After closing, an indemnification claim follows the procedure in your purchase agreement. The buyer gives written notice of a covered loss within the claim period, the seller accepts or disputes it, and payment comes from an escrow, a set-off, or the seller directly. Outside a sale of goods, no Minnesota statute writes those terms for a business sale, so the signed agreement controls. Minnesota law sets the outer frame: limitations periods, limits on shortened claim periods and on contracting away fraud, and the rules for mediation and arbitration.

This page is written for a buyer or a seller of a Minnesota business after closing. The buyer has found a problem, such as an undisclosed liability, a breached representation, or a claim from a third party. It covers making and answering the claim. My work on business acquisitions and sales covers the deal itself.

How Does an Indemnification Claim Work After Closing?

An indemnification claim after closing works the way the purchase agreement’s indemnity article says it does, because, outside a sale of goods, Minnesota has no statute that supplies those terms for a business sale. The article answers six questions, and the answers decide whether a claim exists and how it is paid:

  1. What is covered. Breached representations and warranties, breached covenants, liabilities the seller kept, and any item the parties listed for a specific indemnity.
  2. What counts as a loss. The definition of “losses” or “damages,” and whether it excludes items such as lost profits or consequential damages.
  3. How a claim is made. The notice contents, the notice address and method, and the claim period, which may be tied to how long the representations survive closing.
  4. How much can be recovered. Any basket (a threshold before the seller pays), any cap, and any exclusions.
  5. Where the money comes from. An escrow, a holdback, a right of set-off, or the seller directly.
  6. What else is available. Whether indemnity is the exclusive remedy, what the agreement says about fraud, and how disputes are resolved.

An agreement may treat two kinds of claims differently: a direct claim, where the buyer itself suffered the loss, and a third-party claim, where someone outside the deal makes a demand. I suggest reading which procedure applies before sending or answering anything, because a third-party procedure adds steps about who defends.

Minnesota law then supplies the frame around the agreement. It sets the statutory limitations periods and decides whether a shortened contractual claim period is enforceable. In a construction-contract case, it conditioned the duty to indemnify on a tender of the defense. It also limits how far a contract can bar a fraud claim and governs mediation and arbitration. Each is covered below.

What Should a Claim Notice Contain, and When Is It Due?

A claim notice should contain what the agreement’s notice clause lists and should reach the seller by the method and before the date the agreement sets, because those are the conditions the seller agreed to. A notice that misses them can give the seller a defense to an otherwise valid claim. I suggest that a buyer’s notice identify the facts discovered, the representation or covenant breached, and the amount claimed or a good-faith estimate, because an agreement can make those the elements of a valid claim. If the amount is not yet known, I suggest checking whether the agreement accepts an estimate. A notice sent before the claim period ends can preserve a claim whose final amount comes later. In a sale of goods, a statute adds its own notice step: where a tender of goods has been accepted, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-607(3)(a) provides that “the buyer must within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered any breach notify the seller of breach or be barred from any remedy.” I also suggest keeping proof of delivery to the notice address the agreement names, since the date of delivery can decide whether the claim was timely.

The claim period itself can be a survival clause: the representations “survive” closing only for a stated time. Minnesota enforces a shorter contractual period within limits. In a 2002 home-sale case, the Minnesota Supreme Court, citing its earlier decisions, stated: “Parties may limit the time within which legal claims may be brought provided there is no statute specifically prohibiting the use of a different limitations period in such a case and the time fixed is not unreasonable.” Whether a period is reasonable “depends upon the particular facts presented; what is acceptable in one case may be objectionable in another” (Peggy Rose Revocable Trust v. Eppich, 640 N.W.2d 601 (Minn. 2002)). That case’s fraud holding is covered in the section on fraud.

