A small Minnesota manufacturer can be held liable when a product leaves its control in a defective condition that is unreasonably dangerous and that defect causes an injury. An injured person can sue the manufacturer on strict liability, negligence, or breach of warranty, and the claim turns on whether the product had a manufacturing, design, or warning defect. Minnesota product liability law for manufacturers comes mostly from Minnesota Supreme Court decisions. Minnesota statutes set the time limit for strict liability claims, divide fault among the parties, and restrict punitive damages. This page is for the owner of a Minnesota company that makes what it sells, including parts sold to another manufacturer. When a product claim becomes a lawsuit against the company, it is business litigation.
What Makes a Minnesota Manufacturer Liable for a Defective Product?
A manufacturer is strictly liable when the injured person proves that the product was defective and unreasonably dangerous, that the defect existed when it left the manufacturer, and that the defect caused the injury. In Bilotta v. Kelley Co., 346 N.W.2d 616 (Minn. 1984), the Minnesota Supreme Court, in a footnote citing an earlier decision, listed those elements: the plaintiff must establish “(1) that the defendant’s product was in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous for its intended use, (2) that the defect existed when the product left the defendant’s control, and (3) that the defect was the proximate cause of the injury sustained.”
The same person can also sue for negligence. Bilotta explained the difference for design and warning claims: “in strict liability, knowledge of the condition of the product and the risks involved in that condition will be imputed to the manufacturer, whereas in negligence these elements must be proven.”
A warranty claim is a third route. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.2-318, “A seller’s warranty whether express or implied extends to any person who may reasonably be expected to use, consume or be affected by the goods and who is injured by breach of the warranty. A seller may not exclude or limit the operation of this section.” That can reach a user or bystander your company never sold to. Minnesota’s comparative fault statute counts all three theories as fault: under Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 1a, fault includes acts or omissions “that subject a person to strict tort liability,” and the term “also includes breach of warranty,” along with product misuse and other conduct.
The Minnesota Supreme Court has separated the strict liability claim from contract warranties. In McCormack v. Hankscraft Co., 154 N.W.2d 488 (Minn. 1967), the court described the view, adopted by many courts and embodied in section 402A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts, “that the liability of a seller to persons injured by its defective product is not one governed by the law of contract warranties but by the law of strict liability in tort.” It declared its agreement with the principles underlying that rule. It also said it wanted “to set at rest such future arguments which seek to raise various illusory contract defenses to a rule of liability which we believe should be imposed by law, in tort, as a matter of policy in cases such as this.”
On the warranty route, sales terms can limit remedies within the UCC’s limits. Minn. Stat. § 336.2-719(1) begins “Subject to the provisions of subsections (2) and (3) of this section and of the preceding section on liquidation and limitation of damages,” and under (1)(a) the agreement “may limit or alter the measure of damages recoverable under this article.” Under (1)(b), “resort to a remedy as provided is optional unless the remedy is expressly agreed to be exclusive, in which case it is the sole remedy.” Subsection (2) says “Where circumstances cause an exclusive or limited remedy to fail of its essential purpose, remedy may be had as provided in this chapter.” Subsection (3) says “Consequential damages may be limited or excluded unless the limitation or exclusion is unconscionable. Limitation of consequential damages for injury to the person in the case of consumer goods is prima facie unconscionable but limitation of damages where the loss is commercial is not.” And § 336.2-318, quoted above, says “A seller may not exclude or limit the operation of this section.”
