If you are selling your Minnesota business and staying on with the buyer, the agreement for your role decides what happens to you after closing. It sets how long you stay, what you do, what you are paid, and whether the buyer can end the role early. Either an employment agreement or a consulting agreement can work. The label does not settle your status. A fixed term or agreed termination conditions can limit when the buyer may fire an employee; without them, the buyer may fire for any reason except one a statute forbids, such as age. A promise of permanent employment can bind the buyer when you gave something beyond your services for it. Your earnout and any seller note should say what ending the role does to them.

The rules come from Minnesota statutes on worker status and final pay, Minnesota Supreme Court decisions on at-will and fixed-term employment, and the contract you sign. This page is for the selling owner who stays on after closing. The rest of the process is in the guide to selling your business, and the deal terms are part of my business sale and acquisition work.

What Is the Difference Between Staying On as an Employee and as a Consultant?

Under Minnesota’s misclassification statute, whether you stay on as an employee or as a consultant (an independent contractor) turns on the same tests used for workers’ compensation and unemployment insurance, whatever the agreement calls you. Minn. Stat. § 181.722, subd. 3 provides: “For purposes of this section, the nature of an employment relationship is determined using the same tests and in the same manner as employee status is determined under the applicable workers’ compensation and unemployment insurance program laws and rules.”

For unemployment insurance, Minn. R. 3315.0555, subp. 1 provides that “five factors must be considered and weighed within a particular set of circumstances” and states: “The two most important factors are items A and B.” Item A is “the right or the lack of the right to control the means and manner of performance,” and item B is “the right to discharge the worker without incurring liability for damages.” So the first factor that rule calls most important is whether the buyer has the right to control the means and manner of your work. The second is whether it has the right to end your role without owing you damages.

If you will also be an officer of the buyer’s corporation, two more rules speak to that title. For unemployment insurance, Minn. Stat. § 268.035, subd. 15(a) defines employment to include service performed by “an officer of a corporation,” and subdivision 20(29) lists as noncovered “employment of a corporate officer, if the officer directly or indirectly, including through a subsidiary or holding company, owns 25 percent or more of the employer corporation.” For federal employment taxes, 26 C.F.R. § 31.3121(d)-1(b) provides: “Generally, an officer of a corporation is an employee of the corporation. However, an officer of a corporation who as such does not perform any services or performs only minor services and who neither receives nor is entitled to receive, directly or indirectly, any remuneration is considered not to be an employee of the corporation.”

The duty to get the label right falls on the buyer. Under § 181.722, subd. 1(a)(3), a person shall not “require or request an individual who is the person’s employee pursuant to subdivision 3 to enter into any agreement or complete any document that misclassifies, misrepresents, or treats the individual as an independent contractor or otherwise does not reflect that the individual is the person’s employee pursuant to subdivision 3.” Subdivision 4(a)(1) allows “compensatory damages to the individual the person has failed to classify, represent, or treat as an employee pursuant to subdivision 3.” If you are an employee, Minn. Stat. § 181.032(d) also requires the buyer to give you a written notice of your pay terms at the start of your employment. The full set of tests, including the workers’ compensation rules, is on the page about independent contractor versus employee in Minnesota.

How Does a Fixed Term Change Whether the Buyer Can End Your Role?

As an employee with no fixed term and no agreed termination conditions, you can be let go at any time, though not for a reason a statute forbids, such as your age. Under the general rule, a written term with an end date, in an agreement silent on termination, limits the buyer to ending it early for good cause. In Pine River State Bank v. Mettille, 333 N.W.2d 622 (Minn. 1983), the Minnesota Supreme Court said that when a hiring is for an indefinite term, “the employer can summarily dismiss the employee for any reason or no reason.” It said a promise of “permanent” or “life-time” employment does not change that, “at least not in the absence of some kind of additional consideration supplied by the employee which is uncharacteristic of the employment relationship itself.” It also said: “We are not dealing with a discharge that is retaliatory, in bad faith or abusive.” The court added: “The general rule is that contracts for a specified duration can nonetheless be terminated during the period of the contract if the employer has good cause.”

