Minnesota’s LLC act gives a member a right to a distribution before the company dissolves only if the company decides to make one, and Minnesota’s corporation act leaves distributions, share buybacks included, to the board. So a passive investor who demands the money back cannot, by the demand alone, force your company to pay. Other facts can change the answer, including whether the investor put in equity or made a loan, what your agreements say, and how the investment was offered and sold. A court can also order a sale of the interest, and certain corporate actions give a shareholder the right to “dissent from, and obtain payment for the fair value of the shareholder’s shares” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.471, subd. 1).
The LLC rules come from chapter 322C of Minnesota Statutes, the corporation rules from chapter 302A, and the investor’s possible right to rescind the purchase from Minnesota’s securities act, chapter 80A, with a federal parallel. This page is written for the owner who runs the company and received the demand. A business never formed as an LLC or corporation falls outside chapters 322C and 302A and follows other rules. The partnership buyout rule in Minn. Stat. § 323A.0701 reaches a partnership as the partnership act defines it, an association “formed under section 323A.0202, predecessor law, or comparable law of another jurisdiction” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0101, clause (8)), and “An association formed under a statute other than this chapter, a predecessor statute, or a comparable statute of another jurisdiction is not a partnership under this chapter” (Minn. Stat. § 323A.0202(b)). A limited partnership follows chapter 321, including Minn. Stat. § 321.0505 and Minn. Stat. § 321.0601. Chapter 80A’s definition of a security still reaches “an interest in a limited partnership” (Minn. Stat. § 80A.41, clause (30)). The investor’s general role is covered on the page about a silent partner in an LLC. If the demand has already become a business partner dispute, the same rules decide what each side can force.
How Do You Tell Whether the Money Was a Loan or an Investment?
The records from the time the money changed hands can show whether it was a loan or an equity investment. A loan is a debt the company repays on its terms. Equity buys an ownership interest: under Minnesota’s LLC act, a “contribution” is a benefit a person gives the company to become a member, or “in the person’s capacity as a member and in accordance with the operating agreement or an agreement between the member and the company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0102, subd. 5). Money the company pays out on an equity interest is a distribution, which the act defines: a distribution “means a transfer of money or other property from a limited liability company to another person on account of a transferable interest” (subd. 7). A corporation’s distribution is a transfer “by a corporation to any of its shareholders in respect of its shares,” including a payment “as consideration for the purchase, redemption, or other acquisition of its shares” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.011, subd. 10).
The label matters because a lender is paid on the note, while an equity investor is paid through a distribution the company decides to make, within the payout limits discussed below. An equity investor can also be paid through another route this page describes, such as a contractual redemption, a sale to a new investor, a court-ordered sale, or a securities rescission claim. The records that tend to show which one you have include:
- A promissory note from the company. A signed note with a principal amount, an interest rate, and a due date points toward a loan. Under Minnesota’s version of the Uniform Commercial Code, a promissory note governed by its Article 3 is payable on demand if it “(i) states that it is payable on demand or at sight, or otherwise indicates that it is payable at the will of the holder, or (ii) does not state any time of payment” (Minn. Stat. § 336.3-108(a)). A note that names no repayment date can therefore be due whenever the holder asks.
- An ownership record. Units or shares issued to the investor, a capital account on the books, and a percentage in the operating agreement or share register point toward equity.
- How the company reported the money. Whether the books and tax returns treated the money as debt or as an owner’s capital can show how the parties understood it at the time.
- What the investor was promised. A fixed interest rate points one way, and a share of profits points the other.
A note can appear on either side of the deal. The LLC act lets a contribution consist of “money, services performed, promissory notes, other agreements to contribute money or property, and contracts for services to be performed” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0402), so the question is who promised to pay whom. While preparing an outline of one company’s ownership structure, I asked my client to identify which of the people proposing to contribute money would be investors and which would be lenders. Investors would be owners who share in the profits, and lenders would be paid a guaranteed interest rate. If the papers never answered that question, I suggest gathering every document and message from the time the money changed hands, because they show what both sides said the money was.
