A Minnesota buy-sell price that is years out of date can still bind the owners, because the agreement is a contract and an old number does not change on its own. For a corporation, the statute tells a court in a court-ordered buyout to use the agreed price if the shares “are then subject to sale and purchase” under the agreement, unless that price is unreasonable (Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 2). The practical fix is to change the price, or the method, before a death, disability, departure, or dispute triggers a sale.
Minnesota’s corporation statute speaks directly to an agreed buyout price in a court-ordered buyout. The LLC statute’s court-ordered sale provision does not mention a price set in an agreement, and outside those sections a court reads the buy-sell agreement as a contract. If the old number has already started a shareholder dispute, the same rules decide who gets paid what. This page explains how each rule treats a stale price, who must agree to change it, and the options for owners who find one in their files.
How Does a Minnesota Court Treat an Out-of-Date Buy-Sell Price?
A Minnesota court can order a buyout of a corporation’s shares once one or more of the statute’s grounds is established in a shareholder’s lawsuit. In that buyout, if the shares “are then subject to sale and purchase pursuant to the bylaws of the corporation, a shareholder control agreement, the terms of the shares, or otherwise,” the court must order the sale “for the price and on the terms set forth in them, unless the court determines that the price or terms are unreasonable under all the circumstances of the case” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 2). Otherwise the price is “the fair value of the shares as of the date of the commencement of the action or as of another date found equitable by the court.” In one Minnesota case, a price far below two appraisals was held reasonable. The Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed a finding that an agreement price was unreasonable where “the agreement required that the shareholders annually revise the purchase price” and “the parties never reestablished the price” (Piche v. Braaten, Nos. A13-0406, A13-0534 (Minn. Ct. App. Feb. 3, 2014)). The court still applied the agreement’s installment schedule to the higher fair value. That decision is unpublished, and under Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 136.01 such a decision “may be cited as persuasive authority.”
The subdivision 2 price rule applies only inside a shareholder’s lawsuit under § 302A.751, subd. 1(b), in a corporation that is not publicly held, once a ground such as deadlock or conduct “unfairly prejudicial toward one or more shareholders” is established. The court then may, “upon motion of a corporation or a shareholder or beneficial owner of shares of the corporation,” order a sale if it finds the order “would be fair and equitable to all parties under all of the circumstances of the case” (subd. 2). The statute also says that “any written agreements, including employment agreements and buy-sell agreements, between or among shareholders or between or among one or more shareholders and the corporation are presumed to reflect the parties’ reasonable expectations concerning matters dealt with in the agreements” (§ 302A.751, subd. 3a).
In Gunderson v. Alliance of Computer Professionals, Inc., 628 N.W.2d 173 (Minn. Ct. App. 2001), the company offered a departing shareholder $2,300 under its buy-sell formula. His appraiser valued his interest at $1,133,000, and the company’s appraiser at $175,000. The shareholder had helped draft the agreement and proposed its valuation provision. The court of appeals wrote that “Minnesota courts are required to honor shareholder agreements setting the purchase price of shares, unless the court determines that the price is unreasonable under all the circumstances,” and that “The district court correctly concluded that the contractual price was reasonable under all the circumstances.” It relied on facts specific to that case: the agreement “was an arm’s-length transaction,” “The shareholders had a legitimate business reason for agreeing to the provision under which Gunderson’s shares were priced,” and “they all assumed the same risk.” It limited that ruling to its record, writing that “in the absence of evidence that the controlling shareholders used the buy-sell agreement manipulatively to force the sale of Gunderson’s shares, the facts do not support Gunderson’s claim that the controlling shareholders frustrated his reasonable shareholder expectations by enforcing the buy-sell agreement.” The court added that “written agreements are not dispositive of shareholder expectations in all circumstances.” It reversed the dismissal of his shareholder-employee claim and “the premature denial of his motion for a fair-value buyout as it relates solely to his reasonable expectations as a shareholder-employee,” and it remanded.
