Yes, two businesses can have the same name in Minnesota. The Secretary of State accepts a business name that is distinguishable on its own records, but that filing does not decide which business may keep using the name against the other. That question belongs to trademark law, and it turns on who used the name first, where each business operates, whether either holds a federal registration, and whether customers are likely to confuse the two.
No single Minnesota statute decides who owns a business name. The answer comes from Minnesota court decisions and the federal trademark statute, the Lanham Act, with Minnesota statutes on entity names, assumed names, deceptive trade practices, and state trademark registration layered on top. This page is written for Minnesota business owners who have found another business using their name or one close to it, whether their business came first or second, and it is part of my material on trademark law for Minnesota businesses.
What Does Registering a Business Name in Minnesota Give You?
Registering a corporation, LLC, or assumed name with the Minnesota Secretary of State puts the name on the state’s records, and it does not decide who owns the name against another business. The corporation and LLC name statutes state that they do not limit unfair-competition or trademark law, which is where ownership is decided.
For a corporation, the name must “be distinguishable upon the records in the Office of the Secretary of State from the name of each domestic corporation, limited partnership, limited liability partnership, and limited liability company, whether profit or nonprofit, and each foreign corporation, limited partnership, limited liability partnership, and limited liability company on file, authorized or registered to do business in this state at the time of filing, whether profit or nonprofit, and each name the right to which is, at the time of incorporation, reserved as provided for in sections 5.35, 302A.117, 321.0109, 322C.0109, or 333.001 to 333.54,” under Minn. Stat. § 302A.115, subd. 1(d). An LLC name must meet a parallel test, covering domestic and foreign entities on file and names reserved or registered under the listed statutes, under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0108, subd. 1(5). Under both statutes, a filer may still use a name that is not distinguishable if it files one of three documents. These are the other business’s written consent, a Minnesota court decree establishing the filer’s prior right, or an affidavit, under conditions the statutes list, that the other business appears to have stopped doing business in Minnesota. “The secretary of state shall determine whether a name is ‘distinguishable’ from another name for purposes of this section and section 302A.117,” under § 302A.115, subd. 3. That is a records check, not a review of who used the name first in the market.
The ownership question sits outside the filing. Section 302A.115, subd. 4, states: “This section and section 302A.117 do not abrogate or limit the law of unfair competition or unfair practices, nor sections 333.001 to 333.54, nor the laws of the United States with respect to the right to acquire and protect copyrights, trade names, trademarks, service names, service marks, or any other rights to the exclusive use of names or symbols, nor derogate the common law or the principles of equity.” Section 322C.0108, subd. 3, carries the same words for LLCs.
An assumed name (a “doing business as” name) gives even less. Under Minn. Stat. § 333.055, subd. 4, the Secretary of State accepts an assumed-name certificate “notwithstanding the fact that the assumed name disclosed therein may not be distinguishable from one or more other assumed names already filed with the secretary of state.” Two businesses can file the same assumed name. The Secretary of State refuses one that is not distinguishable from an entity name in use or reserved, or from a mark registered with the state, unless the filer supplies “a written consent, court decree of prior right, or affidavit of nonuser.”
A state agency’s approval of a name also did not shield a business in court. In North Star State Bank of Roseville v. North Star Bank Minnesota, 361 N.W.2d 889 (Minn. Ct. App. 1985), a bank argued that the Commissioner of Commerce had approved its new name. The court was not persuaded, noting that “No contested case hearing was held before the name change was approved by the Commissioner of Commerce in this matter,” and it affirmed a temporary injunction against the later bank. How federal and Minnesota trademark registration compare is covered on a separate page.
How Does First Use Decide Who Owns a Business Name?
At common law, rights in a business name come from using it in the market, not from choosing it, filing it, or reserving it. Between two businesses, the one that first used a distinctive name for its goods or services holds the earlier right, subject to the limits on territory and federal registration covered below. Those rights can be lost: federal law treats a name as abandoned “When its use has been discontinued with intent not to resume such use,” and “Intent not to resume may be inferred from circumstances,” under 15 U.S.C. § 1127.
