A reservation of rights letter means your insurer will defend the lawsuit against your business for now but may still refuse to pay a judgment or settlement later. The letter keeps both outcomes open. What your company does next can affect who defends the case, how a settlement can work, and who pays for it.
Minnesota has no statute on reservation of rights letters. The rules come from decisions of the Minnesota Supreme Court and the Minnesota Court of Appeals. Statutes govern how insurers handle claims (Minn. Stat. § 72A.201), declaratory judgments (Minn. Stat. § 555.01), interest on a breach (Minn. Stat. § 60A.0811), and the reach of the bad-faith statute (Minn. Stat. § 604.18). This page is written for a Minnesota company defending a lawsuit under a commercial liability policy read under Minnesota law. If your company has just been served, my page for a business served with a lawsuit covers tendering the suit and the answer deadline. This page is part of my Minnesota business litigation materials.
What Does a Reservation of Rights Letter Mean for Your Business?
A reservation of rights letter is the insurer’s notice that it accepts the defense of the lawsuit while keeping the right to contest coverage later. The Minnesota Supreme Court described the practice in Remodeling Dimensions, Inc. v. Integrity Mutual Insurance Co., 819 N.W.2d 602 (Minn. 2012): “When an insurer has a duty to defend a liability claim for which it questions coverage, the insurer must expressly inform its insured that it accepts defense of the claim subject to its right to later contest coverage of the claim based on facts developed at trial.” In plain terms, the insurer pays for the defense now and keeps the right to contest coverage later, based on facts developed at trial.
The letter protects the insurer. The same decision states, “An insurer that fails to make such a reservation of rights is estopped from later denying coverage of the claim, up to the policy limits.” Estoppel here means the insurer loses the right to argue that the claim is not covered. It does not raise the limits. In Faber v. Roelofs, 250 N.W.2d 817 (Minn. 1977), the court said, “Estoppel acts only to prevent Tri-State from denying that its policy covers this injury.”
The letter is neither a promise to pay nor a denial. It is a statement of the insurer’s position, and your company can answer it.
How Does the Duty to Defend Differ From the Duty to Pay a Judgment?
The duty to defend is broader than the duty to pay. An insurer must defend the whole lawsuit if any claim in it might be covered, but it must pay only the liability the policy covers. In Prahm v. Rupp Construction Co., 277 N.W.2d 389 (Minn. 1979), the Minnesota Supreme Court stated the defense rule, restating an earlier decision: “If any part of a cause of action is arguably within the scope of coverage, the insurer must defend.” In Mutual Service Casualty Insurance Co. v. Luetmer, 474 N.W.2d 365 (Minn. Ct. App. 1991), the Court of Appeals added, citing a federal appeals decision, “If the complaint against the insured includes multiple claims, and one of the claims, if proved, would require the insurer to indemnify, the insurer must defend against all claims.”
Remodeling Dimensions stated the payment rule. It said “an insurer has a duty to indemnify when its insured is found liable for a third-party claim within the terms of the liability insurance policy, but an insurer has no duty to indemnify when its insured is found liable for a third-party claim that is outside the policy’s scope.” To indemnify means to pay the covered loss. To sort a judgment into covered and uncovered parts, “the court examines the language of the particular policy and the claim or claims actually proven by the third-party claimant in the liability action against the insured.”
That gap is why insurers reserve their rights. In Luetmer, the Court of Appeals wrote, “Problems can arise when an insurer defends under a reservation of rights.” The insured and the insurer both want the company to win, but “the insurer has an additional interest that if liability is found, that it be found on claims for which there is no coverage.”
The defense can also end before the case does. In Meadowbrook, Inc. v. Tower Insurance Co., 559 N.W.2d 411 (Minn. 1997), the court held that “an insurer who undertakes an insured’s defense under a reservation of rights can withdraw its defense once all arguably covered claims have been dismissed with finality.” The insurer in that case withdrew too early and had to pay the company’s defense fees from its withdrawal until the arguably covered claims settled. My page on the duty to defend and indemnify covers the two duties side by side.
How Should You Read the Reservations Against Your Policy?
