee per week during which the employer was not in compliance,” and it provides that “the term ’employer’ includes any owners or officers of a corporation who direct and control the activities of employees.” Subdivision 3(b) provides, “An employer shall have ten working days to contest such an order by filing a written objection with the commissioner, stating in detail its reasons for objecting. If the commissioner does not receive an objection within ten working days, the commissioner’s order shall constitute a final order not subject to further review, and violation of that order shall be enforceable by way of civil contempt proceedings in district court.” It continues, “If the commissioner does receive a timely objection, the commissioner shall refer the matter to the Court of Administrative Hearings for an expedited hearing before a compensation judge. The compensation judge shall issue a decision either affirming, reversing, or modifying the commissioner’s order within ten days of the close of the hearing.” It ends, “If the compensation judge affirms the commissioner’s order, the compensation judge may order the employer to pay an additional penalty if the employer continued to employ persons without complying with subdivision 2 while the proceedings were pending.” Check the current text of section 176.181 before relying on these periods. Under § 176.181, subd. 4, “any employer willfully and intentionally failing to comply with the provisions of subdivision 2 is guilty of a gross misdemeanor.”
For vehicles, Minn. Stat. § 65B.48, subd. 1, requires “Every owner of a motor vehicle of a type which is required to be registered or licensed or is principally garaged in this state” to maintain “a plan of reparation security” while operation or use is contemplated. That plan insures “against loss resulting from liability imposed by law for injury and property damage sustained by any person arising out of the ownership, maintenance, operation or use of the vehicle.” Subdivision 1 adds, “The plan of reparation security shall provide for basic economic loss benefits and residual liability coverage in amounts not less than those specified in section 65B.49, subdivision 3, clauses (1) and (2).”
These two statutes do not require the other lines on this page, though a contract may. I suggest checking any license the company holds for its own insurance condition, because a license can carry a requirement these statutes do not.
How Do You Match Your Contracts’ Insurance Promises to Your Policies?
You match them by listing what each contract requires and then finding the endorsement that delivers each item. A customer, landlord, or lender agreement can require specific lines and limits, additional-insured status for the other party, primary and noncontributory wording, or a waiver of subrogation. Each of those is a promise your company made, and the policy has to carry it. In a building and construction contract, which Minn. Stat. § 337.01, subd. 2, defines as “a contract for the design, construction, alteration, improvement, repair or maintenance of real property, highways, roads or bridges,” part of that promise can be void: under Minn. Stat. § 337.05, subd. 1(b), “A provision that requires a party to provide insurance coverage to one or more other parties, including third parties, for the negligence or intentional acts or omissions of any of those other parties, including third parties, is against public policy and is void and unenforceable.” Subdivision 1(c) to (e) keeps listed promises valid, including coverage “for the promisee’s vicarious liability, or liability imposed by warranty, arising out of the acts or omissions of the promisor,” and paragraph (b) “does not apply to building and construction contracts for work within 50 feet of public or private railroads, or railroads regulated by the Federal Railroad Administration.”
For each contract, write down the required item in one column and the policy form or endorsement number that meets it in the next. I suggest reading the endorsement itself, because the endorsement’s wording decides which claims against the other party it covers. Where a gap appears, the company has two paths: ask the broker for the endorsement or limit, or negotiate the contract’s insurance clause at its next renewal or amendment.
In a building and construction contract, § 337.05, subd. 2, provides that if “(a) a promisor agrees to provide specific types and limits of insurance; and (b) a claim arises within the scope of the specified insurance; and (c) the promisor did not obtain and keep in force the specified insurance; then, as to that claim and regardless of section 337.02, the promisee shall have indemnification from the promisor to the same extent as the specified insurance.” Subdivision 3 removes that indemnity only if “(a) the specified insurance was not reasonably available in the market; and (b) the promisor so informed the other party to the agreement to insure before signing the agreement, or signed the agreement subject to a written exception as to the nonavailable insurance.” Subdivision 4 sets a separate rule for deductibles and retentions: if “(1) a promisor agrees to provide specific types and limits of insurance; and (2) a claim arises within the scope of the specified insurance; and (3) the insurance provided by the promisor includes a self-insured retention or a deductible amount; then, as to that claim and regardless of section 337.02, the promisee shall have indemnification from the promisor to the full extent of the deductible amount or self-insured retention.” I suggest closing a gap in a construction contract through the broker first, because subdivision 2 reaches a claim that arises while the company lacks the specified insurance. My page on vendor insurance requirements explains additional-insured endorsements, certificates, and waivers of subrogation, and what happens when the promised insurance is missing.
