Your buyer’s claim that your new work violates the noncompete you signed when you sold your Minnesota business turns on three things. They are whether Minnesota enforces that covenant, whether your work falls within its words, and what a court can order. Minn. Stat. § 181.988 voids a covenant not to compete in an agreement between an employee and employer. As an exception to that ban, it makes a covenant made during the sale of a business “valid and enforceable.” Its enacting law limits the section to contracts entered into on or after July 1, 2023. Minnesota Supreme Court decisions supply the rest: how courts read the covenant, when they narrow it, and when they stop a seller from working.

This page is for the former owner who sold. One statute’s ban on employee covenants carries an exception for a covenant made in a sale, court decisions decide the dispute, and Minnesota’s civil procedure rules govern any order to stop your work. The buyer’s side of this dispute is on the page about a seller competing after selling the business, and the deal terms that create the covenant are part of my business sale and acquisition work.

When Does Minnesota Enforce a Noncompete From the Sale of Your Business?

Minnesota enforces a seller’s covenant made in a business sale when its reach is reasonable, and a court can narrow one that reaches too far and enforce the narrower version. In Bess v. Bothman, 257 N.W.2d 791 (Minn. 1977), the Minnesota Supreme Court upheld a district court’s authority to modify and enforce a seller’s covenant that had no limit on territory or time. It left that step to the court’s equitable discretion, covered under a covenant that is too broad. For a contract entered into on or after July 1, 2023, Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 2(b)(1) makes an exception to the ban, which subd. 1(a) limits to “an agreement between an employee and employer”: “Notwithstanding paragraph (a), a covenant not to compete is valid and enforceable if” it “is agreed upon during the sale of a business.” The same clause says what the covenant may do: “The person selling the business and the partners, members, or shareholders, and the buyer of the business may agree on a temporary and geographically restricted covenant not to compete that will prohibit the seller of the business from carrying on a similar business within a reasonable geographic area and for a reasonable length of time.”

The enacting law, Laws 2023, chapter 53, article 6, section 1, states that the section “is effective July 1, 2023, and applies to contracts and agreements entered into on or after that date.” The date decides whether the ban can reach a covenant that sits in an agreement between an employee and employer, the case covered under the noncompete ban.

Minnesota case law uses a different measure for a seller’s covenant than for an employee’s. In Bennett v. Storz Broadcasting Co., 134 N.W.2d 892 (Minn. 1965), an employment case, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that “courts recognize a distinction between restrictive covenants as they relate to the ordinary commercial transaction involving business or property transfers and those which relate to employment contracts entered into by wage earners. A different measure of reasonableness is used.” I suggest finding the signed covenant and its date before you answer the buyer, because the date and the document it sits in decide whether the ban can reach it.

When Does Minnesota’s Noncompete Ban Void a Former Owner’s Covenant?

The ban can void your covenant if it sits in a post-closing employment or consulting agreement signed on or after July 1, 2023, rather than in the sale. Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 1(a) defines the covenant the ban governs as “an agreement between an employee and employer that restricts the employee, after termination of the employment.” Subd. 1(c) provides that “employee” means “any individual who performs services for an employer, including independent contractors.” Subd. 2(a) states: “Any covenant not to compete contained in a contract or agreement is void and unenforceable.”

Some sellers stay on after closing under a separate employment or consulting agreement. If your only noncompete is in that later agreement, the question is whether it was “agreed upon during the sale of a business” under subd. 2(b)(1). If it was not, and the ban covers it, the statute gives you two more points:

  1. The rest of the agreement survives. Subd. 2(c) provides: “Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to render void or unenforceable any other provisions in a contract or agreement containing a void or unenforceable covenant not to compete.” A confidentiality or nonsolicitation clause beside a void noncompete can still bind you.
  2. Fees can run to you. Under subd. 2(d), “a court may award an employee who is enforcing rights under this section reasonable attorney fees.”

Whether or not the ban reaches your later agreement, the case law on employee covenants also bears on it. In National Recruiters, Inc. v. Cashman, 323 N.W.2d 736 (Minn. 1982), the Minnesota Supreme Court said, citing a federal appeals decision, that where an employee’s covenant “is not ancillary to the initial oral employment contract, it can be sustained only if supported by independent consideration.” It held invalid a covenant that recruiters were told to sign after they had started work.

A covenant the ban reaches is void, so a court has no valid covenant to narrow. The rules for employee covenants generally are on the page about Minnesota noncompete agreements.

What Counts as Competing Under a Sale-of-Business Noncompete?