Each reservation is a statement about a specific policy term, such as an exclusion, a notice or cooperation condition, or the definition of what the policy insures. I suggest checking each named term in your own copy of the policy against the complaint, because each one is a reason the insurer may later give for refusing to pay. Working through the letter in this order narrows what is actually in dispute:
- Match each reservation to a claim. Mark which claims in the complaint the letter says may be outside coverage, and which it does not mention. A reservation tied to a fact, such as intent or the date of the damage, points to the fact the lawsuit may decide.
- Note who must prove what. Remodeling Dimensions states, “The insured bears the initial burden of proving prima facie coverage of a third-party claim under a liability insurance policy.” It continues, “If the insured meets its burden of establishing coverage of the claim, the burden shifts to the insurer to prove the applicability of an exclusion under the policy as an affirmative defense.” An exclusion named in the letter is the insurer’s to prove, and an exception to that exclusion is your company’s. In King’s Cove Marina, LLC v. Lambert Commercial Construction LLC, No. A19-0078 (Minn. Apr. 14, 2021), the Minnesota Supreme Court said, restating an earlier decision, “But the insured carries the burden of establishing that an exception to an exclusion applies.”
- Look for the claims the defense rests on. In Meadowbrook, the defamation claims were “arguably covered,” and the insurer “assumed defense of the entire claim under a reservation of rights” and “suggested that the insured retain its own counsel to help it defend the uninsured claims.” The insurer later withdrew. In a footnote on estoppel, the court said that because the insurer’s letter stated it was “undertaking the defense only upon the basis of the defamation claims,” and it suggested the insured hire its own counsel, “the insured cannot now argue that the withdrawal harmed its defense.”
- Check the notice and cooperation conditions. A reservation based on late notice raises its own Minnesota rules, covered on my page about late notice. A reservation based on an intentional conduct exclusion is covered on my page about the intentional acts exclusion.
If the insurer later denies coverage, the denial has to say why. Under Minn. Stat. § 72A.201, subd. 8, an insurer commits an unfair settlement practice by “(1) denying a claim or any element of a claim on the grounds of a specific policy provision, condition, or exclusion, without informing the insured of the policy provision, condition, or exclusion on which the denial is based.” Clause (5) of the same subdivision also lists “denying a claim without including the following information,” and its four listed items include “(i) the basis for the denial” and “(iii) the claim number and the policy number of the insured.” Subdivision 4 adds the form: “No insurer shall deny a claim on the grounds of a specific policy provision, condition, or exclusion unless reference to the provision, condition, or exclusion is included in the denial. The denial must be given to the insured in writing with a copy filed in the claim file.”
How Do You Push Back on a Reservation You Think Is Wrong?
I suggest answering the letter in writing, reservation by reservation, with the facts and policy language that show coverage, and asking the insurer to withdraw each reservation you dispute. A written answer costs little and creates a record the insurer has to respond to. Minnesota’s claim-handling statute, § 72A.201, subd. 4, lists among the “unfair settlement practices” of an insurer “failing to reply, within ten business days of receipt, to all other communications about a claim from an insured or a claimant that reasonably indicate a response is requested or needed.”
The statute’s definition of a claim covers a request for services as well as for payment. Subdivision 3 provides, “‘Claim’ means a request or demand made with an insurer for the payment of funds or the provision of services under the terms of any policy, certificate, contract of insurance, binder, or other contracts of temporary insurance.” The statute has limits. Under subdivision 1, “The commissioner may, in accordance with sections 72A.22 to 72A.25, seek and impose appropriate administrative remedies, including fines, for (1) a violation of this section or the rules adopted pursuant to this section; or (2) a violation of section 72A.20, subdivision 12.” The same subdivision adds, “No individual violation constitutes an unfair, discriminatory, or unlawful practice in business, commerce, or trade for purposes of section 8.31.” Subdivision 10 states, “Nothing in this section abrogates any policy provisions.”
I suggest including these items in the written answer, because each one sets up a later step:
- The claim number, the policy number, and the date of your tender.
- Each reservation, quoted, with the facts and policy words that put the claim within coverage.
- A request for a complete copy of the policy and every endorsement, and for any other policy the insurer issued to your company for the same period.
- A request for independent counsel at the insurer’s expense, if the coverage question turns on facts the lawsuit will decide (next section).