What Notice and Claims-Made Terms Should the Review Check?
The review should confirm what each policy requires the company to report, to whom, and by when, because each policy sets its own notice terms, though a late notice does not always end coverage. In Reliance Insurance v. St. Paul Insurance Companies, 239 N.W.2d 922 (Minn. 1976), a case about two lawyers’ professional liability policies that required notice “as soon as practicable,” the Minnesota Supreme Court held “that despite delay in notification the insurers are required to afford coverage under their contracts in the absence of actual prejudice, should liability be otherwise shown according to the terms of the policies.” The court added, “We are not holding that in some cases such an extraordinary length of time between an event and notification would not be prejudicial in itself, but this factual setting is not one of those cases.” In Cargill, Inc. v. Evanston Insurance Co., 642 N.W.2d 80 (Minn. App. 2002), a company’s environmental impairment liability policy stated that “[a]s a condition precedent to his right to the protection afforded by this policy, the Insured shall, as soon as practicable, give to the Company written notice” of any claim. The Court of Appeals sent the timeliness question to a fact-finder but held that “the fact-finder shall not consider whether the timing of Cargill’s notice prejudiced Evanston.”
Minnesota’s claim-handling statute limits how an insurer may use a missed deadline for written notice of loss or proof of loss, but it yields to the policy. Under Minn. Stat. § 72A.201, subd. 4, it is an unfair settlement practice, “unless otherwise provided by law or in the policy,” to require “written notice of loss or proof of loss within a specified time” and then seek to “relieve the insurer of its obligations if the time limit is not complied with.” That applies “unless the failure to comply with the time limit prejudices the insurer’s rights and then only if the insurer gave prior notice to the insured of the potential prejudice.”
Subdivision 10 adds, “This section does not apply to workers’ compensation insurance. Nothing in this section abrogates any policy provisions.” So the review reads the notice conditions of each policy, including whether timely notice is a condition of coverage. I suggest reporting a claim or incident found late to the broker rather than assuming the coverage is lost, because, as Reliance shows, a late notice does not always end coverage.
I suggest checking whether each liability policy is written on an occurrence basis or a claims-made basis, because a claims-made policy sets its own terms for when a claim must be reported. I also suggest naming one person to receive every demand letter, lawsuit, and agency notice. That person should send each one to the broker the same week, because the reporting period in a claims-made policy can run while a letter sits on a desk. My pages on late notice and on notice clauses in claims-made policies cover the disputes that follow a late report.
How Should You Weigh D&O, Cyber, and Employment Practices Coverage?
Weigh each of these lines against the claim it answers and the company’s exposure to that claim. Directors and officers (D&O) coverage answers claims against the people who run the company. Cyber coverage answers the costs and claims that follow a data breach, and employment practices coverage answers claims by employees and applicants. A general liability policy may not reach any of them, so the review asks whether each risk is insured somewhere.
D&O. Minnesota permits the coverage. Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 7, provides that “A corporation may purchase and maintain insurance on behalf of a person in that person’s official capacity,” whether or not the corporation would have been required to indemnify the person. Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 7, gives a limited liability company the same permission for “a member, manager, or governor.” The company has its own exposure as well. Under § 302A.521, subd. 2(a), “Subject to the provisions of subdivision 4, a corporation shall indemnify a person made or threatened to be made a party to a proceeding by reason of the former or present official capacity of the person” when that person meets the statute’s conditions, including that the person “acted in good faith,” and § 322C.0408, subd. 2(a), sets a parallel rule for a limited liability company. Subdivision 4 of each section lets the company’s articles or bylaws, or for a limited liability company its articles of organization or operating agreement, “prohibit indemnification or advances of expenses otherwise required by this section” or add conditions. For a corporation, such a limit “may not apply to or affect the right of a person to indemnification or advances of expenses with respect to any acts or omissions of the person occurring prior to the effective date” of the provision. I suggest reading those documents alongside the D&O quote, because they set what the company itself must pay for its directors and officers. An outside director may ask for this coverage before joining, which my page on when to form a board of directors covers.
