Doctor’s Associates LLC, a Delaware company based in Shelton, Connecticut, franchises Subway restaurants; investment funds managed by Roark Capital Management, LLC own its parent company. Item 20 of its disclosure document reports 355 franchised Subway restaurants in Minnesota at the end of 2025, down from 400 at the start of 2023. This page reviews the form documents in the Subway disclosure document filed with the Minnesota Department of Commerce on October 29, 2026.

Four points matter most. Every owner must personally guarantee the whole franchise agreement, and ending early for default triggers damages equal to the present value of three years of royalty and advertising fees. The agreement grants no territory, so Subway may open or license another Subway anywhere, including next door. Subway gives no earnings information in Item 19. Minnesota’s franchised count fell by 45 restaurants over three years, faster than the system as a whole.

What It Costs to Open and Run a Subway

Item 5 sets the standard initial franchise fee at $15,000. Qualified existing franchisees, honorably discharged veterans buying a first franchise, and some non-traditional operators pay $7,500.

Item 6 and Section 13 of the franchise agreement set the ongoing fees. The royalty is 8% of gross sales and the advertising contribution is 4.5%, both drawn weekly from your bank account. Together that is 12.5% of every sales dollar before rent, food, and labor. Technology adds a $75 monthly Restaurant Technology Fee and about $57 per month for required point-of-sale hardware, and optional leased digital menu boards cost $155 per month. A renewal costs 25% of the then-current franchise fee (currently $3,750), and a transfer costs 50% (currently $7,500), though Section 18.C.2 lists lower fees of $3,200, $2,000, and $200 for certain transfers.

Item 7 estimates the initial investment for a single traditional restaurant at $263,000 to $630,000, with a mid estimate of $430,000. A non-traditional location runs $227,000 to $458,000. The largest lines are equipment, furniture, and décor ($110,000 to $210,000), leasehold improvements ($75,000 to $250,000), and three months of additional funds ($15,000 to $45,000). That last line does “not include royalty, advertising fees, or food costs or any allowance for an owner’s draw.” Note 11 excludes key money paid to a landlord, and Note 3 says a free-standing drive-thru may cost substantially more.

Item 7 estimates typical rent at $1,000 to $6,000 per month. Under Section 4.D, Subway chooses whether you sublease from its leasing affiliate or lease directly. Item 6 says “we or our leasing affiliate may keep the difference between the rent under the master lease and the sublease.” If the landlord ends the lease through Subway’s fault, Section 24.H.2 limits what Subway owes you. You recover “the original cost of your leasehold improvements, less depreciation based on a five (5) year life under the straight-line method,” paid when you reopen elsewhere.

What Franchisees Earn (Item 19)

Subway gives no earnings figures. Item 19, where a franchisor may report what units sell or earn, states: “We do not make any representations about a franchisee’s future financial performance or the past financial performance of company-owned or franchised outlets.”

Your projections therefore rest on your own work. Item 19 says “if you are purchasing an existing outlet, we may provide you with the actual records of that outlet,” so a buyer of an existing restaurant should ask for them. Exhibit B lists franchisees you may call. Item 20 says Subway has “signed confidentiality clauses with current or former franchisees which restrict them from speaking openly with you about their experience with us.”

How Often Minnesota Units Close (Item 20)

Item 20’s table of franchised outlets shows Minnesota’s Subway count for 2023 through 2025.

Year Open at start Opened Terminated Not renewed Reacquired by franchisor Ceased operations Open at end
2023 400 2 0 0 2 9 393
2024 393 4 0 3 1 20 374
2025 374 8 0 3 0 24 355

Minnesota fell from 400 to 355 restaurants (11.25%) over three years, while the systemwide franchised count fell from 20,576 to 18,773 (8.8%). In 2025, Item 20 reported 27 Minnesota outlets as ceased (24) or not renewed (3), 7.2% of the 374 open in January. Systemwide, terminations, non-renewals, and ceased operations totaled 1,076, or 5.5% of 19,502. Item 20’s footnotes say the closing columns may include some of the 792 locations temporarily closed at year-end. The table prints the counts as filed, so the 2023 and 2024 rows do not add up: Item 20 lists 2 and 1 Minnesota outlets as reacquired by Subway. Its footnote says these “represent franchises that have been reacquired from a franchisee and then immediately” passed to another franchisee, so they stayed franchised and did not change the count.

