A Minnesota business with defective work on its commercial building can recover when the work breaches the construction contract or a written warranty. The main claims are breach of the construction contract and, where the contractor or a manufacturer gave one, breach of an express written warranty. The rest of the claim turns mostly on your construction contract: what the contractor promised, how you must give notice, and where a dispute is heard. Minnesota law limits that last point. Under Minn. Stat. § 337.10, subd. 1, a provision in a building and construction contract to be performed in Minnesota is void and unenforceable if it makes the contract subject to another state’s laws. The same is true of a provision requiring that the dispute resolution process on the contract occur in another state.
This page is for the owner of a Minnesota business that hired a contractor to build or remodel its commercial building or space and then found defective work. The building side of construction law (contracts, licensing, and liens) is on my Minnesota construction attorney page. This page belongs to my material on business litigation.
What Claims Does a Commercial Owner Have for Defective Construction?
A commercial owner’s main claims are breach of contract and breach of an express written warranty. A contract claim covers work that does not match the plans and specifications, and a warranty claim covers a written promise about the quality of the work. A contract claim runs against the contractor you signed with, and a warranty claim runs against the contractor or manufacturer that gave the warranty. Minnesota’s construction time-limit statute, Minn. Stat. § 541.051, reaches both, except claims against “the manufacturer or supplier of any equipment or machinery installed upon real property,” which its subd. 1(e) excludes. Minn. Stat. § 541.051, subd. 1, opens by naming the claims it covers: “Except where fraud is involved, no action by any person in contract, tort, or otherwise to recover damages for any injury to property, real or personal, or for bodily injury or wrongful death, arising out of the defective and unsafe condition of an improvement to real property.” Its limits protect “any person performing or furnishing the design, planning, supervision, materials, or observation of construction or construction of the improvement to real property.”
A Minnesota Supreme Court case shows the usual shape of a commercial claim. In Day Masonry v. Independent School District 347, 781 N.W.2d 321 (Minn. 2010), a school district “commenced an arbitration proceeding against” the general contractor, the roofing contractor, and the roof membrane manufacturer over leaks in a new high school. The manufacturer had given the district two written warranties of its own, and the district’s contracts with the two contractors warranted “that all Work will be of good quality, free from faults and defects and in conformance with the Contract Documents.” The district brought both warranty claims and non-warranty claims, and the court treated the two kinds differently, as the section When Does the Clock Start on a Defect Claim Versus a Warranty Claim? explains.
How Do the Contract’s Warranty, Notice, and Cure Terms Shape the Claim?
Your construction contract sets many of the rules for your claim. It says what the contractor promised, how and when you must give notice, whether the contractor gets a chance to correct the work, and where a dispute is heard. Minnesota’s new-home warranty statute does not supply these steps for a commercial building, because its definitions in Minn. Stat. § 327A.01 reach dwellings and residential buildings. I suggest reading these terms before you send any letter, because a missed notice step can give the contractor a defense you did not need to hand it:
- The warranty. What the contractor promised about the work, for how long, and whether the promise is limited to repair or replacement.
- Notice and claims. Whether a claim must be in writing, to whom it goes, and any time the contract sets for giving it.
- Correction of the work. Whether the contractor has a right to come back and fix defects before you hire someone else.
- Dispute resolution. Whether disputes go first to mediation, then to arbitration or court.
- Damage limits. Any waiver of consequential damages or cap on the contractor’s liability.
- Contract time limits. In Day Masonry, the arbitration clause provided that a demand “in no event shall . . . be made after the date when institution of legal or equitable proceedings based on such claim, dispute or other matter in question would be barred by the applicable statute of limitations.”
How warranties are created, disclaimed, and enforced generally is covered on my page about express and implied warranties in Minnesota. The ways to measure what you can recover (repair cost, lost value, and the rest) are on my page about remedies for breach of contract.
How Long Does a Commercial Owner Have to Bring a Defect Claim?
