A patent infringement letter is a demand, not a court order or a lawsuit, and your business has time to choose how to answer it. The letter can still change your exposure. It can start damages running on some patents, and it tells a court what your business knew. Before anyone replies, I suggest reading the patent, identifying who sent the letter, tendering the claim to anyone who owes you a defense, and preserving your records. Then you can choose among the responses, from saying nothing to asking the Patent Office to cancel the patent’s claims.
Federal patent law decides whether your product infringes and what a patent owner can recover. Minnesota adds two layers. Minn. Stat. § 325D.72 prohibits a bad-faith patent claim sent in a written or electronic communication to an end user located or doing business in Minnesota. The statute limits an end user to one accused over its own use of something it obtained not for resale. Unless otherwise agreed, the Minnesota Uniform Commercial Code makes a seller that is a merchant regularly dealing in goods of the kind answerable for some infringement claims against the buyer. Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725 limits when a suit on that warranty may be brought, even if the buyer does not know of the breach. Its text is under How Do You Tender a Patent Claim to a Supplier or Insurer?
This page is written for owners of Minnesota businesses that received a letter accusing a product or process of infringing a patent and demanding a license fee or that the business stop. My page on how to respond to a demand letter covers the steps that apply to any demand letter, and this page is part of my material on business litigation in Minnesota.
What Does a Patent Infringement Letter Change About Your Exposure?
A patent letter is not a lawsuit, but it can start damages running and it gives your business knowledge a court can weigh. For a patented product that was not marked in a way 35 U.S.C. § 287(a) allows, damages can be recovered only for infringement after notice. Section 287(a) allows marking with “patent” or “pat.” and the patent number, or with “patent” or “pat.” and a free Internet address that ties the product to the number. When the product cannot be marked, a label on it or its package can carry the notice. A letter can be that notice when it identifies the patent and the activity believed to infringe, not merely the patent’s existence or ownership. What your business knew and did after the letter can also bear on whether a court multiplies damages.
Damages and notice. If the patent owner wins, 35 U.S.C. § 284 requires “damages adequate to compensate for the infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty for the use made of the invention by the infringer, together with interest and costs as fixed by the court.” 35 U.S.C. § 287(a) lets a patent owner, and those making or selling a “patented article for or under them,” give notice that the article is patented “either by fixing thereon the word ‘patent’ or the abbreviation ‘pat.’, together with the number of the patent, or by fixing thereon the word ‘patent’ or the abbreviation ‘pat.’ together with an address of a posting on the Internet, accessible to the public without charge for accessing the address, that associates the patented article with the number of the patent, or when, from the character of the article, this can not be done, by fixing to it, or to the package wherein one or more of them is contained, a label containing a like notice.” It then provides: “In the event of failure so to mark, no damages shall be recovered by the patentee in any action for infringement, except on proof that the infringer was notified of the infringement and continued to infringe thereafter, in which event damages may be recovered only for infringement occurring after such notice. Filing of an action for infringement shall constitute such notice.”
What makes a letter notice. In Amsted Industries Inc. v. Buckeye Steel Castings Co., 24 F.3d 178 (Fed. Cir. 1994), the court held that notice under § 287(a) “must be of ’the infringement,’ not merely notice of the patent’s existence or ownership,” and that “Actual notice requires the affirmative communication of a specific charge of infringement by a specific accused product or device.” A later decision, SRI International, Inc. v. Advanced Technology Laboratories, Inc., 127 F.3d 1462 (Fed. Cir. 1997), held that the requirement “is satisfied when the recipient is informed of the identity of the patent and the activity that is believed to be an infringement, accompanied by a proposal to abate the infringement, whether by license or otherwise,” and that “It is not controlling whether the patentee threatens suit, demands cessation of infringement, or offers a license under the patent.”
Products made by a patented process. Section 287(b) sets separate rules for these products. Under § 287(b)(2), “No remedies for infringement under section 271(g) shall be available with respect to any product in the possession of, or in transit to, the person subject to liability under such section before that person had notice of infringement with respect to that product.” Under § 287(b)(5)(B), a written notification charging infringement “shall specify the patented process alleged to have been used and the reasons for a good faith belief that such process was used.” Under § 287(b)(5)(C), a business that receives that notification “shall be deemed to have notice of infringement with respect to any patent referred to in such written notification or response unless that person, absent mitigating circumstances” both “promptly transmits the written notification or response to the manufacturer or, if the manufacturer is not known, to the supplier, of the product purchased or to be purchased by that person” and “receives a written statement from the manufacturer or supplier which on its face sets forth a well grounded factual basis for a belief that the identified patents are not infringed.” Under § 287(b)(1), these modified remedies “shall not be available to any person who” practiced the patented process, owns or controls or is owned or controlled by the person who did, or “had knowledge before the infringement that a patented process was used to make the product the importation, use, offer for sale, or sale of which constitutes the infringement.”
