A post-term noncompete in a Minnesota franchise agreement can bind you after you leave the system, but only if it is reasonable. Minnesota’s franchise rule makes it unfair and inequitable for anyone to “enforce any unreasonable covenant not to compete after the franchise relationship ceases to exist.” The answer for your covenant turns on its scope, territory, and length, and on how your franchise ended.

This page is written for the owner of a Minnesota franchised business who is leaving the system through a termination, a nonrenewal, or a sale. The governing law is mostly an administrative rule adopted under the Minnesota Franchise Act, plus Minnesota court decisions on covenants not to compete. Minnesota’s 2023 noncompete statute is written for employers and employees, and its text does not mention franchises. For the wider set of franchise rules, see Minnesota franchise law.

What Minnesota Rule Governs a Franchise Noncompete After the Franchise Ends?

Minn. R. 2860.4400 governs it. The rule lists practices that are “unfair and inequitable,” and item I makes it unfair and inequitable to “enforce any unreasonable covenant not to compete after the franchise relationship ceases to exist.” The rule bars enforcing an unreasonable covenant. It does not bar a franchisor from enforcing a reasonable one.

The rule’s opening words state its reach: “All franchise contracts or agreements and any other device or practice of a franchisor, shall conform to the following provisions.” The Minnesota Franchise Act gives it force. Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 1 provides that no person “shall engage in any unfair or inequitable practice in contravention of such rules as the commissioner may adopt.”

Two limits apply. The rule covers only a “franchise” as Minn. Stat. § 80C.01, subd. 4 defines it, and that definition excludes new motor vehicle dealer agreements, among others. For a motor vehicle fuel franchise, Minn. R. 2860.5400 states: “The provisions of part 2860.4400 shall not apply.”

How Does Minnesota’s 2023 Noncompete Ban Apply to a Franchisee?

Minnesota’s 2023 noncompete statute, Minn. Stat. § 181.988, is written for employers and employees, and its text does not mention franchises or franchisors. Subdivision 1(a) defines the covenant it bans as “an agreement between an employee and employer that restricts the employee, after termination of the employment, from performing” work for another employer for a specified period of time, work in a specified geographical area, or work for another employer in a similar capacity.

The statute stretches “employee” further than payroll. Subdivision 1(c) defines “employee” as “any individual who performs services for an employer, including independent contractors.” Subdivision 1(d) also reaches an entity “when an employer requires an individual to form such an organization for purposes of entering into a contract for services as a condition of receiving compensation under an independent contractor agreement.” The text does not say whether a franchisee that licenses a franchisor’s brand and runs its own business is an “employee” who performs services for the franchisor.

Three more points of the statute matter to a franchisee:

  1. The date of your agreement. The 2023 session law that enacted the section states that the section “applies to contracts and agreements entered into on or after” July 1, 2023. A franchise agreement signed earlier is outside it.
  2. What the ban voids. For a covenant the statute covers, subdivision 2(a) provides that it “is void and unenforceable.” Subdivision 2(b) makes a covenant “valid and enforceable” in two cases. The first is a covenant that “is agreed upon during the sale of a business,” limited to “a temporary and geographically restricted covenant not to compete” that keeps the seller from a similar business “within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time.” That exception can matter if you sell your franchise to a buyer who asks you not to compete. The second is a covenant that “is agreed upon in anticipation of the dissolution of a business,” under which “The partners, members, or shareholders, upon or in anticipation of a dissolution of a partnership, limited liability company, or corporation may agree” not to carry on a similar business “within a reasonable geographic area where the business has been transacted.”
  3. What the ban leaves alone. Subdivision 1(a) states: “A covenant not to compete does not include a nondisclosure agreement, or agreement designed to protect trade secrets or confidential information. A covenant not to compete does not include a nonsolicitation agreement, or agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists, or solicit customers of the employer.”