Competing is whatever your covenant’s words forbid, and a Minnesota court can find a breach even if you never asked a former customer for work. In Haynes v. Monson, 224 N.W.2d 482 (Minn. 1974), the sellers of a bookkeeping and tax practice in Austin promised not to “carry on or be engaged or interested in the business of bookkeeping, accounting, or tax practice” within 50 miles of Austin for five years. One seller opened an office in Red Wing, about 100 miles away. In his deposition he testified that “he did work for 45-50 Austin clients through his Red Wing office,” though “only two actually came to this office.” He kept his Austin residence and telephone and returned there every week or two, and client information was “either mailed to Red Wing, delivered to Haynes’ Austin residence, or left with Haynes’ relatives for delivery to him.”

The Minnesota Supreme Court said covenants like this one “should be strictly construed,” and it still affirmed a summary judgment against the sellers, concluding “that on the basis of the record before us, there existed no genuine issue of material fact.” Its reason: “when one has conducted a business in the same area for many years and has built a sizable clientele, active solicitation on his part is unnecessary to compete so as to defeat the covenant. Solicitation by mere reputation and past business practices is more than sufficient.”

What the covenant leaves out matters as much. The covenant in Bess v. Bothman, 257 N.W.2d 791 (Minn. 1977) “permitted him to tow work in connection with his repair business; it prohibited only general towing services.” I suggest comparing your new work, line by line, against four parts of your covenant:

  • the activity it bars (“a similar business,” a named trade, or being “interested in” one);
  • the territory, measured from where it says;
  • the period, counted from the date it names; and
  • any carve-out for work you kept.

A promise not to solicit customers is a separate term read on its own words. The ban’s definition in Minn. Stat. § 181.988, subd. 1(a) leaves such a promise out of the ban: a covenant not to compete “does not include a nonsolicitation agreement, or agreement restricting the ability to use client or contact lists, or solicit customers of the employer.”

What Makes a Seller’s Covenant Too Broad to Enforce as Written?

A Minnesota court asks whether the covenant goes beyond protecting the goodwill the buyer purchased, places an undue hardship on you, or harms the public. If it is too broad, the court can narrow it and enforce the narrower version. In Bess, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that “a restraint that provides more protection to the purchaser than is necessary to secure the goodwill he purchased is unreasonable and therefore illegal.” It named three elements:

  1. “whether the restriction exceeds the protection necessary to secure the goodwill purchased”;
  2. “whether the restriction places an undue hardship on the covenantor” (you, the seller who made the promise); and
  3. “whether the restriction has a deleterious effect on the interests of the general public.”

The seller in Bess signed a covenant with no limit on territory or time. The district court concluded that “without judicial modification the covenant not to compete was an unreasonable restraint of trade.” On appeal the seller argued that “the court was without authority to supply the limitations necessary to render the restraint reasonable,” and he lost: the Minnesota Supreme Court held “that the district court had authority to modify and enforce the covenant not to compete,” and it affirmed a judgment barring general towing in Forest Lake for five years. Minnesota calls this equitable modification: the court rewrites an overbroad term to a reasonable scope instead of voiding the whole promise.

Modification is discretionary. Bess said enforcement “remains a matter of equitable discretion and should be granted only when neither injury to the public interest nor injustice to the parties will result.” An overbreadth argument can shrink the territory or period you are held to, so I suggest pairing it with facts on hardship and on where the goodwill you sold actually came from.

What Other Defenses Can a Seller Raise Against the Buyer’s Claim?

Defenses that attack how the covenant was made, such as duress or a lack of consideration (something given in exchange for the promise), are available but face a sale’s facts. In Bess, the seller argued both. On duress, the court found “no evidence indicating that defendant’s will was not his own when he signed the contract.” On consideration, the seller said he signed after the deal was complete and got nothing extra. The court said the district court “could have found, however, that the signing was contemporaneous with and a part of the transaction and that the $10,000 therefore supported the covenant as well.” Whether a covenant in a later employment or consulting agreement needed consideration of its own turns on the rule for employee covenants quoted under the noncompete ban.

The general contract defenses, from mistake to waiver, are summarized on the page about common defenses to a breach of contract claim. The defenses built on your own covenant are the date and document it sits in, its words, and its reasonableness. Each has its own section: the noncompete ban, what counts as competing, and a covenant that is too broad.

How Does the Buyer’s Unpaid Note or Earnout Affect Your Covenant?

