When the original will is lost in Minnesota, the will can still be probated from a copy or from proof of its terms, through a formal court proceeding. An electronic will follows its own rule: under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-518, its certified paper copy may be substituted for an original will when the probate code requires an original. In informal probate, the registrar must find that “an original, duly executed and apparently unrevoked will is in the registrar’s possession,” under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-303, and a will already probated elsewhere follows separate rules. If the decedent was the last person known to have the original and it cannot be found after death, Minnesota courts presume the decedent destroyed it to revoke it. The person offering the copy must then come forward with evidence that the will was not revoked. If no one proves the will, any part of the estate not allowed to the decedent’s spouse or descendants and “not disposed of by will” passes to the heirs by intestate succession, “except as modified by the decedent’s will,” under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-101.
Minnesota’s probate code, chapter 524 of the Minnesota Statutes, sets the filing rules. The presumption of revocation and the evidence that overcomes it come from decisions of the Minnesota Supreme Court and the Minnesota Court of Appeals. This article is written for family members and for the personal representative named in the will. It serves both sides: those who want the copy probated, and those who would inherit if it is not. For how I handle these disputes, see my trust and estate litigation page.
What Does Minnesota Law Presume When the Original Will Is Missing?
Minnesota law presumes that a missing will was revoked when the decedent was the last person known to have it. In Matter of Estate of Langlie, 355 N.W.2d 732 (Minn. Ct. App. 1984), the Court of Appeals described “a common law presumption that a lost will possessed by a testator has been destroyed.” The testator is the person who made the will.
The presumption has two conditions. In In re Estate of Botko, 541 N.W.2d 616 (Minn. Ct. App. 1996), the court summarized an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision as “stating that under common law, a lost will is presumed revoked if (1) at the time the will was last seen, it was in the testator’s possession, and (2) the will cannot be located after the testator’s death.” That earlier decision, In re Estate of Pundt, 157 N.W.2d 839 (Minn. 1968), refused to apply the presumption where no one showed the testator ever had the will: “Thus the requisite proof that a copy of the will remained in the possession of Herman is missing, and the rule cannot apply.” In Pundt, the copy was found in the late drafting attorney’s office.
The presumption matters because destroying a will is one way to revoke it. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-507, a will is revoked “by performing a revocatory act, if the testator performed the act with the intent and for the purpose of revoking the will or part or if another individual performed the act in the testator’s conscious presence and by the testator’s direction.” The statute adds: “For purposes of this clause, ‘revocatory act’ includes burning, tearing, canceling, obliterating, or destroying the will or any part of it.” A will is also revoked “by executing a subsequent will that revokes the previous will or part expressly or by inconsistency.” So the first question in any lost-will case is who last had the original.
Where Should You Look for the Original Will?
The places to search are the decedent’s home and papers, the lawyer who drafted the will, the district court, and any safe deposit box. In Botko, the trial court listed the search the family had done: “searching the home of the decedent and her personal papers, inquiring of the attorney who drew the will, searching the will depository at the courthouse and a further extensive search of the premises.” The trial court relied on that search, among its other findings, in deciding the copy could not be probated.
The court. A person may leave a will with a court while alive. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-515, “A will may be deposited by the testator or the testator’s agent with any court for safekeeping, under rules of the court. The will must be sealed and kept confidential.” The statute also provides: “Upon being informed of the testator’s death, the court may deliver the will to the appropriate court.” Each county court sets its own procedure. In Hennepin County, the court’s wills page covers a testator who died while living in the county where the will is deposited. There, an interested party may get a copy by filing a Petition for Copy of Will for Safekeeping and a certified death certificate.
The drafting attorney, a bank, or a relative. After the death, anyone holding the original must turn it over to a court on request. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-516, “After the death of a testator and on request of an interested person, a person having custody of a will of the testator shall deliver it with reasonable promptness to an appropriate court. A person who willfully fails to deliver a will is liable to any person aggrieved for any damages that may be sustained by the failure.” In one inquiry I received, an executor of a relative’s estate wrote that the trust company that had handled the relative’s finances could not find the original will and was stalling. If the holder is the personal representative already appointed, see remedies for executor misconduct.
Even when the search fails, the attorney’s file may hold a signed copy or a conformed copy, which is a copy marked to show who signed and when. In Langlie, the decedent’s longtime attorney furnished conformed copies of the will and codicil after the originals were not found in the safe deposit box.
How Does a Safe Deposit Box Will Search Work in Minnesota?