The U.S. Supreme Court put the rule this way in United Drug Co. v. Theodore Rectanus Co., 248 U.S. 90 (1918). That case was decided under Kentucky common law before the Lanham Act existed, and the Court wrote that “the right to a particular mark grows out of its use, not its mere adoption.” Federal law now defines a trade name as “any name used by a person to identify his or her business or vocation,” and defines use in commerce as “the bona fide use of a mark in the ordinary course of trade, and not made merely to reserve a right in a mark,” both in 15 U.S.C. § 1127. A name held in reserve or used only as a token does not create priority through use.
How distinctive the name is decides whether first use is enough. The Minnesota Supreme Court explained in Imported Auto Parts Corp. v. R. B. Shaller & Sons, Inc., 258 N.W.2d 797 (Minn. 1977): “If the business selects a mark that is arbitrary with respect to its trade or merely suggestive of it, the business’ first use of the mark will establish common-law rights, if another has not yet appropriated it.” A descriptive name needs proof that buyers connect it with one company, called secondary meaning. A generic name belongs to no one company, though the court added: “A generic term is free to be used by all. Nevertheless, the doctrine of unfair competition requires that subsequent use of the term be fair.” In North Star, the court treated “North Star” as arbitrary for banking services, so the earlier bank did not need to prove secondary meaning. How first use and the federal priority date interact is covered on a separate page.
Dates and markets come first in a dispute because everything else rests on them. In one inquiry I received, an owner whose company started several years before a similarly named competitor reported that at least two of the company’s own customers had taken the competitor’s calls believing they came from the owner’s company. Which company held the stronger claim to the name in that shared market was the first question any demand to the competitor had to answer, because what the demand could ask for rested on it.
When Can Two Businesses Use the Same Name in Different Places?
Two businesses can lawfully use the same name in separate markets when each adopted it in good faith and neither holds a federal or Minnesota trademark registration that limits the other’s rights. A business’s common-law rights extend to the market it actually reached, and in Minnesota that market is not limited to the area where the two businesses already compete.
United Drug applied the territorial rule to a Massachusetts seller and a Louisville druggist who had used the same mark for decades without knowing of each other. The Court described a case “where the same trademark happens to be employed simultaneously by two manufacturers in different markets separate and remote from each other, so that the mark means one thing in one market, an entirely different thing in another.” It held that the newcomer to Louisville could not stop the local user there, and it affirmed the appeals court’s decree directing dismissal of the suit.
Minnesota courts measure the earlier user’s market broadly. In North Star, the court stated that “A territorial market is not necessarily confined to an area of actual competition.” The two banks were about ten miles apart, they agreed that no geographic or legal boundaries limited where either could draw customers, and the earlier bank had advertised in the metropolitan market and, to a limited extent, statewide. Reviewing a temporary injunction, the court held that the trial court did not clearly err in finding the earlier bank likely to prevail on this point.
A Minnesota trademark registration also limits common-law rights against the registrant. Minn. Stat. § 333.30 provides: “Nothing herein shall adversely affect a person’s rights or the enforcement of the rights in a mark acquired in good faith at any time at common law, except that the rights as against the registrant of the same or confusingly similar mark are limited to the areas of the person’s use established prior to the registration date and areas in which the person’s mark has become known prior to the registration date.” Proving that territory takes evidence, and what it takes to prove common-law rights is covered on a separate page.
How Does Federal Trademark Registration Change Who Wins?
A federal registration gives its owner a right of priority, “nationwide in effect,” from the application’s filing date for the goods or services in the registration, against later uses “likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive.” That priority does not reach a business that was already using the name before the filing and has not abandoned it.