What Are the Rules When an LLC Member Wants Capital Back?
Before a Minnesota LLC dissolves, the LLC act gives a member no right to take capital back unless the company decides to make a distribution or the operating agreement creates the right. A court order or a securities claim, covered below, can be another route. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0404, subd. 2, “A person has a right to a distribution before the dissolution and winding up of a limited liability company only if the company decides to make an interim distribution. A person’s dissociation does not entitle the person to a distribution.” That is the default rule. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0110, subds. 1 and 2, the operating agreement governs “relations among the members as members and between the members and the limited liability company,” and “To the extent the operating agreement does not otherwise provide for a matter described in subdivision 1, this chapter governs the matter.” A redemption right, a put option, or a promised return date in your operating agreement can replace the default.
The investor can still leave. “A person has the power to dissociate as a member at any time, rightfully or wrongfully, by withdrawing as a member by express will under section 322C.0602, clause (1)” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0601, subd. 1). Leaving does not cash the investor out. After dissociation, “the person’s right to participate as a member in the management and conduct of the company’s activities terminates,” and the person’s transferable interest “is owned by the person solely as a transferee” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0603, subd. 1). The member’s information rights under the LLC act “do not extend to a person as transferee” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410, subd. 6). A former member still has limited access: “On ten days’ demand made in a record received by a limited liability company, a dissociated member may have access to information to which the person was entitled while a member if the information pertains to the period during which the person was a member, the person seeks the information in good faith, and the person satisfies the requirements imposed on a member by subdivision 2, clause (2). The company shall respond to a demand made pursuant to this subdivision in the manner provided in subdivision 2, clause (3)” (subd. 3).
Withdrawal can also cost the investor. Under § 322C.0601, subd. 2, a dissociation is wrongful if it “is in breach of an express provision of the operating agreement,” or if it “occurs before the termination of the company and” the person “withdraws as a member by express will,” among the other events that subdivision lists. “A person that wrongfully dissociates as a member is liable to the limited liability company and, subject to section 322C.0901, to the other members for damages caused by the dissociation” (subd. 3). The member’s side of these rules is on the page about an LLC member who resigns and withdraws capital.
How Does a Corporation Handle a Shareholder Who Wants to Be Cashed Out?
In a Minnesota corporation, buying back a shareholder’s investment is a distribution, and the board decides whether to make it. Under Minn. Stat. § 302A.553, subd. 1, “A corporation may acquire its own shares, subject to section 302A.551 and subdivision 3.” Minn. Stat. § 302A.551, subd. 1, then sets the condition: “The board may authorize and cause the corporation to make a distribution only if the board determines, in accordance with subdivision 2, that the corporation will be able to pay its debts in the ordinary course of business after making the distribution and the board does not know before the distribution is made that the determination was or has become erroneous.” The statute gives that decision to the board, so a shareholder’s demand alone does not require a payment.
The company’s own documents can change that. The board’s power and the rights of persons to receive distributions “may be prohibited, limited, or restricted by, or the rights and priorities of persons to receive distributions may be established by, the articles or bylaws or an agreement” (§ 302A.551, subd. 1). Redeemable shares in the articles or a buyout clause in a shareholder agreement can turn a request into a contract claim.
One more statute gives a shareholder a right to payment in specific events. A shareholder may “dissent from, and obtain payment for the fair value of the shareholder’s shares in the event of, any of the following corporate actions” listed in Minn. Stat. § 302A.471, subd. 1, such as certain amendments of the articles and a plan of merger. That right arises only when the company takes one of those listed actions.
How Does the Operating or Shareholder Agreement Change the Answer?
