When a Minnesota building official issues a decision, interpretation, or order against your building or project, the appeal runs through three steps. You start at the local board of appeals, or a state-assembled board where the city has none. You then go to the commissioner of labor and industry as a contested case, and then to the Court of Appeals by certiorari. The State Building Code rules in Minn. R. 1300.0230 and the appeal statute, Minn. Stat. § 326B.139, set that route, and chapter 14 governs the court review. This page is for the owner of a business or commercial building facing that decision, and it sits with my other Minnesota real estate and property pages.

How Do You Appeal a Building Official’s Decision in Minnesota?

You appeal first to the board of appeals that the State Building Code rules create for decisions of the building official, and then, if you lose there, to the commissioner and the courts. Minn. R. 1300.0230, subp. 1 creates the board “to hear and decide appeals of orders, decisions, or determinations made by the building official relative to the application and interpretation of this code.” Under § 326B.139, a person aggrieved by a board’s final decision “may, within 180 days of the decision, appeal to the commissioner,” and “An appeal must be heard as a contested case under chapter 14.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on this period. The Court of Appeals described the last step in Centra Homes, LLC v. City of Norwood Young America, 834 N.W.2d 581 (Minn. App. 2013): “A contested-case decision may be appealed by writ of certiorari to this court.”

A denied permit or plan, a correction notice, a stop work order, or a suspended certificate of occupancy can start this route. It does so when it rests on how the official applied or read the code, because the board hears determinations “relative to the application and interpretation of this code.”

Some buildings have the state, not the city, as their code official. Minn. Stat. § 326B.107, subd. 1 states: “Unless the commissioner has entered into an agreement under subdivision 2 or 3, the commissioner shall administer and enforce the State Building Code as a municipality with respect to public buildings and state-licensed facilities in the state.” Minn. Stat. § 326B.103, subd. 13 defines a state-licensed facility by its state license. The listed licenses are for a hospital, nursing home, supervised living facility, assisted living facility, free-standing outpatient surgical center, correctional facility, boarding care home, or residential hospice. If your building is one of these, I suggest confirming who issued the decision before choosing a board, because the commissioner enforces the code there unless an agreement exists.

What Grounds Can a Building Code Appeal Raise?

A building code appeal can raise three grounds: the official misread the code, the provision does not fully apply to your building, or you propose construction that is equally good or better. Minn. R. 1300.0230, subp. 3 states that an application “shall be based on a claim that the true intent of this code or the rules legally adopted thereunder have been incorrectly interpreted, the provisions of this code do not fully apply, or an equally good or better form of construction is proposed.”

Each ground calls for different proof:

  1. Misread code. The proof is the code section, its text, and the reason the official’s reading departs from its intent.
  2. Provision does not fully apply. The proof is the set of facts that takes your building outside the provision, such as its occupancy classification, its construction type, or the code edition under which the permit was issued.
  3. Equally good or better construction. The proof is a showing that your design gives the protection the requirement aims at, for example through an engineer’s or architect’s analysis or test results.

A complaint that compliance costs too much is not one of the three grounds, so I suggest framing a cost problem as one of them or as a request for a modification.

What Can You Ask the Building Official for Before Appealing?

Before appealing, you can ask the building official for a modification or for approval of an alternative design, and either one can end the dispute without a hearing. Minn. R. 1300.0110, subp. 12 states: “If there are practical difficulties involved in carrying out the provisions of the code, the building official may grant modifications for individual cases, upon application by the owner or owner’s representative, provided the building official finds that special individual reason makes the strict letter of the code impractical, the modification is in compliance with the intent and purpose of the code, and the modification does not lessen health, life, and fire safety or structural requirements.” Under subpart 13, “An alternative material, design, or method of construction shall be approved where the building official finds that the proposed design is satisfactory and complies with the intent of the code, and that the material, method, or work offered is, for the purpose intended, at least the equivalent of that prescribed in the code in quality, strength, effectiveness, fire resistance, durability, and safety.”

Your options at this stage include:

  • A direct conversation with the official. A dispute can turn on a detail the official has not seen, such as a product listing or an engineer’s calculation, and a short meeting with that document may resolve it.
  • A written modification or alternative request. A written request states exactly what you asked the official to approve.
  • A design professional’s report or tests. Under subpart 15, “If there is insufficient evidence of compliance with the code, or evidence that a material or method does not conform to the requirements of the code, or in order to substantiate claims for alternative materials or methods,” the official may require tests “to be made at no expense to the municipality,” so the cost of testing falls on you.
  • Correcting the work. When the cost of the fix is less than the cost of the appeal, fixing it may be the better business choice. Separate pages cover the steps for fixing a building code violation and scheduling re-inspection and the rules on when a building permit is required.

