Not always. Whether to rebrand after a trademark claim depends on three things. The first is how strong the claim against your name is. The second is what keeping the name would expose your business to now that you have the letter, and the third is what a new name would cost. Between fighting and a full rebrand sit middle paths, such as adding distinguishing words, signing a coexistence agreement, or changing the name on a schedule the two businesses negotiate.

Federal trademark law, the Lanham Act, supplies the main claims in a dispute over a business or product name. It reaches a registered mark through 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1) and an unregistered name through 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1). Minnesota adds its Deceptive Trade Practices Act and its state trademark registration statutes. No statute tells a business whether to change its name: that is a business decision made against the exposure these laws set. This page is written for the owner of a Minnesota business that has received a trademark demand over its business or product name. It is part of my material on trademark law for Minnesota businesses.

How Do You Decide Whether to Rebrand After a Trademark Claim?

You decide by weighing three questions against each other. How likely is the claimant to win, what could continuing to use the name cost if it does, and what would changing the name cost your business? Each infringement claim described below asks whether customers are likely to be confused by your use of the name. A dilution claim by the owner of a famous mark, covered in what makes a claim strong or weak, applies under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)(1) “regardless of the presence or absence of actual or likely confusion.”

For a registered mark, 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1) reaches use “in connection with the sale, offering for sale, distribution, or advertising of any goods or services on or in connection with which such use is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive.” For an unregistered name, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1) asks whether the use “is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive as to the affiliation, connection, or association of such person with another person, or as to the origin, sponsorship, or approval of his or her goods, services, or commercial activities by another person.” Minnesota law adds a claim against a business that “causes likelihood of confusion or of misunderstanding as to the source, sponsorship, approval, or certification of goods or services,” under Minn. Stat. § 325D.44, subd. 1.

The choices are wider than keep or change:

  • Keep the name and answer the letter. This fits when the claim is weak and the name carries real value. The risk is a lawsuit and the money exposure described below.
  • Talk owner to owner. This fits when the two businesses can draw lines between themselves without a lawsuit. The risk is that what you say can be quoted later.
  • Add distinguishing words or narrow the use. This fits when confusion is limited to one product line, market, or channel.
  • Sign a written agreement. An agreement can let both names continue on stated terms, or set a date for a change.
  • Change the name. This fits when the claim is strong, the name is new, or a fight would cost more than the name is worth.

Before choosing, I suggest taking the first steps after a demand letter arrives, including preserving your records and notifying your insurer. Those steps keep your choices open.

What Makes a Trademark Claim Against Your Name Strong or Weak?

A trademark infringement claim is strongest when the claimant holds a federal registration for goods or services like yours and its rights date from before you first used your name. It is stronger still when customers are likely to confuse the two businesses. An infringement claim weakens when your business came first, the goods or services differ, or confusion is unlikely. Against a federal registrant, its application filing date matters too. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1057(c), once the mark registers, the registrant’s application filing counts as constructive use of the mark, with nationwide priority for the goods or services in the registration. That priority does not reach, among others, “a person whose mark has not been abandoned and who, prior to such filing” used the mark. The owner of a mark “widely recognized by the general consuming public of the United States” also has a dilution claim against a use begun after the mark became famous, “regardless of the presence or absence of actual or likely confusion, of competition, or of actual economic injury,” under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)(1). Minnesota adds a dilution claim for a mark famous in this state.

Registration. The USPTO’s public records show whether the mark named in a letter is registered, who owns it, and the goods or services it covers. I suggest checking first whether the registration a demand cites exists and covers what you sell. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1115(a), a registration is prima facie evidence of the registrant’s exclusive right to use the mark “on or in connection with the goods or services specified in the registration subject to any conditions or limitations stated therein.” A registration is “prima facie evidence of the validity of the registered mark,” but under 15 U.S.C. § 1115(a) it “shall not preclude another person from proving any legal or equitable defense or defect, including those set forth in subsection (b), which might have been asserted if such mark had not been registered.” The rule tightens once a registration becomes incontestable: “To the extent that the right to use the registered mark has become incontestable under section 1065 of this title, the registration shall be conclusive evidence of the validity of the registered mark,” subject to the defenses § 1115(b) lists. Incontestability itself has limits: 15 U.S.C. § 1065 excepts, among other things, the extent “to which the use of a mark registered on the principal register infringes a valid right acquired under the law of any State or Territory by use of a mark or trade name continuing from a date prior to the date of registration under this chapter of such registered mark.”

