Winmark Corporation, a Minneapolis-based Minnesota corporation, has offered Plato’s Closet franchises for teen and young adult clothing resale stores since March 1999. Item 20 of its disclosure document reports 13 franchised Plato’s Closet stores in Minnesota at the end of 2025. This page reviews the brand’s form franchise agreement and related form documents in the disclosure document filed with Minnesota on March 16, 2026.

Four points matter most. Every person who owns 10% or more of the franchisee, and that person’s spouse, must personally guarantee the franchise and is bound by its noncompete. A terminated franchisee must pay “the fees that would be owed through the end date of this Agreement’s remaining term,” a clause I compare below with Minnesota’s rule on termination penalties. The cover page highlights a risk that Winmark’s financial condition “calls into question the franchisor’s financial ability to provide services and support to you.” And Item 19 reports average 2025 gross sales of $1,307,875 per store, but its figures stop before rent, payroll, and royalties.

What It Costs to Open and Run

Item 7, the disclosure document’s estimate of the money needed to open, puts the total initial investment at $355,700 to $467,900. The cover page says $48,200 to $55,900 of that is paid to Winmark. The largest Item 7 lines are:

  • Opening inventory: $75,000 to $85,000
  • Fixtures and supplies: $55,000 to $70,000
  • Miscellaneous pre-opening expenses: $50,000 to $65,000
  • Additional funds for the first 3 months: $40,000 to $50,000
  • Build-out labor: $35,000 to $55,000

Item 5 sets the initial franchise fee at $25,000, or $15,000 for a second store or an existing franchisee of another Winmark brand. The point-of-sale system and software bought from Winmark cost $23,200 to $30,900, including a $6,000 software license fee. Item 7 also warns: “Winmark may refuse to allow you to open your Store if you have less than $75,000 in used inventory.”

The ongoing fees in Item 6 and the franchise agreement are:

  • Continuing Fee (royalty): 5% of Gross Sales, drafted from your bank account weekly (Section 5).
  • Advertising Fee: beginning July 1, 2026, 2% of Gross Sales to a North American Ad Fund, which Winmark may raise to 3% on 60 days’ notice (Section 6(D)).
  • Advertising minimum: the Advertising Fee, cooperative advertising, and local marketing must together reach at least 6% of Gross Sales each year (Section 6).
  • Marketing Fee: $1,500 per year, which may increase by no more than $1,000 over the term (Section 6(C)).
  • Software Fee: $295 per month, with a built-in 10% annual increase.
  • Technology Fee: currently $0; Item 6 estimates $500 to $2,500 per year if Winmark establishes one.
  • Other: a $10,000 transfer fee, a $10,000 renewal fee, and interest on late amounts at the lesser of 18% per year or the legal maximum.

Item 6 puts inventory replenishment at $65,000 to $80,000 per quarter; Item 7 puts rent at $80,000 to $120,000 per year.

What Franchisees Earn (Item 19)

Item 19, where a franchisor may report what units earn, gives 2025 gross sales and gross profit for 492 franchised stores in the United States and Canada with the same owners all year. That is 492 of the 526 stores open at year end; the 34 stores that opened or changed hands in 2025 are excluded.

The average store reported gross sales of $1,307,875 and gross profit (sales minus cost of goods sold) of $833,084, about 63.7% of sales. Item 19 states that the figures “do not reflect the operating expenses that must be deducted from the gross profit figures to obtain your net income or profit.”

The results vary widely. Of the 492 stores, 297 reported gross sales between $1,000,001 and $2,000,000, and 130 reported between $500,001 and $1,000,000. Nine stores reported $500,000 or less, and 5 reported more than $3,000,000. Only 195 stores (40%) reached the average, and only 6 of the 29 stores opened in 2024 did.

Item 19 gives no Minnesota-only figures. Its footnote 7, on the sales range column, reads “As reported by Music Go Round” franchisees, a different Winmark brand. Winmark will provide written substantiation for Item 19 “upon reasonable request,” and a buyer should ask for it.

How Often Minnesota Units Close (Item 20)

Item 20 reports 12 franchised Plato’s Closet stores in Minnesota at the start of 2023 and 13 at the end of 2025, with no terminations, non-renewals, or closures in those years.

Year Open at start Opened Terminated Not renewed Reacquired by franchisor Ceased operations Open at end
2023 12 0 0 0 0 0 12
2024 12 1 0 0 0 0 13
2025 13 0 0 0 0 0 13

Across the United States and Canada, franchised stores grew from 500 to 526 over the same three years. Winmark terminated 16 franchise agreements in that period (5, 5, and 6 by year) and did not renew 1. The 7 exits in 2025 equal about 1.4% of the 515 stores open at the start of that year. Item 20’s transfer table, which counts stores sold to new owners, reports 16 transfers systemwide in 2025, including 1 in Minnesota. Winmark owns no stores itself.