Your company’s agreements can turn the investor’s request into a binding obligation. I suggest reading them before you answer, because a redemption clause, a put right, or a buyout trigger can require the company or the other owners to buy. When an agreement requires the company itself to pay, the payout statutes still apply. “A limited liability company may not make a distribution if after the distribution” it fails either test in Minn. Stat. § 322C.0405, subd. 1. A corporation’s board may make a distribution “only if” it makes the determination § 302A.551, subd. 1, requires, and both rules are quoted in the sections on corporations and creditor limits. In an LLC, the act’s default rules apply only where the operating agreement does not provide otherwise (§ 322C.0110, subd. 2). Subdivision 3 lists terms an operating agreement cannot change, including that it may not “vary the power of a court to decree dissolution in the circumstances specified in section 322C.0701, subdivision 1, clauses (4) and (5)” (§ 322C.0110, subd. 3). The operating agreement need not be a signed document: the act defines it as the agreement “whether oral, in a record, implied, or in any combination thereof, of all the members of a limited liability company” (§ 322C.0102, subd. 17). A promise all the members made when the money came in, even an unwritten one, can therefore be part of the operating agreement.
In a corporation, written agreements among shareholders, or between shareholders and the corporation, “are presumed to reflect the parties’ reasonable expectations concerning matters dealt with in the agreements” in a court case under Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 3a. In a court-ordered buyout under that section, “if the shares in question are then subject to sale and purchase pursuant to the bylaws of the corporation, a shareholder control agreement, the terms of the shares, or otherwise, the court shall order the sale for the price and on the terms set forth in them, unless the court determines that the price or terms are unreasonable under all the circumstances of the case” (subd. 2).
When you read the agreements, I suggest looking for these terms, because each one can change what you owe:
- A redemption or put clause. It names who can start a buyback, the price or formula, and the payment terms.
- A buyout trigger. It lists the events, such as withdrawal or death, that require or permit a purchase.
- A return-of-capital or preferred return clause. It can set the order in which money is paid out when the company makes distributions. I suggest reading whether it also gives the investor a right to demand payment, because the two are separate terms.
- The amendment rule. If the operating agreement sets no other rule, in a member-managed LLC “The operating agreement may be amended only with the consent of all members” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0407, subd. 2). In a manager-managed LLC, “The consent of all members is required to” take several listed actions, including to “amend the operating agreement” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 3). The investor’s consent is then needed to amend the operating agreement.
What Are the Rules That Limit a Payout to Protect Creditors?
Even when the company wants to return the money, Minnesota law bars a payout to an owner that fails the statute’s debt-paying test. An LLC faces a balance-sheet test as well, and a corporation’s distribution to a class of shares faces a preference test. Under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0405, subd. 1, “A limited liability company may not make a distribution if after the distribution” either “the company would not be able to pay its debts as they become due in the ordinary course of the company’s activities” or “the company’s total assets would be less than the sum of its total liabilities plus the amount that would be needed, if the company were to be dissolved, wound up, and terminated at the time of the distribution, to satisfy the preferential rights upon dissolution, winding up, and termination of members whose preferential rights are superior to those of persons receiving the distribution.” For a redemption, the effect is measured “as of the date money or other property is transferred or debt incurred by the company” (subd. 3), but that measure applies “Except as otherwise provided in subdivision 6,” and under subdivision 6 each payment on a note issued as a distribution is measured “on the date the payment is made.”
A corporation applies the debt-paying test of § 302A.551, subd. 1, quoted in the corporation section above. For a distribution to a class of shares, subdivision 4 adds: “A distribution may be made to the holders of a class or series of shares only if: (1) All amounts payable to the holders of shares having a preference for the payment of that kind of distribution, other than those holders who give notice to the corporation of their agreement to waive their rights to that payment, are paid; and (2) The payment of the distribution does not reduce the remaining net assets of the corporation below the aggregate preferential amount payable in the event of liquidation to the holders of shares having preferential rights, unless the distribution is made to those shareholders in the order and to the extent of their respective priorities or the holders of shares who do not receive distributions in that order give notice to the corporation of their agreement to waive their rights to that distribution” (§ 302A.551, subd. 4(a)).