Litigation Disclosed (Item 3)

Item 3 refers to Exhibit L, which describes 46 actions and lists 10 more that Subway filed against franchisees in 2025. These matter most to a Minnesota buyer:

  • California franchisees (Beri). Franchisees sued on May 1, 2025, alleging among other things depressed menu pricing, required promotions “that operated at a loss,” and oversaturated markets. The case is stayed while a Connecticut court decides Subway’s motion to compel arbitration.
  • Renewal disputes (Offutt). A franchisee claimed his expired 1990s agreements automatically extended. On August 7, 2026, an arbitrator found the parties’ “course of conduct created an implied agreement to continue operating under the same terms as the original Franchise Agreements,” terminable on reasonable notice. She “specifically found that the Franchise Agreements were not renewed,” found Subway’s conduct not in bad faith but unfair under Connecticut’s unfair trade practices law, and awarded attorney’s fees only. Subway intends to seek to vacate the award. In a companion arbitration over a satellite restaurant, the arbitrator rejected the franchisee’s claims and ordered that restaurant closed; his challenge is pending in federal court.
  • Texas terminations (Khanna). Subway terminated franchisees operating 73 Texas restaurants in March 2025, alleging unapproved transfers. The franchisees counterclaimed for $11,011,250; the parties reached a settlement in principle in July 2026.
  • Settled franchisee claims. Franchisees who lost a location when its lease was not renewed alleged that Subway allowed a new location in that space. They settled in 2024 for $125,000 plus $125,000 in transfer fee waivers (Bhatt).
  • Government order. In a 2020 California consent order, Subway agreed to pay $410,000 in penalties over alleged unregistered franchise sales.

The 10 franchisor-initiated actions enforce system standards or seek termination for unpaid fees. Exhibit L puts those franchisees at about 0.2% of Subway franchisees globally, while Item 3 says about 0.03%.

Franchise Agreement Review: Comments and Concerns

The Minnesota addendum restates Minnesota’s notice periods, bars releases of Minnesota Franchise Act liability, preserves Minnesota court access, and deletes the franchisee acknowledgments in Sections 25.A through 25.F. It also promises to reimburse you for damages from using Subway’s marks as the agreement allows. It states that no acknowledgment you sign at the start waives state franchise law claims or disclaims reliance on the seller’s statements. Every other clause below applies as written unless Minnesota law itself controls.

Term and Renewal

Section 3.A says the agreement will “expire twenty (20) years from the Agreement Date.” Section 3.B allows one 20-year renewal on eight conditions. They include compliance with all material provisions during the entire term, a remodel to then-current standards, notice 12 to 18 months ahead, the renewal fee, and a general release. You must also sign the then-current agreement, whose terms “may materially differ from the terms of this Agreement,” including “a different percentage Royalty Fee and Advertising Contribution.”

Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 4 bars a non-renewal without 180 days’ written notice and a chance to recover the franchise’s fair market value. The exception is a non-renewal for good cause where the franchisee has failed to correct it. The addendum restates the 180-day notice. It also quotes Minn. R. 2860.4400, item D. That rule makes it unfair to “require a franchisee to assent to a release, assignment, novation, or waiver” that would relieve anyone of Franchise Act liability. You should ask what remodel Subway expects at renewal and whether the renewal royalty can be fixed now.

Termination

Section 22.B says the agreement “shall terminate automatically upon delivery of notice of termination to you” for 14 events, most with no cure period. They include closing without approval for two business days in 12 months, and understating royalties by more than 3% over three or more weeks unless you show inadvertent error. They also include conduct that, in Subway’s judgment, is “reasonably likely to have an adverse effect on the System.” Two events allow a cure: a health or safety violation corrected within 72 hours, and an unpaid third party, such as a landlord, paid within that party’s cure period. Section 22.B.10 adds three compliance failures in 12 months, “whether or not those failures are corrected after we deliver written notice.” Section 22.C gives 10 days to cure a missed payment and 30 days for other defaults. Under Section 22.E, after an uncured default Subway may run the restaurant itself and charge “not less than Five Hundred Dollars ($500.00) per day” plus expenses.

The agreement gives you no right to terminate for Subway’s default; Section 4.C’s exit if no site is approved within six months is the only one. Under Section 22.A, “you must give us written notice within ninety (90) days of the start of the default.” If Subway does not cure within 60 days, you may declare an arbitrable dispute.

Section 22.F carries the largest cost, and it applies if Subway terminates for your default or you quit early without cause. You must pay “the then net present value of the Royalty Fees and Advertising Contributions that would have become due” over the next three years. Based on your last 12 months of sales, that is about 37.5% of one year’s gross sales before discounting, plus any other damages Subway proves.

Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 3 states: “No person may terminate or cancel a franchise except for good cause.” It requires 90 days’ notice and 60 days to cure, with narrow exceptions such as abandonment. The addendum restates that notice, and Section 22.D says conflicting terms “not be effective.” Minn. R. 2860.4400, item J, makes it unfair to require a franchisee “to consent to liquidated damages, termination penalties, or judgment notes.” The addendum does not mention Section 22.F. You should ask Subway, in writing, whether it will delete or limit Section 22.F for a Minnesota restaurant.