Minn. Stat. § 541.051 measures an owner’s time to bring a claim from discovery, inside an outer limit measured from “substantial completion of the construction.” For a claim arising out of a defective and unsafe condition, subd. 1 bars an action brought “more than two years after the cause of action accrues, as specified in paragraph (c), nor in any event shall such a cause of action accrue more than ten years after substantial completion of the construction.” For a warranty claim, subd. 4 provides that, as to “actions based on breach of an express written warranty, such actions shall be brought within two years of the discovery of the breach.” Under subd. 1(e), these periods do not apply to the manufacturer or supplier of installed equipment or machinery. The statute for equipment bought as goods is quoted under Who Besides the General Contractor Can Be Responsible? A limited extension, quoted in the list that follows, applies to a claim that accrues in the ninth or tenth year. Check the current text of § 541.051 before relying on these periods.
The statute defines the starting points and the outer limits:
- Substantial completion. “Date of substantial completion shall be determined by the date when construction is sufficiently completed so that the owner or the owner’s representative can occupy or use the improvement for the intended purpose.”
- Accrual. A property-damage claim accrues “for an action for injury to real or personal property, upon discovery of the injury, but in no event does a cause of action accrue earlier than substantial completion, termination, or abandonment of the construction or the improvement to real property.”
- Ending the general contractor’s contract. In American Family Insurance Co. v. NB Electric, Inc., No. A24-0377 (Minn. July 22, 2026), the Minnesota Supreme Court held that “terminating the contract with the general contractor for the construction or the improvement to real property constitutes” the “termination” named in the accrual rule above. There, a fire damaged a home during a remodel. The homeowner hired a new general contractor and then discontinued the first general contractor’s services, and the court reinstated the district court’s dismissal of the insurer’s action as time-barred.
- Late discovery. Under subd. 2, for a cause of action “which accrues during the ninth or tenth year after substantial completion of the construction, an action to recover damages may be brought within two years after the date on which the cause of action accrued, but in no event may such an action be brought more than 12 years after substantial completion of the construction.” Check the current text of subd. 2 before relying on these periods.
- Warranty claims. In Day Masonry, the Minnesota Supreme Court explained: “In 2004, the Minnesota Legislature amended subdivision 4 so that the ten-year statute of repose found in subdivision 1 of Minn. Stat. § 541.051 would also apply to breach-of-warranty claims.” The court did not decide whether that limit barred the district’s warranty claims; it remanded “the question of whether the statute of repose operates to bar the School District’s warranty claims to the court of appeals for further consideration.” Check the current text of § 541.051, subd. 1, before relying on that period.
One qualifier applies to contract claims. Minnesota’s general statute, Minn. Stat. § 541.05, subd. 1, provides: “Except where the Uniform Commercial Code otherwise prescribes, the following actions shall be commenced within six years” and lists an action “upon a contract or other obligation, express or implied, as to which no other limitation is expressly prescribed.” Whether § 541.051 governs a particular claim depends on whether it arises out of the “defective and unsafe condition of an improvement to real property,” in the words of § 541.051, subd. 1. I suggest treating the § 541.051 periods as the ones that apply until the contract and the facts show otherwise, because a claim that misses them may be lost. Check the current text of § 541.05 before relying on this period. Periods for other business claims are on my quick reference to Minnesota statutes of limitations for business claims.
When Does the Clock Start on a Defect Claim Versus a Warranty Claim?
A defect claim and a warranty claim start on different events. A claim for the defective condition accrues on discovery of the injury, while a warranty claim turns on discovery of the breach of the warranty. In Day Masonry, the Minnesota Supreme Court put it this way: “But a breach-of-warranty claim does not accrue upon knowledge of the injury.” For an express warranty, the court has “focused on the date the warrantor gives some affirmative indication that it will not or cannot” honor the warranty. The parties in that case agreed to treat the warranties as warranties of future performance, and the court decided the case on that footing.