The penalty for getting it wrong can fall on individuals. In an LLC, “Except as otherwise provided in subdivision 2, if a member of a member-managed limited liability company, manager of a manager-managed limited liability company, or governor of a board-managed limited liability company consents to a distribution made in violation of section 322C.0405 and in consenting to the distribution fails to comply with section 322C.0409, the member, manager, or governor is personally liable to the company for the amount of the distribution that exceeds the amount that could have been distributed without the violation of section 322C.0405” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0406, subd. 1). “A person that receives a distribution knowing that the distribution to that person was made in violation of section 322C.0405 is personally liable to the limited liability company but only to the extent that the distribution received by the person exceeded the amount that could have been properly paid under section 322C.0405” (subd. 3). The same section provides: “An action under this section is barred if not commenced within two years after the distribution” (subd. 5). Check the current text of the statute before relying on that period.
In a corporation, “a director who is present at a meeting and fails to vote against, or who consents in writing to, a distribution made in violation of section 302A.551, subdivision 1, paragraph (a), or 4, or a restriction contained in the articles or bylaws or an agreement, and who fails to comply with the standard of conduct provided in section 302A.251, is liable to the corporation” for the excess (Minn. Stat. § 302A.559, subd. 1). “A shareholder who receives a distribution made in violation of the provisions of section 302A.551 is liable to the corporation, its receiver or other person winding up its affairs, or a director under section 302A.559, subdivision 2, but only to the extent that the distribution received by the shareholder exceeded the amount that properly could have been paid under section 302A.551” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.557, subd. 1). The LLC section reaches a recipient who knew of the violation, and the corporate section’s text states no knowledge condition. Each corporate section provides: “An action shall not be commenced under this section more than two years from the date of the distribution” (§ 302A.557, subd. 2; § 302A.559, subd. 4). Check the current text of the statutes before relying on those periods.
Both statutes tie the decision to reasonable financial information. An LLC may rely on “financial statements prepared on the basis of accounting practices and principles that are reasonable in the circumstances or on a fair valuation or other method that is reasonable under the circumstances” (§ 322C.0405, subd. 2). For a corporation, a determination made under the standard of conduct in section 302A.251 “on the basis of financial information prepared in accordance with accounting methods, or a fair valuation or other method, reasonable in the circumstances” is presumed proper, and “No liability under section 302A.251 or 302A.559 will accrue if the requirements of this subdivision have been met” (§ 302A.551, subd. 2). I suggest having current financial statements in hand and recording the decision before any payout, because that record is what each statute looks to.
When Does a Silent Partner’s Investment Become a Securities Problem?
An LLC interest or corporate stock sold to a passive investor is a security under Minnesota law. If the sale was not registered, not exempt, and not of a federal covered security, the investor can have a statutory right to get the money back. The securities act’s definition of a security begins with “a note; stock; treasury stock” and later lists an “investment contract,” which, the definition adds, includes “an interest in a limited partnership and a limited liability company” (Minn. Stat. § 80A.41, clause (30)). Under Minn. Stat. § 80A.49, “It is unlawful for a person to offer or sell a security in this state unless” the security is a federal covered security, “the security, transaction, or offer is exempted from registration under sections 80A.45 through 80A.47,” or “the security is registered under this chapter.”
The remedy is a rescission claim. “A person is liable to the purchaser if the person sells a security in violation of section 80A.49,” or sells it by a material misstatement or omission, “the purchaser not knowing the untruth or omission and the seller not sustaining the burden of proof that the seller did not know and, in the exercise of reasonable care, could not have known of the untruth or omission,” and “The purchaser may maintain an action to recover the consideration paid for the security, less the amount of any income received on the security, and interest from the date of the purchase, costs, and reasonable attorneys’ fees determined by the court, upon the tender of the security, or for actual damages as provided in paragraph (3)” (Minn. Stat. § 80A.76(b)). The tender step is light: “Tender requires only notice in a record of ownership of the security and willingness to exchange the security for the amount specified.” A letter offering to hand back the units for the money paid can be the investor’s tender.
The claim can reach you personally. Under § 80A.76(g), certain persons are “liable jointly and severally with and to the same extent as persons liable under subsections (b) through (f),” including “an individual who is a managing partner, executive officer, or director of a person liable under subsections (b) through (f),” “unless the individual sustains the burden of proof that the individual did not know” of the conduct, under the reasonable-care condition that paragraph states. What you told the investor also matters: the act makes it unlawful, in connection with the offer, sale, or purchase of a security, “to make an untrue statement of a material fact or to omit to state a material fact necessary in order to make a statement made, in the light of the circumstances under which it is made, not misleading” (Minn. Stat. § 80A.68).