Cyber. A breach can bring a statutory duty. Under Minn. Stat. § 325E.61, subd. 1, a business that “owns or licenses data that includes personal information, shall disclose any breach of the security of the system” to each Minnesota resident “whose unencrypted personal information was, or is reasonably believed to have been, acquired by an unauthorized person.” Subdivision 4 says the section does “not apply to any ‘financial institution’ as defined by United States Code, title 15, section 6809(3).” Under subdivision 1(b), a business that holds personal information it does not own must notify the owner of a breach “immediately following discovery.” The review asks whether any policy pays for meeting that duty and for the claims that follow. The duty itself is covered in Minnesota data breach notification requirements.
Employment practices. A company with employees faces claims over hiring, discipline, and termination. My page on employment practices liability insurance explains how that coverage works.
For all three lines, ask whether defense costs reduce the limit, whether the policy is claims-made, and whether the company or the insurer picks defense counsel.
How Do You Check Whether Limits and Property Values Still Fit?
Limits fit when they meet every contract minimum and the largest claim the company can plausibly face. Property values fit when they reflect what it would cost today to repair or replace the property on the policy’s valuation basis (replacement cost or actual cash value). I suggest comparing each liability limit with the highest minimum in your contracts list. I also suggest comparing each scheduled property value with a current estimate, because last year’s figure may no longer match the cost to repair or replace.
Minnesota’s fire insurance chapter addresses coinsurance clauses. Minn. Stat. § 65A.08, subd. 5, provides: “Any policy may contain a coinsurance clause, if the insured requests the same, in writing, of which fact such writing shall be the only evidence, and if, in consideration thereof, a reduction in the rate of premium is made by the company.” It continues that “in case of loss, the actual cash value of the property so insured at the time of the loss, including the buildings, shall be the basis for determining the proper amount of the coinsurance, and the amount of loss, notwithstanding any previous valuation of the building.”
A coinsurance clause ties the payment to whether the company insured its property to a stated share of its value. I suggest asking the broker whether any property form carries one, what share it sets, and whether the file holds the written request the statute describes. Because the statute measures value at the time of the loss, updating values each year keeps the insured amount close to the figure that would count.
When Should a Company Review Its Coverage?
I suggest starting the review about 90 days before the policies expire and repeating it after any change in operations, because Minnesota’s renewal notices can arrive closer to the expiration date. Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.351, when a licensed insurer “offers or purports to offer to renew any commercial liability and/or property insurance policy at less favorable terms as to the dollar amount of coverage or deductibles, higher rates, and/or higher rating plan,” the change has a notice condition. It provides that “the new terms, the new rates and/or rating plan may take effect on the renewal date of the policy if the insurer has sent to the policyholder notice of the new terms, new rates and/or rating plan at least 30 days prior to the expiration date.” It continues, “If the insurer has not so notified the policyholder, the policyholder may elect to cancel the renewal policy within the 60-day period after receipt of the notice,” and “Earned premium for the period of coverage, if any, shall be calculated pro rata upon the prior rate.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.
Section 60A.351 states its own exceptions: “This section does not apply if the change relates to guide ‘a’ rates or excess rates also known as ‘consent to rates’ or if there has been any change in the risk insured.” It also excludes ocean marine, accident and health, reinsurance, and federal Terrorism Risk Insurance Act coverage. Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.35, “Except as specifically limited in section 60A.351, sections 60A.35 to 60A.38 apply to all commercial liability and/or property insurance policies issued by companies licensed to do business in this state except ocean marine insurance, accident and health insurance, excess insurance, surplus lines insurance, and reinsurance.” A separate section, Minn. Stat. § 60A.37, sets the notice an insurer owes before it declines to renew.
Between renewals, a new location, vehicle, product line, large contract, or group of employees can open a gap. Reviewing the affected policy when the change happens keeps the gap from waiting for the next renewal.
What Notice Must an Insurer Give Before Cancelling Midterm?
The notice depends on the line of coverage. Minnesota’s rule for commercial liability and property policies from licensed insurers limits midterm cancellation to listed reasons and sets notice periods, with exceptions that include excess and surplus lines policies. Workers’ compensation policies and auto policies insuring fewer than five vehicles rated on a commercial or fleet basis follow their own statutes.
