A Minnesota company can pay legal fees in a dispute among its owners, but through set channels. The company may pay its own lawyer, who represents the company. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, an owner sued “by reason of the former or present official capacity of the person,” such as a director or officer, is entitled to advances of defense costs on written request and to indemnification at the end. Both depend on stated conditions and on the company’s documents not prohibiting or limiting them. A payment for a controlling owner’s personal fight outside that process is tested against that owner’s duties to the company and the other owners.
Minnesota sets these rules by statute: § 302A.521 for corporations and Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408 for limited liability companies (LLCs), alongside the conflict-of-interest and duty sections of both chapters. This page is written for an owner of a closely held Minnesota corporation or LLC in a dispute with co-owners. You may be the owner whose fees the company is paying or the owner objecting to it. The page is part of my material on how a shareholder dispute is resolved in Minnesota.
How Can Company Money Pay for Lawyers in an Owner Dispute?
Company money can reach lawyers in an owner dispute in three ways. It can pay the company’s own lawyer, it can pay an owner’s personal lawyer under the indemnification statute, and it can make some other payment for an owner, which that owner’s duties test. The company’s lawyer and the controlling owner’s personal lawyer serve different clients, even when the controlling owner hires both.
Under Minn. R. Prof. Conduct 1.13(a), “A lawyer employed or retained by an organization represents the organization acting through its duly authorized constituents.” The company’s lawyer serves the company, whoever gives the instructions. When the company’s interests turn against an owner’s, Rule 1.13(e) provides that “a lawyer shall explain the identity of the client when the lawyer knows or reasonably should know that the organization’s interests are adverse to those of the constituents with whom the lawyer is dealing.”
An owner’s own lawyer is paid by the owner unless a rule moves the cost to the company, and the indemnification statute is one rule that does. Whether the company’s lawyer may also represent an owner, and what happens to what you tell that lawyer, is covered on my page about who the company’s lawyer represents in an owner dispute.
When Does the Indemnification Statute Cover a Co-Owner’s Legal Fees?
Under § 302A.521, subd. 2, the statute covers an owner made, or threatened to be made, a party to a proceeding “by reason of the former or present official capacity of the person.” In a corporation, an official capacity is a position as a director, an officer, a member of a board committee, or an employee. Owning shares is not on that list, so the question for each claim is whether it targets the owner in one of the listed positions.
Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 2, provides that “Subject to the provisions of subdivision 4, a corporation shall indemnify a person made or threatened to be made a party to a proceeding by reason of the former or present official capacity of the person against judgments, penalties, fines,” along with settlements and reasonable expenses, including attorneys’ fees. Subdivision 1 defines the capacity: “‘Official capacity’ means (1) with respect to a director, the position of director in a corporation, (2) with respect to a person other than a director, the elective or appointive office or position held by an officer, member of a committee of the board, or the employment relationship undertaken by an employee of the corporation.” A third clause covers service for another organization at the company’s request.
The kind of case is broad. “‘Proceeding’ means a threatened, pending, or completed civil, criminal, administrative, arbitration, or investigative proceeding, including a proceeding by or in the right of the corporation” (subd. 1). A suit a co-owner brings on the company’s behalf qualifies, and so does a civil suit in the co-owner’s own name. In a closely held company, one owner can be a director, an officer, and an employee at the same time, so a single lawsuit can reach the owner in several roles.
An LLC’s statute adds owners who manage. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 1, “‘Official capacity’ means (1) with respect to a member of a member-managed company, a manager of a manager-managed company, or a governor of a board-managed company, actions taken in that capacity.” It also covers officers, committee members, employees, and “the scope of the services provided by members of the limited liability company who provide services to the limited liability company.”
What Must Happen Before the Company Advances a Co-Owner’s Fees?
Before the case ends, a covered owner is entitled to have the company pay reasonable defense costs once four things happen. The owner makes a written request, gives a written good-faith affirmation and a written promise to repay, and receives a determination that the facts then known would not preclude indemnification. The company’s documents may prohibit or condition these advances, and indemnification at the end requires five criteria.
Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 3, makes advances available “upon receipt by the corporation of a written affirmation by the person of a good faith belief that the criteria for indemnification set forth in subdivision 2 have been satisfied and a written undertaking by the person to repay all amounts so paid or reimbursed by the corporation, if it is ultimately determined that the criteria for indemnification have not been satisfied, and (b) after a determination that the facts then known to those making the determination would not preclude indemnification under this section.” The written undertaking “is an unlimited general obligation of the person making it, but need not be secured and shall be accepted without reference to financial ability to make the repayment.”
Under § 302A.521, subd. 2, the person must meet all five criteria:
- The person has not been indemnified by another organization or employee benefit plan for the same amounts.
- The person acted in good faith.
- The person “received no improper personal benefit and section 302A.255, if applicable, has been satisfied.”
- In a criminal proceeding, the person had no reasonable cause to believe the conduct was unlawful.
- The person reasonably believed the conduct was in the best interests of the corporation, or, for service to another organization at the company’s request, not opposed to them.
A co-owner’s claim that the controlling owner used the company for personal benefit goes to the third and fifth criteria. The outcome of the lawsuit does not settle them: “The termination of a proceeding by judgment, order, settlement, conviction, or upon a plea of nolo contendere or its equivalent does not, of itself, establish that the person did not meet the criteria set forth in this subdivision” (subd. 2). For an LLC, the third criterion requires that the person “received no improper personal benefit and complied with the duties stated in sections 322C.0405 and 322C.0409, if applicable” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 2). The LLC version also requires a written request, a written affirmation of a good faith belief that the criteria are met, and a written undertaking to repay “if it is ultimately determined that the criteria for indemnification have not been satisfied” (subd. 3). It also requires a determination that the facts then known would not preclude indemnification.
Who Decides Whether the Company Pays a Co-Owner’s Fees?
The statute names who decides, and in a corporation the directors who are not parties to the case decide first. If they cannot form a quorum, a committee of two or more non-party directors decides, and after that come special legal counsel and then the shareholders, with parties’ shares excluded. Under § 302A.521, subd. 6(b), for a person who is not, and was not at the time, “a director, officer, or person possessing, directly or indirectly, the power to direct or cause the direction of the management or policies of the corporation,” the decision “may be made by an annually appointed committee of the board, having at least one member who is a director.” A court can also decide on the person’s application under subd. 6(a)(5), including “if an adverse determination is made under clauses (1) to (4) or under paragraph (b).” In an LLC without a board of governors, the members vote with the parties’ interests excluded.
Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 6, names first “the board by a majority of a quorum, if the directors who are at the time parties to the proceeding are not counted for determining either a majority or the presence of a quorum.” Every director can be a party, as in a company whose two owners both sit on the board. Then neither the board route nor the route through a committee of two or more non-party directors is available. The decision then goes to special legal counsel, “selected either by a majority of the board or a committee by vote pursuant to clause (1) or (2) or, if the requisite quorum of the full board cannot be obtained and the committee cannot be established, by a majority of the full board including directors who are parties.” The statute limits who can serve: “‘Special legal counsel’ means counsel who has not in the preceding five years (1) represented the corporation or a related organization in a capacity other than special legal counsel, or (2) represented a director, officer, member of a committee of the board, or employee, whose indemnification is in issue” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 1(e)).
If those routes produce no decision, the shareholders decide by the required affirmative vote under § 302A.521, subd. 6, “but the shares held by parties to the proceeding must not be counted in determining the presence of a quorum and are not considered to be present and entitled to vote on the determination.” The person may apply to a Minnesota court after an adverse decision, or if no decision is made “within 60 days after (i) the later to occur of the termination of a proceeding or a written request for indemnification to the corporation or (ii) a written request for an advance of expenses, as the case may be.” That court “may be the same court in which the proceeding involving the person’s liability took place.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on this period. In that court, “The person seeking indemnification or payment or reimbursement of expenses pursuant to this clause has the burden of establishing that the person is entitled to indemnification or payment or reimbursement of expenses.”