The claims have short limits. No relief is available “under subsection (b) for violation of section 80A.49, or under subsection (d) or (e), unless the action is instituted within one year after the violation occurred,” or “under subsection (b), other than for violation of section 80A.49, or under subsection (c) or (f), unless the action is instituted within the earlier of two years after discovery of the facts constituting the violation or five years after the violation” (§ 80A.76(j)). Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. Signed investor papers cannot waive compliance with the act: “A condition, stipulation, or provision binding a person purchasing or selling a security or receiving investment advice to waive compliance with this chapter or a rule adopted or order issued under this chapter is void” (§ 80A.76(l)).
The act also gives the seller a way to close off the claim. Under Minn. Stat. § 80A.77, “A purchaser, seller, or recipient of investment advice may not maintain an action under section 80A.76 if” the person “receives in a record, before the action is instituted” an offer meeting every condition the section lists. The offer must be “an offer stating the respect in which liability under section 80A.76 may have arisen and fairly advising the purchaser, seller, or recipient of investment advice of that person’s rights in connection with the offer, and any financial or other information necessary to correct all material misrepresentations or omissions in the information that was required by this chapter to be furnished to that person at the time of this purchase, sale, or investment advice” (§ 80A.77, clause (1)(A)).
For a claim under § 80A.76(b), the offer to a purchaser who still owns the security must include “an offer to repurchase the security for cash, payable on delivery of the security, equal to the consideration paid, and interest from the date of the purchase, less the amount of any income received on the security” (§ 80A.77, clause (1)(B)). A purchaser who no longer owns the security gets the damages offer that clause describes. The offer must also state “that it must be accepted by the purchaser, seller, or recipient of investment advice within 30 days after the date of its receipt by the purchaser, seller, or recipient of investment advice or any shorter period, of not less than three days, that the administrator, by order, specifies” (§ 80A.77, clause (2)). The offeror must have “the present ability to pay the amount offered,” and a purchaser who accepts must be “paid in accordance with the terms of the offer” (§ 80A.77, clauses (3) and (5)).
The offer is itself an exempt transaction under Minn. Stat. § 80A.46, clause (19), which adds: “The person making the rescission offer must provide to the administrator notice of the transaction by filing a written description of the transaction and a copy of the record that must be delivered to the offeree under section 80A.77. Notice must be filed at least ten days in advance of any rescission offer under section 80A.77 or a shorter period as permitted by the administrator.” Check the current text of the statutes before relying on these periods.
Federal law runs alongside. Under 15 U.S.C. § 77e(a), “Unless a registration statement is in effect as to a security, it shall be unlawful for any person, directly or indirectly” to use interstate commerce or the mails to sell it. A person who “offers or sells a security in violation of section 77e of this title” is liable to the buyer “to recover the consideration paid for such security with interest thereon, less the amount of any income received thereon, upon the tender of such security, or for damages if he no longer owns the security” (15 U.S.C. § 77l(a)(1)). Whether an exemption covered the original sale is the question the page on unregistered securities in friends and family capital raises works through. Before you answer the demand, I suggest pinning down how the money was raised: who was approached, what was said, and what was signed. Those facts decide whether chapter 80A gives the investor a path to the money that the LLC and corporation acts do not.
When Can a Silent Partner Ask a Court to Force a Buyout?
A silent partner can ask a Minnesota court for relief, including a court-ordered sale, on the grounds each statute lists. In an LLC those grounds include illegal, fraudulent, or oppressive conduct by those in control, and in a corporation they include conduct unfairly prejudicial to the shareholder. For an LLC, a court may dissolve the company “on application by a member” on the grounds that those in control “have acted, are acting, or will act in a manner that is illegal or fraudulent” or “have acted or are acting in a manner that is oppressive and was, is, or will be directly harmful to the applicant” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0701, subd. 1, clause (5)). In that proceeding, “the court may order a remedy other than dissolution, which may include the sale for fair value of all membership interests a member owns in a limited liability company to the limited liability company or one or more of the other members” (subd. 2).