How far back damages reach. Under 35 U.S.C. § 286, “Except as otherwise provided by law, no recovery shall be had for any infringement committed more than six years prior to the filing of the complaint or counterclaim for infringement in the action.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on this period.
Multiplied damages. 35 U.S.C. § 284 also provides that “the court may increase the damages up to three times the amount found or assessed.” In Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., 579 U.S. 93 (2016), two cases the Supreme Court decided together, the Court rejected a rigid lower-court test for increasing damages. It said “such punishment should generally be reserved for egregious cases typified by willful misconduct,” and that “culpability is generally measured against the knowledge of the actor at the time of the challenged conduct.” Three justices, concurring, wrote that the Court’s references to willful misconduct “do not mean that a court may award enhanced damages simply because the evidence shows that the infringer knew about the patent and nothing more.”
Advice of counsel. Not obtaining a written opinion of counsel cannot be used to prove willful infringement. Under 35 U.S.C. § 298, “The failure of an infringer to obtain the advice of counsel with respect to any allegedly infringed patent, or the failure of the infringer to present such advice to the court or jury, may not be used to prove that the accused infringer willfully infringed the patent or that the infringer intended to induce infringement of the patent.”
Attorney fees. Under 35 U.S.C. § 285, “The court in exceptional cases may award reasonable attorney fees to the prevailing party.” The statute does not limit the award to the patent owner, so in an exceptional case the sender can be ordered to pay your business’s reasonable attorney fees if your business prevails.
What Should You Do in the First Weeks After a Patent Letter Arrives?
In the first weeks after a patent letter arrives, I suggest five steps before any reply, because each keeps a later option open. The steps are calendaring the letter’s date, preserving records, finding every contract and policy that could shift the claim, gathering facts about the accused product, and choosing one person to speak for the business. None of the five steps requires a reply to the sender.
- Calendar the date. I suggest recording the date on the letter, the date it arrived, and how it arrived. The response date it names is the sender’s request, but the arrival date can matter to the notice rules for damages.
- Preserve the records. I suggest keeping the product’s design files, source code, supplier specifications, purchase records, and sales figures, and pausing any automatic deletion that would reach them. My page on how missing emails can become spoliation explains what deleting them after a dispute is foreseeable can cost.
- Find who might share the claim. I suggest pulling every supply agreement, purchase order, license, and insurance policy that touches the accused product, because a supplier or insurer may owe your business a defense. I cover the notice each one may require under How Do You Tender a Patent Claim to a Supplier or Insurer?
- Gather the product facts. I suggest writing down when the business started making, selling, or using the accused feature, which supplier provided it, and the U.S. sales of products that include it. Those facts set the realistic size of the claim.
- Choose one voice. I suggest that one person write and speak for the business about the letter. I also suggest that no one reply in the first days, because an early reply written without these facts can concede points the business would otherwise dispute.
How Do You Read a Patent Infringement Letter?
To read a patent infringement letter, find four things: the patent number, who claims the right to enforce it, the product or activity accused, and what the sender wants. I then suggest checking the patent itself, because the letter’s description of it is the sender’s argument and the patent’s text is what a court reads. The claims, the owner, and the status are the three checks listed below.
Direct infringement. Under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a), “Except as otherwise provided in this title, whoever without authority makes, uses, offers to sell, or sells any patented invention, within the United States or imports into the United States any patented invention during the term of the patent therefor, infringes the patent.” That is why a business that only uses a purchased scanner, network, or software feature can receive a letter, and why a letter about activity after the patent expired describes no infringement.