A Minnesota safe deposit company must open the box of a deceased sole or last surviving renter for a will search when an interested person appears in person with proof of death and an affidavit. The exceptions are in the FAQ below. Under Minn. Stat. § 55.10, subd. 4, “Upon being furnished with satisfactory proof of death of a sole lessee or the last surviving co-lessee of a safe deposit box, an employee of the safe deposit company shall open the box and examine the contents in the presence of an individual who appears in person and furnishes an affidavit stating that the individual believes” the box may hold a will, burial papers, or estate property. The affiant must be an interested person as the subdivision defines it. That list includes a person named as personal representative in a purported will, the surviving spouse, a devisee (a person who receives property under the will), and an heir.
The bank does not hand the will to the family. If the box holds a will, “the safe deposit company shall remove any document that appears to be a will and make a true and correct machine copy thereof, replace the copy in the box, and then deliver the original thereof to the clerk of court for the county in which the lessee resided immediately before the lessee’s death, if known to the safe deposit company, otherwise to the clerk of the court for the county in which the safe deposit box is located.” Nothing else leaves the box this way: “No contents of a box other than a will and a document required to facilitate the lessee’s wishes regarding body, funeral, or burial arrangements may be removed pursuant to this subdivision.” When a co-owner of the box is still living, this subdivision does not apply, because it covers only a sole or last surviving lessee.
How Do You Probate a Copy of a Lost Will in Minnesota?
A copy of a lost will is probated in a formal proceeding before a judge, because informal probate requires the original. A will already probated in another state follows separate rules. In informal probate, the registrar must find that “an original, duly executed and apparently unrevoked will is in the registrar’s possession,” under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-303, paragraph (a)(5). With only a copy, that finding cannot be made. The rule differs for an electronic will: under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-518, “A certified paper copy of an electronic will may be substituted for an original will when an original will is required by this chapter.”
The formal petition must say the will is missing and what it said. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-402, paragraph (a), “If the original will is neither in the possession of the court nor accompanies the petition and no authenticated copy of a will probated in another jurisdiction accompanies the petition, the petition also shall state the contents of the will, and indicate that it is lost, destroyed, or otherwise unavailable.” The court’s form for this is the Statement of Contents of Lost, Destroyed, or Otherwise Unavailable Will (PRO1206). On it, the petitioner says why the original is unavailable and either attaches a true copy or writes out the will’s terms, signed under penalty of perjury.
The family then gets notice that the will may be lost. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-403, “The petitioner, having reason to believe that the will has been lost or destroyed, shall include a statement to that effect in the notice.” Notice goes to “the surviving spouse, children, and other heirs of the decedent, the devisees and personal representatives named in any will that is being or has been probated,” among others. An heir who believes the will was revoked can object in that proceeding. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-404, “Any party to a formal proceeding who opposes the probate of a will for any reason shall state in pleadings the objections to probate of the will.” Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-405, “If a petition in a testacy proceeding is unopposed, the court may order probate or intestacy on the strength of the pleadings if satisfied that the conditions of section 524.3-409 have been met, or conduct a hearing in open court and require proof of the matters necessary to support the order sought.”
A copy kept outside court does not transfer property on its own. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-102, with narrow exceptions, “to be effective to prove the transfer of any property, to nominate an executor or to exercise a power of appointment, a will must be declared to be valid by an order of informal probate by the registrar, or an adjudication of probate by the court in a formal proceeding or proceedings to determine descent.” Probate also has an outer time limit. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-108, “No informal probate or appointment proceeding or formal testacy or appointment proceeding, other than a proceeding to probate a will previously probated at the testator’s domicile and appointment proceedings relating to an estate in which there has been a prior appointment, may be commenced more than three years after the decedent’s death,” except in situations the statute lists. The same section adds: “These limitations do not apply to proceedings to construe probated wills, determine heirs of an intestate, or proceedings to determine descent.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. The exceptions are covered in the deadlines to contest a will or trust in Minnesota.
What Evidence Overcomes the Presumption That the Will Was Revoked?
Evidence that the decedent did not revoke the will, such as statements confirming it after it went missing, can overcome the presumption, and evidence that someone else last had the original keeps it from arising. The standard is a preponderance, meaning more likely than not. In Langlie, the court stated: “Neither statutes nor appellate decisions in Minnesota impose on the proponent a burden greater than proof by a preponderance of the evidence.”
The burden moves between the sides. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-407, “Proponents of a will have the burden of establishing prima facie proof of due execution in all cases,” and “Contestants of a will have the burden of establishing lack of testamentary intent or capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress, mistake or revocation.” Langlie explained how the presumption fits that statute: “The contestant must prove revocation, but evidence of loss of a will possessed by the testator switches to the proponent the burden to go forward with evidence. A prima facie showing of nonrevocation compels admission to probate unless it does not preponderate over evidence offered by contestant, who has the ultimate burden of persuasion on revocation.” The proponent also proves the will was properly signed, which turns on what a valid Minnesota will requires.
