Yes, a Minnesota court can order a defendant’s assets attached or garnished before you win, but only on grounds the statutes list and only after you post a bond. The two main tools are a prejudgment attachment and a prejudgment garnishment. In an attachment, the sheriff seizes and holds the defendant’s property; in a garnishment, a bank or other third party holds money it owes the defendant. A defendant that simply owes you money and is slow to pay does not meet the grounds for either court order.

This page is for the owner of a Minnesota business suing another business for money who worries the defendant will spend, hide, or move its assets before the case ends. Minnesota’s attachment statute, chapter 570 of Minnesota Statutes, and its garnishment statute, chapter 571, set the rules. If the lawsuit is still ahead of you, my page on suing a customer for unpaid invoices covers the claim itself. This page belongs to my material on business litigation.

How Can You Freeze a Defendant’s Assets Before Judgment in Minnesota?

You ask the judge in your lawsuit for one of two orders: an attachment of the defendant’s property or a garnishment summons served on a third party who holds the defendant’s money. Both orders secure a future judgment; neither pays you before you win. Each has its own grounds, hearing, and bond.

Attachment. Under Minn. Stat. § 570.01, in a civil action for money “the claimant, at the time of commencement of the civil action or at any time afterward, may have the property of the respondent attached in the manner and in the circumstances prescribed in sections 570.01 to 570.14, as security for the satisfaction of any judgment that the claimant may recover.” The respondent is the party whose property would be attached: Minn. Stat. § 570.011, subd. 3, defines it as “a party against whom an order of attachment is requested.” Under § 570.01, “The order for attachment may be issued only by a judge of the court in the county in which the civil action is pending. All property not exempt from execution under the judgment demanded in the civil action is subject to attachment.”

Prejudgment garnishment. Under Minn. Stat. § 571.71, a creditor may serve a garnishment summons on a third party “(1) at the time the civil action is commenced or at any time after the commencement of the civil action, but before the entry of a judgment, if the court orders the issuance of the garnishment summons pursuant to section 571.93.” A garnishment reaches what a bank, a customer of the defendant, or another third party holds for the defendant.

Attachment fits property the defendant controls, such as equipment, inventory, vehicles, or real estate. Garnishment fits money in someone else’s hands, such as a bank balance or a receivable.

What Grounds Allow a Prejudgment Attachment?

An attachment requires one of six grounds, each tied to something the defendant has done. Minn. Stat. § 570.02, subd. 1, provides: “An order of attachment that is intended to provide security for the satisfaction of a judgment may be issued only in the following situations”

  1. “(1) when the respondent has assigned, secreted, or disposed of, or is about to assign, secrete, or dispose of, any of the respondent’s nonexempt property, with intent to delay or defraud the respondent’s creditors”
  2. “(2) when the respondent has removed, or is about to remove, any of the respondent’s nonexempt property from this state, with intent to delay or defraud the respondent’s creditors”
  3. “(3) when the respondent has converted or is about to convert any of the respondent’s nonexempt property into money or credits, for the purpose of placing the property beyond the reach of the respondent’s creditors”
  4. “(4) when the respondent has committed an intentional fraud giving rise to the claim upon which the civil action is brought”
  5. “(5) when the respondent has committed any act or omission, for which the respondent has been convicted of a felony, giving rise to the claim upon which the civil action is brought”
  6. “(6) when the respondent has violated the law of this state respecting unfair, discriminatory, and other unlawful practices in business, commerce, or trade, including but not limited to any of the statutes specifically enumerated in section 8.31, subdivision 1.”

Proving a ground takes facts, not the statute’s words. In Greene v. Environmental Development Corp., 415 N.W.2d 374 (Minn. Ct. App. 1987), the Court of Appeals stated, citing an earlier decision, that “Evidence supporting an order of attachment must be by testimony or affidavit alleging specific facts and must be more than a mere recitation of the statutory grounds for attachment.” Because a defendant rarely admits its intent, the court added: “Intent must be shown by inference or presumption.” There, homeowners suing a builder showed that money they paid for their home went into a model home owned personally by the company’s chairman, who had put that home on the market. I suggest collecting the bank records, sale listings, and messages that show what the defendant is doing with its property, because the affidavit must set out those facts.