“Oppressive” has a statutory meaning. It covers conduct “that is unfairly prejudicial to the applicant member in a capacity listed in clause (2), because the conduct frustrated an expectation of the applicant member” that meets four listed conditions, and conduct “is not oppressive solely by reason of a good faith disagreement as to the content, interpretation, or application of the company’s operating agreement” (§ 322C.0102, subd. 18). The application belongs to a member, and the act defines a member as a person who “has not dissociated under section 322C.0602” (subd. 15).
For a corporation, the grounds in Minn. Stat. § 302A.751, subd. 1(b), include that “the directors or those in control of the corporation have acted in a manner unfairly prejudicial toward one or more shareholders in their capacities as shareholders or directors of a corporation that is not a publicly held corporation, or as officers or employees of a closely held corporation.” Once a ground is established in a case involving a corporation that is not publicly held, the court may, on motion, “order the sale by a plaintiff or a defendant of all shares of the corporation held by the plaintiff or defendant to either the corporation or the moving shareholders, whichever is specified in the motion, if the court determines in its discretion that an order would be fair and equitable to all parties under all of the circumstances of the case” (subd. 2). The price is “the fair value of the shares as of the date of the commencement of the action or as of another date found equitable by the court,” subject to the proviso for shares already subject to sale and purchase that the agreement section above quotes. The court considers the duty of shareholders in a closely held corporation “to act in an honest, fair, and reasonable manner in the operation of the corporation” (subd. 3a). “If the court finds that a party to a proceeding brought under this section has acted arbitrarily, vexatiously, or otherwise not in good faith, it may in its discretion award reasonable expenses, including attorneys’ fees and disbursements, to any of the other parties” (subd. 4).
The doctrine behind these claims is on the page about shareholder oppression. I suggest answering the investor in writing, with the reason for your position tied to the agreement, because both statutes look at whether the people in control acted in good faith.
How Do You Negotiate a Redemption or Buyout With a Silent Partner?
A negotiated exit lets the owners set the price, the timing, and the release on terms the company can afford, and it can start with a direct conversation. I suggest asking first what the investor needs, because a need for cash by a certain date, a target return, or a wish to stop worrying about the business each points to a different solution. The realistic options are these:
- Talk owner to owner. A conversation can surface a fix that costs less than a dispute, such as a partial payment now and the rest later. It fits when the relationship is intact. The risk is an informal promise, so I suggest putting any agreed terms in writing, because an unwritten agreement of all the members can be part of the operating agreement.
- Find a replacement investor. In an LLC, a transfer of a transferable interest “is permissible” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0502, subd. 1), and “A transferee has the right to receive, in accordance with the transfer, distributions to which the transferor would otherwise be entitled” (subd. 2). The transfer alone does not let the buyer “participate in the management or conduct of the company’s activities” (subd. 1). The sale also “does not by itself cause a member’s dissociation” (subd. 1), and “Except as otherwise provided in section 322C.0602, clause (4), item (ii), when a member transfers a transferable interest, the transferor retains the rights of a member other than the interest in distributions transferred and retains all duties and obligations of a member” (subd. 7). Under that exception, the investor can be “expelled as a member by the unanimous consent of the other members” once “there has been a transfer of all of the person’s transferable interest in the company” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0602, clause (4)). That clause excludes a transfer for security purposes and a charging order that has not been foreclosed. The investor can also be “expelled as a member pursuant to the operating agreement” (clause (3)). It fits when someone else wants in. The risk is a transfer restriction in your agreement, which I suggest checking first.