The rule is 15 U.S.C. § 1057(c): “Contingent on the registration of a mark on the principal register provided by this chapter, the filing of the application to register such mark shall constitute constructive use of the mark, conferring a right of priority, nationwide in effect, on or in connection with the goods or services specified in the registration against any other person except for a person whose mark has not been abandoned and who, prior to such filing . . . has used the mark.” The statute also excepts a person who filed its own application first. The earlier user’s own rights remain common-law rights, and those rights do not “project the right of protection in advance of the extension of the trade,” as the Supreme Court put it in United Drug. Once registered, the registration “shall be constructive notice of the registrant’s claim of ownership thereof,” under 15 U.S.C. § 1072.
The earlier user’s protection depends on whether the registration has become incontestable. Before then, under 15 U.S.C. § 1115(a), the registration “shall not preclude another person from proving any legal or equitable defense or defect, including those set forth in subsection (b), which might have been asserted if such mark had not been registered.” Section 1052(d) also bars registering a mark likely to be confused with “a mark or trade name previously used in the United States by another and not abandoned.” An earlier user raises that bar against a pending application by an opposition, which 15 U.S.C. § 1063(a) times from the application’s publication. Against an issued registration, the earlier user files a petition to cancel under 15 U.S.C. § 1064. A petition to cancel on that ground falls under the deadline in § 1064(1), because the grounds § 1064(3) allows “At any time” name subsections “(a), (b), or (c) of section 1052” and not subsection (d).
The narrower defense in § 1115(b)(5) applies “To the extent that the right to use the registered mark has become incontestable under section 1065 of this title.” It requires that the earlier user’s name “was adopted without knowledge of the registrant’s prior use and has been continuously used by such party or those in privity with him from a date prior to (A) the date of constructive use of the mark established pursuant to section 1057(c) of this title.” The defense “shall apply only for the area in which such continuous prior use is proved.”
A registration is strong evidence, not the end of the analysis. Even an incontestable registration yields under 15 U.S.C. § 1065 “to the extent, if any, to which the use of a mark registered on the principal register infringes a valid right acquired under the law of any State or Territory by use of a mark or trade name continuing from a date prior to the date of registration.” A clearance search of federal and state records shows whether either business has filed.
What Makes Two Business Names Confusingly Similar?
Two names conflict when customers are likely to be confused about which business they are dealing with or whether the two are connected. The names do not have to be identical, and courts weigh all the circumstances rather than any single factor.
The Eighth Circuit, the federal appeals court for Minnesota, affirmed an injunction against the soft drink name QUIRST in favor of the registered mark SQUIRT in SquirtCo v. Seven-Up Co., 628 F.2d 1086 (8th Cir. 1980). The appeal followed a bench trial, and the Eighth Circuit noted that “Both parties recognize that the district court applied the proper legal standards regarding infringement.” It described the trial court as recognizing that “resolution of this issue does not hinge on a single factor but requires a consideration of numerous factors to determine whether under all the circumstances there is a likelihood of confusion.” The factors include:
- the strength of the earlier name, because “A strong and distinctive trademark is entitled to greater protection than a weak or commonplace one”;
- how similar the names look and sound as a whole;
- how closely related the goods or services are;
- how close the businesses are as competitors, though “Competitive proximity is one factor to be considered, even though infringement may be found in the absence of direct competition”;
- how much care buyers use;
- whether the later business intended to trade on the earlier one; and
- evidence of actual confusion.
Minnesota law reaches the same conduct. Under Minn. Stat. § 325D.44, subd. 1, a business engages in a deceptive trade practice when it “causes likelihood of confusion or of misunderstanding as to the source, sponsorship, approval, or certification of goods or services” or “causes likelihood of confusion or of misunderstanding as to affiliation, connection, or association with, or certification by, another.” Under subd. 2, “a complainant need not prove competition between the parties or actual confusion or misunderstanding.” Federal law adds a claim for unregistered names under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1), and a claim for registered marks under 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1).