- Commercial liability and property policies. Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.36, subd. 1, “No insurer may cancel a policy of commercial liability and/or property insurance during the term of the policy, except for one or more of the following reasons,” and the list begins with “(1) nonpayment of premium.” Subdivision 2 provides, “Cancellation under subdivision 1, clauses (2) to (8), shall not be effective before 60 days after notice to the policyholder.” It adds, “A policy shall not be canceled for nonpayment of premium pursuant to subdivision 1, clause (1), unless the insurer, at least ten days before the effective cancellation date, has given notice to the policyholder of the amount of premium due and the due date,” and “No cancellation for nonpayment of premium shall be effective if payment of the amount due is made before the effective date in the notice.”
- Loss of reinsurance and new policies. Clause (6) of § 60A.36, subd. 1, covers “loss of reinsurance by the insurer which provided coverage to the insurer for a significant amount of the underlying risk insured,” and its notice “shall advise the policyholder that the policyholder has ten days from the date of receipt of the notice to appeal the cancellation to the commissioner of commerce and that the commissioner will render a decision as to whether the cancellation is justified because of the loss of reinsurance within 30 business days after receipt of the appeal.” Subdivision 3 sets the exception for new policies: “Subdivisions 1 and 2 do not apply to any insurance policy that has not been previously renewed if the policy has been in effect less than 90 days at the time the notice of cancellation is mailed or delivered. No cancellation under this subdivision is effective until at least ten days after the written notice to the policyholder.” Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.38, subd. 3, “Notice by first class mail is effective upon deposit in the United States mail.” These rules reach the policies § 60A.35 covers, and § 60A.38, subd. 1, says their rights “are in addition to and do not prejudice any other rights the policyholder may have at common law, under statute, or rules.”
- Workers’ compensation policies. Under Minn. Stat. § 176.185, subd. 1, no policy may be canceled within the policy period or ended at expiration “until a notice in writing is delivered or mailed to the insured that meets all of the requirements in paragraphs (a) to (c).” Paragraph (c) says the notice “must be mailed or delivered to the insured as follows, notwithstanding any contrary time frame for notice to the policyholder in section 60A.36 or 60A.37: (1) at least 60 days before the actual date the policy is due to expire or be terminated or canceled for any reason other than as provided in clause (2); (2) if the cancellation is due to nonpayment of premium, the notice must be sent at least 30 days before the actual date of cancellation and shall state the amount of premium due and the due date.” Under subdivision 1a(d), “If the notice required by subdivision 1 is not sent to the insured or does not meet all of the requirements of subdivision 1, the cancellation or termination shall not be effective until 60 days after the notice of cancellation or termination has been sent to the insured and received by the commissioner, except as otherwise provided in paragraph (e).” Under subdivision 1a(c), “If within the ten calendar days after the specified cancellation or termination date the notice of cancellation or termination is not sent to the insured and received by the commissioner, the cancellation or termination shall not be effective until the notice has been sent to the insured and received by the commissioner, except as otherwise provided in paragraph (d) or (e).” Paragraph (e) ends those extensions if “the employer obtains other insurance coverage or an order exempting the employer from carrying insurance as provided in section 176.181.”
- Small commercial auto policies. Minn. Stat. § 65B.14, subd. 2, brings within these sections “a plan of reparation security as defined in section 65B.48 insuring less than five vehicles rated on a commercial or fleet basis.” For that policy, Minn. Stat. § 65B.15, subd. 1, bars cancellation “unless based on one or more reasons stated in the policy which shall be limited to the following,” a list that begins with “nonpayment of premium” and “the policy was obtained through a material misrepresentation.” Subdivision 2 says the section “shall not apply to any policy of automobile liability insurance which has been in effect less than 60 days at the time notice of cancellation is mailed or delivered by the insurer unless it is a renewal policy.” Under Minn. Stat. § 65B.16, no notice of cancellation is effective “unless the specific underwriting or other reason or reasons for such cancellation or reduction in the limits of liability of coverage are stated in such notice and the notice is mailed or delivered by the insurer so as to provide the named insured with at least 30 days’ notice prior to the effective date of cancellation.” The section then provides “that when nonpayment of premium is the reason for cancellation or when the company is exercising its right to cancel insurance which has been in effect for less than 60 days at least ten days’ notice of cancellation, and the reasons for the cancellation, shall be given.” It continues that “if the company is exercising its right to cancel within the first 59 days of coverage and notice is given with less than ten days remaining in the 59-day period, the coverage must be extended, to expire ten days after notice was mailed.” I suggest checking each statute’s current text before relying on these periods, because a later amendment can change them.