Two more corporate rules can decide whether the old price binds a particular person:
- Notice on the shares. Shareholders can impose a transfer restriction “by an agreement among or other written action by a number of shareholders” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.429, subd. 1). A written restriction “that is not manifestly unreasonable under the circumstances” and is noted conspicuously on the certificate, or sent to holders of uncertificated shares, “is valid and specifically enforceable against the holder of the restricted securities or a successor or transferee of the holder, including a pledgee or a legal representative” (subd. 2). Without that notation, the restriction “is ineffective against a person without knowledge of the restriction.”
- Shares issued earlier. “A restriction is not binding with respect to securities issued prior to the adoption of the restriction, unless the holders of those securities are parties to the agreement or voted in favor of the restriction” (§ 302A.429, subd. 1).
An LLC works differently. The operating agreement governs “relations among the members as members and between the members and the limited liability company,” except as subdivisions 2 and 3 of Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110 provide. The LLC court remedy reads: “In a proceeding brought under subdivision 1, clause (5), the court may order a remedy other than dissolution, which may include the sale for fair value of all membership interests a member owns in a limited liability company to the limited liability company or one or more of the other members” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0701, subd. 2). In that proceeding a member applies on the ground that “the managers, governors, or those members in control of the company . . . have acted, are acting, or will act in a manner that is illegal or fraudulent,” or “have acted or are acting in a manner that is oppressive and was, is, or will be directly harmful to the applicant” (subd. 1). Unlike § 302A.751, subd. 2, that subdivision does not mention a price set in an agreement. A court-ordered buyout under section 302A.751 has its own page covering the grounds and the process.
What Happens When a Buyout Is Triggered Before the Price Is Updated?
When a trigger arrives first, the agreement’s old price or formula sets the buyout price under the contract, and the parties to the agreement can agree on a different one. The old price is not always the end of the money, though. In a court-ordered corporate buyout, the court can find the agreed price unreasonable under § 302A.751, subd. 2. Where the other owners’ breaches of fiduciary duty forced the sale, a Minnesota court measured the shortfall as fair value minus the agreement price.
In Pedro v. Pedro, 463 N.W.2d 285 (Minn. Ct. App. 1990), three brothers each owned a third of a closely held Minnesota corporation. Their stock retirement agreement priced shares at “75% of net book value at the end of the preceding calendar year.” After one brother raised an accounting discrepancy and was fired, the court held: “If the fair value of the shares is greater than the purchase price for the buyout as calculated from the formula in the SRA, the difference is the measure of respondent’s damage resulting from having been forced to sell his shares in the company.” On remand, the trial court awarded the agreement price of $766,582.33 plus $563,417.67, the gap to a fair market value of $1,330,000. The appeals court affirmed (Pedro v. Pedro, 489 N.W.2d 798 (Minn. Ct. App. 1992)). That award rested on findings that the other brothers breached their fiduciary duties.
For an LLC member who dies, the statute supplies what happens if the operating agreement has no buyout. A member is dissociated when “the person dies,” or when “an event stated in the operating agreement as causing the person’s dissociation occurs” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0602). The member’s “right to participate as a member in the management and conduct of the company’s activities terminates,” and “any transferable interest owned by the person immediately before dissociation in the person’s capacity as a member is owned by the person solely as a transferee,” subject to the exceptions that clause names (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0603, subd. 1). The page on buying a deceased co-owner’s share covers dealing with the estate.
What Standard of Value and Discounts Apply to a Buyout Price?
The agreement’s own words set the standard of value: book value, a formula, fair market value, or an appraised value. In a court-ordered corporate buyout, “fair value” is the purchase price where no agreed price governs or the court finds that price unreasonable (§ 302A.751, subd. 2). For a court-ordered buyout under § 302A.751, the Minnesota Supreme Court held that fair value means a pro rata share of going-concern value without a marketability discount, absent extraordinary circumstances.