Federal law adds limits for a consumer product sold with a written warranty. Under 15 U.S.C. § 2308(a), “No supplier may disclaim or modify (except as provided in subsection (b)) any implied warranty to a consumer with respect to such consumer product if (1) such supplier makes any written warranty to the consumer with respect to such consumer Product, or (2) at the time of sale, or within 90 days thereafter, such supplier enters into a service contract with the consumer which applies to such consumer product.” Subsection (b) lets implied warranties “be limited in duration to the duration of a written warranty of reasonable duration, if such limitation is conscionable and is set forth in clear and unmistakable language and prominently displayed on the face of the warranty.” Under subsection (c), “A disclaimer, modification, or limitation made in violation of this section shall be ineffective for purposes of this chapter and State law.” If a supplier designates its warranty a “full (statement of duration)” warranty, 15 U.S.C. § 2304(e) says the warranty “shall, for purposes of any action under section 2310(d) of this title or under any State law, be deemed to incorporate at least the minimum requirements of this section and rules prescribed under this section.” Those requirements include, under subsection (a)(2), that the warrantor “may not impose any limitation on the duration of any implied warranty on the product,” and, under (a)(3), that it “may not exclude or limit consequential damages for breach of any written or implied warranty on such product, unless such exclusion or limitation conspicuously appears on the face of the warranty.”
How Do Manufacturing, Design, and Warning Defects Differ?
A manufacturing defect is judged by the condition of the product, while design and warning claims ask whether the company’s choices were reasonable. In Bilotta, the court said “in manufacturing-flaw cases, the defect is proved by focusing on the condition of the product,” measured against “the flawless product.” A design defect is present in every unit the company made to that design: “In a design-defect case, however, there is no doubt that the product is in the condition intended by the manufacturer.”
Bilotta continued: “In such a case, the ‘defect’ lies in a consciously chosen design.” Quoting an earlier decision, Bilotta said reasonable care involves “a balancing of the likelihood of harm, and the gravity of harm if it happens, against the burden of the precaution which would be effective to avoid the harm.” In Kallio v. Ford Motor Co., 407 N.W.2d 92 (Minn. 1987), the court added: “To establish a prima facie case that it was unreasonably dangerous normally requires production of evidence of the existence of a feasible, alternative safer design.” It called Ford’s requested instruction overly broad in part because it “tends to elevate proof of the existence of a feasible alternative safer design from a factor properly for jury consideration to an element of the plaintiff’s claim.” In a footnote, the court noted that, “as a practical matter, successful plaintiffs, almost without fail, introduce evidence of an alternative safer design.”
A warning claim asks whether you told users about a danger they would not recognize. In Montemayor v. Sebright Products, Inc., 898 N.W.2d 623 (Minn. 2017), the district court had granted summary judgment to an extruder maker, and the court of appeals affirmed. In a 4-3 decision, the Minnesota Supreme Court held that a factual dispute about foreseeability made summary judgment improper, reversed the court of appeals, and remanded to that court. It treated design and warning claims as separate causes of action but said “each requires the manufacturer to owe a duty of care to the injured party.” Quoting an earlier decision, it said a manufacturer must warn if it “should anticipate that an unwarned operator might use the machine in a particular manner so as to increase the risk of injury and the manufacturer has no reason to believe that users will comprehend that risk.” The design duty reaches a product “used as intended or misused in a reasonably foreseeable manner.”
When Does a Manufacturer Have to Warn Buyers After the Sale?
A Minnesota manufacturer has a duty to warn after the sale only when four conditions all exist. In Great Northern Insurance Co. v. Honeywell International, Inc., 911 N.W.2d 510 (Minn. 2018), the Minnesota Supreme Court adopted section 10 of the Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability. Under it, a reasonable person in the seller’s position “would provide a warning after the time of sale” when all four of these are true:
- The seller “knows or reasonably should know that the product poses a substantial risk of harm to persons or property.”
- The people “to whom a warning might be provided can be identified and can reasonably be assumed to be unaware of the risk of harm.”
- In the court’s words, “a warning can be effectively communicated to and acted on by those to whom a warning might be provided.”
- The fourth factor is that “the risk of harm is sufficiently great to justify the burden of providing a warning.”
The court stressed that “the rule’s factors are conjunctive, and a plaintiff must establish all the requirements for the duty to attach.” It found no duty for the company that made a motor inside another company’s ventilator, because “McMillan did not have any records regarding the ventilators’ distribution or the consumers using the ventilators because McMillan’s only customer was Nutech, the ventilator’s manufacturer.” A component maker that sells only to another manufacturer may be in the same position. The court also left out whether a manufacturer had volunteered a warning: “The Restatement rule avoids this potential problem by omitting consideration of whether a manufacturer voluntarily undertook a duty to warn.”