Who used the name first. Which business used the name first, in what areas each used it, and, for a federal registrant, also whether your use began before its application was filed bear on how strong the claim is. How courts sort out which business holds the earlier right to a name, and in what territory, is covered on a separate page.

Likelihood of confusion. Courts in the Eighth Circuit, the federal appeals court for Minnesota, weigh many factors rather than one. SquirtCo v. Seven-Up Co., 628 F.2d 1086 (8th Cir. 1980) was an appeal after a bench trial. The court described the trial court as recognizing that “resolution of this issue does not hinge on a single factor but requires a consideration of numerous factors to determine whether under all the circumstances there is a likelihood of confusion,” and it affirmed the injunction against the QUIRST name. Under Minnesota’s act, “a complainant need not prove competition between the parties or actual confusion or misunderstanding,” under § 325D.44, subd. 2. The factors courts weigh are covered on my page on likelihood of confusion.

A famous mark. A claimant with a famous mark can bring a dilution claim. “Subject to the principles of equity,” 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)(1) entitles the owner of a famous, distinctive mark to an injunction against another person who, “at any time after the owner’s mark has become famous, commences use of a mark or trade name in commerce that is likely to cause dilution by blurring or dilution by tarnishment of the famous mark,” with no need to show confusion, competition, or economic injury. A mark is famous under that section only “if it is widely recognized by the general consuming public of the United States as a designation of source of the goods or services of the mark’s owner.” Money is harder to reach than an injunction. Under § 1125(c)(5), the owner recovers the § 1117(a) remedies only if your name “was first used in commerce by the person against whom the injunction is sought after October 6, 2006,” and, for blurring, you “willfully intended to trade on the recognition of the famous mark,” or, for tarnishment, you “willfully intended to harm the reputation of the famous mark.”

Minnesota has its own dilution claim. Under Minn. Stat. § 333.285, paragraph (a), the owner of “a mark that is famous in this state” may, “subject to the principles of equity and upon terms the court considers reasonable,” seek an injunction if the use “begins after the mark has become famous and causes dilution of the distinctive quality of the mark.” Under paragraph (b), the owner “is entitled only to injunctive relief in this state, unless the person against whom the injunctive relief is sought willfully intended to trade on the owner’s reputation or to cause dilution of the famous mark.” Under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c)(6), a business’s own valid federal registration “on the principal register” is “a complete bar” to a state-law dilution claim against it “with respect to that mark.” Both statutes exclude some uses, including noncommercial use and news reporting.

What Does a Trademark Demand Letter Change About Your Exposure?

A demand letter is dated proof that your business knew of the other side’s claim, and several trademark rules turn on what a business knew. Actual notice decides whether a federal registrant that did not mark its registration can recover profits or damages under the federal trademark statute. A mark registered in Minnesota carries its own money remedies under state law. Your state of mind bears on whether a court awards your profits, on the multiplied award a Minnesota-registered mark allows, and on attorney fees.

Actual notice of a registration. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1111, a registrant “may give notice that his mark is registered by displaying with the mark the words” the statute lists, or the ® symbol. If it did not, the same section provides that “in any suit for infringement under this chapter by such a registrant failing to give such notice of registration, no profits and no damages shall be recovered under the provisions of this chapter unless the defendant had actual notice of the registration.” A letter that identifies the registration is written evidence of the date your business learned of it.

Your state of mind. In Romag Fasteners, Inc. v. Fossil, Inc., 590 U.S. 212 (2020), a case brought under § 1125(a), the U.S. Supreme Court wrote that “the statutory language has never required a showing of willfulness to win a defendant’s profits.” The Court added that “a trademark defendant’s mental state is a highly important consideration” in deciding whether profits should be awarded. Good faith does not defeat the claim itself: in SquirtCo, the Eighth Circuit wrote that “intent is not an element of a claim for trademark infringement.”