Statutes limit an at-will firing too. Minn. Stat. § 363A.08, subd. 2 provides: “Except when based on a bona fide occupational qualification, it is an unfair employment practice for an employer, because of race, color, creed, religion, national origin, sex, gender identity, marital status, status with regard to public assistance, familial status, membership or activity in a local commission, disability, sexual orientation, or age to: . . . (2) discharge an employee.” Minn. Stat. § 181.932, subd. 1 bars an employer from discharging an employee because the employee, “in good faith, reports a violation, suspected violation, or planned violation of any federal or state law or common law or rule adopted pursuant to law to an employer or to any governmental body or law enforcement official,” among other reasons it lists.

A selling owner can be the employee who supplies that additional consideration. In Bussard v. College of Saint Thomas, Inc., 200 N.W.2d 155 (Minn. 1972), an owner gave part of his stock in a magazine company to the college that bought the rest. He claimed an oral promise that he could stay on as publisher for as long as he wished. The court said he “clearly did furnish the valuable consideration contemplated by the existing rule” and reversed a summary judgment against him, so he could take the claim to trial. In ruling that the written agreement did not shut out proof of the oral promise, the court relied on the deal not being “the ordinary, arm’s length transaction.” It said that otherwise “we could well conclude that the alleged oral agreement is one that parties otherwise similarly situated would embody in the written agreement.”

Pine River also held “that where an employment contract is for an indefinite duration, such indefiniteness by itself does not preclude handbook provisions on job security from being enforceable, whether they are proffered at the time of the original hiring or later, when the parties have agreed to be bound thereby.” The handbook language must be an offer, and “The offer must be definite in form and must be communicated to the offeree.”

The Minnesota Court of Appeals applied the fixed-term rule to a company president in Kvidera v. Rotation Engineering & Manufacturing Co., 705 N.W.2d 416 (Minn. Ct. App. 2005). He had signed a one-year “Employment Contract” with start and end dates and no at-will term. The employer argued that he stayed at will because “both of those documents are silent as to termination and neither document contained a term explicitly modifying respondent’s at-will status.” The court said that under a contract of specific duration, “an employee may only be terminated during the period of the contract upon a showing that the employer had good cause,” and that “an employment agreement may supersede the at-will doctrine if it contains either termination conditions or a specified duration.” It held that “a contract for a specific duration is sufficient to create employment terminable for cause.”

Those decisions are about employment. If you stay on as a consultant, I suggest writing the term and every way to end it into the consulting agreement, because written terms give both sides a rule to apply.

What Should the Agreement Say About Term, Duties, Hours, and Pay?

Your agreement should state, in a document the buyer signs, how long the role lasts, what you will do, how much you will work, what you are paid, and how either side may end it. Writing matters most for a role that cannot be finished within a year of the day you agree to it, which can include a one-year role agreed before closing that starts at closing. In Borchardt v. Kulick, 234 Minn. 308, 48 N.W.2d 318 (Minn. 1951), the court said “an oral contract for the performance of services for a term of one year, to begin in the future, is within the statute of frauds.” Minn. Stat. § 513.01 provides: “No action shall be maintained, in either of the following cases, upon any agreement, unless such agreement, or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing, and subscribed by the party charged therewith.” The first case it lists is “every agreement that by its terms is not to be performed within one year from the making thereof.”

I suggest covering these points, because each one otherwise turns on what each side remembers agreeing:

  1. Term. The start date (for example, the closing date), the end date, and whether either side may extend the term, for how long, and at what pay.
  2. Duties. The tasks you will handle, such as introductions to named customers and suppliers and training your successor, and to whom you report.
  3. Time. A cap on hours per week or month, and whether you work on site or remotely.
  4. Pay. The rate, when it is paid, and reimbursement of expenses. A consultant’s agreement should also state when invoices are due.
  5. Ending the role. What counts as cause, how much notice the buyer must give to end the role without cause, and what you are paid if it does.
  6. Link to the price. What each way of ending the role does to your earnout and seller note, covered below.