Other ways to infringe. Section 271(a) is not the only way to infringe. Under § 271(b), “Whoever actively induces infringement of a patent shall be liable as an infringer.” In Global-Tech Appliances, Inc. v. SEB S.A., 563 U.S. 754 (2011), the Supreme Court held that “induced infringement under §271(b) requires knowledge that the induced acts constitute patent infringement.” The Court also applied the doctrine of willful blindness to that knowledge, seeing “no reason why the doctrine should not apply in civil lawsuits for induced patent infringement.” Under § 271(g), “Whoever without authority imports into the United States or offers to sell, sells, or uses within the United States a product which is made by a process patented in the United States shall be liable as an infringer, if the importation, offer to sell, sale, or use of the product occurs during the term of such process patent.” The same subsection provides that “no remedy may be granted for infringement on account of the noncommercial use or retail sale of a product unless there is no adequate remedy under this title for infringement on account of the importation or other use, offer to sell, or sale of that product,” and that a product is not considered made by the process after “(1) it is materially changed by subsequent processes; or (2) it becomes a trivial and nonessential component of another product.” The notice rules for these products differ from § 287(a)’s.
What to check in the patent.
- The claims. The numbered claims at the end of the patent are what the letter must match to your product. I suggest noting which claims the letter names, and whether it includes a chart comparing your product to those claims.
- The owner. Under 35 U.S.C. § 261, “The Patent and Trademark Office shall maintain a register of interests in patents and applications for patents and shall record any document related thereto upon request.” The Office’s public assignment records show who has recorded an interest in the patent, which you can compare with the sender’s name. Because the Office records a document “upon request,” a sender missing from it is a question to put to the sender rather than proof that it lacks the right.
- The status. I suggest checking whether the patent has expired or has been held invalid or unenforceable, since each one bears on the claim and on Minnesota’s bad-faith statute.
What the patent is worth on paper. Under 35 U.S.C. § 282(a), “A patent shall be presumed valid,” and “The burden of establishing invalidity of a patent or any claim thereof shall rest on the party asserting such invalidity.” A weak-looking patent therefore stays enforceable until someone proves otherwise: in court by clear and convincing evidence, and in an inter partes review by a preponderance of the evidence, as the validity analysis explains.
How Does the Sender Change Your Response?
The sender’s business model shapes what the letter is really asking for. A competitor that makes products under the patent may want your product off the market more than it wants a fee. A patent assertion entity is a company whose business is licensing or suing on patents rather than making products. Its revenue comes from license payments, so a fee is what its letter is built to obtain, and it may send similar letters to many businesses.
The difference matters in three ways.
- The likely resolution. A license fee can be the realistic end point with a patent assertion entity, so the price compared with the cost of a defense drives the decision. With a competitor, a design change, a narrower license, or a direct conversation between the two owners can sometimes resolve what a fee cannot.
- Who else is affected. A letter sent to many users of the same product can mean the product’s maker, which may owe your business a defense, has received a claim too.
- Minnesota’s statute. Minn. Stat. § 325D.72, subd. 4(b), says the section does not apply to a communication “sent by any owner of a patent who has engaged in substantial research, commercial development, production, manufacturing, processing, or delivery of products or materials related to the patent or substantially similar patents.” A letter from a competitor that makes products under the patent falls outside the statute when the competitor meets that description.
When Is a Patent Letter a Bad-Faith Claim Under Minnesota Law?
Minnesota prohibits sending a bad-faith patent claim to an end user located or doing business in Minnesota. A letter is a bad-faith claim when it claims that the end user or a person affiliated with it infringed a patent and is liable for that infringement. It must also meet any one of five listed conditions, and subdivision 4 excludes some senders and letters. An end user is a person, business, or financial institution accused because of its use of a product, service, or technology it obtained not for resale. Only the attorney general can sue under the statute.
Who it protects. Minn. Stat. § 325D.72, subd. 2(a), provides: “A person may not send to an end user located or doing business in this state a written or electronic communication that is a bad faith claim of patent infringement.” Subdivision 1 defines an end user as a person “that purchases, rents, leases, or otherwise obtains a product, service, or technology in the commercial market that is not for resale and that is, or later becomes, the subject of a patent infringement assertion due to the person’s use of the product, service, or technology.” A business accused of making or reselling the product is outside that definition.
What makes a claim bad faith. Under subd. 2(b), the letter must claim that “the end user or a person affiliated with the end user has infringed a patent and is liable for that infringement,” plus any one of these:
- It “falsely states that the sender has filed a lawsuit in connection with the claim.”
- “the sender or a person the sender represents does not have a current right to license the patent to or enforce the patent against the end user.”
- “the patent has been held invalid or unenforceable in a final judgment or administrative decision.”
- “the infringing activity alleged in the communication occurred after the patent expired.”
- It “is likely to materially mislead a reasonable end user because the communication does not contain information sufficient to inform the end user of” the identity of the person asserting the claim, the patent, and “at least one product, service, or technology obtained by the end user that is alleged to infringe the patent or the activity of the end user that is alleged to infringe the patent.”