A 2026 Court of Appeals case, Fabyanske Westra Hart & Thomson PA v. Western National Mutual Insurance Co., 37 N.W.3d 625 (Minn. Ct. App. 2026), shows the pattern. There, “In June 2023, Fabyanske sent Western a letter on general contractor’s behalf objecting to the reservation of rights.” The insurer answered “refusing to withdraw its reservation of rights,” and “Fabyanske notified Western that it intended to file a notice of appearance in the underlying action to monitor appointed counsel’s defense.” The firm later sued the insurer for its fees, and the Court of Appeals reversed the summary judgment against it.
When Does a Reservation of Rights Let You Choose Your Own Lawyer?
A reservation of rights lets your company choose its own lawyer at the insurer’s expense only when it creates an actual conflict of interest. A 2026 Court of Appeals decision says one exists when coverage turns on the same facts the lawsuit will decide. The baseline comes from Luetmer. It held that “before an insured will be entitled to counsel of its own choice, an actual conflict of interest, rather than an appearance of a conflict of interest, must be established.” The court found no conflict there and said “A finding of conflict of interest must rest on more substantial evidence, such as actions which demonstrate a greater concern for MSI’s interests than respondents’ interests.”
In Fabyanske, the insurer defended a general contractor but reserved the right to refuse coverage for the contractor’s own negligence. That was the same question the injury lawsuit would decide. The court held “that an actual conflict of interest entitling an insured to independent counsel exists when the insurer defends under a reservation of rights and the facts to be determined in the underlying action are the same facts upon which coverage depends.” It also said the rule “requires a case-by-case determination to assess whether the reservation of rights creates an actual conflict of interest.”
The remedy comes from Prahm: “This conflict of interest does not relieve Great American of its duty to defend, but rather transforms that duty into the duty to reimburse Rupp for reasonable attorneys’ fees incurred in defending the lawsuit.” Fabyanske restated it: “When an actual conflict of interest exists, an insurer’s duty to defend ’transforms’ into a duty to reimburse, and the insured has the right to select independent counsel at the insurer’s expense.” Fabyanske is a Court of Appeals decision, docket No. A25-1640. I suggest checking whether the Minnesota Supreme Court has reviewed it before relying on it, because a Supreme Court decision would control.
The facts of Fabyanske also show what an appointed lawyer can decide without the client. “Without discussing the issue with general contractor or Fabyanske, appointed counsel elected not to oppose subcontractor’s motion for summary judgment on general contractor’s crossclaims.” I suggest reading every motion filed in the case, including any against claims your company brought, because a lost crossclaim is your company’s loss whoever is paying the defense. My page on how to choose a lawyer when your business is sued covers what to weigh in picking defense counsel.
How Does a Miller-Shugart Settlement Work Under a Reservation of Rights?
When the insurer denies that the policy covers the claim, a Miller-Shugart settlement lets your company agree to a judgment that the plaintiff may collect only from insurance. That can end the company’s own exposure while the coverage fight continues. In Buysse v. Baumann-Furrie & Co., 448 N.W.2d 865 (Minn. 1989), the Minnesota Supreme Court said, “The initial basis for a Miller-Shugart settlement is the insurer’s denial of any coverage for the claim against the insured.” The court approved the method in Miller v. Shugart, 316 N.W.2d 729 (Minn. 1982), where the insurer was contesting coverage in a declaratory judgment action and had provided counsel. The court reasoned, “While the defendant insureds have a duty to cooperate with the insurer, they also have a right to protect themselves against plaintiff’s claim.” It held, “On the facts of this case we hold, therefore, that the insureds did not breach their duty to cooperate with the insurer, which was then contesting coverage, by settling directly with the plaintiff.” Those facts included notice: “They also advised Milbank of what they were doing.”
The Supreme Court applied the method in King’s Cove to an insurer that denied coverage but defended under a reservation of rights. There, “United Fire denied coverage for the claims but defended Lambert under a reservation of rights. United Fire subsequently brought a declaratory judgment action, seeking a ruling that United Fire does not have a duty to defend or indemnify Lambert.” The court’s first footnote describes the agreement as one in which “the defendant, having been denied coverage for the claim, agrees that the plaintiff may enter judgment against it for a sum collectible only from the insurance policy.” The court stated the test, citing Miller: “A Miller-Shugart settlement agreement is enforceable against the insurer if the insurer receives notice of the settlement, and the settlement is reasonable and not the product of fraud or collusion.” It also held “that the failure to allocate between covered and uncovered claims does not make the Miller-Shugart settlement agreement per se unreasonable.” It further held “that determining the reasonableness of an unallocated Miller-Shugart settlement agreement involves a two-step inquiry,” and it placed “the burden of proof on allocation” on the plaintiff judgment creditor.