What Counts as Cause for Ending the Role Early?

What counts as cause depends on how your agreement defines it, so a written definition spares you an argument over the word when the job ends. In Pine River, the Minnesota Supreme Court left the definition open: “Whether, assuming a good cause requirement, this was a proper definition of good cause has not been made an issue, and we need not decide it.”

I suggest a definition that lists specific conduct, because each side can then check the conduct against the list when the role ends. A definition might list fraud or theft from the business, a conviction for a serious crime, and a material breach of the agreement that you fail to fix within a stated time after written notice. It also helps to state who decides cause on the buyer’s side and how that decision is recorded. As the seller, you may also want a resignation for a listed reason, such as a cut in pay or a change in your duties, treated the same as a firing without cause.

In a buyout where the papers never defined cause, the company read the word through the founder’s older employment agreement, and the managers recorded a written vote before ending the job.

What Happens to Your Earnout or Seller Note When the Role Ends?

Your sale documents should state what each way of ending your role does to your earnout and to any seller note. In Hunt v. IBM Mid America Employees Federal Credit Union, 384 N.W.2d 853 (Minn. 1986), a case about an at-will general manager, the Minnesota Supreme Court said: “Moreover, we have not read an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing into employment contracts.” That rule is about the employment contract. For other contracts, the court said in In re Hennepin County 1986 Recycling Bond Litigation, 540 N.W.2d 494 (Minn. 1995), citing an earlier decision, that “every contract includes an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing requiring that one party not ‘unjustifiably hinder’ the other party’s performance of the contract,” and that “the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing does not extend to actions beyond the scope of the underlying contract.” If you stay on as an employee, protection against a firing timed to the earnout should be written into the sale documents.

The earnout is a separate promise in the purchase agreement, and the terms that address a termination are covered in earnouts in Minnesota business sales. I suggest the documents answer three questions, because once you leave, the buyer controls both your role and the business:

  1. If the buyer ends your role without cause, does any unpaid earnout speed up, count as earned, or keep running on the same terms?
  2. If the buyer ends your role for cause, or you quit, does any earnout or note amount change?
  3. May the buyer withhold note payments to cover a claim it says arises from your role? Limits on that right are covered under set-off limits that protect a seller note.

Pay for the role can itself carry part of the deal’s economics. In one sale I worked on, the draft consulting agreement for the selling owner carried payments measured by EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization). I pointed out that the buyer’s finance team would look to those sections to work out what it owed. I suggest giving pay measured by the business’s results the same care as an earnout, because the buyer’s own team will apply those clauses.

When Must the Buyer Pay Your Final Wages as an Employee?

Under Minn. Stat. § 181.13(a), if the buyer is an employer “employing labor within this state” and discharges you, your earned and unpaid wages are immediately due on your written demand. If you quit, Minn. Stat. § 181.14, subd. 1(a) makes them due by the first regularly scheduled payday after your last day. Two parts of § 181.14, quoted below, can push payment later. Subdivision 1(a) allows the second regularly scheduled payday when your last day falls close to the first one. Subdivision 4 gives the buyer time to audit the accounts of an employee entrusted during employment with collecting, paying out, or handling money or property, whether discharged or quitting.