What it allows. Subd. 4(a) says the section does not prohibit “a person who owns or has a right to license or enforce a patent from notifying others of the person’s ownership or right; offering the patent to others for license or sale; notifying any person of the person’s infringement of the patent as provided by United States Code, title 35, section 287; or seeking compensation for past or present infringement of the patent or for a license to the patent.” It also does not apply to “a person who has demonstrated good faith business practices in previous efforts to enforce the patent, or a substantially similar patent, or who has successfully enforced the patent, or a substantially similar patent, through litigation.” Subd. 4(b) excludes letters sent by a patent owner that meets the subd. 4(b)(1) description quoted under How Does the Sender Change Your Response? It also excludes letters sent by an institution of higher education, a 501(c)(3) charitable institution, or a technology transfer organization whose primary purpose is to facilitate the commercialization of technology either one developed. Letters about certain drug and biologic claims are excluded too.
Who enforces it. Under subd. 3, “If the attorney general believes that a person has violated or is violating this section, the attorney general may bring an action on behalf of the state to enjoin the person from violating this section.” The court may also order relief including “the imposition of a civil penalty in an amount not to exceed $50,000 for each violation of subdivision 2” and “an order requiring restitution to a victim for legal and professional expenses related to the violation.” Subd. 5 adds: “This section does not create a private cause of action for a violation of subdivision 2.”
How Do You Tender a Patent Claim to a Supplier or Insurer?
To tender a patent claim, send a copy of the letter to each supplier and insurer that may owe your business a defense, with a written request that it defend and indemnify the business. For goods bought from a seller that is a merchant regularly dealing in goods of the kind, Minnesota’s Uniform Commercial Code supplies a warranty against infringement unless otherwise agreed. A buyer that furnished specifications must hold the seller harmless against a claim that arises out of compliance with those specifications, and the contract and policy terms decide the rest. I suggest reading Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725, quoted below, before relying on the warranty. It limits when a suit on the warranty may be brought, even if the buyer does not know of the breach. I also suggest asking the manufacturer or supplier of a product made by a patented process for the written statement 35 U.S.C. § 287(b)(5)(C) describes. Without that statement, the business may be deemed to have notice of infringement.
The seller’s warranty. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.2-312(3), “Unless otherwise agreed a seller who is a merchant regularly dealing in goods of the kind warrants that the goods shall be delivered free of the rightful claim of any third person by way of infringement or the like but a buyer who furnishes specifications to the seller must hold the seller harmless against any such claim which arises out of compliance with the specifications.” The warranty can be changed by agreement. When your business furnished the specifications, as with a product a manufacturer builds to them, your business must hold the seller harmless against a claim “which arises out of compliance with the specifications.” My page on IP conflicts in white-labeled products covers that arrangement.
The notice the buyer owes. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.2-607(3), after accepting goods “the buyer must within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered any breach notify the seller of breach or be barred from any remedy.” For an infringement claim, if “the buyer is sued as a result of such a breach the buyer must so notify the seller within a reasonable time after receiving notice of the litigation or be barred from any remedy over for liability established by the litigation.” I suggest giving written notice when the letter arrives rather than waiting for a lawsuit, because the seller then has the most time to respond.
The time to sue the seller. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725(1), “An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within four years after the cause of action has accrued. By the original agreement the parties may reduce the period of limitation to not less than one year but may not extend it.” Under § 336.2-725(2), “A cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the breach. A breach of warranty occurs when tender of delivery is made, except that where a warranty explicitly extends to future performance of the goods and discovery of the breach must await the time of such performance the cause of action accrues when the breach is or should have been discovered.” Check the current text of section 336.2-725 before relying on these periods.
The seller’s right to take over. Section 336.2-607(5) applies “Where the buyer is sued for breach of a warranty or other obligation for which the buyer’s seller is answerable over.” For an infringement claim, § 336.2-607(5)(b) provides that “the original seller may demand in writing that the original seller’s buyer turn over control of the litigation including settlement or else be barred from any remedy over.” When the seller “also agrees to bear all expense and to satisfy any adverse judgment,” a buyer that does not turn over control “after seasonable receipt of the demand” is “so barred.” Subsection (6) applies the same rules to a buyer’s duty to hold its seller harmless.