In Ellie Fam LLC v. Coelho, Nos. A25-1515, A25-1517 (Minn. App. Apr. 13, 2026) (nonprecedential), on the franchisees’ argument “that the district court erred in its analysis of the” five injunction factors “and abused its discretion,” the Court of Appeals affirmed a temporary injunction enforcing “the noncompete clauses in the franchise agreements” of a Minnesota franchisor against Arizona and Nevada franchisees pending resolution of the underlying disputes. For how the statute works for workers, see how Minnesota’s 2023 noncompete ban works for employees and contractors, and for the appellate rulings, see Minnesota noncompete cases decided since the ban.

What Makes a Post-Term Franchise Covenant Reasonable in Minnesota?

Minn. R. 2860.4400 does not define “unreasonable,” so Minnesota’s court decisions on covenants not to compete supply the questions. The Minnesota Supreme Court stated the general test in Bennett v. Storz Broadcasting Co., 134 N.W.2d 892 (Minn. 1965): “Where the restraint is for a just and honest purpose, for the protection of a legitimate interest of the party in whose favor it is imposed, reasonable as between the parties, and not injurious to the public, the restraint has been held valid.”

Bennett was an employment case, and the court drew a line between two kinds of covenants. It wrote that “courts recognize a distinction between restrictive covenants as they relate to the ordinary commercial transaction involving business or property transfers and those which relate to employment contracts entered into by wage earners. A different measure of reasonableness is used.” A franchise covenant is an agreement between two businesses, and Bennett did not address a franchise covenant.

For limits of territory and time, the court in Bess v. Bothman, 257 N.W.2d 791 (Minn. 1977), a covenant given in the sale of part of a towing business, named three elements: “First, whether the restriction exceeds the protection necessary to secure the goodwill purchased; second, whether the restriction places an undue hardship on the covenantor; and third, whether the restriction has a deleterious effect on the interests of the general public.” Applied to your covenant, those elements raise four questions:

  • Scope. Does the covenant bar only the business you ran under the brand, or any business in the industry, including work for someone else?
  • Territory. Is the radius measured from your own location, or from every unit in the system, so that it reaches places where you never built goodwill?
  • Duration. How long does it run, and does it start when you stop operating or when a court order issues?
  • Public effect. Would enforcing it leave your customers or patients without a provider?

In Bess, an overbroad covenant given in a business sale was not thrown out: the court held that “the district court had authority to modify and enforce the covenant not to compete,” a power Minnesota calls equitable modification. Bess did not involve a franchise. The court also wrote that enforcement “remains a matter of equitable discretion and should be granted only when neither injury to the public interest nor injustice to the parties will result.” For a covenant that § 181.988 covers, the statute’s words “void and unenforceable” govern instead of modification.

How Does the Way Your Franchise Ended Affect the Covenant?

Item I of the rule applies to any covenant enforced “after the franchise relationship ceases to exist,” and its text does not distinguish a termination, a nonrenewal, or a sale. How the franchise ended matters in other ways, because it can decide whether the franchisor is the party in breach.

  • A termination by the franchisor. Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 3 states: “No person may terminate or cancel a franchise except for good cause.” It defines good cause as “failure by the franchisee to substantially comply with the material and reasonable franchise requirements imposed by the franchisor,” including the grounds it lists. Under § 80C.14, subd. 2, a class of franchises the commissioner recognizes, such as motor vehicle fuel franchises, need not “conform to subdivisions 3 and 4.” For a motor fuel franchise, 15 U.S.C. § 2806(a)(1) also bars a state from enforcing a law on termination unless that law is the same as the federal provision. The notice, cure, and nonrenewal steps are covered in Minnesota’s franchise termination and nonrenewal rules. In an employment case, Webb Publishing Co. v. Fosshage, 426 N.W.2d 445 (Minn. App. 1988), the Court of Appeals, citing an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision, stated that termination of an employment contract “does not preclude enforcement of a restrictive covenant, at least where the employer has not taken ‘undue advantage’ of his right to terminate.” It added that “wrongful termination may preclude enforcement of restrictive covenants,” and held that the trial court’s finding that the employee “had failed to establish a likelihood of success on this defense was not clearly erroneous.”