Minn. Stat. § 181.13(a) provides: “When any employer employing labor within this state discharges an employee, the wages or commissions actually earned and unpaid at the time of the discharge are immediately due and payable upon demand of the employee.” It adds that “An employee’s demand for payment under this section must be in writing but need not state the precise amount of unpaid wages or commissions.” It also provides: “If the employee’s earned wages and commissions are not paid within 24 hours after demand, whether the employment was by the day, hour, week, month, or piece or by commissions, the employer is in default.” The discharged employee may then collect “a penalty equal to the amount of the employee’s average daily earnings at the employee’s regular rate of pay or the rate required by law, whichever rate is greater, for each day up to 15 days, that the employer is in default, until full payment or other settlement, satisfactory to the discharged employee, is made.” A contracted bonus can count. Kvidera, the company-president case discussed above, held that when an employee “contracts for a bonus in exchange for his services” and “the right to that bonus vests prior to the employee’s termination, an employer’s failure to pay that unpaid bonus within 24 hours of the employee’s demand subjects the employer to a claim for statutory penalties” under § 181.13. It applied the 2004 text, since amended, and the current text quoted above requires that demand to be in writing. The court also said: “This court is not confronted with a claim for statutory penalties involving a pro rata portion of an unvested bonus, a profit sharing plan, or a gratuitous bonus subject solely to the employer’s discretion.” When you quit, § 181.14, subd. 1(a) provides that your earned and unpaid wages “shall be paid in full not later than the first regularly scheduled payday following the employee’s final day of employment, unless an employee is subject to a collective bargaining agreement with a different provision.” It adds: “If the first regularly scheduled payday is less than five calendar days following the employee’s final day of employment, full payment may be delayed until the second regularly scheduled payday but shall not exceed a total of 20 calendar days following the employee’s final day of employment.” Subdivision 2 provides: “Wages or commissions not paid within the required time period shall become immediately payable upon the demand of the employee. If the employee’s earned wages or commissions are not paid within 24 hours after the demand, the employer shall be liable to the employee for a penalty equal to the amount of the employee’s average daily earnings at the employee’s regular rate of pay or the rate required by law, whichever rate is greater, for every day, not exceeding 15 days in all, until such payment or other settlement satisfactory to the employee is made.” Subdivision 2 also provides that an employee’s demand under that section “must be in writing,” as § 181.13 does. A selling owner who was entrusted during employment with collecting, paying out, or handling the company’s money or property can face a longer wait. Minn. Stat. § 181.14, subd. 4 provides: “In cases where the discharged or quitting employee was, during employment, entrusted with the collection, disbursement, or handling of money or property, the employer shall have ten calendar days after the termination of the employment to audit and adjust the accounts of the employee before the employee’s wages or commissions shall be paid as provided in this section, and the penalty herein provided shall apply in such case only from the date of demand made after the expiration of the period allowed for payment of the employee’s wages or commissions.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.

If the buyer disputes the amount, § 181.14, subd. 3 limits what it owes: “If the employer disputes the amount of wages or commissions claimed by the employee under the provisions of this section or section 181.13, and the employer makes a legal tender of the amount which the employer in good faith claims to be due, the employer shall not be liable for any sum greater than the amount so tendered and interest thereon at the legal rate, unless, in an action brought in a court having jurisdiction, the employee recovers a greater sum than the amount so tendered with interest thereon.”

Both sections speak of an employee. If you stay on as a consultant, I suggest stating in the consulting agreement when your last invoice will be paid, because a stated date leaves nothing to argue about.

How Does Minnesota’s Noncompete Ban Reach a Seller Who Stays On?

Minnesota’s noncompete ban treats a consultant the same as an employee, so changing your title from employee to consultant does not take a noncompete outside the ban. Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 1(c) provides: “"Employee" as used in this section means any individual who performs services for an employer, including independent contractors.” Subdivision 2(a) provides that “Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable,” and subdivision 2(b)(1) makes an exception where “the covenant not to compete is agreed upon during the sale of a business,” under which the seller, its partners, members, or shareholders, and the buyer “may agree on a temporary and geographically restricted covenant not to compete that will prohibit the seller of the business from carrying on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time.”

The ban does not reach every restriction you may sign. Subdivision 1(a) provides: “A covenant not to compete does not include a nondisclosure agreement, or agreement designed to protect trade secrets or confidential information. A covenant not to compete does not include a nonsolicitation agreement, or agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists, or solicit customers of the employer.” The page about a seller’s noncompete covers how courts test a sale covenant’s reach. It also covers whether a noncompete that appears only in an employment agreement signed after closing counts as one agreed during the sale.

What Are the Options for Your Role After Closing?