If the official denies an alternative, subpart 13 states: “The permit applicant may request written documentation of the denial, including the reasons for the denial.” For a rejected permit application, Minn. R. 1300.0120, subp. 8 states: “The applicant may request written documentation of the rejection and the reasons for the rejection.” I suggest that the applicant make the request that fits the denial every time, because the reasons show the board what it is reviewing.

How Does the Local Board of Appeals Work?

The local board is a panel of people with construction experience who are not city employees, and it must hear your appeal promptly. Minn. R. 1300.0230, subp. 2 requires members “qualified by experience and training to pass on matters pertaining to building construction” who “are not employees of the affected jurisdiction.” The official whose decision you are appealing sits on the board but “shall have no vote on any matter before the board.”

The rule sets two time limits on the city and the board. “Appeals hearings must occur within ten working days from the date the municipality receives a properly completed application for appeal. If an appeals hearing is not held within this time, the applicant may appeal directly to the State Building Code Appeals Board.” After the hearing, the board must “render all decisions and findings in writing to the appellant with a duplicate copy to the building official and to the state building official within five working days of the decision.”

Each board “shall adopt rules of procedures for conducting its business,” so the application form, any filing deadline, and the hearing format come from your city. I suggest getting the city’s board procedures in writing on the day you receive the decision, because the hearing clock starts only when the city receives a properly completed application.

How Does an Appeal to the Commissioner Work?

If the board rules against you, Minn. Stat. § 326B.139 provides that you “may, within 180 days of the decision, appeal to the commissioner” of labor and industry, and that appeal is a contested case under chapter 14. The section states: “A person aggrieved by the final decision of any local or state level board of appeals as to the application of the code, including any rules adopted under section 471.469, may, within 180 days of the decision, appeal to the commissioner.” Check the current text of section 326B.139 before relying on this period.

The statute adds: “Appellant shall submit a nonrefundable fee of $70, payable to the commissioner, with the request for appeal. An appeal must be heard as a contested case under chapter 14.” A contested case is a formal evidentiary hearing whose costs the statute assigns to the losing side, so I suggest treating it as the stage where your evidence should be complete. Under Minn. Stat. § 14.58, “The record shall contain a written transcript of the hearing only if preparation of a transcript is requested by the agency, a party, or the chief administrative law judge,” so I suggest requesting one, because the Court of Appeals reviews the decision against the record.

Before the commissioner decides, Minn. Stat. § 14.61, subd. 1 bars the final decision until “the report of the administrative law judge as required by sections 14.48 to 14.56, has been made available to parties to the proceeding for at least ten days and an opportunity has been afforded to each party adversely affected to file exceptions and present argument to a majority of the officials who are to render the decision.” Under subdivision 2, the record closes “upon the filing of any exceptions to the report and presentation of argument under subdivision 1 or upon expiration of the deadline for doing so.” Subdivision 1 states that “This section does not apply to a contested case under which the report or order of the administrative law judge constitutes the final decision in the case.” Check the current text of section 14.61 before relying on this period. Minn. Stat. § 326B.139 also states that “The commissioner shall submit written findings to the parties,” and that “Any person aggrieved by a ruling of the commissioner may appeal in accordance with chapter 14.”

When Does a Code Question Go to a Final Interpretation?

A final interpretation is a statewide ruling on what a building code provision means, and for the building code only a board of appeals can ask for one. Minn. Stat. § 326B.127, subd. 5 states that, except for the plumbing, electrical, and high-pressure piping codes, “requests for final interpretation must come from a local or state level building code board of appeals.” A seven-member committee of “three building officials, two inspectors from the affected field, and two construction industry representatives” reviews the request and recommends an answer to the commissioner.

Once issued, a final interpretation applies statewide: “Municipal building officials shall administer all final interpretations issued by the commissioner,” until the commissioner or the relevant board considers it for adoption into the code. The statute also gives a separate appeal: “Any person aggrieved by a final interpretation may appeal the interpretation within 30 days of its issuance by the commissioner or the board in accordance with chapter 14.” Check the current text of section 326B.127 before relying on this period.