A maker of consumer products that learns of a possible defect may also owe a report to the Consumer Product Safety Commission. The federal definition of a consumer product covers “any article, or component part thereof,” produced or distributed for sale to a consumer or for a consumer’s personal use (15 U.S.C. § 2052(a)(5)). The definition lists exclusions, such as “food” and “motor vehicles or motor vehicle equipment.” A maker of parts for another company’s consumer product can therefore owe that report too. That duty and the recall process are covered in what to do when your company’s product is defective. If a recall follows, the cost dispute between your company and its customers is covered in who pays for a product recall.
Who Else in the Chain of Distribution Shares a Product Claim?
Retailers and distributors can be sued along with the manufacturer, but the manufacturer stays in the case on strict liability. Under Minn. Stat. § 544.41, subd. 2, a defendant other than the manufacturer that has certified the manufacturer’s identity gets the strict liability claim against it dismissed. That happens once the injured person has sued the manufacturer and the manufacturer has answered or was required to. The dismissal can be undone: the plaintiff “may at any time subsequent to dismissal move to vacate the order of dismissal and reinstate the certifying defendant” by showing one of the grounds subdivision 2 lists, including “that the manufacturer is unable to satisfy any judgment as determined by the court.” The dismissal is barred when subdivision 3 applies, such as when the seller exercised “some significant control over the design or manufacture of the product,” knew of the defect, or created it. Subdivision 4 says subdivisions 1 to 3 do not “affect the right of any person to seek and obtain indemnity or contribution.” A retailer may also demand that its supplier defend it, which is the subject of a retailer’s demand for indemnity on a product claim. If a claimant’s attorney sends a notice of possible claim and asks, Minn. Stat. § 604.04, subd. 1, requires each company in the chain to “promptly furnish” the names and addresses of the others it knows.
When a company in the chain cannot pay its share, Minnesota shifts that share to the others in the chain. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.02, subd. 3, an amount uncollectible from any person in the chain “shall be reallocated among all other persons in the chain of manufacture and distribution but not among the claimant or others at fault who are not in the chain of manufacture or distribution of the product.” The same subdivision adds that “a person whose fault is less than that of a claimant is liable to the claimant only for that portion of the judgment which represents the percentage of fault attributable to the person whose fault is less.” An insolvent supplier’s share can therefore land on your company.
Your contracts with suppliers and customers can move that loss between the companies. Allocating liability in contract manufacturing agreements covers the indemnity, limitation-of-liability, and insurance clauses that do it.
How Does Comparative Fault Reduce What a Manufacturer Pays?
Minnesota reduces an injured person’s damages by that person’s own share of fault, and bars recovery when that share is greater than the fault of the company being sued. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 1, contributory fault does not bar recovery “if the contributory fault was not greater than the fault of the person against whom recovery is sought, but any damages allowed must be diminished in proportion to the amount of fault attributable to the person recovering.” Subdivision 1a counts “unreasonable assumption of risk not constituting an express consent or primary assumption of risk, misuse of a product and unreasonable failure to avoid an injury or to mitigate damages” as fault. The same subdivision limits the last of these: “Evidence of unreasonable failure to avoid aggravating an injury or to mitigate damages may be considered only in determining the damages to which the claimant is entitled. It may not be considered in determining the cause of an accident.”
Among several defendants, each pays its own share unless an exception applies. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.02, subd. 1, “contributions to awards shall be in proportion to the percentage of fault attributable to each,” except that listed persons are jointly and severally liable for the whole award, including “a person whose fault is greater than 50 percent.” The product-chain reallocation above is a second exception.
An employer’s safety lapses do not automatically free the manufacturer. In Montemayor, the court said the employer’s “comparative negligence does not automatically foreclose Sebright’s potential liability for defective design and warnings,” because the employer’s conduct may have been foreseeable to the maker. In Bilotta, the jury assigned 50% of the fault to the dockboard maker, 40% to the warehouse lessee whose employee drove the forklift, and 10% to the distributor. The Supreme Court ordered a new trial on liability for other reasons. It said the negligence of McGrath, one of the lessee’s employees, and the lessee’s violations of OSHA “are adequately taken into consideration in the comparative-fault formula.”