Transfer and Sale

Section 18.B requires Subway’s written consent for any transfer of the agreement or of an ownership interest, and Item 6 says adding or removing an owner counts. Section 18.C.1 states that “[t]here may be no transfers before the Restaurant has opened for business.” It adds: “If you and your owners are in full compliance with this Agreement, we shall not unreasonably withhold our consent to a transfer.” That promise also requires Subway to be “satisfied in our sole business judgment” about the buyer. Conditions include the transfer fee, the buyer’s training and signing of the then-current agreement, and your general release. Under Section 18.C.3, “Completion of the Remodeling Requirements shall be your responsibility and shall be a condition of our final consent.”

Section 18.D gives Subway 30 days to buy “for the price and on the terms and conditions contained in such offer.” If your sale does not close within 120 days, that right returns. If a controlling owner dies or becomes disabled, Section 18.E requires the personal representative to transfer the interest to an approved buyer within 12 months, or the franchisee is in breach. An heir or immediate family member may take it for a $200 fee.

Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 5 makes it “unfair and inequitable for a person to unreasonably withhold consent to an assignment, transfer, or sale of the franchise.” That applies when the buyer meets the franchisor’s present qualifications and standards. The addendum’s release language covers the seller’s release too. You should ask for Subway’s current remodel standards, since a future buyer’s approval depends on them.

Noncompete

During the term, Item 17 summarizes the rule as “No direct or indirect association with a competitive business anywhere.” Section 19.E.1 defines a Competitive Business as one earning “more than twenty percent (20%) of its total gross revenue from the sale of any type of sandwiches.” Its examples include Jersey Mike’s and Jimmy John’s. For one year after the agreement ends, Section 19.C bars any association “within a three (3) mile radius of the Approved Location” or of any Subway then open or under construction. That restriction also binds owners’ immediate families, which Section 18.E defines as “parents, spouses, children and siblings, and the parents, children and siblings of spouses.”

Section 19.D sets the payment for each violation at “Fifteen Thousand Dollars ($15,000.00) plus eight percent (8%) of its gross sales,” or $100,000 per year if Subway cannot verify the competitor’s sales during the term. Because the radius runs from every Subway, it may cover much of a metro area. Minn. R. 2860.4400, item I, makes it unfair to “enforce any unreasonable covenant not to compete after the franchise relationship ceases to exist.” The addendum does not modify Section 19. You should ask to limit the radius to your own location, remove family members, and strike the $100,000 payment.

Territory

Section 2.B states that “this Agreement does not grant you any territorial rights” and that “We and our affiliates have unlimited rights to compete with you and to license others to compete with you.” Item 12 says Roark-owned affiliates may sell similar food near you, and Item 1 lists Jimmy John’s franchisor among those affiliates.

Minn. R. 2860.4400, item C, bars a franchisor from competing “in an exclusive territory,” but only where the agreement grants one, and this agreement does not. You should ask which Subway restaurants are open or approved near your site, and whether Subway will agree in writing to any protected radius.

Fees and Price Changes

Section 13.B requires the royalty “without offset, credit or deduction of any nature.” For the $75 technology fee, Section 13.E says, “We reserve the right to increase this fee at any time without notice to you.” Item 6 instead describes the fee as “subject to increases of up to 10% annually.” Sections 13.F and 13.G let Subway raise two fees at any time: the $200 monthly Legacy Support Fee for technology noncompliance and the $155 digital menu board fee. Section 13.E also reserves a future Digital Technology Fee.

Under Section 12, “you will make such expenditures as such changes or modifications in the System as we may reasonably require, including but not limited to repairs, upgrades and remodels.” Section 10.E says that, where the law allows, “you must comply with our minimum, maximum, and other pricing requirements.”

Minn. R. 2860.4400, item G, makes it unfair to “impose on a franchisee by contract or rule, whether written or oral, any standard of conduct that is unreasonable.” No saved Minnesota provision caps these fees, and the addendum leaves Section 13 unchanged. You should ask Subway to put Item 6’s 10% annual cap into the agreement.

Personal Guaranty

Section 17 requires every owner of an entity franchisee to sign the Owner’s Guaranty and Assumption of Franchisee Obligations. Each guarantor “agrees personally to be bound by, and personally liable for the breach of, each and every provision in the Agreement.” Guarantors waive notice and other defenses, are bound by the noncompete, and state that “GUARANTOR hereby waives the defense of the statute of limitations.” Item 7 adds: “Each of your owners will sign and deliver to our affiliate a guarantee of the payment obligations under the Sublease.” An owner’s personal assets therefore back the rent, the fees, and the Section 22.F damages.