Contracts and policies. A supply, software, or license agreement can vary these rules with its own indemnity clause, notice deadline, and control terms, within limits. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.1-302(b), “The obligations of good faith, diligence, reasonableness, and care prescribed by the Uniform Commercial Code may not be disclaimed by agreement,” and “Whenever the Uniform Commercial Code requires an action to be taken within a reasonable time, a time that is not manifestly unreasonable may be fixed by agreement.” Minn. Stat. § 336.2-719 governs contract terms that limit or replace the buyer’s remedies for goods. My page on IP indemnity in SaaS agreements covers how those clauses are written. For insurance, the policy’s definition of a claim and its notice condition decide whether and when to report. My page on what to do when an insurer denies a business claim covers the next step if coverage is refused.
What Are Your Options for Responding to a Patent Letter?
You have at least eight ways to respond to a patent letter, legal and business, and several can be combined. I suggest choosing by the outcome you want most, such as keeping the product on the market, paying as little as possible, or ending the dispute quickly, because each route serves those goals differently. The eight routes below run from no reply to a declaratory judgment action in federal court.
- No reply. Silence can fit a vague letter from a sender with no apparent intent to sue. Its cost is that the sender’s account stays the only written one, and a letter that identifies the patent and the activity believed to infringe may still serve as notice.
- A written reply asking for the theory. A short reply can ask the sender to identify the claims it relies on and to explain how your product meets them, without conceding anything. The sender’s answer shows how much analysis stands behind the letter.
- A business conversation. With a competitor, a direct conversation between owners can surface a business fix, such as a supply or co-marketing arrangement, that a letter exchange would not.
- A license. Paying for a license fits when the price is below the cost of a defense and the analysis shows real risk. The FAQ below covers the terms to confirm before signing.
- A design change. Changing the accused feature so it no longer matches the patent’s claims can end future exposure, although it does not resolve past sales.
- Stopping the product. Stopping can fit a low-margin product, and like a design change it addresses only future sales.
- An inter partes review. Under 35 U.S.C. § 311(a), “Subject to the provisions of this chapter, a person who is not the owner of a patent may file with the Office a petition to institute an inter partes review of the patent.” Under § 311(c), “A petition for inter partes review shall be filed after the later of either . . . the date that is 9 months after the grant of a patent; or . . . if a post-grant review is instituted under chapter 32, the date of the termination of such post-grant review.” A 2013 law, Pub. L. 112-274, § 1(d)(1), provides that “Section 311(c) of title 35, United States Code, shall not apply to a petition to institute an inter partes review of a patent that is not a patent described in section 3(n)(1) of the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act.” Under § 311(b), the petitioner “may request to cancel as unpatentable 1 or more claims of a patent only on a ground that could be raised under section 102 or 103 and only on the basis of prior art consisting of patents or printed publications,” meaning earlier patents and publications showing the invention was not new or was obvious. Under 35 U.S.C. § 315(a)(1), a review “may not be instituted if, before the date on which the petition for such a review is filed, the petitioner or real party in interest filed a civil action challenging the validity of a claim of the patent.” Under § 315(a)(3), “A counterclaim challenging the validity of a claim of a patent does not constitute a civil action challenging the validity of a claim of a patent for purposes of this subsection.” Under § 315(b), “An inter partes review may not be instituted if the petition requesting the proceeding is filed more than 1 year after the date on which the petitioner, real party in interest, or privy of the petitioner is served with a complaint alleging infringement of the patent. The time limitation set forth in the preceding sentence shall not apply to a request for joinder under subsection (c).” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. In an instituted review, the petitioner must prove unpatentability by a preponderance of the evidence under § 316(e), rather than by the clear and convincing evidence a court requires, as the validity analysis explains. A review also limits later defenses. Under § 315(e)(2), a petitioner whose review of a claim “results in a final written decision under section 318(a)” “may not assert either in a civil action arising in whole or in part under section 1338 of title 28 or in a proceeding before the International Trade Commission under section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930 that the claim is invalid on any ground that the petitioner raised or reasonably could have raised during that inter partes review.”
- A declaratory judgment action. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2201(a), “In a case of actual controversy within its jurisdiction,” a federal court “may declare the rights and other legal relations of any interested party seeking such declaration, whether or not further relief is or could be sought.” Filing first lets your business ask a court to declare that the product does not infringe or the patent is invalid, and the court decides whether the letter created an actual controversy. My page on filing a declaratory judgment action covers how these cases work. Because of § 315(a)(1), a suit challenging validity filed before an inter partes review petition can close off that review, though under § 315(a)(3) a counterclaim challenging validity does not count as such a suit.