Litigation Disclosed (Item 3)

Item 3 states: “No litigation is required to be disclosed in this Item.” The disclosure document reports no lawsuits or arbitrations brought by franchisees against Winmark. Former owners listed in Exhibit B are a direct source on why stores change hands.

Franchise Agreement Review: Comments and Concerns

Term and Renewal

Section 2(A) sets a term of “ten (10) years commencing on the date of this Agreement.” Section 2(B) grants renewal “for continuing ten (10) year terms” if you give written notice at least 180 days before the term ends. You must also be in compliance, remodel to current standards, pay a $10,000 Renewal Fee, and extend your lease or secure an approved new site. At Winmark’s option, you must sign its then-current agreement, which may carry different rates and “an altered Exclusive Territory.”

Yet Section 2(B)(5) says that renewal agreement “may not contain any further rights of renewal,” and the agreement does not say which clause controls at a second renewal. The cost of years 11 through 20 is also unknown when you sign.

The Minnesota addendum revises Section 15(C) so that Winmark will comply with Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subds. 3, 4, and 5. Subdivision 4 generally requires 180 days’ written notice of nonrenewal. It also requires “an opportunity to operate the franchise over a sufficient period of time to enable the franchisee to recover the fair market value of the franchise as a going concern.” These rules address a refusal to renew, not the renewal terms.

What to ask: whether a renewal agreement would include further renewal rights, and whether Winmark would cap renewal royalty and advertising rates.

Termination

Section 15(A) lists 14 grounds for termination. Section 15(B) generally gives 30 days to cure, but it allows termination “with no opportunity to cure” for many grounds. Those include failing to open on time, repeated defaults (two in any 24 months, even if cured), and “frequent and/or severe complaints from customers and/or employees.” A sales report that understates Gross Sales by more than 4% is “conclusively deemed to be materially false.”

Section 15(A)(1) requires opening when the premises are ready or within 12 months of signing, “whichever occurs first.” Item 11 puts the typical time from signing to opening at “approximately 9-12 months.” The form treats a missed opening deadline as a default with no cure period, so a permit or construction delay matters.

If the agreement “is terminated for any reason,” Section 17(A)(1) requires the franchisee to pay, within 5 days, all amounts due, “including the fees that would be owed through the end date of this Agreement’s remaining term.” The agreement does not say how future percentage-based fees would be measured. For a store terminated early, the clause could reach years of royalties, and it does not exclude a termination the franchisee makes under Section 16(A) for Winmark’s uncured breach.

Minnesota law changes the procedure. The addendum states that Winmark will comply with § 80C.14, which requires “except in certain specified cases” 90 days’ notice of termination with 60 days to cure. Subdivision 3 requires written notice “setting forth all the reasons for the termination or cancellation” and states: “No person may terminate or cancel a franchise except for good cause.” The statute makes notice effective immediately only for voluntary abandonment, a conviction related to the business, or a default that “materially impairs the good will” left uncured after 24 hours’ notice. Several of Section 15(B)’s no-cure grounds, including failure to open, repeated defaults, and customer complaints, are not on that list. Section 15(C) itself says applicable law applies where Section 15 is inconsistent with it.

On the future-fees clause, Minn. R. 2860.4400, item J, makes it unfair to require a franchisee “to consent to liquidated damages, termination penalties, or judgment notes.” The Minnesota addendum does not mention Section 17. Minn. Stat. § 80C.21 voids any provision binding a buyer of a Minnesota franchise “to waive compliance” with the Minnesota Franchise Act or its rules. The documents do not say how those provisions apply to Section 17(A)(1).

What to ask: whether Winmark would delete or cap the future-fees clause, exclude terminations for Winmark’s breach from it, extend the opening deadline for permit and construction delays, and define “frequent and/or severe complaints.”

Transfer and Sale

Section 13 gives Winmark a right of first refusal: you must first offer the business to Winmark at the outside buyer’s price and terms. Winmark has 10 business days to respond, and if it negotiates, the outside sale waits up to 30 days. If Winmark passes, you may sell on the stated terms “but not upon more favorable terms.”

Under Section 14(C), Winmark will not unreasonably withhold consent, but you must be current, not in default, and bound by the post-term noncompete. The buyer must meet Winmark’s standards and complete training, and you pay a $10,000 transfer fee (none for a transfer to a spouse or children). Winmark must also determine that the price and payment terms “will not adversely affect” the buyer’s operation of the store.

If you finance part of the sale, your note ranks behind the buyer’s fees owed to Winmark. Winmark may also require the buyer to sign its then-current agreement, with possibly different rates, an altered territory, and no further renewal rights.

Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 5 makes it unfair to “unreasonably withhold consent to an assignment, transfer, or sale of the franchise.” That applies “whenever the franchisee to be substituted meets the present qualifications and standards required of the franchisees of the particular franchisor.” The addendum states that Winmark will comply with subdivision 5.

What to ask: whether a buyer could take over your remaining term on your existing terms, and what standard Winmark uses to judge the price.

Noncompete

During the term, Section 18(A) bars any outside resale business “involving the purchase and/or sale of used clothing and accessories” without Winmark’s consent. After the agreement ends, Section 18(B) bars that business for 2 years, “whether conducted in-person or on-line.” The ban covers your location, any Plato’s Closet store, and any business “located within or markets into a ten (10) mile radius of the Franchised Location” or of any other Plato’s Closet store.

The covenant binds every owner and guarantor and applies on expiration too, unless Winmark’s breach caused the termination. Section 18(C) extends the 2 years by any time you are in breach. Section 18(E) still lets you own a Once Upon A Child or Style Encore franchise.

Minn. R. 2860.4400, item I, makes it unfair to “enforce any unreasonable covenant not to compete after the franchise relationship ceases to exist.” Section 18(D) has you stipulate to an injunction without a bond, and the Minnesota addendum amends Section 18 on that point. It provides: “Franchisee cannot consent to the Franchisor obtaining injunctive relief.” It adds: “A court will determine if a bond is required.”

What to ask: whether Winmark would limit the radius to your own store, shorten the period, and confirm whether working for a thrift store falls within the ban.

Territory

Under Section 1(B) and Item 12, you receive an Exclusive Territory drawn in Exhibit A, “typically a 3 to 5 mile radius around your Store.” Winmark agrees not to open or franchise a Plato’s Closet store “from a permanent location within the area specified in Exhibit A.” You need no sales quota to keep the territory.

Winmark may sell under other trademarks inside your territory, and under the Plato’s Closet marks online and through other channels if those sales are “not for the sole benefit of Franchisor.” Other franchisees may advertise in and serve customers from your territory without paying you. You may not sell online unless Winmark authorizes it.

Minn. R. 2860.4400, item C, makes it unfair to “compete with the franchisee in an exclusive territory” where the agreement specifically grants one. Here the agreement itself defines what the exclusivity covers, and the Minnesota addendum does not change Section 1(B).

What to ask: whether “permanent location” allows temporary or pop-up Plato’s Closet sales in your territory, and how Winmark’s online sales would benefit your store.

Fees and Price Changes

Several fees can rise during the term on notice. Section 6(D) lets Winmark raise the Advertising Fee from 2% to 3% on 60 days’ notice and “modify the frequency and/or minimum amounts” for cooperative and local marketing. Item 6 says the combined minimums will not exceed 6% of Gross Sales, but Section 6(D) does not state that ceiling. If you spend less than 6%, Winmark may require you to deposit the difference. The agreement states the Ad Fund “is not a trust or escrow account,” and Winmark provides only an “annual unaudited statement” of it.

Section 1(E)(6) of the Software License Agreement lets Winmark “change the frequency and/or the amount of the Software Fee” on 60 days’ notice. The fee also rises 10% a year, and “Adjustments are compounded annually and cumulative.” At 10% a year, the fee roughly doubles in about 7 years. Any technology fee follows the same 10% rule (Section 8(Q)).

Section 12(B) requires you to use, at your expense, one of Winmark’s approved accounting and bookkeeping suppliers and to deliver quarterly and annual financial statements in Winmark’s formats. Section 8(E) can require a remodel once every 5 years, and Section 8(P) a point-of-sale update every 5 years or less. The Minnesota addendum does not change these terms.

What to ask: whether Winmark would put a dollar cap on the Software Fee and any technology fee, and write the 6% advertising ceiling into Section 6(D).

Personal Guaranty

Exhibit C to the franchise agreement treats anyone who directly or indirectly owns 10% or more of the franchisee as a Principal Owner. It states: “All Principal Owners and their spouses must execute the following Personal Guaranty.” The guarantors jointly and severally guarantee every payment and obligation under the franchise agreement, the Software License Agreement, and any other agreement with Winmark.

The guaranty also binds each signer to “every provision contained in the Agreements including the non-compete and confidentiality provisions,” so a spouse who owns nothing is bound by the noncompete. Winmark may “proceed as if the undersigned was the primary obligor,” and each guarantor waives “any right he/she may have to require that an action be brought against Franchisee” first. The guaranty has no dollar cap or end date, and it survives the franchisee’s bankruptcy.

The cover page warns: “Your spouse must sign a document that makes your spouse liable for all financial obligations under the franchise agreement even though your spouse has no ownership interest in the franchise.” The Minnesota addendum does not change the guaranty.

What to ask: whether Winmark would release a non-owner spouse, cap the guaranty, or end it after a sale.