- Buy the interest yourself. The LLC act describes a distribution as “a transfer of money or other property from a limited liability company” (§ 322C.0102, subd. 7), and the corporation act as a transfer “by a corporation to any of its shareholders” (§ 302A.011, subd. 10). A purchase with your own money is a sale between owners, so the company’s cash stays in the business. In an LLC, your purchase of the investor’s transferable interest is a transfer under § 322C.0502, so the subdivision 1 and 7 rules quoted in option 2 apply to it. The investor then “retains the rights of a member other than the interest in distributions transferred” unless dissociated, such as by the expulsion option 2 describes. It fits when you have the funds and want a larger stake. The risk is personal cash and the price, plus the buyer’s liability under the securities act: “A person is liable to the seller if the person buys a security by means of an untrue statement of a material fact or omission to state a material fact necessary in order to make the statement made, in light of the circumstances under which it is made, not misleading, the seller not knowing of the untruth or omission, and the purchaser not sustaining the burden of proof that the purchaser did not know, and in the exercise of reasonable care, could not have known of the untruth or omission” (§ 80A.76(c); see § 80A.76(j), quoted in the securities section above).
- Have the company redeem the interest, possibly over time. This keeps the cost inside the business, within the payout limits in the creditor section above. It fits a company with steady cash flow. The risk is that a schedule of payments has its own solvency rules, which FAQ 3 below covers, and the company, as the buyer, carries the § 80A.76(c) liability quoted in option 3. Unless the operating agreement provides otherwise, the LLC act’s default also applies: “Subject to section 322C.1204, subdivision 3, clause (3), items (i) through (iv), any distributions made by a limited liability company before its dissolution and winding up must be in equal shares among members and dissociated members, except to the extent necessary to comply with any transfer effective under section 322C.0502 and any charging order in effect under section 322C.0503” (§ 322C.0404, subd. 1). For “a limited liability company formed before August 1, 2015,” the act provides, “subject to the operating agreement of the limited liability company,” that “section 322C.0404, subdivision 1, does not apply to the limited liability company” and that “distributions of cash or other assets of the company, including distributions on termination of the limited liability company, must be allocated in proportion to the value of the contributions of the members reflected in the records required by item (i)” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.1204, subd. 3, clause (3)).
- Say no, with reasons. Where the agreement gives no right to a buyback and the company cannot spare the cash, declining is an option. The risk is escalation, which the court and securities sections above describe.
Two rules shape how you negotiate. First, every LLC member “shall discharge the member’s duties and exercise any rights under this chapter or under the operating agreement consistently with the contractual obligation of good faith and fair dealing, including acting in a manner, in light of the operating agreement, that is honest, fair, and reasonable” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0409, subd. 4). Second, a buyout may need the other members’ approval: by default in a member-managed LLC, “An act outside the ordinary course of the activities of the company may be undertaken only with the consent of all members” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 2). In a manager-managed LLC, “The consent of all members is required to” take several listed acts, including to “undertake any other act outside the ordinary course of the company’s activities” (§ 322C.0407, subd. 3, clause (4)). In a board-managed LLC, the company’s activities and affairs are “to be managed by and under the direction of a board of governors” (subd. 4, clause (1)). Subdivision 4, clause (16), lists three acts that need the consent of all members. They are a sale or other disposition of all or substantially all of the company’s property outside the ordinary course, a merger, conversion, or domestication, and an amendment of the operating agreement.
Information comes with any consent. In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, “Whenever this chapter or an operating agreement provides for a member to give or withhold consent to a matter, before the consent is given or withheld, the company shall, without demand, provide the member with all information that is known to the company and is material to the member’s decision” (§ 322C.0410, subd. 2). In a member-managed LLC, the company must furnish each member “without demand, any information concerning the company’s activities, financial condition, and other circumstances which the company knows and is material to the proper exercise of the member’s rights and duties under the operating agreement or this chapter, except to the extent the company can establish that it reasonably believes the member already knows the information” (subd. 1).
The investor may also send a records demand under Minn. Stat. § 302A.461, subd. 4, or § 322C.0410. In a manager-managed or board-managed LLC, a member may obtain information “as is just and reasonable if” the member “seeks the information for a purpose material to the member’s interest as a member,” “makes a demand in a record received by the company, describing with reasonable particularity the information sought and the purpose for seeking the information,” and “the information sought is directly connected to the member’s purpose” (§ 322C.0410, subd. 2, clause (2)). “Within ten days after receiving a demand pursuant to clause (2), item (ii), the company shall in a record inform the member that made the demand” of the information it will provide and when and where, and of its reasons for declining any demanded information (subd. 2, clause (3)).