Miller itself built checks into the settlement:
- Fraud or collusion. “We start with the general proposition that a money judgment confessed to by an insured is not binding on the insurer if obtained through fraud or collusion.”
- Reasonableness. “The burden of proof is on the claimant, the plaintiff judgment creditor, to show that the settlement is reasonable and prudent.”
- The coverage outcome. “Of course, the insurer escapes the risk if it should be successful on the coverage issue, and, in that event, it is plaintiff who loses.”
King’s Cove also stated the result when coverage exists but the settlement fails the reasonableness test, quoting an earlier decision: “If insurance coverage is established, but the settlement is unreasonable, the default rule is that the parties to the settlement agreement are returned ’to the even footing of a trial on the merits of the main action.’”
The method has a limit when the insurer accepts coverage. Buysse said, “Ordinarily, when an insurer has acknowledged the existence and applicability of coverage with respect to a pending action, the deprivation of the contractual right to defend and settle the lawsuit attendant upon the execution of a stipulation for settlement prejudices the insurer and voids the policy coverage.” The insurer there had acknowledged coverage and disputed how much was available. The court said, “Only the insurer’s denial of the existence of any coverage for the claim and the resultant exposure of the insured to liability for the entire amount of any damage award provide a basis for requiring the insurer’s right to the insured’s cooperation to yield to the insured’s need to extricate himself or herself without the insurer’s agreement.” It treated the insured’s settlement there as “a breach of contract which voids coverage if it is material and prejudicial.” I suggest giving the insurer written notice of any proposed settlement and inviting it to take part before signing, because King’s Cove makes notice a condition of enforcing the agreement against the insurer.
How Does a Declaratory Judgment Action Settle the Coverage Question?
A declaratory judgment action can ask a court to decide coverage now, in a separate case, instead of waiting for the lawsuit to end, when the lawsuit will not decide the same question. Minn. Stat. § 555.01 provides, “Courts of record within their respective jurisdictions shall have power to declare rights, status, and other legal relations whether or not further relief is or could be claimed.” Under Minn. Stat. § 555.02, “Any person interested under a deed, will, written contract, or other writings constituting a contract, or whose rights, status, or other legal relations are affected by a statute, municipal ordinance, contract, or franchise may have determined any question of construction or validity arising under the instrument, statute, ordinance, contract, or franchise and obtain a declaration of rights, status, or other legal relations thereunder.”
Either side can bring one. In Jostens, Inc. v. Mission Insurance Co., 387 N.W.2d 161 (Minn. 1986), the Minnesota Supreme Court said “any insured can, of course, bring a declaratory judgment action to resolve the duty to defend dispute before substantial defense costs are incurred.” Luetmer added, “The Minnesota Supreme Court has repeatedly advised the use of a declaratory judgment action in a reservation of rights situation.” The route has a limit when the lawsuit itself will decide the coverage question. In Grain Dealers Mutual Insurance Co. v. Cady, 318 N.W.2d 247 (Minn. 1982), the Minnesota Supreme Court said, citing a Maryland decision, “Where the question to be resolved in the declaratory judgment action between an insurer and an insured will be decided in the main action, it is inappropriate to grant a declaratory judgment.” It added that “if the issue is not exactly the same in each action, though closely tied together, the parties are entitled to have a declaration establishing coverage or the lack thereof in the declaratory judgment action.” My page on filing a declaratory judgment action covers the procedure.