In Advanced Communication Design, Inc. v. Follett, 615 N.W.2d 285 (Minn. 2000), the court held that “absent extraordinary circumstances, fair value in a court-ordered buy-out pursuant to section 302A.751 means a pro rata share of the value of the corporation as a going concern without discount for lack of marketability.” It treated a marketability discount, which reflects how hard closely held shares are to sell, as different from “a minority discount, which adjusts for lack of control of the corporation.” In that case the court found extraordinary circumstances and sent the case back to set a discount. The Minnesota Court of Appeals later restated that fair value “generally means undiscounted value” (Lund v. Lund, 924 N.W.2d 274 (Minn. Ct. App. 2019)).
When the parties to a court-ordered corporate buyout cannot agree on fair value, the court determines it under Minn. Stat. § 302A.473, subd. 7, “taking into account any and all factors the court finds relevant, computed by any method or combination of methods that the court, in its discretion, sees fit to use, whether or not used by the corporation or by a dissenter.”
An agreement that names a standard without saying whether discounts apply leaves a large gap open. The two appraisals in Gunderson valued one interest at $1,133,000 and $175,000, the lower one after a minority discount. I suggest an updated agreement state in words whether a minority discount, a marketability discount, or neither applies, because Follett treats them as separate adjustments.
Who Must Agree to Change the Buy-Sell Price?
For a price in an operating agreement or another agreement among the owners, that agreement’s own amendment clause decides who must sign a new price. A price in a corporation’s bylaws can be changed by the board unless the articles reserve that power to the shareholders. For a Minnesota LLC, the operating agreement governs “the means and conditions for amending the operating agreement” (§ 322C.0110, subd. 1), and where it says nothing, the statute requires the consent of all members.
- LLC. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subd. 1, the operating agreement sets its own amendment rule. “To the extent the operating agreement does not otherwise provide,” the chapter governs (subd. 2). In a member-managed LLC, “The operating agreement may be amended only with the consent of all members” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407, subd. 2). In manager-managed and board-managed LLCs, “The consent of all members is required to . . . amend the operating agreement” (subds. 3 and 4). Before members consent, the statute requires the company to share what it knows: in a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, “the company shall, without demand, provide the member with all information that is known to the company and is material to the member’s decision” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410, subd. 2). In a member-managed LLC, the company must furnish “without demand, any information concerning the company’s activities, financial condition, and other circumstances which the company knows and is material to the proper exercise of the member’s rights and duties under the operating agreement or this chapter, except to the extent the company can establish that it reasonably believes the member already knows the information,” and that duty “also applies to each member to the extent the member knows any of the information” (subd. 1).
- Corporation with a shareholder control agreement. That written agreement became enforceable because it was “signed by all persons who, on the date the agreement first becomes effective, are then the shareholders of the corporation,” and it “may provide for its amendment through nonunanimous means” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.457, subd. 2).
- Corporation with an ordinary buy-sell contract. Section 302A.457 “does not apply to, limit, or restrict agreements otherwise valid” (subd. 4), so the contract’s own amendment clause controls. If it has none, I suggest getting every party’s signature on the change, because each party signed the original.
- Corporation with the price in its bylaws. “Unless reserved by the articles to the shareholders, the power to adopt, amend, or repeal the bylaws is vested in the board,” and “The power of the board is subject to the power of the shareholders, exercisable in the manner provided in subdivision 3, to adopt, amend, or repeal bylaws adopted, amended, or repealed by the board” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.181, subd. 2).
- A change that adds a new restriction. If the update adds a trigger or a new limit on transfer, § 302A.429, subd. 1 makes it binding on shares issued earlier only for holders who “are parties to the agreement or voted in favor of the restriction.”
Owners can change a price in writing. The three brothers in Pedro “modified and re-executed the SRA, reducing the purchase price of the shares” years before their dispute, and the trial court awarded the price that re-executed agreement set.
How Do Agreed-Value Certificates and Formulas Keep a Price Current?