What Damages Can an Injured Person Recover From the Company?
An injured person can recover compensatory damages for the harm, and punitive damages only on proof of deliberate disregard for safety. Minnesota’s comparative fault statute frames the claim as an action “to recover damages for fault resulting in death, in injury to person or property, or in economic loss” (Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 1). The amounts can be large for a small company. The Bilotta jury assessed $2,300,000. In Hodder v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., 426 N.W.2d 826 (Minn. 1988), the jury awarded $3,368,916 in compensatory damages and $12.5 million in punitive damages.
Punitive damages have their own statute. Under Minn. Stat. § 549.20, subd. 1, “Punitive damages shall be allowed in civil actions only upon clear and convincing evidence that the acts of the defendant show deliberate disregard for the rights or safety of others.” That standard requires that the company knew or intentionally disregarded facts creating a high probability of injury and then deliberately went ahead in conscious or intentional disregard of, or with indifference to, that probability. Under Minn. Stat. § 549.191, “the complaint must not seek punitive damages”; the injured person must later move to add them, with one or more affidavits showing the factual basis, and the court allows the claim if it “finds prima facie evidence in support of the motion.”
Punitive damages for an employee’s act have a further limit. Under § 549.20, subd. 2, “Punitive damages can properly be awarded against a master or principal because of an act done by an agent only if” one of four grounds applies. The first is that “the principal authorized the doing and the manner of the act.” The second is that “the agent was unfit and the principal deliberately disregarded a high probability that the agent was unfit.” The third is that the agent “was employed in a managerial capacity with authority to establish policy and make planning level decisions for the principal and was acting in the scope of that employment.” The fourth is that “the principal or a managerial agent of the principal, described in clause (3), ratified or approved the act while knowing of its character and probable consequences.” Under subdivision 3, “Any award of punitive damages shall be measured by those factors which justly bear upon the purpose of punitive damages,” including “the duration of the misconduct and any concealment of it” and “the attitude and conduct of the defendant upon discovery of the misconduct.” In Hodder, the evidence included that Goodyear withheld some accident reports. The court still cut the punitive award to $4 million, on more than one ground. It said “first of all, the award must be substantially discounted for the erroneous per-rim recall calculation,” since the jury had found the rim’s design not defective. It added that “the egregious misconduct must, under the jury’s findings, be restricted to the inadequacies of the warnings.”
A business buyer whose purchase fails faces a narrower path. Minn. Stat. § 604.101, subd. 3, bars a buyer’s product defect tort claim against a seller for compensatory damages unless a defect in the goods caused harm to “the buyer’s tangible personal property other than the goods or to the buyer’s real property,” and subdivision 2 says “This section does not apply to claims for injury to the person.”
How Long Can a Product Claim Follow a Manufacturer?
Minnesota statutes set separate periods for strict liability, negligence, and contract-for-sale claims, and a separate statute governs goods built into real property. A product’s age can also reduce what the manufacturer owes. Under Minn. Stat. § 541.05, subd. 2, “Unless otherwise provided by law, any action based on the strict liability of the defendant and arising from the manufacture, sale, use or consumption of a product shall be commenced within four years.” That period covers actions “based on the strict liability of the defendant.” A negligence claim over the same injury falls under subdivision 1 of the same section, which says “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within six years,” and lists among them an action “for criminal conversation, or for any other injury to the person or rights of another, not arising on contract, and not hereinafter enumerated.” In a footnote in Great Northern, the Minnesota Supreme Court described subdivision 1 as covering “contract and negligence claims.” For a breach of a contract for sale, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725(1) says “An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within four years after the cause of action has accrued. By the original agreement the parties may reduce the period of limitation to not less than one year but may not extend it.” Subsection (2) says “A cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the breach. A breach of warranty occurs when tender of delivery is made, except that where a warranty explicitly extends to future performance of the goods and discovery of the breach must await the time of such performance the cause of action accrues when the breach is or should have been discovered.” The same section limits its own reach. Its limitations “do not apply to actions for the breach of any contract for sale of a grain storage structure or other goods that are incorporated into an improvement to real property, except equipment and machinery. These actions are subject only to the statute of limitations set forth in section 541.051.” It also says “This section does not apply to claims against sellers of goods for damages to property caused by the goods where the property that is damaged is not the goods and the sale is not a sale between parties who are each merchants in goods of the kind.” Check the current text of the statute before relying on these periods. When a claim arrives late, the statute of limitations defense is how a company raises the time bar.