What Must You Prove at the Attachment Hearing?

At the hearing you must show that you will probably win and that a ground exists, and the court can still refuse if there is no real risk to collecting. Minn. Stat. § 570.026, subd. 3, provides: “An order for attachment may be issued only if the claimant has demonstrated the probability of success on the merits, and the claimant has demonstrated facts that show the existence of at least one of the grounds stated in section 570.02.”

The usual route is a motion on notice. Under subdivision 1, “A claimant seeking to obtain an order of attachment in other than extraordinary circumstances shall proceed by motion,” with an affidavit setting out the claim and the facts behind a ground. Subdivision 2 requires the motion to be served like a summons, unless that service is impracticable or ineffective and the court prescribes another method, and it adds: “If the respondent has already appeared in the action, the motion shall be served in the manner prescribed for service of pleadings subsequent to the summons.” The motion must also carry a statutory notice. That notice tells the defendant, in capital letters: “IF YOU DO NOT ATTEND THIS HEARING, THE COURT MAY ORDER YOUR NONEXEMPT PROPERTY TO BE SEIZED.”

Even when you meet the standard, subdivision 3 bars the order in two situations:

  1. “(1) the circumstances do not constitute a risk to collectibility of any judgment that may be entered”
  2. “(2)(i) respondent has raised a defense to the merits of the claimant’s claim or has raised a counterclaim in an amount equal to or greater than the claim and the defense or counterclaim is not frivolous; and (ii) the interests of the respondent cannot be adequately protected by a bond filed by the claimant pursuant to section 570.041 if property is attached; and (iii) the harm suffered by the respondent as a result of seizure would be greater than the harm which would be suffered by the claimant if property is not attached.”

In Greene, the Court of Appeals found “ample evidence of a clear risk to collectibility of any judgment the Greenes might obtain,” and it found that the defendants’ defenses were not frivolous but that a bond would adequately protect the chairman. The trial court’s order had been “an invitation to Endeco and Werdan to elect either to (1) post a $65,000 bond or (2) face the issuance of an order of attachment for $120,056.21.” The Court of Appeals explained that “The court was unwilling to issue the attachment if some other means could be devised to protect the Greenes’ interests,” and it held that “The issuance of an order for attachment was properly conditioned on the posting of a $65,000 bond.”

When the court denies attachment under the second bar after you made your showing, subdivision 4 requires a different order “protecting the rights of the claimant to the extent possible.” Subdivision 4 provides: “The order may require that the respondent post a bond in an amount set by the court, that the respondent make the property available for inspection from time to time, that the respondent be restrained from certain activities, including, but not limited to, selling, disposing, or otherwise encumbering property, or any other provision the court may deem appropriate.”

When Can a Court Order Attachment Before the Defendant Is Heard?

A court can order attachment before any hearing only on a written application that meets four conditions. They are a good-faith effort to tell the defendant (unless telling it would endanger collection), a probable win on the merits, one of four listed grounds, and extraordinary circumstances. Minn. Stat. § 570.025, subd. 2, allows a preliminary order before the hearing “only if the following conditions are met: (1) the claimant has made a good faith effort to inform the respondent of the application for a preliminary attachment order or that informing the respondent would endanger the ability of the claimant to recover upon a judgment subsequently awarded; (2) the claimant has demonstrated the probability of success on the merits; (3) the claimant has demonstrated the existence of one or more of the grounds specified in section 570.02, subdivision 1, clause (1), (2), (3), or (6); and (4) due to extraordinary circumstances, the claimant’s interests cannot be protected pending a hearing by an appropriate order of the court, other than by directing a prehearing seizure of property.” Grounds (4) and (5) of § 570.02, intentional fraud and a felony conviction, are not among the grounds clause (3) of § 570.025, subd. 2, allows before a hearing.

The application must be supported by affidavits or testimony stating the claim, the facts behind the ground, and “a good faith estimate, based on facts known to the claimant, of any harm that would be suffered by the respondent if a preliminary attachment order is entered.”

The defendant then gets a prompt hearing. Under subdivision 4, “At the hearing, the burden of proof shall be on the claimant.” Subdivision 5 adds a cost for misuse: “if the court finds that the motion for a prehearing attachment order was made in bad faith, the court shall award respondent the actual damages, including reasonable attorney’s fees, suffered by reason of seizure of the property.”