Three methods keep a buy-sell price from going stale: an agreed value the owners re-sign on a schedule, a formula tied to current financial statements, and an appraisal at the trigger. The owners choose among them in the agreement, and each method fails in a known way.
- An agreed-value certificate. The owners sign a short certificate stating the company’s value, for example each year. It costs little and gives a number every owner signed. It fails when nobody signs the next one, which is how a fixed price becomes years old. A fallback clause should say what happens when the newest certificate is older than a set period, because otherwise the agreement still points to the last signed number, however old it is. A missed certificate can also change the federal estate tax treatment of the agreement, as the estate tax section explains. That section also quotes the regulation’s exception. It applies only if individuals who are not members of the owner’s family own, directly or indirectly, more than 50% by value of the shares subject to the agreement (26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-1(b)(3)). Their shares must also be bound to the same extent as the owner’s.
- A formula. A formula updates itself from the books. It can still drift from what a buyer would pay. In Pedro, the formula of “75% of net book value at the end of the preceding calendar year” produced $766,582.33 for a one-third interest the trial court valued at $1,330,000.
- An appraisal at the trigger. An appraisal produces a current number, at the cost of time, fees, and a fight over method. The section What Makes an Appraisal Clause Work When the Buyout Arrives? covers how its machinery goes stale.
An agreement can combine the methods, using a certificate while it is current and an appraisal once it lapses. The page on valuation methods for an LLC buy-sell compares the drafting choices in more detail.
What Makes an Appraisal Clause Work When the Buyout Arrives?
An appraisal clause cannot go stale through its number, because it sets the price when the trigger occurs. It goes stale through its machinery: a named appraiser who no longer exists, or owners who skip the appraisal and agree on a number among themselves.
In Follett, the buy-sell named one valuation firm, Exponential, “or its successor, or any other firm selected by agreement of the parties.” By the time of the buyout, “Exponential no longer performed such appraisals,” and the company used a different firm. In January 1998, the parties agreed to a court-ordered panel of three appraisers, one chosen by each side and one by the court. At the trial that followed, the court found that the company’s firm was not Exponential’s successor and that the company’s president “failed to follow the valuation procedures in the buy-sell agreement.”
In Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. 257 (2024), a Missouri company’s agreement contemplated an outside appraisal of fair market value. The deceased owner’s son and the surviving brother skipped it and agreed on $3 million. The IRS later valued the shares at $5.3 million and assessed $889,914 in additional estate tax. The higher value came from the company’s life insurance, which the estate’s valuation had left out: “The IRS counted the $3 million in life-insurance proceeds excluded by the analyst and assessed Crown’s total value as $6.86 million ($3.86 million + $3 million).”
I suggest an appraisal clause name a selection method rather than a single firm, because the firm named in Follett stopped doing appraisals. The clause should also state the standard of value, the discount rule, and who pays, so the appraisers do not have to guess.
How Does Life Insurance Fund a Buyout at the Agreement Price?
Life insurance pays a fixed face amount, so a policy bought when the price was set can fall short of what the agreement now requires, or exceed a price that never changed. Who owns the policy can also affect the federal estate tax value of the shares, and Minnesota’s estate tax starts from the federal taxable estate (Minn. Stat. § 291.016, subd. 1). In Connelly, the U.S. Supreme Court said a cross-purchase agreement among the owners would have avoided the risk that the insurance proceeds would raise the deceased owner’s share value.
In Connelly, the corporation held $3.5 million of insurance on each brother to fund a redemption, meaning a purchase of the deceased owner’s shares by the company itself. The Court held that “An obligation to redeem shares at fair market value does not offset the value of life-insurance proceeds set aside for the redemption because a share redemption at fair market value does not affect any shareholder’s economic interest.” The proceeds therefore counted in the company’s value for estate tax. The Court limited that holding in a footnote, saying it did not hold “that a redemption obligation can never decrease” a company’s value.