For an LLC that is not board-managed, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 6, sends the decision to the members, “with each member having voting power in proportion to the member’s interest in distributions of the limited liability company prior to dissolution, but the membership interests held by parties to the proceeding must not be counted in determining the presence of a quorum and are not considered to be present and entitled to vote on the determination.” A board-managed LLC starts with governors who are not parties, then a committee of them, then special legal counsel. Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 1(e) sets a parallel limit on who may serve as that counsel: “‘Special legal counsel’ means counsel who has not in the preceding five years (1) represented the limited liability company or a related organization in a capacity other than special legal counsel, or (2) represented a member, governor, manager, member of a committee of the board of governors, or employee, or other person whose indemnification is in issue.” In either form, a court decides after an adverse decision or none.
How Can the Articles, Bylaws, or Operating Agreement Change the Answer?
Under § 302A.521, subd. 4, a corporation’s articles or bylaws may prohibit the indemnification and advances the statute otherwise requires, or add conditions. The prohibition or conditions must apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class. Under § 322C.0408, subd. 4, an LLC’s articles of organization or operating agreement may prohibit the indemnification and advances the statute otherwise requires. They may also add conditions if the conditions apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class. In a corporation, a limit in the articles or bylaws does not reach acts or omissions before the provision’s effective date or adoption. For an LLC, that timing rule covers provisions in the articles of organization, a member control agreement, or the bylaws, and does not name the operating agreement. Separately, under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 7, an LLC’s operating agreement may alter or eliminate the indemnification that § 322C.0408, subd. 2 provides for a member, manager, or governor. Unless the operating agreement sets its own amendment terms, amending it requires the consent of all members under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407. Your documents are therefore the first place to look.
Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 4, “The articles or bylaws either may prohibit indemnification or advances of expenses otherwise required by this section or may impose conditions on indemnification or advances of expenses in addition to the conditions contained in subdivisions 2 and 3,” including dollar limits. That power applies “if the prohibition or conditions apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class.” The timing rule follows: “A prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances may not apply to or affect the right of a person to indemnification or advances of expenses with respect to any acts or omissions of the person occurring prior to the effective date of a provision in the articles or the date of adoption of a provision in the bylaws establishing the prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances.”
For an LLC, “The articles of organization or the operating agreement either may prohibit indemnification or advances of expenses otherwise required by this section” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 4). Those documents may also add conditions “if the conditions apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class,” and the subdivision’s timing rule protects acts or omissions “occurring before the effective date of a provision in the articles of organization, a member control agreement, or the date of adoption of a provision in the bylaws establishing the prohibition or limit on indemnification or advances.” Separately, “The operating agreement may alter or eliminate the indemnification for a member, manager, or governor provided by section 322C.0408, subdivision 2” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 7). The operating agreement may set its own amendment terms (§ 322C.0110, subd. 1(4)). Absent those terms, a member-managed LLC’s operating agreement “may be amended only with the consent of all members” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 2). In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, amending it requires “the consent of all members” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407, subds. 3 and 4). How to write these terms before a dispute starts is covered on my page about indemnification of directors, officers, and employees.
When Is Paying a Controlling Owner’s Legal Bills a Breach of Duty?
Paying a controlling owner’s legal bills can breach a duty. Minnesota tests the payment under the standards of conduct for directors and officers in a corporation and the duty of loyalty in an LLC. The conflict-of-interest statute, Minn. Stat. § 302A.255, subd. 1, covers a transaction between a corporation and one or more of its directors. It also covers one with an organization in which a director holds a listed position or a material financial interest. Such a transaction “is not void or voidable because the director or directors or the other organizations are parties” if one of the statute’s routes is met. Inside the indemnification statute, payment also depends on the owner having received no improper personal benefit. A court may act when company assets are misapplied or wasted.