How Can an Inaccurate Application Undo Coverage?
An inaccurate application can let the insurer void the policy if it held a material misrepresentation or omission, or fraud, made by the company or with its knowledge. For fire coverage, the standard fire policy bars rescission except for willful intent to defraud, but its adopting statute names exceptions, including one that also asks whether a misrepresentation increases the risk of loss. Under Minn. Stat. § 65A.01, subd. 1, a policy covering fire and other perils “shall, with respect to the peril of fire, afford the insured all the rights and benefits of the Minnesota standard fire insurance policy,” and subdivision 3b of that standard policy provides, “This policy must not be rescinded or voided except where the insured has willfully and with intent to defraud concealed or misrepresented a material fact or circumstance concerning this insurance or the subject of this insurance or the interests of the insured in this insurance.”
Subdivision 1 of § 65A.01 requires a fire policy to conform to that standard form “except as provided in sections 60A.08, subdivision 9; 60A.352; 65A.06; 65A.29; 72A.20, subdivision 17; and other statutes containing specific requirements that are inconsistent with the form of this policy.” The first of those, Minn. Stat. § 60A.08, subd. 9, provides, “No oral or written misrepresentation made by the assured, or in the assured’s behalf, in the negotiation of insurance, shall be deemed material, or defeat or avoid the policy, or prevent its attaching, unless made with intent to deceive and defraud, or unless the matter misrepresented increases the risk of loss.” Subdivision 11 of that section adds, “No misrepresentation or omission made in an application or negotiation for any policy providing directors and officers liability coverage for directors or officers of a corporation shall defeat or avoid coverage or prevent the policy from attaching for a director or officer unless the director or officer has signed the application and has actual knowledge of the facts misrepresented or omitted.”
For other coverage, the general rule comes from sections that apply to commercial liability and property policies from insurers licensed in Minnesota. Those sections exclude ocean marine, accident and health, excess, surplus lines, and reinsurance policies (Minn. Stat. § 60A.35). Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.36, subd. 5, “(a) No insurer may rescind or void a contract of liability or property insurance unless there was material misrepresentation, material omission, or fraud made by or with the knowledge of the insured in obtaining the contract or in pursuing a claim under the policy.” Subdivision 5 sets a minimum condition for materiality: “(b) No misrepresentation or omission shall be material unless knowledge by the insurer of the facts misrepresented or omitted would have led to a refusal by the insurer to make such a contract.” Rescission is separate from cancellation, and subdivision 5 says, “(d) This subdivision does not limit the right to cancel the policy prospectively for the reasons stated in subdivision 1, clause (2).” That clause lists “misrepresentation or fraud made by or with the knowledge of the insured in obtaining the policy or in pursuing a claim under the policy.”
I suggest having the person who knows each fact answer that part of the application, and keeping a copy of what was submitted, because the statute turns on what was stated and who knew it. Revenue, payroll, locations, prior claims, and the work the company performs are the answers to check against the company’s records.
How Can the Review Work Be Divided?
The work divides by what each party takes on: your broker places the coverage and follows your instructions, and Minnesota case law generally limits an insurance agent’s duty to what the agent undertook. In Gabrielson v. Warnemunde, 443 N.W.2d 540 (Minn. 1989), a homeowner’s policy case, the Minnesota Supreme Court wrote, “An insurance agent’s duty is ordinarily limited to the duties imposed in any agency relationship, to act in good faith and follow instructions.” It added, “Absent an agreement to the contrary, an agent has no duty beyond what he or she has specifically undertaken to perform for the client.” The court recognized that “special circumstances” in the relationship can create a further duty.
In Atwater Creamery Co. v. Western National Mutual Insurance Co., 366 N.W.2d 271 (Minn. 1985), a business claimed its agent should have found a gap in its coverage without being asked. The court held that “The standard of care in this case needed to be established by expert testimony.” Because Gabrielson measures the agent’s duty by what the agent undertook, I suggest putting each coverage request to the broker in writing.
The company has three ways to run the review, and each fits a different company:
- Broker-led. The broker reviews the program with you. I suggest asking whether that review is part of its service and what it covers, because the answer defines what the broker has undertaken. This fits a company with few contracts and standard operations.
- Owner-led with the broker. An owner or CFO works through the five steps above and sends the broker written questions. This fits a company with time to read the policies and a short contracts list.