A maker whose goods become part of a building or other improvement to real property faces Minn. Stat. § 541.051. Subdivision 1(a), “Except where fraud is involved,” covers any action “in contract, tort, or otherwise to recover damages for any injury to property, real or personal, or for bodily injury or wrongful death, arising out of the defective and unsafe condition of an improvement to real property.” It bars such an action against “any person performing or furnishing the design, planning, supervision, materials, or observation of construction or construction of the improvement to real property” if brought “more than two years after the cause of action accrues, as specified in paragraph (c), nor in any event shall such a cause of action accrue more than ten years after substantial completion of the construction.” Under paragraph (c), for paragraph (a)’s period, a cause of action accrues “for a bodily injury or wrongful death action, upon discovery of the injury,” and for property injury “upon discovery of the injury, but in no event does a cause of action accrue earlier than substantial completion, termination, or abandonment of the construction or the improvement to real property.” Subdivision 2 adds that a cause of action “which accrues during the ninth or tenth year after substantial completion of the construction” may be brought “within two years after the date on which the cause of action accrued, but in no event may such an action be brought more than 12 years after substantial completion of the construction.” Paragraph (e) says “The limitations prescribed in this section do not apply to the manufacturer or supplier of any equipment or machinery installed upon real property.” In Great Northern, the court applied the statute to the maker of a motor inside a home ventilator, held that the ventilator was “machinery” under paragraph (e), and so held that “section 541.051, subdivision 1(a), does not bar Great Northern’s claims against McMillan.” The same statute sets other periods for related claims. Under subdivision 1(b), “Notwithstanding paragraph (a), an action for contribution or indemnity arising out of the defective and unsafe condition of an improvement to real property may be brought no later than two years after the cause of action for contribution or indemnity has accrued, regardless of whether it accrued before or after the ten-year period referenced in paragraph (a), provided that in no event may an action for contribution or indemnity be brought more than 14 years after substantial completion of the construction.” Paragraph (c) says that cause of action “accrues upon the earlier of commencement of the action against the party seeking contribution or indemnity, or payment of a final judgment, arbitration award, or settlement arising out of the defective and unsafe condition.” Subdivision 4 says “For the purposes of actions based on breach of the statutory warranties set forth in section 327A.02, or to actions based on breach of an express written warranty, such actions shall be brought within two years of the discovery of the breach.” Check the current text of section 541.051 before relying on its periods.
Age matters separately under the useful-life statute. Minn. Stat. § 604.03, subd. 1, says “it is a defense to a claim against a designer, manufacturer, distributor or seller of the product or a part thereof, that the injury was sustained following the expiration of the ordinary useful life of the product.” Under subdivision 2, “The useful life of a product is not necessarily the life inherent in the product, but is the period during which with reasonable safety the product should be useful to the user,” and the factors include “(5) the useful life as stated by the designer, manufacturer, distributor, or seller of the product in brochures or pamphlets furnished with the product or in a notice attached to the product, and (6) any modification of the product by the user.”
The defense is not a complete bar. In Hodder, a 1955 truck rim exploded in 1981, and the court held: “We hold, therefore, that the expiration of a product’s useful life under section 604.03 is a factor to be weighed by the jury in determining the fault of the manufacturer and the fault of the user.”
What Can a Small Manufacturer Do to Reduce Product Liability Exposure?