What Does an Analysis of the Patent Answer?
An analysis of the patent answers two questions: whether your product infringes any claim the letter relies on, and whether that claim is valid. Together they set the realistic value of the demand and tell you which of the responses above fits. An infringement analysis compares your product with each claim the letter relies on, and a validity analysis searches for earlier patents, publications, and products.
Infringement. An infringement analysis compares your product, feature by feature, with the words of each claim the letter relies on, read with the rest of the patent. It also asks whether your business has a defense, such as a license that already covers the product through your supplier. 35 U.S.C. § 282(b) lists among the defenses “Noninfringement, absence of liability for infringement or unenforceability.”
Validity. A validity analysis searches for earlier patents, publications, and products that the patent’s claims may not be new over or may be obvious in light of. Because “A patent shall be presumed valid” under § 282(a), the business asserting invalidity carries the burden of proving it. How much proof is required depends on where the patent is challenged. In court, the Supreme Court held in Microsoft Corp. v. i4i Ltd. Partnership, 564 U.S. 91 (2011) that § 282 “requires an invalidity defense to be proved by clear and convincing evidence.” In an instituted inter partes review, under 35 U.S.C. § 316(e), “the petitioner shall have the burden of proving a proposition of unpatentability by a preponderance of the evidence.”
Whether to get a written opinion. Under 35 U.S.C. § 298, that choice belongs to the business, since failing to obtain advice of counsel “may not be used to prove that the accused infringer willfully infringed the patent.” A written opinion can still be useful as evidence of what the business believed when it decided to keep selling. My page comparing trade secrets versus patents covers how the patent system works from the owner’s side.
Do I have to stop selling the product once I get the letter?
Not because of the letter alone, since a letter is a demand and not a court order. If a patented article was not marked, 35 U.S.C. § 287(a) allows no damages “except on proof that the infringer was notified of the infringement and continued to infringe thereafter,” and then “only for infringement occurring after such notice.” A letter can be that notice when it identifies the patent and the activity believed to infringe, not merely the patent’s existence. Marking and multiplied damages turn on more than the letter, as the section on exposure explains. I suggest comparing the patent’s claims with your product, and checking the patent’s status, before deciding, because those checks show what continuing could cost.
Can I sue a company that sent us a bad-faith patent demand?
Not under Minnesota’s bad-faith patent statute. Minn. Stat. § 325D.72, subd. 5, says it “does not create a private cause of action for a violation of subdivision 2.” Subdivision 3 lets the attorney general sue, and the court may order, among other relief, “restitution to a victim for legal and professional expenses related to the violation.” Subdivision 4 says it does not “limit the rights and remedies available to the state or another person under any other law.” Your business can seek a federal declaratory judgment under 28 U.S.C. § 2201(a) in “a case of actual controversy within its jurisdiction.”
What if our customers got letters about a product we sold them?
Your customers may look to your business. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.2-312(3), “Unless otherwise agreed a seller who is a merchant regularly dealing in goods of the kind warrants that the goods shall be delivered free of the rightful claim of any third person by way of infringement or the like but a buyer who furnishes specifications to the seller must hold the seller harmless against any such claim which arises out of compliance with the specifications.” A customer located or doing business in Minnesota that bought the product for its own use, not for resale, may also be an “end user” protected by Minn. Stat. § 325D.72. I suggest reading your sales terms before answering a customer, because they may change the warranty.
Should I sign the license agreement the letter offers?
I suggest not signing until three terms are confirmed, because a license is only as good as what it covers. The party signing should hold the right to license the patent, which the recorded assignments in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office can help confirm. The license should release claims for past sales. It should also cover every product, customer, and location you need.
Answering a Patent Infringement Letter
The response date in a patent infringement letter is the sender’s request, so your business has time to decide how to reply. The notice a supplier or insurer may be owed has its own rules. Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725 limits when a suit on a seller’s warranty may be brought, and its text is under How Do You Tender a Patent Claim to a Supplier or Insurer? Before any reply, I suggest reading the patent and checking its owner and status, and identifying whether the sender is a competitor or a patent assertion entity. I also suggest tendering the claim to suppliers and insurers and preserving records. After comparing the patent’s claims with your product and checking for earlier patents and publications, your business can choose its route. The routes include a reply, a license, a design change, an inter partes review, and a declaratory judgment action, and each has its own cost. My broader material on business litigation in Minnesota covers what follows if the dispute reaches court.
If you want to know which response fits the letter your business received, email [email protected] with a brief description, and I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.