If your dispute turns on a provision that officials across the state read differently, I suggest asking the board to request a final interpretation, because the answer then applies to your next project too.

How Does Court of Appeals Review by Certiorari Work?

After the commissioner rules, the next step is a petition for a writ of certiorari in the Minnesota Court of Appeals, and the statute sets both a filing deadline and service steps. Minn. Stat. § 14.63 states: “A petition for a writ of certiorari by an aggrieved person for judicial review under sections 14.63 to 14.68 must be filed with the court of appeals and served on all parties to the contested case not more than 30 days after the party receives the final decision and order of the agency.” A request for reconsideration changes the start date under Minn. Stat. § 14.64: “If a request for reconsideration is made within ten days after the decision and order of the agency, the 30-day period provided in section 14.63 shall not begin to run until service of the order finally disposing of the application for reconsideration.” Check the current text of sections 14.63 and 14.64 before relying on these periods.

Section 14.64 also sets the steps that start review:

  1. Serve the petition “personally or by certified mail upon the agency.”
  2. Promptly file “the proof of service in the Office of the Clerk of the Appellate Courts,” after which “the matter shall proceed in the manner provided by the Rules of Civil Appellate Procedure.”
  3. Serve the writ on the other parties: “Copies of the writ shall be served, personally or by certified mail, upon all parties to the proceeding before the agency in the proceeding in which the order sought to be reviewed was made.”
  4. Provide “A copy of the petition . . . to the attorney general at the time of service of the parties.”

Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 115.03 adds filing requirements: “The petition shall definitely and briefly state the decision, judgment, order or proceeding that is sought to be reviewed and the errors that the petitioner claims. A copy of the decision and the statement of the case pursuant to Rule 133.03 shall be filed with the petition.” The same rule states: “The petitioner shall pay $550 to the clerk of the appellate courts, unless no fee is required under Rule 103.01, subd. 3, or by statute.” Subdivision 4 adds a time limit to step 2 and the writ to step 4: “The petitioner shall serve a copy of the petition and the writ, if issued, upon the agency or body to which it is directed and upon every party. Proof of service shall be filed with the clerk of the appellate courts within 7 days of service. A copy of the petition and writ shall be provided to the Attorney General, unless the state is neither a party nor the body to which the writ is directed.” Check the current text of Rule 115.03 before relying on this period.

Filing the petition does not by itself pause enforcement of the decision under Minn. Stat. § 14.65, which lets the agency or the court order a stay. Rule 115.03, subd. 2(b) sets the order of those requests: “Application for a supersedeas bond or a stay on other terms must be made in the first instance to the agency or body. Upon motion, the Court of Appeals may review the agency’s or body’s decision on a stay and the terms of any stay.”

Under Minn. Stat. § 14.69, the court may affirm the decision or remand it. It may reverse or modify the decision if “the substantial rights of the petitioners may have been prejudiced” because the decision is unconstitutional, beyond the agency’s authority, made on unlawful procedure, affected by other error of law, “unsupported by substantial evidence in view of the entire record as submitted,” or arbitrary or capricious.

What Should Your Appeal Record Contain?

Your appeal record should contain every written order, every request you made, every denial with its reasons, and every technical report, because the Court of Appeals tests the decision against the record. One ground of review under § 14.69 is a decision “unsupported by substantial evidence in view of the entire record as submitted,” so I suggest putting each piece of evidence before the board and the contested case hearing.

The rules give you ways to build that record:

  • The written order. Under Minn. R. 1300.0110, subp. 4, “Notices and orders shall be in writing unless waived by the permit applicant, contractor, owner, or owner’s agent.” I suggest never waiving that, because a written order shows exactly what you are appealing.
  • The code edition. The same subpart states that orders “shall be based on the edition of the code under which the permit has been issued,” so keep the permit and confirm which edition the official applied.
  • The written denial. This is the written documentation, with its reasons, that you may request as described above. Subpart 13 gives the permit applicant that request for a denied alternative, and Minn. R. 1300.0120, subp. 8 gives the applicant one for a rejected permit application.
  • Your technical proof. This includes engineer or architect reports, product listings, and any test results under subpart 15.
  • The board’s written findings. Under Minn. R. 1300.0230, subp. 1, the board must render its decisions and findings in writing to you as the appellant.