Fees and interest depend on a breach. Meadowbrook stated, citing an earlier decision, “Legal fees generally are not recoverable, but attorney fees are recoverable in a declaratory judgment action if the insured proves that the insurer breached a contractual duty.” In American Standard Insurance Co. v. Le, 551 N.W.2d 923 (Minn. 1996), the insurer “had undertaken the defense of Nguyen’s action subject to a reservation of rights.” The Minnesota Supreme Court reversed the insured’s fee award for the declaratory action, stating, “The insured is not entitled to recover attorney fees incurred in maintaining or defending a declaratory action to determine the question of coverage unless the insurer has breached the insurance contract in some respect,” which it said is “usually by wrongfully refusing to defend the insured.” Under Minn. Stat. § 60A.0811, subd. 2, “(a) An insured who prevails in any claim against an insurer based on the insurer’s breach or repudiation of, or failure to fulfill, a duty to provide services or make payments is entitled to recover ten percent per annum interest on monetary amounts due under the insurance policy, calculated from the date the request for payment of those benefits was made to the insurer.” Subdivision 1 limits the section to “a commercial or professional insurance policy or contract,” with listed exceptions. Subdivision 3 provides, “This section applies to a court action or arbitration proceeding, including an action seeking declaratory judgment.”
Minnesota’s bad-faith statute does not reach a defense dispute. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.18, subd. 1, “Insurance policy does not include provisions of a written agreement obligating an insurer to defend an insured, reimburse an insured’s defense expenses, provide for any other type of defense obligation, or provide indemnification for judgments or settlements.” For a denied claim on your company’s own property, my page on a business insurance claim denied covers that statute.
How Can Your Insurance Broker and Other Non-Court Steps Help?
Several steps that cost less than a coverage lawsuit can narrow a reservation or answer the question behind it. They include asking your broker for complete policy copies, exchanging facts in writing with the claims handler, and having your own lawyer monitor the defense. Two more are talking settlement with the plaintiff while keeping the insurer involved, and asking for an allocated award in arbitration. Each one below fits a different problem and carries its own risk:
- Your insurance broker or agent. The professional who placed the policy can gather complete policy copies and press the claims department for a written answer. A broker can also look for other policies that may respond, such as an umbrella, earlier policy years, or coverage as an additional insured on a customer’s or vendor’s policy. I suggest tendering the lawsuit in writing to the insurer on each policy found, because Remodeling Dimensions states, restating an earlier decision, “A potential duty to defend a particular claim is triggered when the insured tenders notice of suit and opportunity to defend to the insurer.” In SCSC Corp. v. Allied Mutual Insurance Co., 536 N.W.2d 305 (Minn. 1995), the court reversed the award of the insured’s fees from before its tender letter, because the insured “did not invoke this duty until it properly tendered its defense request.” This step fits when the open question is what coverage exists. The risk is relying on anyone’s view of what the policy covers, because in Minnesota “The interpretation of an insurance policy and application of the policy to the facts of a case are questions of law,” as Remodeling Dimensions put it, restating an earlier decision.
- A written exchange with the claims handler. It fits when a reservation rests on a fact the insurer does not have, such as when the damage occurred or who did the work. It costs little. The risk is an informal statement that the insurer later reads against coverage, so I suggest putting facts in writing with the documents behind them.
- Your own lawyer monitoring the defense. It fits when the reservation and the lawsuit turn on the same facts, or when your company has claims of its own in the case. The cost is your own lawyer’s fees unless a conflict shifts them to the insurer. The risk of skipping it is the Fabyanske problem: decisions in the case made without your company’s input.
- Settlement talks with the plaintiff. An owner-to-owner conversation can fit when the companies want to keep doing business. The risk is settling without the insurer. In Faber, the court explained, citing earlier decisions, that “the insurer, by taking control of the defense without a reservation of rights, takes away from the insured his right to control the defense as he sees fit and to make or negotiate a settlement.” In Buysse, where the insurer had “conceded that all of the conduct alleged by the various plaintiffs falls within the coverage afforded by its policy,” the court treated the insured’s settlement over its insurer’s protest as “a breach of contract which voids coverage if it is material and prejudicial.” I suggest involving the insurer in any settlement discussion, because King’s Cove makes notice to the insurer a condition of enforcing a Miller-Shugart settlement against it.