Disputes, Venue, and Governing Law

Section 19(A) requires arbitration in Minneapolis under the American Arbitration Association’s commercial rules, and states: “Claims in arbitration of different parties may not be joined.” Section 19(C) waives, “to the fullest extent permitted by law, the right to or claim for any punitive or exemplary damages.” Section 19(D) lets Winmark go to court for an injunction on listed breaches without posting a bond. Under Section 19(F), the losing party pays the winner’s costs and reasonable attorney fees.

Court cases go to Hennepin County or federal court in Minnesota (Section 19(E)), and Section 20(D) applies the law of the store’s state, so a Minnesota buyer gets an in-state forum and Minnesota law. Section 16(B) adds that if a party does not give written notice of a default within one year of knowing of it, “the alleged default will be deemed to be approved and waived.”

Minn. R. 2860.4400, item J, bars requiring a waiver of “rights to any procedure, forum, or remedies provided for by the laws of the jurisdiction.” It adds that “this part shall not bar an exclusive arbitration clause.” Minn. Stat. § 80C.17, subd. 5 allows three years to sue under the Act. The Minnesota disclosure addendum states: “We will comply with Minnesota Statute Section 80C.17 Subd. 5 with respect to limitation of claims.” The franchise agreement addendum does not repeat that promise.

What to ask: whether Winmark would add the three-year limitation language to the agreement addendum, make the injunction terms mutual, and make Section 5(B)’s one-way collection-cost clause mutual.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

  1. The audited balance sheet in the disclosure document’s Exhibit C reports a total shareholders’ deficit, and the North Dakota addendum defers initial fees “because of Winmark’s current financial condition.” What explains the cover-page financial risk, and would Winmark defer fees for a Minnesota buyer?
  2. How would Winmark calculate “the fees that would be owed through the end date” of the term under Section 17(A)(1), and will it delete or cap that clause?
  3. Will Winmark extend the 12-month opening deadline in Section 15(A)(1) for permit and construction delays, given its own 9-to-12-month estimate?
  4. Will a renewal or transfer agreement include further renewal rights, and what royalty, advertising rate, and territory would it carry?
  5. Will Winmark release a non-owner spouse from the personal guaranty and its noncompete, or cap the guaranty?
  6. Will Winmark set a dollar cap on the Software Fee and any future technology fee for the term?
  7. Which stores supplied Item 19’s sales range column (footnote 7 names Music Go Round franchisees), and will Winmark share its substantiation and any Minnesota results?

This review covers the form documents in Plato’s Closet’s disclosure document as filed with the Minnesota Department of Commerce on March 16, 2026. The agreement you are offered may differ, and this page is general information about those public documents, not advice about your purchase.

How much does it cost to open a Plato's Closet franchise?

Item 7 of the disclosure document filed with Minnesota on March 16, 2026 estimates a total initial investment of $355,700 to $467,900. That includes a $25,000 initial franchise fee, $75,000 to $85,000 of opening inventory, and $23,200 to $30,900 for the point-of-sale system bought from Winmark.

How much does a Plato's Closet franchise make?

Item 19 reports average 2025 gross sales of $1,307,875 and average gross profit of $833,084 for 492 U.S. and Canadian stores. Gross profit is sales minus cost of goods sold, before rent, payroll, royalties, and other operating expenses, and only 40% of the stores reached the average.

How many Plato's Closet stores are in Minnesota?

Item 20 reports 13 franchised Plato’s Closet stores in Minnesota at the end of 2025, up from 12 at the start of 2023. It reports no Minnesota terminations, non-renewals, or closures from 2023 through 2025.

What are the Plato's Closet royalty and advertising fees?

The Continuing Fee is 5% of Gross Sales, paid weekly. Beginning July 1, 2026, an Advertising Fee of 2% of Gross Sales applies, which Winmark may raise to 3%, and total advertising spending must reach at least 6% of Gross Sales. There is also a $1,500 annual Marketing Fee and a $295 monthly Software Fee.

Does my spouse have to sign a Plato's Closet personal guaranty?

Yes. The form guaranty requires every owner of 10% or more and each owner’s spouse to sign. Signers guarantee all of the franchisee’s obligations to Winmark and agree to be bound by the noncompete, even a spouse with no ownership interest.

Having This Franchise’s Documents Analyzed

If you are considering this franchise, I can analyze its disclosure document and your franchise agreement before you sign: what the fees and the initial investment really total, what the franchisor can terminate you for, what a sale or transfer will cost, what your personal guarantee covers, and which terms are worth asking to change. It is a fixed fee, quoted before work begins. Email [email protected] with the brand and where you plan to open. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents. My page on buying a franchise in Minnesota explains what to check first, and the Minnesota Franchise Directory lists the other brands I have reviewed.