A buyer’s missed payments do not automatically free you from the covenant. Whether they excuse your promise turns on your purchase agreement and on whether the buyer’s breach is material. Kuhn v. Dunn, 8 N.W.3d 633 (Minn. 2024) involved sellers of a family farm who canceled a contract for deed after the buyer’s breach. The Minnesota Supreme Court defined a material breach as “a breach that goes to the essence of the parties’ agreement.” Quoting an earlier decision, it noted the rule “that only a material breach of a contract or a substantial failure in its performance justifies a party thereto in rescinding.”

The risk runs the other way too. In Haynes, the buyers stopped paying the installments, leaving about $7,000 unpaid, while the seller was serving Austin clients from Red Wing. The sellers sued for the balance and lost: the Minnesota Supreme Court affirmed a summary judgment that dismissed their suit and preserved for trial the buyers’ counterclaim for damages for breach of the covenant.

Your remedies for the money are separate claims. A seller carrying a note has the options on the page about a buyer who stopped paying the seller note. A seller whose contingent payments were cut short can start with earnouts in Minnesota business sales. If you sold your stake to your co-owners rather than an outside buyer, the claims a former owner can bring after a buyout are laid out from the remaining owners’ side.

How Does a Temporary Injunction Against a Seller Work?

A temporary injunction is a court order that can stop your new work while the lawsuit is pending, and Minnesota’s rules give you notice, a hearing, and protection if the order proves wrong. Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.02(a) provides: “No temporary injunction shall be granted without notice of motion or an order to show cause to the adverse party.”

If the court grants the order, security protects you. Under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.03(a), no order “shall be granted except upon the giving of security by the applicant, in such sum as the court deems proper, for the payment of such costs and damages as may be incurred or suffered by any party who is found to have been wrongfully enjoined or restrained.” I suggest giving the court a figure for what the order would cost you, because Rule 65.03(a) leaves the amount to the court. A restraining order granted without notice can be challenged under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.01: “On written or oral notice to the party who obtained the ex parte temporary restraining order, the adverse party may appear and move its dissolution or modification, and in that event the court shall proceed to hear and determine such motion as expeditiously as the ends of justice require.”

In Dahlberg Bros., Inc. v. Ford Motor Co., 137 N.W.2d 314 (Minn. 1965), a car dealer’s franchise case, the Minnesota Supreme Court reviewed a temporary injunction “in light of five considerations which we consider relevant in deciding whether the determination made by the trial court should be sustained on appeal.” The page about temporary injunctions in Minnesota business cases explains how each consideration works, the general steps for obtaining an order under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65, and who an order binds under Minn. R. Civ. P. 65.04. A bare claim of harm is not enough. In Carl Bolander & Sons Co. v. City of Minneapolis, 502 N.W.2d 203 (Minn. 1993), the court said a “mere statement that it is suffering or will suffer irreparable injury, without more, is not enough to support a claim for injunctive relief.” A seller’s covenant is measured differently from an employee’s on this point. In Peterson v. Johnson Nut Co., 283 N.W. 561 (Minn. 1939), a suit to enforce a covenant made in the sale of a business, the Minnesota Supreme Court set employee covenants apart and said: “Where an established business has been sold with its good will and there is a valid covenant not to compete in certain territory, in this state and others, the breach is regarded as the controlling factor, and relief follows almost as a matter of course.”

A buyer can argue that harm should be inferred. In St. Jude Medical, Inc. v. Carter, 913 N.W.2d 678 (Minn. 2018), an employee-covenant case about a permanent injunction, the court listed situations “where customer good will is at stake” as ones where a court may infer irreparable harm. It added that “such an inference can be rebutted by evidence to the contrary.” Evidence that rebuts it can include records showing that the customers who left had reasons of their own.

What Damages Can the Buyer Recover From You?

The buyer can recover profits it lost because of your breach when it proves them with reasonable certainty, and in an employee-covenant case the Minnesota Supreme Court let the violator’s own profits measure damages. In Cardinal Consulting Co. v. Circo Resorts, Inc., 297 N.W.2d 260 (Minn. 1980), a tour operator’s suit against a hotel, the Minnesota Supreme Court quoted earlier decisions: lost profits “may be recovered where they are shown to be the natural and probable consequences of the act or omission complained of and their amount is shown with a reasonable degree of certainty and exactness.” It added: “The controlling principle is that speculative, remote, or conjectural damages are not recoverable.”