When Does a Building Code Dispute Belong in District Court?

Under Centra Homes, a dispute over how a building official applied or interpreted the code goes through the board and the commissioner before judicial review, unless an exception applies. Centra Homes, quoting an earlier decision, repeats the general rule that “exhaustion of administrative remedies need not be pursued if it would be futile to do so,” and a 2012 Court of Appeals case discussed next shows a second exception. An order under Minn. Stat. § 463.16 from the governing body of a municipality to the owner of a hazardous building within the municipality follows a separate district court process. The end of this section describes that process. The Centra Homes opinion names certiorari to the Court of Appeals as the review of the resulting contested-case decision. In Centra Homes, builders sued a city in district court over building-permit fees, and the Court of Appeals held that because the fees were “determinations made by the city building official relative to the application and interpretation of the state building code,” the builders “were required to exhaust their administrative remedies before seeking judicial review.” The court reversed the district court’s refusal to dismiss the suit.

One exception is a dispute the commissioner cannot decide. In Builders Ass’n v. City of St. Paul, 819 N.W.2d 172 (Minn. App. 2012), a trade association challenged a city egress-window policy that differed from the code. Because the case also required interpreting the city’s policy and the State Fire Code, “neither of which fall within the commissioner’s interpretative authority,” the court held that “no adequate administrative remedies were available” and the association did not have to exhaust them.

On the merits, the court held that “The state building code preempts the city’s attempt to impose differing requirements for egress window sizes.” It relied on Minn. Stat. § 326B.121, which states in subdivision 1 that “The State Building Code supersedes the building code of any municipality.” Subdivision 2 adds that “A municipality must not by ordinance, or through development agreement, require building code provisions regulating components or systems of any structure that are different from any provision of the State Building Code.” The same subdivision also keeps some local powers, including these two. “This subdivision does not prohibit a municipality from enacting or enforcing an ordinance requiring existing components or systems of any structure to be maintained in a safe and sanitary condition or in good repair, but not exceeding the standards under which the structure was built, reconstructed, or altered, or the component or system was installed, unless specific retroactive provisions for existing buildings have been adopted as part of the State Building Code.” And “A municipality may, with the approval of the state building official, adopt an ordinance that is more restrictive than the State Building Code where geological conditions warrant a more restrictive ordinance.”

A hazardous-building order from a municipality’s governing body takes a different route. Minn. R. 1300.0180 first gives the building official its own orders: “The building official shall order any building or portion of a building to be vacated if continued use is dangerous to life, health, or safety of the occupants.” The building official also “shall have the authority to order disconnection of utility services to the building, structure, or system, regulated by the code, in case of an emergency to eliminate a hazard to life or property,” and “The order shall be in writing and state the reasons for the action.” For abatement, the rule states: “All unsafe buildings, structures, or appendages are public nuisances and must be abated by repair, rehabilitation, demolition, or removal according to Minnesota Statutes, sections 463.15 to 463.26.” Under Minn. Stat. § 463.16, “The governing body of any municipality may order the owner of any hazardous building or property within the municipality to correct or remove the hazardous condition of the building or property or to raze or remove the building.” Minn. Stat. § 463.17, subd. 1 requires the order to “state that a motion for summary enforcement of the order will be made to the district court of the county in which the hazardous building or property is situated unless corrective action is taken, or unless an answer is filed within the time specified in section 463.18.”

The owner may serve an answer to the order. Minn. Stat. § 463.18 states: “Within 20 days from the date of service, any person upon whom the order is served may serve an answer in the manner provided for the service of an answer in a civil action, specifically denying such facts in the order as are in dispute.” Check the current text of section 463.18 before relying on this period. Under Minn. Stat. § 463.19, “If no answer is served, the governing body may move the court for the enforcement of the order,” and the court may “affirm or modify the order and enter judgment accordingly, fixing a time after which the governing body may proceed with the enforcement of the order.” If an answer is served, Minn. Stat. § 463.20 states that “further proceedings in the action shall be governed by the Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts, except that the action has priority over all pending civil actions and shall be tried forthwith.” Minn. Stat. § 463.26 states: “Sections 463.15 to 463.26 are supplementary to other statutory and charter provisions and do not limit the authority of any city to enact and enforce ordinances on the same subject.” I suggest checking which statute or ordinance an unsafe-building order cites before choosing how to respond, because the order may rest on a city ordinance rather than these sections.