Behind the contract sits the statute. Minn. Stat. § 541.05, subd. 1, provides that, “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code otherwise prescribes,” listed actions “shall be commenced within six years.” The list includes an action “upon a contract or other obligation, express or implied, as to which no other limitation is expressly prescribed.” In a case about public pension rights, the Minnesota Court of Appeals, quoting an earlier decision, stated that “A cause of action for breach of contract [generally] accrues at the time of the alleged breach,” and added: “This is true even when actual damages resulting from the breach do not occur until some time afterwards or when the aggrieved party was ignorant of the facts constituting the breach” (Jacobson v. Board of Trustees, 627 N.W.2d 106 (Minn. Ct. App. 2001)). The list also includes an action “for relief on the ground of fraud, in which case the cause of action shall not be deemed to have accrued until the discovery by the aggrieved party of the facts constituting the fraud.” In Peggy Rose, the Minnesota Supreme Court described a fraud claim that had not yet accrued as one brought “before the party knew or reasonably should have known that he or she was harmed by another’s conduct.” For a contract for sale of goods, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725(1) provides: “An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within four years after the cause of action has accrued. By the original agreement the parties may reduce the period of limitation to not less than one year but may not extend it.” Subsection (2) sets when that period starts: “A cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the breach. A breach of warranty occurs when tender of delivery is made, except that where a warranty explicitly extends to future performance of the goods and discovery of the breach must await the time of such performance the cause of action accrues when the breach is or should have been discovered.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.

How Do Third-Party Claims and Control of the Defense Work?

A third-party claim comes from someone outside the deal, such as a customer, a former employee, or a taxing authority. The agreement’s third-party procedure decides who defends it, who chooses the lawyer, and who may settle. Minnesota case law adds a condition, stated in a construction-contract indemnity case. The indemnitor’s obligation to indemnify starts with the indemnitee’s tender of the defense, and the indemnitee’s fees from before the tender may not be recoverable.

The Minnesota Court of Appeals, citing a 1981 Minnesota Supreme Court decision, held: “A tender of defense is a condition precedent to the creation of an obligation to indemnify” (Seifert v. Regents of the University of Minnesota, 505 N.W.2d 83 (Minn. Ct. App. 1993)). In that construction-contract case, the property owner defended an injured worker’s suit for nearly a year before tendering it to the contractor that had agreed to indemnify it. The court held the fees from that year “unrecoverable as a matter of law.” It explained that a contrary rule “would encourage indemnitees to defend claims on their own and then, after fees have been incurred, notify the indemnitor and hold it liable for earlier costs.” The same court, quoting a federal appeals decision, treated defense costs as part of the indemnity: “Legal fees and expenses incurred in defending an indemnified claim are one such cost and thus fall squarely within the obligation to indemnify.”

For a buyer, I suggest tendering the defense in writing as soon as the third-party claim arrives, with a copy of the complaint or demand, because fees spent before the tender may be lost. For a seller, the tender starts a decision the agreement frames: assume the defense or decline and leave the buyer to defend. Assuming it may bring the right to choose counsel and limits on settling without the buyer’s consent. I suggest reading what assuming the defense commits you to before accepting, because some agreements tie assumption to an acknowledgment that the claim is covered. How courts read the indemnity language itself is covered in how Minnesota courts read indemnification clauses.

How Do Baskets, Caps, and Exclusions Change What the Seller Pays?

Baskets, caps, and exclusions reduce a valid claim to the amount the seller actually pays, and the agreement’s own definitions decide each step. Outside a sale of goods, no Minnesota statute changes those numbers in a business purchase agreement. Where the sale is a sale of goods, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-719(3) provides that “Consequential damages may be limited or excluded unless the limitation or exclusion is unconscionable,” and subsection (2) opens the chapter’s remedies when an exclusive or limited remedy fails of its essential purpose. I suggest working through a claim in this order, because each step uses the result of the one before:

  1. Is the loss covered? The facts have to match a specific representation, covenant, or listed liability, and the definition of losses. Some agreements remove a “materiality” qualifier from the representations when measuring a claim.
  2. Does the basket apply? A deductible basket lets the buyer recover only the amount above the threshold. A tipping basket, once crossed, lets the buyer recover from the first dollar.
  3. Is the cap reached? General representations may carry a lower cap than fundamental ones such as title and authority, and a specific indemnity may sit outside the cap.
  4. Do other recoveries reduce the claim? Some agreements reduce losses by insurance proceeds or tax benefits the buyer receives.

How baskets, survival, and the buyer’s knowledge before closing work is the subject of reps and warranties in a Minnesota asset purchase agreement, and the cap is the subject of indemnification caps in small deals.

How Does a Buyer Collect: Escrow, Holdback, or Set-Off?

A buyer collects an indemnification claim from the source the agreement names. That source may be an escrow held by an agent, a holdback kept by the buyer, a set-off against later payments, or the seller directly. Each source has its own procedure, and the agreement may make one of them the only source.