The Court described the alternative: a cross-purchase agreement, under which the owners buy policies on each other and the proceeds go to the surviving owner instead of the company. It also said, “But, every arrangement has its own drawbacks,” noting that each owner must keep paying premiums on the others and that the structure “would have had its own tax consequences.” The page on how a buy-sell agreement works as an exit plan compares the funding structures.
A company-owned policy also has an income-tax rule. For a policy the company owns on an owner who is its employee, officer, or director, “the amount excluded from gross income of an applicable policyholder by reason of paragraph (1) of subsection (a) shall not exceed an amount equal to the sum of the premiums and other amounts paid by the policyholder for the contract” (26 U.S.C. § 101(j)(1)). The exceptions in § 101(j)(2) apply only where written notice and consent are given “before the issuance of the contract” (§ 101(j)(4)). The 2006 law that added § 101(j) provides that it “shall apply to life insurance contracts issued after the date of the enactment of this Act [Aug. 17, 2006], except for a contract issued after such date pursuant to an exchange described in section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 for a contract issued on or prior to that date,” and that “any material increase in the death benefit or other material change shall cause the contract to be treated as a new contract” (Pub. L. 109-280, § 863(d), in the note to 26 U.S.C. § 101). Moving an existing policy from the company to the other owners has its own limit: after “a transfer for a valuable consideration, by assignment or otherwise, of a life insurance contract or any interest therein,” the excluded amount “shall not exceed an amount equal to the sum of the actual value of such consideration and the premiums and other amounts subsequently paid by the transferee,” unless an exception in § 101(a)(2) applies, such as a transfer “to the insured, to a partner of the insured, to a partnership in which the insured is a partner, or to a corporation in which the insured is a shareholder or officer.”
I suggest the owners review the policy amounts whenever they update the price, because a gap between the two is cash the buyer must find on the day of the trigger.
When a Minnesota corporation is the buyer, the distribution rules in Minn. Stat. § 302A.551 reach “a distribution made by a corporation in connection with a purchase, redemption, or other acquisition of its shares” (subd. 3(a)). Under subd. 1(a), “The board may authorize and cause the corporation to make a distribution only if the board determines, in accordance with subdivision 2, that the corporation will be able to pay its debts in the ordinary course of business after making the distribution and the board does not know before the distribution is made that the determination was or has become erroneous.” For an LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0405, subd. 3 reaches a “distribution by purchase, redemption, or other acquisition of a transferable interest in the company.” Under subd. 1, an LLC “may not make a distribution if after the distribution” the company “would not be able to pay its debts as they become due in the ordinary course of the company’s activities.” Subdivision 1 also bars a distribution that would leave total assets below liabilities plus the amount needed to satisfy superior preferential rights on dissolution. When an LLC pays with a note, “each payment of principal or interest on the indebtedness is treated as a distribution, the effect of which is measured on the date the payment is made” (§ 322C.0405, subd. 6), so a later installment can be barred even if the first was lawful.
How Do Federal Estate Tax Rules Treat the Agreement Price?
For federal estate and gift tax, the value of property is determined “without regard to” an agreement to buy it “at a price less than the fair market value of the property,” unless the agreement meets each of three tests in 26 U.S.C. § 2703. A Treasury regulation applies that rule to an agreement “created or substantially modified after October 8, 1990” (26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-2). A stale low price can bind the owners under the contract and still be disregarded in valuing a deceased owner’s estate. A regulation quoted in this section makes an exception where people outside the owner’s family own most of the shares on the same terms.
26 U.S.C. § 2703(b) lifts that rule only for an agreement that “meets each of the following requirements”:
- “It is a bona fide business arrangement.”
- “It is not a device to transfer such property to members of the decedent’s family for less than full and adequate consideration in money or money’s worth.”
- “Its terms are comparable to similar arrangements entered into by persons in an arms’ length transaction.”
For owners who are not family, a regulation treats the tests as met: an agreement “is considered to meet each of the three requirements” if “more than 50 percent by value of the property subject to the right or restriction is owned directly or indirectly . . . by individuals who are not members of the transferor’s family,” and “the property owned by those individuals must be subject to the right or restriction to the same extent as the property owned by the transferor” (26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-1(b)(3)).