- Broker and lawyer together. A lawyer reads the contracts’ insurance clauses against the endorsements, reads exclusions and definitions under the Minnesota rules above, and checks the application answers.
A company that already has outside general counsel can ask that lawyer to read the insurance clauses alongside the contracts the lawyer already handles.
Are we bound by an exclusion we never read?
Yes, when the policy plainly labels it as an exclusion and its words apply. In Atwater Creamery Co. v. Western National Mutual Insurance Co. (Minn. 1985), the Minnesota Supreme Court said its reasonable-expectations doctrine “does not automatically remove from the insured a responsibility to read the policy.” The court said that where “major exclusions are hidden in the definitions section, the insured should be held only to reasonable knowledge of the literal terms and conditions.” In Midwest Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Wolters, 831 N.W.2d 628 (Minn. 2013), the court held the doctrine did not apply to an exclusion placed under a heading for exclusions.
Must we tell our broker when we add a location, vehicle, or product line?
Minnesota case law puts that responsibility on the company. In Gabrielson v. Warnemunde (Minn. 1989), a homeowner’s policy case, the Minnesota Supreme Court wrote, “The insured bears the responsibility to inform the agent of changed circumstances which might affect the coverage of the insurance policy.” The court held that, absent special circumstances, an agent has no legal duty to update a policy at renewal or to ask about changes. I suggest telling the broker in writing, because the written request records what you asked for and when.
Can the insurer cancel our policy in the middle of the term?
It depends on the line of coverage, the insurer’s reason, and the notice it gives. A commercial liability or property policy from an insurer licensed in Minnesota follows Minn. Stat. § 60A.36, unless it is an ocean marine, accident and health, excess, surplus lines, or reinsurance policy. That section limits midterm cancellation to listed reasons, including nonpayment of premium, with an exception for new policies. Workers’ compensation policies follow Minn. Stat. § 176.185. Auto policies insuring fewer than five vehicles rated on a commercial or fleet basis (Minn. Stat. § 65B.14) follow §§ 65B.15 and 65B.16. The body section on midterm cancellation notice quotes each rule.
What if the insurer does not send a nonrenewal notice in time?
A covered commercial policy can stay in force past its expiration date. A covered policy is a commercial liability or property policy from an insurer licensed in Minnesota, other than an ocean marine, accident and health, excess, surplus lines, or reinsurance policy (Minn. Stat. § 60A.35). Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.37, notice must come “At least 60 days before the date of expiration provided in the policy,” and if it does not, “the policy shall continue in force until 60 days after a notice of intent not to renew is received by the policyholder.” Subd. 2 removes that protection if the company “has insured elsewhere, has accepted replacement coverage, or has requested or agreed to nonrenewal.” Check the current text of section 60A.37 before relying on these periods.
Can we hold our broker responsible for a gap in coverage?
Yes, in limited cases, because Minnesota case law measures an insurance agent’s duty by what the agent undertook. In Gabrielson v. Warnemunde (Minn. 1989), the Minnesota Supreme Court said an agent has “no duty beyond what he or she has specifically undertaken to perform for the client,” absent an agreement or special circumstances. In Atwater Creamery Co. v. Western National Mutual Insurance Co. (Minn. 1985), a business claimed its agent should have filled a gap unasked. The court required expert testimony on the agent’s standard of care. I suggest putting each coverage request to the broker in writing.
Business Insurance Coverage Reviews
A coverage review is a written comparison of your company’s policies with its operations and its contract promises, done before renewal and after any major change. Minnesota reads clear policy words as written, reads ambiguity against the insurer, and puts the burden of an exclusion on the insurer. It also expects the company to read its policies and tell its broker what has changed. Statutes require workers’ compensation insurance, or a self-insurance order, of an employer liable to pay compensation, and that chapter excludes some owners unless the company elects to cover them. The owner of a vehicle of a type required to be registered or licensed, or principally garaged, in Minnesota must maintain reparation security. For commercial liability and property policies from licensed insurers, statutes require notice before cancellation, nonrenewal, or renewal on worse terms, with exceptions that include excess and surplus lines policies. When a business insurance claim is denied, that page covers the options, and my Minnesota business compliance practice covers the rest of a company’s regulatory work.
If you want your company’s policies read against its contracts before renewal, email [email protected] with a brief description of the company and its renewal date. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any policies or contracts.