The cases show which evidence worked:
- Statements after the loss. In Langlie, the decedent confirmed the will’s terms after the originals could not be found. The court, relying on an earlier Minnesota Supreme Court decision, treated those statements as competent evidence that the will was not revoked.
- Terms that make sense. In Langlie, the will matched earlier wills and the decedent’s family relationships. In In re Estate of Carlson, 384 N.W.2d 239 (Minn. Ct. App. 1986), the widow testified she knew of no revocation, and the division of property did not appear unreasonable. That was enough: “Respondent wife made a prima facie showing of nonrevocation.”
- Time to replace the will. Langlie, citing a Wisconsin decision, stated: “When a testator has knowledge a will is lost, inaction may show revocation, but only where circumstances reasonably enable the testator to replace the will.” There, the Court of Appeals upheld a trial court that gave little weight to an 85-year-old’s failure to sign a new will during his final illness.
The presumption alone does not defeat a prima facie showing. In Carlson, the heirs opposing the copy “offered no such proof, but instead rely solely on the common law presumption of revocation of a lost will. Such reliance is insufficient.” The reverse also holds: in Botko, the only testimony offered for nonrevocation was that the will was fair, and the court affirmed a finding that the will was revoked.
What Happens to the Estate If the Lost Will Is Not Proved?
If the court does not probate the lost will, Minnesota’s intestacy rules apply to any part of the estate not disposed of by another valid will, such as an earlier will. The heirs take any part of the estate not allowed to the decedent’s spouse or descendants and not disposed of by will. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-101, “The intestate estate of the decedent consists of any part of the decedent’s estate not allowed to the decedent’s spouse or descendants under sections 524.2-402, 524.2-403, and 524.2-404, and not disposed of by will. The intestate estate passes by intestate succession to the decedent’s heirs as prescribed in this chapter, except as modified by the decedent’s will.” In Botko, that is what happened: the court adjudicated intestacy, named the decedent’s nieces and nephew as heirs, and refused the photocopy.
An earlier will that the lost will wholly revoked does not simply return: under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-509, when the later will is revoked by a revocatory act, “the previous will remains revoked unless it is revived. The previous will is revived if it is evident from the circumstances of the revocation of the subsequent will or from the testator’s contemporary or subsequent declarations that the testator intended the previous will to take effect as executed.” An earlier will that the lost will only partly revoked is treated differently: under paragraph (b) of that section, “If a subsequent will that partly revoked a previous will is thereafter revoked by a revocatory act under section 524.2-507, paragraph (a), clause (2), a revoked part of the previous will is revived unless it is evident from the circumstances of the revocation of the subsequent will or from the testator’s contemporary or subsequent declarations that the testator did not intend the revoked part to take effect as executed.”
The heirs’ shares depend on whether a spouse and children survive, and are covered in how Minnesota probate works. A friend or a charity named in the copy is not an heir, so it takes no part of the intestate estate. An heir the copy left out may receive an intestate share.
A lost will can also be challenged on other grounds, such as pressure on the decedent when it was signed. The procedure for objecting in a formal proceeding is covered in contesting a will for undue influence.
What Are the Options When the Family Disagrees About a Missing Will?
The options run from a family conversation to a contested hearing, and the right one depends on how far apart the family is and what the estate holds. Each carries a different cost and risk:
- A direct conversation among the heirs and the people named in the copy. This fits when everyone accepts the copy as what the decedent wanted. Its risk is an informal understanding that one person later disputes.
- A written agreement. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-912, “Subject to the rights of creditors and taxing authorities, competent successors may agree among themselves to alter the interests, shares, or amounts to which they are entitled under the will of the decedent, or under the laws of intestacy, in any way that they provide in a written contract executed by all who are affected by its provisions.” An agreement can divide the estate as the copy did, or on other terms, without a trial over revocation. It requires a written contract signed by all who are affected, and the statute reaches only competent successors, so one holdout can prevent it. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-1101, “A compromise of any controversy as to admission to probate of any instrument offered for formal probate as the will of a decedent,” among other disputes, “if approved in a formal proceeding in the court for that purpose, is binding on all the parties thereto including those unborn, unascertained or who could not be located.” Court approval still starts with a signed agreement: under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-1102, paragraph (1), the compromise “shall be set forth in an agreement in writing which shall be executed by all competent persons and parents acting for any minor child having beneficial interests or having claims which will or may be affected by the compromise,” and “Execution is not required by any person whose identity cannot be ascertained or whose whereabouts is unknown and cannot reasonably be ascertained.”