How Does a Prejudgment Garnishment Reach Bank Accounts and Receivables?

A prejudgment garnishment order lets you serve a garnishment summons requiring a third party, such as the defendant’s bank or one of its customers, to hold what it owes the defendant. The hold is capped at 110% of the unpaid claim and lasts until a writ of execution, a release, a court order, or operation of law ends it. Minn. Stat. § 571.93, subd. 1, provides: “The court may order the issuance of a garnishment summons before judgment or default in the civil action, if a summons and complaint, or copies of these documents, are filed with the appropriate court, and if, upon application to the court, it appears that any of the following grounds exist”

The grounds in clauses (1) through (5) track the first five attachment grounds. Clause (6) covers garnishment to establish jurisdiction over property in listed situations. Clause (7) covers a creditor that “has been unable to serve upon the debtor the summons and complaint in the civil action because the debtor has been inaccessible due to residence and employment in a building where access is restricted.”

The procedure is similar to attachment. Under Minn. Stat. § 571.932, subd. 3, “An order for prejudgment garnishment may be issued only if the creditor has demonstrated the probability of success on the merits, and the creditor has stated facts that show the existence of at least one of the grounds stated in section 571.93, subdivision 1.” The same subdivision bars the order on the risk-to-collectibility and defense-and-harm grounds that apply to attachment. An order before any hearing requires a written application and, under Minn. Stat. § 571.931, subd. 2, four conditions: “(1) the creditor has made a good faith effort to inform the debtor of the application for a prejudgment garnishment order or that informing the debtor would endanger the ability of the creditor to recover upon a judgment subsequently awarded; (2) the creditor has demonstrated the probability of success on the merits; (3) the creditor has demonstrated the existence of one or more of the grounds specified in section 571.93, subdivision 1; and (4) due to extraordinary circumstances, the creditor’s interests cannot be protected pending a hearing by an appropriate order of the court, other than by directing a prehearing seizure of property.”

Two limits shape what a garnishment holds:

  1. The amount. Under Minn. Stat. § 571.72, subd. 2, the summons must state “(5) that the garnishee shall retain disposable earnings, indebtedness, money, or property of the debtor in the garnishee’s possession or under the garnishee’s control not in excess of 110 percent of the amount of the claim that remains unpaid,” until a writ of execution, a release, a court order, or operation of law.
  2. The time. Under Minn. Stat. § 571.79, “Except as provided in paragraph (h), the garnishee, after disclosure, shall be discharged of any further retention obligation to the creditor with respect to a specific garnishment summons when one of the following conditions are met,” including: “(c) If the garnishee was served with a garnishment summons before entry of judgment against the debtor by the creditor in the civil action and the garnishee has retained any disposable earnings, indebtedness, money, or property of the debtor, 270 days after the garnishment summons is served the garnishee is discharged and the garnishee shall return any disposable earnings, indebtedness, money, and property to the debtor.” Paragraph (h) provides: “The garnishee is not discharged if within 20 days of the service of the garnishee’s disclosure or the return to the debtor of any disposable earnings, indebtedness money, or other property of the debtor, whichever is later, an interested person (1) serves a motion scheduled to be heard within 30 days of the service of the motion relating to the garnishment, or (2) serves a motion scheduled to be heard within 30 days of the service of the motion for leave to file a supplemental complaint against the garnishee, as provided under section 571.75, subdivision 4, and the court upon proper showing vacates the discharge of the garnishee.” Check the current text of § 571.79 before relying on these periods.