A small manufacturer can reduce its exposure through design and warning choices made before a claim, and through how it responds once one arrives. These are the main options, each tied to the rule it answers:
- Standard safety features. Bilotta held that “a manufacturer may not delegate its duty to design a reasonably safe product,” and that the added cost and lost sales of a standard safety device “should be a factor considered within the balancing approach given to the jury but should not provide an absolute defense.” I suggest pricing a needed guard into the product rather than selling it as an option. Under that holding, the duty to design a reasonably safe product stays with the company, and the cost of a standard guard is a factor for the jury rather than an absolute defense.
- Warnings and instructions for how the product is actually used. In Montemayor, a reasonable person could find the injury foreseeable because “Sebright designed the extruder to allow for the relocation of the control panel and failed to provide any instruction on where it should be positioned so that operators could see dangerous parts of the extruder.” I suggest listing what your product lets a user move, remove, or bypass, because each one is a foreseeable use your instructions should address.
- Records of design choices and complaints. I suggest keeping a complaint log, because it tells you when the Great Northern factors for a post-sale warning may be met, and the seller’s duty there turns on what it “knows or reasonably should know.” In Montemayor, the worker’s expert faulted the maker for an inadequate hazard analysis and for not documenting customer feedback. The maker’s experts disagreed, and the court held that the dispute about foreseeability made summary judgment improper. Records also cut both ways. In Kallio, Ford had received many earlier complaints, and an internal company memorandum had suggested that alternative designs be explored; the court said that “From this and other evidence in the record, the jury could have drawn the inferences that prior to 1977 Ford knew of and admitted the defect in the design of the transmission.”
- A stated useful life. I suggest stating the product’s useful life in “brochures or pamphlets furnished with the product” or on a notice attached to the product, because a useful life stated there is one of the § 604.03 factors. Under Hodder, the expiration of that life is a factor the jury weighs in fault rather than a bar that ends a claim. I suggest wording the stated life as a limit on use rather than a promise of performance, because a statement in those materials can also create a warranty. Under Minn. Stat. § 336.2-313(1)(a), “Any affirmation of fact or promise made by the seller to the buyer which relates to the goods and becomes part of the basis of the bargain creates an express warranty that the goods shall conform to the affirmation or promise.” Under subsection (2), the seller need not use formal words such as warrant or guarantee or “have a specific intention to make a warranty,” but “an affirmation merely of the value of the goods or a statement purporting to be merely the seller’s opinion or commendation of the goods does not create a warranty.” A warranty that “explicitly extends to future performance of the goods” can also change when a warranty claim accrues under § 336.2-725(2).
- Fixes after an injury. I suggest fixing a problem when you find it, because Minn. R. Evid. 407 keeps evidence of a measure taken after an injury from being used “to prove negligence, culpable conduct, a defect in a product, a defect in a product’s design, or a need for a warning or instruction.” The rule still lets that evidence in “for another purpose, such as proving ownership, control, or feasibility of precautionary measures, if controverted, or impeachment.”
- Talking with the customer who reported the problem. I suggest a direct conversation, a replacement part, or a refund, because it can resolve a complaint early and tells your engineers what failed. The risk is a careless statement later read as an admission. A payment to an injured person, by contrast, “shall not constitute an admission of liability” under Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 2.
- Contracts, insurance, and the entity. Minn. Stat. § 336.2-719(3) makes a limit on consequential damages “for injury to the person in the case of consumer goods” prima facie unconscionable, while a limit on commercial loss is not. The insurance your supply contracts require, and how it works with the indemnity clause, is covered in insurance requirements in vendor and supply contracts. Whether the company structure protects you personally is covered in what an LLC’s liability shield covers.
Can we still be liable if our product met industry standards?
Yes. Meeting industry standards is evidence a jury weighs, not a complete defense. In Kallio v. Ford Motor Co. (Minn. 1987), Ford offered evidence that it had used the state of the art and that no safer practical design existed. The Minnesota Supreme Court said that ’the resolution of this disputed fact issue was for the trier of fact.’ In Montemayor v. Sebright Products (Minn. 2017), experts disputed the maker’s compliance with industry standards. The court held that the factual dispute about foreseeability made summary judgment improper, reversed the court of appeals, and remanded to that court.
Does selling a safety guard as an optional add-on shift the risk to the buyer?