The warranty claims came out differently. The district’s December 2004 letters to the general contractor and the roofing contractor forwarded an engineering report and named potential warranty claims, and the court held: “We therefore hold that the earliest the warranty claims could have accrued was December 2004.” It then held: “We therefore hold that the statute of limitations does not bar the School District’s warranty claims.” The statute-of-repose question on those claims went back to the court of appeals, and the court declined to reach the manufacturer’s separate arguments about an earlier letter and the warranty’s expiration date. The court added that a refusal “would most likely come in response to an affirmative request for performance,” but it left open whether written notice to the contractor is always required.
The district’s non-warranty claims were barred. Applying the standard of an earlier decision, the court explained that “a party need not be aware of the extent of its injury for the statute of limitations to begin to run so long as the party is aware of the injury and the need for repairs.” Two 2002 roof repair invoices referring to leaks, and custodians’ testimony about the leaks, were enough. The court treated the custodians as the district’s agents “to the extent they were entrusted with the upkeep” of the school: “Their knowledge of the leaks and the efforts they took to have the leaks repaired therefore is imputed to the School District.” The statute’s accrual rule for non-warranty claims was then in subd. 1(b) of § 541.051 and is now in subd. 1(c).
For an owner, the lesson from that record is practical. I suggest treating the first leak, crack, or failure reported by staff who take care of the building as the possible start of the clock. In Day Masonry, a later engineering report did not move that date.
What Role Does an Engineer or Other Expert Play in Proving the Defects?
An engineer, architect, or other consultant can identify what is wrong, what caused it, and what the repair will cost. In Day Masonry, the school district hired “Inspec, an independent forensic engineering and testing firm, to do a thorough investigation of the causes of the roof leaks at the high school.” The firm “issued two reports detailing the nature and cause of the roof leaks and recommending extensive repairs,” and “The recommended repairs totaled about two million dollars.” The district then sent the general contractor and the roofing contractor letters enclosing the report.
Documentation starts before the consultant arrives. I suggest these steps, because each preserves proof that is hard to recreate later:
- A dated record. I suggest logging each leak, crack, or failure with photos, the date, the location, and who saw it, because the log shows what was found and when.
- Repair invoices. I suggest keeping each one, because small invoices can show when you knew of a problem, as the 2002 invoices did in Day Masonry.
- Notify before you open up the work. I suggest giving the contractor written notice and a chance to attend before destructive testing or repairs, because the contractor may later dispute what the removed work showed.
- Save removed materials. I suggest keeping samples of failed materials until the claim is resolved, because they may be the best evidence of the defect.
A claim against an architect or engineer adds a formal expert step, explained under Who Besides the General Contractor Can Be Responsible?
Who Besides the General Contractor Can Be Responsible?
Subcontractors, material suppliers, architects, and engineers can share responsibility for a defect, and § 541.051’s time limits cover each of them. The protected persons listed in Minn. Stat. § 541.051, subd. 1 include anyone furnishing “the design, planning, supervision, materials” for the improvement. Equipment is the exception: “The limitations prescribed in this section do not apply to the manufacturer or supplier of any equipment or machinery installed upon real property.”
For equipment bought as goods, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725 provides: “An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within four years after the cause of action has accrued. By the original agreement the parties may reduce the period of limitation to not less than one year but may not extend it.” It adds: “A cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the breach. A breach of warranty occurs when tender of delivery is made, except that where a warranty explicitly extends to future performance of the goods and discovery of the breach must await the time of such performance the cause of action accrues when the breach is or should have been discovered.” Goods built into the building are treated differently: “The limitations in this section do not apply to actions for the breach of any contract for sale of a grain storage structure or other goods that are incorporated into an improvement to real property, except equipment and machinery. These actions are subject only to the statute of limitations set forth in section 541.051.” The section also “does not apply to claims against sellers of goods for damages to property caused by the goods where the property that is damaged is not the goods and the sale is not a sale between parties who are each merchants in goods of the kind.” Check the current text of § 336.2-725 before relying on these periods. How warranties work generally is on my page about express and implied warranties in Minnesota.