Escrow. The escrow agent is bound by the escrow agreement and pays out only as it allows, such as on joint written instructions from buyer and seller or on a final decision. I suggest sending the claim notice to the agent as well as the seller when the escrow agreement requires it. Some escrow agreements release a claimed amount to the buyer if the seller does not object in time, so the notice to the agent can start that clock. The structure and release terms of these accounts are covered in escrow holdback clauses.

Holdback. When the buyer keeps part of the price, the agreement’s holdback terms decide when the buyer may apply it to a claim and when it must pay the balance to the seller.

Set-off. A buyer may reduce a later payment to the seller as the agreement allows. If part of the price is a seller note, the buyer’s set-off claim and the seller’s response are covered in when the buyer stops paying the seller note. If part of the price is an earnout, the earnout terms decide whether a claim may reduce it.

Direct payment. If the escrow is not the only source and the claim exceeds it, the buyer may pursue the seller for the balance, subject to the cap.

How Can a Seller Dispute an Indemnification Claim?

A seller disputes an indemnification claim by sending a written objection within the agreement’s objection period, stating each ground. Some agreements treat silence as acceptance, which can release escrow funds, so I suggest answering every claim notice in writing even when the claim looks weak. The grounds track the agreement:

  1. The notice was late or deficient. The claim arrived after the claim period, went to the wrong address, or lacked the required contents. A reasonable contractual claim period is enforceable under the rule the Minnesota Supreme Court stated in Peggy Rose, quoted above.
  2. No breach. The representation was true at closing, the disclosure schedule listed the problem, or the loss arose from the buyer’s own operation of the business after closing.
  3. Not a covered loss. The item is excluded by the definition of losses or by a specific exclusion.
  4. Below the basket or above the cap. The claim, alone or with earlier claims, does not exceed the basket, or the cap has been reached.
  5. The defense was not tendered. For a third-party claim, fees incurred before the tender may not be recoverable, as Seifert held in a construction-contract case.

I suggest that a seller preserve the closing files and any records about the disputed item, because the disclosure schedules and the seller’s own records can be the evidence that answers the claim. A seller who receives a third-party lawsuit through the buyer can also accept the defense while reserving the right to dispute coverage, if the agreement allows it.

When Can a Fraud Claim Get Past a Disclaimer or Claim Period?

Two Minnesota appellate decisions let a fraud claim proceed despite contract terms. One got past a settlement agreement’s no-reliance and integration clauses, and the other got past a claim period the court found unreasonable as applied to the fraud. The Minnesota Court of Appeals stated: “The Minnesota Supreme Court has long held that fraud cannot be waived by a contractual disclaimer” (Great Plains Educational Foundation, Inc. v. Student Loan Finance Corp., 954 N.W.2d 844 (Minn. Ct. App. 2020)). Great Plains involved a settlement agreement, not a purchase agreement, and its clauses were no-reliance and integration clauses, not an exclusive-remedy clause. The court held those clauses did not bar a fraud claim as a matter of law. The exception was where “there are express terms in the settlement agreement that contradict the alleged oral misrepresentations.” The case came up on a motion to dismiss, so the court accepted the complaint’s facts as true and sent the case back. For an exclusive-remedy clause, the starting point is the clause’s own words, and a purchase agreement may carve fraud out expressly.

A contractual claim period can also give way for fraud. In Peggy Rose, a separate arbitration agreement signed with a home sale required any claim, including fraud, within a period measured from closing. The Minnesota Supreme Court refused to read in a tolling rule, saying “it is not proper to impose a tolling requirement for claims of fraud where the plain language of the agreement does not suggest that one was contemplated.” It held instead that “an 18-month limitations period measured from the date of a real estate closing is unreasonable as applied to this claim of fraud where undisclosed water problems resulted in structural damage not readily apparent to Buyers.” In a footnote, the court called its decision “fact-specific” and said it was “not intended to diminish the right of private parties to freely contract.”

Minnesota’s statutory discovery rule for a fraud claim is quoted in the section on claim notices.