An amendment can count as a new agreement for this rule. Under 26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-1(c)(1), “A right or restriction that is substantially modified is treated as a right or restriction created on the date of the modification.” The same paragraph of 26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-1 adds, “If the terms of the right or restriction require periodic updating, the failure to update is presumed to substantially modify the right or restriction unless it can be shown that updating would not have resulted in a substantial modification.” Under 26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-1(c)(2)(iv), a substantial modification does not include “A modification that results in an option price that more closely approximates fair market value.”
In Connelly, the Court said that a share redemption agreement may set how the price is determined but ordinarily does not settle the value of the shares for estate tax, citing § 2703. The result for an estate can be a tax bill computed on a value higher than the price the estate actually received. The Court also noted, “Not all estates are subject to the estate tax.” Minnesota has its own estate tax: “the Minnesota taxable estate equals the federal taxable estate as provided under section 2051 of the Internal Revenue Code, without regard to whether the estate is subject to the federal estate tax” (Minn. Stat. § 291.016, subd. 1), with the adjustments that subdivision lists, including a subtraction for an exclusion amount of “$3,000,000 for decedents dying in 2020 and thereafter” (subd. 3). Chapter 291 also defines the federal gross estate as the gross estate “as required to be valued and otherwise determined for federal estate tax purposes under the Internal Revenue Code” (Minn. Stat. § 291.005, subd. 1). As a result, the federal valuation rules on this page can raise a Minnesota estate tax bill for an estate that owes no federal estate tax. Whether an estate owes the tax, and how much, is work for the estate’s CPA and an appraiser. The owners’ part is to know that a price far below market value may not hold for tax purposes.
What Are the Options When the Price Is Years Out of Date?
Owners who find a stale price have six realistic paths, and the first is a conversation among the owners before any document or court. Each fits a different situation and carries a different risk.
- Talk and agree on a new number. The owners meet, agree on a current value, and sign an amendment. In an LLC, the company must first share the material information § 322C.0410 requires, as the section on who must agree quotes. It fits when no trigger is near and the owners get along. The risk is that one owner, such as the one the old price favors, refuses.
- Commission one appraisal and adopt it. The owners hire a single appraiser now and sign the result into the agreement. It fits when the owners cannot agree on a number but trust a neutral one. The risk is the fee and an argument over the appraiser’s method.
- Change the method instead of the number. The owners add an agreed-value certificate with an appraisal fallback, or a formula, so the price stops depending on someone remembering. It fits owners who have let a fixed price lapse before. The risk is drafting a formula that drifts.
- Resize or restructure the insurance. The owners match policy amounts to the new price and decide whether the company or the owners should own the policies. It fits any update. The risks include premium cost and the tax effect Connelly describes. They also include the income-tax limits in 26 U.S.C. § 101(j) and § 101(a)(2) on a company-owned policy and on a policy transferred for value, which the life insurance section quotes.
- After a trigger, negotiate a price. The buyer and the departing owner or estate can agree on any price both accept, within two limits. When the company is the buyer, the debt-paying limits in § 302A.551 and § 322C.0405 apply, and for an LLC paying on a note they apply to each payment. When the seller is an estate, a sale “to the personal representative, the personal representative’s spouse, agent or attorney, or any corporation or trust in which the personal representative has a substantial beneficial interest,” or a transaction “affected by a substantial conflict of interest on the part of the personal representative,” is “voidable by any person interested in the estate except one who has consented after fair disclosure, unless (1) the will or a contract entered into by the decedent expressly authorized the transaction; or (2) the transaction is approved by the court after notice to interested persons” (Minn. Stat. § 524.3-713). It fits when the old number is plainly wrong and both sides want to avoid court. The risk is a tax result like Connelly’s, where the agreed price did not control the estate tax value.