For a Minnesota common-law trade-name claim, the Minnesota Supreme Court in Howards Clothes, Inc. v. Howard Clothes Corp., 236 Minn. 291, 52 N.W.2d 753 (1952) set out three requirements for the earlier business. Its name must have special significance or secondary meaning in the trade, and it must have a protectable interest in the name in its market. The later name must be one by which the ordinary purchaser “has been, or is reasonably likely to be, deceived as to the true identity of the goods, services, or business.” The later Minnesota decisions discussed above do not require secondary meaning for an arbitrary or suggestive name. The test for likelihood of confusion is covered in more depth on a separate page.
What Can a Court Order When Two Business Names Conflict?
A court can order the later business to stop using the name, or to change how it uses the name so customers can tell the two apart. Money damages and attorney fees are available in narrower circumstances.
Minnesota’s injunction remedy does not require proof of lost money. Under Minn. Stat. § 325D.45, subd. 1: “A person likely to be damaged by a deceptive trade practice of another may be granted an injunction against it under the principles of equity and on terms that the court considers reasonable. Proof of monetary damage, loss of profits, or intent to deceive is not required.” Fees cut both ways under subd. 2: a court may award them if “the party complaining of a deceptive trade practice has brought an action knowing it to be groundless,” or if “the party charged with a deceptive trade practice has willfully engaged in the trade practice knowing it to be deceptive.”
A business whose name is registered as a Minnesota trademark or service mark has added remedies. Under Minn. Stat. § 333.29, subd. 1, “An owner of a mark registered under sections 333.18 to 333.31 may bring an action to enjoin the manufacture, use, display, or sale of any counterfeits or imitations of the mark,” and the court “may enter judgment for an amount not to exceed three times the profits and damages and reasonable attorneys’ fees of the prevailing party if the court finds the other party committed the wrongful acts with knowledge or in bad faith or otherwise as according to the circumstances of the case.” In federal court, under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a), a plaintiff who shows a violation, or a likelihood of success for a preliminary order, “shall be entitled to a rebuttable presumption of irreparable harm.”
Minnesota courts have shaped relief instead of ordering a full stop. In Howards Clothes, both stores had adopted the Howard name in good faith, and the court sustained a trial court order requiring the later store to feature the words “of New York” prominently with its name. In North Star, the trial court required the later bank to use “North Star Bank Minnesota, formerly Crystal State Bank” in its advertising and other uses, and the Court of Appeals affirmed that temporary relief as “fashioning relief which protects the investment of both parties.” A business seeking any of these orders can start with a cease-and-desist letter.
How Do Two Businesses Resolve a Name Conflict Without a Lawsuit?
Two businesses can resolve a name conflict by agreement: one rebrands, both add distinguishing words, or they divide markets or territories in a written coexistence agreement. Minnesota’s entity-name statutes let a filer rely on the other business’s written consent, and federal law lets the USPTO issue concurrent registrations, including when the earlier owner consents.
The options include:
- Written consent. A company that wants to file a name the Secretary of State would otherwise refuse can file “The written consent of the domestic corporation, limited partnership, limited liability partnership, or limited liability company” holding the similar name, under § 302A.115, subd. 1(d)(1), and the parallel LLC provision. Consent is one of three routes the statutes list; the others are a court decree of prior right and, under conditions the statutes list, an affidavit that the other business appears inactive.
- A coexistence agreement. The businesses set out who uses the name where, for which goods or services, and with what distinguishing words. A settlement or coexistence agreement should say what each business may do if the other expands into its market, because terms written only for today’s markets leave that question open.
- Concurrent federal registration. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1052(d), the USPTO may issue concurrent registrations “if the Director determines that confusion, mistake, or deception is not likely to result from the continued use by more than one person of the same or similar marks under conditions and limitations as to the mode or place of use,” to users who “have become entitled to use such marks as a result of their concurrent lawful use in commerce prior to (1) the earliest of the filing dates of the applications pending or of any registration issued under this chapter.” The statute adds: “Use prior to the filing date of any pending application or a registration shall not be required when the owner of such application or registration consents to the grant of a concurrent registration to the applicant.”