  • A nonrenewal by the franchisor. Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 4 provides: “Unless the failure to renew a franchise is for good cause as defined in subdivision 3, paragraph (b), and the franchisee has failed to correct reasons for termination as required by subdivision 3, no person may fail to renew a franchise unless” two conditions are met: “(1) the franchisee has been given written notice of the intention not to renew at least 180 days in advance of the expiration of the franchise,” and “(2) the franchisee has been given an opportunity to operate the franchise over a sufficient period of time to enable the franchisee to recover the fair market value of the franchise as a going concern, as determined and measured from the date of the failure to renew.” It adds: “No franchisor may refuse to renew a franchise if the refusal is for the purpose of converting the franchisee’s business premises to an operation that will be owned by the franchisor for its own account.”

    Subdivision 2 states: “All franchise contracts or agreements, other than those classifications of franchises specifically recognized by the commissioner under subdivision 1, and any other device or practice of a franchisor must conform to subdivisions 3 and 4. It is an unfair and inequitable practice for a person to commit an act specified in subdivisions 3 to 5.” In Minn. R. 2860.5100, “The commissioner specifically recognizes the classification of motor vehicle fuel franchises.” For a franchisor “engaged in the sale, consignment, or distribution of motor fuel in commerce,” federal law in 15 U.S.C. § 2802 sets the terms on which it may “fail to renew any franchise relationship.” 15 U.S.C. § 2806(a)(1) bars a state from enforcing any law “with respect to . . . the nonrenewal (or the furnishing of notification with respect thereto) of any such franchise relationship unless such provision of such law or regulation is the same as the applicable provision of this subchapter,” meaning the federal provision.

  • A termination by you. In Ellie Fam, franchisees sent notices to rescind or terminate their agreements for the franchisor’s alleged breaches, then argued that no contractual relationship remained. The Court of Appeals answered: “This argument goes to the merits of the underlying dispute, not the parties’ relationship preceding the dispute.” On the injunction factor that looks at the parties’ relationship before the dispute, it held that the district court did not abuse its discretion by determining that, “for the purpose of this factor in deciding whether to grant a temporary injunction, the parties remained bound by the contract.” The injunction enforced the noncompete provision “pending resolution of the underlying disputes.”

  • A sale. Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 5 makes it unfair to “unreasonably withhold consent to an assignment, transfer, or sale of the franchise whenever the franchisee to be substituted meets the present qualifications and standards required of the franchisees of the particular franchisor.” More on that route is in when a franchisor may withhold consent to a sale. Whether a sale triggers your covenant turns on your agreement’s own wording.

How Do Minnesota Courts Decide Whether to Enjoin a Former Franchisee?

A Minnesota state court weighs five factors when deciding whether to order a former franchisee to stop competing before trial. They come from Dahlberg Bros. v. Ford Motor Co., 137 N.W.2d 314 (Minn. 1965), itself a franchise case:

  1. The nature and background of the parties’ relationship before the dispute.
  2. The harm to the franchisor if the injunction is denied, compared with the harm to you if it is granted.
  3. The likelihood that either side will win on the merits.
  4. Public policy expressed in state and federal statutes.
  5. The administrative burden on the court of supervising and enforcing the order.

The franchisor, as the party asking for the order, carries the burden. In Ellie Fam, the Court of Appeals wrote: “The burden of proof is on the party seeking an injunction.” Quoting Minnesota Supreme Court decisions, it added that a temporary injunction requires “a showing of irreparable harm” because it “is granted before a trial on the merits,” that the movant must “establish that [the] legal remedy is not adequate and that the injunction is necessary to prevent great and irreparable injury,” and that irreparable injury must be “likely, not just possible.” In federal court, a different, four-factor test applies.