Inside the indemnification statute, the third criterion of § 302A.521, subd. 2, already asks whether the person “received no improper personal benefit and section 302A.255, if applicable, has been satisfied.” Outside it, Minn. Stat. § 302A.255, subd. 1, addresses “A contract or other transaction between a corporation and one or more of its directors.” Such a transaction is not void or voidable because of the director’s interest if one of the statute’s routes is met. One route requires the person defending it to prove it “was, fair and reasonable as to the corporation at the time it was authorized, approved, or ratified.” Another is approval in good faith, after the material facts are fully disclosed or known to the board or a committee, “by a majority of the directors or committee members currently holding office, but the interested director or directors shall not be counted in determining the presence of a quorum and shall not vote.”
The director’s standard of conduct applies throughout. A director “shall discharge the duties of the position of director in good faith, in a manner the director reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.251, subd. 1). A director “who is present at a meeting of the board when an action is approved by the affirmative vote of a majority of the directors present is presumed to have assented to the action approved,” unless the director objects at the beginning of the meeting that it is not lawfully called or convened and then does not participate, “votes against the action at the meeting,” or “is prohibited by section 302A.255 from voting on the action” (subd. 3).
An officer “shall discharge the duties of an office in good faith, in a manner the officer reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation, and with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.361, subd. 1). Under subd. 2 of that section, the articles may eliminate or limit an officer’s personal liability to the shareholders for money damages only for breach “during the time the corporation is a publicly held corporation,” and never “in any action by or in the right of the corporation,” among other exceptions. Under § 302A.251, subd. 4, a director’s liability for money damages for breach of fiduciary duty “may be eliminated or limited in the articles,” but not “for any breach of the director’s duty of loyalty to the corporation or its shareholders,” “for acts or omissions not in good faith or that involve intentional misconduct or a knowing violation of law,” or “for any transaction from which the director derived an improper personal benefit,” among other exceptions.
In a shareholder’s action under Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 1, a court may act when “the corporate assets are being misapplied or wasted,” among other grounds. In a closely held corporation, the court must consider “the duty which all shareholders in a closely held corporation owe one another to act in an honest, fair, and reasonable manner in the operation of the corporation” (subd. 3a).
Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 2, “The duty of loyalty of a member in a member-managed limited liability company includes the duties” listed there, among them the duty “to account to the company and to hold as trustee for it any property, profit, or benefit derived by the member,” including a benefit “from a use by the member of the company’s property.” It also includes the duty “to refrain from dealing with the company in the conduct or winding up of the company’s activities as or on behalf of a person having an interest adverse to the company.” For that adverse-dealing duty, “It is a defense to a claim under subdivision 2, clause (2), and any comparable claim in equity or at common law that the transaction was fair to the limited liability company” (subd. 5). In a manager-managed LLC, “Subdivisions 1, 2, 3, and 5 apply to the manager or managers and not the members” (subd. 7), and in a board-managed LLC, “Subdivisions 1, 2, 3, and 5 apply to the governors and not the members” (subd. 8). Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 4, “If not manifestly unreasonable, and without limiting the terms that may be included in an operating agreement, the operating agreement may” restrict or eliminate some of these loyalty duties.
A claim for harm to the company is brought on the company’s behalf. In Wessin v. Archives Corp., 592 N.W.2d 460 (Minn. 1999), minority shareholders of a closely held corporation sued in their own names over the alleged misappropriation and waste of corporate assets. Their complaint, as the court quoted it, listed among other things “the reimbursement of personal expenses by Archives” unrelated to its business. The Minnesota Supreme Court stated that “Where the injury is to the corporation, and only indirectly harms the shareholder, the claim must be pursued as a derivative claim.” It held that each of the shareholders’ claims was derivative and that, even though the claims “specifically pled violations of Minn.Stat. § 302A.751, subds. 1(b)(2) and 1(b)(3), they are traditional derivative claims subject to the derivative pleading requirements of Rule 23.06.”