A claim against an architect or engineer for professional negligence carries a formal expert-affidavit step where expert testimony will be used to establish a prima facie case. The affidavit is served with the pleadings unless subd. 3(a), clause (2) or (3), applies. Under Minn. Stat. § 544.42, subd. 1, the term “professional” covers “a licensed attorney or an architect, certified public accountant, engineer, land surveyor, or landscape architect licensed or certified under chapter 326 or 326A.” An action under the section “includes an original claim, cross-claim, counterclaim, or third-party claim.” Subd. 2 applies “In an action against a professional alleging negligence or malpractice in rendering a professional service where expert testimony is to be used by a party to establish a prima facie case.” In that action the party must “(1) unless otherwise provided in subdivision 3, paragraph (a), clause (2) or (3), serve upon the opponent with the pleadings an affidavit as provided in subdivision 3.” The party must also “serve upon the opponent within 180 days of commencement of discovery under the Rules of Civil Procedure, rule 26.04(a) an affidavit as provided in subdivision 4.” Check the current text of § 544.42, subd. 2, before relying on that period.
Under subd. 3(a), the first affidavit “must be drafted by the party’s attorney and state that” one of three things. The first is that “the facts of the case have been reviewed by the party’s attorney with an expert whose qualifications provide a reasonable expectation that the expert’s opinions could be admissible at trial and that, in the opinion of this expert, the defendant deviated from the applicable standard of care and by that action caused injury to the plaintiff.” The second is that “the expert review required by clause (1) could not reasonably be obtained before the action was commenced because of the applicable statute of limitations.” The third is that “the parties have agreed to a waiver of the expert review required by clause (1) or the party has applied for a waiver or modification by the court under paragraph (c).”
Under subd. 3(b), “If an affidavit is executed under paragraph (a), clause (2), the affidavit in paragraph (a), clause (1), must be served on the defendant or the defendant’s counsel within 90 days after service of the summons and complaint.” Under subd. 3(c), “The certification of expert review required under this section may be waived or modified if the court where the matter will be venued determines, upon an application served with commencement of the action, that good cause exists for not requiring the certification.” That paragraph adds: “Good cause includes, but is not limited to, a showing that the action requires discovery to provide a reasonable basis for the expert’s opinion or the unavailability, after a good faith effort, of a qualified expert at reasonable cost.” It also provides: “If the court denies a request for a waiver under this subdivision, the plaintiff must serve on the defendant the affidavit required under subdivision 2, clause (1), within 60 days, and the affidavit required under subdivision 2, clause (2), within 180 days.” Under subd. 6, “Failure to comply with subdivision 2, clause (1), within 60 days after demand for the affidavit results, upon motion, in mandatory dismissal of each cause of action with prejudice as to which expert testimony is necessary to establish a prima facie case.” Subd. 6 also provides: “Failure to comply with subdivision 3, paragraph (b) or (c), results, upon motion, in mandatory dismissal of each cause of action with prejudice as to which expert testimony is necessary to establish a prima facie case.” Check the current text of § 544.42 before relying on these periods.
How Do Arbitration Clauses and Damage Waivers Affect the Claim?
An arbitration clause in your construction contract can move the whole dispute out of court, and a damages waiver can limit what you recover. Under Minn. Stat. § 572B.06, “An agreement contained in a record to submit to arbitration any existing or subsequent controversy arising between the parties to the agreement is valid, enforceable, and irrevocable except upon a ground that exists at law or in equity for the revocation of contract.” When one side asks a court to enforce the clause, Minn. Stat. § 572B.07 provides: “Unless the court finds that there is no enforceable agreement to arbitrate, it shall order the parties to arbitrate.” Under § 572B.06, “The court shall decide whether an agreement to arbitrate exists or a controversy is subject to an agreement to arbitrate, except in the case of a grievance arising under a collective bargaining agreement when an arbitrator shall decide.” The same section provides: “An arbitrator shall decide whether a condition precedent to arbitrability has been fulfilled and whether a contract containing a valid agreement to arbitrate is enforceable.” Under Minn. Stat. § 572B.04, “Except as otherwise provided in subsections (b) and (c), the parties to an agreement to arbitrate or to an arbitration proceeding may waive or vary the requirements of sections 572B.01 to 572B.31 to the extent permitted by law.” Its subsection (b) bars the parties, before a controversy arises, from waiving or varying “572B.06, subsection (a),” among other listed sections. The contracts in Day Masonry sent claims to arbitration, and the school district brought its claims by a demand for arbitration.