When the defendant does not answer. Section 571.71 also allows a garnishment without a court order against a defendant in default. Clause (2) of § 571.71 permits it “(2) at any time 45 days or more after service of the summons and complaint upon the debtor in the civil action when a judgment by default could have, but has not, been entered pursuant to Rule 55.01(a) of the Minnesota Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts.” That clause of § 571.71 continues: “Garnishment under this clause is effective only after the Notice of Intent to Garnish form in section 571.72, subdivision 11, and the Exemption form in section 571.72, subdivision 10, are served on the debtor at any time 20 or more days after the service of the Summons and Complaint and, in addition, the creditor does not receive an Answer from the debtor within 25 days after service of the Notice of Intent to Garnish.” Clause (2) of § 571.71 then limits the creditor’s default judgment: “If a creditor sends a Notice of Intent to Garnish form to a debtor under this clause, the creditor cannot obtain a default judgment against the debtor under Rule 55.01(a) of the Minnesota Rules of Civil Procedure for the District Courts until 25 days after the service of the Notice of Intent to Garnish form.” Clause (2) of § 571.71 ends: “No filing of a pleading or other documents by the creditor is required to issue a garnishment summons under this clause; however, the creditor must comply with the service requirement of section 571.72, subdivision 4.” Check the current text of § 571.71 before relying on these periods.

When the defendant is an individual with a bank account. Minn. Stat. § 571.911 provides: “If the garnishment summons is used to garnish funds of a debtor who is a natural person and if the funds to be garnished are held on deposit at a financial institution, the creditor shall serve with the garnishee summons a notice, instructions, and two copies of an exemption notice,” and “Failure of the creditor to send the exemption notice renders the garnishment void, and the financial institution shall take no action.” My page on garnishing a debtor’s bank account walks through those bank forms and steps.

What Does the Attachment Bond Cover if You Lose?

The bond covers the defendant’s costs and the damages your attachment caused if the defendant wins or the order is vacated. Minn. Stat. § 570.041, subd. 1, provides: “Before issuing any order of attachment, the court shall require the claimant to post a bond in the penal sum of at least $500, conditioned that if judgment be given for the respondent or if the order is vacated, the claimant will pay all costs that may be awarded against the claimant and all damages caused by the attachment.”

Your exposure can exceed the bond. The same subdivision provides: “Damages may be awarded in a sum in excess of the bond only if, before issuance of the order establishing the amount of the bond, the respondent specifically notified the claimant and the court of the likelihood that the respondent would suffer the specific damages, or the court finds that the claimant acted in bad faith in bringing or pursuing the attachment proceeding.” The subdivision ends: “Nothing in this section shall modify or restrict the application of section 549.20 or 549.211.” In setting the amount, the court considers the value and nature of the property, how it will be stored, and the potential harm to the defendant. Under subdivision 3, “In lieu of filing a bond, either the claimant or the respondent may satisfy bonding requirements by depositing cash, a letter of credit, a cashier’s check, or a certified check with the court.”

The other costs of freezing assets come from the same chapters:

  1. A garnishment bond. Under Minn. Stat. § 571.932, subd. 6, “(a) Before issuing an order of garnishment, the court shall require the creditor to post a bond in the penal sum of at least $500, conditioned that if judgment be given for the debtor or if the order is vacated, the creditor will pay all costs that may be awarded against the creditor and all damages caused by the garnishment.” Damages above that bond are limited in the same way, to cases of advance notice of the specific damages or bad faith, and the subdivision likewise provides: “Nothing in this section modifies or restricts the application of section 549.20 or 549.211.”
  2. Bad-faith damages. For a garnishment ordered before a hearing, Minn. Stat. § 571.931, subd. 5, provides that “if the court finds that the motion for a prejudgment garnishment order was made in bad faith, the court shall award debtor the actual damages, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees, suffered by reason of the prejudgment garnishment.”
  3. The sheriff’s charges. Under Minn. Stat. § 570.131, subd. 2, “If the order of attachment is vacated, the claimant shall be responsible for payment of any charges and expenses incurred by the sheriff.” If you win, Minn. Stat. § 570.08 provides: “The fees and costs of the sheriff shall be deducted before any payment to the claimant.”

Damages from a seizure can be large when the property runs a business, such as inventory or equipment the defendant needs to operate. I suggest asking the court to name specific property in the order rather than all nonexempt property, because the bond under § 570.041 covers “all damages caused by the attachment,” and seizing less property can cause less damage.

How Does the Sheriff Carry Out an Attachment, and How Long Does It Last?

The sheriff seizes and holds the property the order names, and the order and the attachment each expire on events the statute sets. Under Minn. Stat. § 570.051, subd. 1, the order must “(4) direct the sheriff of the county in which the court is located or of any other county to seize and safely keep all nonexempt property of the respondent or such specific property as the court may specify, or so much as is necessary to satisfy the amount claimed with expenses and costs using the full force of the county”

The sheriff’s window. Minn. Stat. § 570.061, subd. 1, provides: “If the sheriff does not attach property within 90 days after the order is issued by the court, or such further time as the court may order, the order shall automatically terminate.” Check the current text of § 570.061 before relying on this period.