A zoning decision is a different body of law with its own board. If the city’s objection is about use, height, or placement, the route is appealing a zoning decision to the board of appeals and adjustments. The zoning variance appeal process and the Minnesota zoning setback requirements cover two of those placement questions.

Can the board of appeals waive a code requirement for my building?

No, the board cannot waive one. Minn. R. 1300.0230, subp. 3 states: “The board shall have no authority to waive requirements of this code.” The board decides whether the code was misread, whether it fully applies, or whether your proposal is equally good or better. For a requirement that is impractical on your site, the code’s own route is a modification the building official may grant under Minn. R. 1300.0110, subp. 12. That subpart sets conditions and findings, which this page’s section on requests before appealing quotes in full.

What if my city has no board of appeals?

You still have an appeal. Under Minn. R. 1300.0230, subp. 1, “For jurisdictions without a board of appeals, the appellant may appeal to an appeals board assembled by the state of Minnesota, Department of Labor and Industry’s Construction Codes and Licensing Division.” If a city board does not hold your hearing on time, the same rule states that “the applicant may appeal directly to the State Building Code Appeals Board.” Under Minn. Stat. § 326B.139, a person aggrieved by either board’s final decision “may, within 180 days of the decision, appeal to the commissioner.” Check the current text of section 326B.139 before relying on this period.

Who pays the hearing costs if I lose an appeal to the commissioner?

The losing side pays the hearing costs, and the costs this section shifts do not include attorney fees. Minn. Stat. § 326B.139 states: “The party not prevailing shall pay the costs of the contested case hearing, including fees charged by the Court of Administrative Hearings and the expense of transcript preparation. Costs under this section do not include attorney fees.” The $70 filing fee is nonrefundable.

Can I keep working on the project while I appeal a stop work order?

You cannot continue the cited work. Minn. R. 1300.0170 states: “Upon issuance of a stop work order, the cited work shall immediately cease.” The rule adds: “A person who continues work after having been served with a stop work order, except for work that the person is directed to perform to remove a violation or unsafe condition, is subject to penalties as prescribed by law.” The order itself must state “the conditions under which the cited work will be permitted to resume,” so I suggest reading those conditions first, because meeting them can end the stop faster than an appeal.

Does a certiorari petition stop the decision from being enforced?

Filing the petition does not stop enforcement by itself. Minn. Stat. § 14.65 states: “The filing of the writ of certiorari shall not stay the enforcement of the agency decision; but the agency may do so, or the court of appeals may order a stay upon such terms as it deems proper.” To ask for one, Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 115.03, subd. 2(b) states that an application for a stay “must be made in the first instance to the agency or body,” and that on motion “the Court of Appeals may review the agency’s or body’s decision on a stay.”

Does this process cover electrical, plumbing, or fire code orders?

It depends on which code the order cites and who enforces that code. Minn. Stat. § 326B.106, subd. 3 states: “Under the direction and supervision of the commissioner, the provisions of the code relating to electrical installations, plumbing, boilers, high pressure steam piping and appurtenances, and ammonia refrigeration piping shall be enforced by the Department of Labor and Industry,” and “Under direction of the commissioner of public safety, the state fire marshal shall enforce the State Fire Code as provided in chapter 299F.” Under § 326B.127, subd. 5, final interpretations of the State Plumbing Code, the State Electrical Code, and the State High Pressure Piping Code come from their own boards, not the commissioner. The State Fire Code is outside the commissioner’s interpretive authority, as the Court of Appeals noted in Builders Ass’n v. City of St. Paul, 819 N.W.2d 172 (Minn. App. 2012).

Building Code Appeal Routes in Minnesota

A Minnesota building code appeal turns on the written record. The local board, the commissioner’s contested case, and certiorari to the Court of Appeals form one chain. Under Centra Homes, a dispute over the official’s application of the code goes through the board and the commissioner before you seek judicial review, subject to the exceptions described above. An order under section 463.16 from a municipality’s governing body to the owner of a hazardous building within the municipality follows sections 463.15 to 463.26 in district court. Those sections do not limit a city’s own ordinances on the same subject. Before appealing, a modification or alternative request to the building official may resolve the problem faster. My other Minnesota real estate pages cover the property questions around these disputes. If a building official’s decision is holding up your building or project, email [email protected] with a short description. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any documents.