The current derivative-action rule, Minn. R. Civ. P. 23.09, requires the complaint to “allege with particularity the efforts, if any, made by the plaintiff to obtain the desired action from the directors or comparable authority and, if necessary, from the shareholders or members, and the reasons for the plaintiff’s failure to obtain the action or for not making the effort.” Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0902, an LLC member may maintain a derivative action after first making a demand on those who manage the company, if “the member, manager, or board does not bring the action within a reasonable time.” The member may also maintain it if a demand “would be futile.” An LLC member suing directly “must plead and prove an actual or threatened injury that is not solely the result of an injury suffered or threatened to be suffered by the limited liability company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0901, subd. 2). The other requirements for a derivative claim, and the wider problem of owners spending company money on themselves, are covered on my page about using company funds for personal use.
How Do You Find Out What the Company Has Paid?
In a suit brought by or on behalf of the company, the company must report any indemnification or advance to its owners in writing by the next owners’ meeting. For other payments, a shareholder may demand other corporate records in writing, but under Minn. Stat. § 302A.461, subd. 4(b), has that right only if the shareholder “demonstrates a proper purpose for the examination.” Under subd. 4(a), a shareholder of a corporation that is not publicly held “has an absolute right, upon written demand,” to examine and copy at any reasonable time the share register and the subd. 2 documents, which include “records of all proceedings of the board for the last three years.” In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, a member’s demand must be made in a record “describing with reasonable particularity the information sought and the purpose for seeking the information,” and the member must seek the information “for a purpose material to the member’s interest as a member,” among the other conditions of Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410, subd. 2.
Under § 302A.521, subd. 8, “A corporation that indemnifies or advances expenses to a person in accordance with this section in connection with a proceeding by or on behalf of the corporation shall report to the shareholders in writing the amount of the indemnification or advance and to whom and on whose behalf it was paid not later than the next meeting of shareholders.” An LLC in the same kind of proceeding “shall report to the members in writing the amount of the indemnification or advance and to whom and on whose behalf it was paid not later than the next meeting of members” (§ 322C.0408, subd. 8). Neither report requirement reaches a suit an owner brings only in the owner’s own name.
Legal invoices and the ledger entries paying them fall among the other corporate records of a corporation that is not publicly held. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.461, subd. 4, a shareholder “has a right, upon written demand, to examine and copy, in person or by a legal representative, other corporate records at any reasonable time only if the shareholder, beneficial owner, or holder of a voting trust certificate demonstrates a proper purpose for the examination.” Under the same subdivision, “a ‘proper purpose’ is one reasonably related to the person’s interest as a shareholder.” I suggest stating in the demand that the records show whether company money is paying an owner’s legal fees and on what authority, because that purpose ties to your interest as a shareholder. An LLC member’s access depends on the management form under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410. The wording of a demand and the limits on using what you receive are covered on my page about a minority owner’s right to demand company information.
Who Pays the Attorney’s Fees When the Case Ends?
Each side pays its own attorney’s fees unless a contract or a statute shifts them. In an owner dispute, the statutes that can shift fees include the bad-faith rule in § 302A.751, the corporation chapter’s remedies section, the records statute, and the LLC derivative-action statute. Each award is up to the court. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0906, subd. 2, the court may award reasonable expenses in an LLC derivative action that succeeds in whole or in part, paid from the LLC’s recovery.
The Minnesota Supreme Court, quoting an earlier decision, stated in Dunn v. National Beverage Corp., 745 N.W.2d 549 (Minn. 2008), that “attorney fees are not recoverable in litigation unless there is a specific contract permitting or a statute authorizing such recovery.” The statutes on this page that authorize recovery are these:
- Bad faith in a § 302A.751 case. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 4, a court that finds a party “has acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith” may award reasonable expenses, including attorneys’ fees, “to any of the other parties.” The award can run against either side. The Minnesota Court of Appeals reads subdivision 4 to require two findings. The court “must first find there was a breach of fiduciary duty,” and if so, “then the court must find that the breaching party acted” arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith (Pedro v. Pedro, 463 N.W.2d 285 (Minn. Ct. App. 1990)).