For a mark registered with the State of Minnesota, Minn. Stat. § 333.28 provides that, “Subject to the provisions of section 333.30,” a person who uses a mark “without the consent of the registrant” that is “likely to cause confusion or mistake” is liable “for any or all of the remedies provided in section 333.29.” Under Minn. Stat. § 333.29, subd. 1, the court may require the defendant to pay “(1) all profits derived from the wrongful manufacture, use, display, or sale; or (2) all damages suffered by reason of the wrongful manufacture, use, display, or sale.” A court also “may enter judgment for an amount not to exceed three times the profits and damages and reasonable attorneys’ fees of the prevailing party if the court finds the other party committed the wrongful acts with knowledge or in bad faith or otherwise as according to the circumstances of the case,” under the same subdivision.

In one Minnesota dispute, a finding that the infringing business believed in good faith that it could use the names was among the reasons the trial court denied profits and fees. In Safeway Transit LLC v. Discount Party Bus, Inc., 954 F.3d 1171 (8th Cir. 2020), two Minnesota party-bus companies disputed two unregistered names under § 1125(a) and § 325D.44. After a bench trial, the district court enjoined the infringing business but denied profits and attorney fees, and the Eighth Circuit affirmed. It read the district court’s findings, which included that the infringing business had used the terms first, this way: “These comments make clear that the district court actually found that DPB held a good faith belief in its right to use the trademarks.” If you keep the name after a demand, I suggest writing down why you believe your use is lawful, such as your first-use dates and the differences between the businesses. The reason is that Romag and Safeway make your state of mind part of the money question.

What Can a Court Order If You Keep the Name and Lose?

If you keep the name and lose, a court can order your business to stop using it or to change how you use it, and it can award money in some cases. The Eighth Circuit in Safeway, quoting an earlier decision, wrote that “an injunction is the preferred Lanham Act remedy.”

An injunction. Federal courts “shall have power to grant injunctions, according to the principles of equity and upon such terms as the court may deem reasonable,” under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a). The same subsection gives the claimant a head start: “A plaintiff seeking any such injunction shall be entitled to a rebuttable presumption of irreparable harm upon a finding of a violation identified in this subsection in the case of a motion for a permanent injunction or upon a finding of likelihood of success on the merits for a violation identified in this subsection in the case of a motion for a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order.” For your business, that means a claimant who shows it is likely to win does not have to prove separately that waiting for trial would harm it. Your business carries the burden of rebutting that presumption.

Money. A claimant that establishes a violation of its registered mark, or a violation under § 1125(a), “shall be entitled, subject to the provisions of sections 1111 and 1114 of this title, and subject to the principles of equity, to recover (1) defendant’s profits, (2) any damages sustained by the plaintiff, and (3) the costs of the action,” under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a). Damages can exceed the claimant’s loss: “In assessing damages the court may enter judgment, according to the circumstances of the case, for any sum above the amount found as actual damages, not exceeding three times such amount.” The statute adds that such a sum “shall constitute compensation and not a penalty.” Attorney fees are narrower: “The court in exceptional cases may award reasonable attorney fees to the prevailing party.” Fee awards can turn on the infringer’s conduct, and the Safeway opinion repeats an earlier Eighth Circuit statement: “Where a defendant’s unlawful conduct was willful and deliberate, the court may well determine that this is the type of exceptional case for which an award of attorney’s fees is appropriate.”

Minnesota’s act. Under Minn. Stat. § 325D.45, subd. 1, “A person likely to be damaged by a deceptive trade practice of another may be granted an injunction against it under the principles of equity and on terms that the court considers reasonable. Proof of monetary damage, loss of profits, or intent to deceive is not required.” Fees run both ways under subd. 2: “The court may award attorneys’ fees to the prevailing party if (1) the party complaining of a deceptive trade practice has brought an action knowing it to be groundless, or (2) the party charged with a deceptive trade practice has willfully engaged in the trade practice knowing it to be deceptive.”

What Does Changing a Business Name Cost Compared With Keeping It?

Changing a name costs money and some customer recognition up front. Keeping a contested name costs the defense and leaves the injunction and money exposure open until the dispute ends. The comparison turns on your own numbers, and the cost of a change can grow the longer the name stays in use.