Where the sale is a sale of goods, Minnesota’s UCC adds its own rule for an exclusive remedy: “resort to a remedy as provided is optional unless the remedy is expressly agreed to be exclusive, in which case it is the sole remedy,” and “Where circumstances cause an exclusive or limited remedy to fail of its essential purpose, remedy may be had as provided in this chapter” (Minn. Stat. § 336.2-719(1)(b), (2)). The claims a buyer can bring when a seller hid a pending lawsuit are covered in failing to disclose a lawsuit when selling a business. When the sale was a buyout among co-owners, release and fraud questions are covered in a former owner suing after a buyout.

How Are Indemnification Disputes Resolved: Mediation, Arbitration, or Suit?

An indemnification dispute goes to the forum the agreement names: a required negotiation or mediation step, then arbitration or a lawsuit in the court the agreement selects. Minnesota statutes govern when a mediated settlement binds and when an arbitration clause will be enforced.

Mediation. A signed mediated settlement agreement does not bind automatically. Minn. Stat. § 572.33, subd. 4, defines that term as “a written agreement setting out the terms of a partial or complete settlement of a controversy identified in an agreement to mediate, signed by the parties, and dated,” and subd. 3 requires a written agreement to mediate that, among other terms, provides for termination “upon written notice from either party or the mediator delivered by certified mail or personally to the other people who signed the agreement” and “is signed by the parties and mediator and is dated.” Under Minn. Stat. § 572.35, subd. 1, a mediated settlement agreement “is not binding unless” one of two conditions is met. The first is that it “contains a provision stating that it is binding” and a provision stating substantially that the parties were advised in writing that “(a) the mediator has no duty to protect their interests or provide them with information about their legal rights; (b) signing a mediated settlement agreement may adversely affect their legal rights; and (c) they should consult an attorney before signing a mediated settlement agreement if they are uncertain of their rights.” The second is that “the parties were otherwise advised of the conditions in clause (1).” When the dispute is between a debtor and a creditor, such as over a seller note, subdivision 2 provides that the agreement “is not binding until 72 hours after it is signed by the debtor and creditor, during which time either party may withdraw consent to the binding character of the agreement.” I suggest that the settlement document carry the subdivision 1 language, because it removes any question about whether the deal binds.

Arbitration. Under Minn. Stat. § 572B.06(a), “An agreement contained in a record to submit to arbitration any existing or subsequent controversy arising between the parties to the agreement is valid, enforceable, and irrevocable except upon a ground that exists at law or in equity for the revocation of contract.” A court decides “whether an agreement to arbitrate exists or a controversy is subject to an agreement to arbitrate,” but “An arbitrator shall decide whether a condition precedent to arbitrability has been fulfilled and whether a contract containing a valid agreement to arbitrate is enforceable” (§ 572B.06(b), (c)). For a written arbitration provision in a contract “evidencing a transaction involving commerce,” the Federal Arbitration Act makes the provision “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, save upon such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract or as otherwise provided in chapter 4” (9 U.S.C. § 2). What happens when one side files suit anyway is governed by Minn. Stat. § 572B.07.

Suit. Without an arbitration clause, the claim goes to the court the agreement selects, or to a court with jurisdiction. Fees follow the agreement. In Seifert, the court held that fees spent establishing the right to indemnity were not recoverable unless the agreement “explicitly states so.” I suggest reading any fee clause before deciding how hard to litigate a modest claim, because those fees may stay with the side that spent them.

What Are the Options for Resolving an Indemnification Claim?

Both sides can have more options than paying in full or litigating. The right one depends on the size of the claim, the strength of the documents, and whether the buyer and seller still deal with each other through consulting, an earnout, or a seller note.

  1. An owner-to-owner conversation. The buyer and seller talk directly before lawyers exchange letters. This fits when the facts are clear and the relationship matters, as when the seller is still owed money or still consulting for the business. The risk is a statement in that conversation later used as an admission, so I suggest keeping the claim notice and the formal objection in writing on their own track.
  2. A negotiated adjustment. The parties agree to release part of the escrow, reduce a note or earnout payment, or extend a consulting term in exchange for a smaller payment. This fits a claim both sides see as partly valid. A written amendment signed by both should state what the adjustment resolves, because an unstated scope invites a second dispute over the same loss.
  3. Mediation. A neutral mediator helps the parties reach terms. This fits when the amount is disputed but both want to avoid the cost of a hearing; a mediated settlement agreement as § 572.33 defines it must meet § 572.35 to bind.
  4. Arbitration or suit. This fits a large claim, a fraud claim, or a party that will not negotiate. It brings the cost of a hearing, and fee recovery depends on the agreement’s terms under the Seifert rule above.
  5. Accepting or dropping the claim. A seller may pay a claim the documents clearly support, and a buyer may drop one the basket or cap makes uneconomic. Either choice can preserve the business relationship and avoid fees larger than the claim.
Can the buyer still make a claim after the survival period ends?