- A violation of chapter 302A. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.467, if a corporation or an officer or director violates a provision of the chapter, a court may, in an action by a shareholder, “grant any equitable relief it deems just and reasonable in the circumstances and award expenses, including attorneys’ fees and disbursements, to the shareholder.”
- A records violation. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.461, subd. 4, a court may “specifically enforce this section and award expenses, including attorney fees and disbursements” to the shareholder.
- A successful LLC derivative action. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0906, subd. 2, “If a derivative action under section 322C.0902 is successful in whole or in part, the court may award the plaintiff reasonable expenses, including reasonable attorney fees and costs, from the recovery of the limited liability company.”
The cases applying these statutes are collected on my page about attorney’s fees in corporate and LLC disputes. The cost of each stage is on my page about what a shareholder dispute costs in Minnesota.
What Are Your Options When the Company Pays the Other Side’s Lawyer?
You can raise it owner to owner, object in writing and ask for the statute’s paperwork, demand the records, negotiate how legal fees will be handled, or ask a court for relief. Each fits a different stage of the dispute, and each carries its own risk. A court claim can expose the owner who brings it to a fee award, because § 302A.751, subd. 4 allows reasonable expenses against a party the court finds “acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith.”
- An owner-to-owner conversation. This fits when the relationship still works and the payments may have started without anyone thinking about the statute. I suggest raising it with the documents in hand, because a conversation about the written request, affirmation, and undertaking is easier to resolve than one about motives. The risk is that the other owner treats it as the start of a fight.
- A written objection. You can ask the company in writing whether it received the written request, affirmation, and undertaking § 302A.521, subd. 3, requires, and who made the determination subdivision 6 requires. The objection creates a record before more money goes out. If you sit on the board, § 302A.251, subd. 3 presumes that a director present at a meeting assented to an action approved by a majority of the directors present. That presumption applies unless the director “votes against the action at the meeting” or meets one of the subdivision’s other exceptions. The risk is that it hardens positions.
- A records demand. The demand shows what has been paid, to whom, and on what approval, under the records statutes in the section on finding out what the company has paid.
- Negotiated fee terms. The owners can agree that each pays their own fees, that advances continue up to a cap, or that amounts paid are tracked and credited in any buyout price. In a corporation, one approval route for a director’s transaction under § 302A.255, subd. 1, is a vote of “the holders of two-thirds of the voting power of the shares entitled to vote which are owned by persons other than the interested director or directors.” That vote must approve the transaction in good faith, after the material facts are fully disclosed or known to the holders of all outstanding shares. In an LLC, “All of the members of a member-managed limited liability company or a manager-managed limited liability company may authorize or ratify, after full disclosure of all material facts, a specific act or transaction that otherwise would violate the duty of loyalty” (§ 322C.0409, subd. 6).
- A court claim. In a shareholder’s action under § 302A.751, once a ground is established, “A court may grant any equitable relief it deems just and reasonable in the circumstances or may dissolve a corporation and liquidate its assets and business” (subd. 1). Under Wessin, a claim for harm to the company is brought on its behalf, on the terms quoted in the section on when paying a controlling owner’s legal bills is a breach of duty. Those are Minn. R. Civ. P. 23.09 for a corporation and §§ 322C.0901 and 322C.0902 for an LLC. An LLC member may apply under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0701, subd. 1, among other grounds, when “the managers, governors, or those members in control of the company: (i) have acted, are acting, or will act in a manner that is illegal or fraudulent; or (ii) have acted or are acting in a manner that is oppressive and was, is, or will be directly harmful to the applicant.” In that case, “the court may order a remedy other than dissolution, which may include the sale for fair value of all membership interests a member owns in a limited liability company to the limited liability company or one or more of the other members” (subd. 2).