The lien. For real estate, subdivision 2 provides: “The attachment shall be a lien on the interest of the respondent in the real estate from the time of recording with the recorder or registrar.” For other property, subdivision 3 provides: “Attachment of personal property shall be a lien on the interest of the respondent in the personal property from the time of seizure by the sheriff or subjection to the control of the sheriff.”

Expiration. Under Minn. Stat. § 570.131, subd. 2, the attachment expires on the defendant’s demand or at the sheriff’s discretion in four situations. They are “(1) in cases in which the civil action was commenced by delivery of the summons and complaint to the sheriff, service of process in the civil action is not obtained on the respondent within 60 days after the order for attachment or such further time as the court specifies”; “(2) judgment is entered in favor of the respondent”; “(3) no judgment is entered against the respondent within three years after the date of the order of attachment or such further time as the court specifies”; and “(4) the property subject to an attachment is not sold or otherwise applied to the judgment within six months after the date when the judgment becomes final and nonappealable.” Check the current text of § 570.131 before relying on these periods. If you win, § 570.08 provides: “If judgment is recovered by the claimant, the sheriff shall satisfy the judgment out of the property attached, if sufficient, first paying to claimant the proceeds of sales of perishable property and of all credits collected by the sheriff, or so much as may be required. If a balance remains due and an execution on the judgment is issued, the sheriff shall sell as much of the attached property as may be necessary to satisfy the balance.” My page on collecting a judgment from a business explains the writ of execution and the other post-judgment tools.

When Is a Fraudulent-Transfer Claim, Injunction, or Receiver the Better Tool?

When the defendant has already moved assets to someone else, a claim to undo the transfer can reach the asset in the hands of the person who received it. The statute gives some recipients protections. Under Minn. Stat. § 513.47, a creditor suing over the transfer, “subject to the limitations in section 513.48,” may obtain “(2) an attachment or other provisional remedy against the asset transferred or other property of the transferee if available under applicable law.” Subject to principles of equity, it may also obtain “(i) an injunction against further disposition by the debtor or a transferee, or both, of the asset transferred or of other property,” or a receiver. My page on how a creditor can undo a debtor’s transfer of assets explains the grounds and the remedies.

An injunction is an order to do or stop doing something, rather than a seizure. The attachment statute itself lets a court that denies attachment under the defense-and-harm bar restrain the defendant from selling property, as explained under What Must You Prove at the Attachment Hearing?. For a court order stopping conduct while a case is pending, see my pages on the temporary injunction and on getting a temporary restraining order.

A receiver takes control of property for the court, and the grounds before judgment are narrow. Minn. Stat. § 576.25, subd. 2, provides: “Except where judgment for failure to answer may be had without application to the court, a limited receiver may be appointed before judgment to protect any party to an action who demonstrates an apparent right to property that is the subject of the action and is in the possession of an adverse party, and that the property or its rents and profits are in danger of loss or material impairment.” Subdivision 4 adds that “a limited or general receiver may be appointed when a corporation or other entity is dissolved, insolvent, in imminent danger of insolvency, or has forfeited its corporate rights and in like cases of the property within the state of foreign corporations and other entities.” My page on receivership explains what a receiver controls and who pays for it.

What Are the Options Besides a Court Order?

A court order is one way to protect a future judgment, and several business steps can protect it faster or at lower cost. Each fits a different defendant:

  1. An owner-to-owner conversation. A defendant with a cash problem may agree to a payment schedule it can meet. This fits a defendant that wants to keep the relationship or its reputation, and it risks giving the defendant time to move assets if it is acting in bad faith.
  2. Security by agreement. A settlement or payment plan can include a personal guarantee from an owner, a security interest in equipment or receivables, or money placed in escrow. This fits a defendant that disputes the timing more than the debt, and its value depends on what the guarantor or the collateral is worth.
  3. Stopping further credit. Holding new orders until the balance is paid limits how much more you can lose. It fits an ongoing customer, and your contract’s payment and termination terms affect whether you may stop.
  4. A default. A defendant that ignores the complaint can face a default judgment. Where § 571.71, clause (2), allows it, the defendant can also face a garnishment without a court order, as explained under How Does a Prejudgment Garnishment Reach Bank Accounts and Receivables?. Sending the Notice of Intent to Garnish under that clause delays the default judgment, as that section quotes. This fits a defendant with no defense, and it does nothing to stop a defendant that answers.
  5. An attachment or garnishment motion. This fits a defendant whose own conduct meets a statutory ground. It costs a bond and the work of a specific-facts affidavit, and it carries the damages risk explained under What Does the Attachment Bond Cover if You Lose?.

I suggest weighing these against what the defendant owns and how fast it is moving, because each route reaches different property. An attachment reaches the defendant’s own property, a garnishment reaches what a third party holds for it, and a claim to undo the transfer reaches property already transferred.

Can I freeze a customer's bank account just because it is not paying me?

Nonpayment alone is not a ground for a court order. Minn. Stat. § 571.93, subd. 1, lets a court order a garnishment before judgment where “it appears that any of the following grounds exist.” The listed grounds, such as hiding or moving property with intent to delay or defraud creditors, do not include nonpayment alone. If the customer never answers, a garnishment without a court order may be possible under conditions in Minn. Stat. § 571.71, clause (2). The section How Does a Prejudgment Garnishment Reach Bank Accounts and Receivables? quotes that clause.

Do I have to start the lawsuit before asking for an attachment?

Yes. Minn. Stat. § 570.01 makes attachment part of a civil action for money, available “at the time of commencement of the civil action or at any time afterward.” A prejudgment garnishment order has a similar starting point: Minn. Stat. § 571.93, subd. 1, requires that “a summons and complaint, or copies of these documents, are filed with the appropriate court,” and that one of the grounds listed in that subdivision exists. I suggest preparing the attachment affidavit alongside the complaint, because the motion can then be filed when the case starts.

Can I attach the owner's personal property if I sued only the company?

No. Under Minn. Stat. § 570.01, the claimant may have “the property of the respondent attached,” and Minn. Stat. § 570.011, subd. 3, defines the respondent as a party against whom an order of attachment is requested. An owner who is not a party to your lawsuit is not a respondent. If the owner is also a defendant, for example on a personal guarantee the owner signed, the same grounds and bond rules apply to the owner’s property.

Can the defendant keep its property by posting its own bond?

Yes, if the court allows it. The notice Minn. Stat. § 570.026, subd. 2, requires tells the defendant: “If the court directs the sheriff to seize and secure the property while the lawsuit is pending, you may still keep the property until the lawsuit is decided if you file a bond in an amount set by the court.” Subdivision 5 provides: “An order requiring seizure of property may be stayed up to three days to allow the respondent time to post a bond.” Check the current text of § 570.026 before relying on this period.

Is an attachment a lien on the defendant's real estate?

Yes, once it is recorded. Attaching real estate takes recording the sheriff’s certified copy of the order and a return of attachment with the county recorder, or the registrar of titles for registered land. The order and return are also served on or mailed to the defendant. Minn. Stat. § 570.061, subd. 2, provides: “The attachment shall be a lien on the interest of the respondent in the real estate from the time of recording with the recorder or registrar.” The lien reaches the defendant’s own interest in the property, not the interests of others who hold title or liens.

Freezing Assets Before a Minnesota Judgment

The main court orders for freezing assets before judgment in Minnesota are a prejudgment attachment and a court-ordered prejudgment garnishment. Each requires a statutory ground, a likely win, a real risk to collection, and a bond. The grounds look to what the defendant has done with its property or to you, such as hiding or moving property with intent to delay or defraud creditors, or intentional fraud. A defendant that only owes money does not meet them. A garnishment without a court order against a defendant that never answers turns on the conditions of § 571.71, clause (2), which How Does a Prejudgment Garnishment Reach Bank Accounts and Receivables? quotes. When assets have already moved, a claim to undo the transfer may be the better tool. This page is part of my material on business litigation.

If a defendant in your Minnesota lawsuit is moving or selling assets and you want to know whether an attachment or garnishment fits your facts, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.