In a member-managed LLC, “On reasonable notice, a member may inspect and copy during regular business hours, at a reasonable location specified by the company, any record maintained by the company regarding the company’s activities, financial condition, and other circumstances, to the extent the information is material to the member’s rights and duties under the operating agreement or this chapter” (subd. 1). The same subdivision requires the company to furnish each member, “on demand, any other information concerning the company’s activities, financial condition, and other circumstances, except to the extent the demand or information demanded is unreasonable or otherwise improper under the circumstances” (subd. 1, clause (2), item (ii)). A dissociated member must also seek the information “in good faith” (subd. 3, quoted in the LLC section). I suggest preparing the financials you would share in any case, because either kind of demand can reach them. The valuation and payment-term choices that follow are on the page about how to buy out a business partner in Minnesota.
Can the silent partner demand the company's books while we negotiate?
Yes, while the investor is a shareholder or member, and in part after an LLC member withdraws. A shareholder of a corporation that is not publicly held “has an absolute right, upon written demand, to examine and copy, . . . at any reasonable time” the share register and listed records, which the corporation “shall make available within ten days after receipt by an officer of the corporation of the written demand” (Minn. Stat. § 302A.461, subd. 4). Other corporate records require “a proper purpose.” An LLC member’s rights under Minn. Stat. § 322C.0410 depend on how the company is managed, as the negotiation section quotes. They “do not extend to a person as transferee,” though a dissociated member keeps the limited access of subdivision 3, which the LLC section quotes.
Does the investor become a creditor once the company agrees to buy them out?
Yes, as to the payment the investor becomes entitled to. In an LLC, a member entitled to a distribution “has the status of, . . . a creditor of the limited liability company with respect to the distribution” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0404, subd. 4), and the company’s debt to a member “incurred by reason of a distribution made according to this section is at parity with the company’s indebtedness to its general, unsecured creditors” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0405, subd. 4). A corporation’s debt to a former shareholder “incurred or issued in a distribution in accordance with this section” has the same parity, unless the parties subordinate, secure, or otherwise agree to change it (Minn. Stat. § 302A.551, subd. 3).
Can the company pay the investor back in installments?
Yes, but the creditor-protection test applies differently by entity. In an LLC, when a note is issued as a distribution, “each payment of principal or interest on the indebtedness is treated as a distribution, the effect of which is measured on the date the payment is made” (Minn. Stat. § 322C.0405, subd. 6), so a later payment can fail the test. A corporation measures the effect of a redemption as of the earliest of the date it transfers money, incurs the installment debt, or the shareholder stops being a shareholder (Minn. Stat. § 302A.551, subd. 3).
Is it different if the business was never formed as an LLC or corporation?
Yes. Such a business is outside chapters 322C and 302A, the LLC and corporation acts this page discusses. For a partnership formed under Minn. Stat. § 323A.0202, the purchase of a dissociated partner’s interest is governed by Minn. Stat. § 323A.0701, but “An association formed under a statute other than this chapter, a predecessor statute, or a comparable statute of another jurisdiction is not a partnership under this chapter” (§ 323A.0202). A limited partnership follows chapter 321, including Minn. Stat. §§ 321.0505 and 321.0601. The securities act can still apply, because its definition of a security reaches “an interest in a limited partnership” (Minn. Stat. § 80A.41).
Handling a Silent Partner’s Demand
A silent partner’s demand for the money back does not by itself obligate a Minnesota LLC or corporation to pay. Other facts can, including a loan the company owes, a redemption or buyout term in your agreements, a court order, and a rescission right under the securities act. I suggest answering in order: identify what the money was, read the agreements, test any payout against the creditor rules, and check how the investment was sold. A written, good-faith answer can help keep the demand from growing into a larger shareholder dispute.
If a passive investor is asking for their money back, email [email protected] with a short description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.