You have four workable ways to set up your role after closing, and the right one depends on how long the buyer needs you and how much of your price depends on the business’s results. Before either side drafts anything, I suggest asking the buyer which relationships and tasks it needs you for, because the answer sets the size of the role.

  1. Employee for a fixed term. This fits when the buyer needs you for a set period and will direct your work. Under Kvidera, when the agreement is silent on termination, the buyer may end the role early only for good cause, and the wage-payment statutes cover you. You commit your time for the whole term.
  2. At-will employee. This fits a short or uncertain role. With no agreed termination conditions, the buyer may end it “for any reason or no reason,” in Pine River’s words, except a reason a statute forbids, such as age. A promise of permanent employment can bind the buyer when you gave something beyond your services for it, such as part of your stock in Bussard. Your earnout and note terms should address a firing without cause, because the buyer may end this role without one.
  3. Consultant. This fits when you will advise on your own schedule and methods. If the buyer will have the right to control the means and manner of your work, the consultant label may not hold under § 181.722. If you will also be an officer of the buyer’s corporation, the label is harder to keep. Unemployment insurance law and the federal employment-tax regulation quoted above generally treat a corporate officer as an employee, subject to the exceptions quoted there. I suggest writing its termination terms in full, because the employment cases above do not set them.
  4. Transition help in the purchase agreement, with no separate role. This fits when the business can run without you. I suggest giving its hours and tasks the same detail as a separate agreement, because the purchase agreement’s words will be the only description of the help.

How pay for your role is taxed, compared with the purchase price, is a tax question. The guide to tax structuring for a Minnesota business sale covers how the price itself is allocated and taxed.

Does a handshake deal to stay on for two years bind the buyer?

Unless it is in writing, the buyer can refuse to be held to it, though the agreement still governs what you both have already done under it. In Borchardt v. Kulick, 234 Minn. 308, 48 N.W.2d 318 (Minn. 1951), the court held that such a contract is “unenforceable at the option of the party against whom enforcement is sought,” not void, and said: “The contract controls the rights of the parties with respect to what they have done under it.” Minn. Stat. § 513.01 provides that “No action shall be maintained” on “every agreement that by its terms is not to be performed within one year from the making thereof” unless the agreement, “or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing, and subscribed by the party charged therewith.” When you are the one enforcing the promise, the party charged is the buyer. I suggest putting the term and your pay in a document the buyer signs, because a two-year role is that kind of agreement.

Does forming my own LLC for the consulting role change the noncompete rules?

It does not when the buyer requires the LLC as a condition of paying you. Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 1(d) provides that “independent contractor also includes any corporation, limited liability corporation, partnership, or other corporate entity when an employer requires an individual to form such an organization for purposes of entering into a contract for services as a condition of receiving compensation under an independent contractor agreement.” Subd. 1(c) counts independent contractors as employees, so the section’s ban and its sale-of-business exception still govern a noncompete in that LLC’s agreement.

Is my bonus owed if the buyer fires me before paying it?

It can be, if you contracted for the bonus in exchange for your services and your right to it vested before the firing. The decision on this point is Kvidera v. Rotation Engineering & Manufacturing Co., 705 N.W.2d 416 (Minn. Ct. App. 2005). This page’s section on final wages quotes its holding, the kinds of bonus it did not decide, and the current statute’s conditions on your demand and on the penalty.

Must the buyer give me written notice of my pay terms when I become its employee?

Yes. Minn. Stat. § 181.032(d) provides: “At the start of employment, an employer shall provide each employee a written notice containing the following information:” The list includes your rate of pay and its basis, your paid time off and its terms, and whether you are exempt from minimum wage and overtime. Paragraph (f) adds: “An employer must provide the employee any written changes to the information contained in the notice under paragraph (d) prior to the date the changes take effect.” The duty runs to employees.

Planning Your Role After the Sale

The agreement for your role after closing should match how the work will actually run, set a term, and define cause. It should also say what each way of ending the role does to your earnout and seller note. Those terms are part of the business sale and acquisition work I handle for selling owners. If you want to know whether the role your buyer offers protects your pay, earnout, and note, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.