It depends on whether the survival clause limits the time to bring claims, and whether that limit is enforceable. The Minnesota Supreme Court has said parties “may limit the time within which legal claims may be brought provided there is no statute specifically prohibiting the use of a different limitations period in such a case and the time fixed is not unreasonable.” Peggy Rose Revocable Trust v. Eppich, 640 N.W.2d 601 (Minn. 2002) held a claim period in a separate arbitration agreement, running from a home sale’s closing, unreasonable as applied to a fraud whose damage was not readily apparent to the buyers. The agreement’s fraud carve-out may also keep a fraud claim open.

Do I have to pay the other side's attorney fees in an indemnity dispute?

It depends on the agreement. Seifert v. Regents of the University of Minnesota, 505 N.W.2d 83 (Minn. Ct. App. 1993) was a construction-contract case. The Court of Appeals, quoting a federal appeals decision, treated fees for defending an indemnified claim as part of the indemnity “unless the agreement explicitly states otherwise.” It held that fees spent establishing the right to indemnity were not recoverable, and said they could be if the agreement “explicitly states so.” A prevailing-party fee clause in the purchase agreement adds its own rule.

What if the buyer defended a lawsuit for months before telling me?

Fees the buyer incurred “before a formal tender of defense” to you may not be yours to pay. In Seifert v. Regents of the University of Minnesota, 505 N.W.2d 83 (Minn. Ct. App. 1993), a construction-contract case, the Court of Appeals held that “A tender of defense is a condition precedent to the creation of an obligation to indemnify.” It found the fees from the year before the tender “unrecoverable as a matter of law.” The purchase agreement’s notice clause may add its own consequence for late notice.

Can the buyer stop paying my seller note because of an indemnity claim?

The buyer may withhold note payments only if the purchase agreement or the note gives a right of set-off. The buyer must then meet the conditions it states, such as a written claim notice or a dispute process. A proved indemnity claim can still reduce what the buyer owes on a note. How that works, and what to do when payments stop, is covered in when the buyer stops paying the seller note.

Is a mediated settlement binding once we both sign it?

Not always. Minn. Stat. § 572.33, subd. 4, defines a mediated settlement agreement as a written settlement of a controversy identified in an agreement to mediate, signed by the parties, and dated. Under Minn. Stat. § 572.35, subd. 1, such an agreement “is not binding unless” it states that it is binding and contains the written advisements subdivision 1 lists, or “the parties were otherwise advised of the conditions in clause (1).” Under subdivision 2, an agreement between a debtor and creditor “is not binding until 72 hours after it is signed by the debtor and creditor, during which time either party may withdraw consent to the binding character of the agreement.”

Can I go to court if the purchase agreement has an arbitration clause?

You can file, but the other side can move to compel arbitration. Under Minn. Stat. § 572B.07, “Unless the court finds that there is no enforceable agreement to arbitrate, it shall order the parties to arbitrate,” and the court “may not refuse to order arbitration because the claim subject to arbitration lacks merit or grounds for the claim have not been established.” If the court orders arbitration, the court “shall on just terms stay any judicial proceeding that involves a claim subject to the arbitration.”

Post-Closing Indemnification Claims in Minnesota

The purchase agreement decides much of what happens in a post-closing indemnification claim: the notice, the claim period, the basket and cap, where the money comes from, and the forum. Minnesota law adds the frame around it, including the reasonableness limit on shortened claim periods and the tender rule a construction-contract case applied to defense costs. It also includes the limits on contract terms that would bar a fraud claim, covered in the section on fraud, and the conditions for a binding mediated settlement and an enforceable arbitration clause. A timely written claim notice can preserve the buyer’s claim, and a timely written objection can preserve the seller’s defenses. My work on business acquisitions and sales covers the deal documents that set these terms.

If you are making or answering an indemnification claim after a Minnesota business sale and want to know where your claim stands under your agreement, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.