Not as a matter of law. In a 1984 decision, the Minnesota Supreme Court adopted the rule that ‘a manufacturer may not delegate its duty to design a reasonably safe product’ (Bilotta v. Kelley Co.). The extra cost and lost sales of a standard safety device are factors the jury weighs in deciding whether the design was reasonable. The court said the optional-device defense ‘would not apply to dockboards which are not multi-use and whose functioning is never impaired by the installation of the panic stop device.’
Will a warning label protect us if a worker ignores it?
Not automatically. The Minnesota Supreme Court addressed this in Montemayor v. Sebright Products (Minn. 2017). It said manufacturers ‘can be held liable despite intervening circumstances’ such as a plaintiff’s failure to heed warnings ‘if such circumstances were also foreseeable.’ The worker’s conduct can still count as fault. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.01, subd. 1a, fault includes misuse of a product and unreasonable assumption of risk not constituting an express consent or primary assumption of risk. The section ‘How Does Comparative Fault Reduce What a Manufacturer Pays?’ explains how each party’s share changes what the company pays.
Can our sales terms limit a consumer's injury claim?
Sales terms can limit warranty remedies only within statutory limits, and an injured consumer can also sue in strict liability or negligence. The section ‘What Makes a Minnesota Manufacturer Liable for a Defective Product?’ quotes the Minnesota Supreme Court’s decision in McCormack v. Hankscraft Co. on strict liability and each limit on warranty terms. Those limits come from Minn. Stat. §§ 336.2-719 and 336.2-318 and, for a consumer product sold with a written warranty, 15 U.S.C. §§ 2304 and 2308.
Can a business customer sue us in tort when our part fails?
A business customer can sue in tort only in limited cases. Under Minn. Stat. § 604.101, subd. 3, a buyer may not bring a product defect tort claim against a seller for compensatory damages without harm to other property. The defect must have caused harm to the buyer’s tangible personal property other than the goods or to the buyer’s real property. If your part is a component of the buyer’s product, harm to that product is not harm to tangible personal property other than your component (subd. 1). The statute does not apply to claims for injury to the person (subd. 2). It governs claims where both sales occurred on or after August 1, 2000.
Does fixing the design after an accident prove the old design was defective?
No, not for that purpose. Minnesota Rule of Evidence 407 covers a measure taken after an injury that would have made it less likely. Evidence of that measure is not admissible to prove negligence, culpable conduct, a defect in a product or its design, or a need for a warning or instruction. The rule still lets that evidence in for another purpose, such as proving ownership, control, or feasibility of precautionary measures, if controverted, or impeachment.
Do we have to tell a claimant's lawyer who else made or sold the product?
Yes, if the lawyer asks when giving notice of the claim. Minn. Stat. § 604.04, subd. 1, covers every person in the chain of manufacture and distribution. Each must promptly furnish the claimant’s attorney the names and addresses of the others it knows to be in the chain. The duty applies if the attorney requests it at the time the notice is given. Under subd. 3, a person injured by a violation may recover damages, costs, and reasonable attorney fees.
Is the company protected once the product has outlived its useful life?
Not completely. Minn. Stat. § 604.03, subd. 1, creates a useful-life defense. It applies when the injury happened after the expiration of the ordinary useful life of the product. The Minnesota Supreme Court decided Hodder v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. in 1988. It held that expiration ‘is a factor to be weighed by the jury in determining the fault of the manufacturer and the fault of the user,’ not an absolute bar. The jury in Hodder found the rim’s useful life had expired and still held Goodyear at fault for inadequate warnings.
Managing Product Liability Risk as a Minnesota Manufacturer
A Minnesota manufacturer’s product liability exposure turns on its design and warning choices, the records it keeps, and how it responds when it learns of a problem. In design and warning claims, strict liability treats the company as knowing what its product was. Comparative fault and the useful-life defense can reduce what it pays, and punitive damages require proof of deliberate disregard for safety. Records made before a claim, such as design files and a complaint log, can become evidence for either side if an injury leads to business litigation. If your company has received a claim notice or a lawsuit over a product it made, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.