The risks run both ways. Under § 302A.751, subd. 4, reasonable expenses can be awarded against any party the court finds acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith, including the owner who brought the case. The Court of Appeals’ two-finding reading of that subdivision in Pedro is quoted in the section on who pays the attorney’s fees. An LLC member must also act consistently with good faith and fair dealing, “including acting in a manner, in light of the operating agreement, that is honest, fair, and reasonable” (§ 322C.0409, subd. 4). Each legal claim behind these options has its own limitations period, so I suggest checking it before you choose which option to pursue first. If the company is paying your fees, I suggest making the written request, affirmation, and undertaking, because § 302A.521, subd. 3, and § 322C.0408, subd. 3, condition advances on them. Those subdivisions also require a determination, and subdivision 6 of each section names who makes it. The other parts of that position are on my page about defending a shareholder oppression claim.
Can the company's lawyer also represent the majority owner in our dispute?
The company’s lawyer can, but only within the conflict rules. Minn. R. Prof. Conduct 1.13(f) lets a lawyer representing an organization also represent any of its directors, officers, employees, members, shareholders, or other constituents, subject to the provisions of Rule 1.7. A lawyer with a concurrent conflict may represent a client under Rule 1.7(b) only if, among other conditions, the representation “does not involve the assertion of a claim by one client against another client represented by the lawyer in the same litigation or other proceeding before a tribunal.” Each affected client’s informed consent is a separate condition, so consent alone does not satisfy the rule. If the company’s consent is required, an appropriate official other than the individual to be represented, or the shareholders, must give it. Under Rule 1.13(a), the company’s lawyer represents the company acting through its duly authorized constituents. I suggest asking that lawyer at the start whom they represent, because the answer decides whose interests they protect.
Do I have to pay back advanced fees if I lose the case?
It depends on whether it is ultimately determined that you did not meet the criteria for indemnification, and on what your company’s documents say. Before an advance, Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 3 and Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 3 require a written undertaking to repay if that determination is made. Subdivision 4 of each lets the company’s documents prohibit advances or add conditions. The full rules, including how a judgment or settlement bears on the criteria, are quoted in the sections on advances and the company’s documents.
Can the company pay my legal fees if I am the minority owner?
It can, if you are made or threatened to be made a party to a proceeding by reason of an official capacity and your company’s documents do not prohibit it. An advance also requires the written steps and determination, and indemnification requires the five criteria, described in the section on advances. Minn. Stat. § 302A.521 and Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408 say nothing about the size of your stake. Subdivision 4 of each lets a corporation’s articles or bylaws, or an LLC’s articles of organization or operating agreement, prohibit the indemnification or advances the statute otherwise requires. The terms of that power are quoted in the section on the company’s documents. Under § 302A.521, subd. 9, a corporation also keeps its power to indemnify, “by contract or otherwise,” a person other than a director, officer, employee, or board committee member. Fees for claims you bring turn on separate fee statutes, quoted in the section on who pays the attorney’s fees.
Can the majority change the bylaws now to stop the company from advancing my fees?
A bylaw change cannot reach conduct that already happened. Minn. Stat. § 302A.521, subd. 4 lets a corporation’s articles or bylaws prohibit or condition the advances the statute otherwise requires. The rule must apply equally to all persons or to all persons within a given class. A new prohibition or limit may not apply to or affect your rights for acts or omissions occurring before the provision’s effective date or adoption. For an LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0408, subd. 4 sets that timing rule for the articles of organization, a member control agreement, or the bylaws, and does not name the operating agreement. The operating agreement may prohibit advances, and Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 7 lets it alter or eliminate the indemnification. By default, amending it requires the consent of all members (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407).
Company Money and Legal Fees in an Owner Dispute
Company money may pay the company’s own lawyer. It may pay an owner’s defense when the owner is sued in a covered position and the indemnification statute’s written steps and required determination are complete. Payments outside that process are tested against the controlling owner’s duties. I suggest reading your articles, bylaws, or operating agreement first, then demanding the records, because both decide which options are open to you. More on resolving a shareholder dispute is on my ownership disputes page.
If the company you co-own is paying legal fees in a dispute among the owners, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.