- A planned rebrand. A business that decides to change its name can negotiate time to use up materials and finish existing commitments.
Waiting has its own cost. Federal law lists among the defenses even to an incontestable registration “That equitable principles, including laches, estoppel, and acquiescence, are applicable,” under § 1115(b)(9). A business that knows of a conflicting name and does nothing may weaken its own position, and how courts apply laches is covered on a separate page.
In another inquiry I received, the cease-and-desist letter a business owner had been sent rested on pending federal applications rather than registrations, and the response I proposed used that difference as one of its points. I suggest answering a demand like that through a letter rather than contacting the other business informally, because an informal explanation can be read as accepting the other side’s demands.
Can a court make my company stop using a name the Secretary of State accepted?
Yes. Minnesota’s corporation and LLC name statutes, Minn. Stat. § 302A.115 and Minn. Stat. § 322C.0108, say they do not limit the law of unfair competition or federal trademark law, so a business with a prior right can still sue over a confusing name. Each statute also lets a court, on application of the state or a person interested or affected, enjoin a company from doing business under a name used in violation of the section, even after its articles were filed.
Do I need proof that customers were actually confused?
No. Minn. Stat. § 325D.44, subd. 2, says a complainant need not prove competition between the parties or actual confusion or misunderstanding; the question is whether confusion is likely. The federal appeals court for Minnesota has said that actual confusion is not essential to a finding of trademark infringement, though it is positive proof of likelihood of confusion, and that court weighs it among the factors. Dated records of misdirected calls, emails, or payments are the evidence I suggest keeping.
Can I use my own last name if another business already uses it?
Only with a distinguishing addition, if the other business has a prior right to the name in your market for related goods or services. Assuming, without deciding, that two stores shared a market, the Minnesota Supreme Court stated that a later user of a personal name, even its own and in good faith, may not use it as a trade name there without a distinguishing legend or other device that removes any reasonable likelihood of confusion. It sustained a finding that the words of New York, featured prominently, would prevent diverted trade.
Is a name that just describes my services protected?
Not as one company’s property if the name is generic, though a later user’s use of it must still be fair, and only with proof of secondary meaning if it is descriptive. The Minnesota Supreme Court treated Imported Auto Parts as a generic name free to be used by all, and it affirmed for a later business that put its own, more prominent name in front of those words. A descriptive name is protected only after a substantial number of prospective buyers connect it with one company rather than with a characteristic of the product.
What if a later company federally registers the name I used first?
If you used the name before the other company filed and have not abandoned it, its nationwide filing-date priority under 15 U.S.C. § 1057(c) does not reach you, though your rights stop at your trade’s reach. Registration does not bar any defense available without it (§ 1115(a)). Section 1052(d) bars registering a mark likely confused with a name another previously used and has not abandoned; opposition and cancellation on that ground are time-limited (§§ 1063(a), 1064(1)). After incontestability, the § 1115(b)(5) defense requires adoption without knowing of the registrant’s prior use, and covers only areas of proven continuous prior use.
Next Steps
Whether your business came first or second, the evidence that decides a name conflict is dated and specific. I suggest gathering it before contacting the other business, because a demand can ask only for what your evidence supports.
- Your first-use evidence. I suggest collecting the earliest invoices, signs, advertising, website archives, and filings showing the name in use, with where your customers are located, because priority and territory both rest on those dates and places.
- The other business’s dates. I suggest searching the Minnesota Secretary of State’s records and the federal trademark register for both names, because a federal filing date or registration changes who can stop whom.
- Instances of confusion. I suggest keeping a dated record of every misdirected call, email, payment, or review, because courts treat actual confusion as “positive proof of likelihood of confusion,” even though no claim on this page requires it.
- Your goal. I suggest deciding whether you want the other business to stop, to add distinguishing words, or to agree on separate markets, because each outcome calls for a different first letter.
If another business is using a name close to yours and you want to know which of you holds the stronger claim on your facts, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents. More on how I handle these matters is on my trademark practice page.