A waiver of consequential damages, if your contract has one, can limit which losses beyond the work itself you can recover. I suggest reading its list of excluded losses before you put a number on the claim, because a loss on that list may not be recoverable.
If the defective item is equipment or materials you bought as goods, Article 2 of Minnesota’s Uniform Commercial Code may apply. Minn. Stat. § 336.2-102 provides: “Unless the context otherwise requires, and except as provided in subsection (3), this article applies to transactions in goods and, in the case of a hybrid transaction, it applies to the extent provided in subsection (2).” For goods, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-719 provides: “Consequential damages may be limited or excluded unless the limitation or exclusion is unconscionable.” For accepted goods, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-607 provides that “the buyer must within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered any breach notify the seller of breach or be barred from any remedy.” The Article 2 statute on when a claim for equipment or machinery must be brought, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725, is quoted under Who Besides the General Contractor Can Be Responsible?
How cost, discovery, privacy, and appeal rights differ between the two forums is on my page with arbitration and litigation compared.
What Are the Owner’s Options When the Work Is Defective?
An owner has several ways to get defective work fixed or paid for, and the legal steps are only some of them. Each fits a different situation:
- Talk owner to owner. A direct conversation with the contractor’s owner can get a crew back on site without the cost of a formal claim. It fits when the relationship is still good. Its risk is an oral promise that is never kept, so I suggest confirming any agreement in a short email.
- Make a written warranty request. A letter naming the defects, enclosing your consultant’s findings, and asking the contractor to correct the work under the warranty follows the contract’s process. In Day Masonry, where the parties agreed to treat the warranties as warranties of future performance, the district’s letters of this kind marked the earliest date its warranty claims could have accrued. The court did not decide how a warranty to repair or replace is treated. I suggest not waiting on a letter to start counting, because the court noted a federal decision explaining that a breach of a “repair and replace” warranty is discovered “as soon as the owner discovers the product is defective.”
- Hold back payment. Withholding money still owed puts pressure on the contractor. The contractor may respond with a lien on your property, which can leave the owner without clear title; my page on Minnesota mechanic’s lien law explains how liens work. I suggest checking what your contract allows you to withhold before holding back, because withholding more than the contract allows can put you in breach. Minnesota law also limits retainage and withholding. Under Minn. Stat. § 337.10, subd. 4, “Retainage on a building and construction contract may not exceed five percent,” and “The owner or the owner’s agent must release all retainage no later than 60 days after substantial completion subject to the terms of this subdivision.” Paragraph (e) provides: “After substantial completion, an owner or owner’s agent may withhold no more than: (1) 250 percent of the cost to correct or complete work known at the time of substantial completion; and (2) one percent of the value of the contract or $500, whichever is greater, pending completion and submission of all final paperwork by the contractor or subcontractor.” An owner who withholds under that paragraph “must promptly provide a written statement detailing the amount and basis of withholding to the contractor.” The same paragraph provides: “Any amounts withheld under clause (1) must be paid within 60 days after completion of the work. Any amounts withheld under clause (2) must be paid within 60 days after submission of all final paperwork.” The subdivision adds: “Withholding retainage for warranty work is prohibited. This provision does not waive any rights for warranty claims.” Check the current text of § 337.10 before relying on these periods.
- Hire another contractor to repair. This stops further damage. Its risk is losing proof, so I suggest documenting the defects and giving the original contractor written notice first. If you end the general contractor’s contract, I suggest treating that date as a possible start of the clock on defects you already know about. That suggestion rests on American Family, which treated ending that contract as a “termination” that can start it.
- Send a demand letter. A pre-litigation demand letter states the claim and a deadline to respond, and it can settle the dispute without a filing.