A buyer’s revenue can fall for reasons that have nothing to do with you: lost staff, price changes, or the market. In Cherne Industrial, Inc. v. Grounds & Associates, Inc., 278 N.W.2d 81 (Minn. 1979), an employee-covenant case, the court said that “the violator of a covenant not to compete may be required to account for his profits, and such illegal profits may properly measure the damages.” I suggest keeping your own records of which customers you served, when, and how each came to you, because those records bear on both the buyer’s lost profits and any claim to your profits. A damages claim can proceed on its own: in Haynes, the buyers’ counterclaim for damages for breach of the covenant was preserved for trial after the sellers’ own suit was dismissed.

What Are the Options for Resolving the Buyer’s Claim?

A seller accused of breaking a sale noncompete has five options. You can talk directly with the buyer, pause or reshape the disputed work, negotiate a release or a narrower covenant, answer formally through an attorney, or defend the claim in court. Each fits a different relationship with the buyer and carries a different cost. The first three keep the dispute out of court, and the last two prepare for it.

  1. A direct owner-to-owner conversation. This fits when you still work with the buyer on a transition, are owed money on a note, or think the buyer misread your work. The risk is that what you say can later serve as evidence, so I suggest sticking to facts about the work itself.
  2. Pausing or reshaping the disputed work. Moving a project outside the territory, turning away customers from the business you sold, or waiting out the remaining term can limit both damages and the case for an order. Moving your office alone may not be enough. In Haynes, the seller opened an office about 100 miles away but kept serving clients from the town he had sold out of. On the record before the court, he still lost on summary judgment. The cost is income during the pause.
  3. A negotiated release or narrowed covenant. A payment for release of the remaining term, a smaller territory, or an agreed list of customers you may serve can end the dispute. A signed amendment should say which original terms survive, because that settles later what still binds you.
  4. A formal written response. A letter that quotes the covenant, describes your work accurately, and states your defenses puts your position on paper before a lawsuit. It also tells the buyer what it would have to prove.
  5. Defending the lawsuit. This fits when your work falls outside the covenant’s words, the covenant was signed outside the sale, or the buyer cannot show harm. For a valid covenant made in the sale, Peterson treats the breach as “the controlling factor” for an order. The cost is time and fees, and a temporary injunction can stop your work while the case is pending.
Can I breach the noncompete by serving former customers without soliciting them?

You can, if the covenant’s words reach that work. In Haynes v. Monson, 224 N.W.2d 482 (Minn. 1974), a seller moved 100 miles away but kept his home in the town he had sold out of. Client information was still delivered there, and he did work for 45 to 50 clients from that town. Deciding “on the basis of the record before us,” the Minnesota Supreme Court said that a seller with a sizable clientele built over many years did not need to solicit: “active solicitation on his part is unnecessary to compete so as to defeat the covenant.”

Does the noncompete still bind me after its time period ends?

A court generally will not order you to stop once the period has run; damages for breach during the term are a separate question. In Cherne Industrial, Inc. v. Grounds & Associates, Inc., 278 N.W.2d 81 (Minn. 1979), an employee-covenant case, the Minnesota Supreme Court said that “if the restrictive period of a covenant not to compete has expired, an injunction will not be granted to enforce the covenant,” allowing exceptions. Resting a longer order on the duty not to use confidential information, it said “we need not decide whether this injunction could be issued as a remedy for the breach of the covenant not to compete.” In Haynes, a damages counterclaim was preserved for trial.

Does a clause saying the buyer will suffer irreparable harm mean the court must enjoin me?

No. In St. Jude Medical, Inc. v. Carter, 913 N.W.2d 678 (Minn. 2018), an employee-covenant case about a permanent injunction, the Minnesota Supreme Court held that the district court was not required to find irreparable harm based “solely on the language of a private agreement.” It said it “may be appropriate for a district court to infer irreparable harm” where “customer good will is at stake,” which gives a buyer of goodwill an argument, but “such an inference can be rebutted by evidence to the contrary.”

Answering a Buyer’s Noncompete Claim in Minnesota

Section 181.988 bans covenants not to compete between an employee and employer. As an exception to that ban, it makes a covenant made during the sale of a business valid and enforceable. The seller and buyer may agree on one limited in time and to a reasonable area. Under Bess, a court asks whether the covenant exceeds the protection needed for the goodwill sold, places an undue hardship on you, or harms the public. It may narrow an overbroad covenant instead of voiding it. Under Haynes, decided “on the basis of the record before us,” a seller with a long-built clientele who kept his home in the territory and still had client information delivered there lost on summary judgment for serving former customers without soliciting them. Your position rests on the covenant’s date and document, its exact words, and evidence of what your new work actually is. The deal terms behind this covenant are part of my work on buying and selling businesses.

If the buyer of your business says your new work violates your noncompete, email [email protected] with a brief description of the claim and your new work. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.