- An allocated award in arbitration. If the dispute is in arbitration, Remodeling Dimensions held that “when an insurer notifies its insured that it accepts the defense of an arbitration claim under a reservation of rights that includes covered and noncovered claims, the insurer not only has a duty to defend the claim, but also to disclose to its insured the insured’s interest in obtaining a written explanation of the award that identifies the claims or theories of recovery actually proved and the portions of the award attributable to each.” The court said, “The duty we impose upon the insurer is conditioned upon the insured affirmatively showing that a written explanation of an award is available under applicable rules, the insurer had the opportunity to provide timely notice to the insured of the insured’s interest in a written explanation of the award, and prejudice was caused by the failure of the insurer to provide such notice.” In that case, the arbitration rules allowed a written explanation as of right only if all parties asked before the arbitrator was appointed. I suggest asking about an allocated award at the start, because the court said “Ordinarily, the insurer’s disclosure should be made at or near the time the defense of the claim is accepted under a reservation of rights.”
Is a reservation of rights the same as a denial of coverage?
No. A reservation of rights means the insurer is defending your business while keeping the right to contest coverage later, and a denial means it refuses. In Remodeling Dimensions, Inc. v. Integrity Mutual Insurance Co. (Minn. 2012), the Minnesota Supreme Court said an insurer that questions coverage “must expressly inform its insured that it accepts defense of the claim subject to its right to later contest coverage.” If the insurer later denies, Minn. Stat. § 72A.201, subd. 4, provides that no insurer may deny on a policy provision, condition, or exclusion “unless reference to the provision, condition, or exclusion is included in the denial,” given to the insured in writing.
What if the insurer controlled the defense for months without reserving its rights?
Then Minnesota law can bar the insurer from denying coverage. In Remodeling Dimensions (Minn. 2012), the Minnesota Supreme Court said an insurer that fails to reserve its rights “is estopped from later denying coverage of the claim, up to the policy limits.” In Faber v. Roelofs (Minn. 1977), the court said prejudice to the insured “will be conclusively presumed when the insurer exercises complete control over the defense without a reservation of rights.” Faber said a showing of prejudice is the rule for an insurer that withdraws before trial, and estoppel does not raise the policy limits.
Can the insurer stop defending partway through the case?
Yes, once nothing arguably covered remains. In Meadowbrook, Inc. v. Tower Insurance Co. (Minn. 1997), the Minnesota Supreme Court said, restating an earlier decision, that the duty to defend “extends until it can be concluded as a matter of law that there is no basis on which the insurer may be obligated to indemnify the insured.” An insurer defending under a reservation of rights “can withdraw its defense once all arguably covered claims have been dismissed with finality,” meaning “when no further rights to appeal those arguably covered claims exist.” The insurer there withdrew too early and owed fees.
Does Minnesota's bad-faith statute cover a dispute over the defense?
No. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.18, subd. 1, an insurance policy for that statute “does not include provisions of a written agreement obligating an insurer to defend an insured” or to “reimburse an insured’s defense expenses.” Routes include a fee suit (Fabyanske, 2026) and a declaratory judgment action, where Meadowbrook (Minn. 1997) states fees are recoverable if the insured proves the insurer breached a contractual duty. In American Standard Insurance Co. v. Le (Minn. 1996), the Minnesota Supreme Court reversed a fee award for the declaratory action to an insured defended under a reservation of rights. Minn. Stat. § 60A.0811 adds interest on a commercial policy.
Do I still have to cooperate with the lawyer the insurer appointed?
Yes. The appointed lawyer is your company’s lawyer. In Remodeling Dimensions (Minn. 2012), the Minnesota Supreme Court said, restating earlier decisions, that an attorney hired by an insurer to defend a claim against its insured “represents the insured” and “owes a duty of undivided loyalty to the insured.” In Miller v. Shugart (Minn. 1982), the court said insureds “have a duty to cooperate with the insurer” and “also have a right to protect themselves against plaintiff’s claim.” A coverage disagreement goes to the insurer in writing.
Responding to a Reservation of Rights Letter
A reservation of rights letter means the insurer is defending your company while keeping its coverage defenses open. Reading each reservation against the policy, answering it in writing, and asking for independent counsel where the coverage facts are the trial facts protect your company’s position. When the letter cannot be worked out and the insurer denies coverage, a Miller-Shugart settlement can end your company’s own exposure while the coverage fight continues. A declaratory judgment action can ask a court to decide coverage now when the lawsuit will not decide the same question. My Minnesota business litigation attorney page describes how I defend Minnesota companies. If your company has received a reservation of rights letter, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.