The costs of a change can include:

  1. Signs, vehicle graphics, packaging, labels, printed materials, and any inventory that carries the name.
  2. The website, domain name, email addresses, and social media accounts.
  3. Online listings, review profiles, and the search traffic tied to the old name.
  4. State filings, bank accounts, contracts, and licenses that carry the name.
  5. Advertising and staff time to tell customers about the change.

The costs of keeping a contested name can include attorney fees for a defense, an injunction on a date the court chooses, and the money remedies described above. If the claimant seeks your profits, its proof starts with your revenue: under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), “In assessing profits the plaintiff shall be required to prove defendant’s sales only; defendant must prove all elements of cost or deduction claimed.”

Timing changes the comparison. In footnote 2 of SquirtCo, the Eighth Circuit noted: “At the time that SquirtCo first objected, Seven-Up had invested relatively little in the QUIRST mark.” The same footnote continued: “The investment had risen to over $200,000 at the time of the preliminary hearing and to over $2,000,000 by the end of 1978.” The injunction against the QUIRST name was affirmed. I suggest weighing how long the name has been in use and how far it reaches. A name adopted recently and used in one market costs less to change than one customers have known for years.

What Are the Middle Paths Between Fighting and Rebranding?

The middle paths let a business keep part of what its name is worth. They include an owner-to-owner conversation, distinguishing words, a coexistence agreement, and a negotiated change of name with a transition period and a release of claims. A business with a strong position can also ask a court to decide the question first.

  1. An owner-to-owner conversation. Two owners can agree on boundaries without a lawsuit, such as which markets or product lines each will use the name in. I suggest following any understanding with a written agreement, because an oral understanding is hard to enforce.
  2. Distinguishing words or a narrower use. Adding a word, a place name, or a distinct logo, or dropping the name from one product line, can address confusion without a full change. Courts can shape relief the same way: Minnesota’s act allows an injunction “on terms that the court considers reasonable” under § 325D.45, subd. 1.
  3. A coexistence agreement. Both businesses keep their names under written limits on territory, products, or presentation. What a coexistence agreement should cover, and the drafting mistakes to avoid, is covered on a separate page.
  4. A negotiated change of name. Your business agrees to change on a set date, with time to use up stock and a release of claims for past use. A trademark settlement agreement should state each of those terms.
  5. A court decision on the name. Under 28 U.S.C. § 2201(a), “In a case of actual controversy within its jurisdiction,” a federal court “may declare the rights and other legal relations of any interested party seeking such declaration, whether or not further relief is or could be sought.” How a declaratory judgment action can follow a cease-and-desist letter is covered on my page on those letters.

A demand aimed at your search ads rather than your business name raises different questions. How the Eighth Circuit judges search ads that use another company’s name is covered on my page about a competitor bidding on a brand name.

How Do You Plan a Transition to a New Name?

I suggest planning a transition in a fixed order, because clearing the new name before ordering signs avoids paying twice if the search finds a conflict. The order is to clear and file the new name, list every place the old name appears, and set a date for each. The dates, any sell-off of existing stock, and a release of claims then go in a signed agreement with the claimant.

  1. Clear and file the new name first. A new name that starts a second dispute repeats the cost of the first. The section below covers how.
  2. List every use of the old name. The list should include signs, vehicles, packaging, the website, social media, online listings, invoices, email signatures, contracts, and state filings.
  3. Set a date for each use. Customer-facing uses, such as signs, the website, and listings, can change on one date, while printed stock and inventory may need a sell-off period. I suggest setting that date after any assumed-name filing the new name needs, because under Minn. Stat. § 333.01, subd. 1, “No person shall hereafter carry on or conduct or transact a commercial business in this state under any designation, name, or style, which does not set forth the true name of every person interested in such business unless such person shall file in the Office of the Secretary of State, a certificate setting forth the name and business address under which the business is conducted or transacted, or is to be conducted or transacted, and the true name of each person conducting or transacting the same, with the address of such person.” The same subdivision provides that the certificate “shall be published after it has been filed with the secretary of state in a qualified newspaper in the county in which the person has a principal or registered office for two successive issues.”
  4. Tell customers. A short announcement that the business has a new name, with the same owners and services, helps customers find you.
  5. Keep a dated record. I suggest recording when each use of the old name ended, because the record shows that your business kept its side of the agreement.