In Ellie Fam, the Court of Appeals wrote that “the most important is the third factor”: the likelihood of prevailing, citing an earlier decision. Quoting another earlier decision, it added that “[i]f a plaintiff makes even a doubtful showing as to the likelihood of prevailing on the merits,” a district court may issue a temporary injunction to preserve the status quo. The district court found that the balance of harms favored the franchisees but “the remaining factors weighed in favor of granting the temporary injunction.” The Court of Appeals discerned “no abuse of discretion in the district court’s final determination.”

The franchisees in that case sent their notices in February 2025, the franchisor sued in May 2025, and the district court granted the injunction on August 18, 2025. That court stayed its order until December 30, 2025, “to prevent disruption in patient care and allow for mediation.” In its order granting the temporary injunction, it also “established a 90-day time period for franchisees to transition their clinics back to operating as Ellie clinics, to allow for continuity of care.”

A franchisor seeking an injunction must post security. Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.03 provides that no temporary injunction “shall be granted except upon the giving of security by the applicant, in such sum as the court deems proper, for the payment of such costs and damages as may be incurred or suffered by any party who is found to have been wrongfully enjoined or restrained.”

What Remedies Does a Franchisee Have Against an Unreasonable Covenant?

A franchisee can sue a franchisor that enforces an unreasonable covenant, because enforcing one violates a rule adopted under the Minnesota Franchise Act. Minn. Stat. § 80C.17, subd. 1 provides that a person who violates “any provision of this chapter or any rule or order thereunder shall be liable to the franchisee or subfranchisor who may sue for damages caused thereby, for rescission, or other relief as the court may deem appropriate.” Subdivision 3 allows recovery of “the actual damages sustained by the plaintiff together with costs and disbursements plus reasonable attorney’s fees.”

Subdivision 5 sets a time limit: “No action may be commenced pursuant to this section more than three years after the cause of action accrues.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on this time limit.

You can also ask a court to stop enforcement. Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 1 states: “A violation of this section is enjoinable by a court of competent jurisdiction.” Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 1 adds: “A temporary injunction may be granted under this section without requiring the posting of any bond or security. A bond or security is required if a temporary restraining order is granted.”

Two contract terms shape where and how that fight happens:

  1. Choice of law. Minn. Stat. § 80C.21 voids any provision, “including any choice of law provision,” that waives compliance with the act “or any rule or order thereunder.” It protects a person who was a Minnesota resident when acquiring the franchise, a partnership or corporation organized under Minnesota law, and a person acquiring a franchise to be operated in Minnesota.
  2. Arbitration. Item J of the rule makes it unfair to “require a franchisee to waive his or her rights to a jury trial or to waive rights to any procedure, forum, or remedies provided for by the laws of the jurisdiction,” and adds, “provided that this part shall not bar an exclusive arbitration clause.” An arbitration clause in your agreement may send the dispute to an arbitrator instead of a court. In Ellie Fam (nonprecedential), the franchise agreements had an arbitration clause, and the district court still granted the franchisor a temporary injunction. The Court of Appeals declined to consider the franchisees’ argument that the clause barred that relief “because franchisees forfeited this argument by failing to timely assert it in district court.” I suggest raising an arbitration clause in your first response to an injunction motion, because a late objection can be lost.

The full set of claims under the act is covered in remedies for a Minnesota Franchise Act violation.

How Can You Negotiate a Release or a Narrower Covenant on Exit?

You can negotiate a release of the covenant, or a narrower one, as part of a written exit agreement with the franchisor. The ways to resolve a covenant problem, legal and practical, each fit a different situation:

  1. A direct conversation with the franchisor’s leadership. This fits when you are leaving on workable terms. A franchisor may want to protect the territory for its next franchisee. A plan that addresses that interest, such as a different service line or a location outside the area, can be easier to accept than a lawsuit.
  2. A written termination or exit agreement. This fits when you want certainty before you open anything new. It can release the covenant or rewrite its scope, territory, and length, and it can settle de-branding, phone numbers, and records at the same time. Item D of the rule makes it unfair to “require a franchisee to assent to a release, assignment, novation, or waiver that would relieve any person from liability imposed by” the act, but adds that it “shall not bar the voluntary settlement of disputes.” I suggest reading every release in the exit agreement against item D and Minn. Stat. § 80C.21, because that section voids a provision that “has the effect of waiving compliance” with the act. Any exit payment raises the issues covered in termination fees and liquidated damages.
  3. A sale to an approved buyer. This fits when the business has value inside the system. A buyer keeps the brand in your location, and the franchisor may agree to limit your covenant as part of the transfer.
  4. Compliance. This fits when the covenant is short or narrow. Waiting it out, moving outside the territory, or changing your line of business avoids a fight, at the cost of time or location.
  5. A challenge in court or arbitration. This fits when the covenant is broad enough that compliance would end your livelihood, or when the franchisor’s own breach is serious. The risk is an injunction before trial, as Ellie Fam shows, along with the cost of litigation.
Does a choice-of-law clause naming another state's law control my franchise noncompete?

Not where it would bind a covered franchisee to waive compliance with Minnesota’s franchise act or its rules. Minn. Stat. § 80C.21 voids any provision, “including any choice of law provision,” purporting to bind a covered person “to waive compliance or which has the effect of waiving compliance with any provision of sections 80C.01 to 80C.22 or any rule or order thereunder,” such as Minn. R. 2860.4400. It covers a Minnesota resident acquiring the franchise, a partnership or corporation organized under Minnesota law, and anyone acquiring a franchise to be operated in Minnesota. For other franchisees, the chosen state’s law may govern.

Does the noncompete still bind me if I sell my franchise instead of being terminated?

It can. Minn. R. 2860.4400 makes it unfair to enforce an unreasonable covenant “after the franchise relationship ceases to exist,” and its text does not treat a sale differently from a termination or nonrenewal. Whether a transfer triggers your covenant at all turns on the wording of your franchise agreement and any transfer documents. I suggest negotiating the covenant’s scope as part of the sale terms, because a sale that needs the franchisor’s consent puts the covenant’s terms on the table at the same time.

Can a court rewrite an overbroad franchise noncompete instead of throwing it out?

A Minnesota court has done so for a covenant given in a business sale. In Bess v. Bothman (1977), the Minnesota Supreme Court held that the district court “had authority to modify and enforce the covenant not to compete.” This is called equitable modification, and enforcement remains a matter of equitable discretion. Bess did not involve a franchise. The answer also turns on whether Minn. Stat. § 181.988 reaches your covenant and, if it does, whether a subdivision 2(b) exception applies. This page quotes that rule and both exceptions under How Does Minnesota’s 2023 Noncompete Ban Apply to a Franchisee?

Do I have to post a bond if I ask a court to stop the franchisor from enforcing the covenant?

Not necessarily: under Minn. Stat. § 80C.14, subd. 1, a temporary injunction “may be granted under this section without requiring the posting of any bond or security.” The same subdivision states that a bond or security “is required if a temporary restraining order is granted.” A franchisor seeking an injunction to enforce the covenant falls under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.03, which requires security from the applicant.

Can I keep serving my customers under a new name while I dispute the termination?

That turns on whether your covenant is enforceable, and a court may order you to stop before the dispute is decided. In Ellie Fam LLC v. Coelho (Minn. App. 2026, nonprecedential), franchisees sent notices to rescind or terminate their agreements and “began operating their clinics independently under names not associated with Ellie.” The Court of Appeals affirmed a temporary injunction enforcing “the noncompete clauses in the franchise agreements,” and said the argument that the notices ended the agreements “goes to the merits of the underlying dispute, not the parties’ relationship preceding the dispute.”

Your Franchise Noncompete in Minnesota

A post-term franchise noncompete binds a Minnesota franchisee only if it is reasonable, because Minn. R. 2860.4400 makes enforcing an unreasonable one unfair and inequitable. Its scope, territory, and length, how the franchise ended, and the date of your agreement decide how much room you have, and a negotiated exit can settle all of it in writing. For the wider franchise relationship, see the Minnesota franchise attorney page. If you are leaving a franchise system and want to know whether your covenant is enforceable on your facts, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.