- Ask a court. In a corporation, a court buyout requires a ground in § 302A.751, subd. 1(b), and even then the agreement price applies only if the shares “are then subject to sale and purchase” under the agreement, unless the court finds it unreasonable. In an LLC, the remedy requires a proceeding on the grounds in § 322C.0701, subd. 1, clause (5). It fits a real fight over control or conduct, which the page on ways out of a business with a bad partner compares to the other exits. The risk is cost, time, and a ruling that the old price stands.
Keeping the old number on purpose is also a choice. It fits owners who agree the number is acceptable to them. I suggest writing that agreement down, because a later owner or an estate may not remember it.
Can one co-owner block an update to the price?
It can, depending on which document holds the price. If a Minnesota LLC’s operating agreement sets no amendment rule of its own, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407 allows an amendment only with the consent of all members, so one member can say no. In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410, subd. 2 requires the company to provide, without demand, all information it knows that is material to a member’s consent decision. In a member-managed LLC, subdivision 1 requires the company to furnish, without demand, information it knows that is material to the proper exercise of the member’s rights and duties. That duty does not apply where the company can establish that it reasonably believes the member already knows the information. A shareholder control agreement or an ordinary buy-sell contract follows its own amendment clause. A price in corporate bylaws follows the bylaw amendment rules, which the section on who must agree to change the price quotes. The other owners can still negotiate a price change in exchange for something the holdout wants.
Do we need a new appraisal every year?
You need one only if your agreement requires it. The agreement sets the valuation method, and a yearly appraisal costs money each year. One alternative is an agreed-value certificate the owners sign each year, with an appraisal required only if the certificate lapses. For federal estate tax, “If the terms of the right or restriction require periodic updating, the failure to update is presumed to substantially modify the right or restriction unless it can be shown that updating would not have resulted in a substantial modification” (26 C.F.R. § 25.2703-1(c)(1)). The section on federal estate tax quotes the exception for shares owned mostly outside the owner’s family.
Should the company or the owners own the life insurance policies?
Either can work if its tax rules are met. In Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. 257 (2024), the company owned the policies, and the Supreme Court reasoned that “An obligation to redeem shares at fair market value does not offset the value of life-insurance proceeds set aside for the redemption.” The Court said a cross-purchase arrangement would have avoided that risk, though each owner then pays premiums on the others. A company-owned policy on an owner-employee also has income-tax limits. They turn on when the policy was issued or materially changed and on notice and consent before issuance, which the section on life insurance funding quotes. The Court noted, “Not all estates are subject to the estate tax,” but the Minnesota taxable estate starts from the federal one “without regard to whether the estate is subject to the federal estate tax” (Minn. Stat. § 291.016, subd. 1).
Can an out-of-date price be too high instead of too low?
Yes. A price set in a stronger year can exceed the business’s value at the trigger. Whether the buyer must pay it turns first on whether the agreement requires the purchase or grants only an option. When the company buys, it also turns on the debt-paying limits in Minn. Stat. § 302A.551 and Minn. Stat. § 322C.0405. In a court-ordered corporate buyout, it turns on whether Minn. Stat. § 302A.751 makes the agreement’s price apply to that sale. A price negotiated with an estate can also meet the probate conflict-of-interest rule in Minn. Stat. § 524.3-713. The sections on how a court treats the price, life insurance funding, and the options quote each rule.
Updating an Out-of-Date Buy-Sell Price
An old buy-sell price can bind the owners until they change it. In a court-ordered buyout, Minnesota’s corporation statute tells the court to apply it if the shares “are then subject to sale and purchase” under the agreement, unless it is unreasonable (§ 302A.751, subd. 2). The time to change it is before a trigger, with the signatures the agreement or the statute requires, and with the valuation method, the discount rule, and the insurance updated together. I suggest updating it while the owners can still agree on their own terms, because after a trigger the same number can become the center of a business partner dispute.
If your buy-sell price is years old, email [email protected] with a short description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.