- Mediate, arbitrate, or sue. Your contract decides which forum hears the claim, subject to Minnesota law. Under Minn. Stat. § 337.10, subd. 1, “Provisions contained in, or executed in connection with, a building and construction contract to be performed in Minnesota making the contract subject to the laws of another state or requiring that any litigation, arbitration, or other dispute resolution process on the contract occur in another state are void and unenforceable.” A lawsuit’s costs by stage are on my page about what a business lawsuit costs in Minnesota.
Do I have to send the contractor a written demand before I sue?
It depends on your contract and on what was supplied. Your construction contract may require written notice of a claim. For goods accepted under Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-607 requires the buyer to notify the seller of a breach “within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered any breach” or “be barred from any remedy.” A written request can also affect a warranty claim’s timing. In Day Masonry v. Independent School District 347, 781 N.W.2d 321 (Minn. 2010), the parties agreed to treat the warranties as warranties of future performance. On that footing, the court held that “the earliest the warranty claims could have accrued was December 2004,” after the owner sent its letters. It left open whether written notice is always required.
Does Minnesota's new-home warranty law cover my commercial building?
No, unless the building is a dwelling or the work is on a residential building. Under Minn. Stat. § 327A.01, subd. 3, a dwelling is “a new building, not previously occupied, constructed for the purpose of habitation.” Under subd. 9, home improvement is “the repairing, remodeling, altering, converting or modernizing of, or adding to a residential building.”
What if the defect first appears eleven years after the building was finished?
A claim arising out of a defective and unsafe condition generally cannot accrue that late unless fraud is involved, and a claim against an equipment maker or supplier turns on a different statute. Minn. Stat. § 541.051, subd. 1, opens “Except where fraud is involved” and bars an action brought “more than two years after the cause of action accrues, as specified in paragraph (c), nor in any event shall such a cause of action accrue more than ten years after substantial completion of the construction.” Subd. 1(e) adds: “The limitations prescribed in this section do not apply to the manufacturer or supplier of any equipment or machinery installed upon real property.” For a contract for the sale of equipment or machinery, Minn. Stat. § 336.2-725 applies, as quoted in the section on other responsible parties. For a claim that accrued in the ninth or tenth year, § 541.051, subd. 2, provides that “an action to recover damages may be brought within two years after the date on which the cause of action accrued, but in no event may such an action be brought more than 12 years after substantial completion of the construction.” Check the current text of § 541.051 and its subd. 2 before relying on these periods.
Can I go to court if my contract has an arbitration clause?
You can file in court, but the contractor can ask the court to send the dispute to arbitration under an enforceable clause that covers it. Under Minn. Stat. § 572B.07, “Unless the court finds that there is no enforceable agreement to arbitrate, it shall order the parties to arbitrate.” The court also “may not refuse to order arbitration because the claim subject to arbitration lacks merit or grounds for the claim have not been established.” Whether a judge or the arbitrator decides your challenge to the clause depends on what you challenge and on your agreement. Minn. Stat. § 572B.06 and § 572B.04 are quoted under How Do Arbitration Clauses and Damage Waivers Affect the Claim?
Commercial Construction Defect Claims
A Minnesota business with defective work on its commercial building may have a contract claim against the contractor it hired. It may also have a warranty claim against a contractor or manufacturer that gave a written warranty, and in some cases claims against designers, subcontractors, and suppliers. The construction contract sets many of the notice, correction, and forum steps. Minn. Stat. § 337.10, subd. 1, though, voids a provision in a building and construction contract to be performed in Minnesota requiring that the dispute resolution process occur in another state. Day Masonry shows that the clock on a defect claim can start with the first repair invoice. On warranties the parties there treated as warranties of future performance, the earliest the warranty claims could have accrued was after the owner’s December 2004 letters. More on disputes like this one is in my material on business litigation. If your business has found defective work on its building and you want to know which claims apply on your facts, email [email protected] with a brief description. I can then start an intake and conflict check before you send any confidential documents.