- A request to the person who may hold the original. A written request to the drafting attorney, the bank, or a relative may end the problem if the original turns up. The § 524.2-516 duty supports the request.
- A formal probate hearing on the copy. This fits when the family cannot agree. The proponent brings evidence of the decedent’s statements, the will’s terms, and who last had the original, and the contestant keeps the ultimate burden on revocation. Its cost is time and legal fees, and the outcome turns on the evidence about who last had the original and whether the decedent revoked the will. Some of those fees can come from the estate: under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-720, “Any personal representative or person nominated as personal representative who defends or prosecutes any proceeding in good faith, whether successful or not, or any interested person who successfully opposes the allowance of a will, is entitled to receive from the estate necessary expenses and disbursements including reasonable attorneys’ fees incurred.”
I suggest gathering the evidence of who last had the original and what the decedent said about the will before choosing among these options. The reason is that the hearing turns on that evidence, and so does each side’s view of a fair settlement.
What if the drafting attorney or a relative has the original and will not hand it over?
The holder has a legal duty to deliver it. Under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-516, “After the death of a testator and on request of an interested person, a person having custody of a will of the testator shall deliver it with reasonable promptness to an appropriate court.” A person who willfully fails to deliver it is liable for the damages that failure causes. And “A person who willfully refuses or fails to deliver a will after being ordered by the court in a proceeding brought for the purpose of compelling delivery is subject to penalty for contempt of court.” I suggest a dated written request, because the duty arises on request.
Does a photocopy found in the decedent's papers prove the will was not revoked?
A photocopy alone does not prove it. In In re Estate of Botko (Minn. Ct. App. 1996), a photocopy was found among the decedent’s papers, and searches of the home, the drafting attorney, and the courthouse will depository never found the original. The court stated that “the law permits an inference of revocability when an original will is not produced and the record shows no evidence that the original will was kept by someone other than decedent,” and affirmed the refusal to probate the copy. The proponents’ testimony that the will was fair “did not reflect testator’s subsequent intentions.”
Is there a deadline to probate a lost will in Minnesota?
Yes, with exceptions. Minn. Stat. § 524.3-108 provides that “No informal probate or appointment proceeding or formal testacy or appointment proceeding, other than a proceeding to probate a will previously probated at the testator’s domicile and appointment proceedings relating to an estate in which there has been a prior appointment, may be commenced more than three years after the decedent’s death.” The statute lists exceptions, which this site’s page on deadlines to contest a will or trust in Minnesota covers. The statute adds: “These limitations do not apply to proceedings to construe probated wills, determine heirs of an intestate, or proceedings to determine descent.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods.
Can the bank refuse to open the safe deposit box for a will search?
Yes, in situations Minn. Stat. § 55.10, subd. 4 names. The company need not open the box if it was already opened for the same purpose, if it “has received notice of a written or oral objection from any person or has reason to believe that there would be an objection,” or if “the lessee’s key or combination is not available.” It “may not open the box under this section if it has received a copy of letters of office of the representative of the deceased lessee’s estate or other applicable court order.” And it “may decline to open the box” if it is not satisfied the statute’s requirements are met.
What if the original will turns up after the estate was settled without it?
Whoever holds the found original must deliver it “with reasonable promptness to an appropriate court” on request of an interested person, under Minn. Stat. § 524.2-516. Whether it can still be probated depends on what has already happened in court and when. This site’s page on deadlines to contest a will or trust in Minnesota quotes the rules for reopening a court order for a later-found will and describes their time limits. I suggest reading them as soon as the original is found, because those limits keep running.
Next Steps When a Minnesota Original Will Is Missing
The first questions in a lost-will case are who last had the original and what the decedent said and did after that. If the decedent last had it, Minnesota courts presume revocation, and the copy can be probated in a formal proceeding. The showing includes a statement of its contents, “prima facie proof of due execution” under Minn. Stat. § 524.3-407, and evidence that the will was not revoked. Without a proved will, the intestacy rules of Minn. Stat. § 524.2-101 reach whatever part of the estate is “not disposed of by will” and not allowed to the decedent’s spouse or descendants. That part passes to the heirs “except as modified by the decedent’s will.” More on how I handle these cases is on my trust and estate litigation page.
If you are an heir, a person named in the will, or the named personal representative, email [email protected] with a brief description of the copy you have and where the original was last seen. I start with an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.