The Minnesota addendum does not mention the guaranty, and no saved Minnesota provision limits its amount. Minn. Stat. § 80C.21 voids any term that “has the effect of waiving compliance with any provision” of the Franchise Act. You should ask how that statute applies to the guaranty’s waiver of “any and all other notices and legal or equitable defenses to which GUARANTOR may be entitled.” You should also ask whether the guaranty can be capped, limited to active owners, or released when you sell.

Disputes, Venue, and Governing Law

Section 24.K requires arbitration before one arbitrator in “the city where we then have our headquarters at the time of the commencement of the arbitration,” currently in Connecticut. In cases of $1,000,000 or less, “the only depositions will be for the sole purpose of preserving testimony.” Section 24.J applies Florida law, and Section 24.G waives punitive and consequential damages and states, “YOU AND WE IRREVOCABLY WAIVE TRIAL BY JURY.” Section 24.H.1 bars most claims not brought “within one (1) year from the date the party asserting the claim knew or should have known of the facts giving rise to such claims.” Section 24.B lets Subway seek injunctions “from any court of competent jurisdiction,” and Section 24.K.6 lets it sue in court over its marks and confidential information. Sublease enforcement goes to the courts where the restaurant sits.

The Minnesota addendum states that Section 24 “SHALL NOT IN ANY WAY ABROGATE OR REDUCE ANY RIGHTS OF THE FRANCHISEE” under Chapter 80C. That includes “THE RIGHT TO SUBMIT MATTERS TO THE JURISDICTION OF THE COURTS IN MINNESOTA.” Minn. Stat. § 80C.21 voids waivers of the Act, “including any choice of law provision.” Minn. Stat. § 80C.17, subd. 5 allows claims under that section for three years after they accrue. Minn. R. 2860.4400, item J, bars a required jury waiver but adds “that this part shall not bar an exclusive arbitration clause.” Section 24.K.7 states that federal arbitration law “preempts any state law restrictions (including the site of the arbitration).” The documents do not settle how that sentence and the addendum fit together.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

  1. Will Subway delete or limit the three-year damages formula in Section 22.F for a Minnesota restaurant, given Minn. R. 2860.4400, item J?
  2. Which Subway restaurants are open, approved, or planned within three miles of my site, and will Subway agree in writing to a protected radius?
  3. Will Subway write Item 6’s 10% annual cap on the Restaurant Technology Fee into Section 13.E, and cap the other technology fees?
  4. What remodel will Subway require during the term, at renewal, and at any transfer, and what does it cost today?
  5. Can the Owner’s Guaranty be capped or released when I sell, and who must sign the separate Sublease guaranty?
  6. Will Subway narrow the post-term noncompete to my own location, remove my family members, and strike the $100,000 payment in Section 19.D?
  7. Since Item 19 gives no figures, which Minnesota franchisees can I call, and which of them have signed confidentiality clauses?
  8. Why does Item 3 put the franchisees Subway sued at about 0.03% of the system, while Exhibit L says about 0.2%?

This review covers the form documents in Subway’s disclosure document as filed with the Minnesota Department of Commerce on October 29, 2026. The agreement you are offered may differ, and this page is general information about those public documents, not advice about your purchase.

How much does it cost to open a Subway franchise in Minnesota?

Subway’s Item 7 estimates $263,000 to $630,000 for a single traditional restaurant and $227,000 to $458,000 for a non-traditional location. That includes the $15,000 initial franchise fee and three months of additional funds, but not royalties, advertising fees, food costs, or an owner’s draw.

What royalty does a Subway franchisee pay?

The royalty is 8% of gross sales and the advertising contribution is 4.5% of gross sales, both paid weekly under Section 13 of the franchise agreement. Monthly technology fees, such as the $75 Restaurant Technology Fee, are added on top.

Does Subway tell you how much a franchise earns?

No. Subway’s Item 19 states that it does not make any representations about franchisees’ future or past financial performance. A buyer of an existing restaurant may ask for that outlet’s actual records, and Exhibit B lists franchisees a buyer may contact.

How many Subway restaurants closed in Minnesota?

Item 20 reports Minnesota franchised Subways fell from 400 at the start of 2023 to 355 at the end of 2025. In 2025, 24 ceased operations, 3 were not renewed, and 8 opened.

Does a Subway franchise come with a protected territory?

No. Section 2.B of the franchise agreement states that it does not grant any territorial rights, and Subway and its affiliates may compete with you or license others to do so near your restaurant.

Having This Franchise’s Documents Analyzed

If you are considering this franchise, I can analyze its disclosure document and your franchise agreement before you sign: what the fees and the initial investment really total, what the franchisor can terminate you for, what a sale or transfer will cost, what your personal guarantee covers, and which terms are worth asking to change. It is a fixed fee, quoted before work begins. Email [email protected] with the brand and where you plan to open. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents. My page on buying a franchise in Minnesota explains what to check first, and the Minnesota Franchise Directory lists the other brands I have reviewed.