A negotiated date matters because, without an agreement, a court can set the timetable. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a), the claimant can seek a preliminary injunction or temporary restraining order before trial, with a presumption of irreparable harm once it shows “likelihood of success on the merits.”

How Do You Keep a New Name From Starting Another Trademark Dispute?

A new name avoids a second dispute when it is cleared before the business commits money to it and filed with the USPTO early. I suggest running a trademark clearance search of federal, state, and common-law uses before ordering signs or printing. The reason is that a federal registration on the principal register gives notice of the registrant’s claim whether or not the search finds it.

That notice comes from 15 U.S.C. § 1072: “Registration of a mark on the principal register provided by this chapter or under the Act of March 3, 1881, or the Act of February 20, 1905, shall be constructive notice of the registrant’s claim of ownership thereof.” A business does not need to wait until the new name is in use to file. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1051(b)(1), “A person who has a bona fide intention, under circumstances showing the good faith of such person, to use a trademark in commerce may request registration of its trademark on the principal register.” The filing date then matters: under 15 U.S.C. § 1057(c), “Contingent on the registration of a mark on the principal register provided by this chapter, the filing of the application to register such mark shall constitute constructive use of the mark, conferring a right of priority, nationwide in effect,” for the goods or services in the registration. That priority does not reach, among others, “a person whose mark has not been abandoned and who, prior to such filing” used the mark, which is why the clearance search comes first. I suggest filing before the public announcement, because the filing date is the date that priority runs from once the registration issues.

Do I have to stop using the name by the date in the letter?

Not by the letter’s date alone, because that date is the sender’s request. The letter can still raise your exposure. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1111, a registrant that did not mark its registration recovers no profits and no damages “unless the defendant had actual notice of the registration.” For a Minnesota-registered mark, Minn. Stat. § 333.29, subd. 1 allows up to three times the profits and damages for acts done “with knowledge or in bad faith or otherwise as according to the circumstances of the case.” A federal court may grant a preliminary injunction before trial under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a). I suggest a written answer before the date passes, because silence leaves the claimant’s account as the only written one.

Can I keep my name if I used it before the other business filed?

Possibly. The answer turns on facts including which business used the name first, in what areas each used it, and whether the other business’s federal application has become a registration. My page on two businesses that share the same name covers how courts sort out which business holds the earlier right to a name and in what territory.

Will changing our name end the claim for past use?

No, because the change stops new use and does not erase past use. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), a claimant that establishes a violation may recover the defendant’s profits, its damages, and costs, “subject to the provisions of sections 1111 and 1114 of this title, and subject to the principles of equity.” Under 15 U.S.C. § 1111, an unmarked registrant recovers no profits and no damages “under the provisions of this chapter unless the defendant had actual notice of the registration.” For a mark registered in Minnesota, Minn. Stat. § 333.29, subd. 1 separately lets the court require payment of either or both of “all profits derived from the wrongful manufacture, use, display, or sale” and “all damages suffered by reason of the wrongful manufacture, use, display, or sale.” A signed settlement release of past claims is one way to end that exposure, and I suggest asking for one.

Should I answer the letter if I have already decided to rebrand?

Yes, I suggest a written answer, because the terms of a change are worth negotiating. A reply can propose a transition date, ask to sell existing stock, and ask for a release of claims for past use. The claimant has a reason to agree, because a negotiated change avoids the cost of a lawsuit for both businesses. I suggest putting the agreed terms in a signed settlement rather than an exchange of emails, because a signed agreement states each promise in one place.

Deciding Whether to Rebrand

A trademark demand starts a decision, and the date in the letter does not make the decision for you. The decision weighs the claim’s strength against the cost of a change and the exposure of keeping the name after the letter. Strength depends on factors including registration, priority, likelihood of confusion, whether the claimant’s mark is famous, and the defenses your business may have. When the claim is strong, a negotiated change lets your business set the transition date and obtain a release. A court order would give it neither. More about how I approach these disputes is on my trademark practice page.

If you want to know whether your business should change its name on your facts, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.